COMMUNITY CASE STUDY article

Front. Educ., 05 June 2026

Sec. Higher Education

Volume 11 - 2026 | https://doi.org/10.3389/feduc.2026.1827903

Fostering engagement through content-based instruction: a study of Chinese tier-2 university EFL students

  • College of Applied Foreign Languages, Zhejiang Yuexiu University of Foreign Languages, Shaoxing, China

Abstract

The present study investigates how Content-based Instruction (CBI) fosters multidimensional engagement: emotional, cognitive, and behavioral, among non-English majors at a Chinese tier-2 university. Using a sequential explanatory mixed-methods design, it tracked 200 second-year engineering students across five CBI classes via longitudinal questionnaires. Follow-up semi-structured interviews with five instructors and a focus group with ten students, complemented by classroom observations, provided qualitative depth. Findings indicate that CBI significantly enhances student engagement over time when implemented with high-quality authentic materials and a supportive, facilitative teaching style. However, challenges persist: tensions between content and language goals, disparities in students’ English proficiency, and insufficient linguistic scaffolding can hinder equitable participation. Situating these insights within recent engagement theory and Global South CBI/EMI research, the study offers a nuanced understanding of CBI's potential and limitations within the specific context of Chinese tier-2 engineering universities, serving as a case study for similar institutions in emerging economies.

1 Introduction

In 2001, the Ministry of Education in China (MoE) issued a landmark policy endorsing the use of English as the Medium of Instruction (EMI) for key technical and professional disciplines, including biotechnology, information technology, finance, and law (Feng et al., 2023). This directive catalyzed a nationwide movement towards integrating language and content learning, with Content-based Instruction (CBI) emerging as the primary pedagogical vehicle for its implementation. Over two decades later, CBI programs are now a fixture in hundreds of Chinese universities, driven by a national ambition to cultivate globally competitive graduates equipped with both specialized knowledge and advanced English proficiency (Qiu and Yuan, 2025).

CBI, a pedagogical approach whose roots are often traced to Canadian immersion programs, is fundamentally characterized by its dual, integrative focus on content and language (Cenoz, 2015). In a CBI classroom, the target language (in this case, English) is not the object of study but the medium through which disciplinary knowledge is acquired. This paradigm shift promises significant benefits, moving beyond the decontextualized grammar drills of traditional EFL classrooms to offer learners authentic, meaningful, and cognitively demanding tasks. A substantial body of research has explored the implementation of CBI in various global contexts, illuminating its positive impacts on students' academic learning, cognitive development, specialized vocabulary acquisition, and overall motivation (Escudero et al., 2025; Iglesias Diéguez, 2022; Sugianti, 2024). Simultaneously, scholars have documented the complex challenges inherent in its execution, such as content teachers' frequent lack of formal language pedagogy training (Lo and Othman, 2023), students’ anxiety stemming from limited English proficiency (San Isidro and Lasagabaster, 2022), and the perennial struggle to balance linguistic accuracy with disciplinary rigor (Aguilar and Rodríguez, 2012).

Within the specific context of Chinese higher education, research on CBI has grown steadily. Studies have analyzed its application across diverse fields, from medical education (Guan, 2024) to legal English (Li and Pei, 2024) and maritime studies (Hui and Ishak, 2022). While these investigations consistently affirm CBI's significant application value (Hui and Ishak, 2022), their primary focus has been on outcomes such as language proficiency gains, learning motivation, and the development of critical thinking skills. A critical gap, however, remains in our understanding of how CBI influences the fundamental process of student engagement, the very engine that drives deep learning and long-term retention.

Student engagement is a powerful predictor of educational success, encompassing the emotional, cognitive, and behavioral investments a learner makes in their education (Christenson et al., 2012). It represents the nexus where pedagogical design meets the learner's intrinsic motivation and willingness to participate. Despite its centrality to effective learning, few studies have systematically investigated CBI's potential to foster this multidimensional construct, particularly in the understudied context of tier-2 Chinese universities. Research in secondary CBI settings has begun to explore cognitive engagement (Evnitskaya and Dalton-Puffer, 2020), but a holistic view of engagement in the tertiary EFL landscape is lacking.

This gap is particularly salient given the evolving nature of both CBI theory and the Chinese higher education environment. Recent scholarship has moved beyond a simple dichotomy between CBI and EMI, recognizing them as part of a broader continuum of Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL) (Doiz and Lasagabaster, 2025; Lo, 2024; Nikolov and Krevelj, 2024). Furthermore, the post-pandemic era has seen a surge in research on learner agency and well-being, all of which are increasingly relevant to CBI practice (Mercer and Dornyei, 2022; Wang et al., 2024). Against this backdrop, a fresh and empirically grounded investigation into CBI's impact on student engagement is not only timely but essential.

Therefore, the present study aims to bridge this critical research gap by conducting a detailed, mixed-methods inquiry into the effectiveness of CBI in enhancing students' multidimensional engagement at a Chinese tier-2 university. By triangulating data from questionnaires, classroom observations and interviews with both students and teachers, this research seeks to provide a comprehensive and nuanced account of the CBI experience, moving beyond simple efficacy claims to explore the underlying mechanisms and contextual factors that shape student engagement. The findings aim to offer valuable theoretical insights and practical guidance to stakeholders invested in the successful implementation of CBI in similar EFL contexts across the Global South.

It is important to clarify the terminology adopted in this study. While Content-Based Instruction (CBI), English as a Medium of Instruction (EMI) and Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL) are often used interchangeably, we position them along a pedagogical continuum (Lo, 2024; Nikolov and Krevelj, 2024). In this study, CBI refers specifically to the instructional approach where English is the medium for delivering disciplinary content to non-language majors, with an implicit rather than explicit focus on language form.

2 Literature review

2.1 Content-based instruction: evolution and core principles

Content-based Instruction is defined by Richards and Rodgers (2001, p. 204) as “the teaching of content or information in the language being learned with little or no direct or explicit effort to teach the language itself separately from the content being taught”. This definition, while foundational, has been refined and expanded over the past two decades. Contemporary CBI is less about the complete absence of language focus and more about its seamless integration into meaningful content-driven tasks. It is now widely recognized as a leading pedagogical approach in language teaching, particularly in contexts where learners have a clear, instrumental need for the target language in their academic or professional futures (Richards and Rodgers, 2001).

The core strength of CBI lies in its ability to increase learners' exposure to the target language through authentic and purposeful communication. Instead of learning about English, students learn through English engaging with real-world texts, problems and discourses from their chosen field of study. This approach aligns with sociocultural theories of learning, which posit that knowledge is co-constructed through social interaction and situated activity (Vygotsky, 1978). In a CBI classroom, the curriculum is subject-matter-based, utilizes authentic language and texts and is designed to address the specific needs and interests of the learners, a bottom-up approach that fosters natural language acquisition through meaningful input and output (Krashen, 1985).

Recent studies continue to report high levels of student approval and motivation for CBI at the university level (Iglesias Diéguez, 2022; Qiu and Yuan, 2025). Students frequently report tangible benefits in their language attainment, particularly in the acquisition of discipline-specific vocabulary and improvements in their listening and speaking skills, which are directly scaffolded by the authentic communicative demands of the classroom (Sugianti, 2024). However, the implementation of CBI is marked by a notable tension: the instructor's self-positioning. As Aguilar and Rodríguez (2012) and Block and Moncada-Comas (2022) have observed, content lecturers typically do not see themselves as English language teachers. Consequently, they rarely incorporate formal language learning assessments or provide systematic corrective feedback on linguistic form, often prioritizing the accurate transmission of disciplinary knowledge over linguistic precision.

This tension is central to the ongoing debate about the relationship between CBI and EMI. Historically treated as distinct, recent scholarship by Nikolov and Krevelj (2024) argues that they are not pedagogically separate approaches but rather lie on a spectrum of integrated learning, both capable of impacting students' academic performance. The key differentiator may lie not in the label but in the degree of explicit attention paid to language as a learning objective. Lyster and Tedick's (2022) influential counterbalanced approach remains highly relevant, cautioning that simply teaching content through an L2 is insufficient to lead to content and language learning, and a focus on language form is necessary. This principle underscores a critical challenge for CBI practitioners: how to maintain the integrity of the content while simultaneously creating opportunities for deliberate language practice and development.

2.2 Student classroom engagement: a multidimensional construct

Student engagement is a cornerstone of effective education, serving as a powerful predictor of learning, development and academic persistence (Christenson et al., 2012). It is not a monolithic concept but a complex and multidimensional construct that encompasses the learner's investment across three interconnected domains: emotion, behavior and cognition (Fredricks et al., 2004).

Emotional engagement refers to the student's affective reactions to teachers, peers, academic tasks and the learning environment itself. It includes feelings of interest, enjoyment, belonging and a sense of safety. A student who feels valued and connected to their learning community is far more likely to invest effort and persist through challenges. Behavioral engagement is the observable manifestation of a student's involvement. It includes active participation, attentiveness, effort, persistence, asking questions and following classroom rules. This is the dimension most easily measured by an external observer and is crucial for preventing disengagement and dropout (Fredricks et al., 2004). Cognitive engagement pertains to the mental investment a student makes in their learning. It involves the strategic use of metacognitive and self-regulatory strategies, a willingness to grapple with complex ideas, and a commitment to deep understanding rather than rote memorization. A cognitively engaged student is one who actively constructs knowledge, makes connections between new and prior learning, and seeks to master difficult material.

These three dimensions are deeply intertwined and ideally go hand in hand (Mercer and Dörnyei, 2022). Optimal learning occurs when a student is affectively invested (emotionally engaged), demonstrates this investment through their actions (behaviorally engaged), and is mentally processing the material at a deep level (cognitively engaged). High-quality engagement, as Blumenfeld et al. (2006) suggest, is fostered by authentic, inquiry-based, collaborative and technologically enriched learning environments.

CBI, by its very design, appears to be a potent catalyst for all three dimensions of engagement. Its use of authentic, discipline-specific materials provides a strong foundation for emotional engagement by making learning relevant and intrinsically interesting. The collaborative, task-based nature of many CBI activities naturally promotes behavioral engagement through peer interaction and active participation. Finally, the requirement to process complex academic content in a foreign language demands significant cognitive effort, thereby fostering deep cognitive engagement. The ideal CBI curriculum, therefore, creates a synergistic loop where content provides the purpose, language provides the tool, and engagement is the dynamic outcome.

However, achieving this ideal is challenging. The same features that make CBI engaging for some can be overwhelming for others, particularly in an EFL context where students' language proficiency varies widely. The cognitive load of processing both novel content and a non-native language simultaneously can lead to frustration and disengagement for lower-proficiency learners (Foncubierta et al., 2018). Furthermore, if the teacher fails to create a psychologically safe and supportive environment, the fear of making linguistic errors can stifle behavioral engagement. Thus, while CBI holds immense promise for enhancing engagement, its success depends on thoughtful implementation that addresses these potential pitfalls.

Thus, it is hypothesized that CBI, functioning as a socioculturally mediated learning environment, will yield measurable improvements across the three dimensions of engagement. Specifically, the use of authentic materials​ (the “tool”) provides the cognitive demand and relevance necessary to stimulate cognitive engagement, prompting students to deploy advanced learning strategies. Concurrently, the interactive classroom (the social interaction), characterized by teacher facilitation and peer collaboration, establishes the psychological safety and rapport needed to boost emotional engagement (a sense of belonging and value) and promote behavioral engagement (observable participation and sustained effort). This integrated framework positions engagement not merely as an outcome, but as the dynamic mechanism through which CBI fosters deep, lasting learning in the EFL context. Guided by this logic, this study operationalizes the following research questions to empirically test these relationships.

To what extent can CBI enhance students’ multidimensional classroom engagement in English-medium subject courses at a Chinese tier-2 university? This overarching question is operationalized into two concrete research questions designed to provide both a broad assessment and a detailed analysis of the phenomenon:

RQ1: How does participation in a CBI program influence students' emotional, behavioral and cognitive engagement over time, considering variations in English proficiency?

RQ2: What are the specific mechanisms (e.g., authentic materials, teacher facilitation) through which CBI impacts the three dimensions of engagement, and how do these mechanisms interact with student proficiency levels?

3 Research methodology

3.1 Research settings

This study was conducted at a large, public tier-2 university in Eastern China, with a century-long history and a strong reputation in engineering disciplines. The university enrolls approximately 6,000 new students annually, with its most popular majors lying in textile engineering, material science, and biological engineering. In alignment with the MoE's (2001) policy on EMI, the university launched a formal CBI initiative over a decade ago. The program's structure is as follows: (1) content teachers with significant overseas experience in English-speaking countries are selected to lead CBI courses; (2) these instructors deliver standard curriculum subjects (e.g., Chemical Engineering, Welding Materials) entirely in English; and (3) final examinations are administered in English to assess both content mastery and English proficiency. Currently, 26 courses are part of the CBI program, with five being year-long and the remainder spanning a single semester. The university provides financial incentives for CBI teachers to develop or adapt teaching materials from published and online resources, acknowledging the substantial additional workload involved.

3.2 Research subjects

All participants were sophomore (second-year) non-English major students who had successfully passed the College English Test Band 4 (CET-4), a benchmark that roughly corresponds to a B2 level on the CEFR or a 4.5 on the IELTS scale. Their participation in the CBI program was voluntary, requiring an individual application and official assignment from their respective colleges, a common selection model in Chinese tier-2 institutions (Cai, 2022; Liao et al., 2025).

It is important to acknowledge a significant selection bias inherent in the participant recruitment process. As participation was voluntary and contingent on passing the CET-4, the sample likely represents a subset of students who are more motivated and have higher baseline English proficiency than the general student population. Consequently, the positive effects of CBI reported in this study may be overestimated and may not be generalizable to all EFL learners, particularly those with lower proficiency levels.

3.2.1 Questionnaire survey participants

Questionnaire Survey Participants: A cohort of 200 students from five intact CBI classes, representing five different engineering majors, was selected for the longitudinal questionnaire component of the study. Their demographic profile is detailed in Table 1.

Table 1

CBI CohortsVariablen / Value
GenderMale92
Female108
Total200
AgeMaximum23
Minimum17
Mean19.53
MajorChemistry41
Computing Science38
Civil Engineering39
Costume (clothing) Engineering37
Material Engineering45
Total200
Years of English LearningMaximum14
Minimum10
Mean11.18

Demographic information of the participants for the questionnaire surveys.

3.2.2 Student focus-group interview

Focus Group Interviewees (Table 2): Ten students were purposively selected from the larger cohort to participate in a focus group interview. The selection aimed for a balanced representation of English proficiency levels: three high-proficiency, four medium-proficiency and three low-proficiency students, as determined by their CET-4 scores and teacher recommendations. The group was also gender-balanced (5 male, 5 female).

Table 2

CategoryVariablen / Value
GenderMale5
Female5
AgeMaximum22
Minimum19
MajorChemistry1
Computing Science2
Civil Engineering3
Costume Engineering3
Material Engineering1
Years of English LearningMaximum14
Minimum11

Demographic information of the participants for focus group.

3.2.3 Teacher semi-structured interview

Teacher Semi-structured Interviewees: Five content teachers, all holding PhDs and with extensive teaching experience (ranging from 12 to 28 years), were invited to participate. Each had been teaching their CBI course for at least five years. Their demographic information is summarized in Table 3.

Table 3

TeacherABCDE
GenderMaleMaleFemaleMaleFemale
DegreePh. DPh. DPh. DPh. DPh. D
Years of teaching1216282014
Years of teaching CBI55855

Demographic information of the teachers for the semi-structured interview.

3.3 Data collection

Data collection spanned one full academic year, from August 2024 to July 2025.

Questionnaires: A 12-item questionnaire (see Appendix A) was developed to measure the three dimensions of engagement. The instrument was pilot-tested twice with similar student populations in September and November 2024, resulting in a final Cronbach's Alpha reliability coefficient of 0.78. Exploratory Factor Analysis (EFA) revealed a three-factor structure aligning with the emotional, behavioral and cognitive dimensions, explaining 68.5% of the total variance (KMO = 0.81). The survey was administered in Chinese to ensure clarity. The first administration (Survey I) occurred at the end of the first semester, and the second (Survey II) was distributed at the conclusion of the academic year to the same 200 students. This repeated-measures design allowed for the detection of changes in engagement over time.

In Focus Group Interview, a single, three-hour focus group session was conducted on May 27th, 2025, in a comfortable, private room. An invitation letter with a list of guiding questions was sent in advance to help participants prepare. The discussion was audio-recorded and centered on students' lived experiences with CBI, their perceptions of its impact on their English learning, and their expectations for the program. In Teacher Interviews, individual semi-structured interviews with the five teachers were conducted in their offices in early June 2025 to ensure a relaxed atmosphere conducive to open dialogue. The interview protocol included seven open-ended questions that probed their understanding of CBI, pedagogical practices, perceptions of student engagement and views on the balance between content and language. All interviews were audio-recorded.

Regarding Classroom Observations, a structured observation scheme, adapted from Ullman and Geva's (1984) Target Language Observation Scheme and Aldakhil and Alfadda's (2021) Sheltered Instruction Observation Protocol, was used. The scheme was piloted and revised in September 2024. Two 45-minute observation sessions were conducted for each of the five CBI classes (ten sessions total) during the second semester of the academic year. The observation scheme coded for three dimensions of engagement: (1) Emotional Engagement: Observed smiles, nodding, eye contact, and expressions of interest; (2) Behavioral Engagement: Frequency of voluntary contributions, on-task behavior; (3) Cognitive Engagement: Use of elaboration or questioning strategies, and evidence of connecting new content to prior knowledge. Detailed field notes were taken, focusing on teacher-student and student-student interactions, the use of authentic materials, and observable indicators of the three engagement dimensions.

3.4 Data analysis

A sequential explanatory mixed-methods design was employed. Quantitative data from the two questionnaires were analyzed using descriptive statistics (frequencies, percentages, means) to identify trends and changes in engagement over time. This quantitative analysis informed the subsequent qualitative phase.

All qualitative data, interview transcripts, focus group recordings, and field observation notes were transcribed verbatim. The student focus group and interviews were conducted in Mandarin; therefore, transcription and initial thematic analysis were performed in the source language to preserve meaning and nuance. Key quotes were then translated into English for presentation in this paper, and the translations were verified by two independent bilingual colleagues.

Thematic analysis followed a six-phase process (Braun and Clarke, 2006): (1) familiarization with the data through repeated reading, (2) generating initial codes, (3) searching for themes, (4) reviewing themes, (5) defining and naming themes, and (6) producing the final report. The analysis was guided by the three dimensions of engagement, allowing for a structured yet flexible exploration of the data. Triangulation was achieved by comparing and contrasting findings across the three qualitative data sources (student focus group, teacher interviews, classroom observations) and against the quantitative survey results to build a coherent and robust narrative.

This study received ethical approval from the university. Written informed consent was obtained from all student participants and teachers prior to data collection. Participation was voluntary, and anonymity was guaranteed.

4 Findings and discussion

The analysis revealed a complex picture of CBI's impact on student engagement, characterized by significant positive developments alongside persistent challenges. The findings are presented and discussed according to the three dimensions of engagement.

4.1 Quantitative trends in engagement over time

Table 4 presents the comparative results from the two questionnaire administrations. The data show a clear and consistent trajectory of improvement across all measured aspects of engagement over the course of the academic year.

Table 4

ItemStatementDimensionSurvey 1 (Time 1)Survey 2 (Time 2)Paired t-testEffect size (Cohen's d)
% Agree/Strongly agree% Agree/Strongly agreet (199), p-value
1I feel attached to my CBI classes.Emotional44%61%5.14, p < .010.36 (Small-Medium)
2I am enthusiastic and energetic when I am in CBI classes.Emotional38%74%8.32, p < .0010.59 (Medium)
3I am interested in authentic, unabridged materials I learn in CBI classes.Emotional66%84%4.55, p < .0010.32 (Small)
4I give my best effort in CBI classes.Behavioral50%83%7.85, p < .0010.55 (Medium)
5In CBI classes, I use several learner self-learning strategies.Cognitive76%79.5%1.25, p > .050.08 (Negligible)

CBI students’ classroom participation and engagement changes.

“% Agree/Strongly Agree” combines responses from the top two Likert scale categories. Cohen's d values are interpreted as: ∼0.2 (small), ∼0.5 (medium), ∼0.8 (large).

Table 5

TeachersTeacher talkStudent talkOther activitiesTotal
MinutesPercentageMinutesPercentageMinutesPercentageMinutes
Teacher A1121.44%2248.89%1226.67%45
Teacher B2351.11%13.530%8.518.89%45
Teacher C1635.56%19.543.33%9.521.11%45
Teacher D1431.11%2760%48.89%45
Teacher E1124.44%2862.22%613.33%45
Totals7533.33%11048.89%4017.78%225

Aggregate talk time distribution across five CBI classrooms (total observed time: 225 min).

Note: Boldface value represent aggregate totals across all five classrooms.

To determine the statistical significance of changes in engagement, paired-sample t-tests were conducted between Survey I and Survey II. Results indicated a statistically significant increase in behavioral engagement (t(199) = 8.32, p < .001) and emotional engagement (t(199) = 5.14, p < .01). However, the change in cognitive engagement was not statistically significant (p > .05), suggesting that while CBI boosts participation, its effect on deep cognitive processing requires further scaffolding. The effect sizes indicate that the observed improvements in behavioral and emotional engagement were of practical significance, whereas the change in cognitive engagement was negligible.

The most dramatic improvement was seen in behavioral engagement, specifically enthusiasm and energy (Item 2), where the combined “Agree/Strongly Agree” rate surged from 38% to 74%. A similarly strong increase was observed in students' self-reported effort (Item 4), rising from 50% to 83%. Emotional engagement, measured by a sense of attachment to the class (Item 1), also showed notable growth from 44% to 61%. The decline in “Partially Agree” responses across all items, especially for Item 2 (from 42% to 14%), indicates a shift from ambivalence towards more definitive, positive attitudes. These quantitative findings strongly suggest that CBI has a cumulative, positive effect on student engagement, with its benefits becoming more pronounced over extended exposure.

4.2 Emotional engagement: the crucial role of the supportive teacher

The qualitative data provided rich context for these quantitative trends, revealing that the teacher's role as a supportive facilitator was the primary driver of emotional engagement. Classroom observations consistently showed teachers employing a patient, encouraging and non-judgmental approach. They avoided putting students on the spot and instead used scaffolding techniques to build confidence.

Extract 1 (Classroom Observation - Teacher A, April 19, 2025): “What part don't you understand? You can do this because you learned ‘Coagulation and Flocculation’ in the previous class. This problem is similar but more complicated than ‘Sedimentation’. You start the same, but there is an extra step. Please review the previous one, and then start this one again to see if you can figure it out. I will visit your table briefly to see how you are doing.”

This extract illustrates a teacher who validates students' prior knowledge, breaks down a complex task, and offers a safety net of individual support. Such practices made students feel “at ease but energetic”, fostering a “harmonious” relationship with both the teacher and peers. As one student in the focus group articulated:

Extract 2 (Student Focus Group, May 27, 2025): “My CBI teacher tried his best to create a relaxed atmosphere..He was standing on the same side as the students. As time passed, I was no longer a passive listener..It comforted me; I believed I was valuable and essential to the class.”

This sense of belonging and psychological safety was paramount. Teachers frequently used positive reinforcement (“Well done”, “Excellent”) and explicitly decoupled participation from grammatical perfection, stating, “I don't care if you are wrong, but I do care if you don't try.” This created an environment where students felt safe to take risks and engage actively.

However, this positive dynamic was not universal. One student's critique highlighted the fragility of this emotional contract:

Extract 3 (Student Focus Group, May 27, 2025): “My CBI teacher lacked English expertise, rarely teaching grammar and having non-standard pronunciation. His monotonous voice often bored me. I struggled to engage..because understanding difficult subject matter through English was too challenging.”

This sentiment was echoed by Teacher B in his interview, who acknowledged his own limitations: “I feel unqualified to develop students’ language abilities without specific training in English phonetics and EFL methodology.” This finding underscores a critical point: while a supportive attitude is necessary, it is not always sufficient. A teacher's perceived linguistic competence and pedagogical skill are also vital components of the emotional landscape. When these are lacking, even the best intentions can fail to foster engagement, leading to boredom and demotivation.

The divergent experiences of high- vs. low-proficiency learners highlight a tension between intrinsic motivation and cognitive overload. For proficient students, authentic materials triggered autonomous motivation (Deci and Ryan, 2000), aligning with the ‘double-edged sword’ metaphor. However, for less proficient students, the extraneous cognitive load imposed by complex syntax and disciplinary jargon exceeded their working memory capacity (Sweller, 2011), leading to disengagement.

4.3 Cognitive engagement: authenticity as a double-edged sword

CBI's use of authentic, discipline-specific materials was the single most powerful driver of cognitive engagement for many students. The requirement to grapple with real academic texts pushed students to develop sophisticated learning strategies. One student described this process vividly:

Extract 4 (Student Focus Group, May 27, 2025): “CBI classes improved my English through authentic academic content related to my major. Initially difficult, I adapted by reading more, revisiting content and language forms, and discussing challenges with roommates..I developed skimming and scanning techniques to understand new concepts better.”

This account perfectly embodies the core assumption of CBI: that students benefit from encountering the target language in a meaningful, contextualized form focused on information acquisition (Richards and Rodgers, 2001). The authentic materials provided a compelling reason to engage cognitively, as the content was directly relevant to their future careers.

Classroom observations confirmed this, showing lessons structured to maximize cognitive processing. A typical lesson in Applied Materials Chemistry, for example, began with activating prior knowledge, moved to a collaborative text analysis task, and culminated in a research assignment connecting the concept (Flocculation) to daily life. This progression, from known to unknown, from receptive to productive, created a coherent frame for co-constructing knowledge (Shepard and Rose, 2023).

Yet, for students with lower English proficiency, this same authenticity became a formidable barrier. The cognitive load of processing complex, linguistically dense material in a foreign language was simply too high.

Extract 5 (Student Focus Group, May 27, 2025): “FOR ME, CBI courses felt like being plunged into darkness. Learning subject content through English was difficult, and I didn't know whether I was acquiring knowledge. The activities were beyond my abilities, often leaving me sad and discouraged.”

This stark contrast between Extracts 4 and 5 reveals a central paradox of CBI: its greatest strength is also its greatest weakness. The non-significant improvement in cognitive engagement (p > .05, d = 0.08) suggests that while authentic materials triggered strategic learning for proficient students, they may have overwhelmed lower-proficiency learners. This could be attributed to the measurement instrument's potential insensitivity to nuanced cognitive shifts over a one-year timeframe, or perhaps the CBI lessons, while authentic, did not consistently incorporate sufficient higher-order thinking tasks (e.g., critical evaluation, synthesis) that explicitly demand deep cognitive processing. Additionally, the voluntary nature of the sample means students already possessed a baseline motivation, potentially masking the difficulty of fostering genuine cognitive growth in less inclined learners. The authentic, challenging materials that drive deep cognitive engagement for proficient learners can cause profound disengagement and a sense of helplessness for their less proficient peers. This finding aligns with recent work by Wang, et al., (2024), who argue that in EFL contexts, a “one-size-fits-all” approach to authenticity can exacerbate existing inequalities in language proficiency. The dual cognitive demand of CBI requires a delicate balance; without adequate scaffolding, it can overwhelm rather than empower.

4.4 Behavioral engagement: shifting from monologue to dialogue

Behavioral engagement was most directly observable in the classroom through patterns of talk. Table 4 presents the aggregate data from the ten observation sessions, showing the distribution of teacher talk, student talk, and other silent activities.

The data clearly show that student talk time (48.89%) significantly exceeded teacher talk time (33.33%). This interactive environment is optimal for language acquisition and content learning in an EFL context, as it provides ample opportunities for students to produce output and negotiate meaning. This finding was corroborated by the teachers themselves, who reflected on their evolving roles.

Extract 6 (Teacher C Interview, June 2, 2025): “My UK experience showed that CBI teachers should prioritize opportunities for learners to produce output in the target language. I found student-student interactive exchanges particularly compelling, allowing learners to rehearse answers before class presentation.”

Extract 7 (Teacher E Interview, June 5, 2025): “Teachers must fully play the pivotal role of a facilitator instead of dominating the whole class time.”

These reflections demonstrate a conscious shift from the traditional “sage on the stage” model to a more facilitative “guide on the side” approach, a transformation that is central to fostering behavioral engagement (Jiang and Tanaka, 2022).

However, this trend was not uniform. Teacher B, whose class showed the highest teacher talk time (51.11%), offered a counterpoint that reflects a common dilemma in technical disciplines:

Extract 8 (Teacher B Interview, June 1, 2025): “While we shouldn't dominate class time as mere knowledge providers, the technical nature of academic content still requires explicit explanation rather than relying on students’ self-study.”

This perspective highlights the ongoing tension in CBI between fostering student autonomy and ensuring the accurate transmission of complex, technical knowledge. For some content experts, the fear of sacrificing content integrity can lead to a return to teacher-centered monologues, which, while efficient for content delivery, can stifle student interaction and behavioral engagement (Shepard and Rose, 2023). As highlighted in a study on English medium instruction in Hong Kong higher education, the most successful CBI classrooms are those that maintain a dynamic equilibrium between these two pedagogical imperatives (Language and Education, 37(6), pp. 788–805).

5 Synthesis and implications

This study provides compelling evidence that CBI, when thoughtfully implemented in a Chinese tier-2 university context, can be a powerful engine for enhancing EFL learners' multidimensional engagement. The longitudinal data demonstrate a clear, positive trajectory in students' emotional connection to their classes, their cognitive investment in the material, and their observable behavioural participation. Central to this success was the use of diverse, discipline-specific authentic materials, including original English textbooks (e.g., Chemical Engineering Design), peer-reviewed journal articles and industry-standard technical reports, combined with a teacher who acts as a supportive, facilitative guide, creating a safe space for intellectual risk-taking.

However, the research also exposes significant fault lines in the CBI model. The primary challenge is its inherent inequity: the same authentic materials and high cognitive demands that energize proficient learners can alienate and demoralise their less proficient peers. This finding calls into question a purely immersive philosophy and supports Lyster and Tedick's (2022) call for a more “counterbalanced” approach that integrates attention to language form. The teacher's role is therefore not just to facilitate but also to scaffold, to provide the linguistic tools and strategic support that enable all students to access the challenging content.

Furthermore, the study confirms the critical importance of teacher identity and preparation. Many content specialists, despite their subject-matter expertise and good intentions, feel ill-equipped to handle the linguistic dimensions of their CBI role. This gap in pedagogical competence can inadvertently undermine the very engagement the CBI model seeks to foster. Therefore, sustainable CBI programs must be accompanied by robust, ongoing professional development that bridges the gap between content expertise and language pedagogy.

While the longitudinal design tracks changes within the CBI cohort, the absence of a control group (e.g., a traditional EFL class) limits causal inferences. Therefore, the term ‘enhance’ should be interpreted as an association observed within this specific intervention group.

This study, while rich in detail, has several limitations that point toward fruitful avenues for future research. First, it focuses exclusively on inside-classroom engagement. Future studies should investigate how CBI influences students' out-of-class learning behaviors, such as their use of digital resources or participation in study groups. Second, the sample was drawn from a single institution and focused solely on engineering and applied science disciplines. A comparative study across different types of universities (tier-1 and tier-3) and fields of study (e.g., humanities and social sciences) would provide a more comprehensive picture of CBI's applicability and impact. Third, while this study tracked changes in engagement, it did not directly measure corresponding changes in English proficiency or content knowledge. A future study could employ a pre-test/post-test design to establish a clearer causal link between enhanced engagement and specific learning outcomes. Finally, a cross-institutional comparison within China would be invaluable for understanding how regional economic and cultural differences influence the implementation and reception of CBI.

Finally, it is crucial to reiterate the limitations regarding sample selection. The findings reflect the experiences of a self-selected, high-proficiency cohort. Future implementations should consider stratified sampling or include control groups to better understand CBI's differential impact across the full spectrum of student proficiencies.

6 Conclusion

In conclusion, this research affirms that Content-based Instruction holds significant promise for transforming the EFL learning experience in Chinese tier-2 universities. By anchoring language learning in authentic, meaningful content and fostering a supportive, interactive classroom climate, CBI can successfully cultivate the emotional, cognitive, and behavioral engagement that is the hallmark of deep and lasting learning. Students in this study reported growing enthusiasm, a stronger sense of belonging, increased effort and the development of sophisticated learning strategies, all of which attest to the model's potential.

Yet, this potential is not automatic. It is contingent upon a nuanced and responsive implementation that acknowledges the diverse needs of the student body. The path forward for CBI in China lies not in a rigid adherence to an ideal of pure content immersion, but in a flexible and counterbalanced approach. This approach would strategically integrate explicit language support, provide comprehensive teacher training that empowers content specialists as language facilitators, and continuously adapt its methods to ensure the challenge of authentic materials is a ladder for students.

Statements

Data availability statement

The datasets presented in this study can be found in online repositories. The names of the repository/repositories and accession number(s) can be found in the article/Supplementary Material.

Ethics statement

The studies involving humans were approved by Zhejiang Yuexiu University of Foreign Languages. The studies were conducted in accordance with the local legislation and institutional requirements. The participants provided their written informed consent to participate in this study.

Author contributions

XD: Software, Data curation, Formal analysis, Writing – original draft, Resources, Conceptualization, Methodology, Validation, Investigation. PW: Supervision, Methodology, Validation, Resources, Conceptualization, Writing – review & editing.

Funding

The author(s) declared that financial support was not received for this work and/or its publication.

Conflict of interest

The author(s) declared that this work was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.

Generative AI statement

The author(s) declared that generative AI was not used in the creation of this manuscript.

Any alternative text (alt text) provided alongside figures in this article has been generated by Frontiers with the support of artificial intelligence and reasonable efforts have been made to ensure accuracy, including review by the authors wherever possible. If you identify any issues, please contact us.

Publisher’s note

All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.

References

Appendix A

ItemResponse
1. College_____
2. Grade_____
3. Gender_____
4. Place of birth_____
5. How many years have you been learning English? 7 years
 8 years
 9 years
 10 years
 More than 10 years
6. I have passed the CET-4: Yes
 No
7. Which CBI course are you taking?  Applied Chemistry
  Applied Materials Chemistry
  Applied Computing Science
  Applied Civil Engineering Management
 Applied Costume Design and Engineering
Other: ________________________
Dimension12345
8. I feel attached to my CBI classes.Emotional□□□□□
9. I am enthusiastic and energetic when I am in CBI classes.Emotional□□□□□
10. I am interested in the authentic unabridged materials I learn in CBI classes.Emotional□□□□□
11 I give my best effort in CBI classes.Behavioral□□□□□
12 In CBI classes, I employ a lot of learning strategies to learn as much as I can.Cognitive□□□□□

1  =  Strongly Disagree 2  =  Disagree 3  =  Neutral 4 =  Agree 5 =  Strongly Agree.

Summary

Keywords

authentic materials, content-based instruction, English as a Foreign Language (EFL), student engagement, tier-2 university

Citation

Ding X and Wang P (2026) Fostering engagement through content-based instruction: a study of Chinese tier-2 university EFL students. Front. Educ. 11:1827903. doi: 10.3389/feduc.2026.1827903

Received

11 March 2026

Revised

05 May 2026

Accepted

18 May 2026

Published

05 June 2026

Volume

11 - 2026

Edited by

Patricia Arnaiz, University of Las Palmas de Gran Canaria, Spain

Reviewed by

Jiawei Zhang, Central China Normal University, China

Changhong Peng, Shanghai University of Finance and Economics Zhejiang College, China

Updates

Copyright

*Correspondence: Ping Wang

Disclaimer

All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.

Outline

Cite article

Copy to clipboard


Export citation file


Share article

Article metrics