Abstract
Background:
Food system transformation in Southern Africa occurs alongside persistent gender inequalities, climate vulnerability, and interconnected human-animal-environment health challenges. Structural barriers limit women’s participation in agricultural production and informal markets, harming nutrition, livelihoods and public health.
Objectives:
: This study uses a gendered political economy analysis (PEA) integrated with One Health principles to examine how power dynamics, institutional setups, and actor incentives shape food system outcomes across Malawi, Zambia, Tanzania, and South Africa. It focuses on agricultural production systems and informal food markets.
Methods:
A systematic analysis of empirical evidence across the four target countries evaluated actors, institutions, incentives, and power relations. Operating through a gender framework, the review maps how foundational socioeconomic inequalities influence One Health linkages based on a synthesis of 28 eligible studies (n = 28).
Key findings:
Synthesis of 28 studies reveals that gendered political economy structures dictate resource allocation and market power. Institutional exclusions regarding land, credit, and extension models bottleneck technology adoption. In informal markets, infrastructure deficits and exclusionary policing compound precarity. Ultimately, these intersecting structural traps drive a critical human-animal-environmental syndemic, directly undermining regional One Health outcomes.
Policy implications:
To achieve sustainable food system transformation, policymakers must dismantle structural gender barriers by prioritizing women’s leadership in governance and supporting women-led enterprises through targeted extension and finance services. Progress depends on a One Health model recognizing gender equity as a structural pillar linking health, agriculture, and environment.
1 Introduction
Food systems in Southern Africa are undergoing profound transformations driven by climate change, urbanization, market integration and shifting dietary patterns. These transformations occur within contexts of persistent structural inequalities (Djurfeldt et al., 2019; Khoza et al., 2019), where gender, class and other social hierarchies shape who benefits from and who bears the costs of food system change (Rice et al., 2023; Khoza et al., 2022). Despite decades of policy commitments to gender mainstreaming and sustainable development, women, who constitute most smallholder farmers and informal food traders in the region, continue to face systematic barriers to accessing productive resources, markets and decision-making spaces. (Donga et al., 2024; Chibowa et al., 2020; Nchanji et al., 2022).
This systematic review defines food systems as the interconnected processes of food production, processing, distribution, consumption and waste management, along with the social, economic, political and environmental factors affecting these processes. The gendered dimensions of food system transformation in Southern Africa are particularly acute in agricultural production and informal food markets. In agricultural production systems, women farmers face mobility constraints due to domestic care burdens, limited access to land and credit, exclusion from extension services and co-financing requirements for input subsidies, which disadvantage poorer, often female-headed households (Djurfeldt et al., 2019; Kerr et al., 2019). These constraints are not merely technical or resource-based; they are deeply embedded in patriarchal power relations, institutional arrangements and policy frameworks that systematically privilege male farmers and formal sector actors. Consequently, the adoption of climate-smart agriculture (CSA) technologies across Malawi, Zambia, Tanzania and South Africa remains heavily gendered. Men consistently show higher uptake rates (Khoza et al., 2019; Perelli et al., 2024).
In Malawi, for instance, over 70% of male farmers have adopted climate-smart agriculture technologies compared to less than 30% of female farmers, driven by structural barriers such as high input costs, insecure land tenure, labour requirements and lack of credit opportunities (Chibowa et al., 2020; Chabwera and Madhlopa, 2025; Nchanji et al., 2021), alongside intra-household power dynamics that dictate control over income. Similar gendered disparities are evident in Zambia and Tanzania, where women’s adoption of CSA is constrained by insecure land tenure, limited access to agricultural-related information and weaker integration into farmer organisations and innovation networks (Khoza et al., 2019). On the other hand, in South Africa, evidence further highlights that women’s adoption is strongly mediated by intra-household decision-making power, access to productive assets and control over income, reinforcing persistent structural inequalities in agricultural innovation uptake (Perelli et al., 2024).
While regional policy strategies widely champion CSA as a harmonized, ‘triple-win’ approach to productivity and environmental resilience, its implementation encounters significant roadblocks. Sub-Saharan policy regimes frequently adopt idealized, market-driven models that systematically privilege commercial scales, ignoring the acute political economy challenges and structural exclusions embedded within local resource landscapes (Shilomboleni, 2020). Consequently, there is an urgent need to evaluate how these macro-level technology rollouts collide with pre-existing socioeconomic dynamics.
Overall, this scholarship demonstrates that CSA adoption in Southern Africa is shaped not only by technical and economic considerations but also by gendered political economy structures (Table 1) that systematically disadvantage women farmers. Traditional development interventions frequently treat agricultural climate adaptation and food security as apolitical, technical milestones. However, macro-level modernization agendas are heavily driven by dominant, top-down narratives that regularly obscure localized socio-economic realities and labour constraints on the ground (Whitfield, 2016). By ignoring the underlying knowledge politics and structural inequalities that govern who can realistically adopt these technical fixes, conventional programs often inadvertently worsen structural marginalization across sub-Saharan landscapes. In informal food markets, women dominate labour-intensive activities such as fish processing, vegetable trading and street food vending, yet they earn significantly less than their male counterparts and face harassment, corruption by law enforcers and regulatory frameworks that ignore or actively exclude them (Donga et al., 2024; Ragsdale et al., 2022; Ng’ombe et al., 2024). During the COVID-19 pandemic, these vulnerabilities worsened; women informal food traders experienced severe economic shocks yet received minimal government assistance, exposing deep-seated administrative biases (Zimba et al., 2023; Sinyolo et al., 2022; Cook et al., 2024). These market inequities have cascading implications for food security, nutrition, livelihoods and public health, particularly in urban areas where low-income populations rely heavily on informal networks for diverse, affordable and nutritious food. Understanding and addressing these gendered inequities requires analytical frameworks that go beyond descriptive accounts of gender gaps to examine the underlying power relations, institutional arrangements, and actor incentives that produce and reproduce inequality (Khoza et al., 2019; Khoza et al., 2019). Political economy analysis (PEA) provides such a framework, focusing on how power, politics, and economic interests shape policy processes and development outcomes (Djurfeldt et al., 2019; Chabwera and Madhlopa, 2025; Nchanji et al., 2021; Mgalamadzi et al., 2024). When integrated with feminist perspectives, PEA reveals how gender operates as a fundamental organizing principle of economic and political life, shaping access to resources, participation in decision-making, and distribution of benefits and burdens.
Table 1
| Analytical dimension/layer | Case 1: Agricultural production networks (rural smallholder contexts) | Case 2: Informal food markets (urban and peri-urban spaces) |
|---|---|---|
| ACTORS (Stakeholder landscapes and sub-sector profiles) | •Smallholder farmers and female labourers (Djurfeldt et al., 2019; Kumar et al., 2018) •Input suppliers and technical extension agents (Makate et al., 2019) •Farmer cooperatives and producer organizations and government departments (Mgalamadzi et al., 2021) | •Women retailers, vendors, and processors (Manyungwa-Pasani et al., 2018; Sinyolo et al., 2022) •Local municipal councils and urban planners (Cook et al., 2024) •Middlemen and informal transporters (Ragsdale et al., 2022) |
| Institutions (Formal-informal legal, property and policy rules) | • Customary land tenure systems and patriarchal lineages (Kerr et al., 2019; Mphande et al., 2022) •Agricultural policies and strategies (e.g., CAADP alignment) (Ng’ombe et al., 2024) •Credit collateral banking rules (Makate et al., 2019) •Top-down knowledge politics & macro-adaptation frameworks (Whitfield, 2016) | • Market by-laws and trading permits (Sachs, 2019) • Food safety standards & public health regulations (Cook et al., 2024) •Business registration & tax policies (Donga et al., 2024) |
| Incentives (Underlying strategic motivations and target priorities) | •Productivity and income growth (Aberman et al., 2020) •Female priority: food diversity and household consumption stability (Zimba et al., 2023) •State priority: aggregate export statistics (Ng’ombe et al., 2024) •Market-driven ‘triple-win’ CSA targets (Shilomboleni, 2020) | •Income generation and livelihood security (Nchanji et al., 2022) •Social networks and mutual support savings groups (Ragsdale et al., 2022) •Municipal priority: extraction of licensing revenues (Sachs, 2019) |
| Power relations (Socio-economic leverage and control structures) | •Unequal land ownership and control (Kerr et al., 2019) •Gendered access to resources (land, water, inputs, finance) (Mgalamadzi et al., 2021) •Decision-making power in households and communities (Mohammed et al., 2025) | •Gendered control of market spaces and trading rights (Rice et al., 2023) •Asymmetric capital leverage with market gatekeepers (Ragsdale et al., 2022) • Punitive policing and regulatory harassment (Donga et al., 2024) |
| Gendered outcomes (Systemic asymmetries and quantitative baselines) | •Women hold 10–30% of agricultural land (varies by country) (Djurfeldt et al., 2019) •30–50% less access to productive resources & inputs (Mgalamadzi et al., 2024) •20–40% lower yields due to resource and knowledge gaps (Chibowa et al., 2020) • High time burden from unpaid care and household work (Nchanji et al., 2021) | •Women dominate informal food trade (60–80% of traders) (Sinyolo et al., 2022) •Limited access to secure market infrastructure (Cook et al., 2024) •Pronounced gendered income and capital gaps (Rice et al., 2023) •Heightened vulnerability to crisis shock disruptions (Donga et al., 2024) |
| One health implications (human-animal-eco health interface vulnerabilities) | •Animal: Veterinary neglect drives poultry/livestock mortality and zoonotic spillover risks (Mphande et al., 2022) •Environment: Land tenure insecurity stalls agroforestry and soil/water conservation (Kerr et al., 2019; Zimba et al., 2023) •Human: Suppressed control over profits drives lower dietary diversity (Kumar et al., 2018) | •Human: Exposure to severe biological hazards and occupational strain (Chabwera and Madhlopa, 2025) •Environment: Infrastructure deprivation drives poor market sanitation and waste accumulation (Cook et al., 2024) •Animal: Poor biosecurity speeds foodborne pathogen outbreaks and AMR risks (Ng’ombe et al., 2024) |
gendered political economy analysis synthesis across southern african food systems.
Simultaneously, the interconnections between human, animal and environmental health, conceptualized through the One Health approach, are increasingly recognized as critical to food system sustainability and equity. Climate change, zoonotic disease risks, antimicrobial resistance, food safety challenges and nutrition insecurity are all manifestations of the complex interdependencies between agricultural practices, ecosystem health and human well-being (Khoza et al., 2019; Zimba et al., 2023; Mphande et al., 2022; Kumar et al., 2018). Yet, One Health approaches have often failed to adequately integrate gender analysis, missing how gendered power relations shape exposure to health risks, access to health resources and capacity to adapt to environmental change. This review addresses these gaps by applying an integrated gendered PEA and One Health framework to food system transformation in Malawi, Zambia, Tanzania and South Africa. These countries present instructive cases characterized by high smallholder dependence, significant gender productivity gaps, large informal food sectors, and acute vulnerability to climate change (Djurfeldt et al., 2019; Khoza et al., 2019; Chibowa et al., 2020; Nchanji et al., 2022; Khoza et al., 2019). The analysis makes three key contributions. First, it develops an integrated analytical framework demonstrating how gender operates as a cross-cutting dimension that shapes human-animal-environment health interconnections in food systems. Second, it reveals the specific mechanisms through which power relations, institutional arrangements, and actor incentives produce gendered inequities with cascading health, economic and environmental consequences. Third, it generates policy-relevant insights for structural intervention, identifying leverage points for intervention that address structural drivers of inequality rather than merely treating symptoms.
2 Conceptual framework: integrating gendered political economy analysis with one health
2.1 Political economy analysis
PEA provides a critical lens for understanding how power, politics, and economic interests shape policy processes, institutional arrangements, and development outcomes (Djurfeldt et al., 2019; Chabwera and Madhlopa, 2025). Unlike purely technical or economic approaches that assume neutral systems and rational decision-making, PEA acknowledges that development processes are inherently political, influenced by competing interests over resources, authority, and knowledge (Nchanji et al., 2021; Mgalamadzi et al., 2024). This perspective is particularly relevant in food systems, where multiple actors interact across production, distribution and governance domains.
The integrated analytical approach relies on a critical political agronomy perspective, which posits that agricultural transitions are inherently tied to competing institutional power structures (Whitfield, 2016). Rather than evaluating technology uptake or market participation as isolated choices made by individual smallholders, this framework operationalizes the four core PEA dimensions: actors, institutions, incentives and power relations to explain how structural architectures dictate the material realities of resource distribution across the food system interface. The actors and interests focus on identifying key stakeholders, including government institutions, donors, private sector actors, civil society organizations, farmers, and traders and examining their incentives, roles, and influence (Djurfeldt et al., 2019; Morgan et al., 2019). These actors operate across both formal structures, such as ministries and regulatory bodies, and informal systems, including patronage networks and social relations, which often shape decision-making in practice. Collectively, these dimensions provide a basis for understanding how institutional arrangements and power relations mediate whose interests are prioritized, how resources and opportunities are distributed, and ultimately how agricultural transitions unfold.
Second, institutions and rules refer to the formal and informal frameworks that govern behaviour (Djurfeldt et al., 2019; Chabwera and Madhlopa, 2025; Nchanji et al., 2021; Mgalamadzi et al., 2024). Formal institutions include laws, policies, and regulatory systems, while informal institutions encompass social norms, cultural practices, and unwritten rules. Importantly, these two spheres do not always align; in many contexts, informal institutions exert stronger influence on actual practices and outcomes than formal regulations.
Third, incentives and constraints explain why actors behave in certain ways. Incentives may be economic, political, or social, while constraints include limited resources, unequal access to information, and structural barriers embedded within institutional systems (Djurfeldt et al., 2019; Chabwera and Madhlopa, 2025). Finally, power relations shape whose interests are prioritized in decision-making processes. Power operates through various forms, including coercion, authority, control over resources, and the ability to shape dominant narratives and norms.
2.2 Gender as a cross-cutting analytical Lens
Integrating gender into PEA requires moving beyond treating gender as a simple demographic variable to recognizing it as a fundamental organizing principle of social, economic and political life (Nchanji et al., 2021; Mgalamadzi et al., 2024; Aberman et al., 2020). Within food systems, gender relations shape how roles are assigned, resources are distributed, and decisions are made, ultimately influencing development outcomes and equity.
A gendered political economy perspective shows several critical dimensions. First, the division of labour determines who performs specific tasks, under what conditions, and with what levels of recognition and reward, often placing disproportionate burdens on women in productive and reproductive roles (Djurfeldt et al., 2019; Rice et al., 2023; Aberman et al., 2020). Second, access to and control over resources including land, income, credit, and productive assets, are unequally distributed, with women frequently facing systemic barriers that limit their economic agency. (Chabwera and Madhlopa, 2025; Mgalamadzi et al., 2024; Mgalamadzi et al., 2021) Third, participation in decision-making varies significantly by gender, with women often having limited voice and influence at household, community, and policy levels (Mgalamadzi et al., 2024; Aberman et al., 2020; Mohammed et al., 2025). Fourth, gender shapes exposure to risks and access to opportunities, influencing who bears the impacts of environmental degradation, climate change, and economic shocks, as well as who benefits from development interventions (Khoza et al., 2019; Nchanji et al., 2022; Khoza et al., 2019).
Importantly, gender intersects with other social identifiers such as class, age, marital status, ethnicity, and geographic location, producing diverse and context-specific patterns of advantage and disadvantage. (Rice et al., 2023; Mgalamadzi et al., 2021; Sachs, 2019). For example, female-headed households often face different constraints compared to women in male-headed households, while younger women encounter distinct barriers relative to older women. Similarly, rural and urban contexts shape women’s experiences in different ways.
A gendered political economy lens further reveals that policies and institutions often considered “neutral” can produce unequal outcomes. For example, co-financing requirements for agricultural subsidies and formal permit rules for market trading both penalise resource-constrained groups, disproportionately hurting female-headed households and informal traders who rely on flexibility. Similarly, extension services targeting “farmers” frequently reach men, despite women’s significant contributions to agricultural labour. This happens because institutional setups ignore existing social realities, effectively cutting women off from support despite their central role in agricultural labour.
2.3 One health and food systems
The One Health approach recognizes the intrinsic interdependence between human, animal and environmental health systems (Khoza et al., 2019). Within food systems, these linkages are particularly pronounced, as agricultural production, food distribution, and consumption processes simultaneously shape health, ecological sustainability and socio-economic outcomes. At the global level, this multi-sectoral integration has been codified by the Quadripartite collaboration, comprising the FAO, UNEP, WHO, and WOAH within their foundational One Health Joint Plan of Action (2022–2026) (FAO et al., 2022). This international framework establishes clear priority pathways targeting global health threats at the human-animal-ecosystem interface, including zoonotic disease vectors, food safety systems, and antimicrobial threats.
When mapped onto local agri-food systems, the realities of these global priorities become visible across three distinct pathways. First, agricultural production systems play a central role in determining the availability, accessibility, and affordability of diverse and nutritious foods (Ng’ombe et al., 2024; Aberman et al., 2020; Kumar et al., 2018), thereby directly influencing human nutrition and food security outcomes. Second, food systems are closely linked to food safety and zoonotic disease dynamics. Interactions between livestock, wildlife and humans alongside food handling and processing practices significantly shape exposure to foodborne pathogens and zoonotic diseases. Third, the widespread use of antibiotics in animal production systems contributes to the growing global challenge of antimicrobial resistance, which poses a serious threat to public health (Mphande et al., 2022).
In addition, agricultural practices are deeply intertwined with environmental sustainability. They influence greenhouse gas emissions, soil fertility, water quality, and biodiversity, all of which have feedback effects on agricultural productivity and human well-being (Khoza et al., 2019; Zimba et al., 2023; Mphande et al., 2022). Furthermore, food systems encompass important occupational health dimensions, as agricultural and food processing activities expose workers to physical hazards, chemical risks, and ergonomic stressors (Donga et al., 2024; Ragsdale et al., 2022).
Despite increasing recognition of these interconnected pathways in global governance documents like the Quadripartite Joint Plan of Action, standard One Health frameworks have often inadequately incorporated gender analysis. This represents a critical gap, as gender dynamics shape vulnerabilities and opportunities across all dimensions of food systems. Women’s limited access to productive resources constrains household nutrition security and agricultural productivity. Their concentration in informal food markets increases exposure to food safety risks and occupational hazards (Donga et al., 2024; Ragsdale et al., 2022; Sinyolo et al., 2022). Moreover, exclusion from decision-making processes restricts women’s ability to adopt climate-smart agricultural practices and respond to environmental change. Finally, gendered roles in unpaid care work influence women’s time use, mobility and exposure to environmental health risks (Djurfeldt et al., 2019; Rice et al., 2023; Nchanji et al., 2022). By remaining blind to how local patriarchal power structures dictate resource allocation and biosecurity choices, current frameworks overlook the primary social mechanisms driving human, animal, and ecosystem outcomes. Taken together, these gender dynamics highlight the need for a more integrated and gender-responsive application of the One Health approach within food systems, particularly in low- and middle-income contexts where these interconnections are most acute.
2.4 Integrated analytical framework
This integrated framework (Figure 1) combines gendered political economy analysis with One Health approaches to examine how power relations, institutional arrangements and actor incentives shape food system outcomes across human-animal-environment health dimensions.
Figure 1
The framework operates at multiple levels. At the macro level, this review focuses on national and regional policies, legal frameworks, economic structures and cultural norms that shape the overall context for food systems. At the meso level, sectoral institutions, market structures, value chain governance and organizational arrangements that mediate between macro-level structures and micro-level actors become more apparent. Finally, at the micro level, household and individual decision-making, resource allocation, labour allocation and livelihood strategies are of concern. Gender operates as a cross-cutting dimension at all levels, shaping, among other things, dynamics around who participates in food system activities and under what conditions, who accesses resources and opportunities, who bears risks and burdens, who benefits from food system outcomes and how human-animal-environment health interconnections are experienced and managed.
This framework is key to the review’s analysis of agricultural production systems and informal food markets in Southern Africa, revealing how gendered power relations and institutional arrangements produce differential outcomes across One Health dimensions.
2.4.1 Theoretical contributions
This review advances the literature in three key ways. First, it demonstrates the analytical value of integrating gendered political economy perspectives with One Health frameworks. This combined approach enables a more comprehensive understanding of how structural factors, particularly power relations, institutional arrangements, and actor incentives, shape interconnected outcomes across health, agriculture, and environmental systems (Khoza et al., 2019; Nchanji et al., 2022; Nchanji et al., 2021; Mphande et al., 2022). By moving beyond descriptive accounts of gender disparities, this integration provides a more robust explanation of the mechanisms driving inequities and their broader implications.
Second, the review shows the critical interaction between formal and informal institutions in shaping gendered outcomes. Policies and regulations that appear neutral often produce unequal effects when they intersect with informal norms, customary practices, and existing disparities in resource access (Djurfeldt et al., 2019; Donga et al., 2024; Chabwera and Madhlopa, 2025; Nchanji et al., 2021; Sinyolo et al., 2022). This finding reinforces the need for policy approaches that address both formal structures and the informal systems that mediate their implementation.
Third, it emphasizes the interconnected and reinforcing nature of structural barriers faced by women in food systems. Constraints related to land access, credit, labour, time, and institutional support do not operate in isolation but interact to create persistent cycles of disadvantage (Djurfeldt et al., 2019; Rice et al., 2023; Donga et al., 2024; Chabwera and Madhlopa, 2025; Mgalamadzi et al., 2021; Sinyolo et al., 2022). This insight challenges siloed interventions and shows the importance of integrated, multi-sectoral strategies that simultaneously address multiple dimensions of inequality.
2.5 Selection rationale
Malawi, Zambia, Tanzania and South Africa provide particularly instructive cases for examining gendered food system transformation in Southern Africa for several reasons. These countries are characterized by high levels of smallholder agriculture, with women constituting the majority of agricultural labourers, yet facing systematic barriers to accessing productive resources (Djurfeldt et al., 2019; Chibowa et al., 2020; Nchanji et al., 2022; Khoza et al., 2019). The targeted countries also exhibit substantial gender gaps in agricultural productivity, technology adoption, resource access, and market participation, making them ideal contexts for examining mechanisms of gendered exclusion (Djurfeldt et al., 2019; Khoza et al., 2019; Chibowa et al., 2020; Mgalamadzi et al., 2021). Informal food markets are critical to food security and livelihoods, particularly in urban and peri-urban areas, and are dominated by women traders (Donga et al., 2024; Ragsdale et al., 2022; Sinyolo et al., 2022; Cook et al., 2024). They face significant climate change impacts, including increased frequency of droughts and floods, making climate-smart agriculture adoption critical yet highly gendered (Khoza et al., 2019; Chibowa et al., 2020; Nchanji et al., 2022; Khoza et al., 2019). Moreso, they have national policies on gender equality, agricultural development and climate change, yet implementation gaps persist, providing opportunities to examine disconnects between policy rhetoric and practice (Djurfeldt et al., 2019; Chabwera and Madhlopa, 2025; Nchanji et al., 2021). Finally, while each country has unique characteristics, patterns observed in these countries are broadly representative of challenges facing smallholder-dominated, climate-vulnerable food systems across Southern Africa (Djurfeldt et al., 2019; Khoza et al., 2019; Cook et al., 2024).
3 Methodology
3.1 Design and approach
The structural focus of this systematic review is bounded geographically within four distinct Southern African nations: Malawi, Zambia, Tanzania, and South Africa. This comparative geographic selection is purposively justified based on three intersecting criteria.
First, these nations represent highly diverse sub-regional variations in agri-food system commercialization, ranging from largely agrarian, smallholder-dependent landscapes dominated by legumes and small livestock profiles (Malawi and Zambia) to mixed-market networks (Tanzania) and highly formalized, corporate-dominated supermarket supply chains (South Africa). This economic variation allows for a rigorous cross-case political economy analysis of how different market structures influence marginalization.
Second, despite these distinct structural differences, all four countries are exposed to shared macro-level climate vulnerabilities and regional economic shocks, making them a cohesive unit for evaluating climate-adaptive capacities.
Finally, all four nations have actively institutionalized integrated national One Health strategic frameworks and operational bodies. This political baseline makes them ideal focal points for an explanatory investigation into how localized socio-economic power imbalances and gender hierarchies directly influence cross-sectoral human, animal, and environmental health outcomes.
The study followed the 2020 PRISMA guidelines for systematic reviews to compare case study designs, examining agricultural production systems and informal food markets in Malawi, Zambia, Tanzania and South Africa through the lens of gendered political economy analysis integrated with One Health principles. The approach is primarily qualitative and analytical, synthesizing empirical evidence from recent research (2018–2026) to identify patterns, mechanisms and causal pathways through which gender, power and institutions shape food system outcomes.
The analysis is structured around the four core dimensions of political economy analysis: actors, institutions, incentives and power relations, with gender treated as a cross-cutting analytical lens. For each case study domain (agricultural production and informal markets), this systematic review identifies and examines the key actors, with special focus on their different interests and incentives aggregated by gender. The review also examines the influence of formal and informal rules, norms and practices on the governance behaviour and the production of gendered outcomes. In addition, it analyzes key drivers of behaviour and differences in incentive structures between men and women. Finally, the review looked into the dynamics of power distribution and how power asymmetries shape whose interests prevail. These political economy dimensions are then traced across One Health domains, to assess how they interact and cascade to influence nutrition security, food safety, livelihood resilience and ecosystem sustainability.
3.2 Literature search strategy
Database searches were restricted to studies published in English between 2018 and 2026. The final comprehensive literature search across all selected databases was executed in June 2026. This specific baseline is chronologically justified to capture the contemporary operational landscape of Southern African food systems following two critical structural shifts.
First, 2018 marks the post-implementation phase of major regional policy frameworks, specifically aligning with the initial biennial review cycles of the Malabo Declaration (under the Comprehensive Africa Agriculture Development Programme, now Kampala Declaration) and the formalization of integrated National One Health Strategic Plans across the target countries. Limiting the search to this window ensures the synthesis captures empirical evidence generated after these multi-sectoral health and agricultural frameworks were institutionalized, rather than relying on obsolete data from the mid-2015 era.
Second, this timeframe captures the compounding impacts of modern, unprecedented regional disruptions, including intense cyclical climate shocks (such as Cyclones Idai and Freddy) and post-pandemic economic restructurings. By bounding the review within this contemporary window, the analysis explicitly synthesizes how modern gender hierarchies and political-economic mechanisms respond to the current human-animal-environmental health crises facing the region.
A comprehensive and systematic literature search was undertaken to identify studies examining the intersections between gender, political economy, One Health, and food systems in Southern Africa. The search strategy was developed to capture evidence on how gendered power relations, institutional arrangements, governance structures, and actor incentives influence food system outcomes and their implications for human, animal and environmental health. While the search strategy systematically covered the wider Southern African region, explicitly including Malawi, Zambia, Tanzania, and South Africa, the final pool of eligible literature exhibits an uneven geographic distribution. The existing empirical evidence base on the intersections of gender, political economy, and One Health metrics is heavily weighted toward smallholder systems in Malawi and Zambia, with comparatively fewer eligible studies meeting our strict inclusion criteria for Tanzania and South Africa. Rather than altering our rigorous selection criteria, this study transparently synthesizes this unbalanced regional landscape, explicitly addressing these cross-contextual variations and their specific policy implications in our comparative results.
Electronic searches were conducted across multiple multidisciplinary and subject-specific databases, including Scopus, Web of Science, PubMed, ScienceDirect, JSTOR, and Google Scholar. To complement peer-reviewed databases, a targeted grey literature search was conducted from key international bodies such as the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO). This search strategy specifically targeted foundational policy frameworks such as the One Health Joint Plan Action (2022–2026) to ground the review’s conceptual architecture, alongside regional reports to supplement empirical data on agricultural production and informal food markets in Southern Africa. The search strategy combined controlled vocabulary terms and free-text keywords related to four core concepts:
Gender and Social Inclusion;
Political Economy and Governance;
Food Systems and Agricultural Livelihoods; and
One Health Dimensions, including nutrition, food safety, zoonotic diseases, environmental sustainability, climate resilience, and ecosystem health.
Boolean operators (“AND,” “OR”), truncation symbols, and phrase searching were used to maximize sensitivity and specificity. The search captured contemporary evidence reflecting increasing policy attention to gender equality, food systems transformation, climate change, and One Health approaches. Additional studies were identified through backward and forward citation tracking of eligible articles and key review papers.
All retrieved records were exported into a reference management software package, where duplicates were removed prior to title and abstract screening. Full-text articles were subsequently assessed against predefined eligibility criteria. The study selection process was documented using a PRISMA flow diagram (Figure 2).
Figure 2
Following PRISMA 2020 guidelines, an initial search yielded 1,150 records, with 998 screened after removing duplicates. After excluding 870 records during title/abstract screening, 128 full-text articles were assessed, resulting in 100 exclusions due to issues with empirical evidence, format, access, or scope, leaving 28 studies for final synthesis.
3.3 Selection criteria
The eligibility criteria were developed using the Population-Concept-Context (PCC) framework recommended for evidence synthesis studies. The review included studies focusing on food systems in Southern Africa, particularly Malawi, Zambia, Tanzania and South Africa, where gender dimensions, political economy factors, and One Health-related outcomes were explicitly examined or could be inferred from the findings.
Eligible studies included English-only peer-reviewed journal articles, policy analyses, technical reports, and working papers. Studies were included if they examined agricultural production systems, livestock systems, informal food markets, food value chains, food security, nutrition, natural resource management, climate resilience, or related food system domains and reported evidence on gender relations, governance structures, institutional arrangements, power dynamics, resource access, decision-making processes, health outcomes, environmental sustainability, or livelihood implications.
During the full-text screening phase, a total of 100 articles were excluded (n = 100). Reasons for exclusion included a lack of geographical focus on the target Southern African countries, absence of a dedicated gender framework within agricultural production or informal food markets or focusing exclusively on technical agricultural interventions without addressing gender, governance, socio-economic, health, or environmental dimensions. Editorials, conference abstracts, opinion papers, commentaries, and studies lacking sufficient methodological detail were also excluded. Where multiple publications reported findings from the same study, the most comprehensive and recent version was retained.
To ensure objectivity, title, abstract and full-text screening stages were performed independently by two investigators. Discrepancies regarding study eligibility were settled through direct consultation and consensus; when a resolution could not be reached, a third senior author arbitrated the final decision.
3.4 Data extraction table
A standardized data extraction table (Table 2) was developed and pilot-tested to ensure consistency and relevance to the review objectives. Information extracted from each study included author(s), year of publication, country or geographic focus, study design, study population, food system domain, gender-related focus, political economy dimensions examined, One Health components addressed, key findings, and reported implications for food systems, health, livelihoods and environmental sustainability (Table 3).
Table 2
| Study (Author, Year) | Country/geographical focus | Food system domain | Study design | Population/participants | Key gender findings | Political economy dimension | One health implications |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Djurfeldt et al. (2019) | Malawi, Tanzania, Zambia | Agricultural intensification | Mixed methods | Smallholder farmers | Gender gaps in productivity and input access persist | Institutions; Power relations | Food security and livelihood vulnerability |
| Khoza et al. (2019) | Malawi, Zambia | Climate-smart agriculture | Quantitative | Smallholder farmers | Women less likely to adopt CSA practices | Institutions; Incentives | Reduced climate resilience and productivity |
| Rice et al. (2023) | Malawi | Fish trade | Mixed methods | Small-scale fish traders | Women earn less due to gender norms | Power relations; Markets | Nutrition and livelihood insecurity |
| Khoza et al. (2022) | Malawi, Zambia | Climate-smart agriculture | Mixed methods | Farmers | Gendered vulnerability shapes non-adoption | Institutions; Power relations | Climate adaptation gaps |
| Donga et al. (2024) | Zambia (post-COVID context) | Informal food trade | Qualitative | Women entrepreneurs | Women disproportionately affected by shocks | Institutions; Markets | Income loss and food insecurity |
| Chibowa et al. (2020) | Malawi | CSA technologies | Quantitative | Smallholder farmers | Women adopt fewer CSA technologies | Institutions; Capacity | Reduced adaptive capacity |
| Nchanji et al. (2022) | Malawi | Bean production systems | Mixed methods | Farmers | Gender differences in adaptation practices | Institutions; Technology access | Food production resilience |
| Kerr et al. (2019) | Malawi | Agroecology systems | Qualitative | Rural communities | Agroecology may reproduce gender inequality | Power relations; Norms | Food sovereignty outcomes |
| Chabwera and Madhlopa (2025) | Malawi | OFSP value chain | Systematic review | Value chain actors | Gender inequalities across value chain nodes | Market structures; Power | Nutrition outcomes |
| Nchanji et al. (2021) | Eastern and Southern Africa | Food systems (COVID-19) | Qualitative synthesis | Food system actors | Women disproportionately affected by COVID shocks | Institutions; Markets | Food insecurity risks |
| Ragsdale et al. (2022) | Zambia | Fisheries value chain | Quantitative | Fishers, processors, traders | Women face lower empowerment scores | Power relations | Economic vulnerability |
| Ng’ombe et al. (2024) | Zambia | Input subsidies | Quantitative | Farming households | Subsidies not fully gender equitable | Institutions; Policy design | Dietary inequality |
| Zimba et al. (2023) | Malawi | Crop varietal choice | Quantitative | Sorghum/millet farmers | Gendered preferences for climate traits | Institutions; Knowledge systems | Climate resilience outcomes |
| Morgan et al. (2019) | Zambia | Market systems | Program evaluation | Women farmers | Improved market access for women | Institutions; Markets | Income and livelihood gains |
| Mphande et al. (2022) | Zambia | Legume production | Qualitative | Smallholder farmers | Women face climate constraints in legumes | Climate; Institutions | Food security vulnerability |
| Mgalamadzi et al. (2024) | Malawi | Agricultural commercialization | Quantitative | Farm households | Gendered decision-making patterns | Household power dynamics | Nutrition and expenditure outcomes |
| Mgalamadzi et al. (2021) | Malawi | Agricultural commercialization | Qualitative | Rural households | Unequal intra-household control | Power relations | Livelihood inequality |
| Aberman et al. (2020) | Malawi | Crop production decisions | Mixed methods | Farmers | Gender shapes sell vs. consume decisions | Household bargaining | Food consumption outcomes |
| Sinyolo et al. (2022) | South Africa | Informal food trade | Qualitative | Women traders | COVID worsened women’s vulnerability | Markets; Institutions | Food insecurity |
| Manyungwa-Pasani et al. (2018) | Malawi | Fish value chains | Data repository study | Women fish traders | Limited participation in governance | Value chain power | Livelihood insecurity |
| Kumar et al. (2018) | Zambia | Nutrition-sensitive agriculture | Program evaluation | Rural households | Gender-sensitive interventions improve outcomes | Institutions; Programs | Nutrition improvements |
| Mohammed et al. (2025) | Ghana/Zambia (SSA focus) | Nutrition-sensitive agriculture | Mixed methods | Women farmers | Women central to nutrition decisions | Household decision-making | Dietary improvements |
| Cook et al. (2024) | Sub-Saharan Africa | Traditional food markets | Systematic review | Vulnerable populations | Gender shapes market access and benefits | Markets; Governance | Nutrition and food safety |
| Makate et al. (2019) | Southern Africa | CSA technologies | Quantitative | Farmers | Credit + extension improves adoption | Institutions; Incentives | Climate resilience |
| Mabaleka et al. (2025) | South Africa | Climate adaptation | Quantitative | Small-scale farmers | Gendered perception of climate change | Knowledge systems | Environmental resilience |
| Perelli et al. (2024) | Sub-Saharan Africa | CSA adoption | Cross-country analysis | Agricultural systems | Women enhance CSA adoption likelihood | Institutions; Gender equality | Sustainability outcomes |
| Kihoro et al. (2024) | Zambia | Climate adaptation and empowerment | Quantitative | Women in climate hotspots | Empowerment improves adaptive capacity | Power relations; Institutions | Climate resilience |
Data extraction table.
Table 3
| Domain | Maximum score |
|---|---|
| Selection | 4 |
| Comparability | 2 |
| Outcome/exposure assessment | 3 |
| Total | 9 |
Assessment criteria.
Additional information was extracted on actors and stakeholders involved, institutional arrangements, governance mechanisms, power relations, resource access and control, barriers and enabling factors affecting women’s participation, and recommendations for policy and practice. The extraction process was guided by the analytical framework underpinning the review and sought to capture evidence on how gendered power dynamics influence food system outcomes across human, animal, and environmental health domains (Table 4).
Table 4
| Study | Study design | Selection (4) | Comparability (2) | Outcome/exposure assessment (3) | Total score (9) | Quality rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Djurfeldt et al. (2019) | Mixed methods | 4 | 2 | 2 | 8 | High |
| Khoza et al. (2019) | Mixed methods | 4 | 2 | 2 | 8 | High |
| Rice et al. (2023) | Mixed methods | 4 | 2 | 2 | 8 | High |
| Khoza et al. (2022) | Cross-sectional | 3 | 2 | 2 | 7 | High |
| Donga et al. (2024) | Mixed methods | 4 | 2 | 2 | 8 | High |
| Chibowa et al. (2020) | Quantitative | 3 | 2 | 2 | 7 | High |
| Nchanji et al. (2022) | Mixed methods | 4 | 2 | 2 | 8 | High |
| Kerr et al. (2019) | Qualitative | 3 | 2 | 2 | 7 | High |
| Chabwera and Madhlopa (2025) | Systematic review | 3 | 2 | 2 | 7 | High |
| Nchanji et al. (2021) | Review/policy analysis | 3 | 2 | 2 | 7 | High |
| Ragsdale et al. (2022) | Mixed methods | 4 | 2 | 2 | 8 | High |
| Ng’ombe et al. (2024) | Quantitative | 4 | 2 | 2 | 8 | High |
| Zimba et al. (2023) | Mixed methods | 3 | 2 | 2 | 7 | High |
| Morgan et al. (2019) | Programme evaluation | 3 | 2 | 2 | 7 | High |
| Mphande et al. (2022) | Mixed methods | 4 | 2 | 2 | 8 | High |
| Mgalamadzi et al. (2024) | Quantitative | 4 | 2 | 2 | 8 | High |
| Mgalamadzi et al. (2021) | Mixed methods | 3 | 2 | 2 | 7 | High |
| Aberman et al. (2020) | Quantitative | 4 | 2 | 2 | 8 | High |
| Sinyolo et al. (2022) | Mixed methods | 4 | 2 | 2 | 8 | High |
| Manyungwa-Pasani et al. (2018) | Mixed methods | 3 | 2 | 2 | 7 | High |
| Kumar et al. (2018) | Programme evaluation | 3 | 2 | 2 | 7 | High |
| Mohammed et al. (2025) | Mixed methods | 4 | 2 | 2 | 8 | High |
| Cook et al. (2024) | Systematic narrative review | 3 | 2 | 2 | 7 | High |
| Makate et al. (2019) | Quantitative | 4 | 2 | 2 | 8 | High |
| Mabaleka et al. (2025) | Cross-sectional | 3 | 2 | 2 | 7 | High |
| Khoza et al. (2022) | Mixed methods | 4 | 2 | 2 | 8 | High |
| Perelli et al. (2024) | Quantitative cross-country analysis | 4 | 2 | 2 | 8 | High |
| Kihoro et al. (2024) | Mixed methods | 4 | 2 | 2 | 8 | High |
The Newcastle-Ottawa quality assessment scale for cross-sectional studies.
All extracted data were entered into Microsoft Excel and subsequently reviewed for completeness and consistency prior to synthesis.
3.5 Quality assessment
The Newcastle-Ottawa Scale was adapted to assess methodological rigour across diverse study designs, with an emphasis on sampling adequacy, transparency in data collection, analytical rigour, comparability and validity of findings.
The quality of the included empirical literature was appraised using a modified Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (NOS), which is highly suited for the observational and cross-sectional data designs dominating the regional smallholder literature. Purely conceptual or theoretical frameworks included in the wider review for contextual grounding were excluded from this formal empirical appraisal table.
The methodological quality of the included empirical studies was assessed using an adapted version of this scale to accommodate the specific characteristics of the regional data. The assessment considered three distinct domains: Selection (maximum score = 4), which evaluated the appropriateness of study design, sampling procedures, and representativeness of participants; Comparability (maximum score = 2), which assessed the extent to which studies addressed confounding factors and employed appropriate analytical approaches; and Outcome or Exposure Assessment (maximum score = 3), which examined the validity of measurement procedures, transparency of reporting, and robustness of findings. Of the 28 empirical studies subjected to this formal appraisal, all 28 were rated as high quality, scoring between 7 and 9 points. No empirical study was classified as moderate or low quality. This high concentration of top-tier scores reflects the generally strong methodological rigour of the evidence base, particularly among empirical studies employing quantitative surveys, and field programme evaluations. Overall, the quality appraisal indicates that the empirical evidence synthesized in this review is sufficiently robust to support conclusions regarding gendered political economy dynamics, food system transformation, and One Health outcomes in Southern Africa.
Lastly, methodological quality appraisal was conducted in duplicate by two independent reviewers. The authors maintained a high level of initial alignment (approximately 90% agreement), and any minor divergence in quality grading scores was successfully resolved via internal discussion and consensus.
3.6 Data sources and analysis
The analysis synthesizes empirical evidence from peer-reviewed research published between 2018 and 2026, focusing on studies that provide detailed empirical data on gender, food systems and related dimensions. Using the PRISMA methodology for systematic reviews, we synthesized literature on gendered dimensions of agricultural production, including land access, input use, extension services and technology adoption (Djurfeldt et al., 2019; Chibowa et al., 2020; Nchanji et al., 2022; Kerr et al., 2019; Chabwera and Madhlopa, 2025; Zimba et al., 2023; Mphande et al., 2022; Makate et al., 2019; Khoza et al., 2019) This review also focused on studies that captured women’s participation in informal food markets, including fish trade, vegetable markets and street food vending (Rice et al., 2023; Donga et al., 2024; Ragsdale et al., 2022; Sinyolo et al., 2022; Manyungwa-Pasani et al., 2018). In addition, it synthesized literature on political economy of agricultural policies, including input subsidies, extension services, and market regulations (Sachs, 2019; Nchanji et al., 2021; Ng’ombe et al., 2024; Morgan et al., 2019). Finally, it also looked at literature on One Health dimensions, including nutrition security, food safety, climate impacts and livelihood resilience (Khoza et al., 2019; Ng’ombe et al., 2024; Mphande et al., 2022; Kumar et al., 2018; Cook et al., 2024).
A data extraction table was developed to capture study-specific data such as quantitative indicators of gender gaps and disparities, qualitative descriptions of constraints, barriers and opportunities, institutional arrangements and policy frameworks, power relations and actor incentives and One Health implications and interconnections.
The authors then conducted thematic analysis to identify recurring patterns, mechanisms and causal pathways, organizing findings according to the integrated analytical framework. The synthesis table (Table 1) presents comparative insights across political economy dimensions, contexts and One Health implications.
4 Results and discussions
A meta-synthesis of the 28 reviewed empirical studies across Malawi, Zambia, Tanzania, and South Africa demonstrates that food system transformation in Southern Africa is not a linear path toward technical efficiency. Instead, it is a contested political economy process that yields highly uneven, gendered outcomes. Analyzing the evidence base collectively shows that macro-level structural adjustments and modernization policies consistently encounter, and are distorted by, entrenched customary rules and unequal power dynamics at the meso and micro levels (Djurfeldt et al., 2019; Sachs, 2019). Rather than operating as peripheral participants, women act as the primary labour force in agricultural production networks and constitute the numeric majority in informal food retail, yet this foundational contribution does not translate into systemic economic or decision-making power (Morgan et al., 2019; Mgalamadzi et al., 2024).To capture these dynamics accurately, the reviewed evidence is mapped and synthesized across two primary application domains: Case 1: Agricultural Production Networks (comprising studies evaluating rural smallholder dynamics and technology uptake) (Aberman et al., 2020; Chibowa et al., 2020; Djurfeldt et al., 2019; Kerr et al., 2019; Khoza et al., 2019; Khoza et al., 2022; Khoza et al., 2019; Kihoro et al., 2024; Kumar et al., 2018; Mabaleka et al., 2025; Makate et al., 2019; Mgalamadzi et al., 2021; Mohammed et al., 2025; Mphande et al., 2022; Perelli et al., 2024; Zimba et al., 2023) and Case 2: Informal Food Markets (comprising studies evaluating urban, peri-urban, and lakeside distribution networks) (Chabwera and Madhlopa, 2025; Cook et al., 2024; Donga et al., 2024; Manyungwa-Pasani et al., 2018; Nchanji et al., 2021; Ragsdale et al., 2022; Rice et al., 2023; Sachs, 2019; Sinyolo et al., 2022). By analyzing these Southern African food systems through an integrated gendered PEA (Table 1) and One Health lens, this review demonstrates that human, animal, and environmental health outcomes are fundamentally mediated by political economy structures. Traditional One Health approaches, including prominent global strategies (FAO et al., 2022), often adopt a gender-blind framework that reduces animal disease vectors or environmental degradation to technical or ecological variables.
However, the findings show that biosecurity failures, such as uncontrolled zoonotic vectors in smallholder livestock systems or pathogen proliferation in informal markets, are structural symptoms of gendered resource exclusion. When institutional architectures deny women secure land tenure or veterinary extension, they cripple the very actors responsible for daily environmental stewardship and animal care. Thus, sustainable food system transformation cannot be achieved through technical or biomedical interventions alone; it requires dismantling the gendered power dynamics that govern resource distribution across the entire One Health interface. While the evidence base reflects an uneven regional distribution, drawing primarily on extensive smallholder datasets from Malawi and Zambia, with supplementary evidence from Tanzania and South Africa, a cross-contextual analysis reveals how distinct national political economies alter gendered exclusion and One Health outcomes.
4.1 Case 1: the political economy and one health dynamics of agricultural production networks
Within regional agricultural production networks, agri-food systems are contested spaces driven by competing, gendered actors and interests. The primary actors in this domain include male and female smallholders, corporate input suppliers, and state officials. While resource-constrained female smallholders prioritize long-term household consumption stability, crop trait diversity, and dietary resilience, dominant corporate and state actors favour commercialized, high-input value chains (Zimba et al., 2023; Aberman et al., 2020). This divergence regularly triggers a masculine re-appropriation of value chains once they transition from low-return subsistence lines to high-value cash markets. In Malawi and Zambia, as legume or specialized crop value chains become profitable through state input subsidies or external market integration, control over production assets, income allocation, and land use shifts away from women to male household members (Ng’ombe et al., 2024; Mphande et al., 2022).
This pattern persists because resource distribution is governed by interlocking formal and informal institutions that encode gender bias into daily operations. Agrarian landscapes across Malawi, Zambia, and Tanzania are heavily dictated by customary land arrangements. In these contexts, despite pockets of matrilineal tradition in regions like Malawi, women predominantly secure access to arable land through intra-household negotiations or patrilocal customary lineage rules rather than formal, independent ownership (Djurfeldt et al., 2019; Mphande et al., 2022). Similarly, in Tanzania, while the formal Village Land Act legally provides for equal land access, localized customary governance mechanisms frequently bypass these protections, restricting female smallholders from holding primary ownership titles (Djurfeldt et al., 2019). This tenure insecurity creates a direct domino effect: without formal land documentation as collateral, women smallholders across Malawi, Zambia, and Tanzania are locked out of commercial credit channels. This systemic lack of capital directly curtails long-term investments in agroecological land repairs, soil fertility management, and protected water-catchment infrastructure, accelerating regional deforestation and topsoil erosion (Djurfeldt et al., 2019; Kerr et al., 2019). Conversely, South Africa’s agrarian structure is shaped by the legalistic legacies of large-scale, formal commercialization and communal frameworks where women face exclusion through highly institutionalized land distribution systems that historically prioritized male heads of households (Mabaleka et al., 2025; Naicker and Molapo, 2022).
In all four contexts, this gendered resource exclusion restricts a woman’s ability to secure veterinary extension or inputs. This lack of access directly limits poultry vaccinations in Tanzania and restricts access to cattle-dipping infrastructure in South Africa, multiplying community-level livestock mortalities and zoonotic disease vectors across the landscapes (Ragsdale et al., 2022; Mphande et al., 2022). This institutional friction creates a persistent inequality trap rooted in uneven power relations: women are excluded from formal credit channels because commercial banks enforce collateral requirements tied to formal land documentation, assets women cannot structurally acquire (Makate et al., 2019). Consequently, technical interventions that treat resource access as an individual capacity deficit rather than an institutional power lock-in end up reinforcing baseline socio-economic divisions (Mabaleka et al., 2025; Naicker and Molapo, 2022; Kihoro et al., 2024). This mismatch directly validates the broader political agronomy critiques of Whitfield (Whitfield, 2016), who notes that macro-level adaptation policies are driven by dominant, top-down narratives that regularly erase grassroots, gendered labour realities.
These uneven institutional setups create highly divergent incentives and operational constraints. Macro-level and cross-country quantitative evidence demonstrates that women possess strong latent agency to actively enhance the likelihood of CSA adoption, serving as primary drivers of sustainable practices due to their long-term focus on household risk mitigation (Perelli et al., 2024). However, as Shilomboleni (Shilomboleni, 2020) observes, these neoliberal modernization goals frequently clash with the localized needs of resource-poor farmers, meaning this adaptive capacity is bottlenecked by meso-level institutional failures. When micro-level household dynamics and community property regimes are highly unequal, women are forced into non-adoption or active dis-adoption (Khoza et al., 2022). This occurs because labour-intensive conservation techniques such as manual pitting, residue management, or complex agroforestry systems interact destructively with women’s severe time poverty, which is heavily driven by an unequal burden of unpaid domestic care and social reproduction (Chibowa et al., 2020; Nchanji et al., 2021). Furthermore, male actors are structurally incentivized to maximize immediate commercial yields and short-term cash revenues, leaving women constrained by severe property baselines. Because technical innovation routes prioritize short-term commercial returns, extension models ignore female agronomic preferences, driving systemic technology dis-adoption among women once external project funding ends (Khoza et al., 2022; Khoza et al., 2019; Kihoro et al., 2024).
4.2 Case 2: the political economy of precarity and biosecurity in informal food markets
In parallel, informal food markets represent a critical application domain where regional food systems are sustained, yet here too gendered inequalities are deeply entrenched through structural mechanisms. In informal consumer markets, the interests of female actors, who achieve numeric dominance at 60–80% of informal food retail, clash directly with municipal authorities and formal sector competitors (Ragsdale et al., 2022; Sinyolo et al., 2022; Manyungwa-Pasani et al., 2018). While women informal traders depend on flexible, low-barrier market spaces for immediate survivalist livelihood generation, local state enforcers prioritize formal revenue extraction, city beautification mandates, and strict regulation (Cook et al., 2024). These conflicting interests demonstrate that agri-food transformations systematically favour formal, male-dominated commercial paths over informal setups.
The structural position and biosecurity conditions of women informal traders vary sharply based on the formalization of the national economy. South Africa features a highly formalized, corporate-dominated urban food retail market where massive supermarket chains marginalize small vendors. Consequently, South African women informal food vendors who primarily manage survivalist open-air vending are pushed into hyper-peripheral urban spaces (Donga et al., 2024; Sinyolo et al., 2022). Subjected to intense municipal zoning laws, aggressive policing, and arbitrary asset confiscation, these women face extreme occupational stress and operate in spatial displacement without stable public utilities. Conversely, the urban and peri-urban food landscapes of Malawi, Zambia, and Tanzania are overwhelmingly dominated by the informal economy. In these pervasive, subsistence-driven trading systems, women achieve massive numeric dominance but are constrained by a near-total absence of basic municipal infrastructure (Rice et al., 2023; Nchanji et al., 2021; Manyungwa-Pasani et al., 2018; Cook et al., 2024). In large open-air trading markets in Tanzania and Malawi, a chronic lack of running water, secure cold-storage, and sanitary waste systems forces women vendors to handle fresh produce, fish, and small livestock under high-risk biosecurity conditions. Epidemiologically, this means that while South African women face high-risk contamination due to spatial displacement and municipal neglect, women traders in Malawi, Zambia, and Tanzania face widespread pathogen exposure, foodborne pathogen outbreaks, and elevated antimicrobial resistance risks due to systemic, state-wide infrastructure deficits (Nchanji et al., 2021; Cook et al., 2024).
These structural differences are actively driven by formal institutions, such as provincial municipal councils and regional urban planning bodies, which enforce fixed business locations and punitive licensing regimes. These bureaucratic setups directly clash with the highly flexible, mobile livelihood strategies women traders use to manage risk and balance commercial activities with unpaid domestic care burdens. Across this domain, seemingly neutral rules function as structural mechanisms of exclusion. Women remain constrained by severe capital asymmetries, restricted cold-chain transport networks, and market information barriers, proving that numeric dominance does not translate into economic power (Rice et al., 2023; Ragsdale et al., 2022).
Analyzing these mechanisms explains how power relations operate dynamically across macro, meso, and micro levels to reproduce inequality and trap informal actors. At the macro level, international development agendas and national policies prioritize formal, large-scale commercialization over informal food distribution channels. These structural vulnerabilities were intensely magnified during the COVID-19 pandemic, during which emergency public health restrictions dismantled informal food chains and wiped out women’s incomes while formal, corporate food systems were granted state protection and operational continuity (Donga et al., 2024; Nchanji et al., 2021). At the meso level, municipal enforcement bodies become instruments of governance-driven exclusion, altering the incentives of traders by relying on arbitrary policing, asset confiscation, and informal regulatory rents to extract value from marginalized women. When situated within broader global debates, these regional patterns directly advance the scholarship of Feminist Political Ecology (FPE) by demonstrating how environmental degradation and resource control are fundamentally gendered processes driven by state and customary power hierarchies. Furthermore, by exposing how current market designs systematically penalize informal actors, these findings contribute a vital Southern African perspective to the global discourse on food systems justice, proving that true equity requires restructuring institutional governance rather than merely optimizing production numbers.
From a one health perspective, this political neglect and infrastructure deprivation in informal spaces co-produces dangerous biological and environmental hazards. Because municipal governments systematically underfund traditional food markets, resulting in a complete lack of clean running water, drainage, and public sanitation, women traders are forced to operate in highly unhygienic environments. This structural neglect directly causes foodborne pathogen outbreaks, compromises urban consumer food safety, and accelerates antimicrobial resistance (AMR) risks as untreated animal agricultural inputs enter poorly managed communal waste spaces. The syndemic loop closes through intra-household resource and consumption dynamics; because women are denied control over livestock and market revenues, female-headed and resource-poor households across the target countries consistently exhibit lower dietary diversity scores and higher nutritional precarity (Khoza et al., 2019; Mohammed et al., 2025). Isolated technical fixes cannot disrupt these deeply resilient inequality traps; sustainable food system transformation across Southern Africa depends on an operational One Health model that treats gender equality and structural political-economic reform as non-negotiable, foundational requirements for human, animal, and environmental biosecurity.
4.2.1 Actors and Interests
Agri-food systems in the region are contested spaces driven by competing, gendered actor interests across both agricultural production and informal markets. In agricultural systems, primary actors include male and female smallholders, corporate input suppliers, and state officials. While resource-constrained female smallholders prioritize long-term household consumption stability, crop trait diversity, and dietary resilience, dominant corporate and state actors favour commercialized, high-input value chains (Zimba et al., 2023; Aberman et al., 2020). This divergence regularly triggers a masculine re-appropriation of value chains once they transition from low-return subsistence lines to high-value cash markets. In Malawi and Zambia, as legume or specialized crop value chains become profitable through state input subsidies or external market integration, control over production assets, income allocation, and land use shifts away from women to male household members (Ng’ombe et al., 2024; Mphande et al., 2022).
Similarly, in informal consumer markets, the interests of female traders who achieve numeric dominance at 60–80% of informal food retail clash directly with municipal authorities and formal sector competitors (Ragsdale et al., 2022; Sinyolo et al., 2022; Manyungwa-Pasani et al., 2018). While women informal traders depend on flexible, low-barrier market spaces for immediate survivalist livelihood generation, local state enforcers prioritize formal revenue extraction, city beautification mandates, and strict regulation (Cook et al., 2024). These conflicting interests demonstrate that agri-food transformations systematically favour formal, male-dominated commercial paths over informal setups.
4.2.2 Institutions and rules
The distribution of resources within Southern African food systems is governed by interlocking formal and informal institutions that encode gender bias into daily operations. In agricultural production, formal institutions like state-subsidized input programs systematically disadvantage women through rigid co-financing mandates. Simultaneously, formal agricultural transformation models fail to account for the asymmetric institutional baselines of customary land governance. Across the target countries, even where matrilocal or communal customary setups exist, structural land tenure security remains heavily dominated by patriarchal lineage norms and marital asset control (Kerr et al., 2019; Mgalamadzi et al., 2024).
This institutional friction creates a persistent inequality trap: women are excluded from formal credit channels because commercial banks enforce collateral requirements tied to formal land documentation, assets women cannot structurally acquire (Makate et al., 2019). These dynamics are mirrored in the informal market domain, where formal municipal laws enforce fixed business locations and punitive licensing regimes. These bureaucratic setups directly clash with the highly flexible, mobile livelihood strategies women traders use to manage risk and balance commercial activities with unpaid domestic care burdens. Across both domains, seemingly neutral rules function as structural mechanisms of exclusion.
4.2.3 Incentives and constraints
The political economy of regional food systems creates starkly divergent incentive structures and operational constraints for male and female actors. Macro-level and cross-country quantitative evidence demonstrates that women possess strong latent agency to actively enhance the likelihood of Climate-Smart Agriculture (CSA) adoption, serving as primary drivers of sustainable practices due to their long-term focus on household risk mitigation (Perelli et al., 2024). However, this adaptive capacity is frequently bottlenecked by localized, meso-level institutional failures. When micro-level household dynamics and community property regimes are highly unequal, women are forced into non-adoption or active dis-adoption (Khoza et al., 2022).
This occurs because labour-intensive conservation techniques such as manual pitting, residue management, or complex agroforestry systems interact destructively with women’s structural time poverty, which is heavily driven by an unequal burden of unpaid domestic care and social reproduction (Chibowa et al., 2020; Nchanji et al., 2021). Furthermore, male actors are structurally incentivized to maximize immediate commercial yields and short-term cash revenues, while female actors remain constrained by severe capital asymmetries, restricted cold-chain transport networks, and market information barriers (Rice et al., 2023; Ragsdale et al., 2022). These systems persist because regional policy designs and technical extension routes ignore localized household labour burdens and unequal property baselines, treating resource access as an individual capacity deficit rather than an institutional power lock-in (Mabaleka et al., 2025; Naicker and Molapo, 2022; Kihoro et al., 2024).
4.2.4 Power relations
Power operates dynamically across macro, meso, and micro levels to reproduce gendered inequality across both case domains, directly shaping broader theoretical debates. At the macro level, international development agendas and national policies prioritize formal, large-scale commercialization over informal food distribution channels. These structural vulnerabilities were intensely magnified during the COVID-19 pandemic, during which emergency public health restrictions dismantled informal food chains and wiped out women’s incomes while formal, corporate food systems were granted state protection and operational continuity (Donga et al., 2024; Nchanji et al., 2021). At the meso level, provincial municipal councils and regional enforcement bodies become instruments of governance-driven exclusion, relying on arbitrary policing, asset confiscation, and informal regulatory rents to extract value from marginalized women.
When situated within broader global debates, these regional patterns directly advance the scholarship of Feminist Political Ecology (FPE) by demonstrating how environmental degradation and resource control are fundamentally gendered processes driven by state and customary power hierarchies. Furthermore, by exposing how current market designs systematically penalize informal actors, these findings contribute a vital Southern African perspective to the global discourse on food systems justice, proving that true equity requires restructuring institutional governance rather than merely optimizing production numbers.
4.2.5 One health outcomes
When viewed through a one health lens, these political-economic and institutional barriers translate into a tightly bound human-animal-environmental syndemic where socio-economic exclusion directly shapes biological and ecological vulnerabilities. Animal health and biosecurity are systematically compromised by gendered resource gaps; women’s heavy involvement in smallholder livestock systems, small-scale poultry rearing, and artisanal aquaculture is severely bottlenecked by a lack of access to veterinary extension, diagnostic networks, and animal vaccines (Ragsdale et al., 2022; Mphande et al., 2022). Because meso-level veterinary services systematically prioritize commercial, male-dominated larger herds, localized small livestock mortality rates escalate, worsening zoonotic disease spillovers and expanding animal health risks at the community level.
Simultaneously, environmental and ecosystem health is degraded through a clear institutional pathway: structural land tenure insecurity strips women of the long-term economic incentives required to invest in agroecological land repairs, soil fertility management, or catchment biodiversity protection. Consequently, these gendered constraints accelerate local deforestation, topsoil erosion, and biodiversity loss, demonstrating that patriarchal resource distribution actively drives negative environmental and epidemiological outcomes.
Therefore, by analyzing Southern African food systems through an integrated gendered PEA and one health lens, this review demonstrates that human, animal, and environmental health outcomes are fundamentally mediated by political economy structures. Traditional One Health approaches, including prominent global strategies (FAO et al., 2022), often adopt a gender-blind framework that reduces animal disease vectors or environmental degradation to technical or ecological variables. However, our findings show that biosecurity failures, such as uncontrolled zoonotic vectors in smallholder livestock systems or pathogen proliferation in informal markets, are structural symptoms of gendered resource exclusion. When institutional architectures deny women secure land tenure or veterinary extension, they cripple the very actors responsible for daily environmental stewardship and animal care. Thus, sustainable food system transformation cannot be achieved through technical or biomedical interventions alone; it requires dismantling the gendered power dynamics that govern resource distribution across the entire one health interface.
4.3 Comparative political economy and regional one health variations
While the evidence base reflects an uneven regional distribution, drawing primarily on extensive smallholder datasets from Malawi and Zambia, with supplementary evidence from Tanzania and South Africa, a cross-contextual analysis reveals how distinct national political economies alter gendered exclusion and one health outcomes.
4.3.1 Customary land tenure and agricultural resource gaps (Malawi, Zambia, and Tanzania vs. South Africa)
Agrarian landscapes across Malawi, Zambia, and Tanzania are heavily dictated by customary land arrangements. In these contexts, despite pockets of matrilineal tradition in regions like Malawi, women predominantly secure access to arable land through intra-household negotiations or patrilocal customary lineage rules rather than formal, independent ownership (Djurfeldt et al., 2019; Mphande et al., 2022).
Similarly, in Tanzania, while the formal Village Land Act legally provides for equal land access, localized customary governance mechanisms frequently bypass these protections, restricting female smallholders from holding primary ownership titles (Djurfeldt et al., 2019). This tenure insecurity creates a direct domino effect: without formal land documentation as collateral, women smallholders across Malawi, Zambia, and Tanzania are locked out of commercial credit channels. This systemic lack of capital directly curtails long-term investments in agroecological land repairs, soil fertility management, and protected water-catchment infrastructure, accelerating regional deforestation and topsoil erosion (Djurfeldt et al., 2019; Kerr et al., 2019).
Conversely, South Africa’s agrarian structure is shaped by the legalistic legacies of large-scale, formal commercialization and communal frameworks. Here, women face exclusion through highly institutionalized land distribution systems that historically prioritized male heads of households (Mabaleka et al., 2025; Naicker and Molapo, 2022).In all four contexts, this gendered resource exclusion restricts a woman’s ability to secure veterinary extension or inputs. This lack of access directly limits poultry vaccinations in Tanzania and restricts access to cattle-dipping infrastructure in South Africa, multiplying community-level livestock mortalities and zoonotic disease vectors across the landscapes (Ragsdale et al., 2022; Mphande et al., 2022).
4.3.2 Informal market structure and municipal governance (South Africa vs. Malawi, Zambia, and Tanzania)
The structural position and biosecurity conditions of women informal traders vary sharply based on the formalization of the national economy. South Africa features a highly formalized, corporate-dominated urban food retail market where massive supermarket chains marginalize small vendors.
Consequently, South African women informal food vendors who primarily manage survivalist open-air vending are pushed into hyper-peripheral urban spaces (Donga et al., 2024; Sinyolo et al., 2022). Subjected to intense municipal zoning laws, aggressive policing, and arbitrary asset confiscation, these women face extreme occupational stress and operate in spatial displacement without stable public utilities (Cook et al., 2024).
Conversely, the urban and peri-urban food landscapes of Malawi, Zambia, and Tanzania are overwhelmingly dominated by the informal economy. In these pervasive, subsistence-driven trading systems, women achieve massive numeric dominance (constituting 60–80% of informal food traders) but are constrained by a near-total absence of basic municipal infrastructure (Rice et al., 2023; Nchanji et al., 2021; Manyungwa-Pasani et al., 2018; Cook et al., 2024). In large open-air trading markets in Tanzania and Malawi, a chronic lack of running water, secure cold-storage, and sanitary waste systems forces women vendors to handle fresh produce, fish, and small livestock under high-risk biosecurity conditions. Epidemiologically, this means that while South African women face high-risk contamination due to spatial displacement and municipal neglect, women traders in Malawi, Zambia, and Tanzania face widespread pathogen exposure, foodborne pathogen outbreaks, and elevated antimicrobial resistance risks due to systemic, state-wide infrastructure deficits (Nchanji et al., 2021; Cook et al., 2024).
4.4 Study limitations
Several limitations should be noted. First, the analysis synthesizes existing empirical research published in English only rather than generating new primary data, limiting the authors’ ability to explore certain questions in depth or examine recent developments.
Second, while this review focuses on Malawi, Zambia, Tanzania and South Africa, patterns may differ in other Southern African contexts with different political economies, agricultural systems and gender regimes.
Third, the analysis focuses primarily on gender while acknowledging that gender intersects with other axes of social differentiation (class, age, ethnicity, location); a more detailed intersectional analysis would enrich the understanding of diverse experiences.
Fourth, the available literature has uneven coverage, with more research on agricultural production than on informal markets and more on constraints than on women’s agency and resistance strategies.
Finally, the review’s one health analysis is limited by the fact that much existing research does not explicitly adopt One Health frameworks, requiring the authors to infer health-agriculture-environment interconnections from available evidence.
5 Policy recommendations
To move past isolated interventions, regional policymakers must abandon the assumption that technology adoption is purely neutral, technical choice. Mirroring the structural critiques of Shilombeni (Shilomboleni, 2020), this systematic review confirms that meaningful agricultural and climate resilience requires shifting the policy focus from mere input supply networks to deep institutional reforms that protect the land tenure rights and labour flexibility of resource-constrained smallholders. Policy frameworks must be deliberately restricted to align with the strategic motivations of marginalized actors across the one health interface.
In addition, transforming food systems toward greater equity and sustainability requires moving beyond symptomatic interventions to address the structural drivers of gender inequality that underpin differential access to resources, opportunities, and decision-making power. The evidence synthesized in this review shows that gender disparities are embedded within governance systems, institutional arrangements, and market structures, and therefore require coordinated, system-level policy responses.
A priority lies in strengthening women’s participation in governance across multiple levels, including households, community institutions, producer organizations, and policy platforms. Persistent underrepresentation of women in decision-making spaces contributes to policies and interventions that inadequately reflect their needs and priorities. Addressing this gap requires a combination of affirmative action measures, such as gender quotas, alongside investments in leadership capacity and institutional reforms that challenge discriminatory norms and practices. Equally important is the recognition of women’s time constraints, necessitating more inclusive approaches to participation that account for care responsibilities and mobility limitations. Supporting women’s collective organization, including cooperatives and savings groups, further enhances their capacity for collective voice and influence within food systems.
Second, the redesign of agricultural extension systems is critical to ensuring equitable access to knowledge and innovation. The literature consistently demonstrates that conventional extension approaches fail to reach women effectively due to gender biases in targeting, delivery mechanisms, and content. Gender-responsive extension systems should therefore incorporate diversified delivery channels, promote the recruitment of female extension agents, and develop content that reflects women’s priorities, including post-harvest management, nutrition, and labour-saving technologies. Importantly, adopting a household-level approach that engages both men and women can help address intra-household power dynamics that shape technology adoption and resource allocation.
Third, supporting women-led food enterprises represents a key pathway for enhancing both livelihoods and food system resilience. Women’s concentration in small-scale and informal enterprises reflects structural barriers to formal employment but also presents opportunities for inclusive economic development. Policy interventions should prioritize improving access to finance through tailored financial products, strengthening business development services, and facilitating market access through infrastructure investments and information systems. Enhancing women’s participation in higher-value segments of food value chains is particularly important for shifting from subsistence-oriented activities to more profitable and sustainable enterprises.
Regulatory reform of informal food markets is another critical area for intervention. Current regulatory frameworks often marginalize informal traders, many of whom are women, through exclusionary licensing systems and punitive enforcement practices. A shift toward more inclusive and enabling regulatory approaches is needed, including flexible licensing arrangements, investment in basic market infrastructure, and supportive compliance mechanisms. Integrating informal traders into participatory governance structures can further enhance accountability and ensure that regulatory systems are responsive to the realities of informal market actors. Expanding access to social protection mechanisms is also essential for reducing vulnerability within this sector.
The generation of robust, sex-disaggregated data is fundamental to informing evidence-based policy. Existing data systems frequently obscure gendered patterns by focusing on household-level indicators or failing to capture informal sector dynamics. Strengthening data systems to include intra-household dynamics, informal economic activities, and intersectional dimensions of inequality is essential for designing targeted and effective interventions. Participatory approaches to data generation can further enhance the relevance and accuracy of information, particularly in contexts where women’s contributions are underreported.
Finally, the integration of gender-responsive approaches within One Health frameworks is essential for addressing the interconnected challenges of food systems, public health, and environmental sustainability. The review shows that gender shapes exposure to health risks, access to resources, and adaptive capacity across these domains. As such, policies must promote greater coordination across agriculture, health, and environmental sectors while explicitly incorporating gender analysis. This includes advancing nutrition-sensitive agriculture, strengthening inclusive food safety systems, and addressing climate-health linkages through gender-responsive climate adaptation strategies.
6 Conclusion
This review demonstrates that gender inequalities in food systems across Southern Africa are not incidental or sector-specific challenges, but are deeply embedded within broader political, institutional, and socio-economic structures. By integrating a gendered political economy lens with One Health principles, the analysis moves beyond surface-level explanations of gender gaps to uncover the structural mechanisms through which power relations, institutional arrangements, and actor incentives shape food system outcomes. The evidence clearly shows that women’s constrained access to resources, decision-making spaces, and market opportunities systematically limits their participation in and benefits from agricultural and food systems, with cascading implications for nutrition, health, and environmental sustainability. These findings show that technical solutions alone, whether in the form of improved technologies or market interventions, are insufficient without addressing the underlying inequities that determine who can access and utilize such innovations. Policymakers must recognize that gender-neutral interventions often fail to address underlying structural inequalities and may unintentionally reinforce them by overlaying new resources onto fundamentally skewed baselines.
A central contribution of this study is its demonstration that gendered inequalities have far-reaching implications across interconnected One Health domains, affecting not only agricultural productivity but also dietary outcomes, exposure to health risks, and ecosystem resilience. Addressing these challenges therefore requires a fundamental reorientation of policy and practice toward structural transformation. This includes strengthening inclusive governance, redesigning extension and service delivery systems, supporting women’s economic participation across value chains, and reforming regulatory environments to better accommodate informal actors. Equally critical is the need to generate more nuanced and disaggregated data to inform policy and to adopt integrated, gender-responsive one health approaches that recognize the interdependence of human, animal, and environmental health.
Ultimately, building resilient and equitable food systems in Southern Africa will depend on the extent to which policies and interventions confront, rather than accommodate, entrenched power imbalances. The disruptions exposed by recent global crises highlight both the urgency and the opportunity for transformative change. Advancing gender equity within food systems is not only a matter of social justice but a strategic imperative for achieving sustainable development, food and nutrition security, and long-term resilience in the region.
Statements
Author contributions
EN: Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Methodology, Validation, Visualization, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing. MC: Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Methodology, Validation, Writing – review & editing. WK: Supervision, Writing – review & editing. LM: Supervision, Writing – review & editing. YM: Supervision, Writing – review & editing.
Funding
The author(s) declared that financial support was not received for this work and/or its publication.
Acknowledgments
We would like to acknowledge the technical support and mentorship we received from all the research supervisors involved in this work. Special recognition goes to the Department of Food Science and Technology at the Lilongwe University of Agriculture and Natural Resources, where the first and second authors are hosted as PhD students. We also gratefully acknowledge the reviewers for their constructive and insightful feedback, which contributed to improving the clarity, rigour, and overall quality of the manuscript.
Conflict of interest
The author(s) declared that this work was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
Generative AI statement
The author(s) declared that Generative AI was not used in the creation of this manuscript.
Any alternative text (alt text) provided alongside figures in this article has been generated by Frontiers with the support of artificial intelligence and reasonable efforts have been made to ensure accuracy, including review by the authors wherever possible. If you identify any issues, please contact us.
Publisher’s note
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.
References
1
AbermanN. L.MeermanJ.BensonT. (2020). To sell or consume? Gendered household decision-making on crop production, consumption, and sale in Malawi. Food Secur.12, 433–449. doi: 10.1007/S12571-020-01021-2
2
ChabweraA.MadhlopaY. (2025). Gender analysis of the Orange fleshed sweet potato value chain in Malawi: a systematic review. F1000Res14:46. doi: 10.12688/f1000research.165846.1
3
ChibowaS.MsiskaM.JumbeC. (2020). “Gender Differentiation in the Adoption of Climate Smart Agriculture Technologies and Level of Adaptive Capacity to Climate Change in Malawi,” in Climate Change and Agriculture, eds. SinghB.SafalaohA.AmuriN.EikL.SitaulaB.LalR. (Berlin: Springer), 429–445.
4
CookH. L.WamukotaA.WanjohiM.MwangiM.GriffithsJ. K.WebbP. (2024). Nutritional, economic, social, and governance implications of traditional food markets for vulnerable populations in sub-Saharan Africa: a systematic narrative review. Front. Sustain. Food Syst.8:1382383. doi: 10.3389/fsufs.2024.1382383
5
DjurfeldtA. A.DjurfeldtG.LodinJ. B. (2019). Agricultural intensification and gender in Malawi, Tanzania and Zambia.
6
DongaM.NyamwanzaT.ChariF. (2024). Challenges and opportunities of the COVID-19 pandemic on women entrepreneurs operating in the informal food sector: a post COVID-19 analyses. Int. J. Res. Bus. Soc. Sci.13, 456–467. doi: 10.20525/ijrbs.v13i2.3168
7
FAO (2022). One Health Joint Plan of Action (2022–2026). Working Together for the Health of Humans, Animals, Plants and the Environment. Rome: FAO.
8
KerrR. B.HickeyC.LupafyaE.DakishoniL. (2019). Repairing rifts or reproducing inequalities? Agroecology, food sovereignty, and gender justice in Malawi. J. Peasant Stud.46, 1499–1518. doi: 10.1080/03066150.2018.1547897
9
KhozaS.SenyoloG. M.MmbengwaV. M.SoundyP. (2019). Understanding gender dimensions of climate-smart agriculture adoption in disaster-prone smallholder farming communities in Malawi and Zambia. Disaster Prev Manag28, 805–820. doi: 10.1108/DPM-10-2018-0347
10
KhozaS.SenyoloG. M.MmbengwaV. M.SoundyP. (2022). Gendered vulnerability and inequality: understanding drivers of climate-smart agriculture dis-and nonadoption among smallholder farmers in Malawi and Zambia. Ecol. Soc.27:19. doi: 10.5751/ES-13480-270419
11
KihoroE.MwangiV.RaoN.MuteaE. (2024). Uncovering the intersections of women's empowerment and gender equality in climate adaptive capacities in climate hotspots for women in Zambia. J. Asian Afr. Stud.59:1300450. doi: 10.1177/00219096241300450
12
KumarN.NguyenP. H.HarrisJ.HarveyD.RawatR.RuelM. T. (2018). What it Takes: Evidence from a Nutrition-and Gender-Sensitive Agriculture Intervention in Rural Zambia.
13
MabalekaM. B.AgholorA. I.ObiA. (2025). Perceptions and adaptation strategies to climate change among small-scale farmers in Mangolong Village, Eastern Cape, South Africa. iRASD J. Energy Environ.6, 59–70. doi: 10.52131/jee.2025.0601.0059
14
MakateC.MakateM.MangoN.SizibaS. (2019). Synergistic impacts of agricultural credit and extension on adoption of climate-smart agricultural technologies in southern Africa. Environ. Dev.32:100458. doi: 10.1016/J.ENVDEV.2019.100458
15
Manyungwa-PasaniC. L.KaundaE.HüskenS. M. C. (2018). Replication Data for: An Investigation of Women Participation in Fish Value Chains and Value Chain Governance in Malawi: A Case of Msaka on Lake Malawi and Kachulu on Lake Chilwa Harvard Dataverse.
16
MgalamadziL. N.MangisoniJ. H.KambewaP. S.AuneJ. B. (2021). Understanding Gender and Social Differentiation in the Context of Agricultural Commercialisation and Implications for Livelihoods in Rural Malawi. APRA Working Paper, No. 56.
17
MgalamadziL. N.MangisoniJ. H.KambewaP. S.AuneJ. B. (2024). The gendered nature of household decision making and expenditure choices in the context of smallholder agricultural commercialization in Malawi. CABI Agric. Biosci.5:270. doi: 10.1186/s43170-024-00270-x
18
MohammedK.BatungE.KansangaM.Nyantakyi-FrimpongH.LuginaahI. (2025). Women’s roles in decision-making and nutrition-sensitive agriculture. Food Secur.17, 1–18. doi: 10.1007/s12571-025-01553-5
19
MorganM.MalapitH.PereiraA.GalièA.QuisumbingA. R. (2019). Making Market Systems Work for Women Farmers in Zambia: A Final Evaluation of Oxfam's Gendered Enterprise and Markets Programme in the Copperbelt Region of Zambia.
20
MphandeF. A.TemboD.KuntashulaE. (2022). Gender and legume production in a changing climate context: experiences from Chipata, eastern Zambia. Sustainability14:11901. doi: 10.3390/su141911901
21
NaickerL.MolapoS. (2022). A socially-engaged theological response to the historic and structural nature of food insecurity in South Africa. Stud. Hist. Eccl.48, 1–18. doi: 10.25159/2412-4265/10656
22
NchanjiY. K.NkenglaL. W.MalaW. A.LevangP. (2022). Gender differences in climate-smart adaptation practices amongst bean-producing farmers in Malawi: the case of Linthipe extension planning area. Front. Sustain. Food Syst.6:1001152. doi: 10.3389/fsufs.2022.1001152
23
NchanjiY. K.NkenglaL. W.OchiengJ.MalaW. A.KamauG.OnyangoC.et al. (2021). COVID-19 challenges to sustainable food production and consumption: future lessons for food systems in eastern and southern Africa from a gender lens. Sustainable Prod. Consumption27, 2208–2220. doi: 10.1016/J.SPC.2021.05.016,
24
Ng’ombeJ. N.KalindaT. H.TemboG. (2024). Nutrition for all? Input subsidies and equitable diets. Rev. Dev. Econ.29, 1024–1057. doi: 10.1111/rode.13157,
25
PerelliC.CacchiarelliL.PeveriV.BrancaG. (2024). Gender equality and sustainable development: a cross-country study on women's contribution to the adoption of climate-smart agriculture in sub-Saharan Africa. Ecol. Econ.219:108145. doi: 10.1016/j.ecolecon.2024.108145
26
RagsdaleK. A.KeenanR. J.LauJ. D.MangubhaiS.KleiberD.ManlosaA. O.et al. (2022). Adapting the WEAI to explore gender equity among fishers, processors, and sellers at Zambia's Lake Bangweulu. World Dev.151:105821. doi: 10.1016/j.worlddev.2022.105821
27
RiceJ. C.DiedrichA.Budzich-TaborU.DawT. M.HicksC. C.BeaumontN.et al. (2023). Connecting gender norms and economic performance reveals gendered inequities in Malawian small-scale fish trade. Marit. Stud.22, 1–15. doi: 10.1007/s40152-023-00337-x
28
SachsC. E. (2019). Gender, Agriculture and Agrarian Transformations. In: Routledge Handbook of Gender and Agriculture. Abingdon: Routledge, pp. 1–18.
29
ShilomboleniH. (2020). Political economy challenges for climate-smart agriculture in Africa. Agric. Hum. Values37, 1195–1206. doi: 10.1007/s10460-020-10126-5
30
SinyoloS.NdindaC.MurendoC. (2022). Women informal food traders during COVID-19: a south African case study. Agenda36, 63–76. doi: 10.1080/10130950.2022.2082119,
31
WhitfieldS. (2016). Adapting to Climate Uncertainty in African Agriculture: Narratives and Knowledge Politics. Abingdon, UK: Routledge.
32
ZimbaN.CrespoO.HauserM.MwadzingeniL. (2023). Gender differential in choices of crop variety traits and climate-smart cropping systems: insights from sorghum and millet farmers in drought-prone areas of Malawi. Plants People Planet5, 467–481. doi: 10.1002/ppp3.10467
Summary
Keywords
food systems, gender dynamics, informal market, one health, political economy, Southern Africa
Citation
Namaona EM, Chabwera M, Kasapila W, Mgalamadzi L and Madhlopa Y (2026) Food system transformation, social equity and one health in Southern Africa: a gendered political economy analysis. Front. Sustain. Food Syst. 10:1904937. doi: 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1904937
Received
09 June 2026
Revised
31 August 2026
Accepted
10 September 2026
Published
18 September 2026
Volume
10 - 2026
Edited by
Stephen Whitfield, University of Leeds, United Kingdom
Reviewed by
Rika Reviza Rachmawati, National Research and Innovation Agency, Indonesia
Prince Kwadwo Amoako, Ghana Cocoa Board, Ghana
Updates
Copyright
© 2026 Namaona, Chabwera, Kasapila, Mgalamadzi and Madhlopa.
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
*Correspondence: Elizabeth Mnenula Namaona, elizamnenula@gmail.com Yananda Madhlopa, ymadhlopa@luanar.ac.mw
Disclaimer
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.