AUTHOR=Woo Gordon TITLE=Downward Counterfactual Search for Extreme Events JOURNAL=Frontiers in Earth Science VOLUME=7 YEAR=2019 URL=https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/earth-science/articles/10.3389/feart.2019.00340 DOI=10.3389/feart.2019.00340 ISSN=2296-6463 ABSTRACT=

An event catalog is a foundation of the risk analysis for any natural hazard. Especially if the catalog is comparatively brief relative to the return periods of possible events, it may well be deficient in extreme events that are of special importance to risk stakeholders. It is common practice for quantitative risk analysts to construct ensembles of future scenarios that include extreme events that are not in the event catalog. But past poor experience for many hazards shows that these ensembles are still liable to be missing crucial unknown events. An explicit systematic procedure is proposed here for searching for these key missing events. This procedure starts with the historical catalog events, and explores alternative realizations of them where things turned for the worse. These are termed downward counterfactuals. By repeatedly exploring ways in which the event loss might have been incrementally worse, missing events can be discovered that may take risk analysts, and risk stakeholders, by surprise. The downward counterfactual search for extreme events is illustrated with examples drawn from a variety of natural hazards. Attention is drawn to the problem of overfitting to the historical record, and the value of stochastic modeling of the past.