Loss of the Arabidopsis thaliana P4-ATPases ALA6 and ALA7 impairs pollen fitness and alters the pollen tube plasma membrane

Members of the P4 subfamily of P-type ATPases are thought to create and maintain lipid asymmetry in biological membranes by flipping specific lipids between membrane leaflets. In Arabidopsis, 7 of the 12 Aminophospholipid ATPase (ALA) family members are expressed in pollen. Here we show that double knockout of ALA6 and ALA7 (ala6/7) results in siliques with a ~2-fold reduction in seed set with a high frequency of empty seed positions near the bottom. Seed set was reduced to near zero when plants were grown under a hot/cold temperature stress. Reciprocal crosses indicate that the ala6/7 reproductive deficiencies are due to a defect related to pollen transmission. In-vitro growth assays provide evidence that ala6/7 pollen tubes are short and slow, with ~2-fold reductions in both maximal growth rate and overall length relative to wild-type. Outcrosses show that when ala6/7 pollen are in competition with wild-type pollen, they have a near 0% success rate in fertilizing ovules near the bottom of the pistil, consistent with ala6/7 pollen having short and slow growth defects. The ala6/7 phenotypes were rescued by the expression of either an ALA6-YFP or GFP-ALA6 fusion protein, which showed localization to both the plasma membrane and highly-mobile endomembrane structures. A mass spectrometry analysis of mature pollen grains revealed significant differences between ala6/7 and wild-type, both in the relative abundance of lipid classes and in the average number of double bonds present in acyl side chains. A change in the properties of the ala6/7 plasma membrane was also indicated by a ~10-fold reduction of labeling by lipophilic FM-dyes relative to wild-type. Together, these results indicate that ALA6 and ALA7 provide redundant activities that function to directly or indirectly change the distribution and abundance of lipids in pollen, and support a model in which ALA6 and ALA7 are critical for pollen fitness under normal and temperature-stress conditions.

Here, we present evidence that the Arabidopsis P4-ATPases ALA6 and ALA7 are important for rapid, sustained pollen tube growth and are essential for temperature stress tolerance. Genetic evidence indicates that the activities of ALA6 and ALA7 are highly redundant. Pollen defects could be rescued by the expression of fluorescently-tagged ALA6 fusion proteins, which localized simultaneously to both the plasma membrane and highly mobile endomembrane vesicles. Mass spectrometry analysis of mature pollen grains revealed significant differences in lipid composition between ala6-1/7-2 and wild-type. We also show that the ability of lipophilic FM dyes to stain ala6-1/7-2 pollen tubes is reduced by ∼10-fold relative to wild-type, indicating altered properties associated with the plasma membrane. Together, these results suggest a model in which ALA6 and ALA7 directly or indirectly change the distribution and concentration of lipids in pollen, and that these flippases are critical for pollen fitness under normal and temperature-stress conditions.

T-DNA Insertion Mutants
Two T-DNA insertional mutants were used in this study: ala6-1 (SALK_150173, ss757) and ala7-2 (SALK_125598, ss733) (Alonso et al., 2003). Mutants were obtained from the Arabidopsis Biological Resource Facility at Ohio State University (http:// abrc.osu.edu/) and were identified using PCR-based screening techniques. Both mutants are in the Col-0 background. The locations of the T-DNA insertions and PCR primers are indicated in Figure 1. Sequences for the PCR primers can be found in File S2. The individual mutant lines were crossed to create the double mutant ala6-1/7-2 (ss1351).

Plant Growth Conditions
Seeds were sown on 0.5× Murashige and Skoog medium (pH 5.7) containing 1% agar and 0.05% MES. Following 48 h of stratification (4 • C, dark), seedlings were grown at room temperature (∼23 • C) under 24 h light for 7-10 d before being transplanted to soil. The soil used was Sunshine SMB-238 (SunGro Horticulture, Agawam, MA) supplemented with 10-10-10 fertilizer and Marathon pesticide following the manufacturer's instructions. Plants were grown until maturity in a growth chamber (Percival Scientific, Perry, IA) under a long-day photoperiod (16 h light at

Plasmid Construction
For expression in plants, two ALA6 genomic DNA fragments were PCR amplified from BAC clone F20D21 using the primer pairs 1035a+br (C-terminal tag) and 1035a+brs (N-terminal tag) and Phusion High-Fidelity DNA Polymerase (New England Biolabs, Ipswich, MA). An ALA1 genomic DNA fragment was amplified from Arabidopsis genomic DNA (Col-0 ecotype) using the primer pair 1030a+br (C-terminal tag) and Pfu-Turbo DNA Polymerase (Agilent, Santa Clara, CA). PCR primer sequences can be found in File S2. Poly-A tails were added to the PCR products using ExTaq (Takara, Mountain View, CA) and the resultant DNA fragments were T/A cloned into the pGEM-T Easy vector (Amp r in bacteria) using the pGEM-T Easy Vector System kit (Amp r in bacteria) (Promega, Madison, WI). All PCR-derived fragments were sequence verified to be error free in the pGEM-T Easy vector. The ALA6 and ALA1 fragments were subcloned from the pGEM vector into a derivative of the pGreenII plant vector (kan r in bacteria, hyg r in plants) (Hellens et al., 2000). Junction sites were sequence verified to be error free. All fusion proteins expressed in this study were under the control of the Arabidopsis thaliana ACA9 promoter, which drives a moderate expression preferentially in pollen (Schiøtt et al., 2004). Internal stock numbers for each plasmid are: ps1730, ACA9p-NTAP2(G)-ALA6; ps1728, ACA9p-i-ALA6-TAP2(Y); ps1729, ACA9p-i-ALA1-TAP2(Y); and ps779, ACA9pi-TAP2(Y). Sequence information for each plasmid can be found in File S3.

In-Vitro Pollen Tube Growth
The pollen tube growth medium was based on the method described by Boavida and McCormick, and contained: 5 mM CaCl 2 , 0.01% H 3 BO 3 , 5 mM KCl, 10% sucrose, 1 mM MgSO 4 , pH 7.5-7.8, and 1.5% low melting agarose (Boavida and McCormick, 2007). Pollen from stage 13 to 14 flowers was placed on pistils, either from the corresponding genotype or from surrogate ms-1 plants, and the pistils were then placed on ∼400 µL of pollen tube growth medium layered over a microscope slide. The slides were incubated at room temperature (∼23 • C) in a square petri dish containing water-soaked paper towels to maintain high humidity. Pollen tubes were grown for 2-6 h prior to analysis, unless being used for a time course. For the time course analysis of pollen tube length, pollen tubes were photographed with a Hamamatsu Orca ER camera attached to a Leica DM-IRE2 microscope (JH Technologies, Fremont, CA). Length measurements were done using the Fiji software package (Schindelin et al., 2012).

FM Dye Staining
Pollen tubes were stained with the lipophilic dyes FM4-64 and FM1-43 (Invitrogen -Molecular Probes, Eugene, OR). For both dyes, 10 µM staining solutions were prepared by dissolving the individual dye in liquid pollen tube growth medium. When needed, sodium azide (NaAz) was added to the staining solution to a final concentration of 0.05%. Staining solution was directly applied to pollen tubes growing on solid medium layered over a microscope slide (see above section: In-vitro Pollen Tube Growth). Images were captured 1-45 m after the addition of the staining solution, as described in the Confocal Microscopy Section. Fluorescence was quantified in terms of average pixel intensity using the Fiji software package (Schindelin et al., 2012).

Lipid Profiling
Pollen for lipid analysis was collected from independent, parallelgrown groups of ∼75 plants. Total lipid extracts were obtained from pollen using chloroform/methanol extraction, described below. To deactivate phospholipases prior to lipid extraction, pollen samples were immersed for 15 m in 3 mL of 75 • C isopropanol + 0.01% butylated hydroxytoluene (BHT). The first extraction step was done by adding 1.5 mL chloroform and 0.6 mL of water to the pollen/isopropanol mixture. Four subsequent extraction steps were done using chloroform/methanol (2:1) + 0.01% BHT. Each extraction was done for 1 h; except for the last extraction, which was done overnight (∼12 h). The five extracts for each sample were combined and washed twice: first with 1 mL of 1 M KCl and second with 2 mL of water.
Lipid samples were then evaporated to 1 mL and sent to the Kansas Lipidomics Research Center (http://www.k-state. edu/lipid/lipidomics) for routine plant polar lipid analysis by tandem mass spectrometry. The two mass spectrometers used were an Applied Biosystems API 4000 and an Applied Biosystems Q-TRAP, separated by a collision cell. Samples were introduced by electrospray ionization, with no pre-analysis separation. Analysis was done using both precursor and neutral loss scans.

Lipid Translocation Assays
Lipid translocation was assayed as previously described (López-Marqués et al., 2010). ALA6-containing yeast (see Plasmid Construction) was transformed with the yeast plasmid pRS426-GAL (Burgers, 1999); either empty, or containing the putative betasubunits ALA interacting subunit 1 (ALIS1), ALIS3, or ALIS5 (Poulsen et al., 2008). As controls, the wild type BY4741 (MATα his3 leu2 ura3 met15; EUROSCARF) (positive control) and the mutant ZHY709 (negative control) were transformed with empty plasmids pRS423-GAL and pRS426-GAL. Flow cytometry was performed on a FACSCalibur cell analyzer (BD Biosciences, San Jose, CA) equipped with an argon laser using Cell Quest software. Thirty thousand cells were analyzed without gating during the acquisition, and live cells were selected based on forward/sidescatter gating and propidium iodide exclusion. A histogram of the green (NBD) fluorescence of living cells was used to calculate the mean fluorescence intensity of total cells.

Yeast Membrane Fractionation and Immunolabeling
Fractionation of yeast membranes in sucrose gradients, quantification of protein contents, and Western blot analysis were carried out as described in López-Marqués et al. (2012). Fractions enriched in ER (30% sucrose) and PM (48% sucrose) were collected by sucrose density gradient fractionation and used for Western blot analysis. Immunodetection of RGSH6and RGSH10-tagged proteins was performed using a commercial BSA-free RGS-His ™ antibody produced in mouse (Qiagen, Valencia, CA). We used a monoclonal anti-dolichol phosphate mannose synthase (Dpm1p) antibody (Molecular Probes, Eugene, OR) as a marker for the endoplasmic reticulum and a polyclonal antibody against the C-terminal end of the yeast proton ATPase (Pma1p) (Monk et al., 1991) as a marker for the plasma membrane. Golgi fractions were detected with an affinity purified anti-Sed5p polyclonal antibody (Sapperstein et al., 1996).

Results
Among the seven ALAs that are most highly expressed in A. thaliana pollen, ALA6 (At1g54280) and ALA7 (AT3g13900) are two of the most closely related (89% amino acid identity) and account for approximately 56% of the ALA subfamily mRNA in pollen grains or growing tubes (Loraine et al., 2013) (Figure S1a). To determine if these genes have redundant functions in pollen development, we isolated the ala6-1 and ala7-2 T-DNA gene disruption lines from the SALK collection (Alonso et al., 2003) and crossed them to make the double knockout ala6-1/7-2 (Figure 1).
The T-DNA insertions for both ala6-1 and ala7-2 are in the first exon and are predicted to disrupt the production of functional proteins.
Plants heterozygous for ala6-1(+/-) or ala7-2(+/-) individually showed no evidence of a segregation distortion when allowed to self-fertilize (Table 1). However, manual pollen outcrosses showed a ∼2-fold decrease in ala6-1 transmission, indicating the loss of ALA6 alone can result in a detectable phenotype. A similar deficiency was not seen for ala7-2.
preferentially in pollen (Schiøtt et al., 2004). The transgenes were stably expressed in either an ala6-1 or an ala6-1/7-2 mutant background, and reciprocal crosses were done to test for an increase in the transmission efficiency of gametes harboring a transgene. Both transgenes showed an expected 50% transmission through the female, confirming that only one copy of the transgene was present in the plants used in the reciprocal crosses. In contrast, pollen transmission of the transgenes was increased to 78-83% in the ala6-1 background and 98-99% in the ala6-1/7-2 background. Neither transgene showed an increased pollen transmission in wild-type control plants, indicating that the improved transmission in mutants was the result of rescuing the pollen defects associated with ala6-1 and ala6-1/7-2 knockouts. Additional controls showed that ala6-1/7-2 pollen was not rescued by an empty vector or a more distantly related ALA isoform, ALA1. Since the transmission defect associated with the double mutant was more pronounced, subsequent studies were done using ala6-1/7-2.
Seed Set in ala6-1/7-2 is Reduced and Hypersensitive to Temperature Stress In homozygous ala6-1/7-2 mutants, seed set within each silique was decreased to ∼55% that of wild-type (Figure 2). Furthermore, seed was unevenly distributed within ala6-1/7-2 siliques, with a high frequency of empty seed positions at the bottom of the silique. Seed set was restored to wild-type levels in ala6-1/7-2 plants expressing a GFP-ALA6 or an ALA6-YFP construct, but not an empty vector control, indicating that the phenotype was caused by loss of ALA6 and ALA7. A seed set phenotype was not observed when ala6-1/7-2 pistils were manually fertilized with wild-type pollen ( Figure S2), indicating that pollen defects alone account for the mutant phenotype.
To determine if the reduction in ala6-1/7-2 seed set is dependent upon growth conditions, plants were allowed to self-fertilize under a temperature stress that cycled between hot days (40 • C peak) and cold-nights (−1 • C low) ( Figure S3). The temperature stress caused seed set in wild-type siliques to be reduced to ∼38% that of unstressed, whereas ala6-1/7-2 mutants were sterile (Figure 3). Seed set was restored to wild-type levels in ala6-1/7-2 plants expressing a GFP-ALA6 or an ALA6-YFP construct, but not an empty vector control, confirming that the sensitivity to temperature stress was caused by loss of ALA6 and ALA7.

ala6-1/7-2 Pollen Tubes are Short and Slow
To quantify growth defects associated with ala6-1/7-2 pollen, invitro growth assays were done over a 24 h time course (Figure 4). After the 24 h growth period, the overall length of ala6-1/7-2 pollen tubes was ∼35% that of wild-type. The maximal growth rate of ala6-1/7-2 pollen tubes was also reduced to ∼45% that of wild-type. Expression of two different ALA6 transgenes (ALA6-YFP and GFP-ALA6) restored the growth rate and overall length of ala6-1/7-2 pollen tubes to nearly that of wild-type.
To evaluate the in-vivo relevance of ala6-1/7-2 pollen tube growth defects, pollen from ala6-1(-/-)/7-2(+/-) plants was used to fertilize wild-type pistils, and the resulting mature siliques were divided into three sectors of equal length (top, middle, and FIGURE 3 | Loss of ALA6 and ALA7 results in sterility under hot-day/cold-night temperature stress. Plants were allowed to self-fertilize under a temperature stress that cycled between hot-days (40 • C peak) and cold-nights (−1 • C low) with periods of intermediate temperature between the extremes for acclimation. (A) Representative examples of wild-type and ala6-1/7-2 siliques cleared with 70% EtOH to show seed positions. (B) Graph of overall seed set. Average results (±SE) are reported for two independent experiments, n = 15-85 siliques. Siliques were collected from at least four plants for each genotype. For the GFP-ALA6 rescue construct, 6/6 lines showed equivalent rescue of ala6-1/7-2: ss1878, ss1879, and ss1881-1884. For the ALA6-YFP rescue construct, 3/3 lines showed equivalent rescue of ala6-1/7-2: ss1885, ss1887, and ss1888. *Statistically significant difference between wild-type and ala6-1/7-2 (Welch's t-test, p < 0.05). bottom). Without growth defects, the ala6-1/7-2 allele would be expected to transmit to all three sectors equally, with 33% of the total transmission in each sector. However, 72.7% of the ala6-1/7-2 pollen transmission was observed in the top sector, whereas no transmission of ala6-1/7-2 was observed in the bottom sector (Table 3). These results indicate that the competitive fitness of ala-16/7-2 pollen relative to wild-type decreases in the distal region of the pistil, consistent with in-vitro growth assays showing ala6-1/7-2 pollen tubes to be slow and short (Figure 4).

The Subcellular Localization of ALA6 Includes the Plasma Membrane and Endomembrane Structures
The potential subcellular localization of ALA6 was investigated using confocal microscopy to image GFP-ALA6 and YFP-ALA6 fusion proteins in the pollen tubes of stable ala6-1/7-2 transgenic plants ( Figure 5). The transgenes encoding both fusion proteins were shown to rescue ala6-1/7-2 pollen defects (Figures 2,  3; Table 2). In pollen tubes treated with 0.05% NaAz, both ALA6 fusion proteins showed a localization pattern consistent with a plasma membrane association, although some association with endomembrane structures was also observed ( Figure 5C, Movie S1). In growing pollen tubes not treated with NaAz, the relative amount of endomembrane-associated ALA6 fusion protein was higher, with the ALA6-labeled structures engaged in cytoplasmic streaming (Figure 5D, Movie S2). These localization patterns were observed for 11 of 11 independent transgenic lines (7 GFP-ALA6, 4 ALA6-YFP), regardless of whether expression levels were high or at the lower limits of detection, providing evidence that the patterns were not associated with an over-expression artifact.
FIGURE 4 | In-vitro assays show ala6-1/7-2 pollen tubes are short with reduced rates of growth. Pollen was placed on pistils, either from the corresponding genotype or from surrogate ms-1 plants, and the pistils were placed on agar-solidified growth media. Pollen tubes growing out of the pistils were measured over a 24 h time course. Lengths were reported for each time point as the average length of the 10 longest pollen tubes. Values and error bars represent mean ± SE for three independent experiments for all genotypes. An independent transgenic line was used for each ala6-1/7-2 + TG experiment (ss1883, ss1886, and ss1888) with each line showing similar results. Wild-type (WT) and ms-1 pistils were fertilized with ala6-1(-/-)/7-2(+/-) pollen and the resulting siliques were divided into three sectors of equal length Top (stigma end), Middle, and Bottom (base of the silique). The observed results are compared to an expected equal distribution of mutant alleles across all three sectors. Statistical significance was determined by the Pearson's Chi-Squared test.  (Myers et al., 2009). (C,D) Pollen tubes expressing GFP-ALA6 (ss1880) either (C) treated with 0.05% NaAz, or (D) growing. Constructs were expressed under the control of the ACA9 promoter in stable transgenic Arabidopsis plants. Images of GFP-ALA6 are representative of seven GFP-ALA6 (ss1878-1884) and four ALA6-YFP (ss1885-1888) transgenic lines in which the transgenes were shown to rescue the ala6-1/7-2 phenotype. The pattern of localization was equivalent for expression levels that ranged from high to the lower limits of detection. The images shown for GFP-ALA6 represent GFP signals that were significantly above background autofluorescence, as determined by comparison with WT pollen imaged using the same exposure settings (black images not shown).

Lipid Composition is Altered in ala6-1/7-2 Pollen Grains
To determine if loss of ALA6/7 is correlated with a change in lipid composition, tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) was done on lipids extracted from ala6-1/7-2 and wild-type pollen grains (Figure 6, File S1). The MS/MS analysis detected polar lipids from 11 head-groups (MGDG, monogalactosyldiacylglycerol; PC, phosphatidylcholine; PE, phosphatidylethanolamine; PI, phosphatidylinositol; PA, phosphatidic acid; DGDG, digalactosyldiacylglycerol; PG, phosphatidylglycerol; LPG, lysophosphatidylglycerol; LPC, lysophosphatidylcholine; LPE, lysophosphatidylethanolamine; and PS, phosphatidylserine) and quantified the double bonds within the corresponding acyl side chain(s). In total, the abundances of 144 distinct lipids were measured. We chose to examine pollen grains instead of growing tubes because pollen grains could be more easily harvested in sufficient quantities, with the majority of cells in the same developmental and physiological state. Expression profiling data suggests that both ALA6 and ALA7 are expressed at similar levels in mature pollen grains and growing pollen tubes ( Figure S1b). Significant differences between ala6-1/7-2 and wild-type were observed, both in the concentrations of lipid head-groups ( Figure 6A) and the average number of double bonds (i.e., unsaturation) within acyl side chains ( Figure 6B). For example, we observed a ∼2-fold decrease in PI concentration and a ∼2-fold increase in PA concentration in ala6-1/7-2 pollen relative to wild-type.

FM-Dye Staining is Reduced in the ala6-1/7-2 Pollen Tube Plasma Membrane
In an attempt to measure rates of endocytosis, wild-type and ala6-1/7-2 pollen tubes were stained with the lipophilic dyes FM4-64 and FM1-43 (Figure 7). For wild-type tubes only, both FM dyes showed strong PM staining after less than 2 m, and increasing internal staining over a 45 m time period. In contrast, ala6-1/7-2 pollen tubes failed to show any significant PM or internal staining, even after 45 m. However, both wild-type and ala6-1/7-2 pollen tubes showed similar staining when exposed to the sterol-dye Filipin (Boutté et al., 2011) (Figure S4a), indicating that the change in the ala6-1/7-2 plasma membrane that limits FM-dye staining does not affect all dyes. Additionally, the FM dyes were able to stain membranes throughout ala6-1/7-2 pollen tubes that had been killed by prolonged NaAz exposure ( Figure  S4.3b), indicating that loss of ALA6 and ALA7 does not affect all membranes equally.

Discussion
ALA6 and ALA7 are Critical for Rapid, Sustained Pollen Tube Growth In this study, we present genetic evidence that the simultaneous loss of ALA6 and ALA7 result in a male-autonomous reproductive defect (Tables 1, 2). In-vitro growth assays indicate that, relative to wild-type, ala6-1/7-2 pollen tubes have more than 2fold reductions in both maximal growth rate and overall length (Figure 4). These defects are corroborated in-vivo by both the FIGURE 6 | The quantification of lipid head-groups and unsaturation reveals significant differences between wild-type and ala6-1/7-2 pollen. Lipid concentrations were measured using tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) that detected 11 different head-groups and quantified the acyl carbons and double bonds within the corresponding acyl side chain(s).
high frequency of empty seed positions in the bottom of ala6-1/7-2 siliques (Figure 2) and the 0% success rate of ala6-1/7-2 pollen in competition with wild-type to fertilize ovules in the bottom third of a pistil (Table 3). Only a weak reproductive defect was observed for ala6-1 pollen, indicating that ALA6 and ALA7 provide a significant level of redundancy ( Table 1). The observation of a pollen-specific defect for ala6-1/7-2 is consistent with mRNA expression profiling data, which indicate that both isoforms are expressed primarily in pollen ( Figure S1b).
out the possibility of artifacts arising from over-expression or the fluorescent tags, identical localization patterns were observed at both high and low levels of protein expression, and for both N-and C-terminal tags. In addition, because GFP-ALA6 and ALA6-YFP fusion proteins rescued the ala6-1/7-2 pollen defect, we conclude that at least a subset of the observed fusion proteins were in functional locations. This supports a working hypothesis that ALA6 and ALA7 might function in multiple membrane locations, including the plasma membrane.
Lipid Composition is Altered in ala6-1/7-2 Pollen Tandem mass spectroscopy revealed a ∼2-fold increase in PA concentration and a ∼2-fold decrease in PI concentration in ala6-1/7-2 pollen grains relative to wild-type (Figure 6, File S1). While the yeast P4-ATPase mutants drs2 and drs2 dnf1 dnf2 have been linked to altered concentrations of PE, PS, PC, and PI (Pomorski et al., 2003), the lipid changes in ala6-1/7-2 are distinct in two important ways. First, no change in PA concentration was observed for either yeast mutant, whereas a ∼2-fold increase was observed for ala6-1/7-2 pollen. Second, increased PI concentration was observed for the yeast mutant drs2 dnf1 dnf2, whereas a ∼2-fold decrease was observed for ala6-1/7-2 pollen. A parallel lipid profiling analysis was not done on growing pollen tubes because of the difficulties in obtaining sufficient sample material. Therefore, we cannot exclude the possibility that the lipid profile of ala6/7 pollen changes during tube growth. It is also possible that the observed differences between Col-0 and ala6/7 pollen are the result of limited changes in lipid composition at a specific subcellular location.
While the mechanisms causing altered lipid concentrations in ala6/7 pollen are currently unknown, the correlation between an increase in PA concentration and a decrease in PI concentration could be explained by changes in either the biosynthesis or degradation of PI. For example, loss of ALA6/7 might alter the properties of one or more membrane systems, and thereby indirectly inhibit the activities of enzymes involved in PI biosynthesis, such as ER-associated PI synthase (PIS) proteins (Collin et al., 1999;Justin et al., 2002;Löfke et al., 2008). An alternate and non-exclusive possibility is that loss of ALA6/7 might result in increased degradation of PI into PA through the activities of phospholipase C (PLC) and diacylglycerol kinase (DGK) (Testerink and Munnik, 2011). PA has a well-established role in stress signaling Munnik, 2005, 2011), and it is possible that PA production is increased in mutant pollen as a result of a "physiological stress condition" associated with the loss of ALA6/7. It is also possible that loss of ALA6/7 might disrupt a feedback mechanism that adjusts the levels of PI metabolites, which have been shown to regulate the activity of the yeast P4-ATPase Drs2p (Azouaoui et al., 2014).

Loss of ALA6 and ALA7 Disrupts FM Dye Staining of the Pollen Tube Plasma Membrane
A ∼10-fold decrease in FM dye staining was observed for live ala6-1/7-2 pollen tubes relative to wild-type (Figure 7). FM dyes selectively label membranes and are commonly used as tools for studying endocytosis and other vesicular trafficking processes (Betz et al., 1996;Bolte et al., 2004;Hoopmann et al., 2012). When a cell is exposed to an FM dye, the plasma membrane is stained immediately, followed by a time-dependent internalization into endomembrane structures (Bolte et al., 2004). While it is not clear how the loss of ALA6/7 reduces the ability of an FM dye to stain the PM, possible explanations include changes in the PM's surface charge or fluidity. However, it is unclear whether the PM's charge and fluidity could be altered enough to block FM dye staining without compromising the ability the membrane to carry out basic biological functions. Alternate explanations include quenching or sequestration of FM dyes by an unknown molecule(s) in the extracellular matrix or plasma membrane of mutant pollen tubes.

Lipid Transport Activity of ALA6
In an attempt to determine the lipid transport activity of ALA6, the enzyme was expressed in the yeast triple mutant drs2 dnf1 dnf2 . This yeast mutant is deficient in phospholipid transport across the plasma membrane and has been successfully used to quantify the lipid transport activities of ALA2 and ALA3 (Poulsen et al., 2008;López-Marqués et al., 2010). However, ALA6 failed to show any lipid translocation activity for NBD-labeled fluorescent analogs of PS, PE, PC, and PA ( Figure S5a). While controls corroborated that ALA6 was expressed at the yeast plasma membrane ( Figure S5b), it remains unclear if ALA6 has a very different substrate specificity compared to other characterized flippases, or if the heterologous system was lacking a component that is uniquely required for ALA6 activity.

Specialization of P4-ATPases
The P4-ATPase protein family in plants can be divided into five subfamilies (Baxter et al., 2003), each containing at least one pollen-expressed ALA isoform ( Figure S1a). Of the seven pollen expressed ALA isoforms, three have been linked to pollen fertility: ALA3, subfamily 4 (Zhang and Oppenheimer, 2009;McDowell et al., 2013) and ALA6/7, subfamily 3 (this report). While decreased pollen fertility was observed for both ala3 and ala6/7 mutants, the underlying defects were distinct. For example, disorganized cytoplasmic streaming was observed in ala3 pollen tubes (McDowell et al., 2013) but not ala6/7 ( Figure S6). Also, a change in lipid composition was observed in ala6/7 pollen grains (Figure 6, File S1), but not ala3 (McDowell et al., 2013). The differences between the ala3 and ala6/7 knockout phenotypes suggest that ALA3 and ALA6/7 have different cellular functions. Furthermore, the inability of the other four pollen-expressed ALA isoforms to compensate for the loss of ALA3 or ALA6/7 suggests that each ALA subfamily might have unique biological functions. The biological functions of the four other pollen-expressed ALA isoforms are currently unknown.

Role of P4-ATPases in Temperature Stress Tolerance
One of the most dramatic defects associated with ala6-1/7-2 was hypersensitivity to temperature stress. While seed set was reduced to ∼55% of wild-type under unstressed conditions (Figure 2), ala6-1/7-2 plants were completely sterile under hotday/cold-night temperature stress (Figure 3). In comparison, the seed set reduction in wild type plants was ∼2-fold. Interestingly, temperature hypersensitivity has also been reported for ala3 knockouts (McDowell et al., 2013) and a knockdown of ALA1 (Gomès et al., 2000). In addition, the yeast P4-ATPase Drs2p is required for cell growth at or below 23 • C (Ripmaster et al., 1993;Siegmund et al., 1998). It is not clear if these hypersensitivities are caused by defects in stress signaling, or biophysical differences resulting from changes in lipid composition or secretory pathway functions.

Models for ALA6 and ALA7 in Pollen Tube Growth
From the evidence presented in this study, we propose that ALA6 and ALA7 function to directly or indirectly change the distributions and concentrations of PA and PI. PA and the phosphorylated derivatives of PI (phosphatidylinositol phosphates, PIPs), have well-established roles as signaling molecules in plants, animals, and yeast (Wang, 2004;Stace and Ktistakis, 2006;Michell, 2008;Raghu et al., 2009;Ischebeck et al., 2010;Potockı et al., 2014). In plants, PA and PIPs are known to function as membrane-localization signals by binding specific protein targets, and can also regulate protein activity by inducing conformational changes (Wang et al., 2006;Munnik and Testerink, 2009;Xue et al., 2009;Munnik and Nielsen, 2011;Testerink and Munnik, 2011). Both PA and PIPs also have well-established roles in vesicular trafficking and pollen development (Thole and Nielsen, 2008;Fu, 2010;Ischebeck et al., 2010;Testerink and Munnik, 2011). For example, PA has been shown to affect the actin cytoskeleton of Arabidopsis pollen tubes via direct interaction with the actin capping protein AtCP (Huang et al., 2006). Altered PA levels result in disruptions to the pollen tube actin cytoskeleton and reduced tip growth (Potocký et al., 2003;Monteiro et al., 2005;Pleskot et al., 2013). Similarly, transient knockdown studies of NtPLDβ1, a PA-producing enzyme in tobacco, revealed a reduction in pollen tube growth that could be rescued by the addition of exogenous PA (Pleskot et al., 2010).
While it is not yet clear how the loss of ALA6 and ALA7 results in pollen tube growth defects, two non-exclusive models warrant consideration. First, the loss of ALA6 and ALA7 might result in the defective regulation of plasma membrane lipid asymmetry, which could compromise membrane-associated functions such as protein recruitment, localized membrane curvature, signaling, or membrane fluidity. For example, a reduced ability to flip PA or PI to the inner leaflet of the pollen tube plasma membrane might alter the ability of the PM to recruit proteins involved in exocytosis and polar cell growth. In a second model, loss of ALA6 and ALA7 might impair membrane curvature during the formation of endomembrane vesicles, thereby causing a general disruption of the secretory and endocytosis pathways. These pathways are of general importance for all cells, especially pollen tubes, which display one of the most rapid polar growth rates of any plant cell.
Regardless of mechanism, we show here that the P4-ATPases ALA6 and ALA7 are critical for rapid, sustained pollen tube growth as well as tolerance to a temperature stress. Together, these results support a model in which ALA6 and ALA7 have distinct activities from the five other pollen-expressed ALA proteins and directly or indirectly change membrane features important for pollen fitness.