%A Shuryak,Igor
%A Loucas,Bradford D.
%A Cornforth,Michael N.
%D 2017
%J Frontiers in Oncology
%C
%F
%G English
%K linear-quadratic model,stereotactic radiotherapy,Radiation,chromosomal aberrations,lethal lesions,Survival curve,Overdispersion
%Q
%R 10.3389/fonc.2017.00318
%W
%L
%N 318
%M
%P
%7
%8 2017-December-21
%9 Original Research
%+ Igor Shuryak,Center for Radiological Research, Columbia University,United States,is144@cumc.columbia.edu
%#
%! Overdispersion and terminal linearity in the alpha-beta model
%*
%<
%T Straightening Beta: Overdispersion of Lethal Chromosome Aberrations following Radiotherapeutic Doses Leads to Terminal Linearity in the Alpha–Beta Model
%U https://www.frontiersin.org/article/10.3389/fonc.2017.00318
%V 7
%0 JOURNAL ARTICLE
%@ 2234-943X
%X Recent technological advances allow precise radiation delivery to tumor targets. As opposed to more conventional radiotherapy—where multiple small fractions are given—in some cases, the preferred course of treatment may involve only a few (or even one) large dose(s) per fraction. Under these conditions, the choice of appropriate radiobiological model complicates the tasks of predicting radiotherapy outcomes and designing new treatment regimens. The most commonly used model for this purpose is the venerable linear-quadratic (LQ) formalism as it applies to cell survival. However, predictions based on the LQ model are frequently at odds with data following very high acute doses. In particular, although the LQ predicts a continuously bending dose–response relationship for the logarithm of cell survival, empirical evidence over the high-dose region suggests that the survival response is instead log-linear with dose. Here, we show that the distribution of lethal chromosomal lesions among individual human cells (lymphocytes and fibroblasts) exposed to gamma rays and X rays is somewhat overdispersed, compared with the Poisson distribution. Further, we show that such overdispersion affects the predicted dose response for cell survival (the fraction of cells with zero lethal lesions). This causes the dose response to approximate log-linear behavior at high doses, even when the mean number of lethal lesions per cell is well fitted by the continuously curving LQ model. Accounting for overdispersion of lethal lesions provides a novel, mechanistically based explanation for the observed shapes of cell survival dose responses that, in principle, may offer a tractable and clinically useful approach for modeling the effects of high doses per fraction.