Impact of kinase activating and inactivating patient mutations on binary PKA interactions

[This corrects the article on p. 170 in vol. 6, PMID: 26347651.].


Introduction
Small molecules represent the vast majority of cellular components. They are either substrates or products of numerous biochemical reactions. By acting as hormones or ligands, small molecules control protein functions, and molecular interactions which affect signal transmission. Molecular interactions of second messenger molecules with distinct proteins alter protein:protein interactions (PPIs) and signal propagation (Clapham, 2007;Scott and Pawson, 2009;Taylor et al., 2012;Li et al., 2013). The second messenger concept explains the dynamic wiring of membrane receptor pathways to a vast array of intracellular PPIs. One prominent example is the canonical second messenger molecule cyclic AMP (cAMP). It is an evolutionary conserved transmitter of membrane receptor originating input signals. A large number of G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) cascade utilizes cAMP as intracellular second messenger (Neves et al., 2002;Pierce et al., 2002;Lefkowitz, 2007;O'Hayre et al., 2014). cAMP molecules dynamically bind to and regulate activities of its key effector kinase, the cAMP-dependent protein kinase A (PKA). The mechanistic details of cAMP-PKA activation is a textbook paradigm for allostery and small molecule:protein interactions Zhang et al., 2012). In its inactive state the PKA holoenzyme consists of a PKA regulatory subunit homodimer (R; type Ia, Ib, IIa, IIb) which inhibits the phosphotransferase activity of two PKA catalytic subunits (PKAc) through binding. Upon selective GPCR activation cAMP production through adenylyl cyclase (AC) activities is initiated; on the contrary, phosphodiesterase (PDE) control cAMP degradation (Dessauer, 2009;Houslay, 2010). cAMP binding to spatially compartmentalized type I (RI 2 :PKAc 2 ) or type II (RII 2 :PKAc 2 ) PKA holoenzymes causes a conformational change, hence dissociation, and activation of phosphotransferase activities of PKAc. As a consequence PKAc phosphorylates compartmentalized substrates which affects enzyme activities, PPI, localization, or protein abundance (Scott and Pawson, 2009;Lignitto et al., 2011Lignitto et al., , 2013Taylor et al., 2012;Bachmann et al., 2013;Scott et al., 2013;Filteau et al., 2015). To guarantee substrate specificity PKA R subunits bind A kinase-anchoring proteins (AKAPs) which organize the subcellular targeting of PKA activities (Wong and Scott, 2004;Skroblin et al., 2010;Scott et al., 2013). To desensitize PKA phosphotransferase activities nuclear PKAc subunits are specifically inhibited through binding to the protein kinase inhibitor peptide (PKI) (Walsh et al., 1971;Scott et al., 1985;Dalton and Dewey, 2006). Deregulation of cAMP/PKA functions contribute to different diseases. Inactivating PRKAR1A gene (RIa) and activating PRKACA gene (PKAc) mutations/fusions provoke deregulated PKAc activities. As examples, mutations in RIa and PKAc account for the generation of endocrine tumors, cortisolproducing adenomas, and chimeric fusions with PKAc have been linked to the manifestation of hepatocellular carcinoma (Groussin et al., 2002;Meoli et al., 2008;Stratakis, 2013;Beuschlein et al., 2014;Calebiro et al., 2014;Cao et al., 2014;Di Dalmazi et al., 2014;Espiard et al., 2014;Goh et al., 2014;Honeyman et al., 2014;Sato et al., 2014;Cheung et al., 2015;Zilbermint and Stratakis, 2015). However, specific PRKAR1A gene (RIa) mutations impair cAMP-dependent PKA activation and cause hormone resistance as observed in the rare disease Acrodysostosis (a form of skeletal dysplasia) (Linglart et al., 2011;Assié, 2012;Silve et al., 2012). Here we tested the impact of functionally different PKA mutations on mutually exclusive molecular protein interactions using an extended PPI reporter platform based on the Renilla luciferase proteinfragment complementation assay (Rluc PCA) (Stefan et al., 2007;Röck et al., 2015). We show that the presented Rluc PCA platform-which is based on binary PKA network interactionscan be applied to analyze the consequences of patient mutations and upstream receptor activities on defined PKA PPIs directly in living cells.

Materials and Methods
Cell Culture and Antibodies HEK293 and U2OS cells were grown in DMEM supplemented with 10% FBS. Transient transfections were performed with Transfectin reagent (Biorad). Cells were treated with Forskolin (Biaffin) or Isoproterenol (Sigma) with indicated concentrations and for the indicated time frames. As primary antibody we used mouse anti-PKAc (BD Bioscience, #610981).

Constructs
The Rluc PCA based hybrid proteins RIIb-F[1] and PKAc-F [2] have been designed as previously described (Stefan et al., 2007). Rluc PCA fusions with PKI and RIa have been generated using an analogous cloning approach. Following PCR amplification of the of the human RIa (alpha) gene (protein accession number: NP_002725.1) and PKI alpha gene (protein accession number: AAA72716; addgene plasmid # 45066) (Day et al., 1989) we fused them C-terminally with either -F[1] or -F[2] of the Rluc PCA. PKA subunits and PKI were subcloned into the 5 ′ end the 10aa linker (GGGGS) 2 and the Rluc PCA fragments (pcDNA3.1 backbone vector). Site directed mutagenesis have been performed to generate the PKAc amino acid (aa) mutations G187V and L206R in the PRKACA gene and the RIa aa mutations R368X (X stands for the stop codon of the patient mutation; we generated the corresponding RIa truncation) in the PRKAR1A gene. In addition we deleted the corresponding nucleotide sequence from the aa 184-236 in the PRKAR1A gene.

Renilla Luciferase PCA of Detached Cells
HEK293 cells were grown in DMEM supplemented with 10% FBS. We transiently overexpressed indicated versions of the Rluc PCA based reporter constructs in 24 or 12 well-plate formats. In case of the HEK293 cells we exchanged growth medium and resuspended cells in PBS 24 or 48 h post-transfection. Cell suspensions were transferred to 96-well plates and subjected to luminescence analysis using the LMax ™ -II-384 luminometer (Molecular Devices). Rluc luminescence signals were integrated for 10 s.

Renilla Luciferase PCA of Attached Cells
We seeded U2OS cells into white-walled 96 well-plates with transparent bottom. We transiently overexpressed indicated versions of the Rluc PCA based reporter constructs. 24 or 48 h post-transfection we exchanged growth medium with PBS. We performed luminescence analyses of attached U2OS cells at room temperature using the LMax ™ -II-384 luminometer (Molecular Devices). Time dependent changes of the Rluc luminescence signals were integrated in 3-s intervals following addition of the Rluc substrate benzyl-coelenterazine (5 µM; Nanolight) with or without Isoproterenol (final concentration 10 µM) (Stefan et al., 2007). Following determination of the Rluc PCA signals we normalized the resulting signals on the control experiment (data points without Isoproterenol treatment).

Results
The purpose of our study was to extend the application spectrum of a PPI reporter platform (Rluc PCA) to quantify mutually exclusive PKA interactions directly in living cells. It is the simplicity and sensitivity of the genetically encoded Rluc PCA which enables different kinds of perturbation studies to unveil mechanistic details of PKA dynamics. The Rluc PCA facilitates the precise quantification of cellular PPI in an appropriate in vivo setting (Röck et al., 2015). In Figure 1 we illustrate the Rluc PCA design principle to analyze binary PPI of PKAc subunits. PPIs of R subunits and PKI with PKAc trigger folding and complementation of appended PCA-fragments. Following addition of the Rluc substrate benzyl-coelenterazine Rluc PCA emitted bioluminescence signals reflect quantifiable cellular PPI. Elevations of cAMP levels and defined patient mutations in RIa or PKAc affect PPI between the kinase inhibitory proteins (R/PKI) and PKAc which is indicated through alterations of bioluminescence signals. For the cloning of the PPI reporter constructs we fused the carboxy terminus of the PKA subunits (PKAc, RIIb, RIa) and PKI to complementary fragments of the Rluc PCA (either -F[1] or -F[2]). In all cases the bait/prey proteins and the Rluc PCA fragments are separated by an interjacent 10 amino acid (aa) linker with the sequence (GGGGS) 2 . It is a standard linker we previously showed to function using the dynamic RIIb:PKAc Rluc PCA reporter (Stefan et al., 2007). We started with analyzes of time and dose dependent effects of distinct cAMP elevating agents on binary PKA interactions before we initiated investigations of the correlation of cAMP elevation, PPI and patient mutations. In our first tests we transiently over-expressed indicated Rluc PCA pairs in HEK293 cells. We detected significant Rluc PCA originating bioluminescence signals of existing PPI between RIIb:RIIb, RIIb:PKAc, RIa:PKAc, and PKI:PKAc. No significant bioluminescence signals with R subunit:PKI combinations were detectable (Figure 2A). These data confirm the specificity of the assay and the suitability to analyze PKAc complexes with differentially localized phosphotransferase inhibitors. PKA R subunits sense and bind cAMP. We tested different modes of cAMP elevation. We used the general cAMP elevating agent Forskolin to maximally activate AC mediated cAMP production. In addition, we activated a prototypical GPCR which is coupled to cAMP production, the beta-2 adrenergic receptor (β 2 AR), respectively. In this context it needs to be considered that distinct mechanism have been described how β 2 AR switch their G protein coupling from stimulatory G proteins to inhibitory ones (Baillie et al., 2003). We used HEK293 cells stably expressing β 2 AR. Activation of different βAR subtypes are related to proliferation, cardiac function, and memory and learning (Daaka et al., 1997;Wong and Scott, 2004;Zhang et al., 2005;Thaker et al., 2006;Lefkowitz, 2007). As predicted, we observed that both Forskolin exposure and the activation of β 2 AR (with Isoproterenol) triggered R:PKAc complex dissociation. We observed no major changes of PPI between PKI:PKAc and RIIb homodimers following 15 min of cAMP elevation ( Figure 2B). These results indicate that discrete GPCR/cAMP activation induces dissociation of heterodimeric RIa:PKAc and RIIb:PKAc complexes which underlines the suitability of Rluc PCA to characterize transient and small molecule regulated PPI in vivo.
In order to evaluate dose dependent changes of type I and type II PKA dynamics we treated HEK293-β 2 AR cells with increasing concentrations of the non-selective beta adrenergic agonist Isoproterenol. We observed that similar half maximal effective concentrations of Isoproterenol induce PKA type I and type II activation in the used stable HEK293 cell line ( Figure 3A). As predicted, we observed no major impact of β 2 AR-mediated cAMP elevation on RIIb homodimers and the PKI:PKAc complex. Next, we wanted to track time dependent changes of the studied PPIs. We switched to the well-attached human osteosarcoma cell line U2OS. We set out to monitor GPCR mediated changes of PPI in the first 4 min of agonist exposure of attached U2OS cells expressing endogenous β 2 AR directly in the 96-multiwell plate (Stefan et al., 2007). Following transient overexpression of the four Rluc PCA pairs (RIa:PKAc, RIIb:PKAc, RIIb:RIIb, PKI:PKAc) and full length Rluc we observed that Isoproterenol immediately induced the dissociation of heterodimeric type I and type II PKA complexes with similar kinetics. Again, β 2 AR activation for 4 min has no major effect on the RIIb dimer and on PKAc:PKI interactions ( Figure 3B). The results from the realtime measurements of PKA kinetics using whole cell populations underline the suitability of the Rluc PCA to compare subtypereceptor controlled PPI dynamics in distinct cell settings.
Next, we analyzed different kind of patient mutations of PKA subunits and their impact on binary PKA network interactions. We selected patient mutations of PKAc and RIa which contribute to disease etiology and progression (Carney et al., 1985;Horvath et al., 2010;Stratakis, 2013;Beuschlein et al., 2014;Calebiro et al., 2014;Cao et al., 2014;Di Dalmazi et al., 2014;Espiard et al., 2014;Goh et al., 2014;Honeyman et al., 2014;Salpea and Stratakis, 2014;Sato et al., 2014;Cheung et al., 2015;Zilbermint and Stratakis, 2015). We started with analyses of PKAc mutations and their effect on compartmentalized PPI of PKAc with R subunits (type I and II) and PKI (Figure 4A). In addition we investigated the impact of cAMP alterations on wild type and mutant PKA complexes. We introduced two patient mutations into the PKAc-F[2] Rluc PCA constructs. It has been described that the PKAc mutation G187V diminished, whereas the hotspot mutation L206R of PKAc in  PPIs have been determined using the Rluc PCA as read out (representative experiment from n = 3; ±SD from triplicates). PPIs of RIIb:RIIb, RIIb:PKAc, RIa:PKAc, and PKI:PKAc upon 1 pM Isoproterenol exposure have been set to 100%. (B) U2OS cells transiently expressing indicated Rluc PCA pairs have been exposed to time-dependent Isoproterenol treatments (10 µM). Time dependent changes of the Rluc luminescence signals were integrated for 3 s intervals following addition of the Rluc substrate benzyl-coelenterazine (5 µM) with or without Isoproterenol. Following determination of Rluc PCA signals we normalized the data points on the experiments with the full length Rluc (±Isoproterenol) and on the control experiment (without Isoproterenol). Shown is a representative experiment of n = 3; ±SEM.
adrenal Cushing's syndrome promoted PKAc activity (Soberg et al., 2012;Cao et al., 2014;Di Dalmazi et al., 2014;Sato et al., 2014). Following co-expression of PCA pairs in HEK293 cells we observed a significant reduction of complex formation of PKAc mutants with all three PKA-inhibitory proteins. To our surprise also the interaction with PKI was significantly reduced. cAMP binding to the heterodimeric wild type PKA reporter (RIa:PKAc, RIIb:PKAc) caused complex dissociation (Stefan et al., 2007Bachmann et al., 2013). Only in the case of RIIb:PKAc-G187V the remaining PPI was still responsive to general cAMP elevation using Forskolin (Figure 4B). The expression level of mutated PKAc-F[2] was slightly reduced (Figure 4C). These data underline that the patient mutation PKAc-L206R and the mutant PKAc-G187V significantly reduce complex formation with RIa, RIIb, and PKI. However, we show that RIIb has still the potential to bind to the catalytic inactive PKAc-G187V mutant. No remaining PPIs of inhibitory R/PKI proteins with the critical PKAc-L206R mutant were detected.
Following analyses of PKAc patient mutations we tested the consequence of mutating RIa on complex formation with PKAc ( Figure 5A). In the RIa R subunit a variety of mutations have been found which lead to distinct human diseases ( Figure 5A) (Horvath et al., 2010). We decided to test a patient mutation which causes the expression of a RIa protein lacking the aa sequence encoded by exon 6 (R1a 184-236) which contribute to the multiple neoplasia and lentiginosis syndrome Carney complex (Groussin et al., 2002;Meoli et al., 2008). It is a disease described as "the complex of myxomas, spotty skin pigmentation and endocrine over activity" (Carney et al., 1985;Veugelers et al., 2004;Horvath et al., 2010;Salpea and Stratakis, 2014). In case of the Carney complex a collection of RIa mutations lead to PKA activation. As second mutation we introduced one stop codon at the position R368X in RIa which results in a truncation of the last 14 amino acids of the RIa protein. This heterozygous de novo mutation has been identified in patients with Acrodysostosis (a rare form of skeletal dysplasia) which is caused through a resistance to several hormones (Linglart et al., 2011). In case of Acrodysostosis RIa mutations lead to PKA inactivation.
To quantitatively evaluate the impact of these two patient mutations on PPI we transfected the same DNA amount of  indicated Rluc PCA constructs into HEK293 cells. We observed that the R1a 184-236 deletion in RIa-F[1] reduced basal PPI with PKAc-F[2] to less than 50% ( Figure 5B). No major changes of R subunit dimerization of R1a 184-236:RIa was detectable ( Figure 5C). Upon cAMP elevation with Isoproterenol the remaining PKA complex can be activated to a similar extend as the wild type PKA type I complex. In parallel we analyzed the truncated RIa protein simulating the stop codon at position R368 of RIa (=14aa truncation). First, we observed elevated levels of inactive RIa:PKAc complexes. Second, upon cAMP elevation with Isoproterenol we recorded less PKA dynamics ( Figure 5B). No major changes of R subunit dimerization of RIa-R368X:RIa was detectable (Figure 5C). Apparently the RIa-R368X mutated PKA type I complex is less responsive to cAMP elevations. The R368X mutation impairs the cAMP-dependent dissociation of RIa from PKAc. These data underline that specific patient mutations in RIa have different consequences on both the PKA holoenzyme complex formation and on cAMP-induced PKA activation.
Overall our data indicate that the presented Rluc PCA PKA reporter platform is suitable to quantify dynamic and mutually exclusive protein complex assembly and disassembly of the binary PKA network, which is controlled through oscillations of cAMP levels. In addition, we clearly demonstrate with this proof of concept study that observed PPI dynamics of wild type and mutated PKA complexes support findings and hypotheses of disease relevant PKA associations.

Discussion
The ability to precisely record PPI dynamics of the binary PKA network is central for understanding compartmentalized cAMP signal transmission. We present a highly sensitive and easy applicable reporter platform to systematically quantify, map, and manipulate PKA protein complex formation in real time. We show that second messenger initiated changes of PKA reflect connections to upstream located receptor pathways. The implementation of the PPI reporter allows for more accurate and quantitative specification of receptoreffector relationships directly in the preferred cell type. In light of disease relevant PKAc variations (mutations, fusions, decontrolled upstream pathways) application of the PKA Rluc PCA platform offers the possibility to systematically test different means of kinase perturbations using the available biosensor toolbox. We quantified mutually exclusive PKAc interactions which account for different spatially controlled cell functions. We showed that the PPI reporter implementation simplified the determination of consequences of PPI relevant patient mutations. Such comparative in vivo analyses will facilitate the decision how to interfere with deregulated PKA functions. We showed that two PKAc mutations display differences in the binary PPI pattern. We revealed that cAMP-sensing R subunits and PKI form no PPIs with PKAc-L206R, a hotspot mutation of PKAc in adrenal Cushing's syndrome which promotes PKAc activity (Cao et al., 2014;Di Dalmazi et al., 2014). First, this implements that PKAc-L206R cannot be compartmentalized through R/PKI and indirect AKAP interactions. Second, PKAc-L206R operates independently of cAMP. Therefore, alternative means need to be prosecuted to reduce the deregulated phosphotransferase activity. Besides inhibitory small molecules we believe that targeting the stability of PKAc-L206R is one alternative.
We also tested two patient mutations of RIa which are related to two different diseases showing opposite effects on PKA activity. We demonstrated that the Carney complex relevant R1a-184-236 mutation had a major impact on PKA complex formation when compared to the wild type PKA holoenzyme type I. Our data showed that R1a-184-236 has less affinity for PKAc. We assume that the reduced affinity for PKAc contributes to disease relevant elevations of PKAc phosphotranferase activities. The second mutation RIa-R368X (=14aa truncation) caused a defect in PKA activation. The mutation introduces a stop codon and shortens the cAMP binding domain B. The resulting deletion of 14 aa at the C terminus reduced the cooperative binding of cAMP first to binding domain B and then to binding domain A, which is a prerequisite for PKAc dissociation and activation (Kim et al., 2007;Bertherat et al., 2009;Linglart et al., 2011;Taylor et al., 2012). We showed that this truncation is sufficient to elevate basal RIa-1-368:PKAc complexes. Primarily this complex was less responsive to GPCR/cAMP mediated PKA activation what correlates with the findings of Linglart and colleagues (Linglart et al., 2011;Silve et al., 2012). Interestingly, we detected marginal cAMP-dependent activation of the mutated PKA complex. This underscores the suitability of the PKA Rluc PCA reporter to detect even modest changes of PPIs in response to second messenger elevations. Overall we underline with this study that the Rluc PCA is a versatile reporter system to map transient and small molecule controlled PPI. Besides linking membrane receptor pathways to alterations of molecular interactions, the consequence of patient mutations on PPI can be tested with a simple protocol and in parallel fashion. The implementation of this PPI reporter platform will unveil consequences of distinct patient mutations on binary PKA network dynamics. We envision that the mutation approach will disclose hot spots in these critically regulated kinase complexes which become pharmaceutical targets to target both PPI and/or cAMP sensing. This will help to gain novel insights into mechanism of PKA activation which will be relevant for the diagnosis and for identifying treatments of kinase involved diseases.

Author Contributions
RR, JM, VB, and ES performed the experiments. RR, JM, VB, and ES analyzed the results. ES wrote the manuscript.