Taiwanese Records of Oblong Large-Eye Seabream Gymnocranius oblongus (Teleostei: Lethrinidae) and Other Rare or Undetermined Large-Eye Seabreams

The oblong large-eye seabream Gymnocranius oblongus Borsa, Bearez and Chen, 2010, has been described based on specimens from New Caledonia, the only locality where this species has been recorded up to now. Here, new records are reported from Taiwan, which is located over 7,000 km from the previously known site of occurrence. Nucleotide sequences at the cytochrome b locus of the Taiwanese samples of G. oblongus were provided and compared to those of the conspecific New Caledonian samples. The results showed little intraspecific DNA variation among the sequences (only three segregating sites along the 1140 -bp long aligned sequences). Further population genetic analysis revealed a relatively high level of genetic differentiation (Φst = 0.286) indicating limited gene flow between the two populations. The records thus available suggest a wide and antitropical distribution for this relatively rare and poorly known species. In addition to this finding, we report the first Taiwanese records of Gymnocranius satoi Borsa, Bearez, Paijo and Chen, 2013, a species widespread in the western Pacific, and of undetermined Gymnocranius specimens that potentially represent two new species.


INTRODUCTION
Large-eye seabreams (Monotaxinae) comprise medium-to large-sized benthic fishes occurring over sandy or rubble substrates at or in the vicinity of coral reefs, at depths ranging from 1 to 180 meters (Carpenter and Allen, 1989). Large-eye seabreams regularly occur at local fish markets throughout the tropical Indo-West Pacific (Carpenter and Allen, 1989; authors' personal observations). Despite the importance of several large-eye seabream species for human consumption, our knowledge on their biology, taxonomy and biogeography is still limited. Currently, 13 species belonging to four genera are recognized in this fish group that is classified as one of two subfamilies of the perciform fish family Lethrinidae (Carpenter and Allen, 1989;Borsa et al., 2010Borsa et al., , 2013. Gymnocranius is the most speciose genus, with 10 species described thus far. The oblong large-eye seabream, Gymnocranius oblongus Borsa, Béarez and Chen 2010 is one of the three species that have been described since the synopsis of Carpenter and Allen (1989); the other two are Gymnocranius satoi Borsa, Béarez, Paijo and Chen, 2013 and Gymnocranius superciliosus Borsa, Béarez, Paijo and Chen, 2013. The specimens used for the description of G. oblongus had all been collected from New Caledonia; its distribution was thought to be limited to the Coral Sea (Borsa et al., 2010). This fish is characterized by an oblong, fusiform body, a slightly rounded snout, an elongate tail with rounded tips and sub-horizontal, wavy blue lines or dashes on snout and cheeks (Borsa et al., 2010). It is distinct from Gymnocranius grandoculis (Valenciennes, 1830), regularly found at fish markets (e.g., in Taiwan), by a more slender body which is also more symmetrical dorso-ventrally and by a more elongated caudal fin. Another remarkable feature of G. oblongus is its prominent forehead, though less conspicuously so than its relative Gymnocranius microdon (Bleeker, 1851).
Two specimens purchased from local fish markets in Taiwan were identified as G. oblongus. The main purpose of the present work is to put the newly discovered Taiwanese specimens of this species on record. Cytochrome b-gene sequences obtained from the Taiwanese specimens were compared to those from New Caledonia to evaluate the infra-specific genetic diversity and to estimate the level of genetic differentiation between the two populations. Additional records of rare or undetermined Gymnocranius from Taiwan are also provided in this paper.

MATERIALS AND METHODS
We examined 81 large-eye seabream Gymnocranius specimens collected between 2011 and 2015 at several local fish markets in the eastern and southern parts of Taiwan and on Little Liuqiu and Penghu Islands in the Taiwan Strait (see supplementary Table S1). The two specimens of G. oblongus, which had been caught by line, were purchased from fish sellers, one by HCH in Hengchun town, southern Taiwan on 05 August 2011, and the other one by WJC in Magong, Penghu Islands (Taiwan Strait) on 03 May 2015. The specimens were photographed shortly after collection. Standard length (SL), body depth at origin of first dorsal fin (BD), head length, snout length, eye diameter, inter-orbital width and other parameters were measured to the nearest millimeter. Species identification followed Borsa et al. (2010). Other monotaxine specimens collected by us in Taiwanese waters were identified using diagnostic morphological traits, as provided in the relevant literature (Carpenter and Allen, 1989;Borsa et al., 2013;Nakabo, 2013) and/or assessed against the genetic library that we are currently building for the Lethrinidae.
Small pieces of muscle-tissue were excised from the specimens, preserved in 95% ethanol, and stored at -20°C in the Marine Biodiversity and Phylogenomics laboratory at Institute of Oceanography, National Taiwan University (NTU), Taipei with tissue identification numbers LET439 and LET1209, respectively. The Hengchun specimen was lost afterwards. The Penghu specimen was preserved in formaldehyde and deposited at the ichthyological collection of the NTU Museums, Taipei under registration no. NTUM-10819. In total, we accessed tissue samples from seven G. oblongus specimens including the two specimens from Taiwan and five specimens previously collected from New Caledonia (including the holotype and all three paratypes of the species), one G. satoi specimen, and two unidentified Gymnocranius specimens from Taiwan (Table 1). , Genomic DNA was extracted using an automated DNA-extractor (LabTurbo 48 Compact System with LGD 480-220 kits: Taigene Bioscience Corporation, Taipei) following the manufacturer's protocol. Protocols for cytochrome b gene amplification and sequencing have been outlined in Borsa et al. (2013). The sequences were deposited in GenBank (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/) as a genetic reference for future DNA-identification and research on large-eye seabreams.
The softwares PopART (University of Otago, available from http://popart.otago.ac.nz) and PAUP* (Swofford, 2002) were used to compute the number of haplotypes, the minimum spanning network, pairwise p distances, nucleotide diversity, and segregating (polymorphic) sites to assess the intra-and inter-specific genetic diversity of the cytochrome b sequences. The level of genetic differentiation between populations was estimated by ɸ ST , Excoffier et al.'s (1992) estimator of Wright's (1951) F ST , the standardized among-population variance in allele frequency using ARLEQUIN v. 3.5 (Excoffier and Lischer, 2010). The nucleotide-substitution model chosen was TN93, the best model according to the Bayesian information criterion (MEGA6; Tamura et al., 2013) among the suite of models implemented in ARLEQUIN v. 3.5.
Estimates of genetic differentiation in G. oblongus were compared to those between populations of shore fishes from the Coral Sea and the northern South China Sea or adjacent locations. In blacktip grouper Epinephelus fasciatus and largescale mullet Planiliza sp. H (one of 10 cryptic species in the genus Planiliza; Durand et al., 2015), genetic differences were estimated between populations from the Coral Sea or from nearby Fiji and the northern South China Sea and Philippines or nearby Ryukyu Islands, Japan, based on the nucleotide sequence data compiled or produced by, respectively, Borsa et al. (2016) and Durand et al. (2012). For all other species examined, F ST values or equivalents were taken directly from the relevant literature.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The photographs of the two oblong large-eye seabream specimens from Taiwan are shown in Fig. 1. The measurements on the single specimen kept as voucher (NTUM-10819) were the following: SL 241 mm, BD 95 mm, head length 68 mm, snout length 28 mm, eye diameter 21 mm, and inter-orbital width 29 mm; the count of pored scales on lateral line was 48. The ratio of SL to BD was 2.6, which was at the lower end of the range reported for six specimens from New Caledonia (2.6 -2.8) (Borsa et al., 2010). The SL/BD ratio in the Hungchen specimen (Fig. 1A) was around 2.5. The combination of three features diagnose adult specimens of G. oblongus relative to all other species described to date in the genus Gymnocranius, namely, G. audleyi Ogilby, 1916, G. elongatus, G. euanus (Günther, 1879), G. frenatus Bleeker, 1873, G. grandoculis, G. griseus, G. microdon (Bleeker, 1851), G. satoi and G. superciliosus (Carpenter and Allen, 1989;Borsa et al., 2010Borsa et al., , 2013. These are: (1) "sub-horizontal, wavy blue lines or dashes on snout and cheeks"; (2) "fusiform body"; and (3) "elongate tail" (Borsa et al., 2010: 245). The sub-horizontal wavy blue lines on snout were observed in the larger of our two Taiwanese specimens (Fig. 1b), but not in the smaller specimen (Fig. 1a). Both specimens had a fusiform body with remarkable dorso-ventral symmetry (Fig. 1). Both possessed an elongate tail (Fig. 1).
Juvenile and pre-adult Gymnocranius spp. usually present several transversal dark bars on body sides (Carpenter and Allen, 1989). One of these dark bars runs from around the base of the second soft ray of the dorsal fin to the base of the anal fin spines (Carpenter and Allen, 1989). The equivalent transversal dark bar in the smaller G. oblongus specimen from Taiwan (indicated by an arrow on Fig. 1a) ran forward and crossed with another transversal dark bar running from the base of 5th to 6th dorsal spin to ventral part of body at approximately the place of the of the tip of the pectoral fin tip; a faint dark blotch was visible at the crossing position (Fig. 1a). These pigmentation patterns also characterize an early juvenile specimen from New Caledonia (Borsa et al., 2010: figure 3).
Seven new cytochrome b gene sequences of G. oblongus (GenBank nos. KU597058-KU597064) being produced in this study resulted in three haplotypes. The nucleotide diversity was 0.18%. Individual LET 439 from Taiwan possessed the same haplotype as 4/5 individuals from New Caledonia. The haplotype represented by the Penghu specimen (LET1209) diverged by two mutation steps from it. Three segregating sites were observed along the 1140 bp-long aligned sequences of G. oblongus. A total of 323 variable nucleotide sites was observed among all included sequences of Gymnocranius spp. The average interspecific nucleotide divergence (estimated from pairwise uncorrected p-distances) was 11.02% whereas the average infra-specific nucleotide divergence was 0.08% in G. oblongus and 0.4% in G. satoi (see below).
The estimate of genetic differentiation (Φ ST ) between the New Caledonian and Taiwanese populations of G. oblongus was 0.286 (P = 0.057; permutation test; ARLEQUIN) suggesting limited gene flow. This was the fourth-ranking value in Table 2. The three species with higher F ST were E. fasciatus, the coral trout Plectropomus leopardus and the narrow-barred Spanish mackerel Scomberomorus commerson. The high value in E. fasciatus reflects the occurrence of a divergent mitochondrial lineage within a sample (Borsa et al., 2016). The high value in P. leopardus is caused by the occurrence of two mitochondrial clades with allopatric distribution (van Herwerden et al., 2009). The high values reported for S. commerson stem from differences between multiple divergent mitochondrial clades (Fauvelot and Borsa, 2011). The phylogeographic structure uncovered in all three cases suggests the occurrence of cryptic species. Homologous estimates of genetic differentiation in all other species listed in Table 2 were < 0.200. The high Φ ST value observed here for G. oblongus suggests geographically isolated populations, hence an antitropical distribution.
Among the other Monotaxinae collected from Taiwan, four specimens were identified as G. satoi and 15 others could only be identified to the genus Gymnocranius based on the available morphological keys. These Gymnocranius specimens can be classified into two different morphological types based on their transversal dark bar patterns on body sides and fin ray colors (yellowish or reddish) ( Fig. 2; Fig. 3). They also showed substantial genetic divergence (p-distance > 10.7%) with all other known species in the genus for which cytochrome b sequence data were available, indicating potential new species. These two species have been mentioned for the first time by Borsa et al. (2013) as Gymnocranius sp. D (Fig. 2) and Gymnocranius sp. E (Fig. 3). Gymnocranius satoi is the red-finned "Gymnocranius sp." depicted previously (Sato 1986;Carpenter and Allen 1989;Nakabo, 2013) and formally described in Borsa et al. (2013). Its distribution includes New Caledonia, Japan and Raja Ampat in West Papua, and possibly the Great Barrier Reef, the Solomon Sea, the Bismarck Sea, the Pacific coast of New Guinea and the Lesser Sunda Islands (Borsa et al., 2013, and references therein). The present record from Taiwan is new.

CONCLUDING REMARKS
The oblong large-eye seabream likely has an antitropical distribution in the western Pacific. Thus, most monotaxine species, now including G. oblongus, have a relatively wide distribution in the Indo-West Pacific (Carpenter and Allen 1989;Borsa et al., 2013;this study). The new records and species reported in this study make up to ten known and two undescribed monotaxine species in Taiwanese waters (Shao 2016; this study).