Skip to main content

Behavior and Welfare of the Individual Within Large, Commercially-Relevant Groups

123kviews
Editorial23 March 2021
Editorial: Behavior and Welfare of the Individual Within Large, Commercially-Relevant Groups

Individuality is increasingly recognized as important and has become a focus of exploration in many fields that study behavior and other responses. Specifically, in Animal Welfare where a variety of responses (e.g., behavioral, endocrinological, immunological, neurological, etc.) must be amalgamated comprehensively as animals adapt to stressors, animal individuality should be considered essential. The shift towards a focus on individuals (from group-level observations) has largely been driven by a growing awareness that differences between individuals can be consistent over time and across varied settings (Svendsen and Armitage, 1973;Gosling, 2001;Réale et al., 2010;Mittelbach et al., 2014). With the increased attention towards individuality and its incorporation into our understanding of Animal Welfare, we should be encouraging and utilizing the most modern and advanced methods at our disposal. The current research topic comprises 10 articles that utilize novel methods to assess animal behavior, often using advanced sensor technology and analytics, and answer questions about its relationship to welfare and physiological functioning.Measuring the behavior of individuals in their current housing environments should consider longlasting impacts of previous environments. Campbell et al. (2020) looked at the impacts of different types of rearing enrichments on subsequent ranging behavior in free-range hens. Radio-frequency identification technology was used to track individuals across a flock cycle to show that the type of environment they were reared in, affected how much they utilized the range area as adults with rearing perching structures increasing range usage..The impacts of rearing environments as well as subsequent individual variation in ranging behavior on hen welfare was further explored by Bari et al. (2020). Regular external measures of bird welfare such as body weight, plumage coverage, and comb wounds showed that hen welfare was affected by their rearing environment with control reared hens showing worse feather coverage with age. There was also a relationship with range use where hens that spent more time outside had better feather coverage.Developmental impacts on behavior can even precede the rearing environment, occurring via maternal stress and hormone deposition in chicken eggs. Peixoto et al. (2020) assessed offspring of stressed hens for anxiety-like and fear responses. The behavioral tests demonstrated limited impacts of maternal stressors and impacts did not appear to be caused by corticosterone depositions. The greatest differences were found among varying genotypes demonstrating the importance of considering the overarching influence of animal strains on individual variation in behavior when drawing general conclusions based on a specific breed.While a focus on the individual is critical for direct understanding of behavior and welfare impacts, livestock animals are typically housed in groups and will thus be affected by those individuals surrounding them. Keshavarzi et al. (2020) analyzed GPS data to demonstrate that naïve cattle in paddocks with a virtual fence were facilitated by their herd mates when learning the correct responses to this new technology that signals the presence of an invisible fence line via audio and electrical cues.Advances in sensor technology and computational abilities often require novel statistical methods to ensure generated data is used most effectively. In an example of how large complex datasets can be analyzed using these novel methods, McVey et al (2020) examined the sequential order of dairy cows entering the milking parlor over a 6-month period using entropy as a tool to assess variance and the relationship to social and temporal correlates. Interestingly, cows at the front and rear of the queue proved to be most consistent, a feature reminiscent of classical concepts of dominance hierarchies. Further analysis using machine learning proved effective in relating the variables with productivity, health status, and behavior within the home pen.Similarly, Chopra et al. (2020) examined the structural consistency of a commercial dairy herd using remote identification of pairs of cows within 3 meters of each other for more than 60 s. Proximity networks were then related to feeding-specific areas and the entire barn, as well as health status and productivity factors. The study employed applied network visualization and social network analysis to determine that associations of dyads were non-normal but rather related temporally and to specific barn areas. Baur et al. (2020) describe the development of a radiography protocol for assessing keel bone health in conscious laying hens, . The radiographs distinguished between different types of fracture. They demonstrated that keel bone fractures are likely more common than was previously recognized, with 97% of the 150 birds studied having at least one fracture, showing that this method, which is easier to use on farm than other scanning technology, provides more detail and likely sensitivity than the common approach of physical palpation.Bone health in poultry is an example of how health outcomes can be linked with individual developmental and psychosocial factors. Rokavec and Šemrov (2020) thus hypothesized that low body weight and high fear or stress. Although they did not find that low body weight or indicators of fearfulness and corticosterone levels in the feathers of younger birds predisposed them to bone deviations or fractures, such bone damage during lay was associated with lower concurrent open field activity and higher later sociality, posing questions about the causal relationships between putative indicators of fear, stress, social behavior and physical health in this species. Van der Zande et al. (2020), meanwhile, tested new behavioral analyses to quantify what they considered Dynamic Indicators of Resilience in pigs: measures of consistency in physical activity levels, automatically detected by ear tag accelerometers on piglets injected with Porcine Reproductive and Respiratory Syndrome Virus (PRRSV). They found that changes in skewness from pre-to post-injection predicted mortality risk, and that statistical tendencies suggested possible relationships between high variation in activity, as measured by the Root Mean Square Error (RMSE) in the days after the injection and its increase from pre-exposure levels, and clinical illness symptoms. This novel use of accelerometer data thus holds some promise for quantifying individuals' resilience to health challenges.Finally, individual monitoring of behavior can provide insight into changes in the brain, as demonstrated by Armstrong et al. (2020) who tracked over 400 hens using RFID technology and correlated this with responses to standardized behavioral tests and brain samples from a subset of the hens. The results showed that increased ranging behavior may stimulate cell proliferation, a measure of plasticity, in the rostral hippocampus, thus contributing to the cognitive benefits of outdoor access, and that overall proliferation correlated with a personality indicator, tonic immobility as a fear response.Overall, this body of research highlights the use of technology and analysis for precise data collection at the level of the individual to better understand factors that affect animal behavior and welfare as well as how these individuals are influenced by the groups they are housed within.

1,850 views

1 citations

Proximity Interactions in a Permanently Housed Dairy Herd: Network Structure, Consistency, and Individual Differences
Understanding the herd structure of housed dairy cows has the potential to reveal preferential interactions, detect changes in behavior indicative of illness, and optimise farm management regimes. This study investigated the structure and consistency of the proximity interaction network of a permanently housed commercial dairy herd throughout October 2014, using data collected from a wireless local positioning system. Herd-level networks were determined from sustained proximity interactions (pairs of cows continuously within three meters for 60 seconds or longer), and assessed for social differentiation, temporal stability, and the influence of individual-level characteristics such as lameness, parity, and days in milk. We determined the level of inter-individual variation in proximity interactions across the full barn housing, and for specific functional zones within it (feeding, non-feeding). The observed networks were highly connected and temporally varied, with significant preferential assortment, and inter-individual variation in daily interactions in the non-feeding zone. We found no clear social assortment by lameness, parity, or days in milk. Our study demonstrates the potential benefits of automated tracking technology to monitor the proximity interactions of individual animals within large, commercially relevant groups of livestock.

7,251 views

34 citations

Cell Proliferation in the Adult Chicken Hippocampus Correlates With Individual Differences in Time Spent in Outdoor Areas and Tonic Immobility
ORIGINAL RESEARCH
26 August 2020
Cell Proliferation in the Adult Chicken Hippocampus Correlates With Individual Differences in Time Spent in Outdoor Areas and Tonic Immobility
Elena A. Armstrong, 7 more and Tom V. Smulders
Access to outdoor areas is provided as a means of enhancing welfare in commercial systems for laying hens (Gallus gallus domesticus), but substantial individual differences exist in their proportional use. Baseline cell proliferation levels of Adult Hippocampal Neurogenesis (AHN) have been associated with individual differences in reactive versus proactive coping style, and in both mammals and birds, AHN is upregulated by positive experiences including environmental enrichment and exercise. We thus sought to explore whether individual differences in use of outdoor areas and in tonic immobility responses (indicative of fearfulness) were associated with hippocampal cell proliferation and neuronal differentiation. Radio frequency identification technology was used to track the ranging behaviour of 440 individual focal hens within a commercially-relevant system over a 72-day period, after which tonic immobility durations were measured. Following hippocampal tissue collection from 58 focal hens, proliferation and neuronal differentiation were measured through quantitative PCR for proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) and doublecortin mRNA respectively. Individual differences in tonic immobility duration positively correlated with PCNA expression over the whole hippocampal formation, while greater time spent in outdoor areas (the grassy range and stone yard) was associated with higher proliferation in the rostral subregion. Basal proliferation in the chicken hippocampal formation may thus relate to reactivity, while levels in the rostral region may be stimulated by ranging experience. Doublecortin expression in the caudal hippocampus negatively co-varied with time on the grassy range, but was not associated with tonic immobility duration. This suggests that ranging outside may be associated with stress. Within laying hen flocks, individual differences in hippocampal plasticity thus relate to coping style and use of external areas.

17,909 views

26 citations

Rearing Enrichments Affected Ranging Behavior in Free-Range Laying Hens
ORIGINAL RESEARCH
14 August 2020
Rearing Enrichments Affected Ranging Behavior in Free-Range Laying Hens
Dana L. M. Campbell, 3 more and Caroline Lee
Within Australia, free-range systems are prevalent, but pullets destined for range access are reared indoors. This mismatch between rearing and layer housing may hinder adaptation to the free-range environment. Rearing enrichment could enhance pullet development. A total of 1386 Hy-Line Brown® chicks were reared inside an experimental facility across 16 weeks with 3 enrichment treatments including 1) a control group with standard floor-housing, 2) a novelty group providing novel objects that changed weekly (‘novelty’ hens), and 3) a structural group with custom-designed H-shaped structures including opaque sides (‘structural’ hens). At 16 weeks of age all pullets were leg-banded with microchips and moved to an experimental free-range system with 9 identical pens (n = 3/rearing treatment). From 25 to 64 weeks, individual hen daily ranging behavior was tracked via radio-frequency identification technology and grouped into 6 age periods per rearing treatment. Video footage was used to count the number of hens at different distances on the range for the first 14 days of access and eggs were assessed for albumen corticosterone concentrations 4 days prior to (n = 450) and one week after first range access (n = 450). Across most age periods, the structural hens spent the most time ranging (P ≤ 0.01), the novelty hens showed the fewest number of visits to the range (P < 0.0001) and both enriched hen groups had the longest maximum visit durations (P ≤ 0.02). Range use increased with age across all treatments with only 3% of hens never going outside. All hens were initially slow to use the range area with fewer novelty hens venturing farther onto the range (P ≤ 0.03). The structural hens had higher albumen corticosterone concentrations and variance (both P ≤ 0.004) prior to range access. All hens showed an increase in albumen corticosterone following the first week of range access resulting in no differences between rearing treatments in means (P = 0.92) and variance (P = 0.63). Different enrichments have differing impacts on ranging behavior, but further research is needed to understand the mechanisms of effects, with differences in brain lateralization a potential hypothesis to be tested.

9,991 views

38 citations

Maternal stress can affect the offspring of birds, possibly due to hormone deposition in the egg. Additionally, phenotypic diversity resulting from domestication and selection for productivity has created a variety of poultry lines that may cope with stress differently. In this study, we investigated the effects of maternal stress on the behaviour of different strains of laying hens and the role of corticosterone as its mediator. For this, fertilized eggs of 5 genetic lines — 2 brown (Brown 1 & 2), 2 white (White 1 & 2) and 1 pure line White Leghorn — were reared identically as 4 flocks of 27 birds (24F: 3M) per strain. Each strain was equally separated into 2 groups: Maternal Stress (“MS”), where hens were subjected to a series of daily acute psychological stressors for 8 days before egg collection, and “Control,” which received routine husbandry. Fertile eggs from both treatments were collected at 3 different ages forming different offspring groups that were treated as replicates in time; additional eggs from Control were injected either with corticosterone diluted in a vehicle solution (“CORT”) or just “Vehicle”. Eggs from each replicate were incubated, hatched, and offspring (N=1919) were brooded under identical conditions. To measure the effects of maternal stress on anxiety-like and fear behaviour, offspring were subjected to a social isolation test (SI) between 5 to 10 days of age, and a tonic immobility test (TI) at 9 weeks of age. Compared to Control, MS decreased the number of distress vocalizations emitted by White 2 in SI. No effects of MS were observed in TI, and no effects of CORT were observed in any tests. Overall, brown lines vocalized more in SI and remained in TI for a longer duration than white strains, suggesting genetic differences in fear behaviour. Females vocalized more than males in TI and showed a trend towards significance for the same trait in SI. Overall, results suggest that the effects of maternal stress on fearfulness are not directly mediated by corticosterone. Moreover, it highlights behavioural differences across various strains of laying hens, suggesting that fear response is highly dependent on genotype.

13,201 views

42 citations