Skip to main content

Orphan Crops: Breeding and Biotechnology for Sustainable Agriculture, Food and Nutrition

Cover image for Research Topic "Orphan Crops: Breeding and Biotechnology for Sustainable Agriculture, Food and Nutrition"
268kviews
Editorial: Orphan crops: breeding and biotechnology for sustainable agriculture, food and nutrition
Editorial04 January 2024
Editorial: Orphan crops: breeding and biotechnology for sustainable agriculture, food and nutrition

The ultimate goal of most crop improvement programs is to improve productivity, by raising genetic potential as well as by tackling the major production constraints. Most orphan crops continue to suffer from low productivity, a situation exemplified by comparing the productivity of an orphan crop, millet, and the major crop, wheat, in Asia and Africa over six decades (Figure 1). The term "millet" refers to several grain crops grown as staple foods in Asia and Africa. Approximately 15 crops are known as millets, including pearl millet (Pennisetum glaucum), finger millet (Eleusine coracana), foxtail millet (Setaria italica), and proso millet (Panicum miliaceum), the most important in a particular region based on the area under cultivation and the amount of production. Although the productivity levels of both wheat and millet were similar in the early 1960s, due to the advancement of research and development of improved varieties of wheat, the grain yield shows substantial increase, while that of millet was not significantly changed from that of the 1960s. It is important to note that the grain yield of wheat grown in Africa has not increased to the level of that in Asia. While wheat productivity has been steadily increasing in Asia, it has fluctuated extensively in Africa due to several reasons, including the environmental conditions and a lack of adapted varieties and required inputs. However, the productivity of wheat in Asia is still low compared to countries in North and West Europe where the grain yield has already reached 10 ton/ha (FAOSTAT, 2023). In 2021, millets were globally cultivated on 31.8 million hectares of land although their total production was only 32.7 million tons (FAOSTAT, 2023).

The trend in the grain yield of an orphan crop, millet, and a major crop, wheat, from 1961 to 2021 in Africa and Asia. Millet refers to a group of 15 crops that are extensively cultivated for food and feed in Asia and Africa. Adapted from (FAOSTAT, 2023).This special issue of Frontiers in Plant Science is comprised of 22 articles, of which 17 represent original research and five are review articles. Various categories of orphan crops are featured, including cereals, legumes, vegetables, and root and tuber crops as well as non-food plants. Cereals are represented by finger millet (Eleusine coracana) and pearl millet (Pennisetum glaucum) and pseudo-cereals are represented by chia (Salvia hispanica), which provides a rich source of protein, fiber and polyunsaturated fatty acids. Pseudo-cereals refer to crops that do not belong to the Grass Family, being dicotyledonous whereas grasses are monocotyledonous. However, pseudo-cereals show their close relationship to the 'true cereals' by their nutritional content especially with regards to the carbohydrate composition. Orphan legumes, which are the major protein source, are represented by Bambara groundnut (Vigna subterranean), rice bean (Vigna umbellata), lablab bean (Lablab purpureus) and horse gram (Macrotyloma uniflorum). Of importance, Bambara groundnut seeds are highly nutritious and known as a complete food since they contain adequate quantities of protein (19%), carbohydrate (63%), and fat (6.5%) (NRC, 2006). They furthermore have excellent antioxidant properties (Nyau et al., 2015). While lablab bean is native to Eastern Africa, rice bean and horse gram are vital protein sources in Asia (Aditya et al., 2019;Pattanayak et al., 2019). Orphan vegetables are represented by okra (Abelmoschus esculentus), thickhead or obolo (Crassocephalum crepidiodes), and spider plant (Gynandropsis gynandra). In addition to its use as a leafy vegetable, C. crepidiodes is also used as a medicinal plant in Africa. The study published here shows that it accumulates the Pyrrolizidine Alkaloid (PA) Jacobine in response to nitrogen deficiency. Spider plant is rich in vitamins, secondary metabolites and minerals. Sesame (Sesamum indicum) and shea (Vitellaria paradoxa) represent oil crops. While sesame is extensively cultivated globally for its high-quality oil and antioxidant lignans, such as sesamin and sesamolin (Moazzami and Kamal-Eldin, 2006), shea is a tree crop grown in the sub-Saharan Africa for both the oil and butter.Among the root and tuber crops, cassava (Manihot esculenta), sweet potato (Ipomoea batatas) and enset (Ensete ventricosum) are represented. In 2021, cassava was globally cultivated on 30 million hectares of land with the total production of 320 million tons (FAOSTAT, 2023). Cassava is a staple crop for millions of small-holder farmers and consumers particularly in Africa, where its high drought tolerance and outstanding performance on nutrient-poor soils means it survives when other crops would fail. Enset, which is also known as 'false banana', is also a staple food for over 20 million people in the densely populated regions of Ethiopia (Borrell et al., 2019).Robust breeding techniques and statistical tools were reported in several articles. These include the comparison of AMMI and BLUP selection in finger millet; generation mean analysis in pearl millet, and breeding potential of Bambara groundnut. The tools indicated in the first two papers enable breeders to identify high-yielding genotypes with stable performance, while the review on Bambara groundnut addresses the potential and opportunities of this orphan legume in food and nutritional security, especially in Africa.Two articles report how to minimize the effect of major pests and diseases, particularly nematodes from the planting material of enset and cassava brown streak disease (CBSD). Since nematodes cause severe damage to enset, appropriate management options were suggested to make the planting material free of nematodes. CBSD, which is caused by two virus species, results in up to 100% yield loss in cassava. The authors recommended applying rigorous sanitary systems in order to obtain virus-free cassava planting material.In addition to conventional methods, plant breeding applies genomic technologies such as the use of molecular markers. In this regard, two publications showed how molecular markers are effectively implemented for different purposes. In the first, SNPs were used to map the capsule-shattering trait in sesame, while in the second, novel ESTs were used in identifying genetic diversity among finger millet accessions. Capsule shattering is the major constraint in sesame cultivation, as it hinders mechanized harvesting, and reduces yield. Hence, the discovery of the genes influencing expression of capsule shattering and subsequent targeted manipulation could boost sesame productivity substantially. Discovery of novel ESTs has allowed identification of substantial genetic variations for important traits among 55 finger millet landraces.Whole genome sequencing and/or transcriptomics were reported in four orphan crops. These papers include the de novo genome sequence of rice bean; genome and transcriptome of horse gram; genomic resources of shea tree; and a gene expression atlas of chia. In addition, the genome sequence of Pongamia pinnata, a non-food plant with the potential for biodiesel production, was also reported. Information from these whole-genome and/or transcriptome analyses have applications in many areas of plant improvement. These resources set the stage for genomics applications in these crop species.Three articles focused on biotechnology. The first aims to determine efficient transformation and regeneration protocols for farmer-preferred cassava cultivars, while the remaining two are review papers on the benefits of biotechnology and perspectives for gene editing in orphan crops. Although biotechnology has significant economic benefits to farmers and consumers, there are potential hurdles to commercialization of crop varieties with gene-edited traits in terms of biosafety evaluation and regulatory oversight. Countries such as Kenya and Nigeria lead in terms of biosafety capacity while other African countries are slower to put biosafety infrastructure in place. Gene editing by CRISPR/Cas has excellent potential in improving orphan crops. However, the absence of transformation and regeneration methods for most orphan crops may affect the application of the technique in the immediate future.Two papers focused on the benefits of orphan crops in human nutrition. One describes the leaf elemental composition in spider plant while the other reviews aspects of dietary enrichment of orphan crops in marginal environments. In the former, a study of 70 spider plant lines revealed significant differences in micronutrient composition, demonstrating the potential to increase nutritive content through plant breeding. In general, zinc, calcium, phosphorus, copper, magnesium, and manganese represented landmark elements in the spider plant genotypes.Several papers collectively investigated the acceptance of new orphan crop varieties by farmers and applied farmers' selection criteria in their breeding programs. These include: farmers' feedback on okra characterization; acceptability of Vitamin-A-biofortified sweet potato; and farmers' participatory selection of lablab bean lines. The study on okra identified farmers' preferred traits for establishing breeding programs. In an effort to tackle vitamin-A deficiency in sub-Saharan African countries, 14 newly introduced orange-fleshed sweet potato varieties were investigated for their acceptance by farmers, showing that farmers accepted the dry matter content and taste of all introduced varieties. Based on a study with 31 farmers in five districts in Tanzania, farmers' preferred traits were identified in lablab bean, with pest and disease resistances, early maturity, and high yield prioritized as the most important traits.Lastly, the review paper on the exploitation of orphan legumes for food, income, and nutrition security provides an excellent overview on the potential of African crops for improving the nutrition of the African population, and points to the need for genetic improvement of these highly nutritious, culturallyimportant crops using modern breeding and genomic techniques.In general, the papers in this special issue provide substantial information to the crop improvement community and policy makers. It is important to provide due attention to the need for more productive varieties of orphan crops (Tadele, 2019) since these neglected crops in terms of scientific research deserve modern improvement approaches such as speed breeding (Chiurugwi et al., 2019), advanced molecular breeding techniques (Ribaut and Ragot, 2019), and applications of genomics (Jamnadass et al., 2020). In addition, the benefits of orphan crops in human nutrition and health need to be promoted by relevant stakeholders to advance their cultivation and further expand their consumption (Knez et al., 2023).

3,247 views

9 citations

ORIGINAL RESEARCH
4 October 2022
De novo genome assembly of rice bean (Vigna umbellata) – A nominated nutritionally rich future crop reveals novel insights into flowering potential, habit, and palatability centric – traits for efficient domestication
Tanushri Kaul, 11 more and Balamuralikrishnan Balasubramanian

8,250 views

25 citations

ORIGINAL RESEARCH
22 July 2022
Risk factors associated with cassava brown streak disease dissemination through seed pathways in Eastern D.R. Congo
Yves Kwibuka, 6 more and Sebastien Massart

4,184 views

11 citations

REVIEW
23 June 2022
Opportunities for Orphan Crops: Expected Economic Benefits From Biotechnology
Patricia Zambrano, 8 more and Judith A. Chambers

7,874 views

12 citations

Comparative Study of AMMI- and BLUP-Based Simultaneous Selection for Grain Yield and Stability of Finger Millet [Eleusine coracana (L.) Gaertn.] Genotypes
ORIGINAL RESEARCH
6 January 2022
Comparative Study of AMMI- and BLUP-Based Simultaneous Selection for Grain Yield and Stability of Finger Millet [Eleusine coracana (L.) Gaertn.] Genotypes
N. Anuradha, 7 more and Vilas A. Tonapi
Finger millet, an orphan crop, possesses immense potential in mitigating climate change and could offer three-fold security in terms of food, fodder, and nutrition. It is mostly cultivated as a subsistence crop in the marginal areas of plains and hills. Considering the changes in climate inclusive of recurrent weather vagaries witnessed every year, it is crucial to select stable, high-yielding, area-specific, finger millet cultivars. Sixty finger millet varieties released across the country were evaluated over six consecutive rainy seasons from 2011 to 2016 at the Agricultural Research Station, Vizianagaram. The genotype × environment interaction (GEI) was found to be significant in the combined ANOVA. Further, AMMI analysis asserted that genotypes and the GEI effects accounted for approximately 89 percent of the total variation. Strong positive associations were observed in an estimated set of eleven stability parameters that can be chosen to identify stable genotypes. Further, non-parametric and parametric simultaneous selection indexes (NP-SSI & P-SSI) were calculated utilizing AMMI-based stability parameter (ASTAB), modified AMMI stability value (MASV) and Modified AMMI stability index (MASI) to identify stable high yielders. Both methods had inherent difficulties in ranking genotypes for SSI. To overcome this, the initial culling (C-SSI) of genotypes was introduced for stability. In the C-SSI method, the top ten genotypes were above-average yielders, while those with below-average yield were observed in NP-SSI and P-SSI methods. Similarly, estimation of Best Linear Unbiased Prediction (BLUP) based simultaneous selections like Harmonic Mean of Genotypic Values (HMGV), Relative Performance of Genotypic Values (RPGV), and Harmonic Mean of Relative Performance of Genotypic Values (HMRPGV) revealed that none of the top ten entries were below-average yield. The study has proven that C-SSI and BLUP-based methods were equally worthy in the selection of high-yielding genotypes with stable performance. However, the C-SSI approach could be the best method to ensure that genotypes with a considerable amount of stability were selected. The multi-year trial SSI revealed that entries Indaf-9, Sri Chaitanya, PR-202 and A-404 were ascertained to be the most stable high-yielding (>3000 kg/ha) genotypes among medium to late duration while VL324 and VL146 among early entries.

7,494 views

74 citations

ORIGINAL RESEARCH
28 January 2022
Generation Mean Analysis Reveals the Predominant Gene Effects for Grain Iron and Zinc Contents in Pearl Millet
Mahesh Pujar, 5 more and K. M. Satish

10,222 views

11 citations

Constant production of quality food should be a norm in any community, but climate change, increasing population, and unavailability of land for farming affect food production. As a result, food scarcity is affecting some communities, especially in the developing world. Finding a stable solution to this problem is a major cause of concern for researchers. Synergistic application of molecular marker techniques with next generation sequencing (NGS) technologies can unlock the potentials hidden in most crop genomes for improving yield and food availability. Most crops such as Bambara groundnut (BGN), Winged bean, and African yam bean are underutilized. These underutilized crops can compete with the major crops such as cowpea, soybean, maize, and rice, in areas of nutrition, ability to withstand drought stress, economic importance, and food production. One of these underutilized crops, Bambara groundnut (Vigna subterranea (L.), Verdc.), is an indigenous African legume and can survive in tropical climates and marginal soils. In this review, we focus on the roles of BGN and the opportunities it possesses in tackling food insecurity and its benefits to local farmers. We will discuss BGN’s potential impact on global food production and how the advances in NGS technologies can enhance its production.

11,340 views

57 citations

Gene editing provides precise, heritable genome mutagenesis without permanent transgenesis, and has been widely demonstrated and applied in planta. In the past decade, CRISPR/Cas has revolutionized the application of gene editing in crops, with mechanistic advances expanding its potential, including prime editing and base editing. To date, CRISPR/Cas has been utilized in over a dozen orphan crops with diverse genetic backgrounds, leading to novel alleles and beneficial phenotypes for breeders, growers, and consumers. In conjunction with the adoption of science-based regulatory practices, there is potential for CRISPR/Cas-mediated gene editing in orphan crop improvement programs to solve a plethora of agricultural problems, especially impacting developing countries. Genome sequencing has progressed, becoming more affordable and applicable to orphan crops. Open-access resources allow for target gene identification and guide RNA design and evaluation, with modular cloning systems and enzyme screening methods provide experimental feasibility. While the genomic and mechanistic limitations are being overcome, crop transformation and regeneration continue to be the bottleneck for gene editing applications. International collaboration between all stakeholders involved in crop improvement is vital to provide equitable access and bridge the scientific gap between the world’s most economically important crops and the most under-researched crops. This review describes the mechanisms and workflow of CRISPR/Cas in planta and addresses the challenges, current applications, and future prospects in orphan crops.

23,053 views

57 citations

Genomic Resources to Guide Improvement of the Shea Tree
ORIGINAL RESEARCH
9 September 2021
Genomic Resources to Guide Improvement of the Shea Tree
Iago Hale, 13 more and Allen Van Deynze
A defining component of agroforestry parklands across Sahelo-Sudanian Africa (SSA), the shea tree (Vitellaria paradoxa) is central to sustaining local livelihoods and the farming environments of rural communities. Despite its economic and cultural value, however, not to mention the ecological roles it plays as a dominant parkland species, shea remains semi-domesticated with virtually no history of systematic genetic improvement. In truth, shea’s extended juvenile period makes traditional breeding approaches untenable; but the opportunity for genome-assisted breeding is immense, provided the foundational resources are available. Here we report the development and public release of such resources. Using the FALCON-Phase workflow, 162.6 Gb of long-read PacBio sequence data were assembled into a 658.7 Mbp, chromosome-scale reference genome annotated with 38,505 coding genes. Whole genome duplication (WGD) analysis based on this gene space revealed clear signatures of two ancient WGD events in shea’s evolutionary past, one prior to the Astrid-Rosid divergence (116-126 Mya) and the other at the root of the order Ericales (65-90 Mya). In a first genome-wide look at the suite of fatty acid (FA) biosynthesis genes that likely govern stearin content, the primary determinant of shea butter quality, relatively high copy numbers of six key enzymes were found (KASI, KASIII, FATB, FAD2, FAD3, and FAX2), some likely originating in shea’s more recent WGD event. To help translate these findings into practical tools for characterization, selection, and genome-wide association studies (GWAS), resequencing data from a shea diversity panel was used to develop a database of more than 3.5 million functionally-annotated, physically-anchored SNPs. Two smaller, more curated sets of suggested SNPs, one for GWAS (104,211 SNPs) and the other targeting FA biosynthesis genes (90 SNPs), are also presented. With these resources, the hope is to support national programs across the shea belt in the strategic, genome-enabled conservation and long-term improvement of the shea tree for SSA.

17,021 views

34 citations