Abstract
The internal charge and magnetization distributions of the proton are characterized by the electromagnetic form factors and . They are extracted from elastic electron-proton cross sections measured at fixed momentum transfer over a range of beam energies and scattering angles via Rosenbluth separation. Conventionally, form factor values are obtained by plotting reduced cross sections against the virtual photon polarization parameter and then extracting the slope and intercept of the best-fit lines. An alternative visualization method, proposed by Hofstadter and Herman in 1960, plots form factors directly instead. The values of and are immediately visible from the intersection region of the curves and their uncertainty bands. In this work, we apply Hofstadter-Herman visualization to classic 1994 SLAC elastic scattering data. The 1994 data include a 4% downward normalization adjustment applied to the 1.6 GeV/ spectrometer measurements. Overlaying modern global fit extractions on Hofstadter-Herman plots, we show that intersection regions obtained without including this adjustment sit closer to the global fit values. Such tensions are not readily visible in conventional plots. Our results motivate adopting this visualization method as a routine diagnostic cross-check at the Electron–Ion Collider and elsewhere to flag normalization shifts and related adjustments before they enter global fits.
1 Introduction
Nucleon electromagnetic form factors characterize how electric charge and magnetization are distributed within the proton and neutron and are among the most direct experimental probes of their internal structure [–]. Experimentally, form factors are extracted from elastic scattering of charged leptons off nucleon targets. Liquid hydrogen targets are typically used for proton measurements, while neutron information is obtained from quasielastic scattering on light nuclei such as deuterium or 3He. Theoretically, quantum electrodynamics (QED) shows that elastic electron–nucleon scattering proceeds, at leading order, through the exchange of a single virtual photon carrying four-momentum , with the invariant four-momentum transfer squared defined as [–]. For more than 70 years, elastic scattering has played a central role in the study of the internal structure of the proton [–].
Elastic scattering from a spin- nucleon requires two independent Lorentz-invariant form factors to describe its electromagnetic current. These are expressed as the Sachs electric and magnetic form factors, and . In 1962, Sachs showed that, in the Breit frame and in the non-relativistic limit, and can be interpreted as Fourier transforms of the nucleon’s spatial charge and magnetization densities []. The unpolarized elastic scattering cross section depends on both form factors, and their relative weights vary with scattering angle and beam energy at fixed .
The standard procedure for separating and from unpolarized cross sections is the Rosenbluth (or longitudinal–transverse) separation. Measurements are taken at fixed but with different combinations of beam energies and scattering angles. The data are then typically plotted as reduced cross sections versus the virtual photon polarization parameter (a known kinematic function of and ; see Section 2). A linear fit through the data allows for the extraction of and from the slope and intercept of the line. Although robust in principle, this method can obscure systematic inconsistencies between datasets because data are fitted to a line and the form factors are subsequently extracted.
An alternative visualization was proposed by Hofstadter and Herman in 1960 []. Instead of plotting reduced cross sections, they plotted data directly in form factor space, where each data point with uncertainties at fixed corresponds to an allowed band of form factor values. When multiple measurements at the same but with different combinations of beam energy and scattering angle are displayed together, the overlapping region of these bands identifies the consistent form factor pair. Hofstadter and Herman originally presented their visualization in the Dirac–Pauli form factor plane . We apply the same concept in the Sachs basis [].
In this work, we apply both the conventional Rosenbluth plotting method and the Hofstadter–Herman visualization to the 1994 SLAC elastic–scattering data of Andivahis et al. []. We show that the Hofstadter–Herman approach reveals tensions in the data, most notably between normalization-adjusted and unadjusted datasets, that are not apparent in traditional Rosenbluth plots. Comparison with Jefferson Lab global fits [,] suggests that the SLAC-applied 4% downward normalization correction applied by SLAC to a subset of the data does not improve agreement with the 2017 global fit extractions. This study highlights the diagnostic power of visualizing data directly in form factor space to uncover systematic effects and data set inconsistencies, which is relevant for the Electron-Ion Collider [, ].
The remainder of this article is organized as follows. Section 2 reviews elastic electron–proton scattering and electromagnetic form factors and develops the conventional Rosenbluth and Hofstadter–Herman representations used in our comparison. Section 3 reanalyzes the 1994 SLAC data of [], using both representations to examine the effects of the normalization adjustment applied to the 1.6 GeV/ spectrometer data. Section 4 discusses future applications of the Hofstadter–Herman method and summarizes our conclusions. Appendix A details the treatment of experimental uncertainties.
2 Theoretical foundations
Electromagnetic form factors provide a quantitative description of the spatial distributions of electric charge and magnetization within the proton. The electric form factor, , reflects the electric charge distribution, while the magnetic form factor, , characterizes the magnetization profile. Both are functions of the squared four-momentum transfer, , and are fundamental to understanding the internal structure of the nucleon [–]. Form factors are directly related to the underlying quark dynamics as the proton’s electric charge is carried by its constituent quarks and antiquarks. By analyzing the behavior of and over a range of values, one can infer information about the spatial configuration and behavior of confined quarks, as well as estimate key properties such as the proton’s radius [, ] and shape [, ].
As mentioned in the introduction, elastic electron-proton scattering forms the experimental basis for determining the proton’s electromagnetic form factors []. In this process, an incident electron beam of known energy interacts with a stationary proton target, resulting in a scattered electron and a recoiling proton. Crucially, no energy is transferred to the internal degrees of freedom of the proton; although the proton recoils with kinetic energy, it remains in its ground state, distinguishing elastic from inelastic scattering, in which the proton can be excited to resonances or break apart.
In the single photon exchange approximation, the unpolarized differential cross section can be written in the form [].
Here, is the cross section for a point-like spinless target of electric charge (i.e., “no structure,” also known as Mott scattering), GeV is the proton mass, , and is the electron scattering angle. We work with natural units in which . This formulation is based on the Rosenbluth separation technique, which allows independent extraction of electric and magnetic form factors by systematically varying the scattering angle while keeping fixed and will be described in detail in the following subsection.
In the Rosenbluth separation experiments performed at SLAC, high-energy electron beams were directed at liquid hydrogen targets. The angular distribution of scattered electrons was measured using precision magnetic spectrometers (specifically, 1.6 GeV/ and 8 GeV/ spectrometers), enabling accurate determination of differential cross sections over a broad range of momentum transfers.
2.1 Conventional Rosenbluth visualization
Form factors are typically extracted using the Rosenbluth separation technique []. This method involves determining the differential cross section at fixed from data taken at different beam energies and scattering angles. Data are conventionally plotted as the reduced cross section versus virtual photon polarization at fixed . In this case, the slope corresponds to and the intercept to , allowing both form factors to be algebraically extracted from a straight-line fit.
The reduced cross section is defined aswhere the no-structure (Mott) cross section in Equation 3 is given byand the virtual photon polarization parameter is given byand and in Equation 4 denote the incident and scattered electron energies in the laboratory frame. The reduced cross section of Equation 2 is then divided by the square of the magnetic dipole form , resulting in the following equationwhere in Equation 5 is the conventional dipole parametrization used as a reference in the 1994 analysis. We note that is used only to visually scale the conventional plot and does not affect the values of the extracted form factors.
We use this equation in our example of conventional Rosenbluth plots to illustrate the method used in 1994 by SLAC [], shown as vs. in Figure 1. The electromagnetic form factors obtained using this method are extracted from the slope and y-intercept of the best-fit line.
FIGURE 1
The different choices of plotting variables and form factor extraction methods emphasize that conventional visualization methods can be confusing and can visually obscure the physical parameters. Reducing the data to a fitted slope and intercept can obscure potentially important point-to-point information.
2.2 Hofstadter–Herman visualization method
A geometric visualization method was proposed by Richard Hofstadter and Robert Herman in 1960 []. They suggested that the form factor data could be displayed more effectively by plotting constraint regions in form factor space, with uncertainty bands drawn around each form factor curve. The intersection region of the bands yields the form factor values consistent with all measurements.
To derive the relationship between and for the Hofstadter–Herman plots, it is useful to rewrite Equation 1 to make the dependence on the virtual photon polarization parameter explicit. Rearranging to isolate the -dependence yields
Substituting and rearranging Equation 6 algebraically, we findand Equation 7 may be rewritten asThus, for each measurement at fixed , Equation 8 shows that the central measurement line has slope and -axis intercept .
In the original Hofstadter–Herman construction, each measurement defined an ellipse in the Dirac–Pauli form factor plane ; the intersection of several such ellipses identified the consistent form factor pair. In the Sachs representation used here, those loci become straight bands in space, as can be observed from Equation 8, where each measurement at a given is plotted as a line with its experimental uncertainty band. The overlap region of the bands identifies the set of (, ) pairs that are compatible with all measurements at the same (and also the magnitudes and for unpolarized scattering). Figure 2 shows an example of the Hofstadter–Herman visualization plot.
FIGURE 2
3 Re-analysis of 1994 SLAC data
Using the Hofstadter–Herman method, graphical representations were constructed using the published cross sections and kinematic SLAC data from []. The graphs were generated using Python with the NumPy and Matplotlib libraries. As an initial validation step, the reduced cross section graph presented in the original SLAC publication was reproduced. This confirmed the accuracy and reliability of the computational framework. The reproduction was achieved with high fidelity, exhibiting only small deviations that are addressed in the following subsection. Following this verification, the code was adapted to express the algebraic relation between and , which was then used to generate Hofstadter–Herman plots. Each band in these plots corresponds to one measurement at a given beam energy and scattering angle, with the band width reflecting the experimental uncertainty in . The intersection of multiple bands identifies the consistent pair of form factor values for that . This approach enables direct visualization of the form factors’ behavior, eliminating the need to infer results from linear fits.
4 Graphical analysis
We now apply this framework to the 1994 SLAC dataset. The cross section graph originally published by SLAC was successfully reconstructed, reproducing the overall structure of the 1994 result with only minor deviations. These small differences arise from a normalization correction applied to a subset of the data. According to the SLAC report, reduced cross sections from the 1.6 GeV/ spectrometer were adjusted downward by approximately 4% (multiplied by []) to ensure consistency with data collected with the higher energy spectrometers. Figure 3a shows the reconstructed SLAC plot, including this normalization adjustment factor.
FIGURE 3
For comparison, Figure 3b displays the same dataset before normalization. Although the visual differences between the two plots are modest, they illustrate how even small normalization shifts can influence the apparent consistency among measurements. Applying the SLAC-recommended normalization yields a reconstructed graph that is in close agreement with the published result.
The same dataset was then reanalyzed using the Hofstadter–Herman visualization technique, producing two distinct graphical representations: one incorporating the approximately 4% correction (Figure 4a) and one based on the unadjusted data (Figure 4b). The normalization adjustment shifts the 1.6 cross sections downward, and this decreases and increases relative to the unnormalized intersection. The displacement is small, but because is itself small, the same absolute shift represents a larger fractional change in the extracted electric contribution. The normalization choice, applied to a single spectrometer’s data, is sufficient to noticeably shift the extracted form factor values away from the global fits, with the electric form factor being more affected. A visual comparison of both adjusted and unadjusted data together with the Jefferson Lab global fits (Supplementary Appendix A of []) indicates that the global fit extractions align more closely with the unadjusted data, suggesting that the original, uncorrected measurements may better reflect the underlying physical behavior.
FIGURE 4
Table 1 quantifies the visual shifts. At every where an intersection point is defined, the unadjusted data yield an extracted closer to both global fits than the normalization-adjusted data, when distance is measured as the fractional deviation on both form factors relative to the fit value. The fractional separation distance is defined as
TABLE 1
| JLab fit 1 | JLab fit 2 | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| () | Unadj. | Adj. | Unadj. | Adj. | Closer |
| 1.75 | 0.103 | 0.320 | 0.033 | 0.236 | Unadjusted |
| 2.50 | 0.055 | 0.404 | 0.070 | 0.351 | Unadjusted |
| 3.25 | 0.114 | 1.19 | 0.137 | 1.11 | Unadjusted |
| 4.00 | 0.117 | 1.98 | 0.042 | 1.79 | Unadjusted |
| 5.00 | 0.172 | 3.50 | 0.272 | 2.93 | Unadjusted |
| 6.00 | 0.133 | 6.98 | 0.317 | 5.23 | Unadjusted |
| 7.00 | 15.8 | 28.4 | 10.4 | 18.9 | Unadjusted |
| 8.83 | – | – | – | – | N/A |
Fractional separation distance between the Hofstadter–Herman intersection point and the JLab global fits for the unadjusted and normalization-adjusted (of the 1.6 GeV/ spectrometer subset) data. The fractional distance formula is provided in Equation 9. At every where an intersection exists, the unadjusted point is closer to both JLab global fit values.
The tensions observed between the 1994 data and the 2017 Jefferson Lab global fit extractions are difficult to observe in conventional Rosenbluth separation plots. In contrast, the Hofstadter–Herman visualization shows the regions of agreement as overlapping bands of allowed form factor values at fixed across different beam energies. In this representation, the consistent form factor values correspond to the region where the bands intersect, and the JLab Global Fits can be observed to pass through or deviate from this region. As stated in the 8-panel figure captions, the intersection markers sit at the bandwidth-weighted least-squares common point of the central constraint lines. The results from this visualization method underscore the potential limitations of relying solely on global fits without reference to the underlying experimental distributions []. Figures 5, 6 are two eight-panel visualizations of the results for the 1.6 GeV/c spectrometer setup for the previous eight Q2 values from Table 1.
FIGURE 5
FIGURE 6
5 Future applications and conclusion
We have revisited classic SLAC elastic scattering data using both conventional Rosenbluth separation plots and the Hofstadter–Herman visualization method. The latter presents the form factors directly in space rather than through the usual two-step procedure of fitting a line to the data and then extracting and from the slope and intercept. This approach reveals normalization inconsistencies that are difficult to observe in traditional plots. In the SLAC dataset, a 4% downward normalization correction applied to the 1.6 GeV/ spectrometer data in the original SLAC analysis shifted measurements away from the region favored by modern global fits, an effect seen in the Hofstadter-Herman plots but obscured in conventional plots. The shift suggests that the uncorrected data may more accurately reflect the underlying behavior of the form factors.
By mapping the allowed regions directly, Hofstadter–Herman visualization can make certain inconsistencies between data sets apparent, particularly those arising from normalization or calibration shifts that may remain hidden in conventional plots. Such geometric cross-checks can complement standard analysis techniques at current and future facilities, including the Electron–Ion Collider, by helping identify normalization offsets or other biases before they propagate into global fits. More broadly, this work underscores the continuing value of geometry-based representations of form factor data for assessing the internal consistency of high-precision measurements.
Statements
Data availability statement
The original contributions presented in the study are included in the article/Supplementary Material, further inquiries can be directed to the corresponding author.
Author contributions
TW: Data curation, Formal analysis, Software, Visualization, Writing – original draft. JW: Conceptualization, Data curation, Investigation, Validation, Visualization, Writing – original draft, Writing – review and editing. DH: Funding acquisition, Project administration, Resources, Visualization, Methodology, Supervision, Writing – original draft. FB: Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal analysis, Funding acquisition, Investigation, Methodology, Project administration, Resources, Software, Supervision, Validation, Visualization, Writing – original draft, Writing – review and editing.
Funding
The author(s) declared that financial support was received for this work and/or its publication. TW and FB acknowledge support from the National Science Foundation, Award No. Benmokhtar-2310067 and No. Benmokhtar-2610003. JRW acknowledges support from the Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare (INFN), Turin, Grant No. 25864. This research was funded in part by the Department of Energy grant number DE-AC05-06OR23177.
Conflict of interest
The author(s) declared that this work was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
The authors DH, FB declared that they were an editorial board member of Frontiers at the time of submission. This had no impact on the peer review process and the final decision.
Generative AI statement
The author(s) declared that generative AI was not used in the creation of this manuscript.
Any alternative text (alt text) provided alongside figures in this article has been generated by Frontiers with the support of artificial intelligence and reasonable efforts have been made to ensure accuracy, including review by the authors wherever possible. If you identify any issues, please contact us.
Publisher’s note
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.
Supplementary material
The Supplementary Material for this article can be found online at: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fphy.2026.1957613/full#supplementary-material
References
1.
YeZArringtonJHillRJLeeG. Proton and neutron electromagnetic form factors and uncertainties. Phys Lett B (2018) 777:8–15. 10.1016/j.physletb.2017.11.023
2.
LinY-HHammerH-WMeißnerU-G. New insights into the nucleon’s electromagnetic structure. Phys Rev Lett (2022) 128(5):052002. 10.1103/PhysRevLett.128.052002
3.
AlbericoWMBilenkySMGiuntiCGraczykKM. Electromagnetic form factors of the nucleon: new fit and analysis of uncertainties. Phys Rev C (2009) 79:065204. 10.1103/physrevc.79.065204
4.
BernauerJCDistlerMFriedrichJWalcherTAchenbachPAyerbe GayosoCet alElectric and magnetic form factors of the proton. Phys Rev C (2014) 90(1):015206. 10.1103/physrevc.90.015206
5.
KubonGAnklinHBartschPBaumannDBoeglinWBohincKet alPrecise neutron magnetic form-factors. Phys Lett B (2002) 524:26–32. 10.1016/s0370-2693(01)01386-7
6.
RoseME. The charge distribution in nuclei and the scattering of high energy electrons. Phys Rev (1948) 73:279–84. 10.1103/physrev.73.279
7.
RosenbluthMN. High energy elastic scattering of electrons on protons. Phys Rev (1950) 79:615–9. 10.1103/physrev.79.615
8.
SachsRG. High-energy behavior of nucleon electromagnetic form factors. Phys Rev (1962) 126:2256–60. 10.1103/physrev.126.2256
9.
HofstadterRMcAllisterRW. Electron scattering from the proton. Phys Rev (1955) 98:217–8. 10.1103/physrev.98.217
10.
PerdrisatCFPunjabiVVanderhaeghenM. Nucleon electromagnetic form factors. Prog Part Nucl Phys (2007) 59:694–764. 10.1016/j.ppnp.2007.05.001
11.
HermanRHofstadterR. High-Energy Electron Scattering Tables. Stanford University Press (1960).
12.
AndivahisLBostedPELungAStuartLMAlsterJArnoldRGet alMeasurements of the electric and magnetic form factors of the proton from q2 = 1.75 to 8.83(GeV/c)2. Phys Rev D (1994) 50:5491–517. 10.1103/physrevd.50.5491
13.
PuckettAJRBrashEJJonesMKLuoWMezianeMPentchevLet alPolarization transfer observables in elastic electron proton scattering at Q2 =2.5, 5.2, 6.8, and 8.5 GeV2. Phys Rev C (2018) 96(5):055203 (Inserted text B (see Section 3 below)). 10.1103/PhysRevC.96.055203
14.
PuckettAJRBrashEJJonesMKLuoWMezianeMPentchevLet alPolarization transfer observables in elastic electron proton scattering at Q2 = 2.5, 5.2, 6.8, and 8.5 GeV2. Phys Rev C (2018) 96:019907. 10.1103/PhysRevC.98.019907
15.
AccardiAAlbaceteJLAnselminoMArmestoNAschenauerECBacchettaAet alElectron-Ion Collider: the next QCD frontier: understanding the glue that binds us all. Eur Phys J A (2016) 52(9):268. 10.1140/epja/i2016-16268-9
16.
AchenbachPAdhikariDAfanasevAAfzalFAidalaCAl-batainehAet alThe present and future of QCD. Nucl Phys A (2024) 1047:122874. 10.1016/j.nuclphysa.2024.122874
17.
HiginbothamDWKabirAALinVMeekinsDNorumBSawatzkyB. Proton radius from electron scattering data. Phys Rev C (2016) 93(5):055207. 10.1103/physrevc.93.055207
18.
KarrJ-PMarchandDVoutierE. The proton size. Nat Rev. Phys. (2020) 2(11):601–14. 10.1038/s42254-020-0229-x
19.
ArringtonJde JagerKPerdrisatCF. Nucleon form factors: A Jefferson Lab perspective. J Phys Conf Ser (2011) 299:012002. 10.1088/1742-6596/299/1/012002
20.
HandLNMillerDGWilsonR. Electric and magnetic form factors of the nucleon. Rev Mod Phys (1963) 35:335–49. 10.1103/revmodphys.35.335
21.
GramolinAVNikolenkoDM. Reanalysis of Rosenbluth measurements of the proton form factors. Phys Rev C (2016) 93(5):055201. 10.1103/physrevc.93.055201
Summary
Keywords
form factors, global fits, neutron, proton, Rosenbluth
Citation
Williams T, West JR, Higinbotham DW and Benmokhtar F (2026) Hofstadter-Herman visualization as a diagnostic tool for systematic effects in electromagnetic form factor extractions. Front. Phys. 14:1957613. doi: 10.3389/fphy.2026.1957613
Received
04 August 2026
Revised
29 August 2026
Accepted
02 September 2026
Published
10 November 2026
Volume
14 - 2026
Edited by
Jie Meng, Peking University, China
Reviewed by
Satyajit Puhan, Academia Sinica, Taiwan
Muhammad Ridwan, University of Plymouth, United Kingdom
Updates
Copyright
© 2026 Williams, West, Higinbotham and Benmokhtar.
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
*Correspondence: Fatiha Benmokhtar, benmokhtarf@duq.edu
Disclaimer
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.