Skip to main content

Intratympanic and surgical Treatment for Menière's Disease

68kviews
Editorial21 December 2022
Editorial: Intratympanic and surgical treatment for Meniere's disease
Jun Yang, Yupeng Liuand Maoli Duan

Treatment of Meniere's disease (MD) remains controversial and challenging. How to control vertigo while preserving auditory-vestibular function and to improve the quality of life in the process of treatment is the practical dilemma for both of doctors and patients. Both intratympanic and surgical treatment are recommended by latest "Clinical Practice Guideline: Ménière's Disease" (1) when conservative treatment is ineffective. Intratympanic steroid (ITS) injection and intratympanic gentamicin (ITG) injection are effective treatment for vertigo control in MD patients. ITS has advantage in hearing protection while ITG is more effective in vertigo control. ITS is suitable for bilateral disease. The value of endolymphatic sac surgery is that vertigo control and hearing preservation can be achieved concurrently in the procedure. Furthermore, the risk of endolymphatic sac surgery is low, and serious postoperative complications are rare. Triple semicircular canal occlusion (TSCO) is an alternative procedure for the treatment of MD.TSCO is widely accepted by Chinese otolaryngologists. However, the 2020 American guideline (1) and the 2017 European consensus (2) did not recommend TSCO as a selective surgical intervention. Further evidence based studies and mechanism of TSCO are needed before global acceptance. Research Topic "Intratympanic and Surgical Treatment for Meniere's Disease" consists of seven original articles and two reviews. We put the spotlight on the 9 published studies in this topic and within the following categories: Pathogenesis Research; Diagnostic Tool; Intratympanic Treatment and Surgical Treatment.

Pathogenesis of MD remains unclear. Numerous studies have confirmed that the endolymphatic sac (ES) can be stimulated by antigens and generate an immune response. Immune-related diseases, such as allergy, autoimmune diseases, etc., play an important role in the pathogenesis of MD. The pathogenesis of MD is related to various cytokines and inflammatory mediators of allergy and autoimmune diseases. MD patients have a history of abnormal mood, mental anxiety, and overwork before the onset of symptoms. Autonomic nerve dysfunction can increase sympathetic nerve excitability, induce small blood vessel spasm and raise vascular osmotic pressure. As a result, the microcirculation disturbance of the endolymph leads to the manifestations of MD. Kitahara et at reported that long-term high levels of vasopressin may adversely affect inner ear microcirculation and endolymph metabolism leading the development of MD symptoms. After effective treatment of MD, patients' vasopressin levels can be maintained at low levels. However, there are few researches on vasopressin in MD in recent years. The mechanism of the effect of vasopressin on the inner ear still needs to be clarified.

Wideband tympanometry (WBT) can reflect the lesions of different structures of the middle ear by the probe tone in the frequency range of 0.25-8 kHz, which has greater advantages in detection of middle ear function compared with traditional acoustic immittance. WBT can reflect the inner ear pressure indirectly as well. Therefore, it can be applied to the diagnosis of inner ear diseases. In this topic, an overall summary of the role of WBT in the diagnosis of MD was provided by Meng et al. They concluded different results between MD patients and normal individuals in resonance frequency, absorbance, integral area of absorbance and G-Width. The application of WBT in MD is based on the hypothesis that pressure changes caused by the endolymphatic hydrops (EH) alters the tension of the annular ligament and the "third window" of the inner ear, and in the case of an intact ossicular chain, decreased mobility of the stapedial foot plate results in the reduction of tympanic membrane compliance. At present, a broad range of clinical application of WBT is limited for its small sample size studies, lacking follow-up results and lacking data in different age populations and different ethnic groups. WBT can be altered as part of a test battery if further evidence based studies in the field are improved.

Aminoglycosides are ototoxic to both vestibular and cochlear hair cells. Gentamicin is the first preference for intratympanic injection due to its more vestibular toxicity compared to less cochlear toxicity. ITG is well tolerated, controls vertigo attacks, and has a low incidence of severe hearing loss.The 2020 Clinical Practice Guideline (1) recommended use ITG to patients with unilaterally active MD who are refractory to conservative, non-destructive treatments. Caution must be exercised in patients with bilateral MD because ITG carries the risk of significant bilateral vestibular hypofunction and hearing loss. Wegmann-Vicuña et al evaluated the effect of single ITG and they concluded that 59.6% of the patients achieved complete vertigo control after one single dose of ITG with follow-up period up to 6 years. Patients with single ITG injection showed less frequent in chronic disequilibrium and demand of vestibular rehabilitation. They also suggested that the endpoint of treatment with a vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) gain reduction >17.8%. The generally accepted treatment endpoint of ITG is no vertigo attack in a 12-month period or a vestibular loss in objective tests in the affected ear (4). Guan et al completed a retrospective study on the effectiveness of ITG treatment and the value of the Halmagyi head thrust test (HTT) in predicting treatment durability. It is noteworthy that the authors used traditional HTT instead of video Head Impulse Test (vHIT) to identify the impaction of vestibular function. The HTT can be performed without a specialized equipment. It is a facile test and can be performed everywhere. Clinicians should never forget to use it when the resource is limited.

Nonablative surgery is a dispensable part of surgical treatment for MD patients with usable hearing and residual vestibular function when conservative treatment is ineffective. Histopathological change of EH had inspired surgeons to manipulate membranous labyrinth for the purpose of relieving vertigo and preserving hearing. Kersbergen et al reviewed the history of manipulation of the membranous labyrinth.Femenic shunt, Fick Sacculotomy, Tack operation, Cochleosacculotomy, Otic-Perotic shunt and semicircular canal plugging were respectively introduced. The principle of these operations, except canal plugging, is to relieve vertigo and improve hearing by draining excess endolymph. The authors summarized the published literatures of the outcomes of vertigo control and hearing function. Vertigo control was satisfactory in most cases but hearing function was not well reserved. Although these procedures have been abandoned by clinicians, these techniques remain the great innovations in the history of otologic surgery. Jiang et al investigated the surgical outcome by TSCO and vestibular nerve resection. Vertigo control rate was satisfactory in both groups. However, a lower rate of postoperative paroxysmal dizziness and unsteadiness was observed in TSCO group. The limitation of TSCO is that study with large series of cases was only reported by Chinese clinicians (5,6). Further mechanism researches and evidence based studies are required. Endolymphatic sac surgery was not recommended by 2020 American guideline due to its uncertain benefit and discordant underlying mechanisms. Zhang et al reported a series cases of patients underwent resection of lateral wall of endolymphatic sac. Complete vertigo control was achieved in 61.6% of the patients. Reducing secretion of endolymphatic fluid and eliminating the immune response of the endolymphatic sac was speculated as the mechanism of this procedure. Zheng et al compared the surgical effect of local endolymphatic sac decompression, endolymphatic mastoid shunt, and wide endolymphatic sac decompression. The authors concluded that wide endolymphatic sac decompression has a higher vertigo control rate (88.6%), better improvement of QOL, and relatively higher hearing stability. Paparella first proposed the conception of wide endolymphatic sac decompression and speculated that this procedure can enhance the blood supply of the sac and improves its absorption function (7). It is interesting that the two seemingly discordant surgical approaches achieved similar outcomes. The role of the endolymphatic sac in EH and MD remains a mystery.

In summary, 9 articles presented in the Research Topic "Intratympanic and Surgical Treatment for Meniere's Disease" may provide more information in the field. Challenges in the diagnosis and treatment of MD patients is still remained. Firstly, MD is often accompanied by other diseases. Patients with longterm recurrent attacks are likely to have psychological disorder or mental disease. Secondly, due to the long-term nature course and repetitiveness of MD, economic costs in diagnosis, treatment and rehabilitation process is worthy of attention. Thirdly, the factors that affect the treatment outcome of MD are complex, further studies are needed.

3,105 views

1 citations

ORIGINAL RESEARCH
23 February 2022
Up-Regulated Expression of Interferon-Gamma, Interleukin-6 and Tumor Necrosis Factor-Alpha in the Endolymphatic Sac of Meniere's Disease Suggesting the Local Inflammatory Response Underlies the Mechanism of This Disease
Chao Huang, 7 more and Zhiwen Zhang

4,027 views

40 citations

ORIGINAL RESEARCH
11 March 2022
Efficacy of Resection of Lateral Wall of Endolymphatic Sac for Treatment of Meniere's Disease
Daogong Zhang, 5 more and Haibo Wang

3,670 views

8 citations

Meniere's disease (MD) is a clinical syndrome characterized by spontaneous recurrent vertigo, usually accompanied by hearing loss, tinnitus, and aural fullness. The cause of MD remains unclear and is generally considered to be associated with endolymphatic hydrops. Studies showed that patients with MD could have eustachian tube dysfunction (ETD). ETD can disrupt the pressure balance between the middle and inner ear and impair the inner ear's function. In recent years, several studies have attempted to identify MD by using wideband tympanometry (WBT). However, there are limited studies in this area. There is no consensus on how to use WBT to diagnose Meniere’s disease. Therefore, we endeavored to conduct a narrative review in this aspect based on the latest research findings. Reduction in resonance frequency and absorbance are characteristic of MD and can identify Meniere's disease. The use of an increase in the integrated area of absorbance as an indicator for identifying MD is controversial. WBT seems to be ineffective as a diagnostic tool during the acute episodes of Meniere's disease. Patients with MD may benefit from WBT. WBT has excellent potential for future use in Meniere's disease. However, further large sample sizes, multicenter studies are needed.

10,219 views

14 citations

ORIGINAL RESEARCH
9 December 2021
Efficacy and Durability of Intratympanic Gentamicin Treatment for Meniere's Disease
Yafeng Guan, 2 more and Steven D. Rauch

8,297 views

9 citations