Freire's (1972) concept of critical praxis offers an illuminating frame for navigating the epistemological and ontological assumptions and thinking that shape the current food system. His conceptual framework offers analysts a way to reconsider and reframe practices dynamically; that is, in a fashion in which they are not only enacted, but also continuously theorized, evaluated, and reimagined as they evolve. The iterative character of that process highlights the importance of understanding the active operation of power via individual and collective agency. More importantly, it moves scholars beyond efforts to capture "what is happening" and toward identifying generative ways that interested stakeholders may participate actively in the creation of more just and sustainable food systems.In our view, this special issue resulted in a fruitful set of responses to this overarching challenge. As a group, these articles critically engage with various relevant onto-epistemic questions and frameworks. These include, among others, agroecology, regenerative agriculture, Black agrarianism, radical pragmatism, decolonizing strategies, and urban ecology. Collectively, these analyses question the dominant thinking in which today's food systems are entrenched and highlight perspectives that can help to disrupt their dominant meta-narrative that is today driven foremost by efficiency and technology claims, and to explore policy interventions, justicecentered strategies, community-engaged collaborative efforts, and the deep reflexivity that can reveal alternate ways of thinking to those now prevailing. The analyses collected here call on food system scholars, practitioners, and policymakers to work actively toward realizing a future in which such structures and processes are ecologically and socially sustainable and equitable for all.Beyond these core concerns, these analyses are characterized by at least four major cross cutting themes concerning the steps that may be necessary to secure significant change in the West's regnant food system narrative. These illustrate the remarkable social, political, economic and cultural complexity implicit in attaining meaningful change in this domain. Perhaps first among these themes is the need to recognize the wide range of actors with stakes in food systems. These include growers, who may be subsistence farmers or operators of gigantic farms and ranches alike, those who transport and provide storage of their products for wholesale markets, those who prepare and offer those foodstuffs and meats for retail sale, political decision-makers, and the broader population served, which may be located locally or in distant global locales. More, wholesale and retail product, storage and transportation markets may be local, regional, national or international in scale. Notably too, nations are variably equipped to provide the physical and social infrastructures necessary to permit growers awareness and latitude to contemplate change from their existing knowledge. Indeed, each of these elements should be considered as reflecting a point on a spectrum with actors arrayed on a continuum of scale and capacities of various sorts. Perhaps the most elemental competence necessary for systemic change is actor (read individual and collective) awareness of currently shared beliefs and sufficient information and common determination to imagine and realize current food system processes differently. This collection of articles suggests that can be a difficult challenge to meet, especially for subsistence farmers.Second, the fact that today's neoliberal food system narrative is intertwined with a variety of perspectives that work to enervate shared social belief in human equality based on capitalism as well as racialized, patriarchal, religious or ethnic claims of superiority is often a profound impediment to changing the story underpinning its current dominance. This is so because truly democratic change in food systems that will result in improved prospects for social justice for all demands that all within them be treated with dignity and respect and be compensated justly for their work. Such cannot occur when colonialist, ethnic, racial or religious hierarchies continue to operate amidst economic exploitation of any actor in the system based on relative capacities or perceived inferior social or political standing.Third, the ongoing cruelty of systemic injustice rooted in racialized or gender social hierarchies in diverse national contexts suggests that food system change is unlikely to result from logistical/supply chain or alternate planning/planting/irrigation or harvesting improvements alone. That is, one might successfully equip a subsistence farmer, for example, with a knowledge of different crops or of ways to plant and grow them as well as with ways to store and transport them to new markets, but much of that information dissemination might not matter if social and structural ostracism continues de facto to usurp the realization of those possibilities in practice. This fact in turn suggests that long-term systemic changes in food systems to ensure they treat all within them equitably and do not continue to despoil the earth's environment, will not occur simply with technical changes. Instead, as Freire understood, and these articles demonstrate afresh, they will need to be constructed on a foundation foremost of shared social belief in human dignity and equality. Ensuring widespread acceptance of those values will require changes in broadly held hierarchical social norms or in long standing social cruelty targeted to specific groups in the West and in many other nations. While the character of these varies across countries, their results are everywhere the same for affected food system actors¾diminished rights and life possibilities.Finally, these observations suggest that scholars should continue aggressively to explore not only how to build the technical capacities and rights awareness of those working within food systems now structurally disadvantaged within them, but also to devise democratic processes to encourage the populations now oppressing them to adopt alternate ways of knowing that celebrate their common humanity with those they had previously victimized. While the technical project of sustainable farming at scale for a growing global population in forms different from
Editorial13 September 2024
Editorial: Critical praxis and the social imaginary for sustainable food systemsORIGINAL RESEARCH
29 November 2023
Gabriela Valeria Villavicencio-Valdez, 3 more and H. Suzán-Azpiri
5 Authors
- GV
Gabriela Valeria Villavicencio-Valdez
Department of Natural Sciences, Universidad Autónoma de Querétaro (UAQ), México
- JJ
J. Jacobi
Department of Environmental Systems Science, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (ETH), Switzerland
- MS
M. Schneider
International Institute of Social Studies (ISS), Erasmus University Rotterdam, Netherlands
- MA
M. A. Altieri
Department of Environmental Science, Policy, and Management, University of California Berkeley, United States
- HS
H. Suzán-Azpiri
Department of Natural Sciences, Universidad Autónoma de Querétaro (UAQ), México
Small-scale agroecological practices in the urban areas of Querétaro, México, as in other mid-sized cities, could maintain agrobiodiversity pools and sufficient productivity for a food sovereignty baseline. The application of agroecological principles fosters agrobiodiversity and socio-ecological resilience in urban food production. Emerging urban gardens result from an immediate necessity for food that does not appear in local statistics, nor is there any account of them in any cadastral source or land register of Querétaro City. Based on studies of 28 urban gardens, we survey and analyze farming practices using socio-ecological resilience methodologies and the Diagnostic Survey of Agroecological Practices. We find that the agroecological management of urban gardens results in significantly more species richness than in conventionally managed plots, likely due to the multifunctional purposes associated with biocultural memory. The number of social actors participating in agroecological management is increasing. It represents an urban strategy of resilience that contributes to enhancing the microclimate and nutrient cycling, as well as to improving water management and biodiversity. Results also indicate that gardens of approximately 200 m2 harbor the highest levels of agrobiodiversity. This area size for home vegetable production appears optimal for user-friendly management practices in urban settings and could represent the minimum benchmark for a family and a goal for urban planning and policy recommendations. Urban gardens contribute to the adaptive capacities of city dwellers to enhance their food security and sovereignty. Therefore, given that 70% of the national population face some level of food insecurity, we argue that, along with the protection of land-use rights, the promotion of a diverse urban landscape could improve long-term socio-ecological and food supply resilience. Additionally, urban gardens promote neighborhood social inclusion and affordable access to food. The empirical results and insights from this study in Querétaro can inform land-use policies for urban agriculture more broadly, especially in Latin American metropolitan areas.
Over the past three decades West Virginians have experienced a deepening economic crisis. Divestment in coal and manufacturing has resulted in widespread unemployment, state, county and municipal revenue losses, and cascading effects on social services, households, livelihoods and community life. For ten years, FJL has conducted ethnographic research, coordinated cooperative experiments and built pedagogical tools to democratize knowledge about West Virginia’s food system amidst this crisis. Working in a so-called red state, we have fostered conversations about food justice with rural, often socially conservative communities, and have worked to raise up human resources for meaningful community-led food justice organizing in Central Appalachia. In this paper we consider the long accompaniment process with community partners and the effects of this experience on the evolution of research questions and actions.
4,416 views
Rather than treating symptoms of a destructive agri-food system, agricultural policy, research, and advocacy need both to address the root causes of dysfunction and learn from longstanding interventions to counter it. Specifically, this paper focuses on agricultural parity policies – farmer-led, government-enacted programs to secure a price floor and manage supply to prevent the economic and ecological devastation of corporate unfettered agro-capitalism. Though historically underrepresented through lenses of colonialism, classism, and racism, swaths of humanity are continuing to mobilize, especially in India, calling for agri-food systems transformation, farmgate pricing protections, and collective bargaining across the globe. Parity, a movement built on principles of fair farmgate prices and cooperatively coordinated supply management, are mostly considered ‘radical,’ deemed inefficient, irrelevant, obsolete, and grievous government overreach—from the vantage of a system that profits from commodity crop overproduction and agroindustry consolidation. However, by examining parity through a producer-centric lens cognizant of farmers’ ability, desire, and need to care for the land, ideas of price protection and supply management become foundational, so that farmers can make a dignified livelihood stewarding land and water while producing nourishing food. This paradox—that an agricultural governance principle can seem both radical and common sense, far-fetched and pragmatic—deserves attention and analysis. When farmers have been placed on the margins of survival, their voices are absent from these conversations, leaving space for worldviews favoring de-agrarianization altogether. Apart from the history of parity price system in US, the paper will examine an off-shoot of parity program in India – the Minimum Support Price (MSP) system.This paper will explain the parity price system as a dynamic idea with offshoots in the Global South, and is currently the principal demand from the agrarian community. Farmers want to make MSP/fair- prices a legal right for farmers, resisting against the agro-capitalistic forces working to dismantle the economic and social safeguards offered by grain reserves, price supports and pathways of collective bargaining. From East India to the plains of the United States, parity offers a pragmatic solution to global agro-industrial corporate capture, poor labor conditions, environmental destruction, and promotes broader food sovereignty globally.
Urban inhabitants exist within hybrid spaces of continual transformation and metabolism where human labor is woven into the work of the trees, the grass, the water cycle. The built environment – concrete, houses, skyscrapers – butts up against urban riparian zones and wetlands. The postindustrial landscape exposes both the possibilities and the limits of building resilience in the context of constant metabolism and change. This article asks about the potential for collaborative survival in these spaces of deindustrialization, where the abundance of so-called vacant parcels represent a pathway towards more self-determined food systems and the potential for reimagined urban futures. I play with the concept of collaborative survival to consider a plurality of epistemologies, knowledge systems, and traditions, as well as histories and geographies of exclusion that contribute to this reimagining. I examine the work of Black gardeners and farmers in Cleveland, OH as an example of collaborative survival: their work within a changing environment to grow food for themselves and their community, producing the city around them as a socio-ecological hybrid. Urban food production, in this case, serves as a praxis and a knowledge frame for liberation and emancipation.
This paper explores urban agrarianism among Black and brown residents in light of two historical moments that have deeply impacted Cleveland, and that I argue have shaped and informed agrarian praxis and growers’ urban imaginaries. Collaborative survival recognizes that processes of urban development are ongoing and immanent and contests developmentalist narratives that marginalize epistemologies embracing alternative urban futures. Examining Black growers' experiences with attention to a framing around survival and resilience highlights the continuity of structural and systemic racism and violence against Black and brown bodies, as well as the innovations that individuals and groups have deployed to contest that violence.
5,748 views
3 citations
This article offers a theoretical foundation for pursuing transdisciplinary food systems research, informed by deep sustainability and equity, across various scales of the system. It weaves together ontologically aligned, food-relevant social theory from ecofeminism, agroecology, ecological economics, systems theory and food systems scholarship, sensory studies, geography, and sociology. The epistemologies and associated methodologies of this literature all take seriously the physical laws of nature, while also recognizing that knowledge is situated in persons and places, and that people’s experiences of the world are an important part of what we can know. They all recognize the urgent need to reorient Western mental modes and their destructive, attendant material relationships. Epistemological integration rests upon ontological convergence of embeddedness, embodiment, and the context for change, calling for a methodological approach of ethnographic, qualitative, and sensory research. No conception of the food system is complete without attending to the visceral, human experiences that shape it. Embeddedness and embodiment therefore offer an avenue for connecting information across different scales of the system, from the individual to the biosphere, allowing for the macro level to help make sense of the micro, and for the micro to reflect, resist, and alter the macro. Here, a new and better world is imagined and created through our bodies, in dialogue with and resistant to hegemonic power, and sensory research is key to understanding how things must and could change.
4,604 views
4 citations




