Abstract
How can Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) faculty integrate a humanistic approach to create environments where students do not feel marginalized? Changes are necessary to address the historically exclusive climate and systemic oppressive classroom policies and classroom practices dominated by White, patriarchal, Eurocentric perspectives pervasive in many STEM higher education classrooms. By incorporating approaches and practices documented in the literature over time and across multiple STEM disciplines, faculty can create equitable and inclusive (EI) classrooms. However, the challenge for individual faculty members is consolidating the information to identify fundamental elements necessary for establishing EI spaces. This project addresses that challenge by conducting a comprehensive meta-synthesis of higher education literature to identify themes for what constitutes an EI classroom and recommendations for how faculty can facilitate one. The dataset includes 61 articles from 277 authors and 48 unique journals and reflects a timeframe of January 1995āJune 2021. Our findings are organized into four key concepts, indicating that EI pedagogies related to the affective, cognitive, and metacognitive categories of learning are vital to an equitable and inclusive classroom. However, the essential finding of this analysis was the importance of the fourth key concept, faculty cultural competency and elements related to the climate and structure of the classroom, referred to as Faculty Agency and Action (FAA). The results of this meta-synthesis were compared to the most frequently cited seminal works within the field, demonstrating that although these individual works contain most, they do not include all of the themes indicated by this study and, in some cases, over- or underrepresent some of the topics discussed. As mirrored in the most frequently cited works and the findings of this meta-synthesis, it takes incorporating classroom-focused approaches and facultyās reflective resolve to understand and change how dominant and privileged identities are reflected for classrooms to be equitable and inclusive in STEM.
Introduction
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) higher education classrooms are not race-, gender- or class-neutral; therefore, change is necessary to address the resulting exclusive climates that historically and currently exists in many STEM classrooms. Interventions and initiatives supporting students (e.g., ; Kuh, 2008) have resulted in an increased representation of those with marginalized identities studying STEM. However, many current student-focused approaches attempt to fix the symptoms rather than addressing the classroom cultures perpetuating inequities (PeƱa et al., 2006; ).
Rethinking classroom culture in support of equity is an imperative that requires equity-mindedness (): a shift from a student-deficit perspective to a mindset that acknowledges that institutional and faculty changes are necessary to address educational disparities within higher education. Equity emphasizes the need to reinforce ideas and habits that achieve outcome parity and close educational disparities (). Inclusion is the purposeful engagement with diversity () through āauthentic and empowered participation and a true sense of belongingā (The Annie E. Casey Foundation, 2014). Encouraging faculty and administrators to follow an equity and inclusion mindset provides an opportunity to recognize and dismantle systemic, discriminatory structures and barriers students face in STEM environments (; ).
An equity and inclusion mindset leverages varied and interactive approaches to teaching and learning. First, centering the student in teaching strategies is associated with constructivism, where studentsā prior knowledge is integrated into learning (e.g., Hernandez et al., 2013). Tangney (2014) argues, however, that learner-centered teaching is founded in theories beyond constructivism and includes the undervalued humanist approach. Humanism accounts for the personal and cultural experiences students bring as individuals to learning (Lee et al., 2021), emphasizes competencies more frequently associated with the humanities rather than with STEM (), and underscores relationships (notably the student-instructor relationship) as a critical element in quality teaching (Torrisi-Steele, 2018). While educators and researchers have long recognized that these approaches benefit all learners, these approaches are not always used in practice to create equitable environments. Faculty can only create classrooms where students feel they belong, are respected, and are cared for if they incorporate equitable and inclusive (EI) classroom strategies. To do so they need to understand (1) what strategies are necessary to dismantle STEM classroom policies that are systemically oppressive and marginalizing and (2) how to replace classroom practices that represent a system dominated by White, patriarchal, Eurocentric perspectives (Tanner and Allen, 2007; Miller et al., 2021). The STEM education community has explored strategies to assist faculty in creating EI higher education environments by, for example, using active learning strategies (Tang et al., 2017; ), incorporating students into classroom decisions (), creating a curriculum that includes a broader representation of identities and viewpoints (May and Chubin, 2003; Riggs, 2018) and incorporating teaching strategies and experiences that increase student sense of belonging (e.g., Rodriguez and Blaney, 2021).
In a quickly growing field, approaches for creating EI classrooms have been published over time and across STEM disciplines and reflect multiple fields of study. The challenge for university faculty is consolidating the literature to understand the breadth of opportunities to create EI STEM classroom environments (). This research study addresses this challenge and, as a result, aims to encourage more faculty to explore equitable and inclusive pedagogies. Using a qualitative meta-synthesis framework (Levitt, 2018), we have cataloged components of EI in STEM higher education classrooms from literature published through June 2021 and interpreted meaning from these studies (Walsh and Downe, 2005).
In this study, we argue the need for a comprehensive understanding of the literature to highlight the components of equitable and inclusive environments and amplify the voices of the STEM community. As opposed to compiling practices, this study synthesizes literature over time and across disciplines to provide higher education STEM faculty with a roadmap of EI concepts that influence the classroom and provide a comprehensive corpus of references to explore specific EI topics of interest. Notable work that is highly quoted and influential in the field has highlighted important EI strategies (e.g., Lage et al., 2000; Gay, 2013; Tanner, 2013; Zumbrunn et al., 2014; Dewsbury and Brame, 2019; Theobald et al., 2020), but their recommendations are not compiled directly from the literature as will be done in the present study. Further, we compared our findings with those of these seminal works to identify novel or overlooked areas and to highlight any trends reflected within our meta-synthesis findings. Our meta-synthesis surfaces significant ideas validated by published research, and calls attention to opportunities for creating EI classrooms that are not represented or underrepresented in these other compilations of EI practices.
Methods
Meta-synthesis approach and literature search
We used a meta-synthesis approach to systematically review, summarize, and understand elements in previously published literature (Walsh and Downe, 2005; SaldaƱa, 2016; Levitt, 2018). As opposed to a meta-analysis, which only evaluates quantitative data (Grant and Booth, 2009), a meta-synthesis integrates data from both qualitative studies (Walsh and Downe, 2005; SaldaƱa, 2016; Levitt, 2018) and quantitative studies (Urquhart, 2011). In addition, following a meta-synthesis research design was a deliberate choice, as this study aims to interpret a large set of data to present a conceptualized framework of concepts (Finfgeld-Connett, 2010) and follows an interpretive, rather than just aggregative, exploration of the data (Sutton et al., 2019). This differs from a literature review in that rather than compiling a summary of individual articles, it brings together a deeper understanding of the data, describing patterns, concepts, and emerging theories (Finfgeld, 2003; Leary and Walker, 2018). We used both quantitative and qualitative studies as part of our dataset but only gathered qualitative data from all parts of the articles as a data source. Reviewing previously published literature utilizing this approach allows researchers to create meaning from a large set of literature (Levitt, 2018), giving readers a broader depth of knowledge on the topic.
We initially identified relevant literature only from the ERIC (Education Resources Information Center) digital library, a database sponsored by the Institute of Education Sciences (IES) within the United States Department of Education, using a combination of terms and refinements and snowballing. The date range of our dataset represents the chronological boundaries of ERIC when we completed our search (through June 2021). The total number of findings across the ERIC database was 13,244. These methods and all subsequent methods are depicted in Figure 1.
Figure 1
Our search for relevant literature used the following key terms: āachievement gap,ā āculture,ā āculturally responsive,ā ādiversity/diverse,ā āequitable/equity,ā āinclusive/inclusion/inclusive excellence,ā ālearning AND relevant,ā āminority,ā āmulticultural,ā and āsocial justice.ā The assumptions for our search were: āAND higher education,ā āAND classroom,ā āNOT pre-service,ā āNOT preservice,ā āNOT teacher educat*,ā āNOT online,ā āNOT distance learning,ā āNOT supervis*,ā and āNOT mentor*.ā Our search was refined by the terms: āSTEM,ā āscience,ā ābiology,ā āchemistry,ā āphysics,ā ātechnology,ā āengineering,ā and āmath*.ā
Criteria for inclusion in the dataset required that the research be peer-reviewed, situated in higher education, specifically four-year institutions, and US-based. The choices for inclusion criteria were intentional, as the environment in K-12 is distinctive from higher education institutions and was not our focal environment. Further, students enrolled in two-year institutions and those located outside of US-based institutions have their own unique backgrounds and challenges. In addition, we excluded literature that concentrated on preservice or teacher education and medical education to emphasize general classroom approaches that could be applied to all STEM students. Reference snowballing from initial research findings was also used to discover relevant articles ().
By reading abstracts and articles, we manually filtered results to identify studies that described or used classroom applications or approaches, were generally classroom specific (not a lab environment), were not focused on student success beyond the classroom or learning styles, were not focused on work that specifically excluded STEM, and had an equity and inclusion focus. We did not include theoretical-based articles or those focused solely on institutional-level policies and practices. After filtering through the abstracts, we identified 43 articles from ERIC for coding. The process was repeated for Web of Science (WOS), JSTOR, and ScienceDirect, using the chronological boundaries of the databases through June 2021, resulting in 26,421 additional identified articles from these three additional databases. After removing duplicates and filtering abstracts (using the specific inclusion criteria described above), 98 articles were identified from the latter search, further reduced to 18 articles that contained specific classroom applications. The final dataset compiled from all databases included 61 articles from 277 authors and 48 unique journals between January 1995āJune 2021.
Initial coding, code-mapping, and theme processing using the ERIC database
We (VLD and SMK) used NVivo qualitative coding software (QSR International Pty Ltd, 2018) to code a subset of articles from our larger dataset. The subset of articles was arbitrarily selected from the ERIC dataset. This coding process used in vivo coding to organize verbatim passages of text to highlight the voices of the researchers who authored the studies in our dataset (SaldaƱa, 2016) and references therein. We recognize that in some instances, our coding captured paraphrases where authors used their own words to distil the ideas of others within a STEM context. We purposely avoided coding direct quotes used in our articles to limit double-counting phrases that may have occurred elsewhere in our dataset and properly attribute wording to their sources. Verbatim passages of text were then grouped into themes based on their content (SaldaƱa, 2016). Coding a subset of articles allowed for an inductive and iterative coding approach to familiarize the coders with the descriptive coding process, develop a preliminary codebook, and establish acceptable reliability between coders (SaldaƱa, 2016). When appropriate, passages of text were coded into multiple themes. After four articles were coded, we determined that subset coding was complete because the coders reached a threshold of satisfactory intercoder reliability, a Cohenās Kappa value of 0.76, considered a āmoderateā agreement (McHugh, 2012; OāConnor and Joffe, 2020).
Using the preliminary codebook established during the subset coding, the coders independently applied in vivo coding to code approximately half of the remaining ERIC dataset, with overlap to allow for continued analysis of intercoder reliability. Over time, intercoder reliability increased to an average of 0.92, considered an āalmost perfectā agreement (McHugh, 2012; OāConnor and Joffe, 2020). Coders maintained analytic memos to allow for independent documentation of the coding process (Figure 1), including questions and possible revisions to the codebook (SaldaƱa, 2016). Coding was a fluid, collaborative process in which coders revised and consolidated the preliminary codebook and discussed concerns or discrepancies that occurred while coding and were documented in the analytic memos.
The coders purposefully explored the extent of overlap in the preliminary codebook using word comparison representations in NVivo (treemapping, dendrograms, word clouds). In addition, to qualitatively visualize the percentage of overlap, the coders employed a 50% overlap threshold of Jaccardās similarity coefficient analysis, indicating that verbatim passages within two themes shared an overlap of at least 50% (Glen, 2016). Following these analyzes, the codebook was minimally updated after combining themes with greater than a 50% overlap. The finalized codebook consisted of 16 themes that emerged from the ERIC dataset; a theme identifies āwhat a unit of data [verbatim passages] is about and/or what it meansā (Miles et al., 2020). The remainder of the ERIC dataset was coded using the finalized codebook.
To synthesize and catalog components of inclusive and equitable STEM higher education classrooms, we used code-mapping, a second-cycle coding approach, to evaluate content within each theme (SaldaƱa, 2016; Figure 1). Code-mapping uses a hierarchical approach and iterative analysis to ābring meaning, structure, and order to dataā (Anfara, 2008, as quoted in SaldaƱa, 2016, p. 218). First, within each theme, all verbatim passages of text were labeled with a one- or two-word tag, which summarized the content of the passage. Then, tags were compared and consolidated into categories by matching keywords and checking for overlapping synonyms. Through this process, we identified a collection of unique ideas (categories) that describe the breadth and depth of each theme, cataloging the components of inclusive and equitable classroom approaches; see Figure 2 for an example of code-mapping.
Figure 2
To interpret meaning from the dataset, we condensed our themes into a set of key concepts, representing the major ideas that resulted from the meta-synthesis. Although no standardized number of major themes or concepts exist for a meta-synthesis (SaldaƱa, 2016), experts recommend five to seven larger interpretive ideas (; Lichtman, 2013). Because many of our themes emphasized student learning, we organized our themes using three major domains of learning (Vermunt, 1996) as an organizational framework. We did not use Vermuntās domains of learning as initial underlying theory; rather, this emerged as we analyzed our dataset. We found many themes emphasized concepts of student learning; therefore, we scaffolded our results using a structure with which faculty are likely familiar. The framework includes Impact on Studentsā Affective Learning, Impact on Studentsā Cognitive Learning, and Impact on Studentsā Regulatory Learning. Affective learning activities include student feelings and emotions that affect learning (Vermunt, 1996), including student motivation and attitude toward learning (Krathwohl et al., 1964). The cognitive learning category includes activities that āprocess learning contentā (Vermunt, 1996) and describes how students develop knowledge and skills (). Metacognitive activities incorporate the perceptions and personal knowledge about oneās learning process (Flavell, 1976) to regulate affective and cognitive learning activities (Vermunt, 1996). Eleven of the 16 themes were encompassed by this framework. The final key concept, including the remaining five themes, was not specifically associated with student learning. Instead, it contained faculty- or classroom organization-based elements that faculty could use to dismantle oppressive and marginalizing structures and policies within the classroom. These themes were grouped into a final key theme: Faculty Agency and Action (FAA).
Inclusion and processing of additional databases
Using the finalized codebook, we repeated the process for the articles identified from WOS, JSTOR, and ScienceDirect. The verbatim passages of text identified from in vivo coding were coded into existing themes where appropriate (finalized codebook) and labeled with tags to determine categories. One new theme emerged (growth mindset) from this process, which was encompassed by an existing key concept (affective learning).
Reference articles for comparison
In recognition of previous work that aimed to summarize inclusive and equitable classroom practices, we compared our findings to recommendations from our datasetās most cited articles (six articles representing the top 10% most frequently cited articles of the dataset), which we refer to as āreference articles.ā Reference articles were determined by calculating a standardized citation count, dividing how many times the article has been cited on Google Scholar by the number of years since the article was published (which was determined in, 2022). For example, an article published in 2020 with 426 citations would have a standardized citation count of 213. The six reference articles represent around 14% of our data (108 coded passages).
To compare the themes emerging from the meta-synthesis with EI concepts in these reference articles, we calculated the coding frequency of each theme in our dataset to determine the percentage of coded passages in each theme. For example, the affective learning theme comprised 25.8% of our data. We then mapped ideas from the reference articles onto our coding structure, including frequency, to determine where the data aligned with recommendations found within the reference articles and to what degree these were not represented and underrepresented in those six articles.
Positionality statement
In this study, we focus on the voices of the authors within our dataset, but we would like to disclose and intend to be transparent and reflexive about our identities associated with the work we have completed for this project. This research involves decision-making in selection criteria, analysis, and interpretation that may reflect our biases. All authors identify as White, heterosexual, non-disabled women, and SMK and VLD identify as first-generation students. Authors have currently or previously taught STEM courses in higher education. These identities are a lens that informs our experiences and how we view our data and research.
Results
The goal of this meta-synthesis was to catalog and synthesize components of EI classrooms from published literature. We evaluated 61 articles and identified the major foci of the literature regarding EI in STEM higher education. Our data included all sections of the articles and incorporated results and interpretations made by authors. We organized the foci into four key concepts, which included 17 themes. Below, we describe the key concepts and detail the incorporated themes. For comparison, we determined the percentage each theme represents within its associated key concept and the percentage each theme represents in our full dataset. This information is included in Table 1.
Table 1
| Themes | # of Coded passages | % of Key concept | % of Total coded Passages | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Key concepts | Affective | Choice | 27 | 13.8 | 3.6 |
| Competence | 8 | 4.1 | 1.1 | ||
| Growth mindset | 14 | 7.2 | 1.9 | ||
| Motivation | 7 | 3.6 | 0.9 | ||
| Personal relevance | 92 | 47.2 | 12.2 | ||
| Science identity | 7 | 3.6 | 0.9 | ||
| Self-efficacy | 10 | 5.1 | 1.3 | ||
| Sense of belonging | 30 | 15.4 | 4.0 | ||
| Cognitive | High expectations | 7 | 6.4 | 0.9 | |
| Learner centered teaching | 97 | 88.2 | 12.8 | ||
| Subject matter relevance | 6 | 5.5 | 0.8 | ||
| Regulatory | Metacognition | 8 | 100.0 | 1.1 | |
| FAA | Classroom climate | 118 | 26.7 | 15.6 | |
| Classroom structure | 128 | 29.0 | 17.0 | ||
| Facultyās cultural competency | 123 | 27.8 | 16.3 | ||
| Microaggressions | 39 | 8.8 | 5.2 | ||
| Stereotype threat and bias | 34 | 7.7 | 4.5 |
Key concepts and themes.
Themes with the total number of coded passages in the data set, percentage of coded passages represented in each key concept, and percentage of coded passages represented in the full data set. Themes are presented alphabetically, grouped by key concept.
Below, we summarize the features of a STEM higher education EI classroom. In describing our key concepts, themes, and categories, we used direct text excerpts from our corpus of articles to infuse the language and descriptors used by the authors but kept verbatim passages of text short to allow our synthesis to emerge. This leads to a combination of terms used in this manuscript (e.g., students, learners, instructors, teachers, etc.). The references that are cited within each theme are examples that highlight the ideas of the theme but do not include all references within that theme. The accompanying tables, however, list all references for each theme. The number of individual coded passages for each theme is noted in parentheses throughout the text and in tables. Categories, which help describe each theme, are indicated in italics.
With the goal of our analyzes to compile approaches that create environments where students can succeed and student growth and learning are positively impacted, the organization of the initial three concepts was guided by categories of learning and regulation described by Vermunt (1996): affective, cognitive, and metacognitive. While we used the domains of learning to organize our data, the focus remains on providing faculty with EI concepts that can be incorporated in the classroom and are broadly represented across the domains of learning. To meet the needs of students and maximize student learning, faculty can apply these key concepts to the approaches they use in the classroom. The fourth key concept, Faculty Agency and Action (FAA), compiled classroom approaches and reflective actions not directly related to student learning. This key concept is the most under faculty control and encompasses approaches to dismantle systemic oppressive and marginalizing systems within classrooms.
Key concept 1: impact on studentsā affective learning
Affective learning is defined as the emotional approach to learning, which may include studentsā āfeelings, values, appreciation, enthusiasm, motivation, and attitudeā about learning (Krathwohl et al., 1964). Our meta-synthesis suggests that EI environments are impacted by how students affectively learn and interact with content. This key concept incorporates eight themes identified during the coding process that involves student affective learning: choice, competence, growth mindset, motivation, personal relevance, science identity, self-efficacy, and sense of belonging. Affective learning represents 25.8% of the data in our meta-synthesis (195 coded passages). The themes are described below (listed in alphabetical order rather than frequency, to avoid overemphasizing themes that are simply more commonly mentioned, when all are critical elements of EI classrooms). The categories and references for each theme are listed in Table 2.
Table 2
Key concept 1, impact on studentsā affective learning.
Themes (far left column) with accompanying categories. The number of coded passages is indicated in parentheses. References associated with each theme, listed by category, are presented in chronological order.
Choice (27)
The choice theme addresses the studentās role in selecting materials and assignments, having the ability to make decisions, and having control in the classroom environment (Wlodkowski and Ginsberg, 1995; ). In addition, student choice can allow for increased student engagement and students feeling comfortable in the classroom (), a positive outlook from students about learning (Wlodkowski and Ginsberg, 1995) and students who feel motivated and empowered in the classroom (). This theme includes three unique categories (in italics) that further describe how incorporating student choice can create inclusive classrooms.
describe the impact of student choice as resulting in āpositive outcomes, including increased engagement and inclusivity as students delve into issues relevant to them and their culture, feel more comfortable participating in discussion, and take greater ownership of their learning.ā Choice has an influence on whether a class is equitable and inclusive in multiple ways. Faculty can adapt course design to allow āstudents more choice and ownership of their own workā (), and adjust evaluation/assessment to reflect that ānot all studentsā proof of achievement will be tied to traditional forms of assessmentā (). When connected with power-sharing, choice results in an empowering classroom environment (). Dewsbury and Brame (2019) suggest that āa pedagogical choice can be active, but the degree to which it reflects the instructorāstudent dialog is what makes it inclusive.ā Quaye and Harper (2007) also recommend that āsoliciting input from students of all backgroundsā about content can help faculty share authority, holding themselves accountable for choosing diverse course topics.
Competence (8)
We describe the competence theme as student possession of the knowledge and facility with STEM content and/or skills. This theme includes two unique categories.
Engendering student competence can āprovide a boost to historically marginalized groups so that they can more effectively engage in the learning processā (). To influence competence, faculty can adapt aspects of course design by creating a variety of assessment methods, including ācontextualized assessments, authentic assessment tasks, [and] portfoliosā and the use of student self-assessment approaches (Wlodkowski and Ginsberg, 1995). Faculty can modify expectations and assessment by starting with ālow stakes assignments to build confidenceā in students (), and evaluate assessments by critiquing for faculty bias (Wlodkowski and Ginsberg, 1995). By using scaffolding, faculty can enhance āwhat students already knowā (Jett, 2013) and consider how the content is ordered in the course to āpresent concepts firstā before āintroducing (mathematical) tools for problem solvingā () which can aid students to make connections and practice with introductory material. Another aspect for promoting competence is through āmonitoring [facultyās] behaviorā to promote ādivergentā ways of scientific thinking in the classroom (Tanner, 2013). Faculty can monitor their interactions with students by creating a system to call on students instead of asking for volunteers which can āpromote student preparation and engagementā and build āskill and confidence in oral and written communicationā and ensure āthe voices in the discussions mirror the population of the classā (Tobin, 2020). By evaluating interactions, faculty can also make sure that groups of students are not receiving āless attention and encouragementā compared with their peers (Taylor, 1997).
Growth mindset (14)
Dweck (2006) defines a growth mindset as the underlying belief that talents, such as intelligence, can be improved through practice and learning. A growth mindset can influence studentsā outlook on learning by affecting whether they or their faculty believe their āabilities can be developed through dedication and hard workā (Dweck, 2015). This theme includes two unique categories.
Equitable and inclusive classrooms foster a growth mindset and the āfrequent use of growth mindset messagingā to students can āaddress the affective domain of learningā (). Faculty can influence student mindset by ābuilding assessments or interventionsā that discuss growth mindset to āpromote studentsā improvementā and ābuild studentsā self-efficacyā and āconfidence in their ability to function as a scientistā (White et al., 2021). Another aspect of a growth mindset is the impact of the faculty mindset in the classroom. Faculty with a fixed mindset may āstructure courses and communicate in a way that negatively influences studentsā motivation and achievement in their coursesā () when they believe that āstudentsā intelligence and characteristics are innate and staticā (White et al., 2021). Faculty with a growth mindset āaccentuate their high standards while assuring students that they are all capable of meeting themā (OāLeary et al., 2020).
Motivation (7)
Ryan and Deci (2000) define motivation as being āmoved to do somethingā and āenergized or activated toward an end.ā Additionally, the elements of student motivation are āinfluenced by [faculty] coming to know [the student] perspective, by drawing forth who they naturally and culturally are, and by seeing them as unique and activeā (Wlodkowski and Ginsberg, 1995). Student motivation is also impacted by the need for ācompetence, autonomy, and relatednessā (Zumbrunn et al., 2014). This theme includes two unique categories.
Faculty can use positive reinforcement to increase student motivation (Wlodkowski and Ginsberg, 1995). In addition, Wlodkowski and Ginsberg suggest that faculty should avoid negative labels of students where students are stereotyped as āincapable of self-motivation,ā which can create an environment where faculty do not ātrust [studentsā] perspective(s).ā Inclusive environments are those that are also āfocused on respectā () and are relevant based on student interest āto interpret and deepen their existing knowledge and enthusiasm for learningā (Wlodkowski and Ginsberg, 1995) and engage āan interest in the subject matter from and connected to their personal, family, and community experiencesā (). Inclusive learning environments positively influence student motivation, impacting student affective learning.
Personal relevance (92)
Relevance commonly occurred within the literature of our meta-synthesis. We divided relevance into two themes, the first being personal relevance described here in the affective learning key concept, and the second, subject matter relevance described later in key concept 2. We define personal relevance as teaching or pedagogical approaches relating to studentsā cultural and personal identities. This theme includes two unique categories.
To increase personal relevance for students in the classroom, faculty can incorporate student identities into instruction, which can be accomplished by including student āpersonal biographies, group and community contexts, and broader systemic institutionsā (NuƱez et al., 2010). Employing cultural scaffolding () creates a relevant environment for students, bringing in student perspectives and personal experiences and using āinclusive examplesā that āconnect to studentsā own livesā (). suggest connecting content with resources available to students, such as service-learning projects within the community or projects that use technology students have available. Personal relevance can be incorporated into student learning by holding students āaccountable for their own learningā (Jett, 2013) while giving them agency to āengage in reflective, personalized learningā (Dewsbury and Brame, 2019). Examining the dominant identities represented in the course to incorporate various cultural identities and perspectives, can also provide personal relevance for students in the classroom. Faculty can āshift pedagogical cultureā to ensure that āall studentsā perspectives are valuedā (Haynes and Patton, 2019). Faculty are recommended to use the practice of āhighlighting those outside the dominant normā (), incorporating ānon-Western, indigenous, or other racial/ethnic traditions of knowingā into the course curriculum (). By creating āculturally relevant analogiesā faculty can ābridge the gapā between course material and studentsā backgrounds and experiences (Horowitz et al., 2018). Evaluating how content is being presented to students is also essential for EI classroom environments. It is recommended that the lens of content should be focused on students as ānovices attempting to enter our field from a culturally distinct and perhaps even a culturally hostile backgroundā (Tanner and Allen, 2007). Personal relevance in EI classrooms also includes holistic teaching. This form of inclusive teaching is āunified and meaningfulā for students in the classroom, which integrates āstrong, meaningfulā engagement with diverse student populations (Wlodkowski and Ginsberg, 1995). Finally, forming personal relationships with students by knowing āstudents and their backgroundsā and āconnecting through cultureā (Jenkins and Alfred, 2018) can create personally relevant environments for students.
Science identity (7)
Hazari et al. (2013) define science identity as how students think science is ārelated to who they think they are.ā This theme includes one unique category.
The development of studentsā science identity is necessary for them to feel a part of the course and the field. Students are typically introduced to research experiences at the undergraduate level, where many students learn that their identities (such as race or gender) are not thoroughly represented and āare not the norm in our fieldsā (Killpack and Melón, 2016). Inclusive environments incorporate ācultural relevance and diverse role modelsā (Tanner and Allen, 2007). āImpact(ing) self-schemas,ā which are the āinternal structures and representations of oneās abilityā (), gives students recognition to further develop and embrace their identities (Hurtado et al., 2010). For example, āconsistently reinforcing class content with the achievement of diverse chemists and scientists allows minoritized students to see themselves as capable and welcome members of the chemistry communityā (White et al., 2021).
Self-efficacy (10)
defines self-efficacy as studentsā belief in their āability to successfully perform a specific task or behavior.ā Self-efficacy is constructed from a āvariety of informational sourcesā and can āinfluence several behavioral outcomesā () and āacademic engagement and achievement (Zumbrunn et al., 2014). This theme includes two unique categories.
Equitable and inclusive classrooms boost student self-efficacy by creating an environment that gives students a feeling of empowerment () where students ālearn about themselvesā and their āacademic self-conceptā (McGee and Banks, 1995). Using āpedagogical practices that improve ⦠self-efficacy help reinforce a classroom climate that is inclusiveā (Dewsbury and Brame, 2019). Faculty that use modeling, can take the role of an āexpert participant that guides studentsā which can āsignal that studentsā thoughts, beliefs, and contributions are a valued part of the learning processā and that they belong (Tang et al., 2017).
Sense of belonging (30)
Hagerty et al. (1992) define a sense of belonging as āthe experience of personal involvement in a system or environment so that persons feel themselves to be an integral part of that system or environment.ā Specifically, in STEM environments, āperceptions of belongingā have been related to motivation in the course (Zumbrunn et al., 2014), and ābelonging to the scientific community has an important impact on persistence in STEMā (Killpack and Melón, 2016). This theme includes two unique categories.
A sense of belonging in EI classrooms is the āextent to which students feel accepted and supported by teachers and peersā (Zumbrunn et al., 2014). There is a āpositive relationship between freshmen studentsā feelings of sense of class belonging and their subsequent academic self-efficacy and task valueā (Zumbrunn et al., 2014). To improve studentsā sense of belonging and social belonging, EI STEM classrooms should āexplicitly address the development of STEM identitiesā (Dewsbury and Brame, 2019). A classroom where students feel a sense of belonging is a supportive environment where āinstructors establish a psychologically secure and safe space for learning to take placeā (). Penner (2018) recommends that faculty be āexplicit about promoting equity and access to all studentsā to create a supportive climate. It is suggested to āencourage students to develop sociological awareness that can enable them to define their place in historyā as students and professionals (NuƱez et al., 2010). For students to feel a sense of belonging, faculty should also āconsider stereotype threatā that students may face, and address ways to avoid this in the classroom (Dewsbury and Brame, 2019). To foster a sense of belonging, ārelationships between students and the instructor are⦠importantā and instructors are encouraged to get to know their students (). āStrong instructor-student relationships improve student confidence, performance, retention and academic achievementā (White et al., 2021). For many students, their personal and cultural identities are not visible in STEM, and they must āabandon their own cultural identities and assume a cultural identity defined by scienceā (Tanner and Allen, 2007). To combat this deficit in student belonging, Predmore et al. (2017) suggest that instructors build a bridge between cultural contexts by creating a welcoming environment. Students also feel like they belong when instructors āform a multidimensional learning experience that encourages all levels of knowledge and experienceā ().
Key concept 2: impact on studentsā cognitive learning
define cognitive learning as learning āinvolving knowledge and the development of intellectual skills.ā Cognitive learning tasks include āremembering and recalling knowledge, thinking, problem solving, [and] creatingā (). Therefore, it is important to understand how to create EI spaces that impact how students cognitive learning and acquiring knowledge. We found that faculty can use key specific cognitive strategies to be more equitable and inclusive by holding high expectations for all students, centering students in the learning process (employing active learning) and relating content to previous knowledge. Cognitive learning represents 14.6% of the data in our meta-synthesis (110 coded passages). These three themes (which appear in alphabetical order) are described below, with respective categories and references for each theme listed in Table 3.
Table 3
Key concept 2, impact on studentsā cognitive learning.
Themes (far left column) with accompanying categories. The number of coded passages is indicated in parentheses. References associated with each theme, listed by category, are presented in chronological order.
High expectations (7)
High expectations create challenging learning environments that also provide opportunities for success. In addition to the āPygmalion effect,ā whereby faculty behaviors may lead to self-fulfilling prophecies of student achievement in cognitive tasks (), high expectations can lead to inclusive classroom climates where students meet their goals and develop cognitive skills and knowledge. This theme includes two unique categories.
Faculty should ā[maintain] high expectations for all studentsā (Tanner and Allen, 2007) by āteach[ing] their content to the highest standards (Jett, 2013). To set high expectations in the classroom, faculty should have the ābelief that all students can succeedā () and facilitate challenging environments by creating ālearning experiences involving higher-order thinking and critical inquiryā (Wlodkowski and Ginsberg, 1995). The idea that high expectations are set equally should be expressed as āintentional and deliberateā to students (Jett, 2013), and faculty should explicitly explain to students the reasoning and importance for holding high expectations (Hernandez et al., 2013). These expectations should be communicated with students (Hsiao, 2015) along with the facultyās āconfidence in studentās ability to meet themā (Theobald et al., 2020). Faculty can have equitable high expectations of students by deconstructing the norms of academia and embracing a ābrilliance discourseā (Jett, 2013).
Learner-centered teaching (97)
We define the learner-centered teaching theme as a classroom that incorporates group work, student interactions, student engagement, active learning, and multiple perspectives, where faculty act as facilitators of student learning (Driessen et al., 2020). This theme includes six unique categories.
Learner-centered teaching āconnects the strengths, interests, and preconceptions of learners to their current academic tasks and learning goalsā (Smith et al., 2009) which creates learning that is āreal and meaningful to studentsā (McGee and Banks, 1995). Environments with learners as the focus, construct the idea that āstudentsā cultural backgrounds are resources rather than liabilitiesā (NuƱez et al., 2010), which encourages students to āgenerate multiple solutions and perspectivesā (McGee and Banks, 1995). These classrooms also provide āvarious forums for participationā () and validate other ways of knowing by using ānon-traditional discourse stylesā to allow learners to ācommunicate in culturally responsive waysā (Hsiao, 2015). Faculty can maintain a learner-centered classroom by using a wide variety of engagement strategies that āencourage equitable participationā () such as allowing students to āreflect individually in writing firstā to āthink deeply about their own connections to the materialā before having a group discussion (). EI classrooms also involve peer interactions where students āinteract in the classroom in a noncompetitive situationā (). These interactions incorporate group work āusing cooperative learning to promote interaction[s] and enhance learningā () which may be āinstrumental for students from collectivistic or high-context culturesā (White et al., 2021). Learner-centered classrooms also require faculty to be mindful of student-faculty interactions by changing their ārole from expert to facilitator of collaborative learningā and sharing authority by giving āvoice and powerā to students in their classroom (). A learner-centered environment places emphasis on student responsibility where āstudents have access to and responsibility for their own learningā and can āsafely challenge authority when necessaryā (). Faculty should be aware that learner-centered teaching does have limitations. Using cooperative learning strategies āwithout an awareness of contextual issuesā can āreinforce stereotypes and inequality in the classroomā (McGee and Banks, 1995). If students are allowed to choose groups this can cause marginalized āstudents to feel left outā so faculty should try to create groups with ācritical massā and distribution so that students have less feelings of āisolation and exclusionā (). Another limitation is faculty being āmisled that students have had ample time to thinkā before moving into group discussion which can give an advantage to students that have more background knowledge in the content (Tanner, 2013).
Subject matter relevance (6)
As stated in key concept 1, we divided relevance into two themes, the first being personal relevance. The second theme that diverged from the larger topic of relevance is subject matter relevance, which we define as aspects of course content relevant to a studentās previous knowledge and affects their cognitive learning. This theme includes one category.
We found that equitable and inclusive classrooms are environments that scaffold each studentās knowledge with prior and real-world connections. Faculty can create subject matter relevance for students by āconnecting what students were learning to professional goalsā (). Content should ābuild on studentsā background/prior knowledge [to make] science and math concepts accessibleā (Hernandez et al., 2013). Hsiao (2015) encouraged faculty to āreview and assess curriculaā to determine ārelevance to studentsā interests and instructional needs,ā making changes as necessary to increase relevance for students by presenting diverse examples (). also encourage faculty to be ādeliberate in how they use language to convey appreciation of diverse opinions and experiences.ā
Key concept 3: impact on studentsā metacognitive learning
Metacognitive and regulative activities are those ādirected at regulating the cognitive and affective learning activitiesā which can indirectly impact student learning (Vermunt, 1996). To be equitable and inclusive within the learning process, it is important to include activities that allow for student metacognitive processes and tasks. Regulatory learning appears in 1.1% of the total data in our dataset of 61 articles (8 coded passages). Metacognition is the only identified theme in this key concept and includes two unique categories, see Table 4.
Table 4
| Categories | References | |
|---|---|---|
| Metacognition (8) | Processing (4) | Wlodkowski and Ginsberg (1995) and White et al. (2021) |
| Tasks (4) | Wlodkowski and Ginsberg (1995) and Penner (2018) |
Key concept 3, impact on studentsā metacognitive learning.
The single themes (far left column) with accompanying categories. The number of coded passages is indicated in parentheses. References associated with each theme, listed by category, are presented in chronological order.
Metacognition (8)
Flavell (1976) defines metacognition as āconcerning oneās own cognitive processes or anything related to them, e.g., the learning-relevant properties of information or data.ā Metacognitive learning activities include āorienting on a learning task, monitoring whether the learning process proceeds as planned, diagnosing the cause of difficulties and adjusting learning processes when needed,ā including evaluation and reflection about the learning process (Vermunt, 1996).
Equitable and inclusive classrooms include opportunities for students to participate in metacognitive approaches, where faculty scaffold content and provide support for āmetacognitive processingā (White et al., 2021). Metacognitive processes offer opportunities for student self-assessment and engaging students in self-regulation as ābest practices to equatize learning opportunitiesā (White et al., 2021). Faculty can also implement āmetacognitive structuresā or tasks within assessment to āengender competenceā and motivation in students (Wlodkowski and Ginsberg, 1995). These tasks provide frequent opportunities for āretrieval practiceā of the content (Penner, 2018). Penner (2018) also recommends that faculty discuss Bloomās Taxonomy () with students to give a ārationaleā for course structure and support, which allows students to reflect on the learning process.
Key concept 4: faculty agency and action
The final and largest key concept, Faculty Agency and Action (FAA), is a compilation of the remaining themes related to faculty agency. We define FAA as the āinfluence of dynamic internal and external factors on facultyā (), faculty āanalyzing and being aware of experiences in the classroomā (Shellenbarger et al., 2005), and the created structure, policies, and managed climate of the classroom by faculty. FAA incorporates five themes identified during the coding process: classroom climate, classroom structure, faculty cultural competency, microaggressions, and stereotype threat and bias. These ideas emerged in 58.5% of the articles within our dataset and were more frequent over time, expanding across the entire dataset from 1995 to 2021 (e.g., 1990s, four articles; 2000s, six articles; 2010s, 38 articles; 2020s so far, eight articles). Our meta-synthesis underscores the importance of classroom climate and structure, such as ideas related to academic care, creating a welcoming and safe classroom climate, building community, and deconstructing curriculum to remove dominant narratives, making up 32.6% of our data (246 coded passages). Faculty cultural competency comprised 16.3% of our entire dataset (123 coded passages). The themes are described below (in alphabetical order), and the accompanying categories and references are listed in Table 5.
Table 5
Key concept 4, faculty agency and action.
Themes (far left column) with accompanying categories. The number of coded passages is indicated in parentheses. References associated with each theme, listed by category, are presented in chronological order.
Classroom climate (118)
We define classroom climate as approaches faculty use to create a welcoming, trusting, respectful community and a safe space for students. This theme includes three unique categories.
Classroom climate is āthe general temperament created in the courseā due to factors in the classrooms including faculty āverbal interaction with students, and the structure of the interactions between the studentsā (). To facilitate an inclusive classroom climate, faculty can implement academic care by providing ānon-verbal immediacyā (McCroskey et al., 1996), maintaining āpositive, meaningful, caring, and trusting relationshipsā with students (Hsiao, 2015), and including diversity statements in their syllabi (). An inclusive climate is ācaring, supportive, and connectedā (Graham, 2018), where students feel āpsychologically safeā (Jenkins and Alfred, 2018), and are treated āwith dignity and respectā (Theobald et al., 2020). Faculty who form meaningful relationships with students create a climate that āinfuses learning with the emotional sentiments of care and respectā (SĆ”nchez, 2007). Faculty should be ādeliberateā in allowing the āpersonal, intellectual, and the experientialā components of relationships to connect and create and āinclusive multidimensional learning experienceā within the classroom (). Trust can also be a ācritical component of a successful studentāinstructor relationshipā (White et al., 2021), which can be achieved by āfaculty members sharing their own experiences with studentsā () and becoming self-aware about the ācontext of what they bring to the classroomā (). Facilitating opportunities for peer interactions to āfocus on collective work, responsibility, and cooperationā (Hsiao, 2015) can ābuild a sense of community within the classā (Powell and Lines, 2010) and are also a ākey part of a positive classroom climateā (Dewsbury and Brame, 2019). A supportive community also includes how faculty engage in classroom conflict and are encouraged to use conflict in a ātransformative mannerā to support learning and growth in the classroom community (Pasque et al., 2013).
Classroom structure (128)
We describe the classroom structure theme as classroom patterns, layouts, and organizations (including student navigation, available resources, demystifying the syllabus, classroom norms, and explicit presentation and description of learning objectives). This theme includes five unique categories.
An EI classroom follows organization that is āflexibleā in which ādiverse learners can engage [with] the curriculum in their own unique waysā (). The organization of the ācourse design and the classroom environmentā should āpromote an inclusive learning experience that can be accessed by all students in the classā (Penner, 2018). Faculty should also consider that the physical space such as āroom configurationsā (White et al., 2021) and the size of the classroom () can impact the types of interactions occurring within the classroom. EI classroom structure also encourages faculty to demystify the college process to āreveal the secrets to successā (Harrison et al., 2019); for example, āexplain[ing] the purpose and value of office hours to students and mak[ing] deliberate efforts to encourage attendanceā (White et al., 2021). Faculty can also communicate explicit expectations that are āclear with students from the beginning so as to minimize surprise or confusionā () and will set āstudents up for successā (Penner, 2018). Inclusive faculty are mindful of curriculum representation when planning their courses. Quaye and Harper (2007) recommend that faculty āinterweave multicultural perspectives into classroom discourse.ā Incorporating multiple perspectives and āculturally diverse examples and role modelsā () can ācultivate discussion of divergent ideas in the classroomā (Tanner, 2013) and create āidentity-safe learning environmentsā (OāLeary et al., 2020). Deconstructing the content and format of a course is also important for an inclusive classroom structure. Instructors can deconstruct their course by āsearch[ing] for silences and exclusions in both content and pedagogyā and also look for āunconscious biases and assumptions that may be culturally normative and thus oppressiveā (). mention that deconstructing norms in the classroom can create a space that ādoes not expect students to conform to current educational practices as a default.ā
Faculty cultural competency (123)
Livingstone (2014) defines faculty cultural competency as the āability to understand, communicate with and effectively interact with people across cultures.ā By having cultural competence, faculty can reflect and ābecome more informed about the history and culture of groupsā and āknow what is appropriate and inappropriate behavior and speech in cultures different from [their] ownā (). In addition, when faculty are culturally competent, they are āaware of oneās own world view,ā which allows for them to think positively about cultural diversity and learn about ādifferent cultural practices and world viewsā (Livingstone, 2014). This theme includes four unique categories.
Faculty cultural competence plays a role in facilitating EI environments. By using cultural scaffolding, faculty can have āsocio-cultural consciousnessā with a positive view of āstudents from diverse backgroundsā (), be ācommitted to culturally relevant andragogyā (), and develop āintercultural knowledgeā (). White et al. (2021) encourage the adoption of the ācultural wealth modelā which recognizes cultural capital as a student success strategy. By āconnecting culturally responsive teaching to specific subjectsā (Gay, 2013) and recognizing that science is ādominated by white, male cultureā (Tanner and Allen, 2007), faculty can deconstruct dominant narratives within the content of the course. Faculty should also learn about students to meet their needs and understand that āstudents of today are very different from students of the pastā (White et al., 2021). Tanner and Allen (2007) also discuss that interweaving student identities impacts cultural competence by creating inclusive environments for students. The literature encourages faculty to consider questions such as āhow multicultural groups experience a common learning environmentā (), whether you are asking āone person to speak on behalf of their entireā culture () or are ārecognizing and appreciating in-group differencesā (), are extending an āindividualistic worldviewā (White et al., 2021), or perpetuating the concept of āscience as a meritocracy that is neutral to race, ethnicity, and genderā (Tanner and Allen, 2007).
Self-awareness is āthe degree to which the instructor has an understanding of [themselves] in the context of what they bring to the classroomā (Harper, 2009). The āsocial positioning of the instructorā goes beyond their knowledge of course content and is a āfunction of their individual histories, and the ways in which those histories informed their development of a science identityā (Harper, 2009). Faculty should be conscious of their privileged identities and reflect how their āpersonal biases and stereotypesā can impact relationships and interactions with students (Harper, 2009). Killpack and Melón (2016) acknowledge the difficulty of ātaking stock of all of our unearned advantagesā while stressing its importance for creating EI environments and Dewsbury and Brame (2019) recommend faculty ācritique their own beliefs about culturally diverse students.ā When faculty acknowledge their privileged perspectives, it allows for āsocio-cultural consciousnessā () and reflection on how beliefs of āculturally diverse students affect their instructional behaviorsā (Gay, 2013).
Faculty may not āfeel equipped to construct learning environments that support the participation and engagement of students from diverse backgrounds and may find themselves and their studentsā resistant to discussing āhard topicsā such as sexism and racismā (). ā(R)ace-consciousness requires replacing confessions of inadequacyā¦with committed efforts to remediate personal and professional shortcomingsā by for example āreading the student engagement literature, attending conferences where practical suggestions for engaging diverse student populations are offered, seeking corrective assistance from experienced colleagues, and pursuing instructive insights and creative techniques from high-performing institutions that effectively engage racial minority studentsā (Harper, 2009). Faculty āshould also set aside time to immerse themselves in readings about race and racism [as well as other -isms], particularly those that illuminate whiteness and White privilege [and other types of privilege and power] while grappling with the experiences of minoritized groupsā (Haynes and Patton, 2019). āThe goal is for faculty who wish to promote and practice expansive views of equalityā¦to learn more about themselvesā (Haynes and Patton, 2019).
Microaggressions (39)
Pierce (1974) first defined microaggressions as āblack-white racial interactions [that] are characterized by white put-downs, done in an automatic, preconscious, or unconscious fashion.ā Furthering this definition, Sue (2010) defines microaggressions as ābrief, everyday exchanges that send denigrating messages to certain individuals based on their group membership.ā Equitable and inclusive faculty need to become aware of microaggressions and learn how to avoid and respond to them. This theme includes three unique categories.
An EI environment consists of faculty recognizing and āinterrupting microaggressions when they occurā in the classroom (OāLeary et al., 2020). ā[F]ailing to learn to pronounce or continuing to mispronounce the names of students,ā āhosting debates in class that places students from groups who may represent a minority opinion in class in a difficult position,ā āassigning student tasks or roles that reinforce particular sex roles,ā and ācontinuing to misuse pronounsā () are examples of microaggressions. To recognize and avoid these types of behaviors, faculty can engage in professional development opportunities () and continue to ābuild strategiesā to aid with these types of discussions (Murray-Johnson, 2019). also encourages faculty to use self-reflection to analyze the āflaws each of us must address in ourselves and how they relate to microaggressions,ā which can lead to an understanding of āidentity and values, biases and prejudicesā that faculty might hold.
Stereotype threat and bias (34)
Stereotype threat is defined as the āthreat that othersā judgments or their own actions will negatively stereotype them in the domainā (Steele, 1997). Greenwald and Banaji (1995) define implicit bias as āthe unconscious attribution of particular qualities to a member of a certain social group.ā These biases, or stereotypes, are āshaped by experience and based on learned associations between particular qualities and social categories, including race and/or genderā (Greenwald and Banaji, 1995). This theme includes two unique categories.
Unconscious biases that faculty bring to the classroom may impact their expectations of students because of āinaccurate judgmentsā (Killpack and Melón, 2016) of studentsā motivation, preparation, and abilities (White et al., 2021) which can result in reduced achievement. Lowered expectations can also ātrigger stereotype threatā in students, where they feel the need to ādisprove negative stereotypes about their abilities in a particular domainā (Johnson et al., 2017), and āmay feel unsure about whether they will be fully included or that their contributions will be valuedā (). Self-reflection allows faculty to āacknowledge and confront implicit biasesā as well as āmitigate stereotype threat in classroomsā (Killpack and Melón, 2016). recommend adjusting practice, such as evaluation and assessments, and include low-stakes and multiple opportunities for mastery, to increase confidence in students who experience stereotype threat.
Comparing the data to reference articles
We selected the top six most cited articles in our dataset to use as benchmarks with which to compare our data, see Figure 3 for the citation counts of the reference articles. This process aided in furthering our sense-making of the meta-synthesis data. For comparison, we determined the number of coded passages within our dataset found in the reference articles. From this count, we determined the percentage of coded passages in each theme represented in the reference articles standardized by the number of total coded passages in each theme, indicated in Table 6.
Figure 3
Table 6
| Coded passages within reference articles | ||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Themes (number of coded passages) | Th | L | G | Ta | DB | Z | Total | % | ||
| Key Concepts | Affective | Choice (27) | 6 | 2 | 8 | 29.6 | ||||
| Competence (8) | 2 | 2 | 50.0 | |||||||
| Growth Mindset (14) | 0 | 0 | ||||||||
| Motivation (7) | 1 | 1 | 14.3 | |||||||
| Personal Relevance (92) | 2 | 3 | 5 | 5.4 | ||||||
| Science Identity (7) | 1 | 1 | 2 | 28.6 | ||||||
| Self-Efficacy (10) | 1 | 2 | 1 | 4 | 40.0 | |||||
| Sense of Belonging (30) | 1 | 2 | 9 | 6 | 18 | 60.0 | ||||
| Key Concept 1: Affective (195) | 40 | 20.5 | ||||||||
| Cognitive | High Expectations (7) | 1 | 1 | 2 | 28.6 | |||||
| Learner Centered Teaching (97) | 4 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 2 | 33 | 33.0 | |||
| Subject Matter Relevance (6) | 1 | 1 | 16.7 | |||||||
| Key Concept 2: Cognitive (110) | 36 | 32.7 | ||||||||
| Regul-atory | Metacognition (8) | 0 | 0 | |||||||
| Key Concept 3: Regulatory (8) | 0 | 0 | ||||||||
| FAA | Classroom Climate (118) and Structure (128) | 1 | 3 | 3 | 10 | 4 | 21 | 8.5 | ||
| Facultyās Cultural Competency (123) | 2 | 1 | 3 | 6 | 4.9 | |||||
| Microaggressions (39) | 0 | 0 | ||||||||
| Stereotype Threat and Bias (34) | 1 | 2 | 1 | 1 | 5 | 14.7 | ||||
| Key Concept 4: FAA (442) | 32 | 7.2 | ||||||||
Coding comparisons with reference articles.
Themes with (total number of coded passages in the dataset) and the number of coded passages in each reference article, (Lage et al., 2000; Gay, 2013; Tanner, 2013; Zumbrunn et al., 2014; Dewsbury and Brame, 2019; Theobald et al., 2020). Themes are presented alphabetically, grouped by Key Concept. Total number and percentage of coded passages in each theme represented by the reference articles (Total and % far right columns). Entries that are grayed out indicate themes that were not represented in the reference articles.
The results of this comparison indicated how the data aligned with recommendations found within the reference articles and to what degree the ideas found in our meta-synthesis were not represented and underrepresented. We discovered that the reference articles contain most, but not all themes. Growth mindset, metacognition, and microaggressions were not found in the reference articles. Further, in some cases the reference articles overrepresent themes that were not coded as frequently in other sources (e.g., competence, science identity, self-efficacy, and high expectations) and underrepresent themes coded frequently in the remaining dataset (e.g., personal relevance and faculty cultural competency).
Key concept 1: affective learning
Affective learning focuses on how the classroom impacts students emotionally. While affective learning is not a novel topic to EI literature, our meta-synthesis expands on topics reported by the six reference articles by highlighting growth mindset concepts. Mindset, especially growth mindset, emerged as a significant influence on affective learning, with faculty mindset playing an essential role in student success (; White et al., 2021). When students believe they can succeed and faculty create an environment that fosters a growth mindset, it greatly impacts student motivation and achievement (Dweck, 2015).
The six reference articles did not mention mindset, meanwhile, all seven other affective learning themes in our findings were noted in the reference articles. These data suggest that instructors sharing control of learning, providing choice in how learning is assessed, and paying attention to how the materials align with the identities and cultures of the students are broadly seen as relevant to developing EI classrooms. However, the reference articles represented only 20% (40 coded passages) of the 200 coded passages in the affective learning key concept, and no single reference article mentioned all seven themes. Further, our most common affective theme (i.e., personal relevance) was highly underreported by the reference articles, only mentioned in less than half of them.
Key concept 2: cognitive learning
Cognitive learning, the development of knowledge and specific intellectual skills, is impacted by learner-centered teaching techniques. Such pedagogies center students in the learning process and have, over more than a decade, amassed strong evidence of positively impacting student learning (e.g., ; Granger et al., 2012; Freeman et al., 2014). The findings in this key concept, themes of high expectations, learner-centered teaching, and subject matter relevance are represented within the reference articles.
Within the reference articles, there was a significant focus on learner-centered teaching, representing 91.9% (34 coded passages) of the reference article coding related to this theme. We also noted uneven coverage of this key concept in the six reference articles. Gay (2013) contained no coded passages in this key concept, while Tanner (2013) included coded passages from all three cognitive learning themes.
Key concept 3: regulatory learning
By helping students understand what they know through self-assessment, regulatory learning is a powerful tool, especially when coupled with cognitive learning influencers such as high expectations and subject matter relevance. While this key concept is rare within our dataset and not seen in the reference articles, metacognitive strategies can improve student learning and retention, allowing for greater student success and achievement from students marginalized and oppressed in STEM classrooms, such as first-generation students (Franklin et al., 2018). Regulatory learning is not noted in any of the six reference articles.
Key concept 4: faculty agency and action
FAA includes faculty identification, reflection, and classroom organization (notably classroom climate and structure). The critical difference between faculty-centered (key concept 4) and student-focused approaches (key concepts 1ā3) is that FAA requires faculty to explore personal changes and identities in addition to reflecting on elements in the classroom.
While most of the reference articles included two to three of the FAA themes, no single article referenced all four. Microaggressions, a theme within FAA that is not described in any of the six reference articles, makes up 5% of our data (39 coded passages). Although microaggressions is not described in any of our reference articles, our data highlights the role of faculty in recognizing and managing microaggressions in creating EI classroom environments. The reference articles include topics related to the other three FAA themes, with 7% of our data coded from the reference articles (32 coded passages). Many ideas within the reference articles center on classroom climate and structure (21 of 109 coded passages). Faculty cultural competency represented 4.7% of coded passages found in the reference articles (6 coded passages). Finally, 14.3% of our coded passages from the stereotype threat and bias themes were included within our reference articles (5 coded passages). These concepts are frequently discussed in the six reference articles, including recognizing, reflecting, and exploring the impacts of biases and stereotype threats.
Limitations to this study
The methods and design of this study have limitations that may impact the results we found. For example, we only accepted articles that have been peer-reviewed, which does not include books, dissertations, proposals, or theses. Further, the databases selected can bias for what published literature was available for inclusion in this study. We also excluded direct quotes used in our articles from our coding, and it is possible these voices were not otherwise included in our dataset.
Final thoughts
Equity and inclusion are widely discussed topics within higher education institutions as shown in our meta-synthesis, demonstrating that many faculty are aware of the importance of creating equitable and inclusive environments for STEM students (e.g., Killpack and Melón, 2016; Dewsbury and Brame, 2019). When faculty create EI spaces, all students have the opportunity and resources to succeed, and they see themselves in the field of study, and do not feel excluded from the classroom or course content (e.g., Graham et al., 2013; OāKeeffe, 2013; Hales, 2020). Through our analytical approach, we systematically expand on ideas to emphasize concepts that are, and are not, common in the EI literature by comparing our results to reference articles. While many of the themes we identified (i.e., themes in affective and cognitive learning) are included in the reference articles, several ideas and practices are under-reported. By exploring these themes, we highlight authors throughout the STEM higher education literature in addition to those most cited.
Our meta-synthesis suggests that creating equitable and inclusive classrooms in STEM higher education necessitates faculty implementing EI teaching approaches that center students and their identities in the learning process and are reflected in the classroom and curriculum. Incorporating classroom-focused approaches to create environments that enhance, and support studentsā learning is essential. We also found that faculty identification, reflection, and classroom organization (FAA) are essential for faculty to dismantle marginalizing and oppressive policies, structures, and practices within the classroom.
While recognizing the need for EI classrooms and being motivated for change is essential, it takes knowledge and effort for faculty to create these environments, and it can be challenging to know what changes to make (), in addition to the numerous barriers faculty may already face during curricular changes (e.g., ; Kezar et al., 2015; Cooper, 2017). With the breadth of literature available, the work we have completed will aid faculty in knowing where to begin when implementing EI classroom approaches. We invite the reader to use this meta-synthesis as a guide to their learning and as a resource to create an action plan for moving toward EI classrooms. We further recommend that faculty reference the articles compiled in this study to find specific strategies regarding these topics.
Funding
SK acknowledges support from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute through an Inclusive Excellence grant (HHMI-IE 52008718).
Publisherās note
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.
Statements
Author contributions
VD, EH, and SK contributed to conception and design of the study. SK and VD performed the qualitative coding and analysis. All authors contributed to the article and approved the submitted version.
Acknowledgments
We would like to acknowledge that this research was conducted at the University of Northern Colorado, which sits upon the lands and territories of the Ute, Cheyenne, Arapaho, and Lakota peoples who thrived here prior to UNCO ever existing, and further acknowledge that 48 tribes are historically tied to the state of Colorado. We wish to pay tribute and respect to their elders, life, and liberties, both past and present.
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
References
1
Note: coded articles denoted by *, reference articles denoted by **.
2
Achieving the Dream. (2022). Equity. Achieving the dream. Available at: https://achievingthedream.org/achieving-the-dream-equity-statement/.
3
*AikensM. L. (2020). Meeting the needs of a changing landscape: advances and challenges in undergraduate biology education. Bull. Math. Biol.82, 60ā20. doi: 10.1007/s11538-020-00739-6
4
American Association for the Advancement of Science (2011). Vision and change in undergraduate biology education: A call to action. Washington, D.C.: American Association for the Advancement of Science.
5
Anfara JrV. A. (2008). Visual data displays. The Sage encyclopedia of qualitative research methods, Thousand Oaks: Sage. 2, 930ā934.
6
AsaiD. (2016). A new strategy to build capacity for creativity. Howard Hughes Medical Institute. Available at: https://www.hhmi.org/content/new-strategy-build-capacity-creativity-science-education.
7
*BallenC. J.AguillonS. M.AwwadA.BjuneA. E.ChallouD.DrakeA. G.et al. (2019). Smaller classes promote equitable student participation in STEM. Bioscience69, 669ā680. doi: 10.1093/biosci/biz069
8
*BallenC. J.AguillonS. M.BrunelliR.DrakeA. G.WassenbergD.WeissS. L.et al. (2018). Do small classes in higher education reduce performance gaps in STEM?Bioscience68, 593ā600. doi: 10.1093/biosci/biy056
9
BallenC. J.WiemanC.SalehiS.SearleJ. B.ZamudioK. R. (2017). Enhancing diversity in undergraduate science: self-efficacy drives performance gains with active learning. CBE Life Sci. Educ.16:ar56. doi: 10.1187/cbe.16-12-0344
10
BanduraA. (1977). Self-efficacy: toward a unifying theory of behavioral change. Psychol. Rev.84, 191ā215. doi: 10.1037/0033-295X.84.2.191,
11
*BauerA. C.CoffieldV. M.CraterD.LydaT.SegarraV. A.SuhK.et al. (2020). Fostering equitable outcomes in introductory biology courses through use of a dual domain pedagogy. CBE Life Sci. Educ.19,:ar4. doi: 10.1187/cbe.19-07-0134
12
*BaylesT. M.MorrellC. J. (2018). Creating an equitable learning environment. ChE Division ASEE, 52, 143ā151.
13
BeauchampC.ThomasL. (2009). Understanding teacher identity: an overview of issues in the literature and implications for teacher education. Camb. J. Educ.39, 175ā189. doi: 10.1080/03057640902902252
14
BeichnerR. J.. (2007). The SCALE-UP project: A student-centered active learning environment for undergraduate programs. p. 13.
15
BeierM. E.KimM. H.SaterbakA.LeautaudV.BishnoiS.GilbertoJ. M. (2019). The effect of authentic project-based learning on attitudes and career aspirations in STEM. J. Res. Sci. Teach.56, 3ā23. doi: 10.1002/tea.21465
16
BensimonE. M. (2018). Reclaiming racial justice in equity. Change50, 95ā98. doi: 10.1080/00091383.2018.1509623
17
*BerkR. (2017). Microaggressions trilogy: part 3. Microaggressions in the classroom. J. Fac. Dev.31, 95ā110.
18
*BernacchioC.RossF.WashburnK. R.WhitneyJ.WoodD. (2007). Faculty collaboration to improve equity, access, and inclusion in higher education. Equity Excell. Educ.40, 56ā66. doi: 10.1080/10665680601066511
19
BloomB. S.EngelhartM. D.FurstE. J.HillW. H.KrathwohlD. R. (1956). Taxonomy of educational objectives, handbook 1: The cognitive domain. Philadelphia: David McKay Co Inc.
20
*BookerK. C.Campbell-WhatleyG. D. (2018). How faculty create learning environments for diversity and inclusion. InSight, 13, 14ā27, doi: 10.46504/14201801bo
21
BourdeauD. T.WoodB. L. (2019). What is humanistic STEM and why do we need it?J. Hum. Math.9, 205ā216. doi: 10.5642/jhummath.201901.11
22
*BoutteG.Kelly-JacksonC.JohnsonG. L. (2010). Culturally relevant teaching in science classrooms: addressing academic achievement, cultural competence, and critical consciousness. Int. J. Multicult. Educ., 12, 1ā20, doi: 10.18251/ijme.v12i2.343
23
BrownellS. E.TannerK. D. (2012). Barriers to faculty pedagogical change: lack of training, time, incentives, and⦠tensions with professional identity?CBE Life Sci. Educ.11, 339ā346. doi: 10.1187/cbe.12-09-0163
24
*ButterfieldA. E.McCormickA.FarrellS. (2018). Building LGBTQ-inclusive chemical engineering classrooms and departments. Chem. Eng. Educ.52, 107ā113.
25
*CaseK. F. (2013). Teaching strengths, attitudes, and behaviors of professors that contribute to the learning of African-American and Latino/a college students. J. Excell. Coll. Teach.24, 129ā154.
26
Center for Urban Education (2018). Equity mindedness. New Jersey: Center for Urban Education.
27
*Ceo-DiFrancescoD.KochleflM. K.WalkerJ. (2019). Fostering inclusive teaching: a systemic approach to develop faculty competencies. J. High Educ. Theory Pract., 19, 31ā43. doi: 10.33423/jhetp.v19i1.666
28
ChangJ. (2011). A case study of the āpygmalion effectā: teacher expectations and student achievement. Int. Educ. Stud.4, 198ā201. doi: 10.5539/ies.v4n1p198
29
*CharbeneauJ. (2015). White faculty transforming whiteness in the classroom through pedagogical practice. Race Ethn. Educ.18, 655ā674. doi: 10.1080/13613324.2013.831823
30
ChoongM. K.GalganiF.DunnA. G.TsafnatG. (2014). Automatic evidence retrieval for systematic reviews. J. Med. Internet Res.16, e223āe226. doi: 10.2196/jmir.3369
31
*ColbertP. J. (2010). Developing a culturally responsive classroom collaborative of faculty, students, and institution. J. Coll. Teach. Learn.7, 17ā26. doi: 10.19030/tlc.v7i11.247
32
*ConsidineJ. R.MihalickJ. E.Mogi-HeinY. R.Penick-ParksM. W.Van AukenP. M. (2017). How do you achieve inclusive excellence in the classroom?New Dir. Teach. Learn.2017, 171ā187. doi: 10.1002/tl.20255
33
*Cook-SatherA.Des-OguguaC. (2019). Lessons we still need to learn on creating more inclusive and responsive classrooms: recommendations from one studentāfaculty partnership programme. Int. J. Incl. Educ.23, 594ā608. doi: 10.1080/13603116.2018.1441912
34
CooperT. (2017). Curriculum Renewal: Barriers to Successful Curriculum Change and Suggestions for Improvement. J. Educ. Train. Stud.5, 115ā128. doi: 10.11114/jets.v5i11.2737
35
*CorneilleM.LeeA.HarrisK. N.JacksonK. T.CovingtonM. (2020). Developing culturally and structurally responsive approaches to STEM education to advance education equity. J. Negro Educ.89, 48ā57, doi: 10.7709/jnegroeducation.89.1.0048
36
*CotnerS.BallenC. J. (2017). Can mixed assessment methods make biology classes more equitable?PLoS One12, e0189610āe0189611. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0189610
37
CouchB. A.BrownT. L.SchelpatT. J.GrahamM. J.KnightJ. K. (2015). Scientific teaching: defining a taxonomy of observable practices. CBE Life Sci. Educ.14, ar9āar12. doi: 10.1187/cbe.14-01-0002
38
CreswellJ. W. (2013). Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among five approaches. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
39
*DaltonC.HudgingsJ. (2020). Integrating equity: curricular development and student experiences in an intermediate-level college physics major course. Phys. Teach.58, 545ā551. doi: 10.1119/10.0002374
40
DavisB. G. (1993). Tools for teaching. J. High. Educ.66, 237ā238. doi: 10.1080/00221546.1995.11774775
41
*DewsburyB. M. (2017). On faculty development of STEM inclusive teaching practices. FEMS Microbiol. Lett.364, 1ā6. doi: 10.1093/femsle/fnx179
42
*DewsburyB. M. (2020). Deep teaching in a college STEM classroom. Cult. Stud. Sci. Educ.15, 169ā191. doi: 10.1007/s11422-018-9891-z
43
DewsburyB. M.BrameC. J. (2019). Inclusive teaching. CBE Life Sci. Educ.18, 1ā5. doi: 10.1187/cbe.19-01-0021
44
DriessenE. P.KnightJ. K.SmithM. K.BallenC. J. (2020). Demystifying the meaning of active learning in postsecondary biology education. CBE Life Sci. Educ.19, 1ā9. doi: 10.1187/cbe.20-04-0068
45
DweckC. (2006). Mindset: The new psychology of success. Haryana: Random House.
46
DweckC. (2015). Carol Dweck revisits the āgrowth mindset.ā. Educ. Week35, 20ā24.
47
Finfgeld-ConnettD. (2010). Generalizability and transferability of meta-synthesis research findings. J. Adv. Nurs.66, 246ā254. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2648.2009.05250.x
48
FinfgeldD. L. (2003). Metasynthesis: The state of the art - so far. Qual. Health Res.13, 893ā904. doi: 10.1177/1049732303253462
49
FlavellJ. H. (1976). āMetacognitive aspects of problem solvingā in The nature of intelligence. ed. ResnickL. B. (Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum)
50
FranklinS. V.HaneE.KustuschM. B.PtakC.SayreE. C. (2018). Improving Retention Through Metacognition. NSTA. Available at: https://digital.nsta.org/publication/?i=534246&article_id=3213254&view=articleBrowser.
51
FreemanS.EddyS. L.McDonoughM.SmithM. K.OkoroaforN.JordtH.et al. (2014). Active learning increases student performance in science, engineering, and mathematics. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A.111, 8410ā8415. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1319030111
52
*GayG. (2013). Teaching to and through cultural diversity. Curric. Inq.43, 48ā70. doi: 10.1111/curi.12002
53
GlenS. (2016). Jaccard index/similarity coefficient. Statistics How To. Available at: https://www.statisticshowto.datasciencecentral.com/jaccard-index/.
54
*GrahamE. J. (2018). Authority or democracy? Integrating two perspectives on equitable classroom management in urban schools. Urban Rev.50, 493ā515. doi: 10.1007/s11256-017-0443-8
55
GrahamM. J.FrederickJ.Byars-WinstonA.HunterA. B.HandelsmanJ. (2013). Increasing persistence of college students in STEM. Science341, 1455ā1456. doi: 10.1126/science.1240487
56
GrangerE. M.BevisT. H.SakaY.SoutherlandS. A.SampsonV.TateR. L. (2012). The efficacy of student-centered instruction in supporting science learning. Science338, 105ā108. doi: 10.1126/science.1223709
57
GrantM. J.BoothA. (2009). A typology of reviews: an analysis of 14 review types and associated methodologies. Health Inf. Libr. J.26, 91ā108. doi: 10.1111/j.1471-1842.2009.00848.x
58
GreenwaldA. G.BanajiM. R. (1995). Implicit social cognition: attitudes, self-esteem, and stereotypes. Psychol. Rev.102, 4ā27. doi: 10.1037/0033-295x.102.1.4
59
*GrinerA. C.StewartM. L. (2012). Addressing the achievement gap and disproportionality through the use of culturally responsive teaching practices. Urban Educ.48, 585ā621. doi: 10.1177/0042085912456847
60
HagertyB. M. K.Lynch-SauerJ.PatuskyK. L.BouwsemaM.CollierP. (1992). Sense of belonging: a vital mental health concept. Arch. Psychiatr. Nurs.6, 172ā177. doi: 10.1016/0883-9417(92)90028-H
61
HalesK. G. (2020). Signaling inclusivity in undergraduate biology courses through deliberate framing of genetics topics relevant to gender identity, disability, and race. CBE Life Sci. Educ.19, 1ā9. doi: 10.1187/cbe.19-08-0156
62
*HarperS. R. (2009). Race-conscious student engagement practices and the equitable distribution of enriching educational experiences. Lib. Educ.95, 38ā45.
63
*HarrisonC. D.NguyenT. A.SeidelS. B.EscobedoA. M.HartmanC.LamK.et al. (2019). Investigating instructor talk in novel contexts: widespread use, unexpected categories, and an emergent sampling strategy. CBE Life Sci. Educ.18, 1ā23. doi: 10.1187/cbe.18-10-0215
64
*HaynesC.PattonL. D. (2019). From racial resistance to racial consciousness: engaging White STEM faculty in pedagogical transformation. J. Cases Educ. Leader., 22, 85ā98. doi: 10.1177/1555458919829845
65
HazariB. Z.SadlerP. M.SonnertG. (2013). The science identity of college students: exploring the intersection of gender, race, and ethnicity. J. Coll. Sci. Teach.42, 82ā91. Available at: http://www.jstor.org/stable/43631586
66
*HernandezC. M.MoralesA. R.ShroyerM. G. (2013). The development of a model of culturally responsive science and mathematics teaching. Cult. Stud. Sci. Educ.8, 803ā820. doi: 10.1007/s11422-013-9544-1
67
*HorowitzG.DomzalskiA. C.Elizalde-UtnickG. (2018). Can we teach science in a more culturally responsive way without sacrificing time or content?J. Coll. Sci. Teach.47, 8ā10.
68
*HsiaoY. J. (2015). The culturally resposive teacher preparedness scale: an exploratory study. Contemp. Issues Educ. Res., 8, 241ā251. doi: 10.19030/cier.v8i4.9432
69
*HurtadoS.NewmanC. B.TranM. C.ChangeM. J. (2010). Improving the rate of success for underrepresented racial minorities in STEM fields: insights from a national project. New Dir. Inst. Res.148, 1ā11. doi: 10.1002/ir
70
*JenkinsC.AlfredM. (2018). Understanding the motivation and transformation of White culturally responsive professors. J. Adult Contin. Educ., 24, 81ā99. doi: 10.1177/1477971417738793
71
*JettC. (2013). Culturally responsive collegiate mathematics education: implications for African American students. Interdiscip. J. Teach. Learn., 3, 102ā116.
72
*JohnsonA.OngM.KoL. T.SmithJ.HodariA. (2017). Common challenges faced by women of color in physics, and actions faculty can take to minimize those challenges. Phys. Teach.55, 356ā360. doi: 10.1119/1.4999731
73
*JordtH.EddyS. L.BrazilR.LauI.MannC.BrownellS. E.et al. (2017). Values affirmation intervention reduces achievement gap between underrepresented minority and White students in introductory biology classes. CBE Life Sci. Educ.16, 1ā10. doi: 10.1187/cbe.16-12-0351
74
KezarA.GehrkeS.ElrodS. (2015). Implicit theories of change as a barrier to change on college campuses: an examination of STEM reform. Rev. High. Educ.38, 479ā506. doi: 10.1353/rhe.2015.0026
75
*KillpackT. L.MelónL. C. (2016). Toward inclusive STEM classrooms: what personal role do faculty play?CBE Life Sci. Educ.15,:es3. doi: 10.1187/cbe.16-01-0020
76
KrathwohlD. R.BloomB. S.MasiaB. B. (1964). Taxonomy of educational objectives, the classification of educational goals. Handbook II: Affective domain. New York: David McKay Co. Inc.
77
KuhG. D. (2008). High-impact educational practices: What they are, who has access to them, and why they matter. Washington, D.C: AAC&U.
78
LageM. J.PlattG. J.TregliaM. (2000). Inverting the classroom: a gateway to creating an inclusive learning environment. J. Econ. Educ.31, 30ā43. doi: 10.1080/00220480009596759
79
LearyH.WalkerA. (2018). Meta-analysis and Meta-synthesis methodologies: rigorously piecing together research. TechTrends62, 525ā534. doi: 10.1007/s11528-018-0312-7
80
LeeV. R.WilkersonM. H.LanouetteK. (2021). A call for a humanistic stance toward Kā12 data science education. Educ. Res.50, 664ā672. doi: 10.3102/0013189X211048810
81
LevittH. M. (2018). How to conduct a qualitative meta-analysis: tailoring methods to enhance methodological integrity. Psychother. Res.28, 367ā378. doi: 10.1080/10503307.2018.1447708
82
LichtmanM. (2013). Qualitative research in education: A userās guide. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
83
LivingstoneR. (2014). What does it mean to be culturally competent? ACECQA. Available at: https://wehearyou.acecqa.gov.au/2014/07/10/what-does-it-mean-to-be-culturally-competent/.
84
*LowellV. L.MorrisJ. M. (2019). Multigenerational classrooms in higher education: equity and learning with technology. Int. J. Inf. Learn. Technol.36, 78ā93. doi: 10.1108/IJILT-06-2018-0068
85
MackK. M.WinterK.SotoM.. (2019). Culturally responsive strategies for reforming STEM higher education: Turning the TIDES on inequity. Bingley, UK: Emerald Group Publishing.
86
MayG. S.ChubinD. E. (2003). A retrospective on undergraduate engineering success for underrepresented minority students. J. Eng. Educ.92, 27ā39. doi: 10.1002/j.2168-9830.2003.tb00735.x
87
*McCroskeyJ. C.FayerJ. M.RichmondV. P.SallinenA.BarracloughR. A. (1996). A multi-cultural examination of the relationship between nonverbal immediacy and affective learning. Int. J. Phytoremediation44, 297ā307. doi: 10.1080/01463379609370019
88
*McGeeC. A.BanksJ. A. (1995). Equity pedagogy: an essential component of multicultural education. Theory Pract.34, 152ā158. doi: 10.1080/00405849509543674
89
McHughM. L. (2012). Lessons in biostatistics interrater reliability: The kappa statistic. Biochem. Med.22, 276ā282. doi: 10.11613/BM.2012.031
90
MilesM. B.HubermanA. M.SaldaƱaJ. (2020). Qualitative data analysis: A methods sourcebook. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications Inc.
91
MillerR. A.VaccaroA.KimballE. W.ForesterR. (2021). āItās dude cultureā: students with minoritized identities of sexuality and/or gender navigating STEM majors. J. Divers. High. Educ.14, 340ā352. doi: 10.1037/dhe0000171
92
*Murray-JohnsonK. K. (2013). Cultural (de)coding and racial identity among women of the African diaspora in U.S. adult higher education. Adult Learn., 24, 55ā62. doi: 10.1177/1045159513477845
93
Murray-JohnsonK. (2019). (En)gauging self: toward a practical framework for race talk. Adult Learn.30, 4ā14. doi: 10.1177/1045159518805890
94
*NuƱezA. M.RamalhoE. M.CueroK. K. (2010). Pedagogy for equity: teaching in a Hispanic-serving institution. Innov. High. Educ.35, 177ā190. doi: 10.1007/s10755-010-9139-7
95
OāConnorC.JoffeH. (2020). Intercoder reliability in qualitative research: debates and practical guidelines. Int J Qual Methods19:922. doi: 10.1177/1609406919899220
96
OāKeeffeP. (2013). A sense of belonging: improving student retention. Coll. Stud. J.47, 605ā613.
97
*OāLearyE. S.ShapiroC.TomaS.SaysonH. W.Levis-FitzgeraldM.JohnsonT.et al. (2020). Creating inclusive classrooms by engaging STEM faculty in culturally responsive teaching workshops. Int. J. STEM Educ., 7,:32. doi: 10.1186/s40594-020-00230-7
98
*PasqueP. A.CheslerM. A.CharbeneauJ.CarlsonC. (2013). Pedagogical approaches to student racial conflict in the classroom. J. Divers. High. Educ.6, 1ā16. doi: 10.1037/a0031695
99
PeƱaE. V.BensimonE. M.ColyarJ. (2006). Contextual problem defining: learning to think and act from the standpoint of equity. Lib. Educ.92, 48ā55.
100
*PennerM. R. (2018). Building an inclusive classroom. J. Undergrad. Neurosci. Educ., 16, 268ā272. doi: 10.1017/CBO9781107415324.004
101
PierceC. M. (1974). āPsychiatric problems of the black minorityā in American handbook of psychiatry. ed. ArietiS. (New York: Basic Books), 512ā523.
102
*PowellJ. D.LinesJ. I. (2010). Make learning personal: recommendations for classroom practice. About Campus.15, 19ā25. doi: 10.1002/abc.20018
103
*PredmoreC.Remigia KushnerS.James AndersonC. (2017). So, that is what you said?J. Invitational Theory Pract.23, 91ā97. doi: 10.26522/jitp.v23i.3500
104
QSR International Pty Ltd. (2018). NVivo. QSR International Pty Ltd.
105
*QuayeS. J.HarperS. R. (2007). Faculty accountability for culturally inclusive pedagogy and curricula. Lib. Educ.93, 32ā39.
106
RiggsB. (2018). Mutually beneficial research partnerships for equity and innovation in science. American Society of Cell Biology. Available at: https://www.ascb.org/careers/mutually-beneficial-research-partnerships-for-equity-and-innovation-in-science/.
107
RodriguezS. L.BlaneyJ. M. (2021). āWeāre the unicorns in STEMā: understanding how academic and social experiences influence sense of belonging for Latina undergraduate students. J. Divers. High. Educ.14, 441ā455. doi: 10.1037/dhe0000176
108
RyanR. M.DeciE. L. (2000). Intrinsic and extrinsic motivations: classic definitions and new directions. Contemp. Educ. Psychol.25, 54ā67. doi: 10.1006/ceps.1999.1020
109
SaldaƱaJ. (2016). The coding manual for qualitative researchers. London: SAGE.
110
*SĆ”nchezR. M. (2007). Community as a participatory foundation in culturally conscientious classrooms. Multicult. Educ.15, 50ā52.
111
ShellenbargerT.PalmerE. A.LabantA. L.KuzneskiJ. L. (2005). Use of faculty reflection to improve teaching. Annu. Rev. Nurs. Educ.3, 343ā358.
112
*SmithK. A.DouglasT. C.CoxM. F. (2009). Supportive teaching and learning strategies in STEM education. New Dir. Teach. Learn., 17, 19ā32. doi: 10.1002/tl.341
113
SteeleC. M. (1997). A threat in the air: how stereotypes shape intellectual identity and performance. Am. Psychol.52, 613ā629. doi: 10.1037/0003-066X.52.6.613
114
SueD. W. (2010). Microaggressions in everyday life: Race, gender, and sexual orientation. New York: John Wiley and Sons.
115
SuttonA.ClowesM.PrestonL.BoothA. (2019). Meeting the review family: exploring review types and associated information retrieval requirements. Health Inf. Libr. J.36, 202ā222. doi: 10.1111/hir.12276
116
*TangG.El TurkeyH.Cilli-TurnerE.SavicM.KarakokG.PlaxcoD. (2017). Inquiry as an entry point to equity in the classroom. Int. J. Math. Educ. Sci. Technol.48, S4āS15. doi: 10.1080/0020739X.2017.1352045
117
TangneyS. (2014). Student-centred learning: a humanist perspective. Teach. High. Educ.19, 266ā275. doi: 10.1080/13562517.2013.860099
118
TannerK. D. (2013). Structure matters: twenty-one teaching strategies to promote student engagement and cultivate classroom equity. CBE Life Sci. Educ.12, 322ā331. doi: 10.1187/cbe.13-06-0115
119
*TannerK. D.AllenD. (2007). Cultural competence in the college biology classroom. CBE Life Sci. Educ.6, 251ā258. doi: 10.1187/cbe.07-09
120
*TaylorJ. A. T. (1997). Warming a chilly classroom. Am. Soc. Eng. Educ., 6, 28ā33.
121
The Annie E. Casey Foundation. (2014). Embracing equity: 7 steps to advance and embed race equity and inclusion within your organization. Baltimore, MD: The Annie E. Casey Foundation.
122
TheobaldE. J.HillM. J.TranE.AgrawalS.Nicole ArroyoE.BehlingS.et al. (2020). Active learning narrows achievement gaps for underrepresented students in undergraduate science, technology, engineering, and math. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A.117, 6476ā6483. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1916903117
123
*TobinR. G. (2020). Simple steps to promote classroom engagement and inclusion: a report from the field. Phys. Teach.58, 316ā319. doi: 10.1119/1.5145524
124
Torrisi-SteeleG. (2018). The human student: The essentiality of the teacher-student connection in higher education. Int. J. Adult Vocat. Educ. Technol.9, 1ā10. doi: 10.4018/IJAVET.2018040101
125
UrquhartC. (2011). Meta-synthesis of research on information seeking behaviour. Inf. Res.16, 1ā14.
126
VermuntJ. D. (1996). Metacognitive, cognitive and affective aspects of learning styles and strategies: a phenomenographic analysis. High. Educ.31, 25ā50. doi: 10.1007/BF00129106
127
WalshD.DowneS. (2005). Meta-synthesis method for qualitative research: a literature review. J. Adv. Nurs.50, 204ā211. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2648.2005.03380.x
128
*WhiteK. N.Vincent-LaytonK.VillarrealB. (2021). Equitable and inclusive practices designed to reduce equity gaps in undergraduate chemistry courses. J. Chem. Educ.98, 330ā339. doi: 10.1021/acs.jchemed.0c01094
129
WlodkowskiR.GinsbergM. (1995). A framework for culturally responsive teaching. Educ. Leadersh.53, 17ā21.
130
ZumbrunnS.McKimC.BuhsE.HawleyL. R. (2014). Support, belonging, motivation, and engagement in the college classroom: a mixed method study. Instr. Sci.42, 661ā684. doi: 10.1007/s11251-014-9310-0
Summary
Keywords
equity-mindedness, equity, inclusive classrooms, inclusion, STEM, higher education, meta-synthesis
Citation
Duncan VL, Holt EA and Keenan SM (2023) Creating an equitable and inclusive STEM classroom: a qualitative meta-synthesis of approaches and practices in higher education. Front. Educ. 8:1154652. doi: 10.3389/feduc.2023.1154652
Received
30 January 2023
Accepted
24 August 2023
Published
15 September 2023
Volume
8 - 2023
Edited by
Susannah McGowan, Georgetown University, United States
Reviewed by
Sheila S. Jaswal, Amherst College, United States; Amber Simpson, Binghamton University, United States
Updates
Copyright
Ā© 2023 Duncan, Holt and Keenan.
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
*Correspondence: Victoria L. Duncan, victoria.duncan@unco.edu
Disclaimer
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.