Abstract
The Assessment, Evaluation, and Programming System (AEPS) is a curriculum-based early intervention programme, but little attention has been paid to how teachers implement it for children with ADHD in Saudi inclusive kindergartens. This qualitative multiple-case study explored how teachers implemented the AEPS and the factors they perceived as related to their practices. Four special education teachers from two Saudi cities participated. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews and analysed using thematic analysis, followed by cross-case analysis to identify convergent and divergent patterns. Teachers generally perceived the AEPS as a useful framework for supporting children with ADHD but also described several constraints on its implementation. Across the cases, differences in professional training, programme flexibility, parental engagement, and classroom conditions were observed alongside differences in teachers’ reported implementation practices. Teachers reported addressing these challenges by combining AEPS activities with additional behaviour-management strategies. An exploratory conceptual model was developed to represent provisional associations among contextual and teacher-related conditions and reported AEPS implementation practices. Recommendations for policy and practice are offered to strengthen early intervention services in Saudi inclusive kindergartens.
1 Introduction
Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is a neurodevelopmental disorder characterised by persistent patterns of inattention and/or hyperactivity-impulsivity. Symptoms usually emerge in childhood and may persist into adulthood, affecting relationships and daily functioning (; ). Approximately 8% of children and adolescents worldwide are reported to have ADHD (; ). The condition is also associated with academic outcomes, relationships, and emotional well-being (; ; ; ; ). Although several studies have estimated the prevalence of ADHD in Saudi Arabia, no representative study has established a precise national prevalence estimate (; ; ). Available evidence suggests that prevalence in Saudi Arabia may fall within the global range (). Variation in reported prevalence estimates may reflect methodological differences and variation in the diagnostic criteria applied (; ).
The early years are crucial for academic, behavioural, and medical intervention because children's developmental trajectories may be positively modified when support is timely, structured, and responsive to their needs (; ). Evidence suggests that interventions at this stage may improve attention, impulse control, and classroom participation (). Effective intervention for children with ADHD may involve both medication and behavioural strategies (). The Assessment, Evaluation, and Programming System (AEPS) is a curriculum-based early intervention framework that integrates four processes (). The process begins with assessment to establish a baseline of the child's skills and the family's expected outcomes. Information collected at this stage is then used to develop appropriate goals. These goals guide implementation of the Early Intervention Programme (EIP), which aims to support the child's growth and development. Finally, the child's progress is evaluated by comparing post-intervention performance with the baseline established during the initial assessment. The AEPS framework emphasises functional developmental skills, parental engagement, and the integration of assessment with targeted intervention (). Evidence supports the reliability and validity of the AEPS for assessing and planning support for children with diverse developmental needs (; ).
In Saudi Arabia, the AEPS was introduced as part of the Ministry of Education's strategy to enhance inclusive education in kindergartens (). Teachers were instructed to implement the AEPS in classrooms where children diagnosed with ADHD were educated alongside their peers in general education. As discussed in the following section, a review of the available literature identified few empirical studies examining implementation of the AEPS in Saudi inclusive settings. The existing literature also highlights challenges such as limited continuous professional development, insufficient support staff, and variation in teachers’ expertise (; ).
2 Literature review
Early intervention generally refers to approaches intended to prevent or minimise potential difficulties before they become more pronounced. In relation to ADHD, prevention can be divided into primary and secondary approaches (). Primary prevention addresses individuals who may be at greater risk of developing ADHD, for whom early detection through assessment may enable timely intervention and support. Secondary prevention aims to reduce the impact of ADHD symptoms and minimise further complications. Relevant interventions include pharmacological and non-pharmacological treatments, counselling, and educational scaffolding, which may help professionals, children, and families achieve improved outcomes and quality of life ().
2.1 Principles of early intervention
Within the Saudi education system, the Ministry of Education has adopted several principles to support the development of an effective early intervention system. Although the Saudi principles share similarities with international principles (; ; ), some internationally recognised principles receive less attention in the Saudi intervention programme. For example, international principles appear more comprehensive and place greater emphasis on family intervention and parental engagement, whereas the Saudi principles are more general and focus primarily on child-based intervention.
More specifically, the six Saudi early intervention principles emphasise flexibility in planning and delivering services according to children's characteristics, an emphasis that corresponds to the sixth principle identified in the international literature. However, the international principle also foregrounds the distinct needs of both the child and the family rather than focusing exclusively on the child (). International early intervention principles also extend beyond family needs to include continuous observation of children who do not meet diagnostic criteria and the use of evaluation and feedback to improve intervention quality. Cultural values and family beliefs are also considered when professional training programmes are designed. In addition, international principles recommend establishing professional committees to oversee and strengthen early intervention systems (). examined the effectiveness of early intervention services and reported improvements in children's academic performance following programme implementation. These programmes combined direct support for children with professional training intended to sustain intervention.
Differences between international and Saudi early intervention principles may be associated with variation in professionals’ and teachers’ practices, including their implementation of the AEPS. Because the AEPS is grounded in family-centred practice, continuous assessment, and evaluation, discrepancies between these principles and the Saudi national framework may be relevant to how teachers understand and implement the programme in kindergarten classrooms. Incorporating these principles into the Saudi framework could strengthen early intervention provision in inclusive settings.
2.2 Teachers’ knowledge about early intervention
Teachers are central to the delivery of early intervention. Their knowledge of and confidence in early intervention approaches may support children experiencing developmental challenges (). In Saudi Arabia, and found that teachers needed ongoing training in intervention approaches to strengthen their knowledge and skills for working with children with disabilities. In-service training was considered particularly important because initial preparation before entering the profession represents only the beginning of continuing professional development (; ).
reported that teachers had limited knowledge of intervention approaches for children with ADHD, which was attributed to a scarcity of training materials and information sources. Although did not explicitly assess teachers’ knowledge of ADHD intervention, inadequate teacher preparation may create difficulties in implementing evidence-based assessment and intervention approaches. Insufficient training was also reported as an important challenge in implementing behavioural intervention plans. emphasised the need to strengthen teachers’ knowledge and practices through systematic professional development. Such preparation is particularly important for a comprehensive framework such as the AEPS, which requires teachers to integrate its four components into an intervention programme responsive to the needs of children with ADHD.
Teachers need targeted training, collaboration, and appropriate professional preparation to strengthen their competence in early childhood intervention and respond to the diverse needs of children with disabilities. Understanding the strengths and challenges of children with ADHD in inclusive classrooms is fundamental to developing appropriate interventions (). Recent evidence also demonstrates the importance of teachers’ access to and use of evidence-based early intervention practices. Early intervention and early childhood special education teachers have been reported to rely primarily on colleagues and professional learning opportunities when seeking information about intervention practices, underscoring the need for continuing professional development that supports evidence-informed practice (). Similarly, highlighted uncertainty regarding teachers’ use of intervention guidelines developed by professional organisations.
2.3 Assessment, evaluation, and programming system (AEPS)
No single intervention approach is considered most effective for all children with developmental disabilities; early intervention programmes should therefore be designed to meet individual needs. Programming tools should support accurate, reliable, and consistent evaluation. They should also produce meaningful and assessable information that can inform assessment and intervention planning and support the monitoring of children's developmental progress (). According to and , the AEPS is an early intervention approach designed for children from birth to six years of age. It integrates four processes: assessment, goal development, intervention, and evaluation. Its primary purpose is to help parents, professionals, and caregivers identify and monitor the educational and behavioural development of children with disabilities, including those with ADHD.
Although evidence supports the AEPS in a range of contexts (; ), its implementation has not been extensively studied in Saudi Arabia. reported that teachers perceived the AEPS as effective for children with intellectual disabilities but identified difficulties related to parental engagement, modification of developmental objectives for children with severe disabilities, and the suitability of specific objectives. Similarly, found that teachers needed greater adaptability and flexibility when implementing the AEPS. Further training is therefore needed to help teachers respond to children's diverse needs.
2.4 Research gaps and contribution of the study
Despite the growing literature on early intervention, several gaps remain in understanding implementation of the AEPS for children with ADHD in Saudi inclusive kindergartens. At the population level, the limited Saudi research on the AEPS has focused primarily on children with intellectual disabilities (; ), leaving implementation with young children with ADHD underexplored. Much of the Saudi literature on ADHD has also focused on school-aged children rather than children in kindergarten settings. Consequently, there is limited empirical evidence concerning how the AEPS is experienced and implemented with this population in inclusive early childhood classrooms. A methodological and practical knowledge gap is also evident. Previous Saudi research has largely examined assessment, teachers’ knowledge and attitudes, or the perceived effectiveness of intervention approaches, with less attention to how teachers translate their knowledge of early intervention into day-to-day practice within inclusive classrooms. Consequently, little is known about how teachers’ training, professional experience, knowledge, and available support are associated with patterns of AEPS implementation. A qualitative multiple-case study provides an opportunity to examine implementation in depth within individual classroom contexts and to compare patterns across cases.
A conceptual gap also remains in understanding how teacher-related and contextual factors are jointly associated with AEPS implementation for children with ADHD. Existing research identifies teacher knowledge, professional training, flexibility, and support as relevant to early intervention practice but provides limited insight into how these factors co-occur within Saudi inclusive kindergarten classrooms. Examining them across multiple cases may therefore provide a more contextually grounded understanding of the conditions that teachers perceive as supporting or constraining AEPS implementation.
Taken together, these limitations demonstrate the need for context-specific evidence on implementation of the AEPS with children with ADHD in Saudi inclusive kindergartens. The present study addresses this need by examining four inclusive classroom cases and comparing teachers’ experiences and practices across them. Unlike previous Saudi studies that have examined broader early intervention issues, teacher-related factors, or AEPS implementation with other disability groups, this study focuses specifically on how the AEPS is experienced and implemented for children with ADHD in inclusive kindergarten classrooms. Beyond describing individual cases, the study develops an exploratory cross-case conceptual model representing provisional associations among teacher-related, pedagogical, structural, and external conditions and reported AEPS implementation. In doing so, it contributes practice-based evidence that may inform teacher professional development, support provision, and early intervention practice in Saudi inclusive kindergarten settings. Against this background, the study addresses the following research question: How do teachers experience and implement the AEPS for children with ADHD in Saudi inclusive kindergarten settings?
3 Research methodology
The study adopted a qualitative multiple-case design to address the research objectives and answer the research question. A case-study design was appropriate because it supported an in-depth examination of teachers’ implementation of the AEPS in the real-world context of inclusive kindergarten classrooms, where practice occurs through interactions among teachers, children, programme requirements, and contextual conditions (; ; ). The multiple-case design also supported comparison across cases to identify patterns associated with AEPS implementation. The study was informed by a realist perspective, recognising AEPS implementation as a practice situated within the social and educational context of inclusive classrooms while seeking to understand it through teachers’ experiences and perspectives. Consistent with this position, the study adopted an inductive orientation, allowing patterns and contextual explanations to emerge from the data rather than testing a predetermined theoretical model.
The multiple-case design was particularly appropriate because the study sought an in-depth understanding of AEPS implementation within its real-life classroom context and across a small number of information-rich cases. Consistent with multiple-case study approach, each case was examined within its bounded context and replication logic was used to compare patterns across cases. The research process involved defining and purposively selecting the cases, collecting in-depth accounts of AEPS implementation, conducting individual case analyses, and subsequently comparing findings across the four cases. This process enabled both the distinctive features of each classroom context and recurring patterns across cases to be identified and contributed to the development of an exploratory cross-case model of factors associated with AEPS implementation.
3.1 Research design
The study was conducted in two stages. The first comprised individual case analysis, with each inclusive classroom constituting a single case. Each classroom represented a bounded educational context in which the phenomenon of interest, namely implementation of the AEPS by a special education teacher working with a child diagnosed with ADHD, occurred in practice. The cases were bounded by educational setting, geographical location in Jeddah or Riyadh, and the context of AEPS implementation. Through an in-depth interview, the first stage explored teachers’ knowledge of ADHD in relation to intervention approaches, as well as their experiences and practices in implementing the AEPS. Each case was initially examined independently to develop an in-depth account of how the teacher understood, delivered, and responded to the practical demands of AEPS implementation.
In the second stage, cross-case analysis compared findings across the four classrooms, adopting replication logic to identify convergent and divergent patterns (; ). Rather than treating the four teachers as a single group, the analysis compared similarities and differences in their knowledge, implementation practices, available support, and perceived challenges. This sequence was important because analysing each case independently first preserved the contextual characteristics of each classroom, while the subsequent cross-case comparison enabled recurring and contrasting patterns to be identified without losing the distinctiveness of the individual cases. This structure culminated in an exploratory conceptual model of factors associated with AEPS implementation for children diagnosed with ADHD. The use of four cases was appropriate to the exploratory purpose of the study. The aim was not statistical representation, but an in-depth examination of AEPS implementation across classroom contexts that met the specific study criteria. The pool of eligible contexts was limited because only a limited number of kindergartens were implementing the AEPS within inclusive classrooms, and not every inclusive classroom included a child with ADHD. The four selected cases shared the core characteristics required to investigate the phenomenon while providing variation across classroom and geographical contexts. Together, these characteristics provided an appropriate basis for applying replication logic across the cases and identifying recurring and contrasting patterns relevant to the research question.
3.2 Setting and participants
The study was conducted in Jeddah and Riyadh, where the Ministry of Education (MOE) had introduced the AEPS in selected kindergartens. Purposive sampling was used to identify cases capable of providing relevant and in-depth evidence concerning AEPS implementation (). This strategy was appropriate because only a limited number of kindergartens were implementing the AEPS in inclusive classrooms, and not every inclusive classroom included a child with ADHD. Selection began by identifying kindergartens that both implemented the AEPS and enrolled children with ADHD. The MOE special education departments in Jeddah and Riyadh were contacted to identify eligible kindergartens, followed by direct communication with kindergarten administrators. Four cases were selected using predefined inclusion criteria. Each case comprised an inclusive kindergarten classroom in which a special education teacher implemented the AEPS with at least one child aged 4-6 years who had a clinically confirmed diagnosis of ADHD. Diagnoses had been established through external special education service centres before the children entered the inclusive classrooms and were therefore not based on the judgements of teachers or researchers. Each participating kindergarten had one special education teacher who worked with children with ADHD and was directly responsible for implementing the AEPS, resulting in four special education teachers as the primary participants.
All four participants therefore had direct experience of implementing the AEPS with children with ADHD. Their experience with the AEPS ranged from two to three years: Case 1 had approximately 2.5 years of experience, Cases 2 and 3 had three years, and Case 4 had two years. Their broader teaching experience also varied considerably across the cases, ranging from two to 16 years. The cases further differed in participants’ qualifications, classroom size, number of children with ADHD, and the professional support available during implementation. This combination of shared eligibility criteria and variation in AEPS experience, broader professional experience, and classroom contexts provided information-rich cases through which both common and contrasting experiences of AEPS implementation could be examined.
3.3 AEPS implementation within the cases
The AEPS used in the participating kindergartens is a curriculum-based early intervention system designed for children from birth to six years of age. It integrates four interrelated processes: assessment, goal development, intervention, and evaluation (). The AEPS materials include an administration guide, the AEPS Test for children from birth to three years and three to six years, and curriculum materials corresponding to these age ranges. Because the children represented in the four cases were between four and six years of age, teachers worked within the AEPS framework applicable to the three-to-six-year age range.
Within the participating classrooms, AEPS assessment and planning activities were undertaken by the special education teachers as part of their professional practice rather than by the researcher. The special education teacher was responsible for developing an individual plan according to the child's AEPS goals, implementing relevant intervention activities, and providing guidance to the classroom teacher regarding the support required by the child. Teachers described during the interviews how they used the AEPS to identify children's developmental needs, select goals, implement activities, and monitor progress.
Importantly, the AEPS was not administered by the researcher as a research measurement instrument. The researcher did not conduct direct AEPS assessments of the children or collect independent pre- and post-intervention AEPS scores. The children with ADHD were not respondents from whom research data were directly collected; rather, they formed part of the context of the classroom cases in which the participating teachers implemented the AEPS. Accordingly, information concerning children's academic and behavioural responses was obtained through teachers’ accounts of their classroom practice and should be interpreted as teacher-reported observations rather than independently measured child outcomes.
3.4 Data collection and interview procedures
The study used semi-structured interviews to obtain rich and personalised accounts of teachers’ experiences and practices in implementing the AEPS with children with ADHD. This method was appropriate for answering the research question because it enabled exploration of issues that were not readily observable and provided insight into the reasoning underlying teachers’ experiences and practices (). Semi-structured interviews were also consistent with the study's inductive orientation, allowing teachers to describe their experiences in their own terms while providing sufficient flexibility for the researcher to probe responses and explore relevant issues in greater depth (; ). They were also consistent with the realist perspective and case-study design because they provided detailed accounts of how the AEPS was implemented in the real-life context of each inclusive classroom and enabled the practices and contextual conditions of each case to be examined in depth.
The semi-structured interview schedule was developed from the research question using a hierarchical questioning strategy (), in which high-level questions preceded more specific and probing questions. The questions were informed by three sources: relevant literature and interview schedules used in previous studies, the researcher's professional knowledge of the topic, and feedback received during development of the schedule. The interview addressed teachers’ general understanding of early intervention and their application of the AEPS in practice, including goal selection, intervention activities, behavioural support, collaboration, implementation challenges, and perceptions of children's responses. These areas enabled an in-depth account of AEPS implementation to be developed for each case before patterns were compared across the four cases.
To enhance the clarity and contextual appropriateness of the interview schedule, the English version was translated into Arabic and checked through a translation and back-translation process. The interview schedule was reviewed during its development, including feedback and guidance on the questions, before the Arabic version was piloted. The Arabic schedule was subsequently piloted with a Saudi special education teacher who had previously worked in a kindergarten. The pilot confirmed that the questions were comprehensible and free from ambiguity. Four individual interviews were conducted with the special education teachers, one from each case. The interviews were conducted via Zoom and lasted approximately one to one and a half hours each. All interviews were conducted in Arabic, enabling the participants to describe their experiences and practices in their first language. The interviews were conducted by the lead researcher, whose professional knowledge of special education and early intervention informed the development of the interview schedule and the use of follow-up probes during the interviews. All interviews were audio-recorded and transcribed verbatim in Arabic. The transcripts were checked against the audio recordings to ensure transcription accuracy, and the qualitative analysis was conducted using the original Arabic transcripts. Selected excerpts were subsequently translated into English for reporting. By retaining Arabic throughout transcription and analysis and translating only selected material for reporting, the analysis remained grounded in the participants’ original accounts and reduced the potential loss of meaning associated with translating the full dataset before analysis. Following transcription, the transcripts were returned to participants for member checking to verify the accuracy of the recorded information; no participants requested changes. Prior to data collection, ethical approval was obtained from the Research Ethics Committee (REC) at the University of Exeter. Formal permission was also obtained from the Ministry of Education.
3.5 Interview analysis
Interviews were analysed using six-phase framework for thematic analysis, which provided in-depth insight into the phenomenon and aligned with the study's inductive orientation. Analysis involved familiarisation with the data, coding, generation of initial themes, review and development of themes, refinement and naming of themes, and reporting of the findings. Because all interviews were conducted in Arabic, they were transcribed and analysed in Arabic to preserve participants’ original meanings throughout the analytic process. During familiarisation, the researcher repeatedly listened to the recordings and checked each transcript against the corresponding audio recording to ensure transcription accuracy. Selected excerpts were translated into English where required for discussion and review during analysis.
Following familiarisation, the Arabic transcripts were imported into MAXQDA, which supported the systematic organisation and coding of the Arabic-language data. The first author conducted the coding and primary thematic analysis. Coding was conducted iteratively to identify patterns relevant to the research question. Codes were subsequently grouped into potential themes and subthemes. These were reviewed against the coded extracts and the wider dataset, refined to ensure coherence and sufficient supporting evidence, and then clearly defined and named. The second author reviewed the codes and thematic structure, after which both researchers discussed the interpretation and organisation of the themes and agreed on the final thematic structure. The cross-case analysis was primarily inductive, allowing broader patterns and contextual factors to emerge from the data. Analysis proceeded from within-case analysis to cross-case synthesis. Each case was first analysed separately to identify patterns related to teachers’ understanding and implementation of the AEPS. Following completion of the individual case analyses, themes were systematically compared across the four cases to identify similarities, differences, and contextual variations. This comparison enabled recurring and contrasting teacher-related and contextual factors associated with AEPS implementation to be identified across cases.
3.6 Trustworthiness
Trustworthiness was supported through several procedures. Credibility was strengthened through the piloting of the interview schedule, verification of transcripts against audio recordings, and member checking. Dependability was supported by following systematic analytical framework and documenting the progression from coding to theme development and cross-case synthesis. Confirmability was strengthened through analysis of the original Arabic transcripts and review and discussion of the coding and thematic structure by both researchers. Transferability was supported through a detailed description of the participants and case contexts, enabling readers to assess the relevance of the findings to other inclusive early childhood settings.
4 Findings
The cross-case findings focused on similarities and differences in teachers’ reported experiences and practices when implementing the AEPS. The analysis provided insight into these experiences and informed an exploratory conceptual model of conditions perceived to be associated with reported implementation practices. The model is intended to guide future research and policy development rather than to represent established relationships among factors.
4.1 General background across cases
Across the cases, differences in teachers’ experience, qualifications, and classroom organisation were observed alongside differences in reported AEPS implementation (see Table 1). Three of the four teachers had three years or less of experience in inclusive settings, whereas Case 3 had 16 years of experience, indicating substantial variation in professional experience. Two teachers (Cases 1 and 4) held master's degrees in intellectual disability; Case 2 held a bachelor's degree in intellectual disability, and Case 3 held a bachelor's degree in hearing impairment. These differences illustrate the varied professional preparation of teachers working with children diagnosed with ADHD. In terms of classroom organisation, only Case 4 worked with a multidisciplinary team comprising a classroom teacher, an assistant, and a psychologist, whereas the other three teachers received support primarily from the classroom teacher. The child in Case 4 was reported to have low symptom severity, while the children in the other cases were reported to have moderate or severe symptoms. Teachers’ accounts of children's responses also varied: Cases 2 and 4 reportedly achieved all AEPS objectives, Case 1 reportedly exceeded the goals within a short period despite continuing distraction and hyperactivity, and Case 3 reportedly demonstrated abilities beyond the AEPS goals while continuing to experience difficulties with concentration. These cross-case patterns suggest that teachers’ implementation experiences were associated with both their AEPS knowledge and the organisational conditions in which implementation occurred; they do not establish that either condition determined implementation quality or child outcomes.
Table 1
| Themes | Item | Case 1 | Case 2 | Case 3 | Case 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Class information | City | Jeddah | Jeddah | Riyadh | Riyadh |
| Number of children in the classroom | 25 | 35 | 28 | 35 | |
| Number of children with SEN | 5 | 5 | 3 | 5 | |
| Teacher background | Teaching Experience | 2.5 years | 3 years | 16 years | 2 years |
| AEPS Implementation Experience | 2.5 years | 3 years | 3 years | 2 years | |
| Qualification and Specialty | Master's degree in Intellectual Disability EIP (AEPS) | Bachelor's degree in Intellectual Disability | Bachelor's degree in Impaired Hearing | Master's degree in Intellectual Disability | |
| Support received by special education teachers (SETs) | The classroom teacher | The classroom teacher | The classroom teacher | Classroom teacher and assistant; limited psychologist support | |
| Child background | ADHD severity “students’ records” | Moderate to severe | Moderate | Moderate | Low |
| Teacher-reported progress | Exceeded AEPS goals; achieved most goals quickly | Achieved all academic goals within one year | Exceeded AEPS goals | Achieved all AEPS goals | |
| Difficulties | Distractibility and excessive movement | Impulsivity, oppositional behaviour, shyness, and social withdrawal | Difficulty concentrating, excessive movement, and sensitivity | Impulsive |
Characteristics of the four cases.
4.2 Teachers’ knowledge and views of the AEPS
As shown in Table 2, the findings revealed differences in teachers’ knowledge and evaluations of the AEPS. Cases 1, 2, and 3 demonstrated greater knowledge of both the EIP and the AEPS, supported by professional training and prior field experience. Case 1 provided the most detailed responses, reflecting her postgraduate research on early intervention, while Case 3 had considerably longer professional experience in inclusive classrooms. In contrast, Case 4 demonstrated more limited knowledge of the AEPS and relied on self-study and consultation with colleagues rather than formal AEPS training; her previous practice had centred on an alternative tool, HELP.
Table 2
| Themes | Case 1 | Case 2 | Case 3 | Case 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Knowledge | High in EIP+AEPS | High in EIP+AEPS | High in EIP+AEPS | Moderate EIP knowledge; limited AEPS knowledge |
| Knowledge sources | Experience, master's thesis, training | Training and inclusion courses | AEPS training, EI centre, self-learning | Self-directed learning; no professional training |
| Beliefs | Structured, clear, and accurate | Clear | Easy to implement | Unclear translation |
| Effectiveness | Effective but insufficient for ADHD | Useful, but not comprehensive for ADHD | Useful, but limited for ADHD | Limited usefulness |
| Appropriateness for ADHD | Appropriate for severe disabilities | Portage preferred | Not suitable for ADHD/ASD | HELP preferred |
| Understanding of AEPS procedures | Comprehensive | Good | Good | Limited |
| Behavioural goals | Not included | Not included | Not included | Not mentioned |
| Goal appropriateness | Flexible according to ability | Matched child's ability | Below child's ability | Below child's ability |
Teachers’ knowledge and views.
Despite the above differences, the cases converged in identifying limitations of the AEPS for children with ADHD. Cases 1, 2, and 3 reported shortcomings in relation to behaviour modification, while Cases 3 and 4 indicated that children with ADHD could demonstrate abilities beyond the level of some AEPS goals. Reflecting on the child's rapid achievement of the AEPS goals, Case 3 explained that “the expectations of the AEPS are lower than her ability level.” Differences were also evident in how teachers responded to these limitations. Case 1 advocated integrating other intervention programmes when necessary, while Case 2 stated, “I feel that Portage is more suitable than AEPS for some cases, as it is more accurate, with more details, and has more goals.” Case 4 similarly considered HELP more appropriate because it included more challenging goals. Cases 1, 2, and 3 generally viewed the AEPS as clear and useful, whereas Case 4 reported difficulty with the clarity of its translation and questioned its usefulness for parental engagement. Contextual fit was also raised as a concern. Case 1 explained that “there are goals that do not fit our Saudi kindergarten system,” illustrating perceived difficulties in applying some AEPS goals within the local kindergarten context.
In summary, the cases demonstrated varying levels of conceptual and procedural knowledge of the AEPS, while teachers’ practice-based evaluations consistently identified limitations in using it as a sole intervention programme for children with ADHD. The findings indicate that teachers perceived a need for complementary approaches and contextual adaptation to support behavioural and learning goals.
4.3 Teachers’ experiences and practices in inclusive classrooms
The findings demonstrated recurring patterns and notable differences in how teachers reported implementing the AEPS for children with ADHD in inclusive kindergartens (see Table 3). Cases 1, 2, and 3 implemented the programme within inclusive classrooms and were responsible for both educational scaffolding and behavioural management. In contrast, Case 4 delivered the AEPS through individual sessions in a resource room, with support from a psychologist for behavioural intervention. Across the cases, teachers consistently indicated that the AEPS did not provide specific behavioural strategies. Case 2 explicitly stated, “The strategies designed to modify the child's behaviour were not from the AEPS, as the AEPS only focuses on the academic aspect.” Cases 1 and 2 therefore developed behaviour-modification strategies on their own initiative, while Cases 3 and 4 sought advice from external specialists or available professional support. Despite these differences, teachers used reinforcement and other instructional materials to support achievement of AEPS goals rather than relying on the AEPS alone for systematic behaviour modification.
Table 3
| Themes | Case 1 | Case 2 | Case 3 | Case 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Teacher collaboration | SET and classroom teacher | SET and classroom teacher | Strong SET-classroom teacher collaboration | SET, classroom teacher, and assistant; limited psychologist involvement |
| Medication use | Yes | Yes | Yes | No |
| Teacher-reported academic response | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent | Outstanding |
| Teacher-reported behavioural response | Moderate | Moderate | Excellent | Excellent |
| Illustrative interview evidence | “His academic response in all areas is remarkable.” Behavioural change described as “slight to moderate.” | “He was able to achieve all the academic goals.” Behaviour improved as he became compliant with classroom rules. | “Her abilities are above the AEPS's goals.” Behavioural response was described as excellent | Academic response was rated 10/10 and behavioural response 7/10 by the SET |
Teachers’ experiences and practices.
All children followed the regular kindergarten curriculum alongside their peers while participating in the AEPS intervention. Teachers in three cases considered the general curriculum appropriate for children with ADHD, while one teacher believed that AEPS activities could be delivered effectively within the inclusive classroom without withdrawing children to a resource room. Differences were evident in teachers’ reported flexibility in adapting AEPS goals. Case 2, for example, stated, “I cannot make major adaptations to change the AEPS goals. I only facilitate these goals using different presentation tools.” In contrast, Case 4 reported greater flexibility to adjust goals according to the child's needs.
Findings concerning children's academic and behavioural responses were based on teachers’ interview accounts rather than independently measured pre- and post-intervention AEPS scores. Across the four cases, teachers reported positive academic responses during AEPS implementation, although the nature of these responses differed. Cases 1 and 2 described the children's academic responses as excellent, with Case 2 reporting that the child had achieved all academic goals. Case 3 also described the child's academic response as excellent but noted that her abilities exceeded the AEPS goals. In Case 4, the teacher described the child's academic response as outstanding. These accounts indicate teachers’ perceptions of academic progress within the cases but should not be interpreted as independently measured pre-post outcomes.
Greater variation was reported in behavioural responses. Cases 1 and 2 described behavioural improvement as moderate despite strong academic progress, whereas Cases 3 and 4 described the children's behavioural responses as excellent. Illustrating this perceived change, Case 4 explained, “At the beginning of the year, when he used to feel angry, he pushed me, hit the table, and expressed his anger through his actions. However, by the end of the year, even when he felt angry, he was able to control himself.” Teachers discussed several contextual conditions alongside these differences, including the availability of behavioural support, access to psychologists or assistants, medication, and ADHD symptom severity. These accounts and contextual observations represent teachers’ interpretations and do not establish relationships among these conditions, AEPS implementation, and children's outcomes.
The interview data also provided examples of perceived change over the course of implementation. In Case 2, the teacher reported that the child's behaviour improved as he became more compliant with classroom rules, while in Case 3 the teacher reported that the child quickly achieved the AEPS goals and subsequently demonstrated abilities beyond the programme's expectations. These examples provide qualitative evidence of teachers’ perceived progression rather than formal before-and-after measurement. Across the four cases, teachers identified several challenges in applying the AEPS, including large class sizes, inadequate training in using the AEPS with children with ADHD, limited multidisciplinary support, limited flexibility in adapting goals to children's needs, and inconsistent parental engagement. Reflecting concerns about class size, Case 3 stated that “the inclusive classroom should include fewer children when there is a child with ADHD.”
4.4 Teachers’ suggestions for improving AEPS implementation
Teachers offered several recommendations for improving AEPS implementation in kindergarten classrooms. All emphasised specialised training for both special and general education teachers. They also suggested AEPS training for parents to support consistency and follow-up with home-based activities. Teachers in two cases believed that specific AEPS courses could increase parents’ awareness and encourage more consistent engagement. Cases 1, 2, and 3 emphasised the need for multidisciplinary teams, including psychologists and teacher assistants, to reduce reliance on the classroom teacher and provide more structured support. Reflecting this need, Case 2 explained that a support team would “organise the work and relieve the pressure on us.”
Cases 1, 2, and 4 considered classroom preparation, including structural modifications, important for effective inclusion. Teachers also emphasised flexibility in adapting the AEPS to individual children's needs. Case 1 stated, “We should have more freedom and flexibility without restriction.” Teachers reported that Ministry of Education instructions limited their discretion when implementing AEPS procedures. They suggested more flexible scheduling and reduced workloads to encourage participation in the programme and allow more time for communication with parents. Overall, teachers perceived AEPS implementation as related not only to individual skills but also to system-level conditions, collaboration, and parental engagement.
4.5 Cross-case analysis model
An exploratory conceptual model was developed from the within-case and cross-case analyses to organise recurring factors associated with AEPS implementation across the four cases (see Figure 1). Rather than representing empirically tested relationships among factors, the model synthesises patterns of convergence and variation identified across the cases. It is organised into three interconnected sets: contextual and organisational conditions, teacher-related factors, and implementation practices, alongside teacher-reported child responses.
Figure 1
The first set, contextual and organisational conditions, comprises training and preparation, professional support, classroom environment, flexibility to adapt AEPS goals, and family collaboration. These components were derived from recurring findings concerning differences in teachers’ access to training and professional support, classroom conditions, opportunities to adapt AEPS goals, and parental engagement. The second set, teacher-related factors, includes AEPS knowledge and professional experience, reflecting the cross-case differences reported in Section 4.2. The third set, implementation practices, comprises goal selection and adaptation, behavioural strategies, collaboration, and the use of additional resources and materials, all of which emerged from teachers’ accounts of how they implemented the AEPS in their classrooms.
The proposed connections among the three sets were derived from recurring cross-case patterns rather than empirically tested relationships. Across the cases, differences in contextual and organisational conditions (Set 1), particularly training, professional support, and implementation flexibility, were observed alongside differences in teachers’ AEPS knowledge and professional experience (Set 2). Variation in these teacher-related factors was likewise observed alongside variation in implementation practices (Set 3), including goal adaptation, behavioural strategies, collaboration, and the use of additional resources. Figure 1 visually organises these provisional associations; the connections should not be interpreted as directional relationships and require further empirical examination.
The final component represents teacher-reported child responses, comprising academic and behavioural responses described during the interviews. As discussed in Section 4.3, these responses were not independently measured outcomes and should therefore be interpreted as teachers’ perceptions rather than evidence of intervention effectiveness. The framework is consequently presented as an exploratory and provisional representation of patterns identified across the four cases and requires further empirical examination with larger and more diverse samples.
5 Discussion and conclusion
5.1 Knowledge and beliefs about intervention
Teachers’ knowledge of early intervention and the AEPS appeared to be one potentially relevant condition associated with differences in reported implementation practices across the cases. Cases 1, 2, and 3 demonstrated greater knowledge of the AEPS and its procedures, supported by professional training and prior experience. This pattern contrasts with , who reported lower levels of knowledge and intervention skills among special education teachers and emphasised the importance of professional preparation and experience. Teachers with limited knowledge of the AEPS may rely on alternative sources of information, such as colleagues and the programme handbook. This pattern was evident in Case 4, who had not received formal AEPS training and expressed uncertainty about whether she was implementing the programme correctly. Similar patterns have been observed internationally, where teachers rely on peer consultation and self-directed learning in the absence of structured professional training (). Reliance on these sources of guidance may reflect limited access to systematic training in Saudi Arabia and underscores the potential value of structured professional development for AEPS implementation ().
Cross-case patterns suggested an association between teachers’ AEPS knowledge and their reported implementation experiences. Case 1, who demonstrated detailed knowledge of the AEPS, provided more detailed accounts of its procedures and application, whereas Case 4, who had more limited AEPS knowledge and no formal training, expressed uncertainty about whether she was implementing the programme correctly. These patterns do not demonstrate that knowledge determined implementation quality; rather, they identify professional knowledge and training as potentially relevant conditions for AEPS implementation. This interpretation is consistent with , who highlighted the need for targeted professional development for teachers supporting children with ADHD.
5.2 Teachers’ implementation of AEPS
This section addresses the research question of how teachers implement the AEPS in inclusive kindergarten classrooms for children with ADHD. Cases 1, 2, and 3 were primarily responsible for implementing the programme within inclusive classrooms, whereas Case 4 delivered it mainly in a resource room with support from a psychologist and a teacher assistant. Most teachers indicated that AEPS objectives could be integrated into the general classroom curriculum without withdrawing children to resource rooms. These accounts illustrate variation in programme delivery across the cases.
In addition to differences in practice, the findings revealed variation in teachers’ perceptions of the appropriateness of the AEPS for children with ADHD. Teachers who had received structured AEPS training generally described the programme as clear or straightforward to implement, whereas Case 4, who had not received formal AEPS training, expressed uncertainty about implementation and reported problems with the clarity of the translation. This pattern corresponds with , who argued that inadequate localisation of intervention programmes can create implementation difficulties. In the present study, localisation concerns were evident in teachers’ accounts of the Arabic translation and the suitability of some AEPS goals for the Saudi kindergarten context. These accounts suggest that implementation involved both understanding the programme and negotiating its fit with local educational practices and expectations. Teachers also questioned the appropriateness of the AEPS for children with ADHD because it lacks behaviour-modification goals; some perceived it as more suitable for children with other disabilities. Similar concerns have been reported in Turkey, where intervention programmes were criticised for focusing heavily on autism while providing insufficient support for children with ADHD (). In contrast, found the AEPS to be developmentally robust in the UK, suggesting that experiences of programme implementation and appropriateness may vary across contexts. The present findings therefore provide context-specific evidence that participating teachers perceived limitations in using the AEPS with children with ADHD, particularly in relation to behavioural goals and contextual adaptation.
5.3 Challenges of practice for the AEPS
Although the AEPS is mandated nationally by the Ministry of Education, teachers reported multiple challenges in implementing it for children with ADHD. They consistently stated that AEPS objectives could not be substantially modified because fidelity to the published framework was required. Within the Saudi educational context, these accounts also reflected the institutional conditions under which the programme was implemented. Teachers described working within Ministry of Education requirements that limited their discretion to modify goals even when they perceived those goals as insufficient or inappropriate for individual children. These accounts suggest a tension between centrally regulated programme implementation and teachers’ professional judgement in responding to individual needs. Teachers reported that limited flexibility became particularly challenging after children achieved the targeted goals and further adaptation appeared necessary. similarly emphasised the need for greater flexibility and training in alternative intervention approaches. Participating teachers also identified heavy workloads, large class sizes of up to 35 children, and limited access to multidisciplinary support as implementation challenges. likewise reported that overcrowding in general classrooms can impede ADHD interventions, while collaborative classroom environments have been identified as important for supporting intervention practices (). Finally, teachers reported insufficient and inconsistent parental engagement as an additional challenge.
5.4 Strategies used in practice
In response to the reported limitations of the AEPS, teachers used additional strategies, including reinforcement, flashcards, and technology tools. Although recent evidence supports reinforcement strategies for ADHD behaviour management (), reliance on punitive measures may exacerbate behavioural difficulties. Other evidence-based approaches, such as active engagement () and problem-based learning (), were not reported by the participating teachers, suggesting that the strategies described in these cases differed from some approaches recommended in the wider literature. Moreover, differences in access to professional support and resources occurred alongside variation in teachers’ reported implementation practices. Two teachers relied primarily on their own efforts, whereas the other two sought support from a psychologist or special education centre. These differences are consistent with previous research highlighting the relevance of teacher knowledge and professional resources for implementation practices (). The findings also indicated variation in the availability and form of professional collaboration across the four cases, supporting the need for more structured teamwork and information sharing in inclusive kindergarten settings ().
In response to the challenges they experienced, teachers identified several conditions they believed could support AEPS implementation in inclusive kindergarten classrooms. These included continuing professional training, multidisciplinary support, and appropriate classroom conditions (). Teachers also emphasised parental engagement as a means of promoting consistency between home- and school-based intervention. In this context, their emphasis suggests that they viewed AEPS implementation as extending beyond the kindergarten and requiring continuity between professional and family support. Previous evidence similarly highlights the value of involving parents in their child's support team as informed caregivers and partners in intervention (; ).
5.5 Exploratory cross-case conceptual model of AEPS implementation for ADHD
The exploratory conceptual model developed from the cross-case analysis organises the findings into three interconnected sets: contextual and organisational conditions, teacher-related factors, and implementation practices, alongside teacher-reported child responses. Rather than representing empirically established relationships among factors, the framework reflects recurring and contrasting patterns identified across the four cases. Contextual and organisational conditions included training and preparation, professional support, classroom environment, flexibility to adapt AEPS goals, and family collaboration. Teacher-related factors comprised AEPS knowledge and professional experience, while implementation practices included goal selection and adaptation, behavioural strategies, collaboration, and the use of additional resources and materials.
The cross-case findings suggested that these factors co-occurred in different combinations across the four cases. Differences in contextual and organisational conditions were observed alongside variation in teachers’ knowledge, professional experience, and reported implementation practices. Teacher-reported academic and behavioural responses also varied; however, these responses were not independently measured and cannot be attributed to particular implementation conditions or to the AEPS itself. The relationships represented in the framework should therefore be interpreted as provisional associations suggested by qualitative cross-case patterns rather than as empirically validated relationships. The framework extends previous research that has considered individual teacher or contextual variables separately () by organising the factors identified in this study within a single exploratory representation of AEPS implementation in Saudi inclusive kindergartens. Given the small number of cases and the exploratory nature of the study, the framework requires further empirical examination with larger and more diverse samples before the proposed relationships can be established.
6 Limitations
A key limitation is that participants were recruited from only two major Saudi cities. The study also included only four cases, limiting the transferability of the findings beyond the contexts examined. Inclusion of participants from a broader range of regions could have provided a more comprehensive understanding of the phenomenon. In addition, the study relied primarily on teachers’ self-reported interview data without systematic classroom observations to examine reported implementation practices independently. Children's academic and behavioural responses were likewise based on teachers’ accounts rather than independently assessed outcomes. The absence of policymakers’ and parents’ perspectives was another limitation; incorporating their views could have helped translate the findings into more comprehensive recommendations for policy and practice. Finally, the proposed conceptual model is exploratory and provisional, reflecting patterns identified across four cases rather than empirically validated relationships among factors. It therefore requires further examination with larger and more diverse samples.
7 Implications and recommendations
This study foregrounds teachers’ accounts of AEPS implementation across the four cases and suggests that their classroom experiences should inform future policy and programme development. The findings have several implications for policy, practice, and research. Teachers’ accounts indicated the perceived value of multidisciplinary support, including psychologists, assistants, and other specialists. They reported greater demands on individual teachers where such support was limited, particularly when behaviour modification was required. Policymakers could consider increasing the flexibility of the AEPS so that teachers can adapt and supplement its goals with other strategies where appropriate. The findings also suggest the value of ongoing specialised training in both the AEPS and ADHD-specific strategies, with particular emphasis on practical behaviour-management techniques. Participating teachers identified large class sizes as a challenge; consideration of classroom space, resources, and class size may therefore support implementation in inclusive settings. Teachers also suggested that schools establish formal communication platforms with families to encourage reinforcement of strategies at home.
For future research, studies should examine AEPS implementation across different regions of Saudi Arabia, including urban and rural schools, to develop a more comprehensive understanding of teachers’ practices. Further work is also needed to examine families’ perspectives, particularly the extent to which parents reinforce strategies at home. Classroom observations and document analysis could capture teachers’ practices more directly and complement self-reported interview data. Future studies could also incorporate independently assessed child outcomes to examine academic and behavioural responses beyond teachers’ reports. Larger and more diverse samples would enable further empirical examination of the exploratory conceptual model proposed in this study.
Statements
Data availability statement
The raw data supporting the conclusions of this article will be made available by the authors, without undue reservation.
Ethics statement
Ethical approval was obtained from the Research Ethics Committee (REC) at the University of Exeter. Formal permission was also obtained from the Ministry of Education, Saudi Arabia. The studies were conducted in accordance with the local legislation and institutional requirements. The participants provided their written informed consent to participate in this study.
Author contributions
SA: Conceptualization, Methodology, Data curation, Writing – original draft. HA: Validation, Investigation, Writing – review & editing, Visualization, Formal analysis.
Funding
The author(s) declared that financial support was not received for this work and/or its publication.
Acknowledgments
The authors wish to express sincere gratitude to the teachers, school principals, and education department officials in Saudi Arabia.
Conflict of interest
The author(s) declared that this work was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
Generative AI statement
The author(s) declared that generative AI was used in the creation of this manuscript. The authors used generative AI to assist with language proofreading and the refinement of Figure 1. The conceptual content and initial design of Figure 1 were developed by the authors, while generative AI was used solely to improve its visual presentation. All outputs were reviewed, verified, and approved by the authors, who take full responsibility for the final content of the manuscript.
Any alternative text (alt text) provided alongside figures in this article has been generated by Frontiers with the support of artificial intelligence and reasonable efforts have been made to ensure accuracy, including review by the authors wherever possible. If you identify any issues, please contact us.
Publisher’s note
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.
References
1
AbaoudA. A. (2022). An exploratory investigation of difficulties in applying functional behavior assessment and implementing behavioral intervention plans in ADHD programs in Saudi Arabia. Int. J. Ment. Health Promot.24 (4), 595–601. 10.32604/ijmhp.2022.021286
2
AbdullahN.AbdullahN.BariS.YasinM. (2016). Early intervention implementation for preschool special education students in Malaysia. Int. J. Innov. Educ. Res.4 (7), 139–155. 10.31686/ijier.vol4.iss7.569
3
AbedM.AlrawajfhS. (2017). Elementary school teachers’ attitude towards including students with special educational needs into regular public schools in Saudi Arabia. Int. J. Educ.9 (1), 49–66. 10.5296/ije.v9i1.10915
4
AbikoffH.GallagherR.WellsK. C.MurrayD. W.HuangL.LuF.et al (2013). Remediating organizational functioning in children with ADHD: immediate and long-term effects from a randomized controlled trial. J. Consult. Clin. Psychol.81 (1), 113–128. 10.1037/a0029648
5
AlbattiT. H.AlhedyanZ.AlsefriM.AlnasserS.AlmadaniH.AlzahraniM. (2017). Prevalence of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder among primary school children in Saudi Arabia. Neurosciences22 (2), 106–111. 10.17712/nsj.2017.2.20160548
6
AlgraigrayH. (2019). What are in Learning Disability (LD) and Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) names? An exploration of LD and ADHD labels in primary mainstream schools in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia. (Thesis) University of Exeter. Available online at:https://hdl.handle.net/10871/39280(Accessed April 15, 2026).
7
AlgraigrayH. (2023). Professionalism and the challenges of inclusion: an evaluation of special education teachers’ practice. Int. J. Adv. Appl. Sci.10 (7), 99–108. 10.21833/ijaas.2023.07.012
8
AlharthiK.AlqahtaniF. (2020). Effective practices of special education teachers in early intervention programme (challenges and solutions). Saudi J. Spec. Educ.7154 (15), 141–184. Available online at:https://search.mandumah.com/Record/1110829(Accessed April 15, 2026).
9
AljumahL. A.AlhaddadF. A. (2024). The efficacy of the current ADHD training programs in Saudi general education elementary schools: a systematic review. J. Int. Spec. Needs Educ.27 (1), 1–11. 10.9782/JISNE-D-22-00008
10
AlmalkiN. S.ArrushaidO. M.Farah BakhietS.AlkathiriS. (2023). Examining the current practices of the individualized family services plan with young children with disabilities in Saudi Arabia. Int. J. Dev. Disabil.69 (2), 163–178. 10.1080/20473869.2021.1936849
11
AlqahtaniM. M. J. (2010). Attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder in school-aged children in Saudi Arabia. Eur. J. Pediatr.169, 1113–1117. 10.1007/s00431-010-1190-y
12
AouchicheN. T. (2020). Proposing a training program for early intervention to treat developmental learning difficulties in pre-school children and to study its effectiveness in the prevention of academic learning difficulties. Dirasat: Hum. Soc. Sci3 (3), 334–353. 10.33953/0381-003-003-017
13
AyanoG.DemelashS.GizachewY.TsegayL.AlatiR. (2023). The global prevalence of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder in children and adolescents: an umbrella review of meta-analyses. J. Affect. Disord.339, 860–866. 10.1016/j.jad.2023.07.071
14
BaglamaB.DemirokM. S. (2016). Determination of preservice special education teachers’ views on early childhood intervention. Cypriot J. Educ. Sci.11 (4), 213–222. 10.18844/cjes.v11i4.1297
15
BraunV.ClarkeV. (2021). Thematic Analysis: A Practical Guide. London: SAGE Publications.
16
BrickerD.Pretti-FrontczakK.McComasN. (2016). Assessment, Evaluation, and Programming System for Infants and Children (AEPS-3). 3rd edn. Baltimore, MD: Brookes Publishing.
17
CohenL.ManionL.MorrisonK. (2018). Research Methods in Education. 8th edn. New York, NY: Taylor and Francis Group.
18
DuPaulG. J.StonerG. (2014). ADHD in the Schools: Assessment and Intervention Strategies. 3rd edn. New York, NY: Guilford Press.
19
DwyerP. (2022). The Neurodiversity Approach(es): What are they and what do they mean for researchers?Hum Dev.66 (2), 73–92. 10.1159/000523723
20
FeldmanM. E.CharachA.BélangerS. A. (2018). ADHD in children and youth: part 2: treatment. Paediatr. Child. Health. (Oxford)23 (7), 462–472. 10.1093/pch/pxy113
21
FrenchB.NalbantG.WrightH.SayalK.DaleyD.GroomM. J.et al (2024). The impacts associated with having ADHD: an umbrella review. Front. Psychiatry.15, 1343314. 10.3389/fpsyt.2024.1343314
22
GrishamJ.WaddellM.CrawfordR.TolandM. (2021). Psychometric properties of the assessment, evaluation, and programming system for infants and children–third edition (AEPS-3). J. Early. Interv.43 (1), 24–37. 10.1177/1053815120967359
23
GuralnickM. J. (2019). “Implementation science, the developmental systems approach, and family-centered practices,” in Family-Centered Practices in Early Intervention, eds. EscorciaC.RodriguezL. (Madrid: UNED), 51–71.
24
HongY. (2008). Teachers’ perceptions of young children with ADHD in Korea. Early. Child. Dev. Care.178 (4), 399–414. 10.1080/03004430701321829
25
International Society on Early Intervention (2022). Integrating research and practice in early childhood intervention. ISEI and DEC. Available online at:https://bpb-us-e1.wpmucdn.com/sites.uw.edu/dist/5/11736/files/2022/11/ISEI-Chicago-2022_ISEI_Program.pdf(Accessed April 15, 2026).
26
Jimenez-ArberasE.Casais-SuarezY.Fernandez-MendezA.Menendez-EspinaS.Rodriguez-MenendezS.LlosaJ. A.et al (2024). Evidence-based implementation of the family-centered model and the use of tele-intervention in early childhood services: a systematic review. Healthcare12 (1), 112. 10.3390/healthcare12010112
27
KongN. Y.ParksS.LindemanD. P.HornE. M.HurlessN. (2024). Understanding early intervention and early childhood special education professional access to and utilization of evidence-based practices. Exceptionality32 (4), 236–250. 10.1080/09362835.2024.2333774
28
MacLeanJ.KrauseA.RogersM. A. (2023). The student–teacher relationship and ADHD symptomatology: a meta-analysis. J. Sch. Psychol.99, 101217. 10.1016/j.jsp.2023.04.007
29
MacyM.BrickerD.DionneC.BrownJ. G.JohnsonJ. A.SlentzK.et al (2016). Content validity analyses of qualitative feedback on the revised assessment, evaluation, and programming system for infants and children (AEPS) test. J. Intellect. Disabil. Diagn. Treat.3 (4), 177–186. 10.6000/2292-2598.2015.03.04.3
30
MajarwitzD. J.PerumareddiP. (2023). Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder across the spectrum: from childhood to adulthood. Prim. Care.50 (1), 21–36. 10.1016/j.pop.2022.10.004
31
McDougalE.TaiC.StewartT. M.BoothJ. N.RhodesS. M. (2023). Understanding and supporting attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in the primary school classroom: perspectives of children with ADHD and their teachers. J. Autism Dev. Disord.53, 3406–3421. 10.1007/s10803-022-05639-3
32
McLaughlinB. T.BruceM. L.TanskiS. E. (2025). Reimagining the ADHD experience: transforming parent engagement in ADHD care. J. Patient Exp.12, 23743735251321238. 10.1177/23743735251321238
33
McLeskeyJ.BarringerM.-D.BillingsleyB.BrownellM.JacksonD.KennedyM.et al (2017). High-leverage practices in special education. Council for Exceptional Children and CEEDAR Center. Available online at:https://ceedar.education.ufl.edu/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/CEC-HLP-Web.pdf(Accessed March 12, 2026).
34
MilesM. B.HubermanA. M.SaldañaJ. (2014). Qualitative Data Analysis: A Methods Sourcebook. 3rd edn. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
35
Ministry of Education (2019). Saudi Arabia Education Vision 2030. Available online at:https://www.moe.gov.sa/ar/Pages/default.aspx(Accessed March 15, 2026).
36
MoosaV.ShareefaM. (2019). Implementation of differentiated instruction: co-joint effect of teachers’ sense of efficacy, perception and knowledge. Anatol. J. Educ.4 (1), 23–38. 10.29333/aje.2019.413a
37
MunchiK.BagadoodN. (2022). Specialists’ views concerning the assessment, evaluation, and programming system (AEPS) in associations for children with disabilities in Saudi Arabia. Int. J. Comput. Sci. Netw. Secur.22 (2), 91–100. 10.22937/IJCSNS.2022.22.2.12
38
NelsonC. A.SullivanE.EngelstadA.-M. (2024). Annual research review: early intervention viewed through the lens of developmental neuroscience. J. Child Psychol. Psychiatry65, 435–455. 10.1111/jcpp.13858
39
PaynterJ. M.FergusonS.FordyceK.JoostenA.PakuS.StephensM.et al (2017). Utilisation of evidence-based practices by ASD early intervention service providers. Autism21 (2), 167–180. 10.1177/1362361316633032
40
PetersonB. S.TrampushJ.BrownM.MaglioneM.BolshakovaM.RozelleM.et al (2024). Tools for the diagnosis of ADHD in children and adolescents: a systematic review. Pediatrics153 (4), e2024065854. 10.1542/peds.2024-065854
41
PoznanskiB.HartK. C.GrazianoP. A. (2021). What do preschool teachers know about attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), and does it affect ratings of child impairment?School. Ment. Health.13, 114–128. 10.1007/s12310-020-09395-6
42
RubinH. J.RubinI. S. (2012). Qualitative Interviewing: The Art of Hearing Data. 3rd edn. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
43
SadaqirR. I.AljadaniA. H.AbouzedM. A.AlrashedeN. O. E.AlmehmadiS. A.AlshammariT. S.et al (2023). Prevalence and risk factors of attention deficit-hyperactivity disorder in the Saudi population: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Saudi J. Med. Med. Sci.11 (2), 126–134. 10.4103/sjmms.sjmms_528_22
44
Saudi ADHD Society (2026). Evidence-based clinical practice guideline for management of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in Saudi Arabia. Available online at:https://cpg.adhd.org.sa/en/(Accessed April 12, 2026).
45
SayalK.PrasadV.DaleyD.FordT.CoghillD. (2018). ADHD in children and young people: prevalence, care pathways, and service provision. Lancet Psychiatry.5 (2), 175–186. 10.1016/S2215-0366(17)30167-0
46
SibleyM. H.ArnoldL. E.SwansonJ. M.HechtmanL. T.KennedyT. M.OwensE.et al (2022). Variable patterns of remission from ADHD in the multimodal treatment study of ADHD. Am. J. Psychiatry179 (2), 142–151. 10.1176/appi.ajp.2021.21010032
47
SilvermanD. (2017). Doing Qualitative Research: A Practical Handbook. 5th edn. London: SAGE.
48
SinghA.SquiresJ. (2014). ADHD in preschool: approaches and teacher training. J. Am. Acad. Spec. Educ. Prof.3, 122–149. 10.64546/jaasep.245
49
SlapničarN.LocatelliI.KosM.SvabV. (2024). Prevalence of attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD): systematic review and meta-analysis. Eur. Psychiatry67 (1), e68. 10.1192/j.eurpsy.2024.1786
50
SmytheT.SchererN.NanyunjaC.TannC. J.OlusanyaB. O. (2024). Strategies for addressing the needs of children with or at risk of developmental disabilities in early childhood by 2030: a systematic umbrella review. BMC. Med.22, 51. 10.1186/s12916-024-03265-7
51
SnyderP. A.WixsonC. S.TalapatraD.RoachA. T. (2008). Assessment in early childhood. Assess Eff Interv. 34 (1), 25–34. 10.1177/1534508408314112
52
SpenderK.ChenY.-W. R.Wilkes-GillanS.ParsonsL.CantrillA.SimonM.et al (2023). The friendships of children and youth with attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder: a systematic review. PLoS One18 (8), e0289539. 10.1371/journal.pone.0289539
53
TaylorB. S. (2018). Scoring reliability by early childhood educators on a curriculum-based assessment. (Master’s thesis). University of Kentucky. 10.13023/etd.2018.284
54
TolandM. D.GrishamJ.WaddellM.CrawfordR.DueberD. M. (2022). Scale evaluation and eligibility determination of a field-test version of the assessment, evaluation, and programming system–third edition. Topics. Early. Child. Spec. Educ.42 (2), 150–161. 10.1177/0271121420981712
55
TomlinsonP. (1989). Having it both ways: hierarchical focusing as research interview method. Br. Educ. Res. J.15 (2), 155–176. 10.1080/0141192890150205
56
TürkS.KorfmacherA.-K.GergerH.Van Der OordS.ChristiansenH. (2023). Interventions for ADHD in childhood and adolescence: a systematic umbrella review and meta-meta-analysis. Clin. Psychol. Rev.102, 102271. 10.1016/j.cpr.2023.102271
57
WardR. J.KovshoffH.KreppnerJ. (2021). School staff perspectives on ADHD and training: understanding the needs and views of UK primary staff. Emot. Behav. Diffic.26 (3), 306–321. 10.1080/13632752.2021.1965342
58
WellingtonJ.SzczerbinskiM. (2007). Research Methods for the Social sciences. London: Continuum Publishing.
59
WeyandtL. L.DuPaulG. J. (2008). ADHD in college students: developmental findings. Dev. Disabil. Res. Rev.14 (4), 311–319. 10.1002/ddrr.38
60
YazanB. (2015). Three approaches to case study methods in education: Yin, Merriam, and Stake. Qual. Rep.20 (2), 134–152. 10.46743/2160-3715/2015.2102
61
YegencikB.BellB. T.DenizE. (2025). School-based randomized controlled trials for ADHD and accompanying impairments: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Front. Psychol.16, 1611145. 10.3389/fpsyg.2025.1611145
62
YinR. K. (2018). Case Study Research and Applications: Design and Methods. 6th edn. Los Angeles, CA: SAGE.
Summary
Keywords
ADHD, Assessment, Evaluation, Programming System (AEPS), early intervention, implementation, inclusive education
Citation
Alzahrani S and Algraigray H (2026) Teachers’ implementation of the assessment, evaluation, and programming system for children with ADHD in Saudi inclusive kindergartens: a qualitative multiple-case study. Front. Educ. 11:1947031. doi: 10.3389/feduc.2026.1947031
Received
23 July 2026
Revised
08 September 2026
Accepted
09 September 2026
Published
23 September 2026
Volume
11 - 2026
Edited by
Rui Dai, Wichita State University, United States
Reviewed by
Elizabeth Fraser Selkirk Hannah, University of Dundee, United Kingdom
Srie Lisnasari, Universitas Quality, Indonesia
Luluk Asmawati, Sultan Ageng Tirtayasa University, Indonesia
Updates
Copyright
© 2026 Alzahrani and Algraigray.
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
*Correspondence: Hatim Algraigray h.algraigray@uoh.edu.sa
ORCID Samirah Alzahrani orcid.org/0009-0006-1480-1871 Hatim Algraigray orcid.org/0000-0003-4200-6868
Disclaimer
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.