A Review on Multifunctional Carbon-Dots Synthesized From Biomass Waste: Design/ Fabrication, Characterization and Applications

Carbon-Dots (C-Dots) have drawn much attention in recent years owing to their remarkable properties such as high biocompatibility, low toxicity, nano-scale size, and ease of modification with good tuneable photoluminescence performance. These unique properties have led C-Dots to become a promising platform for bioimaging, metal ion sensing and an antibacterial agent. C-Dots can be prepared using the top-down and bottom-up approaches, in which the latter method is commonly used for large scale and low-cost synthesis. C-Dots can be synthesized using sustainable raw materials or green biomass since it is environmentally friendly, in-expensive and most importantly, promotes the minimization of waste production. However, using biomass waste to produce high-quality C-Dots is still a matter of concern waiting for resolution, and this will be the main focus of this review. Fundamental understanding of C-Dots such as structure analysis, physical and chemical properties of C-Dots, various synthesis methodology and type of raw materials used are also discussed and correlated comprehensively. Additionally, factors affecting the bandgap of the C-Dots and the strategies to overcome these shortcomings are also covered. Moreover, formation mechanism of C-Dots focusing on the hydrothermal method, option and challenges to scale up the C-Dots production are explored. It is expected that the great potential of producing C-Dots from agricultural waste a key benefit in view of their versatility in a wide range of applications.


INTRODUCTION
Carbon-based nanostructures have extended colossal designation in the field of material science employed by the researchers since it has been reported in 2004 by Xu et al. who has accidentally discovered carbon dots (C-Dots) as the new addition to the carbon family when using arc discharge to synthesize single-walled carbon nanotubes (CNTs) (Xu et al., 2004). In general, carbon-based nanomaterial structures are classified into zero dimension like fullerene, diamond crystals and carbon dots; one dimension carbon nanotubes (CNTs) or rolled up graphene sheets (as they are likely to unroll and form graphene) (Qu et al., 2013). In addition, graphene quantum dots (GQDs) and graphene oxide are examples of two-dimensional nanomaterials (Demchenko and Dekaliuk, 2013).
The latest semiconductor nanocarbon components consist of carbon dots (C-Dots) or carbon quantum dots (CQDs) (Raveendran et al., 2019) with particle size less than 10 nm (Sagbas and Sahiner, 2019). C-Dots have "nearly spherical shapes" (Tan et al., 2014) and are known to have an amorphous or crystalline core with predominant sp 2 carbon and an oxidized carbon surface with a carboxyl group . Recently, C-Dots have evoked tremendous interests in researchers as a potential candidate to substitute toxic metal-based quantum dots (QDs). The high toxicity of heavy metal-based semiconductor quantum dots seems to limits both biological and environmental applications due to its impact on the environment and human health (Reiss et al., 2016). C-Dots were reported to have good biocompatibility, less toxicity (Wang and Hu, 2014), high photoluminescence (PL) intensity (Sabet and Mahdavi, 2019), high chemical stability (Atchudan et al., 2017) and possesses excellent biological, physical and chemical properties, thus have great potential in various applications Bhatt et al., 2018).
The variety of synthetic approaches for C-dots can be categorized into two main routes: top-down and bottom-up method (Chan et al., 2018), including laser ablation, arc discharge, electrochemical approach, microwave irradiation, direct pyrolysis, and hydrothermal reaction (De and Karak, 2017). Among all the methods used to synthesize C-Dots, hydrothermal treatment is the most popular approach because the synthesis process is simple, clean and economical (Chan et al., 2018). In this method, the carbon-yielding compounds are subjected to a mild experiment condition (Sabet and Mahdavi, 2019) and biomass waste can be used to synthesize the C-Dots. There are three types of biomass resources: organism, waste materials and protein products. Carbon sources from renewable and waste materials are inexpensive and sustainable, thus an ideal material for the synthesis of C-Dots . Different types of wastes had been set as a sustainable green precursor to obtaining C-Dots throughout the years which includes sago waste (Tan et al., 2014), mint leaf (Raveendran et al., 2019), orange waste peel (Prasannan and Imae, 2013), banana plant stem (Vandarkuzhali et al., 2017), waste frying oil , etc. Other C-Dots precursors derived from biomass are shown in Figure 1. The selection of carbon-rich waste from recycling and reuse as starting materials to produce C-Dots will be beneficial to create an ecological community through waste minimization (Tan et al., 2014).
While several C-Dots have been synthesized from large raw materials, synthesizing C-Dots with prevailing performance such as broad photoluminescence and controllable surface groups is still difficult. The development of cost-effective and highly efficient bottom-up fabrication techniques, in particular, promotes wide-range C-Dots synthesis and investigation, thus makes it difficult to reveal the consistency of the structure and photoluminescence process in different systems. The goal of this review report is therefore to evaluate the properties of the C-Dots, focusing on the fabrication of C-Dots, characterization methods, as well as applications of C-Dots, prepared using various forms of biomass as carbon sources. A critical evaluation alongside an inclusive review of improvement in the fundamental understanding of C-Dots including structure analysis, physical and chemical properties of C-Dots, are also discussed and correlated comprehensively. In addition, factors affecting the bandgap of the C-Dots and the strategies to overcome these shortcomings are also covered. Moreover, formation mechanism of C-Dots from biomass, option to scale up the C-Dots production and the challenges in large scale synthesis are discussed comprehensively. It is expected that the great potential of producing C-Dots from agricultural waste the key benefit in view of their versatility in a wide range of applications.

STRUCTURE AND MORPHOLOGY OF C-DOTS
In general, C-Dots consist of mainly carbon skeleton with two other fundamental elements such as hydrogen and oxygen with different ratios in the C-Dots (Bhartiya et al., 2016;Zhao et al., 2015). They can be found mostly amorphous spherical shape consisting of both sp 2 and sp 3 hybridized carbon atoms with sizes of less than 10 nm (Sciortino et al., 2018). C-Dots are different with graphene quantum dots (GQDs) that only consist of sp 2 hybridized carbon packed into two-dimensional honeycomb lattice (Qu et al., 2013). Different species of carbon-based materials formation depend on the different precursor and synthesis methods when fabricating the C-Dots . With polar groups such as carboxyl and carbonyl groups, the C-Dots surface can be richly modified. Basic graphene, graphene oxide and C-Dots are schematically presented in Figure 2.

BIOCOMPATIBILITY
The biocompatibility and small toxicity are two important properties that enable biological applications. According to Bi et al., extracted C-Dots have almost no toxicity which is safe and theoretically high biocompatibility at a dosage 20 mg L −1 (Bi et al., 2017). Most of the C-Dots possess low toxicity when the concentration of the C-Dots is as low as 2.5 mg ml −1 (Kang et al., 2015) or 1 mg ml −1 (Dias et al., 2019) as indicated by some cytotoxicity studies. However, there is an instance where a high concentration (e.g.,100 mg L −1 ) of the C-Dots that shows minimal toxicity (Kavitha and Kumar, 2018). This shows that C-Dots demonstrated minor toxicity at different concentrations which cause a negligible loss in cell viability and excellent biocompatibility for novel biological applications . Although C-Dots have been claimed to have low toxicity but according to the study by Dias et al. (2019), the toxicity of C-dots depends primarily on the extraction process such as the type of the carbon source used and the synthesis conditions (temperature, time) (Pierrat et al., 2015;Dias et al., 2019). the C-Dots. Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) analysis can be used to determine the size and shape of the C-Dots which has an average size of below 10 nm . The latter was evident by TEM images of C-Dots monodispersion in water (from biomass waste) without apparent reunion  with a distinct lattice spacing of 0.21 nm.

XPS and FTIR Analysis
Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) are used to examine the surface properties of the C-Dots. FTIR spectrum captures the functional groups in C-Dots while XPS detects the identities of the elements. C-Dots prepared from plant-based biomass waste such as ginkgo biloba leaves, paulownia leaves and magnolia flowers consists of various chemical composition such as O-H, N-H, C-H, C O, C-N, C-O-C and C-S . The XPS findings can be used to evaluate the elements such as nitrogen and sulphur in the C-Dots and the stretching and bending vibration modes of bonding like-OH, -COOH and-NH 2 between the elements in the C-Dots (Hu et al., 2017). The presence of the hydrophilic groups (-OH, -COOH and-NH 2 ) in the C-Dots indicate well dispersibility of C-Dots in the water as displayed by the TEM and HRTEM images.

Raman and XRD Analysis
Raman spectroscopy is commonly used in material recognition and spectral characteristics of molecular structures (Hu et al., 2017). Raman spectrum acquired using and C-Dots synthesized from sugarcane bagasse showed the presence of D-band and G-band ranging from 1,300-1,400 cm −1 and 1,500-1,650 cm −1 respectively. The results show two obvious peaks; a sharp intense peak of G-band (1,580 cm −1 ) and a weak peak of D-band (1,361 cm −1 ). G-and D-band intensities are derived respectively from their full spectrum peak counts while the 2D peak of sp 2 hybridization was observed at 2,854 cm −1 . X-ray powder diffraction (XRD) can be used to further analyze the structural characteristics of the C-Dots. Normally the XRD spectrum of C-Dots exhibits a large diffraction peak of 2θ values around 20-30° (Thambiraj and Ravi Shankaran, 2016)- (Moradi et al., 2018;Wan et al., 2019).

Optical Absorption
Ultraviolet-Visible (UV-vis) and Photoluminesce (PL) spectroscopy known as spectroscopic techniques are widely used to investigate the linear optical absorption behavior of C-Dots. Generally, the optical absorption spectrum of C-Dots peaked around 230-340 nm with a tail spanning into the visible region. The UV absorption peak of C-Dots located around 230-270 nm is ascribed to the π-π* transitions of C C bonds of the carbon core while the absorption at 300-340 nm is usually due to the n-π* transition of C O surface groups (Hu et al., 2017;Chan et al., 2018;Carbonaro et al., 2019).
C-Dots derived from prawn shells showed two absorption peaks at 280 and 330 nm due to π-π* and n-π* electronic transition indicating the presence of C C and C O bonds (Gedda et al., 2016). Mehta et al. also obtained similar results with two absorption peaks at 250 and 300 nm in C-Dots synthesized from apple juice (Mehta et al., 2015). Interestingly, these absorption transition exhibited bright blue fluorescence under UV excitation. The resultant blue emission may be connected to the zig-zag sites because of the graphene molecules found in the C-Dots (Tan et al., 2013).
Vasimalai et al. also reported two absorption bands characterized by the UV-vis spectroscopy from four types of spices (red chili, black pepper, cinnamon and turmeric). Red chili C-Dots show absorption bands at 273 and 315 nm, black pepper C-Dots at 279 and 329 nm, cinnamon C-Dots at 275 and 324 nm and turmeric C-Dots at 282 and 329 nm. The excitation wavelength at 270-290 nm (π-π*) and 310-400 nm (n-π*) confirmed the mixture of C O (nonbonding oxygen states) and C C (sp 2 domain) groups with brownish-yellow under visible light and blue emissions under UV light (Vasimalai et al., 2018).
Usually, C-Dots display a remarkable PL based on excitation and the fluorescent emission shows λ ex -dependent behavior. The capability of PL spectroscopy on estimating the PL lifetime of C-Dots has recently been proven. A clear description of the UVvis absorption and PL spectrum at specific λ ex of C-Dots synthesized from Ocimum sanctum leaves can be seen in Figure 3. It should be noted that both UV-vis absorption and PL spectrums can also be used to evaluate the quantum yield (QY) of C-Dots. The QY of a sample of C-Dots was calculated in detail by a comparative approach with QY of quinine sulphate (act as reference). A simple ration of the combined PL intensity of both solutions yields the C-Dots QY (Kumar et al., 2017).

Excitation Wavelength-Dependent Fluorescence, Photoluminescence and Tunability
Most studies reported that the peak emission tends to increase the wavelength with decreasing intensity when the wavelength of the excitation increases ( Figure 3A) (Arul and Sethuraman, 2018)- (Sachdev and Gopinath, 2015). It showed that the C-Dots emission is tunable by manipulating the excitation wavelength. C-Dots fluorescence emission is closely linked to the surface state of the C-Dots such as surface functional groups and degree of surface oxidation (Zhang and Yu, 2016). Different functional groups on nano C-Dots play an important role in emission wavelengths as increased content of C O and carboxyl groups in the C-Dots gives a higher emission efficiency (Guo et al., 2018a;Guo et al., 2018b). However, the size of the C-Dots seems does not directly relate to the C-Dots fluorescence based on the recent literature (Jiang et al., 2019). The full-color of C-Dots can be influenced by functional groups rather than the degree of surface oxidation as it had pretty much identical oxygen content. Surface oxidation primarily created surface defects that could behave as capture centers for excitation thus inducing surfacestate-related fluorescence. The exact underlying structure of the fluorescence of C-Dots is not yet fully understood and needs clarification due to the structural complexity of the C-Dots (Yao et al., 2019). Some of the researchers also stated that this unique emission property of C-Dots is caused by several factors such as carbon particles sizes, quantum confinement effect, the availability of the sp 2 sites, aromatic conjugate configuration and structural defect Sabet and Mahdavi, 2019). As such, fluorescent properties of C-Dots can be tuned by doping heteroatoms, surface functionalization, electrostatic attraction, and aggregation-induced emissions, researchers have put a great deal to improve the fluorescence by working on various synthesis approaches to explain different PL mechanisms.

Molecular State via Electron Paramagnetic Resonance (EPR)
spin. Inherently, C-Dots have several paramagnetic defect centers that can be detected using EPR (Genc et al., 2017). A large variety of information can be obtained by EPR spectroscopy, such as structural and dynamical properties of the paramagnetic species and their interaction with the surrounding environment to improve understanding of electronic coupling effects in nanocarbons (Carbonaro et al., 2019). The microscopic information obtained provide insights into the spin properties (conduction electrons, unpaired spins, dangling bonds) and the electronic states.
The g-values calculated from EPR data can be used for the classification of the observed dangling bond centers. The g-values of the carbon radical centers typically ranging from 2.0020 up to 2.0030 (Genc et al., 2017). Privitera et al. (2016), performed EPR studies on the C-Dots to analyze the photogenerated unpairedelectron species (paramagnetic species). The findings show a weak EPR signal at g 2.0035 ± 0.0005, which reveals to long-living radicals formed by photoinduced electron transfer. The identification of a small photogeneration of radicals in the C-Dots reveals a partial double action (both electron and acceptor) of the materials (Kakazey et al., 2017). Lin et al. (2012), monitored EPR spectrum to observe the reaction of the C-Dots with the addition of oxidants such as potassium permanganate (KMnO 4 ) and cerium (IV). A signal at g 1.9903 reveals a singly occupied orbital in ground-state C-Dots which indicate an electron donor or acceptor. EPR studies have also shown a broad signal attributed from the presence of manganese (II) (Mn +2 ) arising from the reaction of the C-Dots with KMnO 4 . KMnO 4 could reduce to Mn 2+ demonstrated that it can inject holes into the C-Dots. It is also found that the g-values from the EPR signal of the C-Dots reaction with cerium (IV) under 77 K was reduced from 1.9903 to 1.9879 after the oxidation which indicated an electron tranfer from the C-Dots to cerium (IV).

SYNTHESIS ROUTES FOR C-DOTS
In recent years, numerous synthetic approaches for the preparation of C-Dots have been explored and reported to improve the fluorescent by increasing the quantum yield and narrowing the bandgap hence producing longer wavelengths (Zhang and Yu, 2016). These methods can be largely classified into two main routes: top-down and bottom-up methods ( Figure 4) (Sagbas and Sahiner, 2019). The most selected synthesis route is focused on their superb optical properties for wide range of applications (Bhartiya et al., 2016).

Overview Top-Down and Bottom-Up Method
The top-down approach involves cutting or breaking down bulky carbon materials such as graphene oxide sheets, graphene, carbon fibers, carbon nanotubes, carbon soot graphite, etc., into nanosized particles using physical forces via laser ablation, arc discharge and electrochemical oxidation methods (Yatom et al., 2017;Reyes et al., 2016)- (Hong et al., 2016). Meanwhile, bottomup approach involves C-Dots as bulk carbon materials as selected precursor molecules transform to "quantum-sized" particles through hydrothermal, pyrolysis and microwave irradiation techniques (Kashani et al., 2019)-(Sendão et al., 2020. The preparation of the C-Dots from biomass is more often carried out by bottom-up approach (Meng et al., 2019). This method offers great benefits as it is easy to control the surface state and the size distribution of the C-Dots to reach great quality and high yield (Saheeda et al., 2019). A simple, cost-effective and large bottom-up synthesis technique can be used under a sort of different reaction condition. In Table 1 is shown the advantages and disadvantages o of the C-Dots for "top-down" and "bottom-up" approaches. way to achieve this goal is to treat raw materials systematically to ensure green carbon sources are uniform and the C-Dots are reproducible (Meng et al., 2019). Different chemical precursors such as ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) (Ankireddy and Kim, 2018;Yang et al., 2020), citric acid (Fang et al., 2017) and reduced glutathione (Vaz et al., 2017), and ethylene glycol  also have been used as the source to synthesize C-Dots. Wide applications of C-Dots in biomedical applications for instance drug delivery (D'souza et al., 2018), biosensing (Sarkar et al., 2018), bioimaging Ren et al., 2018;Amjad et al., 2019) and gene transfer (Mohammadinejad et al., 2019), make it more suitable to move from chemical precursors to organic precursors. For example, numerous biomass has been used for the synthesis of C-Dots in recent years including papaya waste (Pooja et al., 2019), prawn shells (Gedda et al., 2016), grilled fish (Bi et al., 2017), Lycii Fructus (Sun et al., 2017), milk (Bajpai et al., 2019) fruit juices (Atchudan et al., 2018), etc. Nonetheless, various types of precursors may affect the properties of the resulting C-Dots due to variety composition in the samples . Table 2 summarises the properties of C-Dots produced from various green precursors via hydrothermal method.

Hydrothermal Treatment of C-Dots
Among all the bottom-up approaches, the hydrothermal method is the most commonly used to synthesize C-Dots from green sources as it is simple, takes less time, requires mild reaction conditions and capable of large scale synthesis . Hydrothermal method is categorized as an environmentally friendly method because of its non-polluting synthesis condition by using non-toxic materials. Different green precursor need different temperature, time and reaction conditions in hydrothermal treatment, for example, C-Dots from grass carp is prepared at 200°C for 20 h  while the synthesis of C-Dots from apple juice required 150°C for 12 h (Mehta et al., 2015). Some C-Dots are doped with nitrogen, sulphur or other heteroatoms to increase the quantum yield to manipulate the intrinsic properties of the C-Dots efficiently, particularly their surface and local reactivity, optical and electronic properties (Atchudan et al., 2018). Nitrogen is commonly used as the nitrogen atoms have five valence electrons required for carbon bonding. In addition to synthetic approaches, raw materials and reaction conditions often play an important role during the development of C-Dots during carbonation and surface passivation (Radnia et al., 2020).
Generally, the raw material used for the synthesis of biomass derived C-Dots can be divided into three groups: 1) the micromolecules derived from biomass such as citric acid, glucose, sucrose, ascorbic acid etc. 2) Biomass or Plant Waste Components Such as Cellulose, Hemicellulose, Lignin and  3) natural biomass such as peanut shell, rice husk, straw, etc.
By using different groups of biomass, various structures and optical properties of C-Dots could be produced as carbon atom numbers, carbon chain length, surface functional groups could have an impact on the formation process. The formation of C-Dots is divided into different steps: dehydration, polymerization, aromatization, carbonization and passivation. During the hydrothermal reaction in the presence of sucrose, sucrose is hydrolyzed to form fructose and glucose. For the synthesis of C-Dots from biomass components (e.g., cellulose, hemicellulose, chitin, lignin) or natural biomass, it has been reported the disruption of cellulose in the hydrothermal process is performed at a relatively high temperature (higher than 200°C). The physical structure of cellulose is initially disintegrated by hydrolysis where the long chain cellulose breaks down to oligomers compounds composed of C/H/O elements and then further to glucose (Su et al., 2019). These small compounds then follow isomerization, dehydration and decomposition steps producing soluble intermediates such as furfurals, organic acids, ketones and aldehydes (Sevilla and Fuertes, 2009), . Subsequently, hydronium ion formed from these acids act as a catalyst where these intermediaries undergo dehydration, polymerization, condensation and transform into soluble polymeric product. Then, aromatization reactions and creation of aromatic clusters occur via aldol condensation (Chen and Tseng, 2017) and cycloaddition reactions (De and Karak, 2013). A single burst nucleation formed when the concentration of these aromatic clusters reach a critical supersaturation point, and C-Dots are formed. On the other hand, residual precursors such as hydrophilic and oxygen-containing fragments present in the solution tend to stay around the surface of the cluster to form the surface passive layer forming C-Dots with a hydrophobic core and a functional groups rich hydrophilic shell (Sevilla and Fuertes, 2009), (Sahu et al., 2012).

DESIGN PARAMETERS AND FACTORS AFFECTING TUNABLE BANDGAP OF THE C-DOTS
The diversity of C-Dots is primarily attributed by the variety of carbon precursors and synthetic strategies. In C-Dots synthesis, the PL behaviour and quantum yield are the two crucial concerns in which they can be theoretically controlled by the particle size and surface states. The process conditions affecting the chemical structure, crystallinity and size of C-Dots are the molecular structure of the precursors, reaction time, reaction temperature and solvent as shown in Figure 5. The selected reaction conditions are critical because of their strong influence on precursor reactivity, separation of the nucleation and growing stages of the prepared C-Dots.

Particle Size
The emission wavelength is well known to depend on the particle size of the C-Dots which may affect the conjugated domain in the C-Dots cores. Bandgap tuning is often related to the size of the graphite core . C-Dots commonly have a particle size of less than 10 nm with nearly spherical shapes. The overall size of the C-Dots with conjugated graphic core possesses photoluminescence-dependent size property. Photoluminescence of C-Dots emerges from conjugated graphitic core due to exciton containment (Barman and Patra, 2018). The composition of the distinctive C-Dots consists of sp 2 hybridized carbon composition and amorphous carbon framework enclosed with abundant functional groupings or species .  conducted a seeded growth method to yield C-Dots by adjusting the seed amount (0.5, 1, 2, or 3 mg) and reaction time (6-10 h). The experiment showed that the C-Dots emitted colour-tunable fluorescence (blue, green, yellow and orange emissions) which linked to the π-conjugated domains within C-Dots core as the size of the C-Dots increased. The samples are synthesized using dimethylformamide (DMF) as the solvent with citric acid and urea via solvothermal reaction. Six different C-Dots with average sizes of 1.6 ± 0.2, 3.6 ± 0.3, 4.6 ± 0.2, 5.0 ± 0.2, 5.4 ± 0.2 and 5.6 ± 0.2 nm were synthesized. The quantum yields were found to be 17, 17, 24, 24, 26 and 26% respectively. The amount of nitrogen (N) slowly increased when the diameter of the particle size is increasing with the presence of urea as the precursor through their synthesis reaction time. The increasing amount of nitrogen may also contributed to the C-Dots colour emission.
To understand more about the quantum confinement effect, Sarkar et al. (2016), carried out the synthesis of different size water soluble C-Dots from sucrose through a simple lowtemperature hydrothermal method. Four different samples denoted as S1, S2, S3, and S4 were prepared at a different time (120 and 150 min) and temperature (120 and 150°C) with the same initial concentration of sucrose (1.5625 g). Their results showed that particulate size increased with the temperature (ranging from 5 to 10 nm). S1 and S2 were synthesized at different times (120 and 150 min) at the same temperature (120°C). S1 shows emission colour from light purple, purple, purple-blue, blue, and deep blue to light green when excited at 240-440 nm with a maximum intensity of 280 nm. This may due to the presence of sp 2 clusters and various attachments (C-H, Si-O-Si, Si-H, and C-O-C) which reduced energy gap and different energy trap states and different polyaromatic fluorophores with the skeleton of carbon (Sarkar et al., 2016). For S2 it was observed that red emission peak shifted with excitation from 320 to 440 nm with a maximum intensity of 360 nm. For S3 and S4, the sample was synthesized at the same synthesis time (150 min) but at different temperatures (150 and 180°C). It was observed that the sample S3 showed a monotonic redshift when the λex was increasing from 431.88 to 551.31 nm with maximum intensity at 360 nm which was similar with sample S2. Sample S4 had a wide range of excitation wavelength from 320 to 520 nm with a maximum intensity of 360 nm like S2 and S3. It should be noted that C-Dots may have different skeleton chromophoric centers and different energy trap centers when the particle size of C-Dots increased. Subsequently, it may give effect to the π-conjugated graphitic core in the C-Dots as it showed size-dependent luminescent properties as the size is the main factor for photoluminescence properties.
Considering the theoretical and experimental research, Ye et al. worked on two different ways to synthesis C-Dots from anthracite coal. First approach was by chemical oxidative treatment where the reaction temperature was directly controlled the final size of the C-Dots while another approach was via separation by cross-flow ultrafiltration to distinguish them by the size of the C-Dots (Ye et al., 2015). The average sizes of four different C-Dots were 4.5 ± 1.2, 16 ± 3.3, 41 ± 6.4, and 70 ± 1.5 nm by cross-flow ultrafiltration. As the size of the C-Dots increases, the bandgap decreased from ∼2.4 eV (green) to ∼1.9 eV (orange-red) and red-shifted from ∼520 to ∼620 nm. This occurrence was related to the quantum confinement effect graphitic conjugated core. This phenomenon occurred when the particles are smaller than excitons known as Bohr exciton radius at which the carriers of the charge are spatially confined within the particles (Sumanth . The quantum yield was found to decrease from 1.1 to 0.38% because of the size of the C-Dots increase (from 4.4 to 70 nm). This phenomenon was caused by the defects in the C-Dots since larger C-Dots had fewer defect sites per unit area thus less emissive. As the size of the C-Dots increased, the content of functional groups (carbonyl groups) became smaller. The functional groups were similar to the defects states and sp 3 carbon as they also induced structural deformation to the aromatic core and gave effect to the overall emission . It was also found that temperature played an important role in regulating C-Dots diameters (Barman and Patra, 2018). Higher temperatures result in more oxidation and make C-Dots smaller, therefore, enlarged the bandgap of the C-Dots (Ye et al., 2015). The functional groups on the C-Dots changed with the synthesis temperature. Higher synthesis temperatures (130-150°C) increased COOH content and decreased the C-C content which also effected the tunable bandgap of the C-Dots due to size effect and functionality effect (Kumar et al., 2014). In conclusion, larger particle-sized of C-Dots primarily isolated conjugated π-domains are highly probable to regulate the emission and leads to a variation in the energy bandgap.

Effect of Temperature
Temperature is a crucial factor in the design of C-Dots as the synthesis method required carbonization of biomass wastes as carbon source. Some researchers (Xiong et al., 2017)- (Dong et al., 2012;Ogi et al., 2016;Zhou et al., 2017) have studied the morphologies and the structural characterizations of citric acid based C-Dots at various reaction temperatures. Generally, the C-Dots consists of a carbon graphitic core and an amorphous carbon region. An increase in the temperature give rise to the growth of the core and a simultaneous reduction of the amorphous region affecting the optical properties. This is due to the fact that the high reaction temperatures tend to fully carbonize the functional groups of the amorphous surface, resulting in a larger size of the carbon core which leads to a shift of photoluminescence towards larger wavelengths. Zhu et al. (2013) found that as the reaction progressed from low temperature to high temperature, the polymer-like C-Dots were changed into carbogenic C-Dots. The surface/molecule state plays the leading role in the polymer-like C-Dots, while the synergistic effect of the carbon core and the surface/molecule state contributed to the PL of carbogenic C-Dots. However, the carbonization of surface groups generally leads to decrease in quantum yield. Therefore, the maximum quantum yield is attained at the in-between temperature range where both the core and shell structures coexist. According to most of the published literature, the quantum yield for prepared C-Dots can usually reach a maximum when the reaction temperature is in the range of 150-200°C, regardless of the different synthesis method such as hydrothermal, thermal decomposition, pyrolysis, microwave irradiation. Wu et al. (2015) synthesized water-soluble carbon nanodots (CNDt) via onepot simple hydrothermal carbonization of lignocellulose-larch by changing the reaction temperature from 200 to 260°C. Increasing the reaction temperature decreased the average size and increased the fluorescence quantum yield of the CNDt with an obvious blue shift of the excitation and emission peaks was also observed.  investigated the effect of reaction temperature (from 120 to 220°C) and nitrogen doping on the structure and fluorescence properties of C-Dots by using citric acid as carbon source and ammonia solution as nitrogen source. Their findings showed that reaction temperature has obvious effect on carbonization degree, quantum yield, ultraviolet-visible (UV-vis) absorption and photoluminescence (PL) spectra but less effect on functional groups, nitrogen doping degree and fluorescence lifetime of nitrogen doped CDs.

Reaction Time
The effect of reaction time on the optical properties of C-Dots is closely related to reaction temperature. Similarly, the longer reaction time result in higher carbonization degree, which promotes the growth of the carbon core and thus affects the optical properties of the related C-Dots. For example, He et al. (2017) conducted a systematic study on the correlation between the reaction temperature, time and different types of C-Dots formations through microwave-assisted synthesis. By using acetylacetone and ammonia as initial reactants, they successfully developed typical C-Dots with stable optical properties where their most photoluminescence arises from the carbon cores through prolonging the reaction time. It is worthy to note that only when the carbonization process is performed under a suitable temperature, then the optimization of reaction time is significant in tuning the optical properties of C-Dots . The successful synthesis of impactful C-Dots could not be accomplished by adopting an ultra-long reaction time with no prior high enough reaction temperature. For example, Bandi et al. (2016) observed that reaction time had a significant impact on the fluorescence quantum yield of C-Dots synthesized from onion waste by a simple hydrothermal approach. The quantum yield of C-Dots first increased with the increase of reaction time and reaches a maximum and then decreased along with further prolonging of reaction time. Papaioannou et al. (2019) also reported the synthesis of C-Dots from glucose with varying reaction time from 2 to 12 h using hydrothermal method. They found a decrease in particle size, while a higher level of mono dispersity and less crystalline phase over reaction time.

Surface-Related Defective Sites
The surface state of the C-Dots such as chemical compositions and surface functional groups are closely related to the multicolour emissions from C-Dots (Barman and Patra, 2018). It is well accepted that photoluminescence (PL) of the C-Dots are considered originating from the surface state. Surface states are oxygen (O), sulphur (S) or nitrogen (N) that are containing functional groups. Different surface states mean different energy levels, resulting in various electronic transition possibilities and different PL properties. C-Dots predominantly consist of graphitic sp 2 -core (aromatic domain) bounded by an sp 3 matrix with numerous surface functionalities such as C-O, C O, C-O-C, O C-OH and others (Yi et al., 2019). Surface defects can act as trapping centers for excitons and abundant groups such as amino and carboxyl groups on the C-Dots surface tend to form a conjugated π-domain structure, causing surface state-related emissions which resulted from the higher degree of oxidation and surface function . Cao, An and Han worked on a series of C-Dots with different concentrations through the hydrothermal process from citric acid as a carbon source and ethylene imine polymer (PEI) as nitrogen source (Cao et al., 2020). The characterization of the C-Dots showed the surface of the C-dots filled with functional groups (hydrophilic oxygen and nitrogen). Increasing concentration of C-Dots resulted in more oxygen-related groups, impose complex surface states to traps excitons under excitations which bring tunable fluorescence, therefore, generating new energy level (Khan et al., 2015). The increase of C-Dots concentration (from 0.12 to 2.47 g/L) resulted redshift fluorescence (from 444 to 478 nm) from the experiment. It was observed that this factor lead to the increase of the C-Dots PL lifetime from the surface defects states as higher concentration draws complex surface state to the C-Dots structure which was caused by more oxygen-related groups (Hu et al., 2015;Jeong et al., 2016).
Choi et al. prepared nano-sized C-Dots via oxidation and hydrothermal reaction followed by the introduction of an electron-accepting functional group of nitro (-NO 2 ) and nitrile (-CN) to the C-Dots to control the band-gap energy and frontier molecular orbital energy levels (Choi et al., 2018). The functionalized process was reported not affecting the particle size of the C-Dots because the diameter of the C-Dots can be easily manipulated by the reaction time and pore size of the filters.
The band gap of the nano-sized C-Dots has been successfully tuned by functionalization with electron-accepting groups. The band gap for pure C-Dots without any modification on the structure was ∼1.12 eV but it decreased to ∼1.05 eV for nitrofunctionalized C-Dots and the emission was found to be redshifted at 480 nm. The nitrile-substitution to the C-Dots also resulted in a smaller bandgap of ∼1.03 eV with even more redshifted green emission at peak 494 nm. In comparisaon to nitro groups, the nitrile groups showed a greater narrowing effect of the bandgap. From this study, the degree of the bandgap can be tuned by carefully choosing the functional species and the degree of functionalization. Functionalization shifted the spectral bands of absorption and photoluminescence to longer wavelength which defined the relationship between functionalization groups and the C-Dots bandgap energy.
The technique which improved the degree of surface oxidation leading to multicolour emissions with a smaller bandgap that has been thoroughly investigated . Ding et al., reported that the C-Dots red-shifted PL related closely to their degree of surface oxidation using urea and p-phenylenediamine via hydrothermal approach (Ding et al., 2016). C-Dots possess excitation-independent fluorescence from blue to red after column chromatography with a quantum yield of approximately 24% of red-emitting C-dots. An increase in the degree of surface oxidation reduces the bandgap of the C-Dots as the number of the oxygen atoms invading the structure eventually determined the tunable PL. To sum up, high degree surface oxidation always has a large surface defects sites on the C-Dots, leading to narrower energy band gap and thus emission regulation.
Surface passivation is one of the methods of surface functionalization developed to improve the optical properties of C-Dots. Surface passivation with organic molecules and diamine compounds were used for the passivation of C-Dots to provide stable surface energy traps in the C-Dots Park et al., 2016). Polyethylene glycol (PEG) is the common precursor used as a passivating agent because of its abundance of carboxyl groups (Fan et al., 2014). For example, the major beneficial effect of C-Dots surface passivation was studied by  to tune the bandgap of the C-Dots. They extracted C-Dots by introducing a thin passivating layer on the C-Dots surface using polyethylene glycol (PEG 400 ) non-conjugated polymer with a molecular weight of 400 g/mol and exhibited blue fluorescent C-Dots. In a standard reaction, the PEG 400 was then mixed with PEG 1000 (with a molecular weight of 1,000 g/mol) which tuned the emission colour to green. Lastly, further surface passivation was done by using EDA (Ethylene-dioxyethylamine) as a passivation reagent . The emission colour of the fluorescent C-Dots was turned from green to orange. The prepared C-Dots had different emission colours like blue, green and orange consists of C (carbon), H (hydrogen) and O (oxygen) components with additional N (nitrogen) component after added EDA into reaction. C-N bonds were assumed to be capable of modifying the electronic structures of the C-Dots which created low energy band gaps in the C-Dots, hence tuning their emissions.

Heteroatom Doping
Doping is another technique to change the nanomaterial's internal properties which are closely linked to the HOMO-LUMO energy gaps that can be tuned with adjusted amounts and certain types of dopants (Park et al., 2016). Doping also can enhance the quantum yield of the C-Dots. The chosen doping elements can be generally classified as heteroatoms (nonmetal and metal atoms). Different dopants such as N, S, and P have been widely used to evaluate the C-Dots characteristic features towards applications (Barman and Patra, 2018). Tailoring the structural defects, surface functional groups and interactions among carbon atoms with their neighboring atoms may introduce new surface properties of the C-Dots that is closely related to heteroatom doping with other elements. Additionally, there are two types of doping in terms of the number of dopants, namely single doping and multi-doping (Favaro et al., 2015;Yi et al., 2019).
Nitrogen doping is the most adaptable dopant atoms in C-Dots as it has the comparable atomic size to carbon atoms, unique electron configurations and high electronegativity . Nitrogen (N) atom could inject electrons into the C-Dots after successful doping thereby modifying the internal electronic structure. Thus N atom can easily be integrated into the skeleton of carbon material. The wavelength of the red-shifted emissions has resulted from the nitrogen atom which produces a new surface state energy level. Jiang et al., have synthesized three different types of phenylenediamines isomers (o-PD, mPD and pPD) C-Dots denoted as p-C-Dots, o-C-Dots and m-C-Dots through purification using silica gel column chromatography and the emission of the C-Dots were observed in solution and polymer films (Jiang et al., 2015). All these three types of C-Dots emits three primary emission colors which are red (p-C-Dots), green (o-C-Dots) and blue (m-C-Dots) via a solvothermal method. By carefully analyzing the data for the characterization of the C-Dots, it was found that percentage of the nitrogen content for each C-Dots is 3.69% (m-C-Dots), 7.32% (o-C-Dots) and 15.57% (p-C-Dots). Hence, it can be concluded that differences of nitrogen content in the C-Dots might be attributed to the different PL characteristics of the C-Dots.
Nitrogen doping will have a great impact on tunable PL of the C-Dots. From a simple hydrothermal method, Atchudan et al., have produced hydrophilic nitrogen doped-based from the dwarf banana peel (bio-waste) (Atchudan et al., 2020). Red shifted excitation wavelength was from 310 to 460 nm. The peaks of excitation and emission shifted to long-wavelength because the surface of the C-Dots consisted of oxygen-containing and nitrogen-containing groups in the hydrophilic C-Dots which introduced trap states with different energy levels. The introduction of the nitrogen groups by doping also increased the quantum yield of the C-Dots by 23% (Atchudan et al., 2020). Hydrophilic nitrogen in the C-Dots could be an ideal candidate or alternate for fluorescent nanoprobe for detection of metal ions, as a fluorescent ink or as a substitute for commercial dyes (Bandi et al., 2018;Ma et al., 2019).
Zhang et al., reported tunable PL (from blue to yellow) through altering the ratio of the nitrogen (N) and sodium (Na) by Na ion dispersion (NID) technique to prepare C-Dots doped with nitrogen that are solely solid . The quantum yield of the N-doped C-Dots had increased greatly to 80.7% as the nitrogen concentration increased with the urea ratio increasing from 0.5 up to 3.5 g of urea. Introduction N-doping generated different trap states as amino N and Na ion of surface state could generated surface defects. Hence, the emission of fluorescence could be tuned and tunable multicolour photoluminescence could be realized from blue to yellow.
Phosphorus (P) atoms, compared to nitrogen (N), are larger than carbon atoms. Phosphorus was shown to be capable of creating substitution defects in carbon clusters consisting of mostly sp 3 bonds and acted as the n-type donor. Hence, P atoms can alter the electronic and optical properties of C-Dots (Zhou et al., 2014). Doping of phosphorus into the nitrogen-doped polymeric C-Dots was carried out by Zhi et al. using citric acid or malic acid as the carbon precursor together with ethylenediamine as the nitrogen precursor (Zhi et al., 2018). The effect from the phosphorus doping gives the fluorescence lifetime citric acid polymeric C-Dots to decrease while it did not effect the malic acid polymeric C-Dots. The malic acid C-Dots had a lower quantum yield than the C-Dots derived from the citric acid after doping it with different levels of phosphorus due to multiple pathways for relaxation. The doping agent was not toxic to the bacteria and plays a good eco-friendly fluorescent materials (Zhou et al., 2014).
Sulphur-doped C-Dots has recently received a great deal of publicity, as sulphur atoms can also provide a new level of energy or to control the initial bandgap of C-Dots (Naik et al., 2018). Gao et al. have synthesized multiple colour emissive C-Dots from green, yellow to red by doping sulphur (S) elements and water in a solvothermal method (Gao et al., 2020) by using o-phenylenediamine and N-dimethylformamide (DMF) as the carbon precursor. Thiourea was added as the S doping to the C-Dots. The three colour emission originated from the transition of absorption bands in the lower energy region. The green emission (2.36 eV) came from the pyridinic N while yellow fluorescent (2.15 eV) came from an increased amount of graphitic N and becomes prominent after S doping which influences in narrowing the bandgap. The redshift fluorescence (1.98 eV) was due to an increasing degree of surface oxidation and generates a carboxyl group hence narrow bandgap. The quantum yield for the green, yellow and red C-Dots is 22, 26 and 20%. Conclusively, S doping increases the graphitic nitrogen content significantly and produce colour emissions from green to yellow, while adding water to the C-Dots produces carboxylic surface group which influences the C-Dots emission from yellow to red. Table 3 shown a summary of doped C-Dots.

Effect of Solvent
It is worth noting that the solvent is also another critical parameter to control the C-Dots' properties andcharacteristics  as the solvents can regulate the dehydration and carbonization of precursors. The bandgap of the C-Dots can be easily tunable through varying the concentration of the solvents (Zhan et al., 2018). The C-Dots can be produced under mild solvothermal conditions using 1,3,6-trinitropyrene (TNP) in two types of main organic pure solvent (DMF and EtOH) to narrow the band gaps and two types of auxiliary solvent (acetic acid and water) to decrease the lateral size for blue-green emissions. From the characterization studies, the fluorescent C-Dots emitted colourful emission such as blue (2.82 eV), green (2.59 eV), yellow (2.28 eV) and red (2.14 eV) light under different concentration of the solvent of DMF/H 2 O (2:1 vol/vol), EtOH/ CH 3 COOH (450:1 vol/vol), pure EtOH and pure DMF with increasing yield (50, 70, 87 and 90%). Pure DMF and EtOH solvent emitted red and yellow emissions while the mixture of DMF/H 2 O (2:1 vol/vol), EtOH/CH3COOH (450:1 vol/vol) exhibited blue and green emissions. Different type of solvents give different polarity with different concentration exhibits multicolour band gap fluorescence.
Some research groups have found that differentiating the composition of reaction solvents is efficient in controlling CD bandages and thus modulating multicolored emitting CDs or long wavelength-emissive CDs. The CDs could be directly synthesized using different solvents from the same precursor or may be synthesized CDs dispersed in different solvents to observe the tunable property Jing et al., 2019). For example, Tian et al. (2017) prepared all colour emitting CD using citric acid, urea as raw materials and three different solvents (water, glycerol, and dimethyl formamide) via a solvothermal method. Similarly, Yang adopted a solvothermal route by using citric acid, L-serine and monoethanolamine as the precursors and DMF as solvent to prepare blue green to dark green photoluminescent nitrogen doped CDs. The same precursors with water as the solvent allowed the preparation of blue fluorescence under UV light irradiation and showed the yellow color in visible light. Gao et al., found that C-Dots synthesized from citric acid (carbon source) and formamide (nitrogen source) exhibited dispersion solventdependent absorption and emission . The absorption and emission spectra of the C-Dots dispersed in four types of solvents like water, N, N-di-methylformamide (DMF), dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) and methanol produce multi-colour emissions . Water as a solvent generated blue dominated excitation as it cannot produce longwavelength while the other three solvents can generate longwavelength emission (redshift excitation wavelength). Thus, it is worth saying that the tunable bandgap may attribute from the solvents molecules.
Other than that, Zhang et al., have prepared four types of C-Dots from ethanol, n-butanol, domestic candle and benzene through the combustion process in four organic solvents (acetone, ethanol, benzene and petroleum ether) . The prepared C-Dots have different absorption bands in different solvents but the different prepared C-Dots have the same absorption band in the same solvent. For instance, the absorption band of the four C-Dots in the ethanol and petroleum ether located at 200 nm while in the benzene and acetone it is shifted to 280 and 320 nm. The absorption band showed fine emission peak when dispersed in the strong polarity of organic solvents like acetone while in the weaker polarity of solvents (ethanol and benzene), the emission is obscured. It was also reported that the fluorescence emissions band also relied on the length of the carbon chain of the precursors. To conclude, the solvent-dependent emission was attributed to interaction between molecular states and solvents thereby influencing the optical bandgap.

Effect of Raw Materials
The precursor molecules have great effect on the properties of the C-Dot in terms of the fluorescence intensity enhancing and the photoluminescent colors regulation, etc. However, the precise relationship between precursor molecules and special properties of C-Dots remains unclear at present. As reported in the preceding part of the text, it can be seen clearly that the reaction precursors indeed have an influence on the fluorescence of prepared C-Dots. For example, among various nitrogen sources, formamide is famous for the successful preparation of red-emissive C-Dots, which can not only act as nitrogen source but also serve as a solvent in the solvothermal process.

Large Scale Synthesis of C-Dots and Challenges
Large scale synthesis of C-Dots is highly desired owing to their broad and practical applications. Most of the synthetic methods (Chen et al., 2010), (Bhunia et al., 2013) available currently allowed the production of C-Dots in large quantity (Gram scale) using orange juice (Sahu et al., 2012), chicken eggs  and ground coffee (Hsu et al., 2012). Compared to using liquid biomass, the use of solid biomass provides a better option for the scale up due to their diversity, amount available, much longer shelf life and more convenient scalability in quantity. Alternatively, using molecular precursors would be another strategy to consider for producing C-Dots with relatively high yields (Zhang and Yu, 2016). The operating condition, source and composition of the biomass have great influence on the final yield. Most recently, hydrothermal method was used to prepare C-Dots from yeast extract powder on a large scale with 65.8% yield in 1 day at low reaction temperature of 140°C . The high yield was attributed to the hydrolytic breakdown of proteins and cellulose of yeast extract powder followed by the aggregation in hydrolysates at low temperature. Thus, more yeast extract powder was involved in the reaction process when the reaction time prolongs and contributed to an increase in reaction yield. Nevertheless, it was found that the reaction volumes and feeding mass do not vary the production yield and particle size of C-Dots significantly in a scale up synthesis study using rapeseed bee pollen .
While there are literatures reported for large scale C-Dots production, no pilot/full scale production of C-Dots has been reported so far. Due to the low quantum yield and product yield of prepared C-Dots, the cost of source and huge amount of industrial availability of cheap raw materials is crucial for future scale up. In this regards, even though biomass and its derivatives have the advantages of availability, low cost and renewability, the complex precursor composition of biomass might contribute to C-Dots heterogeneity. The use of different biomass precursors might result in the accidental incorporation of trace non-metallic or metallic doping in the synthesis process, and consequently modify the structure and properties of the prepared C-Dots. Moreover, the diversity in the composition of same biomass source but different origin might influence the product quality and consistency. As such, comprehensive and detailed characterization of starting materials is required to ensure the consistency of precursors for reproducibility of C-Dots. At present, one of the most major and vital concerns in the synthesis of biomass derived C-Dots is the lack of a systematic and scalable synthesis procedure to produce high performance C-Dots with desirable structures. Additionally, the exact formation mechanism of biomass derived C-Dots is still unclear due to non-standard synthetic pathways and impurities. Therefore, for large-scale production of useful C-Dots through an efficient route, effects of precursors and reaction conditions (e.g., temperature, time, solvent) on the performance of C-Dots should be systematically explored.

APPLICATIONS OF C-DOTS
The need for green materials have become a necessity in the modern era of nanoscale materials. C-Dots are very promising for many applications due to their unique blend of properties. C-Dots emerge as an important research subject that is still experiencing rapid progress as reported by abundant scientific studies of recent times. In recent years, many natural resources such as honey, prawn shells, pear juice, kiwi fruit and coriander leaves have been adopted as carbon sources for the synthesis of C-Dots. Due to numerous major benefits of C-Dots, including their convenient synthesis, low cost, good renewability, colorful PL and excellent biocompatibility, scientists were inspired to develop new materials with new applications and low impact on the environment. Biomass derived C-Dots via facile and inexpensive systhesis route has profound contributions to the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) including energy conversion (SDG 7), the treatment of environmental pollutant (SDG 6), health (SDG 3) and food (SDG 2) which are explained in detail in the following sections.

Energy Conversion and Electronic Devices
Carbon materials are abundance in nature, high in electrical conductivity and chemical stability. These properties make carbon materials the ideal candidates as the electrode materials for lithium and sodium ion batteries. C-Dots synthesized with semiconductor, can act as surface stabilizer for active electrode material. For example graphene quantum dot-coated VO 2 array electrode exhibited a high lithium capacity retention of 94% after 1,500 cycles (Chao et al., 2015). The unique properties of excitation-dependent or excitation-independent fluorescence emission and size-dependet fluorescence emission of C-Dots have been used for application in solar cells . Grass was used to synthesize C-Dots that significantly enhanced the conversion efficiency of C-Dots sentitized aqueous solar cells. In this work, C-Dots derived from other waste materials such as glucose and chitosan were functionalized with the surface groups in the waste materials to form hybrid materials to be used in solid-state nanostructured solar cells (Briscoe et al., 2015). The performance of the solar cells is highly dependent on the functional groups on the C-Dots during the synthesis process. The charge transport within the layer of the hybrid materials also determines the efficiency of solar cell. Huang et al. (2020) reported the use of allium fistulosum, a spices vegetable widely grown in China to synthesize nitrogen self-doped C-Dots as quantum dots sensitizer in solar cells.
Components of the allium fistulosum such as carbohydrate, cellulose and crude protein were hydrolyzed into glucose and amino acid via hydrothermal treatment. These hydrolysis products generated during the hydrothermal reaction become the precursors for the preparation of C-Dots, while the amino acid provides the nitrogen element for the doping. The influence factors on the photoelectric properties such as C-Dots and the sensitized time were carefully investigated. It is found that the photoelectric properties of the solar cells depends on the particle size, energy level structure, doping atoms as well as the preparation method of C-Dots. Demand for electromobility has sparked intense quest for high energy storage systems to overcome the energy density limitations of conventional supercapacitors. Graphene has gained most attention for charge storage because of its ultrahigh surface area and superior conductivity (Tan et al., 2020), yet the practical specific capacitance of graphene is rather low due to the aggregation of graphene layers, which increase the packing density and impede ion accessibility. This challenge can be resolved by utilizing C-Dots as the spacers.
Electrodes fabricated from C-Dots/reduced graphene oxide (rGO) composites derived from natural carbon precursor such as orange juice (Tibodee et al., 2020) and cauliflower leaf waste (Hoang et al., 2019) exhibited high specific capacitance and superior cycling stability. The high capacitance was greatly depending on the role of the C-Dots as the effective spacers in preventing restacking of graphene nanosheets, leading to greater surface area and pore volume. Detailed study by Hoang (Hoang et al., 2019) revealed that doping of nitrogen influence the active sites for pseudo-capacitance caused by oxygen/nitrogen functional groups, charge transfer resistance and proton diffusivity in acidic electrolyte, resulted in enhanced the electrochemical characteristics of rGO. Praneerad and coworkers (Praneerad et al., 2019) has shown that C-Dots are effective dopant for improving electrode properties and the supercapasitor performances. In their work, C-dots from durian peel waste was prepared by pyrolysis method and was used as dopant to construct a composite electrode using poly (vinylidene fluoride) with a specific capacitance of 60 F·g-1, much higher than that of the pure activated carbon electrode. Further investigation revealed that the capacitance improvement was due to the introduction of high surface area C-Dots and pseudocapasitive behaviors by the surface functional groups of C-Dots.
C-Dots have great potential to improve smart electronic displays systems in optoelectronic devices. The ease of surface modifications, tunable PL emissions and doped chemical elements are the examples of effective measures for applying C-Dots in light emitting diodes (LEDs). The most common phosphors for commercial LEDs primarily depend on rareearth inorganic materials that are expensive and have potential toxicity to the environment (Homann et al., 2018). Compared to toxic starting materials, LEDs that are made up from C-Dots is promising green initiative, with high stability and low cost. Sarswat and Free (2015) produced multicolor, highly luminescent C-Dots to fabricate LEDs from food, beverages and combustion wastes. Gong et al. (2020) synthesized multiemissive C-Dots toward white LEDs from the extract of mango leaves through one-step microwave heating, producing emitting color from blue to yellow. Coated on a commercial 365 nm LED chip, the C-Dots showed greenish white light with CIE coordinates of (0.37, 0.44). Strategies such as N-doping, surface passivation, and functionalization can be used to enhance the photoluminescence properties and stability.

Sensing of Pollutants and Toxic Chemicals in Food
The ever increasing populations is causing the urgent demand for the wastewater remediation due severe water scarcity. This has become a more pressing issue with the various industrial activities including those from the textile industries by discharging chemically stable and non-biodegradable toxic organic dyes into aquatic environments. The C-Dots demonstrates to be an ideal materials in sensing heavy metals in environmental pollutants. Several C-Dots have been developed for metal ions, anions, and molecules as direct fluorescent sensors. Fe 3+ is the most commonly observed in the process of ion detection and relatively few other ions such as Hg 2+ (Pourreza and Ghomi, 2019), Ag + (Zhong et al., 2017) and Cu 2+ (Rong et al., 2017). Fe 3+ are the most frequently observed ions because functional groups such as amino groups, carboxyl groups and hydroxyl groups are typically present on the C-Dots layer. These functional groups can be coupled effectively with iron ions, leading to fluorescence quenching. Orange peel, ginkgo biloba leaves, sweet potato and other diverse biomass waste are commonly used to synthesize C-Dots for iron detection. Shen et al. (2017) reported a facile synthesis from a sweet potato for preparing C-Dots by hydrothermal treatment. The prepared C-Dots was quenched by Fe 3+ ion with a limit of detection of 0.32 µM throughout a linear concentration (1-100 µM). The researchers proposed that the fluorescence quenching by the Fe 3+ ions attributed by the changes in the electronic structure of the C-Dots when the hydroxyl groups on the C-Dots surface is interacting with the iron ions . The fluorescence quenching in many sources means any process reduces the fluorescence intensity of given materials through which the fluorescence molecules interact with the quencher molecules (Callis, 2014). Furthermore, Khan et al. (2019), prepared nitrogen-doped C-Dots through a hydrothermal method of red lentils which act as carbon precursor provides a strong response to Fe 3+ ions and stimulates the fluorescence of C-Dots to quench. The reported detection limit for sensitive and selective Fe 3+ ions is 0.10 µM with a concentration range of 2-20 µM. Similar work also reported by using Lycii Fructus (fruits) as the raw material through a hydrothermal synthesis to detect Fe 3+ ions selectively and sensitively with a low detection limit of 0.021 µM. It is proposed that the fluorescence quenching may due to the inner filter effect (IFE) induced by the Fe 3+ .
Besides the detection of Fe 3+ , the detection of some heavy and poisonous metal ions using C-Dots is increasingly common in recent years. Hg 2+ ion is highly toxic as it is one of most poisonous, harmful and omnipresent pollutants. Pourreza and Ghomi, reported the green synthesis of C-Dots from leaves of Prosopis juliflora as a dual off-on fluorescence probe for sensing mercury (II) ions via hydrothermal route (Pourreza and Ghomi, 2019). The C-Dots have an outstanding selectivity and sensitivity towards Hg 2+ with a low detection limit of 1.26 ng ml −1 under ideal conditions. In the system, the fluorescence of the C-Dots was quenched by the addition of different concentrations (in the range of 5-500 ng ml −1 ) of Hg 2+ ions. A similar study also has been conducted by Li et al. to prepare C-Dots from green carbon sources known as Hongcaitai (vegetables) via a hydrothermal method for Hg 2+ ions detections . The fluorescence of the C-Dots quenched through increasing the Hg 2+ concentrations (from 0.2 to 200 µM) with a detection limit of 0.06 µM. The efficient sensing may probably be due to the good affinity of Hg 2+ with more sulphur-containing functional groups on the surface of the C-Dots. The interaction between the functional groups and the mercury ions may facilitate the electron transfer in the C-Dots leading the C-Dots to be an excellent sensor for Hg 2+ .
Using kelp as the primary carbon source with ethylenediamine as the nitrogen dopant are used to prepare C-Dots by using the microwave-irradiation process by . To detect cobalt ions in water samples, the synthesized C-Dots successfully showed high selectivity and sensitivity of Co 2+ ions detection with a detection limit of 0.39 μmol/L in the concentration range of 1-200 μmol/L. These points proved that C-Dots is an excellent nanosensor for the detection of heavy metals ions pollutants of environmental significance through fluorescence quenching.
On the other hand, excessive use of veterinary drugs, antibiotics and pesticides in poultries and agricultural activities poses a serious threat to the animal bodies, human health and environment. Antibiotic residues such as tetracycline (Jayaweera et al., 2019), (Guo et al., 2020) and amoxicillin  have been detected using C-Dots-based composite sensor through quenching of fluorescence (Guo et al., 2020) or enhancement  and inner filter effect (Jayaweera et al., 2019). Traces of estrogen drugs that were used in animals, birds for fast growth can also be detected by C-Dots-based sensor very effectively . Additionally, pesticides that is widely found in water, soil, sewage sludge, sediment and aquatic biota increase the risk of different diseases such as mental confusion, eczema, reproductive toxicity, damage liver, kidney, neural and immune systems in human beings (Jayaraj et al., 2016). The detection of herbicide (pretilachlor) by C-Dots prepared from water hyacinth has also been reported (Deka et al., 2019). Wool-based microwaved assisted C-Dots sensor for detecting glyphosate based on the inner filter effect was also demonstrated . However, current C-Dots detection approach suffers from poor specificity with the target analyte in the detection of antibiotics and pesticides, therefore precise structure of C-Dots, surface functionalization and control during the synthesis process are important.
Bioimaging C-Dots has great potential as agents for bioimaging. Fluorescence imaging has become an effective technique for visualizing biological processes within living cells due to benefits including lack of risk of radioactivity, higher sensitivity, better spatial resolution and increased high-performance capability. Several research groups have used many raw materials over the past few years to prepare a wide range of bioimaging C-Dots. The precursor origin is wide-ranging and easily available such as common beverages, food and waste.
Leaves are commonly available from the garden or industrial plantation. Bhatt et al. synthesized C-Dots under hydrothermal synthesis from Tulsi leaves with no other reagents used (Bhatt et al., 2018). The C-Dots exhibited low toxicity and emitted blue, yellow and red fluorescent images of bacteria cells during cellular imaging experiments (B.subtilis and E-coli). This implied that carbon dots successfully penetrated the cell membrane, making them potential imaging agents. Therefore, in contrast with traditional dyes and quantum dots, C-Dots act as a better alternative for cell imaging.
At the same time, edible fruits are also suitable material for C-Dots synthesis. For example, Ramezani, Qorbanpour and Rahbar used quince fruit to synthesize C-Dots under microwave irradiation as an effective bioimaging agent for HT-29 cells under inverted fluorescence microscope at a concentration of 1,000 μg ml −1 (Ramezani et al., 2018). The synthesized C-Dots can be used in biosensors as well as in bioimaging due to low toxicity.
Besides that, Sun et al. (2017), also reported the green synthesis of C-Dots from Lycii Fructus fruit, which later showed excellent multicolour (bright blue, glaucous and green) cell imaging with HeLa cells under an upright fluorescence microscope. These findings show that C-Dots were membrane-permeable although the C-Dots concentrations were increased to 200 μg/ ml. The multicolor emission of CDs in bioimaging application was better than traditional fluorescent protein with a single fluorescent characteristic.

Biocide or Antimicrobial Agent
The term to describe biocide is commonly used as a synonym for a disinfectant/sanitizer or antimicrobial agent. (Ribeiro et al., 2018). C-Dots antimicrobial activity has recently gained attention due to its excellent optical properties, low toxicity to mammalian cells, and multivalent microorganism interaction. Besides, photoexcited C-Dots can create reactive oxygen species (ROS) known to kill or inhibit microorganisms as shown in Figure 6. Figure 6. Two types of bacteria, Escherichia coli (Gramnegative) and Staphylococcus aureus (Gram-positive) were used to test the ability of the C-Dots, derived from Henna plant via hydrothermal synthesis without adding chemical reagent as an antibacterial agent at different concentrations of C-Dots (Shahshahanipour et al., 2019). The results showed that in much lower concentrations (100 μg/ml), C-Dots from Henna plant killed Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria like an antibiotic drug. C-Dots caused membrane damage or produced free radicals and oxidizing spices leading to bacterial death due to their small size and the high surface-to-volume ratio (Hajipour et al., 2012). Furthermore, the toxicity of nanoparticles to bacteria, which correlated to the structure, volume, surface and bacterial functional groups of C-Dots disrupted and destroyed major cellular components of the bacteria's vital actions (Shahshahanipour et al., 2019). Jijie et al. (2018) studied a simple hydrothermal process of citric acid and ethylenediamine to synthesis amine-functionalized C-Dots (CDs-NH 2 ) and conjugated with ampicillin (AMP) to produce C-Dots-AMP nanostructures. The results showed the potential of CDs-AMP as an effective platform for the eradication of bacteria. The conjugated C-Dots-AMP has inhibited the growth of E. coli cells in the lowest concentration of 14 μg ml −1 with the exposure of visible light to improve its bactericidal activity. The positively charged C-Dots were found to have the most bactericidal activity, whereas the negatively charged and uncharged C-Dots had almost no bactericidal activity. A mechanistic study revealed that the bacteria showed characteristic markers of apoptosis in treatment with C-Dots charged positively and negatively, similar to those found in common antibiotic treatment. Jhonsi et al. (2018) reported the studies of fluorescent C-Dots synthesized from tamarind towards antimicrobial activity and fungal strain. Disc diffusion analysis determined the antimicrobial activity of the C-Dots. The findings revealed that C-Dots from tamarind successfully inhibited bacteria growth in a concentration-dependent manner. The antibacterial and antifungal activities increased linearly with increased concentrations of C-Dots (2.4, 5 and 10 mg/ml) as the calculated inhibition area ranged from 7 to 12 mm for all bacterial species and 14 mm for fungal strain. Under confocal microscopy, fluorescent properties of C-Dots were evaluated directly without any fluorescent tagging. Fungal cells only fluorescent when attached to the C-Dots, while cells without C-Dots do not have fluorescence properties. Wang et al. (2017) worked on the use of silane binding agents for grafting C-Dots with silver nanoparticles (AgNPs) to develop a new approach to create Ag-nanoclustes-C-shell nanocomposites (Ag@C). The Ag@C nanocomposites were used to evaluate the performance of the antibacterial behaviour and cell toxicity against both Gram-positive S. aureus bacteria and Gram-negative E. coli bacteria. The antimicrobial assay was conducted by using the disc diffusion process with several different concentrations of Ag@C nanocomposites such as 0.25, 0.5, and 1 mg/ml. The Ag@C nanocomposites have potent bactericidal result towards both positive and negative bacteria (S. aureus and E. coli) as Wang et al., inferred that silver ions from silver cores could be emitted via carbon shells due to the entry of the solution where it can prolong the release time of silver (Ag) ions, thus retaining a sustained antibacterial activity. Moreover, damage to DNA and mitochondria would boost reactive oxygen species (ROS) and caused cell death  by which was done by AgNPs or silver salts. On top of that, Ag@C nanocomposites showed no toxicity to hamster ovarian cells due to successful antibacterial concentrations of the Ag@C nanocomposites. Raina et al. (2020) studied bactericidal behavior by using acetone leaf extract of Cannabis sativa (weed plant) as the carbon precursor with AgNO 3 solution to synthesis silver C-Dots via one-step pyrolysis approach. The study showed that an effective difference in antibacterial activity between different concentrations of silver C-Dots used towards these microbes (E.coli and S. aureus) by evaluating it through a disc diffusion and microplate assay. About 90% of these microorganisms have been killed by the synthesized silver C-Dots at a minimum concentration (MIC) of 42 μg/ml that prevented the growth of bacterial. Yet, no concentration of silver C-Dots could be identified as significant MIC as the maximum killing at a concentration of 25 mg/ml against dental microflora due to the heterogeneous nature of the culture showed varying susceptibility to silver C-Dots (Shivaji et al., 2018).
Through the hydrothermal process Lakshmanan et al. have synthesized C-Dots using the orange waste peel to develop it as an antibacterial agent (Lakshmanan et al., 2021). The antibacterial test from C-Dots was tested on both Gram-negative bacteria such as Vibrio cholera, Pseudomonas eruginosa and Escherichia coli and Gram-positive bacteria consisted of Staphylococcus aureus and Bacillus cereus by disc diffusion scheme. The inhibition zone was formed against the bacterial strains where inhibition zone of greater than 6 mm implied an antibacterial activity. On the other hand, the antibacterial activity was considered low if the diameter of inhibition was less than 6 mm. In the presence of moisture, C-Dots contact with bacterial cells developed highly reactive oxygen species (hydroxyl radicals, superoxide) which infiltrated the cell wall and lead to death by bacteria (Alavi and Karimi, 2019). As a result, C-Dots have successfully inhibited the growth of five pathogens, particularly against Pseudomonas aeruginosa bacteria as it showed high antibacterial characteristic as compared to other pathogenic bacteria.

CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE OUTLOOK
This review highlighted the recent progress in the field of C-Dots focusing on the analysis of structure, composition, synthesis routes, the use of raw materials as a carbon source, strategies to tune optical properties and applications of C-Dots in sensing metal ions, bioimaging and as antibacterial agent. In addition, we summarized different C-Dots synthesizing approaches to identify the advantages and disadvantages of the methods, with a particular focus on the bottom-up method. Among all the synthetic processes, hydrothermal treatment of C-dots was the most common technique due to its inexpensive nature, practicality and convenience. The synthesis routes are usually simple and can be prepared from a broad range of carbon sources e.g. chemicals, renewable materials and even wastes. However, there is limited documentation of biomass C-Dots with high quantum yield (QY). Some strategies to tune the fluorescence emission, excitation toward longer wavelength include effects of particle size, surface states, heteroatom doping and the effect of solvent on the optical properties of C-Dots were also reported. Further research and development are still highly desirable in this field. An effective method for the large-scale preparation of high-quality C-Dots with broad visible emission is to be identified in future research. The use of waste materials gives the possibility of large-scale C-Dots preparation with the focus more on the correlation of material structure and properties with photoluminescence mechanism efficiency. It is hopeful that through the related summaries and reviews, more progress can be made with C-Dots for wider applications.