Understanding “green” multicellularity: do seaweeds hold the key?

INTRODUCTION Living organisms are unicellular, composed of a single cell, or multicellular, where a group of up to 10 ^ 12 cells functions co-operatively (Kaiser, 2001). All multicellular organisms evolved from single-celled ancestors; every individual organism arises from a unicell and reproduces by forming unicells. Multicellularity enables competitive advantages, and may have shaped our oxygen-rich atmosphere (Grosberg and Strathmann, 1998; Kaiser, 2001; Schirrmeister et al., 2013). Multicellularity has evolved multiple times: animals, plants, algae, amoebae, fungi, and bacteria are or can all be multicellular (King, 2004; Grosberg and Strathmann, 2007; Rokas, 2008; Claessen et al., 2014). Multicellularity can be clonal (arising from division of a single cell) or aggregative (aggregation of genetically diverse cells), with clonal multicellularity considered evolutionarily more stable (Grosberg and Strathmann, 1998). The molecular mechanisms by which organisms become multicellular are not well understood. In this article, we outline eukaryotic multicellular evolution, and discuss how to increase our future understanding.


INTRODUCTION
Living organisms are unicellular, composed of a single cell, or multicellular, where a group of up to ∼10 12 cells functions co-operatively (Kaiser, 2001). All multicellular organisms evolved from single-celled ancestors; every individual organism arises from a unicell and reproduces by forming unicells. Multicellularity enables competitive advantages, and may have shaped our oxygen-rich atmosphere (Grosberg and Strathmann, 1998;Kaiser, 2001;Schirrmeister et al., 2013). Multicellularity has evolved multiple times: animals, plants, algae, amoebae, fungi, and bacteria are or can all be multicellular (King, 2004;Grosberg and Strathmann, 2007;Rokas, 2008;Claessen et al., 2014). Multicellularity can be clonal (arising from division of a single cell) or aggregative (aggregation of genetically diverse cells), with clonal multicellularity considered evolutionarily more stable (Grosberg and Strathmann, 1998). The molecular mechanisms by which organisms become multicellular are not well understood. In this article, we outline eukaryotic multicellular evolution, and discuss how to increase our future understanding.

EVOLUTION OF UNICELLULAR-MULTICELLULAR TRANSITIONS: A GENETIC TOOLKIT FOR MULTICELLULARITY?
The most well-studied group of multicellular organisms are animals, where multicellularity likely arose once, giving rise to today's diversity of complex forms.
Organisms in animal sister lineages, the aquatic "protist" choanoflagellates and filastereans (forming holozoans collectively with animals), can be unicellular or multicellular. Comparison of unicellular holozoan and animal genomes suggests that part of the "toolkit" of genes required to orchestrate multicellular development (genes for cell adhesion, cell-cell signaling and certain transcription factors) was already present in unicellular ancestors of both holozoans and animals King et al., 2008;Sebe-Pedros et al., 2011;Fairclough et al., 2013;, although "metazoan-specific innovations" also exist .
Data from algae extends this "common toolkit" hypothesis to other kingdoms. The Chlamydomonas (unicellular) and Volvox (simple multicellular) genomes are remarkably similar (Merchant et al., 2007;Prochnik et al., 2010), with very few species-specific genes, and expansion of Volvox extracellular matrix (ECM) gene families (Prochnik et al., 2010). Much is now understood about the evolutionary steps to multicellularity in Volvocine algae (Herron et al., 2009), but the underlying molecular-genetic mechanisms are unknown.
The genome sequence of Ectocarpus, a multicellular brown alga, reveals no obvious trends of specific gene loss/gain in independent multicellular lineages (Cock et al., 2010). Ectocarpus contains possible integrin domains, which are important for animal development and also present in unicellular Holozoa (Cock et al., 2010). Ectocarpus also highlights the independent evolution of large receptor-kinase protein families as a step to drive complex multicellular evolution from a eukaryotic ancestor (Cock et al., 2010), as also suggested in plants (Shiu and Bleecker, 2001) and holozoans (Hunter and Plowman, 1997;Suga et al., 2014). Multicellular fungi possess unique non-receptor kinases (Stajich et al., 2010). Thus, transitions to multicellularity most likely largely require co-option of pre-existing genes, via changes in expression or regulation.

UNICELLULAR-MULTICELLULAR LIFE-CYCLE TRANSITION MECHANISMS
All multicellular organisms possess a unicellular life-cycle stage, undergoing a unicellular-multicellular transition in every generation. In the most complex organisms (animals and terrestrial plants), these transitions are challenging to characterize experimentally, as the unicells (gametes, zygotes) are hidden deep within host tissues (e.g., Figure 1B). However, there are eukaryotes of varying complexity that offer tractable systems to define molecular changes underpinning unicellular-multicellular transitions, enabling new opportunities for characterization and comparison. The multicellular seed (orange) houses the unicellular diploid zygote (brown) surrounded by multicellular endosperm tissue (yellow). The zygote develops into a multicellular embryo within the seed, which then germinates to form the multicellular diploid adult sporophyte plant. Within the sporophyte flower, meiosis occurs to produce single-celled haploid gametes (female ovules and male pollen) in the multicellular diploid ovaries and anthers, respectively. The unicellular megaspores develop into a multicellular (seven-celled) haploid megagametophyte, completely surrounded by maternal multicellular tissue, prior to fertilization of one megagametophyte nucleus to form a zygote buried within the maternal-and developing seed-tissue. The microspores within the anther form a pollen grain with two cells that degenerate when the pollen germinates, allowing transfer of nuclei to the megagametophyte. Although the mature pollen grain (haploid gametophyte) is an accessible unicell it does not germinate to form a multicellular structure by itself, but only after fertilization has occurred. (C) Simplified life cycle of an early-evolving spore-bearing land plant, such as a moss (Bryophyte), showing unicellular-multicellular transitions (orange arrow), and multicellular-unicellular transitions (blue arrows). A haploid spore (brown) germinates to form a haploid multicellular filament, which eventually produces haploid multicellular leafy structures (gametophytes). Gametophytes produce haploid sperm or eggs, which fuse to form a unicellular diploid zygote, which divides by mitosis to form a multicellular diploid sporophyte. The sporophyte matures and then divides by meiosis to form haploid spores, which are released from the capsule. (D) Simplified life cycle of a macroalga such as Ulva (green seaweed) showing unicellular-multicellular transitions (orange arrows) and multicellular-unicellular transitions (blue arrows). Multicellular blade (thallus) tissue, a haploid gametophyte or a diploid sporophyte, arises from haploid spores and a diploid zygote, respectively. Gametes from two different mating types (+ and −) are required for fusion and zygote formation to occur. Sporophyte and gametophyte blades are essentially morphologically identical, as are gametes of different mating types. Isolated gametes in culture are capable of undergoing a parthenogenetic life cycle. Representative images of Ulva linza sporophyte thalli and spores in culture are shown (courtesy of Eleanor Vesty). Life cycles for red and brown algae are similar, but often more complex, with non-isomorphic multicellular stages and/or gametophyte or sporophyte reduced in size.
Reverse transitions from multicellularity likely occurred in Unikonts: fungi may have evolved as filamentous organisms >1 billion years ago (Butterfield, 2005), although many extant yeast species are entirely unicellular. Multicellularity can be selected for in the lab in the normally unicellular baker's yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae (Ratcliff et al., 2012): this is clonal multicellularity, like in choanoflagellates and animals. Multicellular social amoebae diverged from Metazoa ∼1.2 billion years ago ( Figure 1A). The bestknown example, Dictyostelium, forms aggregates from motile cells (Coates and Harwood, 2001;Schaap, 2011). Notably, the protist Fonticula alba, in the sister group to fungi, also shows aggregative multicellularity (Brown et al., 2009). Unicellular-multicellular transcriptional changes are conserved over large evolutionary distances: Dictyostelium discoideum and Dictyostelium purpureum diverged ∼400 MYA but share similar morphologies and incredibly similar global gene expression profiles during their unicellular-multicellular transitions (Parikh et al., 2010).
Becoming multicellular to escape predators can have a physiological cost via a reduction in growth rate. The benefit of multicellularity as a defense mechanism depends on the population dynamics of co-occurring species and the environmental conditions determining the prey's growth rate: in the absence of a predator and under nutrient-replete competitive conditions multicellularity can have an adverse effect on the organism's fitness (Yokota and Sterner, 2011). Multicellularity can also affect green organisms' productivity: in Desmodesmus armatus, light-acclimation occurred in two-celled colonies, whereas maximum photosynthetic rates occurred in fourcelled colonies (Matusiak-Mikulin et al., 2006). As microalgal multicellular morphs and unicells occupy different spaces in the water, unicellular-multicellular transitions can have far-reaching effects on the whole ecosystem (Lürling, 2003).
One emerging paradigm is that signals from eukaryotic-associated bacteria may drive multicellular complexity. C. owczarzaki can form aggregates under axenic conditions  and filamentous colonies in S. rosetta occur without bacteria (Dayel et al., 2011), but S. rosetta rosette colony formation is induced only in the presence of it's bacterial prey species (Dayel et al., 2011), which releases a specific sphingolipid signal that induces rosette formation (Alegado et al., 2012), perhaps enabling S. rosetta to feed more efficiently. Signals from microorganisms also profoundly affect the development of green seaweeds and land plants (Parniske, 2000;Matsuo et al., 2005;Marshall et al., 2006;Spoerner et al., 2012), although both can form multicellular structures in axenic conditions.

"GREEN" MULTICELLULARITY: INDEPENDENT ACQUISITIONS
Acquisition of multicellularity underpinned the key transition of plants to land, but the mechanism(s) by which this occurred are unknown. Land plants evolved from algae ( Figure 1A); algae have evolved multicellularity many times independently of land plants. In particular, the Chlorophyte algae include many "simple" multicellular species alongside morphologically complex green seaweeds (Niklas, 2014). Genomic information to define mechanisms underpinning "green" unicellular-multicellular transitions is lacking compared to the holozoan-animal comparative studies.
As with animals, it seems that the genetic toolkit for green multicellularity was present in unicellular ancestors (Chlamydomonas/Volvox genomes were discussed in Section Evolution of Unicellular-Multicellular Transitions: A Genetic Toolkit for Multicellularity?). Colonial "morphs" can be induced, or selected for, in usually unicellular microalgae e.g., Chlamydomonas (Lurling and Beekman, 2006;Ratcliff et al., 2013) and Chlorella (Boraas et al., 1998). Formation of the Chlamydomonas diploid zygote requires homologs of transcription factors involved in land plant meristem specification, implying that plant multicellular body plans may have evolved from algal sexual developmental mechanisms (Lee et al., 2008). In Scenedesmus, multicellularity correlated with reactive oxygen species production and activation of a kinase (Leflaive et al., 2008); redox state may also have been a driver of animal multicellularity (Blackstone, 2000).
It is technically difficult to study the unicellular-multicellular transition in most land plants at the molecular or genetic level. Embryos/gametes exist only transiently in the flowering plant life cycle, and are surrounded by multicellular tissues ( Figure 1B). Early-evolving sporebearing plants such as mosses and ferns are more experimentally tractable models for studying unicellular-multicellular transitions, as a unicell, the spore, can be isolated (and stored) prior to germination into multicellular structures ( Figure 1C).
We believe that seaweeds are the best group of organisms in which to define the molecular changes involved in unicellular-multicellular transitions, as every seaweed has a unique life cycle that alternates between unicellular and multicellular stages, involving at least two separate unicellular-multicellular transitions: germination of spores into gametophytes, and germination of gametes and/or zygotes into sporophytes ( Figure 1D). Thus, seaweeds represent exciting new systems in which unicellular-multicellular transitions can be studied with relative ease.

SEAWEEDS AS KEY SYSTEMS TO UNDERSTAND UNICELLULAR-MULTICELLULAR TRANSITIONS: UNDERSTANDING SEAWEED MULTICELLULARITY WILL HAVE ECONOMIC IMPORTANCE
The emerging model systems Ulva (a green seaweed) and Ectocarpus (a brown seaweed) offer new ways to define the molecular basis of unicellularmulticellular transitions in complex systems. Relatively large numbers of Ulva unicells (spores or gametes) can be induced and isolated, far more easily than the spores of land plants, from more than one Ulva species (Wichard and Oertel, 2010;Vesty et al., 2015). It is this propensity for multicellular tissues to form unicells (which give rise to new multicellular structures) that leads to Ulva forming nuisance blooms: thus it is key to understand the basic biology of these processes. Ulva can now be grown in axenic laboratory-based culture, including via parthenogenesis (Wichard and Oertel, 2010;Spoerner et al., 2012), enabling a step-change in the methods we can use to understand seaweed biology and development. Ectocarpus has welldeveloped forward genetics, including a series of mutants (Le Bail et al., 2011;Cock et al., 2014), some of which are specifically altered in the spatial organization of the multicellular body [forming callus instead of polarized filaments: gri mutants (Le Bail et al., 2010)], or impaired maintenance of cell-cell adhesion: bib mutants (Charrier et al., in review)].
Many green, red and brown seaweeds are of profound economic importance, both positively as sources of food, fuel and useful chemicals, and negatively as biofoulers (Callow and Callow, 2011) or invasive species that are damaging to marine ecosystems (Smetacek and Zingone, 2013). Until now, seaweeds have been a neglected group of organisms for large-scale gene discovery, thus understanding seaweed growth and development lags behind our equivalent knowledge in land plants. Genome sequences are available for the red seaweeds (and food crops) Pyropia and Chondrus (Collen et al., 2013;Nakamura et al., 2013), and for Ectocarpus (Cock et al., 2010) with an Ulva genomesequencing project underway. Chondrus is also an emerging macroalgal model system, taking ∼2 years to complete its life cycle in the lab. Thus, the time is right to instigate a step-change in the understanding of seaweed biology, including the regulation of its unicellular-multicellular transitions. This will enable new knowledge to apply to seaweed culture (for food and fuel) and control (of blooms and biofouling).

WIDER PERSPECTIVES ON UNDERSTANDING SEAWEED MULTICELLULARITY
Current data suggests that the genetic toolkit underpinning unicellularmulticellular transitions was present in unicellular ancestors, in both Unikonts and "green" organisms. Whether the toolkit is conserved between animals and plants is unknown. Using new "green" systems such as spore-plants, microalgae and seaweeds to define the molecular changes underpinning unicellular-multicellular transitions will shed new light on this question, and will also enable new understanding of how multicellular land plants evolved. Combined with the application of new basic biological knowledge to economically and environmentally important seaweed species, we are entering a new era of plant-and algal biology.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This work was supported by a Royal Society-Leverhulme Trust Senior Research Fellowship 2013-14 to Juliet C. Coates and a Commonwealth Scholarship to Umm-E-Aiman.