Skip to main content

Agrochemical Use Impact on Bee physiology

Cover image for Research Topic "Agrochemical Use Impact on Bee physiology"
63kviews
Editorial12 December 2023
Editorial: Agrochemical use impact on bee physiology

Bees, essential for pollinating crops and wildflowers, are facing a global decline. They are regularly exposed to various agrochemicals like insecticides, herbicides, fungicides, and acaricides. As bees have limited detoxifying enzymes, they are especially vulnerable to these chemical compounds, leading to sub-lethal effects that impair their foraging and orientation abilities, with potential negative colony-level consequences. Furthermore, these agrochemicals may combine with multiple stressors such as parasites, pathogens, or nutritional deficiencies significantly impact bee health. Therefore, it is necessary to understand the factors driving honey bee decline and to guide potential management strategies. The aim of the current Research Topic “Adverse Effects of Agrochemicals on Bee Health” in Frontiers in Physiology is to gain insights into the adverse impacts of agrochemicals on bee health. There are five original research articles and one review published in this Research Topic, focusing on the noteworthy influence of various pesticides and fungicides on the health, behavior, and development of bee species, including Bombus terrestris and Apis mellifera.

Neonicotinoids are the most widely used pesticides worldwide, which negatively impact non-target pollinator bees. Among these insecticides, thiacloprid, a commonly used compound with relatively low toxicity, the effect of sub-lethal larval exposure to thiacloprid on the antennal activity of adult honeybees (Apis mellifera L.) is not yet fully understood. Ke et al. found that honeybee larvae exposed to sub-lethal thiacloprid reduced the electroantennography (EAG) response in adult bees to floral odors, leading to increased olfactory selectivity in higher dosage groups. Additionally, thiacloprid negatively impacted odor-related learning and memory in emerged adult bees. Another pesticide, flupyradifurone (FPF), a systemic butenolide insecticide, has a lower binding affinity to insect nAChRs than traditional neonicotinoids and is effective against many neonicotinoid-resistant insects. Gao et al. investigated the acute toxicity of FPF on nurse bees. The authors found that nurse bees are more sensitive to FPF than larvae, with significant differences in lethal dose (LD50) values. Sublethal concentrations of FPF induced notable apoptosis in the neurons of nurse bees and altered the expression of immune-related genes.

In addition to the effects of neonicotinoid insecticides on bee health, fungicides are another major threat to bees. Xiong et al. investigated the impact of the strobilurin fungicide pyraclostrobin on the development and physiology of honeybee larvae and pupae. In the study, two-day-old larvae were exposed to field-realistic concentrations of pyraclostrobin, leading to significant decreases in survival rates, growth, and delayed development of larvae and alteration of the expression levels of several key genes related to development, nutrition, and immunity.

Bees are more likely to be exposed to multiple agrochemicals at the meanwhile during foraging. Lu et al. examined the toxic effects of the pesticides chlorothalonil and acetamiprid on honeybee larvae. The authors identified no observed adverse effect concentrations (NOAEC) for these pesticides. The results indicated that exposure to both pesticides, even below NOAEC, significantly changed the expression of genes associated with the toxicological process in larvae, including caste development (Tor (GB44905), InR-2 (GB55425), Hr4 (GB47037), Ac3 (GB11637) and ILP-2 (GB10174)), immune system response (abaecin (GB18323), defensin-1 (GB19392), toll-X4 (GB50418)), and oxidative stress response (P450, GSH, GST, CarE).

Another research performed by Tang et al. focused on the sublethal effects of spinetoram and glyphosate on physiological biomarkers and gut microbes in bumblebees (Bombus terrestris). They discovered that spinetoram and glyphosate significantly elevated superoxide dismutase activity while reduced gut α-amylase activity. However, these chemical compounds had no significant effect on glutathione-S-transferase, carboxylesterase or gut protease activities. In addition, glyphosate increased the activity of prophenoloxidase. Moreover, they observed that glyphosate reduced the relative abundance of Zygosaccharomyces relative to fat accumulation, indicating they could affect bumblebee’s health by inhibiting energy acquisition.

Agrochemicals are often used in mixtures with spray adjuvants to enhance physicochemical properties to increase the efficacy. Nevertheless, recent laboratory studies showed that adjuvants can have a toxicity-increasing effect when mixed with insecticides. The semi-field study conducted by Wernecke et al. investigated whether organosilicon surfactants (OSS) mixed with pyrethroid and carbamate can enhance the toxic impact of insecticides on bees and colonies. Their results revealed that the insecticides, either alone or mixed with OSS, did not significantly affect bee mortality, population, and brood development, except for a decrease in flower visitation after carbamate treatments.

Gaubert et al. reviewed the current knowledge about the exposure of honeybees to various stresses and the individual and social defense mechanisms they have developed. It addresses how honeybees encounter both biotic and abiotic stressors, which can interact synergistically or antagonistically, affecting their immune and detoxification systems. This review highlights honeybees’ behavioral strategies and production of antimicrobial compounds in host responses to these stressors.

The collective research presented in this Research Topic provides a comprehensive overview of the adverse effects of agrochemicals and other stressors on larvae or adult honeybees and bumblebees health under different treatments ranging from neonicotinoids and fungicides to organosilicon surfactants. Generally, the interaction of multiple stressors may be more detrimental than a single one. Consequently, it is necessary for continuous research to better understand the complex interactions of those stressors on bee physiology, behavior, and colony health. Ultimately, this knowledge will guide the development of sustainable agricultural practices that safeguard bee populations and ensure the pollination services they provide, benefiting both ecosystems and food production.

2,288 views

Individual and social defenses in Apis mellifera: a playground to fight against synergistic stressor interactions
The honeybee is an important species for the agri-food and pharmaceutical industries through bee products and crop pollination services. However, honeybee health is a major concern, because beekeepers in many countries are experiencing significant colony losses. This phenomenon has been linked to the exposure of bees to multiple stresses in their environment. Indeed, several biotic and abiotic stressors interact with bees in a synergistic or antagonistic way. Synergistic stressors often act through a disruption of their defense systems (immune response or detoxification). Antagonistic interactions are most often caused by interactions between biotic stressors or disruptive activation of bee defenses. Honeybees have developed behavioral defense strategies and produce antimicrobial compounds to prevent exposure to various pathogens and chemicals. Expanding our knowledge about these processes could be used to develop strategies to shield bees from exposure. This review aims to describe current knowledge about the exposure of honeybees to multiple stresses and the defense mechanisms they have developed to protect themselves. The effect of multi-stress exposure is mainly due to a disruption of the immune response, detoxification, or an excessive defense response by the bee itself. In addition, bees have developed defenses against stressors, some 2 behavioral, others involving the production of antimicrobials, or exploiting beneficial external factors.

7,529 views

19 citations

ORIGINAL RESEARCH
1 June 2023
A selected organosilicone spray adjuvant does not enhance lethal effects of a pyrethroid and carbamate insecticide on honey bees
Anna Wernecke, 4 more and Richard Odemer

4,119 views

6 citations

Chronic larval exposure to thiacloprid impairs honeybee antennal selectivity, learning and memory performances
The use of agricultural neonicotinoid insecticides has been shown to result in sub-lethal chronic effects that are more prevalent than acute toxicity to bees. Among these insecticides, thiacloprid, a commonly used low-toxic, has garnered significant attention due to its potential impact on the olfactory and learning abilities of honeybees. The effect of sub-lethal larval exposure to thiacloprid on the antennal activity of adult honeybees (Apis mellifera L.) have yet to be fully understood. To address this knowledge gap, laboratory-based experiments were conducted in which honeybee larvae were administered thiacloprid (0.5 mg/L, 1 mg/L). Using electroantennography (EAG), the impact of thiacloprid exposure on the antennal selectivity to common floral volatiles were evaluated. Additionally, the effect of sub-lethal exposure on odor-related learning and memory were assessed. The results of this study reveal, for the first time, that sub-lethal exposure to thiacloprid, when administered as larvae, prominently decreased honeybee antenna EAG responses to floral scents, leading to increased olfactory selectivity in the high dose 1 mg/L group compared to the control (0 mg/L VS. 1.0 mg/L: p< 0.05). Additionally, the results suggest that thiacloprid negatively affected odor-associated paired learning acquisition, as well as medium-term (1 h) (0 mg/L VS. 1.0mg/L: P = 0.019) and long-term memory (24 h) (0 mg/L VS. 1.0mg/L: P = 0.037) in adult honeybee. EAG amplitudes were dramatically reduced following R-linalool paired olfactory training (0 mg/L VS. 1.0mg/L: P = 0.001; 0 mg/L VS. 0.5mg/L: P = 0.027), while antennal activities were only significantly different in the control between paired and unpaired groups. Our results indicate that exposure to sub-lethal concentrations of thiacloprid can potentially affect honeybees' olfactory perception, as well as their learning and memory behaviors. These findings have important implications for the safe use of agrochemicals in the environment.

5,478 views

27 citations

ORIGINAL RESEARCH
28 March 2023
Acute oral toxicity, apoptosis, and immune response in nurse bees (Apis mellifera) induced by flupyradifurone
Jing Gao, 7 more and Yan-Yan Wu

5,302 views

25 citations

Exposure of chlorothalonil and acetamiprid reduce the survival and cause multiple internal disturbances in Apis mellifera larvae reared in vitro
ORIGINAL RESEARCH
13 February 2023
Exposure of chlorothalonil and acetamiprid reduce the survival and cause multiple internal disturbances in Apis mellifera larvae reared in vitro
Ying Lu, 8 more and Pingli Dai
Despite many studies have revealed that honey bee (Apis mellifera L.) larvae are posting a high risk on exposure to pesticides, but the toxicology information on bee larvae remain limited. Here, we test chronic toxicity of chlorothalonil and acetamiprid to honeybee larvae. After continuously fed with different chlorothalonil (1, 2, 4, 8 and 16 μg/mL) or acetamiprid solutions (0.5, 1, 2, 4 and 8 μg/mL), we determined the no observed adverse effect concentration (NOAEC) of chlorothalonil and acetamiprid were 4 μg/mL and 2 μg/mL, respectively. Except for CarE, the enzymic activities of GST and P450 were not influenced by chlorothalonil at NOAEC, while chronic exposure to ACE slightly increased the activities of the three tested enzymes at NOAEC. Further, the exposed larvae showed significantly higher expression of genes involved in a series of different toxicologically relevant process following, including caste development (Tor (GB44905), InR-2 (GB55425), Hr4 (GB47037), Ac3 (GB11637) and ILP-2 (GB10174)), immune system response (abaecin (GB18323), defensin-1 (GB19392), toll-X4 (GB50418)), and oxidative stress response (P450, GSH, GST and CarE), suggesting that more important synergistic and behavioral effects that can affect larvae fitness should be explored in the further.

4,832 views

24 citations

ORIGINAL RESEARCH
9 February 2023
Field recommended concentrations of pyraclostrobin exposure disturb the development and immune response of worker bees (Apis mellifera L.) larvae and pupae
Manqiong Xiong, 8 more and Xinle Duan

5,118 views

21 citations

Effects of spinetoram and glyphosate on physiological biomarkers and gut microbes in Bombus terrestris
ORIGINAL RESEARCH
9 January 2023
Effects of spinetoram and glyphosate on physiological biomarkers and gut microbes in Bombus terrestris
Qi-He Tang, 10 more and Ji-Lian Li
The sublethal effects of pesticide poisoning will have significant negative impacts on the foraging and learning of bees and bumblebees, so it has received widespread attention. However, little is known about the physiological effects of sublethal spinetoram and glyphosate exposure on bumblebees. We continuously exposed Bombus terrestris to sublethal (2.5 mg/L) spinetoram or glyphosate under controlled conditions for 10 days. The superoxide dismutase, glutathione-S-transferase, carboxylesterase, prophenoloxidase, α-amylase and protease activities, and changes in gut microbes were measured to understand the effects of sublethal pesticide exposure on the physiology and gut microbes of bumblebees. Sublethal pesticide exposure to significantly increased superoxide dismutase activity and significantly decreased gut α-amylase activity in bumblebees but had no significant effect on glutathione-S-transferase, carboxylesterase or gut protease activities. In addition, glyphosate increased the activity of prophenoloxidase. Interestingly, we observed that neither of the two pesticides had a significant effect on dominant gut bacteria, but glyphosate significantly altered the structure of the dominant gut fungal community, and reduced the relative abundance of Zygosaccharomyces associated with fat accumulation. These results suggest that sublethal spinetoram and glyphosate do not significantly affect the detoxification system of bumblebees, but may affect bumblebee health by inhibiting energy acquisition. Our results provide information on the sublethal effects of exposure to low concentrations of glyphosate and spinetoram on bumblebees in terms of physiology and gut microbes.

13,827 views

34 citations