significantly associated with country differences regarding the duration of the stay-athome orders and further called for a reduction of burden and symptoms of anxiety or depression for caregivers and care recipients.Another study by Qazi et al., using Gray Incidence Analysis Model (Gray Relational Analysis), evaluated the health systems at the country level. They reported that the healthcare system of advanced countries, i.e., the UK, USA, France, Denmark, etc. (almost the whole of western Europe/Schengen area/OECD), has a very poor response to the shock of the COVID-19 pandemic, which is in contrast to the myth that these countries have the best healthcare systems in the world. However, 30 countries are categorized as countries having much better health systems, most of which are member countries of the Southern Africa Development Community. Another interesting study from Italy by Blasi et al., to renovate the current healthcare system and guarantee equal access to health services, have proposed a multidisciplinary Think Tank and proposed a manifesto with six drivers for change: vision, governance, competence, intelligence, humanity, and relationship. Further, each driver was linked to action to actively move toward a new healthcare system based on trust between science, citizens, and institutions. Some of the articles have emphasized the role of health systems strengthening and, in this context, Cuschieri et al. have highlighted the Cypriot resilience plan in response to the lessons learned from the pandemic put forward by the Government of the Republic of Cyprus with 6% of the total budget (74.1 million euros) to be allocated on strengthening the capacity of the Global Health Security and supporting public health protection. They further called for the Cypriot government and other states with a similar population or geographical distribution to consider the transformation for public health emergency preparedness and transition to a working syndemic model. Similarly, a Mexican study by Ramos Herrera et al., have highlighted the timely installation and work of the University of Guadalajara-health situation room helped the state of Jalisco in Mexico to maintain one of the lowest incidence and mortality rates in the country.Globally, the COVID-19 pandemic had several impacts on various dimensions, including the global economy. An in-depth analysis by Tang et al. on the impact of the UHC Healthcare system on stock returns during COVID-19 found that the sudden onset of an epidemic disease results in unevenly distributed medical system resources, consequently diminishing the impact of UHC on abnormal returns. Further, the study concluded that abnormal cumulate returns emerge at the early stages of the pandemic, signifying that the strategy of investment as a sudden reaction to the outbreak is normally at the beginning of the pandemic and that a well-organized UHC system is a key factor in avoiding the risk of damage to stock markets as a result of a sudden outbreak. Da Silva et al. have analyzed the relationship between the country's gross domestic product and COVID-19 mortality globally and have reported various scenarios. Their statistical analysis did not reveal any relationship between GDP per capita and the COVID-19 mortality rate. With a base GDP-per capita level of US$1200, a significant statistical relationship (at 5%level) between GDP per capita and COVID-19 mortality rate can no longer be found (p = 0.0588).An epidemiological study of COVID-19 in Saudi Arabia using the data from the Ministry of Health, as reported by Salam et al., has highlighted that though COVID-19 transmission since March 2020 is considered to be widespread, creating an excess burden on the public health system, the disciplined life in compliance with law and order paved the way for effective program implementation and epidemic control. In terms of the dynamics between urbanization and infectious disease spread, a Chinese national study by Yu et al., have concluded that urban education, employment and entrepreneurship, housing, medical and health care, and other basic public services brought by urbanization can help reduce the risk of the spread of infectious diseases. However, the increasing density of buildings caused by land urbanization increases the risk of spreading infectious diseases. Another study in China by Ruishi Si et al. investigated the links between the COVID-19 vaccination and public attitudes toward protective countermeasures have found that gender, age, education level, occupation risk, individual health risk perception, public health risk perception, social responsibility, peer effect, and government supervision are the main drivers for participants to be vaccinated. The results further show that vaccination lessened participants' frequency of hand washing by 1.75 times and their compliance frequency intensity of observing physical distancing by 1.24 times. However, the rate of mask-wearing did not reduce significantly, implying that China's main countermeasure of effective mask-wearing effectively controls COVID-19.UHC demands a multifaceted strategy. Primary health care and life course approaches are crucial. A primary healthcare strategy focuses on organizing and developing health systems so individuals can obtain services for their health and well-being based on their needs and preferences as early as possible and in their everyday settings. Two aspects should be considered when tracking progress toward UHC: 1) The proportion of a population that has access to basic, high-quality health care (SDG 3.8.1) and 2) The proportion of the population that spends a significant portion of their family income on health (SDG 3.8.2). In this regard, Frank et al. have highlighted that Canada ranks highest in the world on the UHC Service Coverage Index, at 89 on a scale of 0 to 100, surpassing comparator countries such as Australia, New Zealand, Norway, the UK, Netherlands, Sweden, and other G-7 nations including the USA, France, Germany. However, they emphasized that UHC systems could easily fall prey to powerful and wealthy forces worldwide, seeking to make healthcare just another profitable business commodity citing the example of "Cambie Trial" (Cambie Surgeries Corporation v. British Columbia). In this context, Montagu shared the European experience in involving the private sector in achieving UHC, where it can be effectively provided with or without large-scale private sector provision in hospital, specialty, and primary care services, and moreover, it can be provided with high levels of patient satisfaction. The study further claimed that the European examples provide critical insight for governments of low-and-middle-income countries that large-scale privately provided medical services are neither necessary for achieving UHC nor a barrier to it. A recent article by Lal et al. highlighted that Health systems designed for UHC had been shown to support communities more equitably through primary health care (Lal et al., 2022).In conclusion, the nations and states that progress toward achieving UHC will certainly make progress toward other health-related targets and goals. Good health allows children to learn and adults to earn, helps people escape from poverty and provides the basis for sustainable economic development. Therefore, this special issue provides original research, reviews, and evidence-based policy recommendations from various geographical regions in achieving the target of UHC amid the COVID-19 pandemic. The COVID-19 pandemic highlighted the critical significance of the health and care workforce and the importance of increasing spending in this sector to reap the economic benefits at the national level.
Editorial04 January 2023
Editorial: Reimagining universal health coverage and other global health targets in the post-COVID-19 eraThe aging of the population, the burden of chronic diseases, possible new pandemics are the challenges for healthcare in the XXI century. Technological innovations and the national recovery and resilience plan within the European Union are opportunities to implement changes and renovate the current healthcare system in Italy, to guarantee equal access to health services. Considering such scenario, a panel of Italian experts gathered in a multidisciplinary Think Tank to discuss possible design of concepts at the basis of a new healthcare system. These ideas were summarized in a manifesto with six drivers for change: vision, governance, competence, intelligence, humanity and relationship. Each driver was linked to an action to actively move towards a new healthcare system based on trust between science, citizens and institutions.
5,049 views
4 citations
ORIGINAL RESEARCH
2 February 2022
Asharaf Abdul Salam, 1 more and Ibrahim Elsegaey
3 Authors
- AA
Asharaf Abdul Salam
Center for Population Studies, King Saud University, Saudi Arabia
- RM
Rshood M. Al-Khraif
Center for Population Studies, King Saud University, Saudi Arabia
- IE
Ibrahim Elsegaey
Center for Population Studies, King Saud University, Saudi Arabia
Background: Saudi Arabia, a prominent Arabian country, has 35.3 million persons living in 2.2 million square kilometers, undergone serious threats, recently, due to the COVID-19 pandemic. With the built in infrastructure and disciplined life, the country could address this pandemic.
Aims: This analysis of COVID-19 cases in Saudi Arabia, attempts to assess the situation, explore its global percentage share, percentage of population affected, and local distribution from the beginning of infection till recently, tracing historical developments and changes.
Data and methods: This analysis made use of data released by the Ministry of Health on a daily basis for a number of parameters. They are compiled on excel sheet on a daily basis: the dataset has undergone rigorous analysis along the trends and patterns; proportion to the world statistics and geographic distribution.
Results: COVID-19 spread rapidly in the country with periodic variations, spreading rapidly across the country during June-August, 2020. But, recoveries accelerated in the period and thus bridging the gap of increasing infections. In comparison with the world statistics, the country proportions are lesser: similar is the percentage of population affected. Apparently, all the 13 administrative areas are affected with varying intensity.
Conclusion: COVID-19 transmission since March, 2020 considered to be wide spread creating excess burden on public health system, delineated into stages (early infection, rapid spread, declining, stabilizing, and second wave). Control measures are set, stage wise, without impinging upon normal life but to ensure that the proportion to global affected persons is lesser than the population share; credit goes to the Ministry of Health. Area wise spread depend largely on population density and development infrastructure dimensions. Ultimately, the disciplined life in compliance with law and order situation paved way for effective program implementation and epidemic control.
Countries worldwide are currently endeavoring to safeguard the long-term health of their populations through implementing Universal Health Coverage (UHC), in line with the United Nation’s 2015-30 Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Canada has some of the world’s strongest legislation supporting equitable access to care for medically necessary hospital and physician services based on need, not ability to pay. A constitutional challenge to this legislation is underway in British Columbia (BC), led by a corporate plaintiff, Cambie Surgeries Corporation (CSC). This constitutional challenge threatens to undermine the high bar for UHC protection that Canada has set for the world, with potential adverse implications for equitable international development. CSC claims that BC’s health care law—the Medicare Protection Act (MPA)—infringes patients’ rights under Canada’s constitution, by essentially preventing physicians who are enrolled in BC’s publicly-funded Medicare plan from providing expedited care to patients for a private fee. In September 2020, after a trial that ran for 3.5 years and included testimony by more than 100 witnesses from around the world, the court dismissed the plaintiffs’ claim. Having lost their case in the Supreme Court of BC, the plaintiffs’ appealed in June 2021. The appellate court’s ruling and reasons for judgment are expected sometime in 2021. We consider the evidence before the court from the perspective of social epidemiology and health inequalities, demonstrating that structural features of a modern society that exacerbate inequalities, including inequitable access to healthcare, can be expected to lead to worse overall societal outcomes.
9,476 views
3 citations
Introduction: The Situation Room is a physical or virtual space where experts systematically analyze information to characterize a health situation, especially during emergencies. Decision-making processes are made towards solving the health needs, promoting collaboration among institutions and social sectors. This paper presents the context and circumstances that led the University of Guadalajara to install a local health situation room to address the COVID-19 pandemic at this institution based in the state of Jalisco, Mexico, a narrative is also made of its working processes as well as some of its results.
Methods: The design of this situation room for COVID-19 was based on the methodology established by the Pan American Health Organization/World Health Organization. This local-type situation room was installed on February 12, 2020. The health problem was characterized, and strategic lines, objectives, and goals were established; the first analysis derived in an action plan deployed at the University of Guadalajara. The strategic lines were situational diagnosis, preventive actions, and containment strategies.
Results: The situation room influenced the activities of the University of Guadalajara before the epidemic cases started in the state. One of the actions with the greatest impact was developing a mathematical model for predicting COVID-19 cases. Subsequently, new models have been developed according to the epidemiological evolution of the disease, helping manage the epidemic in the state. Another important result was the early closing of face-to-face university activities, reducing contagion risks and the mobility of more than 310 thousand students, faculty, and administrative personnel throughout Jalisco.
Conclusions: A consequence of the closure was the confinement generated by the pandemic was the change to virtual meetings from April 2020 to date; but at the same time, this working format was a strength, since it influenced the decision of the university board to change all the academic activities to virtual format before other educational, economic and social activities in the state did. By April 2020, the situation room transcended its institutional boundaries, and was invited to participate at the Jalisco State's Health Committee. Its recommendations have helped maintain the state with one of Mexico's lowest COVID-19 incidence and mortality rates.
4,572 views
3 citations
Purpose: We analyzed the effects of COVID-19 as well as its accompanying epidemiological control measures on health-related outcomes (physical and mental health) and unmet care needs of both caregivers and care recipients across Europe and Israel by taking into account country differences.
Methods: We applied comparisons of adjusted predictions, controlling for a large set of relevant respondent characteristics, to investigate changes in the physical and mental health of caregivers and care recipients due to COVID-19. Further, multilevel regression models were used to analyze the effect of individual and contextual indicators on the probability of reporting difficulties in receiving care. For the analyses, we used data from 26 countries with 51,983 respondents over 50 years based on the 8th wave of the Survey of Health, Ageing and Retirement in Europe (SHARE) which had to be suspended in March 2020 and the SHARE Corona Survey fielded from June to August 2020.
Results: During the first phase of the pandemic in spring/summer 2020, the frequency of providing personal care to parents increased in almost all European countries, while care to children, in turn, decreased. Parental caregivers who increased the frequency of providing personal care reported significantly more mental health strains, i.e., feeling sad/depressed and anxious/nervous more often since the outbreak of the pandemic. With respect to receiving care, about one out of five care recipients had difficulty in obtaining adequate care from outside the household during the pandemic. The perception of unmet care needs was significantly associated with country differences regarding the duration of the stay-at-home orders. In contrast, the number of confirmed deaths did not have a significant effect on perceiving difficulties related to receiving care.
Conclusions: Our findings show the extent of the burden to which caregivers and care recipients were exposed with respect to the unintended consequences of COVID-19-related epidemiological control measures. There is a great need within this population for interventions, which effectively reduce the burden as well as the symptoms of anxiousness or depression for caregivers as well as care recipients. This should be recognized by (health) policymakers and social organizations.
Universal Health Coverage (UHC) exists in all of the countries of Europe, despite variation on the ownership structure of health delivery systems. As countries around the world seek to advance UHC and manage the private sector within their health systems, the European experiences can offer useful insights. We found four different models for the provision of healthcare, with the private sector predominant in some countries, and of minimal importance in others. The European experiences indicate that UHC can be effectively provided with, or without, large-scale private sector provision in hospital, specialty, and primary care services, and that moreover it can be provided with high levels of patient satisfaction. These findings offer regulatory models for countries in other regions to review as they advance UHC.


