Abstract
Background:
Weed management in transplanted rice requires effective herbicide delivery while improving input-use efficiency and reducing reliance on conventional application practices. This study developed and evaluated a biodegradable gelatin capsule-based herbicide delivery system, subsequently protected through a design patent, as an alternative approach for herbicide application.
Methods:
A two-phase study comprising preliminary screening and field validation was conducted using Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl, Butachlor, Bensulfuron methyl + Pretilachlor, and Triafamone + Ethoxysulfuron at different formulation rates. Selected capsule treatments were subsequently compared directly with corresponding conventional applications for weed suppression, crop growth, yield and economic performance. Temporal weed-control performance was quantified using the area under the weed control efficiency curve (AUWCEC) and area under the weed dry weight curve (AUWDWC), together with economic-threshold analysis. The response of culturable soil microbial populations to empty capsule placement was also assessed.
Results:
Field performance varied with herbicide formulation and capsule rate, with the strongest response observed for Bensulfuron methyl + Pretilachlor. At the recommended 100% formulation rate, capsule delivery increased AUWCEC by 16.9% and reduced AUWDWC by 28.7% relative to the corresponding conventional application. The 100% capsule treatment maintained higher weed control efficiency than conventional spraying of the same herbicide combination at 15, 30 and 45 DAT (86.9, 68.7 and 68.3% vs. 81.3, 57.6 and 53.9%, respectively), and increased grain yield by 14.9% (5,463 vs. 4,755 kg ha−1). Although the 150% capsule treatment recorded numerically higher weed control efficiency (87.6%) and grain yield (5,710 kg ha−1), its yield was statistically comparable with the 100% treatment, which achieved the highest benefit:cost ratio (2.42). Overall, the 100% capsule treatment provided the most favorable balance of weed suppression, crop productivity and economic return. Empty-capsule placement was associated with increased culturable bacterial, fungal and actinomycete populations.
Conclusion:
Optimized gelatin capsule-mediated herbicide delivery strengthened weed suppression and crop performance, with the 100% Bensulfuron methyl + Pretilachlor treatment providing effective control, comparable grain yield and the highest economic efficiency relative to conventional application. The findings demonstrate the potential of targeted biodegradable herbicide delivery for improving input-use efficiency and supporting sustainable rice production.
1 Introduction
Weed interference is a major constraint to rice productivity because it reduces crop growth, yield formation, and resource-use efficiency, particularly during the early stages of crop establishment (Paul et al., 2025). Rice (Oryza sativa L.) is a major staple crop in South and Southeast Asia, with around 60% of the global population consuming rice. India is the world’s second-largest rice producer, cultivating approximately 47 million ha and producing about 132 million tonnes of rice annually, accounting for approximately 20% of global rice production (Sellaperumal et al., 2025). India is also the world’s largest rice exporter, with a global market share exceeding 40% in 2022 (Nayak et al., 2024). Effective weed management during the critical stages of crop growth is therefore essential to minimize crop-weed competition and sustain productivity (Anisha et al., 2022). Transplanted rice supports a diverse weed flora comprising grasses, sedges, and broad-leaved species. Among the major grass and sedge weeds, Echinochloa crus-galli, E. colona, Cyperus difformis, C. iria, and C. rotundus are frequently reported from transplanted-rice systems (Arthanari et al., 2017), while Eclipta alba, Ammania baccifera, and other broad-leaved weeds may also contribute substantially to weed competition (Yakadri et al., 2022). In southern India, a phytosociological survey of rice fields identified Cyperus difformis and Echinochloa colona as particularly prevalent species, followed by C. rotundus, E. crus-galli, Leptochloa chinensis, Eclipta alba, and Sphenoclea zeylanica (Sai et al., 2022). The occurrence of diverse weed groups with different emergence patterns makes timely (Driver et al., 2024) and effective weed management essential in transplanted rice (Shah et al., 2025).
Herbicides remain an important component of integrated weed management in rice because of their effectiveness and practicality under labor-constrained production systems (Kumar et al., 2023). However, increasing labor constraints in agricultural production can limit the timely implementation of manual and chemical weed-management practices, particularly during critical periods of crop growth (Arthanari, 2023). Although conventional herbicide spraying is widely used for weed management, it can be associated with herbicide drift and wastage during application, which may reduce application efficiency and increase the potential for off-target exposure (Vijayakumar et al., 2023; Mir et al., 2024). Following spray application, a proportion of herbicides may move away from the intended target through spray drift or downward movement into the soil profile, potentially affecting non-target organisms and increasing the risk of environmental contamination (Travlou et al., 2024). Improper selection and operation of herbicide application equipment, including unsuitable nozzles and spray volumes, can result in suboptimal spray delivery and reduced herbicide efficacy in rice (Hundal and Bhullar, 2023). These limitations highlight the need for alternative herbicide-delivery approaches that can improve placement of the active ingredient, minimize unnecessary losses, and provide more localized delivery within the crop environment.
To address these application constraints, we developed a biodegradable gelatin capsule-mediated approach for localized herbicide delivery in transplanted rice. To address these application constraints, we developed a biodegradable gelatin capsule-mediated approach for localized herbicide delivery in transplanted rice. The capsule physically confines the powdered herbicide during application and enables direct placement of the formulation within the crop soil environment, thereby reducing dependence on spray-based dispersion. Upon contact with moist soil, the gelatin shell progressively disintegrates and releases the herbicide formulation at the placement site, providing a localized delivery pathway. Gelatin-based formulations have previously been explored for agricultural chemical delivery; for example, Yan et al. (2012) demonstrated that a chloropicrin gelatin-capsule formulation provided effective soilborne disease suppression with partial weed control in greenhouse strawberry. In particular, comparative evidence on capsule-mediated delivery versus conventional herbicide application, across formulation rates and in terms of weed suppression, crop productivity and economic performance, remains limited in rice cropping environment. Previous research has also reported positive effects of gelatin-based treatments on plant growth and nitrogen accumulation (Wilson et al., 2018), indicating that gelatin-based formulations may have agronomic effects beyond their function as a carrier. Beyond weed-control efficacy, innovations in herbicide delivery may have broader implications for crop productivity, input-use efficiency, and soil biological responses. In this study, herbicide efficacy refers to the weed-suppression and crop-response outcomes achieved through gelatin capsule-mediated herbicide delivery. In addition, economic-threshold analysis was used to estimate the weed infestation level associated with economically justified weed control, considering herbicide effectiveness, weed-control costs and crop value, as well as the relationship between crop yield and weed dry weight. Hence, we hypothesized that localized delivery of herbicides through biodegradable gelatin capsules would provide more sustained weed suppression and improve rice growth, grain yield, and economic returns compared with conventional spraying of the same herbicide formulation, while achieving effective weed control at the recommended rate.
Accordingly, this study evaluated biodegradable gelatin capsule-mediated herbicide delivery as an alternative approach for weed management in transplanted rice. Specifically, the study aimed to: (i) identify effective herbicide formulations and application rates for capsule-mediated weed suppression through preliminary screening; (ii) evaluate the comparative and temporal effectiveness of gelatin capsule-mediated herbicide delivery against conventional application in terms of weed suppression and herbicide performance; and (iii) determine the effects of capsule-mediated herbicide delivery on rice growth, yield, and economic performance, including the economic threshold for weed management.
2 Materials and methods
The gelatin capsule delivery system evaluated in this study was developed specifically for targeted herbicide application in agricultural crops. The physical capsule design is registered with the Indian Patent Office as Design No. 432328–001, “Herbicide Delivery Capsule for Agricultural Crops” (Arthanari and Sabarivasan, 2024). The associated herbicide-delivery method is disclosed in Indian Patent Application No. 20241103293 A, titled “A Method for Delivering Herbicides Using Biodegradable Gelatin Capsules for Targeted Application” (Arthanari et al., 2025). The capsule shell was composed of gelatin and water. The capsules were approximately 2 cm in dimension, with a filling capacity of 1.5 g. Herbicide formulations were used in both granular and powder forms and manually filled into the capsules according to the respective treatment requirements. In a preliminary soil-placement test, the gelatin shell progressively disintegrated following contact with moist soil, followed by release of the filled herbicide formulation into the surrounding soil. The capsule system was subsequently evaluated under field conditions for its effects on weed suppression, crop growth, productivity and economic performance.
2.1 Preliminary pot experiment and treatment screening
A preliminary pot experiment was conducted primarily to screen the weed-suppression efficacy of selected herbicide formulations in capsule and application rates and to identify promising treatments for subsequent field evaluation in transplanted rice. The experiment was conducted in cylindrical pots measuring 11 cm in diameter and 10.8 cm in height, each containing 600 g of soil collected from the experimental field where the subsequent field experiment was conducted. Twelve-day-old CO 55 seedlings were transplanted at two seedlings per planting position, with three planting positions maintained per pot. Rice plants were included in the pot experiment to provide a field-relevant crop-weed environment for herbicide screening and to facilitate selection of treatments for subsequent field evaluation; the pot experiment was not intended to evaluate rice growth or yield responses or to establish a standardized dose–response relationship for a particular weed species. No weed seeds were artificially added or incorporated into the pots; instead, weed emergence was allowed to occur naturally from the existing weed seed bank in the field soil. Since natural weed emergence is inherently variable, each pot was treated as an independent experimental unit and randomly assigned to treatments. Weed density was recorded separately for each pot at 10 and 20 DAT, and the observed weed population in each experimental unit was used to assess treatment efficacy. Each capsule had an approximate capacity of 1.5 g and was loaded with the respective herbicide formulation (powder) according to the treatment rate. The gelatin capsules were applied at 3 DAT, with one capsule placed in each pot for each herbicide treatment. Each capsule contained the calculated quantity of the respective herbicide formulation required to deliver the designated treatment rate to the pot. The gelatin capsules filled with herbicide formulations is illustrated in Figure 1.
Figure 1
The preliminary pot experiment was laid out in a completely randomized design (CRD) with three replications and 16 treatments comprising four herbicides, namely Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl 10% WP, Butachlor 5% GR, Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR, and Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG, each evaluated at four application rates. Each herbicide formulation was evaluated at 50%, 75%, 100%, and 150% of its recommended formulation rate. The recommended formulation rates were 150 g ha−1 for Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl 10% WP (15 g a.i. ha−1), 25 kg ha−1 for Butachlor 5% GR (1.25 kg a.i. ha−1), 10 kg ha−1 for Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR (60 + 600 g a.i. ha−1), and 222 g ha−1 for Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG (44.4 + 22.2 g a.i. ha−1). An untreated control was maintained to represent the naturally infested condition, while one additional pot was maintained under weed-free conditions as a reference for rice growth in the absence of weed competition. The selected herbicide formulations were chosen for their broad-spectrum weed-control activity against grasses, sedges, and broadleaf weeds and their established use in transplanted rice across diverse agroecological conditions. Photographic documentation of the capsule and pot experiment is provided in Supplementary Figures S1A, B.
2.1.1 Screening and treatment selection
Weed density was recorded by counting the number of weeds emerging in each pot at 10 and 20 days after transplanting (DAT). Observations were recorded for each pot across all replications and expressed as number of weeds pot−1.
Weed control efficiency (WCE) was calculated for the 16 herbicide treatments using the method proposed by Mani et al. (1973). The untreated control was used as the reference for calculating WCE.
Where,
Wpc = Weed density in the control plot.
Wpt = Weed density in the treated plot.
Percent rank analysis was performed following Al Mamun et al. (2011) to rank the 16 herbicide treatments based on their relative weed population. The untreated control and the weed-free reference pot were not included in the percent-rank calculation. Percent rank was calculated as the proportion of weed population in each herbicide-treated pot relative to the total weed population across the 16 herbicide treatments, expressed as a percentage.
Where,
N = represents the total weed population in treated plots.
Based on the preliminary trial, screened herbicides were subjected to field evaluation to evaluate the efficacy of herbicides delivered through gelatin capsules.
2.2 Soil microbial population assessment
Changes in soil microbial populations were assessed following placement of an empty gelatin capsule in the soil. The initial microbial population was assessed from soil collected before placement of the empty gelatin capsule. Following this initial assessment, an empty gelatin capsule was placed in the soil, and soil samples were collected daily thereafter up to seven days to monitor changes in culturable bacterial, fungal and actinomycete populations. Soil samples were collected at both sampling points, and culturable microbial populations were estimated using the serial dilution plate-count method. Bacterial, fungal, and actinomycete populations were enumerated using nutrient agar, Martin’s Rose Bengal agar medium (Martin, 1950), and Ken Knight’s agar medium (Knight, 1936), respectively. Microbial populations were expressed as colony-forming units (CFU) g−1 soil.
2.3 Field experiment
The seedlings were raised in the nursery during February 2024, and the field experiment was conducted at the A6 Block of the Wetland Farm, Tamil Nadu Agricultural University, Coimbatore, India (11°00′11″N, 76°55′40″E, 441.48 m above mean sea level) from March to June 2024. Weather data recorded during the cropping period by the Agro Climate Research Centre, Tamil Nadu Agricultural University, showed a mean rainfall of 39.61 mm, mean maximum and minimum temperatures of 33.6 and 23.62 °C, respectively, mean relative humidity of 62.6%, mean potential evapotranspiration of 6.13 mm day−1, and mean solar radiation of 363.73 cal cm−2 day−1. The experimental soil was clay loam in texture, with a bulk density of 1.34 g cm−3, porosity of 38.75%, soil pH of 8.10, electrical conductivity of 0.5 dS m−1, organic carbon content of 1.40%.
The experiment was laid out in a randomized complete block design (RCBD) with 14 treatments and three replications. The gross plot size was 5 m × 4 m and the net plot size was 4.2 m × 3.6 m. The treatments comprised nine gelatin capsule-mediated herbicide treatments selected from the preliminary screening study (T1-T9), three conventional herbicide spray treatments (T10-T12), a weed-free check (T13), and a weedy check (T14). The capsule-mediated treatments represented selected herbicide formulations and application ratesd identified from the preliminary screening experiment, comprising Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl 10% WP, Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR, and Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG. The conventional treatments consisted of the corresponding recommended formulation rates. Rice (Oryza sativa L.) variety CO 55, released by Tamil Nadu Agricultural University, Coimbatore, Tamil Nadu, India, was used as the test variety. It is a short-duration cultivar (110–115 days) with white, medium-slender grains, high milling (70%), and head rice recovery (65%).
The experimental field was prepared by the cage wheel and leveled with the leveling board, irrigation and drainage channels were laid down at 60 cm spacing. To support establishment of seedlings, irrigation was controlled by maintaining an approximately 2 cm water depth during the initial seven days after transplanting. Thereafter, irrigation was provided to maintain approximately 5 cm water depth, with subsequent irrigation applied after the disappearance of the previously ponded water. Irrigation ceased 15 days prior to harvest. The recommended fertilizer dose of 150:50:50 kg N:P2O5:K2O ha−1 was applied using urea, single super phosphate and muriate of potash as the respective nutrient sources. The entire phosphorus dose and one-fourth of the recommended nitrogen and potassium were applied at transplanting, and the remaining nitrogen and potassium were applied in three equal splits. No additional plant-protection measures were implemented during the experiment because no insect pests or diseases were observed in the field during the crop period.
Each capsule contained the appropriate dose of the different herbicide formulations, and was applied to the plots at 3 days after transplanting (DAT) as a pre-emergent treatment. The number of gelatin capsules required for each treatment was determined based on the formulation quantity and the maximum filling capacity of approximately 1.5 g per capsule. For the 20 m2 plot, 1 capsule was required for Pyrazosulfuron ethyl 10% WP (recommended a.i. rate: 15 g ha−1) and Triafamone 20% WG + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG (recommended a.i. rate: 66.5 g ha−1) treatments, while 7, 10, 14 and 20 capsules were required for the 50%, 75%, 100 and 150% rates of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR (recommended a.i. rate: 660 g ha−1), respectively. On this basis, the theoretical capsule requirements corresponding to the recommended formulation quantities were approximately 100, 6,667 and 148 capsules ha−1, respectively. For conventional treatments, the corresponding herbicide formulations were applied at a spray volume of 500 L ha−1 with a flat-fan nozzle on the high-volume sprayer. Photographic documentation of nursery raising, field preparation, transplanting, and the experimental field is provided in Supplementary Figure S1C.
2.3.1 Weed and herbicide response assessment
Weed density was assessed at 15, 30, and 45 days after transplanting (DAT) using four randomly selected 0.25 m2 quadrats per plot. Weeds within each quadrat were identified and classified as grasses, sedges, or broadleaf weeds, and the total number of weeds was expressed as plants m−2.
Weed biomass was collected from four randomly selected 0.25 m2 quadrats per plot at 15, 30, and 45 days after transplanting (DAT). The collected weeds were initially air-dried under sunlight and subsequently oven-dried at 80 °C until a constant weight was attained. The dry weight was expressed as g m−2.
Weed control efficiency (WCE) was calculated based on weed dry weight using the method proposed by Gautam et al. (1975) and expressed as a percentage.
Where,
Wwc = Dry weight of weeds in the untreated plot.
Wwt = Dry weight of weeds in the treated plot.
Herbicide efficiency index (HEI) was calculated according to Krishnamurty et al. (1975) to assess herbicide performance based on the relative improvement in crop yield and reduction in weed biomass compared with the untreated control.
Where,
Yield of treatment = grain yield obtained from the respective herbicide treatment.
Yield of control = grain yield obtained from the untreated control.
Weed weight in treatment = weed dry weight in the respective herbicide treatment.
Weed weight in control = weed dry weight in the untreated control.
2.3.2 Temporal integration of weed-control and weed biomass responses
To integrate the temporal response across the assessment period, the area under the weed control efficiency curve (AUWCEC) and area under the weed dry weight curve (AUWDWC) were calculated by trapezoidal numerical integration of successive observations over time, following established area-under-the-curve approaches (Simko and Piepho, 2012; Schortgen and Patton, 2024).where Yi and Yi + 1 represent the respective WCE or total weed dry-weight values at consecutive observation times, and ti and ti + 1 represent the corresponding DAT. AUWCEC was expressed as % day, with higher values indicating greater cumulative weed-suppression performance, whereas AUWDWC was expressed as g m−2 day, with lower values indicating lower cumulative weed biomass. The analysis was used to compare the temporal performance of gelatin-capsule herbicide delivery with the corresponding conventional herbicide applications.
2.3.3 Crop performance and yield
Three representative plants were randomly selected and tagged within the net plot of each treatment for recording plant biometric observations.
Plant height was recorded from the three tagged plants at 30, 60, and 90 days after transplanting (DAT) and at harvest. Plant height was measured from the ground level to the tip of the tallest leaf or panicle, as appropriate, and expressed in cm.
The total number of tillers was recorded from four randomly selected 0.25 m2 quadrats within each plot at 30, 60, and 90 days after transplanting (DAT) and at harvest. The mean number of tillers across the four quadrats was calculated and expressed as tillers m−2.
Five randomly selected hills from each plot were sampled at 30, 60, and 90 days after transplanting (DAT) and at harvest. The sampled plants, including their roots, were initially shade-dried and subsequently oven-dried at 80 °C for 72 h until a constant weight was attained. Dry matter production was calculated based on the dry weight of the sampled plants and expressed as kg ha−1.
The crop from the net plot area of each treatment was harvested manually, threshed, and cleaned separately. The grain was sun-dried to a moisture content of 14%, as recommended by Yoshida et al. (1971), and weighed. Grain yield was expressed as kg ha−1. Harvest index (HI) was calculated as the ratio of economic yield to biological yield, following Singh and Stoskopf (1971), and expressed as a proportion.
2.3.4 Economic analysis
The benefit: cost (B:C) ratio was calculated as the ratio of gross returns to the cost of cultivation for each treatment.
Economic threshold analysis was conducted using the approaches proposed by Uygur and Mennan (1995) and Stone and Pedigo (1972) to estimate the weed infestation level at which the economic loss caused by weeds becomes equivalent to the cost of weed management.
2.3.4.1 Uygur and Mennan
Where,
Y - Percentage reduction in yield due to weed infestation (%)
He - Effectiveness of the herbicide (%)
Hc - Cost of herbicide (₹ ha−1)
Ac - Cost of applying herbicide (₹ ha−1)
Gp - Market value of the crop (₹ kg−1)
Ywf - Output from the weed-free plots (kg ha−1)
2.3.4.2 Stone and Pedigo
The economic threshold was estimated according to Stone and Pedigo (1972) as follows:
Where,
The regression coefficient (b) represents the change in crop yield associated with a unit change in weed dry weight, based on the linear relationship Y = a + bx, where Y is crop yield (kg ha−1), x is weed dry weight (g m−2), a is the intercept, and b is the regression coefficient.
2.4 Statistical analysis
All statistical analyses were performed using R (v4.5) statistical software (R Core Team, 2025). The experimental data were subjected to analysis of variance (ANOVA) appropriate for a randomized complete block design (RCBD). Treatment effects were considered statistically significant at the 5% level (p 0.05). When the treatment effect was significant, treatment means were separated using Duncan’s Multiple Range Test (DMRT) at p 0.05. Means sharing the same letter were considered statistically comparable, whereas means with different letters differed significantly according to DMRT (p 0.05).
3 Results
3.1 Response of culturable soil microbial populations to empty gelatin capsule placement
The initial culturable microbial populations recorded in soil before placement of the empty gelatin capsule were 5.0 × 106, 21.3 × 103 and 12.7 × 102 CFU g−1 soil for bacteria, fungi and actinomycetes, respectively. Following capsule placement, bacterial populations increased progressively to 11.0 × 106 CFU g−1 soil by 7 days, while fungal and actinomycete populations increased to 29.3 × 103 and 15.0 × 102 CFU g−1 soil, respectively (Figure 2). The response was greatest for bacteria, followed by fungi and actinomycetes, indicating that empty gelatin capsule placement did not result in an apparent reduction in the culturable microbial groups assessed under the experimental conditions. The observed increase may partly reflect microbial utilization of organic substrates released during gelatin decomposition; however, capsule degradation and associated carbon or nitrogen release were not directly quantified in the present study, and this mechanism therefore remains inferential.
Figure 2
From a sustainable food-system perspective, the absence of an apparent decline in the measured culturable microbial populations following empty-capsule placement provides preliminary evidence of biological compatibility of the gelatin carrier with the rice rhizosphere. This finding is relevant to the development of localized biodegradable herbicide-delivery systems, where the environmental performance of the carrier is an important complement to weed-control efficacy, crop productivity and input-use efficiency. Nevertheless, the results should be interpreted specifically as changes in culturable microbial abundance and not as evidence of improved overall soil microbial health or functioning. The serial dilution plate-count approach captures only the cultivable fraction of soil microorganisms and cannot resolve changes in microbial diversity, community composition, functional potential or nutrient-cycling processes. Accordingly, the present results provide an initial microbiological assessment of carrier compatibility, while culture-independent community profiling and functional assays would be required to determine whether gelatin capsule decomposition produces sustained effects on rhizosphere microbial structure and soil biological functioning.
3.2 Preliminary screening and selection of treatments
3.2.1 Weed dynamics and density
The naturally emerging weed flora in the preliminary pot experiment comprised Echinochloa crus-galli, Leptochloa chinensis, and Portulaca oleracea. Weed density differed significantly among herbicide treatments at 10 and 20 days after transplanting (DAT) (Table 1). The Bensulfuron methyl + Pretilachlor (T9-T12) and Triafamone + Ethoxysulfuron (T13-T16) treatments generally recorded lower weed densities at both observation dates, with several treatments recording 0.71 (0.00) at both 10 and 20 DAT. Among the Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl treatments (T1-T4), T2 (75% of the recommended formulation rate) recorded the lowest weed density, with a value of 0.71 (0.00) at both observation dates. The Butachlor treatments (T5-T8) generally recorded comparatively higher weed densities, with T7 showing the highest density at 20 DAT (1.80), indicating comparatively lower weed-suppression efficacy. Overall, the observed weed-density response provided the basis for selecting the most effective treatments for subsequent field evaluation.
Table 1
| Treatments | Treatment details | 10 DAT | 20 DAT |
|---|---|---|---|
| T1 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 50% Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl 10% WP @ 150 g a.i. ha−1 | 1.00 (0.67) | 1.67 (1.25) |
| T2 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 75% Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl 10% WP @ 150 g a.i. ha−1 | 0.71 (0.00) | 0.71 (0.00) |
| T3 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 100% Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl 10% WP @ 150 g a.i. ha−1 | 0.88 (0.33) | 1.17 (1.00) |
| T4 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 150% Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl 10% WP @ 150 g a.i. ha−1 | 1.21 (1.33) | 1.47 (2.00) |
| T5 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 50% Butachlor 5% GR @ 25 kg a.i. ha−1 | 1.05 (0.67) | 1.43 (2.00) |
| T6 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 75% Butachlor 5% GR @ 25 kg a.i. ha−1 | 0.88 (0.33) | 1.17 (1.00) |
| T7 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 100% Butachlor 5% GR @ 25 kg a.i. ha−1 | 1.27 (1.33) | 1.80 (3.33) |
| T8 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 150% Butachlor 5% GR @ 25 kg a.i. ha−1 | 1.05 (0.67) | 1.27 (1.33) |
| T9 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 50% Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR @ 10 kg a.i. ha−1 | 0.71 (0.00) | 0.71 (0.00) |
| T10 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 75% Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR @ 10 kg a.i. ha−1 | 0.71 (0.00) | 0.88 (0.33) |
| T11 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 100% Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR @ 10 kg a.i. ha−1 | 0.71 (0.00) | 0.71 (0.00) |
| T12 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 150% Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR @ 10 kg a.i. ha−1 | 0.71 (0.00) | 0.71 (0.00) |
| T13 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 50% Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG @ 222 g a.i. ha−1 | 0.71 (0.00) | 0.71 (0.00) |
| T14 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 75% Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG @ 222 g a.i. ha−1 | 0.71 (0.33) | 1.00 (0.67) |
| T15 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 100% Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG @ 222 g a.i. ha−1 | 0.71 (0.00) | 0.71 (0.00) |
| T16 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 150% Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG @ 222 g a.i. ha−1 | 0.71 (0.00) | 0.88 (0.33) |
| S. Ed. | 0.06 | 0.03 | |
| CD (p = 0.05) | 0.12 | 0.07 | |
Effect of gelatin herbicide capsule on weed density (No. pot−1) of screening treatment.
PE = pre-emergence; WP = wettable powder; GR = granule; WG = water-dispersible granule; a.i. = active ingredient; DAT = days after transplanting. Values outside parentheses are square-root-transformed means, while values within parentheses are the corresponding original (untransformed) means. S. Ed. = standard error of difference; CD = Critical Difference at p = 0.05.
3.2.2 Weed control efficiency
Weed control efficiency (WCE) varied among the gelatin capsule treatments at both 10 and 20 DAT (Table 2). At 10 DAT, WCE ranged from 77.8 to 100.0%, while at 20 DAT it ranged from 72.2 to 100.0%. Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl at 75% of the recommended formulation rate (T2) recorded the highest WCE among the treatments, reaching 100.0% at both observation dates. Among the Butachlor treatments, the 75% formulation rate (T6) performed comparatively better, with WCE values of 94.4 and 91.7% at 10 and 20 DAT, respectively. Bensulfuron methyl + Pretilachlor treatments consistently exhibited high WCE, with T9, T11, and T12 maintaining 100.0% WCE at both observation dates. Similarly, T13 and T15, comprising Triafamone + Ethoxysulfuron, recorded 100.0% WCE at both dates. The high WCE observed with several capsule treatments, including reduced formulation rates, indicates effective suppression of emerging weeds through localized herbicide delivery. However, the response was not uniformly dose-dependent across herbicide formulations.
Table 2
| Treatments | Treatment details | 10 DAT | 20 DAT |
|---|---|---|---|
| T1 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 50% Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl 10% WP @ 150 g a.i. ha−1 | 88.9 | 86.1 |
| T2 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 75% Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl 10% WP @ 150 g a.i. ha−1 | 100.0 | 100 |
| T3 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 100% Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl 10% WP @ 150 g a.i. ha−1 | 94.4 | 97.2 |
| T4 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 150% Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl 10% WP @ 150 g a.i. ha−1 | 77.8 | 83.3 |
| T5 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 50% Butachlor 5% GR @ 25 kg a.i. ha−1 | 88.9 | 83.3 |
| T6 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 75% Butachlor 5% GR @ 25 kg a.i. ha−1 | 94.4 | 91.7 |
| T7 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 100% Butachlor 5% GR @ 25 kg a.i. ha−1 | 77.8 | 72.2 |
| T8 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 150% Butachlor 5% GR @ 25 kg a.i. ha−1 | 88.9 | 88.9 |
| T9 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 50% Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR @ 10 kg a.i. ha−1 | 100.0 | 100 |
| T10 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 75% Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR @ 10 kg a.i. ha−1 | 100.0 | 97.2 |
| T11 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 100% Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR @ 10 kg a.i. ha−1 | 100.0 | 100 |
| T12 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 150% Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR @ 10 kg a.i. ha−1 | 100.0 | 100 |
| T13 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 50% Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG @ 222 g a.i. ha−1 | 100.0 | 100 |
| T14 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 75% Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG @ 222 g a.i. ha−1 | 94.4 | 94.4 |
| T15 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 100% Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG @ 222 g a.i. ha−1 | 100.0 | 100 |
| T16 | PE application of gelatin capsule filled with 150% Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG @ 222 g a.i. ha−1 | 100.0 | 91.7 |
Effect of gelatin herbicide capsule on weed control efficiency (%) of screening treatment.
PE = pre-emergence; WP = wettable powder; GR = granule; WG = water-dispersible granule; a.i. = active ingredient; DAT = days after transplanting.
3.2.3 Percent rank analysis
Percent rank analysis was used to rank the 16 herbicide treatments based on their relative weed population in the preliminary screening experiment. The nine highest-performing treatments were selected for subsequent field evaluation (Table 3). T2, comprising Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl at 75% of the recommended rate, ranked first, followed by T9 (50% Bensulfuron methyl + Pretilachlor), T11 (100% Bensulfuron methyl + Pretilachlor), and T12 (150% Bensulfuron methyl + Pretilachlor). T13 (50% Triafamone + Ethoxysulfuron) and T15 (100% Triafamone + Ethoxysulfuron) ranked fifth and sixth, respectively, while T10, T3 and T14 ranked seventh, eighth and ninth. These nine treatments were therefore selected for the field evaluation.
Table 3
| Rank | Treatment details |
|---|---|
| 1 | T2–75% of the recommended dose of Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl 10% WP |
| 2 | T9–50% of the recommended dose of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR |
| 3 | T11–100% of the recommended dose of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR |
| 4 | T12–150% of the recommended dose of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR |
| 5 | T13–50% of the recommended dose of Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG |
| 6 | T15–100% of the recommended dose of Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG |
| 7 | T10–75% of the recommended dose of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR |
| 8 | T3–100% of the recommended dose of Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl 10% WP |
| 9 | T14–75% of the recommended dose of Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG |
Top-performing treatments from the screening experiment.
WP = wettable powder; GR = granule; WG = water-dispersible granule.
3.3 Field study
The field experiment comprised a diverse weed flora representing grasses, sedges, and broadleaf weeds. The dominant grasses were Echinochloa crus-galli, E. colona, Leptochloa chinensis, and Chloris barbata (Poaceae), while Cyperus iria and C. difformis (Cyperaceae) were the predominant sedges. The broadleaf weed flora included Eclipta alba, Portulaca oleracea, Alternanthera sessilis, Malachra capitata, and Rotala densiflora, belonging to the Asteraceae, Portulacaceae, Amaranthaceae, Malvaceae, and Lythraceae, respectively.
3.3.1 Weed and herbicide response assessment
3.3.1.1 Weed density
Weed density differed significantly among treatments at 15, 30, and 45 DAT (Figure 3). Among the gelatin capsule treatments, Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR at 100% (T5) and 150% (T6) of the recommended formulation rate recorded the lowest weed densities and were statistically comparable at the respective observation stages. T6 recorded 8.33, 43.00, and 94.66 plants m−2 at 15, 30, and 45 DAT, respectively. In contrast, the 50% Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG treatment (T7) recorded the highest numerical weed density among the capsule treatments. The conventional spray treatments (T10-T12) showed intermediate weed densities, while the weedy check (T14) recorded the highest weed infestation and the weed-free check (T13) remained weed-free.
Figure 3
3.3.1.2 Weed dry weight
Weed dry weight differed significantly among treatments at 15, 30, and 45 DAT (Figure 4). Among the gelatin capsule treatments, Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR at 100% (T5) and 150% (T6) of the recommended formulation rate recorded the lowest weed biomass and were statistically comparable at all observation stages. The 150% treatment (T6) recorded weed dry weights of 2.23, 25.65, and 42.49 g m−2 at 15, 30, and 45 DAT, respectively, closely followed by the 100% treatment (T5), with 2.36, 25.76, and 42.83 g m−2. In contrast, the 50% Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG treatment (T7) recorded the highest weed dry weight among the capsule treatments, with 7.65, 57.92, and 116.10 g m−2 at the corresponding stages. The conventional spray treatments showed intermediate weed biomass, while the weedy check (T14) recorded the highest weed dry weight and the weed-free check (T13) had no weed biomass.
Figure 4
3.3.1.3 Weed control efficiency
Weed control efficiency (WCE) varied markedly among treatments across the observation period (Figure 5). Among the gelatin capsule treatments, Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR at 100% (T5) and 150% (T6) of the recommended formulation rate recorded the highest WCE, reaching 86.9 and 87.6%, respectively, at 15 DAT, and remaining high at 30 DAT (68.7 and 68.9%) and 45 DAT (68.3 and 68.5%). In contrast, the 50% Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG treatment (T7) recorded the lowest WCE among the capsule treatments, declining from 57.6% at 15 DAT to 14.0% at 45 DAT. The conventional spray treatments recorded WCE values of 79.1–81.7% at 15 DAT and 53.9–58.8% at 45 DAT, whereas the weed-free and weedy checks recorded 100 and 0% WCE, respectively. The higher WCE of the Bensulfuron methyl + Pretilachlor capsule treatments was consistent with their lower weed density and dry biomass, indicating sustained suppression of weed growth under field conditions. Notably, the 100 and 150% formulation rates showed only marginal differences in WCE, suggesting limited additional benefit from increasing the capsule loading beyond the recommended rate.
Figure 5
3.3.1.4 Herbicide efficiency index (HEI)
Herbicide efficiency index (HEI) varied considerably among treatments and observation stages (Figure 6). The highest HEI was recorded with the 150% formulation rate of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR (T6), with values of 14.31, 5.93, and 5.63 at 15, 30, and 45 DAT, respectively, followed by the 100% formulation rate (T5), which recorded HEI values of 12.61, 5.44, and 5.21 at the corresponding stages. The conventional spray treatments showed moderate HEI, whereas the 50–100% Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG capsule treatments recorded the lowest values, ranging from 0.16–0.33 at 15 DAT and declining to 0.08–0.17 at 45 DAT. The higher HEI of the Bensulfuron methyl + Pretilachlor capsule treatments reflects their combined advantage of greater weed suppression and comparatively better crop performance.
Figure 6
3.3.1.5 Temporal dynamics of weed suppression and cumulative weed biomass
The area-under-the-curve analysis provided an integrated assessment of weed-control performance and weed biomass accumulation over 15–45 DAT, enabling direct comparison of gelatin-capsule delivery with conventional herbicide application (Table 4). Across the three herbicide comparisons, gelatin-capsule delivery consistently produced higher cumulative weed-control efficiency (AUWCEC) and lower cumulative weed dry weight (AUWDWC) than the corresponding conventional applications. For pyrazosulfuron ethyl, the 100% gelatin-capsule treatment (T2) recorded an AUWCEC of 1428.75% day compared with 1884.75% day for conventional application (T10), while AUWDWC was 1398.67 and 1011.15 g m−2 day, respectively. Thus, under the present experimental conditions, the capsule treatment did not outperform the conventional treatment for this herbicide, indicating that the response to the delivery system was herbicide-specific rather than universally superior.
Table 4
| Treatments | AUWCEC | AUWDWC |
|---|---|---|
| T1 | 1,278 | 1550.47 |
| T2 | 1428.75 | 1398.67 |
| T3 | 1529.25 | 1318.2 |
| T4 | 1541.25 | 1291.72 |
| T5 | 2194.5 | 725.32 |
| T6 | 2204.25 | 720.15 |
| T7 | 982.5 | 1796.92 |
| T8 | 1086.75 | 1697.18 |
| T9 | 1,131 | 1652.32 |
| T10 | 1884.75 | 1011.15 |
| T11 | 1878 | 1016.78 |
| T12 | 1887 | 1001.4 |
| T13 | 3,000 | 0 |
| T14 | 0 | 2385.38 |
Temporal dynamics of weed suppression and cumulative weed biomass.
AUWCEC - cumulative weed-control efficiency; AUWDWC -lower cumulative weed dry weight; T1 - Capsules filled with 75% of the recommended dose of Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl 10% WP; T2 - Capsules filled with 100% of the recommended dose of Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl 10% WP; T3 - Capsules filled with 50% of the recommended dose of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR; T4 - Capsules filled with 75% of the recommended dose of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR; T5 - Capsules filled with 100% of the recommended dose of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR; T6 - Capsules filled with 150% of the recommended dose of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR; T7 - Capsules filled with 50% of the recommended dose of Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG; T8 - Capsules filled with 75% of the recommended dose of Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG; T9 - Capsules filled with 100% of the recommended dose of Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG; T10 - Conventional spray of recommended Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl 10% WP; T11 - Conventional spray of recommended Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR; T12 - Conventional spray of recommended Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG; T13 – Weed free; T14 – Weedy check; WP = wettable powder; GR = granule; WG = water-dispersible granule.
A clearer advantage of capsule delivery was observed with bensulfuron methyl + pretilachlor. The 100% gelatin-capsule treatment (T5) recorded an AUWCEC of 2194.50% day, compared with 1878.00% day under conventional application (T11), representing a 16.9% greater cumulative weed-control response. Correspondingly, AUWDWC declined from 1016.78 g m−2 day under conventional application to 725.32 g m−2 day with the capsule treatment, equivalent to a 28.7% reduction in cumulative weed biomass. The capsule treatment therefore maintained stronger weed suppression across the assessment period rather than merely producing a higher response at an individual sampling date. The 150% capsule treatment (T6) showed a very similar temporal response, with AUWCEC of 2204.25% day and AUWDWC of 720.15 g m−2 day, indicating that increasing the capsule dose from 100 to 150% resulted in only marginal additional cumulative improvement.
For triafamone + ethoxysulfuron, the 100% capsule treatment (T9) recorded an AUWCEC of 1131.00% day, substantially lower than the 1887.00% day observed under conventional application (T12). Similarly, AUWDWC was higher under capsule delivery (1652.32 g m−2 day) than under conventional application (1001.40 g m−2 day). Thus, unlike bensulfuron methyl + pretilachlor, capsule delivery did not improve cumulative weed suppression for triafamone + ethoxysulfuron.
Overall, the temporal analysis indicates that gelatin-capsule delivery did not provide a universal advantage over conventional application, but produced a pronounced improvement for bensulfuron methyl + pretilachlor at the recommended dose. This herbicide-specific response is important because it strengthens, rather than weakens, the interpretation of the technology by demonstrating that the performance benefit is associated with particular herbicide–delivery combinations rather than being an artefact of a generalized treatment effect. The superior AUWCEC and lower AUWDWC observed for T5 relative to T11 indicate more sustained weed suppression under capsule delivery, while the near-equivalence of T5 and T6 suggests that increasing the dose beyond the recommended level provided little additional temporal benefit. Collectively, these findings support the potential of biodegradable gelatin capsules as a targeted herbicide-delivery platform for selected herbicide formulations, while also highlighting the need for formulation-specific optimization before broader application across herbicide chemistries.
3.3.2 Crop growth and yield response
3.3.2.1 Plant height
Plant height showed a clear treatment-dependent response throughout crop development (Table 5). Among the herbicide treatments, the 150% formulation rate of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR delivered through gelatin capsules (T6) consistently produced the greatest plant height, increasing from 73 cm at 30 DAT to 117 cm at harvest, followed closely by the 100% formulation rate (T5), which increased from 72 to 115 cm over the same period. The conventional spray treatments T10, T11 and T12 produced intermediate plant heights, reaching 104, 105 and 106 cm at harvest, respectively. In contrast, the 50% Triafamone + Ethoxysulfuron capsule treatment (T7) recorded only 52, 62, 77 and 85 cm at 30, 60, 90 DAT and harvest, respectively, while the weedy check (T14) remained the shortest throughout crop development. The weed-free check (T13) produced the greatest plant height, reaching 120 cm at harvest. According to the DMRT grouping, T5 and T6 were statistically comparable with the weed-free check across the observation stages, indicating that effective capsule-mediated weed suppression supported plant height close to the weed-free condition.
Table 5
| Treatments | Plant height (cm) | No. of tillers (m−2) | Dry matter production (Kg ha−1) | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 30 DAT | 60 DAT | 90 DAT | At Harvest | 30 DAT | 60 DAT | 90 DAT | At Harvest | 30 DAT | 60 DAT | 90 DAT | At Harvest | |
| T1 | 59bcd | 67d | 84cd | 93cd | 240abcd | 408d | 489bc | 601abc | 1770a | 2640d | 3650d | 11970b |
| T2 | 61bcd | 68ᵈ | 85bcd | 95bcd | 244abcd | 419cd | 494bc | 606abc | 1875a | 3350c | 3980d | 12000b |
| T3 | 62bcd | 69cd | 87abcd | 96bcd | 245abcd | 425cd | 501bc | 608abc | 1890a | 3790bc | 6750c | 12170b |
| T4 | 64bcd | 70cd | 89abcd | 101abcd | 247abcd | 430bcd | 529ab | 613abc | 1930a | 3980b | 7650b | 12800b |
| T5 | 72ab | 85abc | 104ab | 115abc | 288a | 482a | 573a | 646a | 2009a | 5754a | 9370a | 15200a |
| T6 | 73ab | 87ab | 105ab | 117ab | 289a | 485a | 575a | 648a | 2012a | 5780a | 9380a | 15300a |
| T7 | 52cd | 62d | 77d | 85d | 220cd | 380d | 467bc | 579abc | 650b | 1735e | 2100e | 7630c |
| T8 | 53cd | 65d | 80d | 90d | 222bcd | 386ᵈ | 471bc | 561bc | 684b | 1780e | 2350e | 5700d |
| T9 | 54cd | 67d | 82d | 92d | 232bcd | 397d | 473bc | 584abc | 685b | 2050e | 2400e | 9180c |
| T10 | 63bcd | 72bcd | 94abcd | 104abcd | 268abc | 469abc | 559a | 631ab | 1936a | 5710a | 9180a | 14529a |
| T11 | 66abc | 73bcd | 95abcd | 105abcd | 272ab | 471abc | 567a | 632ab | 1994a | 5720a | 9270a | 14811a |
| T12 | 66abc | 74bcd | 95abcd | 106abcd | 272ab | 475ᵃᵇᶜ | 569a | 635ab | 2001a | 5725a | 9290a | 14865a |
| T13 | 78a | 91a | 106a | 120ᵃ | 291a | 489ᵃ | 587a | 651a | 2019a | 5825a | 9580a | 15650a |
| T14 | 51d | 61d | 76d | 86ᵈ | 208d | 377ᵈ | 465c | 546c | 440b | 925f | 2000e | 3020e |
| S. Ed. | 6.05 | 7.05 | 8.71 | 9.65 | 21.6 | 24.56 | 26.74 | 32.1 | 112.44 | 286.44 | 351.3 | 832.82 |
| CD (p = 0.05) | 12.43 | 14.48 | 17.91 | 19.83 | 44.59 | 50.49 | 54.96 | 65.97 | 231.12 | 588.79 | 722.11 | 1711.89 |
Effect of gelatin herbicide capsules on plant height (cm), No.of tillers (m−2) and Dry matter production (Kg ha−1) in the transplanted rice ecosystem.
T1 - Capsules filled with 75% of the recommended dose of Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl 10% WP; T2 - Capsules filled with 100% of the recommended dose of Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl 10% WP; T3 - Capsules filled with 50% of the recommended dose of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR; T4 - Capsules filled with 75% of the recommended dose of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR; T5 - Capsules filled with 100% of the recommended dose of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR; T6 - Capsules filled with 150% of the recommended dose of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR; T7 - Capsules filled with 50% of the recommended dose of Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG; T8 - Capsules filled with 75% of the recommended dose of Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG; T9 - Capsules filled with 100% of the recommended dose of Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG; T10 - Conventional spray of recommended Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl 10% WP; T11 - Conventional spray of recommended Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR; T12 - Conventional spray of recommended Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG; T13 – Weed free; T14 – Weedy check; WP = wettable powder; GR = granule; WG = water-dispersible granule; Means sharing at least one common letter within a column are not significantly different according to Duncan’s Multiple Range Test (DMRT) at p ≤ 0.05. S. Ed. = standard error of difference; CD = critical difference at p = 0.05.
3.3.2.2 Tiller production
Tiller production exhibited a pattern consistent with plant height, with effective weed management supporting greater tiller establishment and retention (Table 5). T6 recorded the highest tiller density among the herbicide treatments, increasing from 289 tillers m−2 at 30 DAT to 648 tillers m−2 at harvest, followed closely by T5 with 288 and 646 tillers m−2 at the respective stages. The conventional spray treatments T10, T11 and T12 reached 631, 632 and 635 tillers m−2 at harvest, respectively, whereas the Triafamone + Ethoxysulfuron capsule treatments produced fewer tillers, particularly T7, which reached only 579 tillers m−2. The weedy check recorded the lowest tiller density, with 546 tillers m−2 at harvest, whereas the weed-free check produced 651 tillers m−2. The DMRT results showed that T5 and T6 were statistically comparable with the weed-free check across the observation stages. The relatively small difference between T5/T6 and the weed-free check indicates that effective weed suppression largely restored the tillering environment of the crop. This response is biologically important because tiller establishment during the vegetative phase determines the number of potential productive culms and therefore contributes directly to subsequent panicle-bearing capacity. The results indicate that sustained suppression of weed competition under the Bensulfuron methyl + Pretilachlor capsule treatments favored tiller development and maintenance throughout crop growth.
3.3.2.3 Dry matter production
Dry matter accumulation further reflected the differences in crop growth established under the respective weed-management treatments (Table 5). T6 recorded the greatest dry matter production among the herbicide treatments, increasing from 2,012 kg ha−1 at 30 DAT to 15,300 kg ha−1 at harvest, while T5 accumulated 2,009, 5,754, 9,370 and 15,200 kg ha−1 at 30, 60, 90 DAT and harvest, respectively. The conventional spray treatments T10, T11 and T12 accumulated 14,529, 14,811 and 14,865 kg ha−1 at harvest, respectively. In contrast, T7 recorded only 7,630 kg ha−1 at harvest, while the weedy check accumulated 3,020 kg ha−1. The weed-free check produced the highest final dry matter (15,650 kg ha−1), with T5 and T6 approaching this level. The DMRT grouping showed that T5 and T6 were statistically comparable with the weed-free check at the observation stages. The convergence of dry matter accumulation with the patterns observed for weed density, weed biomass and WCE indicates that the principal driver of improved crop biomass was the reduction of interspecific competition under effective weed management. Greater availability of radiation, water and nutrients for the crop would have supported leaf and tiller development and consequently increased whole-plant biomass accumulation. Thus, the gelatin capsule treatments containing 100 and 150% of the recommended Bensulfuron methyl + Pretilachlor formulation produced a crop growth response approaching that of the weed-free condition, demonstrating the capacity of the capsule-mediated delivery system to sustain crop establishment and vegetative development under field conditions.
Overall, capsule-based application consistently produced superior crop growth responses compared with the corresponding conventional application, as reflected in greater plant height, tiller density and dry matter production across the crop growth stages. Among the capsule-based treatments, the Bensulfuron methyl + Pretilachlor formulation showed the most favorable crop growth response, while the capsule treatments remained statistically comparable with the weed-free condition.
3.3.3 Grain yield and harvest index
Grain yield varied significantly among the weed-management treatments, with the response closely reflecting the differences observed in weed suppression and crop growth. The highest grain yield among the herbicide treatments was recorded with the 150% formulation rate of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR delivered through gelatin capsules (T6), producing 5,710 kg ha−1, followed by the 100% formulation rate (T5) with 5,463 kg ha−1. According to the DMRT, T5 and T6 were statistically comparable with each other, while T6 and T5 were also statistically comparable with the weed-free check (T13). These treatments also produced the greatest plant height, tiller density and dry matter accumulation among the herbicide treatments, indicating that effective suppression of weed interference translated into improved crop growth and reproductive productivity. The conventional spray treatments T10, T11 and T12 produced intermediate grain yields of 4,265, 4,755 and 4,895 kg ha−1, respectively. In contrast, the Triafamone + Ethoxysulfuron capsule treatments produced substantially lower grain yields, ranging from 2,200 to 2,340 kg ha−1, while the weedy check (T14) recorded the lowest yield of 2061 kg ha−1. The weed-free check (T13) produced the maximum grain yield of 5,998 kg ha−1. Although T6 recorded the highest yield among the herbicide treatments, its yield remained statistically comparable with the weed-free check because the difference of 288 kg ha−1 was smaller than the critical difference of 705.16 kg ha−1. This indicates that the most effective capsule treatment was capable of maintaining grain productivity close to the weed-free condition under the prevailing field environment.
Harvest index followed a pattern broadly consistent with grain yield, ranging from 0.27 in the weedy check (T14) to 0.40 in the weed-free check (T13). Among the herbicide treatments, T6 recorded the highest harvest index (0.39), followed by T5 (0.38), whereas the Triafamone + Ethoxysulfuron capsule treatments recorded lower values of 0.28–0.29. The conventional spray treatments showed intermediate harvest indices, ranging from 0.33 to 0.36. The DMRT grouping showed that T5 and T6 were statistically comparable with each other and with the weed-free check (T13). The higher harvest index under T5 and T6 indicates that effective weed suppression not only increased total crop biomass but also favored the conversion and allocation of assimilated biomass toward grain production. The close correspondence between weed suppression, vegetative growth, biomass accumulation, grain yield and harvest index demonstrates a coherent crop-level response to capsule-mediated herbicide delivery. Overall, the 100 and 150% Bensulfuron methyl + Pretilachlor capsule treatments provided the most favorable balance between weed suppression and crop productivity, with the 100% treatment achieving nearly the same productivity as the 150% treatment while using a lower formulation rate (Table 6).
Table 6
| S. No | Treatments | Crop yield (kg ha−1) | Harvest index |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | T1 | 3870e | 0.32bcde |
| 2. | T2 | 3855e | 0.32bcde |
| 3. | T3 | 4058de | 0.33bcde |
| 4. | T4 | 4145cde | 0.33bcde |
| 5. | T5 | 5463a | 0.38ab |
| 6. | T6 | 5710a | 0.39ab |
| 7. | T7 | 2200f | 0.28de |
| 8. | T8 | 2280f | 0.29cde |
| 9. | T9 | 2340f | 0.29cde |
| 10. | T10 | 4265cde | 0.33bcde |
| 11. | T11 | 4755cd | 0.35abcd |
| 12. | T12 | 4895bc | 0.36abc |
| 13. | T13 | 5998a | 0.40a |
| 14. | T14 | 2061f | 0.27e |
| S. Ed. | 343.05 | 0.03 | |
| CD (p = 0.05) | 705.16 | 0.07 | |
Effect of gelatin capsule-mediated herbicide application on rice grain yield and harvest index.
T1 - Capsules filled with 75% of the recommended dose of Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl 10% WP; T2 - Capsules filled with 100% of the recommended dose of Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl 10% WP; T3 - Capsules filled with 50% of the recommended dose of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR; T4 - Capsules filled with 75% of the recommended dose of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR; T5 - Capsules filled with 100% of the recommended dose of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR; T6 - Capsules filled with 150% of the recommended dose of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR; T7 - Capsules filled with 50% of the recommended dose of Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG; T8 - Capsules filled with 75% of the recommended dose of Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG; T9 - Capsules filled with 100% of the recommended dose of Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG; T10 - Conventional spray of recommended Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl 10% WP; T11 - Conventional spray of recommended Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR; T12 - Conventional spray of recommended Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG; T13 - Weedy free; T14 - Weedy check; WP = wettable powder; GR = granule; WG = water-dispersible granule; Means sharing at least one common letter within a column are not significantly different according to Duncan’s Multiple Range Test (DMRT) at p ≤ 0.05. S. Ed. = standard error of difference; CD = critical difference at p = 0.05.
3.3.4 Economic performance
Economic returns differed substantially among the weed-management treatments and closely reflected the differences in crop productivity and weed suppression (Table 7). The 150% formulation rate of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR delivered through gelatin capsules (T6) generated the highest gross return (₹ 123,070 ha−1) and net return (₹ 71,821 ha−1), followed closely by the 100% formulation rate (T5), which recorded ₹ 118,025 and ₹ 69,201 ha−1, respectively. Despite the higher absolute returns under T6, T5 recorded the highest B:C ratio (2.42), slightly exceeding that of T6 (2.40), indicating greater economic efficiency per unit of production cost. The conventional spray treatments T10-T12 recorded B:C ratios of 2.31, 2.25 and 2.27, respectively, while the weed-free check recorded a B:C ratio of 2.34. In contrast, the 50–100% Triafamone + Ethoxysulfuron capsule treatments produced substantially lower economic returns, with B:C ratios ranging from only 1.08 to 1.14. The economic advantage of T5 is particularly relevant when considered alongside its agronomic performance: its grain yield of 5,463 kg ha−1 was statistically comparable with T6 (5,710 kg ha−1), while requiring a lower formulation rate. Thus, increasing the Bensulfuron methyl + Pretilachlor capsule loading from 100 to 150% increased absolute returns but did not provide a statistically significant yield advantage and slightly reduced the B:C ratio. This indicates that the 100% formulation rate provided a more favorable balance between productivity and production cost, whereas the 150% rate maximized absolute returns.
Table 7
| Treatments | Gross return (₹ha−1) | Net Returns (₹ha−1) | BCR | Et | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SP | UM | ||||
| T1 | 85,650 | 45,764 | 2.15 | 1.41 | 0.68 |
| T2 | 85,200 | 45,299 | 2.14 | 1.42 | 0.68 |
| T3 | 89,460 | 42,211 | 1.89 | 9.03 | 3.75 |
| T4 | 91,240 | 42,991 | 1.89 | 9.63 | 4.16 |
| T5 | 118,025 | 69,201 | 2.42 | 9.71 | 4.23 |
| T6 | 123,070 | 71,821 | 2.40 | 11.42 | 5.14 |
| T7 | 49,595 | 3,491 | 1.08 | 8.83 | 3.27 |
| T8 | 51,285 | 5,158 | 1.11 | 8.84 | 3.28 |
| T9 | 52,488 | 6,339 | 1.14 | 8.86 | 3.29 |
| T10 | 93,955 | 53,264 | 2.31 | 1.89 | 1.01 |
| T11 | 103,790 | 57,691 | 2.25 | 8.34 | 3.27 |
| T12 | 106,590 | 59,681 | 2.27 | 8.62 | 3.61 |
| T13 | 129,110 | 73,851 | 2.34 | — | — |
| T14 | 46,780 | 8,521 | 1.22 | — | — |
Economics and economics thresholds under different weed management practices in transplanted rice ecosystems.
BCR - benefit–cost ratio; Et - economic threshold; SP- Stone and Pedigo; UM - Uygur and Mennan; T1 - Capsules filled with 75% of the recommended dose of Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl 10% WP; T2 - Capsules filled with 100% of the recommended dose of Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl 10% WP; T3 - Capsules filled with 50% of the recommended dose of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR; T4 - Capsules filled with 75% of the recommended dose of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR; T5 - Capsules filled with 100% of the recommended dose of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR; T6 - Capsules filled with 150% of the recommended dose of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR; T7 - Capsules filled with 50% of the recommended dose of Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG; T8 - Capsules filled with 75% of the recommended dose of Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG; T9 - Capsules filled with 100% of the recommended dose of Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG; T10 - Conventional spray of recommended Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl 10% WP; T11 - Conventional spray of recommended Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR; T12 - Conventional spray of recommended Triafamone 20% + Ethoxysulfuron 10% WG; T13 - Weed free check; T14 - Weedy check; WP = wettable powder; GR = granule; WG = water-dispersible granule.
Economic threshold analysis further demonstrated differences in the economic tolerance of the crop to weed infestation among the herbicide treatments (Table 6). Under the Stone and Pedigo (SP) approach, the estimated economic threshold ranged from 1.42 in T1-T2 to 11.42 in T6, with T5 recording 9.71. The Uygur and Mennan (UM) approach showed a similar treatment ranking, with thresholds ranging from 0.68 in T1-T2 to 5.14 in T6, while T5 recorded 4.23. The relatively higher thresholds under the Bensulfuron methyl + Pretilachlor capsule treatments indicate that these treatments could tolerate a greater level of weed infestation before the projected economic loss exceeded the corresponding cost of control. T6 exhibited the highest threshold under both approaches, consistent with its superior weed suppression and yield response. However, the economic threshold should be interpreted together with treatment cost and realized profitability rather than as an independent indicator of treatment superiority. Taken together, the economic analysis demonstrates that the 100% Bensulfuron methyl + Pretilachlor capsule treatment (T5) provided the most favorable economic efficiency, combining high grain yield, high net return, the highest B:C ratio, and strong weed-management performance, while the 150% treatment (T6) maximized absolute economic returns and provided the highest estimated tolerance to weed infestation.
4 Discussion
4.1 Interpretation of treatment grouping and crop growth responses
The crop growth parameters showed several overlapping DMRT groups among treatments within the same herbicide formulation, reflecting statistically comparable responses despite differences in formulation rates. Treatments T1-T2, T3-T6 and T7-T9 generally showed numerical differences in plant height, tiller production and dry matter accumulation, but these differences were not always sufficient to produce statistically distinct groups, indicating that increasing formulation rate did not necessarily result in a proportional improvement in crop growth once adequate weed suppression was achieved. Similar dose–response patterns have been reported in transplanted rice, where an optimum herbicide dose was found to be comparable with higher doses for weed control, grain yield and benefit:cost ratio, while different herbicide treatments and rates have also produced statistically comparable growth and yield responses (Dhillon et al., 2026; Kithan et al., 2026). At Queensland, O’Brien et al. (2022) also demonstrated the potential of capsulated herbicides for targeted weed control, supporting the broader applicability of capsule-based herbicide delivery beyond conventional application methods.
4.2 Comparative performance of gelatin capsule-mediated and conventional herbicide application
The comparative field evaluation indicates that the benefit of gelatin capsule-mediated herbicide delivery was formulation-specific rather than universal. The clearest advantage occurred with Bensulfuron methyl + Pretilachlor, for which the 100% capsule treatment (T5) produced greater cumulative weed suppression and lower cumulative weed biomass than the corresponding conventional application (T11). AUWCEC increased from 1878.00% day under conventional application to 2194.50% day with capsule delivery, while AUWDWC declined from 1016.78 to 725.32 g m−2 day, representing 16.9% greater cumulative weed-control performance and 28.7% lower cumulative weed biomass, respectively. This temporal advantage is agronomically relevant because the duration and magnitude of weed interference can influence crop growth and productivity; therefore, sustained suppression provides a more informative assessment of treatment performance than a single-point observation. The DMRT results further showed that the Bensulfuron methyl + Pretilachlor capsule treatments, particularly T5 and T6, consistently maintained lower weed density and weed dry weight than the other capsule treatments across the observation periods.
However, the same advantage was not observed for all herbicides. The 100% Pyrazosulfuron Ethyl capsule treatment had lower AUWCEC and higher AUWDWC than its conventional counterpart, and Triafamone + Ethoxysulfuron showed a similar response. Thus, the findings do not support a generalized claim that gelatin capsules are inherently superior to conventional application. Rather, they indicate an interaction between the delivery system and herbicide formulation. The strong response of Bensulfuron methyl + Pretilachlor is consistent with previous field evaluations in transplanted rice, where this combination effectively suppressed mixed populations of grasses, sedges and broadleaf weeds and supported higher crop productivity (Teja et al., 2015; Mishra, 2019). Recent herbicide research also supports the effectiveness of pretilachlor + bensulfuron-based formulations against Echinochloa spp. in transplanted rice (Bhagavathi et al., 2024). The additional advantage observed under capsule delivery may reflect differences in the spatial or temporal availability of the formulation following localized placement, but release kinetics and herbicide fate were not measured and therefore cannot be used to establish a controlled-release mechanism.
The close correspondence between T5 and T6 further strengthens this interpretation. Increasing the Bensulfuron methyl + Pretilachlor capsule loading from 100 to 150% increased AUWCEC only from 2194.50 to 2204.25% day and reduced AUWDWC from 725.32 to 720.15 g m−2 day. These marginal differences indicate that most of the temporal weed-suppression benefit of capsule delivery was achieved at the recommended formulation rate, with limited additional benefit from increasing the capsule loading to 150%.
4.3 Gelatin capsule-mediated weed suppression translates into improved crop productivity
The stronger and more persistent weed suppression under T5 and T6, as reflected in both weed density and weed dry weight, was accompanied by improved crop growth and productivity. These treatments produced the highest plant height, tiller density and dry matter accumulation among the herbicide treatments, approaching the weed-free treatment by harvest. This response is consistent with reduced weed competition, which can improve crop resource capture and sustain tiller development and biomass accumulation under reduced weed pressure (Abdullah Al Mamun, 2014). Importantly, the observed response should not be interpreted as evidence of a direct growth-promoting effect of the gelatin carrier, as the present experiment primarily demonstrates the crop response associated with improved weed suppression.
The yield response provides stronger evidence of the agronomic significance of the delivery system. T6 produced 5,710 kg ha−1, T5 produced 5,463 kg ha−1, and the corresponding conventional treatment T11 produced 4,755 kg ha−1, while the weed-free treatment produced 5,998 kg ha−1. Notably, the difference between T6 and the weed-free treatment was smaller than the reported critical difference, indicating statistical comparability under the experimental conditions. More importantly, the 247 kg ha−1 numerical difference between T6 and T5 was well below the reported critical difference of 705.16 kg ha−1. Thus, increasing the capsule loading from 100 to 150% did not provide a statistically demonstrable yield advantage over the recommended formulation rate.
This finding is consistent with the temporal weed-response data. T5 and T6 differed only marginally in AUWCEC and AUWDWC, indicating that the additional herbicide loading produced little additional reduction in cumulative weed pressure. The agronomic implication is therefore not that maximum capsule loading should be pursued, but that effective weed suppression approached a practical plateau at the recommended formulation rate. The capsule system consequently appears more valuable as a strategy for optimizing herbicide placement and use efficiency than as a justification for increasing herbicide loading.
4.4 Economic-threshold analysis supports formulation-rate optimization
The economic results reinforce the distinction between maximum biological performance and optimum input use. T6 generated the highest gross return (₹ 123,070 ha−1) and net return (₹ 71,821 ha−1), reflecting its numerically higher grain yield. However, T5 achieved the highest B:C ratio (2.42), compared with 2.40 for T6 and 2.25 for the corresponding conventional treatment. Thus, increasing the capsule loading from 100 to 150% increased absolute returns but did not improve economic efficiency, indicating that the recommended formulation rate provided the more favorable balance between weed-control performance and input investment.
The economic-threshold analysis provides complementary evidence for this formulation-rate distinction. T5 showed thresholds of 9.71 under the Stone and Pedigo approach and 4.23 under the Uygur and Mennan approach, whereas T6 recorded 11.42 and 5.14, respectively. The higher thresholds under T6 are consistent with its stronger biological response, but they should not be interpreted independently of treatment cost and realized profitability. In practical terms, the results indicate that the additional suppression achieved with 150% loading did not translate into a corresponding improvement in economic efficiency. Accordingly, T5 represents the more favorable optimization point under the conditions of this experiment: it achieved strong and sustained weed suppression, grain yield statistically comparable with T6, and the highest B:C ratio while avoiding the additional formulation loading. This distinction is consistent with the underlying principle of economic-threshold weed management, in which the objective is not complete weed eradication but economically justified control that balances crop-loss prevention against the cost of intervention (Das et al., 2021).
4.5 Agroecological and sustainability implications of biodegradable herbicide delivery
The principal sustainability implication of the technology is therefore its potential to improve herbicide-delivery efficiency rather than simply increase herbicide application. The strongest evidence is provided by T5, which at the same nominal recommended formulation rate as conventional Bensulfuron methyl + Pretilachlor produced greater cumulative weed suppression, lower cumulative weed biomass, high grain yield and the highest B:C ratio. This combination of weed-control effectiveness, crop productivity and economic efficiency provides a relevant basis for considering capsule-mediated delivery within more resource-efficient rice weed-management strategies.
The biodegradable gelatin carrier also showed no apparent short-term adverse response among the culturable microbial groups assessed. Bacterial, fungal and actinomycete populations increased following empty-capsule placement. However, these results should be interpreted only as preliminary evidence of compatibility with the measured culturable microbial populations. They do not establish improved soil health, microbial diversity or functional activity because culture-dependent methods capture only a fraction of the soil microbiome (Lee et al., 2021).
The environmental advantages of localized delivery require similar caution. Although capsule placement may provide a basis for reducing herbicide exposure outside the intended application zone, this study did not quantify drift, volatilization, runoff, leaching, residues or off-target transport. Previous research with gelatin-based delivery systems has demonstrated that polymeric matrices can modify herbicide release and, in some formulations, reduce leaching potential (Singh et al., 2024), but such effects cannot be assumed for the present capsule system. Consequently, these should be regarded as potential advantages requiring direct validation, rather than demonstrated environmental outcomes. The same applies to herbicide release and capsule degradation, which were not measured.
Within this evidence boundary, the technology has clear relevance to sustainable food-system objectives. Improved rice productivity under effective weed suppression relates directly to SDG 2 (Zero Hunger), while achieving comparable or improved productivity at an optimized formulation rate supports SDG 12 (Responsible Consumption and Production) through more efficient use of agricultural inputs. The preliminary absence of an adverse response among the measured culturable microbial groups provides a cautious basis for considering compatibility with soil biological components potentially relevant to SDG 15 (Life on Land), but this connection should not be interpreted as evidence of broader ecological improvement. The sustainability contribution of the technology is therefore best framed around demonstrated agronomic and economic efficiency, with environmental benefits remaining an important but unresolved research question. Accordingly, the environmental relevance of the technology should be viewed in terms of biodegradable carrier-based delivery and localized application, rather than demonstrated biodegradation or reduced environmental pollution. Further assessment of residues, runoff and leaching is needed to validate these potential benefits.
Overall, the findings support a formulation-specific rather than universal case for gelatin capsule-mediated herbicide delivery. The technology was most effective when paired with Bensulfuron methyl + Pretilachlor, for which the recommended 100% capsule treatment combined sustained weed suppression, crop productivity and economic efficiency without the additional formulation loading used at 150%. Future research should therefore move beyond agronomic validation toward direct characterization of capsule degradation and herbicide release, residue dynamics, runoff and leaching, off-target transport, and longer-term soil biological responses across multiple environments. Such evidence will determine whether the demonstrated gain in herbicide-delivery efficiency can be translated into verifiable environmental benefits at field and production-system scales.
5 Conclusion
Gelatin capsule-mediated herbicide delivery demonstrated potential as an input-efficient approach for weed management in transplanted rice, with its effectiveness varying according to the herbicide formulation and application rate. Among the treatments evaluated, the 100% formulation rate of Bensulfuron methyl 0.6% + Pretilachlor 6% GR delivered through gelatin capsules provided the most favorable overall balance of weed suppression, crop productivity and economic performance, outperforming its corresponding conventional application while achieving the highest benefit: cost ratio. Its statistically comparable grain yield with the 150% capsule treatment further indicates that increasing the formulation rate beyond the recommended level provided limited additional productivity benefit. The temporal analysis similarly demonstrated stronger cumulative weed suppression and lower cumulative weed biomass under the 100% capsule treatment than under the corresponding conventional application, supporting the value of formulation-rate optimization rather than increased herbicide loading. The absence of an apparent adverse response in the measured culturable soil microbial populations following empty-capsule placement provides preliminary evidence of carrier compatibility under the experimental conditions. Overall, the findings support biodegradable gelatin capsules as a promising platform for targeted and input-efficient herbicide delivery, particularly for Bensulfuron methyl + Pretilachlor in transplanted rice. Future research should focus on release kinetics, environmental fate, and longer-term soil biological responses, off-target transport for direct seeded rice while further optimizing capsule composition and delivery characteristics across diverse rice-growing environments.
Statements
Data availability statement
The original contributions presented in the study are included in the article/Supplementary material, further inquiries can be directed to the corresponding author.
Author contributions
RS: Formal analysis, Writing – review & editing, Data curation, Writing – original draft, Visualization. PA: Writing – review & editing, Conceptualization, Supervision, Project administration, Writing – original draft. MD: Validation, Resources, Supervision, Writing – review & editing. SF: Methodology, Visualization, Resources, Writing – review & editing. KS: Resources, Software, Writing – review & editing.
Funding
The author(s) declared that financial support was not received for this work and/or its publication.
Acknowledgments
The authors gratefully acknowledge the support and resources provided by the Tamil Nadu Agricultural University, Coimbatore, which were instrumental in doing the research.
Conflict of interest
The author(s) declared that this work was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
The author MD declared that they were an editorial board member of Frontiers, at the time of submission. This had no impact on the peer review process and the final decision.
Generative AI statement
The author(s) declared that Generative AI was used in the creation of this manuscript. We acknowledge the use of “Grammarly” software. It was utilized to enhance the clarity and readability of the manuscript, ensuring a polished and well-written document. After utilizing this tool, the authors reviewed and revised the text as necessary. They assume full responsibility for the content of the publication.
Any alternative text (alt text) provided alongside figures in this article has been generated by Frontiers with the support of artificial intelligence and reasonable efforts have been made to ensure accuracy, including review by the authors wherever possible. If you identify any issues, please contact us.
Publisher’s note
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.
Supplementary material
The Supplementary material for this article can be found online at: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fsufs.2026.1967832/full#supplementary-material
References
1
Abdullah Al MamunM. (2014). Modelling rice-weed competition in direct-seeded rice cultivation. Agric. Res.3, 346–352. doi: 10.1007/s40003-014-0138-2
2
Al MamunM.ShultanaR.BhuiyanK.MridhaJ.MazidA. (2011). Economic weed management options in winter rice. Pak. J. Weed Sci. Res.17, 323–331.
3
AnishaN.FanishS. A.ArthanariP. M.VanithaK. (2022). Effect of early post-emergence herbicides on photosynthetic pigments and yield in greengram (Vigna radiata L.). IJPSS 34, 461–467. doi: 10.9734/ijpss/2022/v34i2131284
4
ArthanariP. M. (2023). Weed management with Triafamone herbicide in transplanted rice ecosystem. Emir. J. Food Agric.35, 351–356. doi: 10.9755/ejfa.2023.v35.i4.3027
5
ArthanariM.GowthamiS.ChinnusamyC.PriyaR. S.HariharasudhanV. (2017). Early post emergence herbicide and their influence on weed population dynamics in transplanted rice (Oryza sativa L.). Chem. Sci. Rev. Lett.6, 561–566.
6
ArthanariP. M.SabarivasanR. (2024). Herbicide Delivery Capsule for Agricultural Crops. Registered Design No. 432328-001, Intellectual Property India, The Patent Office, Government of India.
7
ArthanariP. M.SabarivasanR.BharathiC. (2025). A Method for Delivering Herbicides Using Biodegradable Gelatin Capsules for Targeted Application. Indian Patent Application Publication No. 20241103293 A, Official Journal of the Patent Office, Journal No. 02/2025.
8
BhagavathiM. S.AjithkumarM.SandhiyaR. (2024). Management of jungle rice (Echinochloa colona) through herbicides in transplanted rice. Indian J. Weed Sci.56, 19–23. doi: 10.5958/0974-8164.2024.00004.2
9
DasT. K.SenS.RajR.GhoshS.BeheraB.RoyA. (2021). Economic threshold concept for weed management in crops: usefulness and limitation. Indian J. Weed Sci.53, 1–13. doi: 10.5958/0974-8164.2021.00001.0
10
DhillonB. S.VijayakumarS.VijL.GopalakrishnanS.Mahender KumarR.SundaramR. M. (2026). Yield performance of imidazolinone-tolerant basmati rice genotypes under dry direct-seeded conditions and its impact on succeeding crops. Front. Sustain. Food Syst.10:1793203. doi: 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1793203
11
DriverK. E.Becerra-AlvarezA.MesgaranM. B.Al-KhatibK. (2024). Emergence timing of smallflower umbrella sedge (Cyperus difformis), barnyardgrass (Echinochloa crus-galli), and bearded sprangletop (Leptochloa fusca spp. fascicularis) in California water-seeded rice. Weed Technol.38:e8. doi: 10.1017/wet.2024.2
12
GautamK. C.ManiV. S.SharmaR. K. (1975). A note on comparative efficiency, selectivity and residual toxicity of some soil-applied herbicides in soybean. Indian J. Weed Sci.7, 72–74.
13
HundalR. K.BhullarM. S. (2023). Enhancing herbicide efficacy with improved spray technology adoption in rice-wheat cropping system. Indian J. Weed Sci.55, 169–173. doi: 10.5958/0974-8164.2023.00030.8
14
KithanL. M.SomasundaramE.SuryaK.PalanisamyM. A.KannanR.PonnusamyJ.et al. (2026). Transplanted rice response to non-chemical weed management in a degraded wetland ecosystem. Front. Sustain. Food Syst.10:1620579. doi: 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1620579
15
KnightG. K. (1936). A method for the isolation of actinomycetes. Soil Sci.41, 207–210.
16
KrishnamurtyK.RajashekaraB. G.RaghunathaG. (1975). Herbicidal efficiency index in sorghum. Indian J. Weed Sci.7, 75–79.
17
KumarG. A.ShuklaR. K.KeshryP. K.GhoshS.ChhabraM. (2023). To study the effect of integrated weed management practices on weeds parameters of transplanted rice in Chhattisgarh plains. IJPSS35, 336–342. doi: 10.9734/ijpss/2023/v35i213982
18
LeeJ.KimH.-S.JoH. Y.KwonM. J. (2021). Revisiting soil bacterial counting methods: optimal soil storage and pretreatment methods and comparison of culture-dependent and -independent methods. PLoS One16:e0246142. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0246142,
19
ManiV. S.MallaM. L.GautamK. C.BhagwandasB. (1973). Weed-killing chemicals in potato cultivation. Indian Farming23, 17–18.
20
MartinJ. P. (1950). Use of acid, rose bengal, and streptomycin in the plate method for estimating soil fungi. Soil Sci.69, 215–232. doi: 10.1097/00010694-195003000-00006
21
MirM. S.SinghP.KanthR. H.ShahZ. A.DarE. A.BhatJ. A.et al. (2024). Influence of sowing dates and weed management practices on weed dynamics, productivity and profitability of direct seeded rice. Sci. Rep.14:18877. doi: 10.1038/s41598-024-69519-9,
22
MishraK. (2019). Effect of herbicide bensulfuron methyl plus pretilachlor in weed management of transplanted kharif rice (Oryza sativa L.). J. Pharmacogn. Phytochem.8, 378–382.
23
NayakH. S.McDonaldA. J.KumarV.CraufurdP.DubeyS. K.NayakA. K.et al. (2024). Context-dependent agricultural intensification pathways to increase rice production in India. Nat. Commun.15:8403. doi: 10.1038/s41467-024-52448-6,
24
O’BrienC. J.MellorV.GaleaV. J. (2022). Controlling woody weed Chinese elm (Celtis sinensis Pers.) with stem-implanted herbicide capsules. Plants11:444. doi: 10.3390/plants11030444,
25
PaulR. A. I.ArthanariP. M.PeramaiyanP.KumarV.BagavathiannanM.SabarivasanR. (2025). UAV-based herbicide application for efficient weed control and resource savings in direct-seeded rice. Crop Prot.190:107129. doi: 10.1016/j.cropro.2025.107129
26
R Core Team (2025). R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. Vienna, Austria: R Foundation for Statistical Computing.
27
SaiM. V., G.Murugan, PerumalM. S.KathiraveluC (2022). A phytosociological survey on weed flora and diversity in rice fields of Chidambaram block, T.N., India. EEC28, 454–458. doi:DOI: 10.53550/EEC.2022.v28i07s.075
28
SchortgenG. P.PattonA. J. (2024). Improved control of Taraxacum officinale with 2,4-D in the field from ammonium sulphate additions. Weed Res.64, 119–126. doi: 10.1111/wre.12609
29
SellaperumalP.KaliaperumalR.DhanarajuM.SudarmanianN. S.ShanmugapriyaP.SatheeshS.et al. (2025). Time series analysis of sentinel 1 A SAR data to retrieve annual rice area maps and long-term dynamics of start of season. Sci. Rep.15:8202. doi: 10.1038/s41598-025-91655-z,
30
ShahM. H.MandalB.MukherjeeD.GaraiS.AktarN. S. (2025). Efficacy of pre- and post-emergence herbicides in managing weeds and improving productivity of rice under new alluvial zone. Indian J. Weed Sci.57, 277–284. doi: 10.5958/0974-8164.2025.00048.5
31
SimkoI.PiephoH.-P. (2012). The area under the disease Progress stairs: calculation, advantage, and application. Phytopathology102, 381–389. doi: 10.1094/PHYTO-07-11-0216,
32
SinghJ.SinghB.Vishavnath (2024). Agar-gelatin-derived hydrogel-based controlled delivery devices for linuron herbicide to prevent environmental hazards. Environ. Chem. Ecotoxicol.6, 153–163. doi: 10.1016/j.enceco.2024.05.006
33
SinghI. D.StoskopfN. C. (1971). Harvest index in cereals. Agron. J.63, 224–226. doi: 10.2134/agronj1971.00021962006300020008x
34
StoneJ. D.PedigoL. P. (1972). Development and economic-injury level of the green cloverworm on soybean in Iowa. J. Econ. Entomol.65, 197–201. doi: 10.1093/jee/65.1.197
35
TejaK. C.DuaryB.KumarM.BhowmickM. K. (2015). Effect of Bensulfuron-methyl+Pretilachlor and other herbicides on mixed weed flora of wet season transplanted rice. Intern. Jour. of Agricul., Environ. and Biotech8:323. doi: 10.5958/2230-732X.2015.00040.6
36
TravlouE.AntonopoulosN.GazoulisI.KanatasP. (2024). Chemical weed control and crop injuries due to spray drift: the case of dicamba. Agrochemicals3, 22–28. doi: 10.3390/agrochemicals3010003
37
UygurF. N.MennanH. (1995) A Study on economic Threshold of Galium aparine L. and Bifora radians Bieb. in wheat fields in Samsun-Turkey ANPP Seizième Conférence du COLUMA: Journées Internationale sur la Lutte Contre les Mauvaises Herbes Association Nationale pour la Protection des Plantes (ANPP)347–354
38
VijayakumarV.AmpatzidisY.SchuellerJ. K.BurksT. (2023). Smart spraying technologies for precision weed management: a review. Smart Agric. Technol.6:100337. doi: 10.1016/j.atech.2023.100337
39
WilsonH. T.AmirkhaniM.TaylorA. G. (2018). Evaluation of gelatin as a biostimulant seed treatment to improve plant performance. Front. Plant Sci.9:1006. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2018.01006,
40
YakadriM.SuvidhM. S.VaishnavS. (2022). A review on integrated Weed Management in transplanted Rice. IJPSS34, 238–247. doi: 10.9734/ijpss/2022/v34i2231374,
41
YanD.WangQ.MaoL.XieH.GuoM.CaoA. (2012). Evaluation of chloropicrin gelatin capsule formulation as a soil fumigant for greenhouse strawberry in China. J. Agric. Food Chem.60, 5023–5027. doi: 10.1021/jf300532x,
42
YoshidaS.FornoD. A.CockJ. H. (1971). Laboratory Manual for Physiological Studies of rice. Los Baños, Philippines: International Rice Research Institute (IRRI).
Summary
Keywords
biodegradable delivery, gelatin capsules, herbicide application, rice, sustainable intensification, weed management
Citation
Sabarivasan R, Arthanari PM, Djanaguiraman M, Fanish SA and Sellamuthu KM (2026) A novel biodegradable gelatin capsule platform for input-efficient herbicide delivery in transplanted rice. Front. Sustain. Food Syst. 10:1967832. doi: 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1967832
Received
14 August 2026
Revised
07 October 2026
Accepted
10 October 2026
Published
27 October 2026
Volume
10 - 2026
Edited by
Aurelio Scavo, University of Messina, Italy
Reviewed by
Manivannan Paramasivan, Muthayammal Memorial College of Artsm and Science, India
Satya Narayan Satapathy, Siksha O Anusandhan University, India
Mona Nagargade, ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute, India
Updates
Copyright
© 2026 Sabarivasan, Arthanari, Djanaguiraman, Fanish and Sellamuthu.
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
*Correspondence: Palanisamy Murali Arthanari, agronmurali@tnau.ac.in
Disclaimer
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.