Skip to main content

COVID Ecology and Evolution: Systemic Biosocial Dynamics

Cover image for Research Topic "COVID Ecology and Evolution: Systemic Biosocial Dynamics"
301kviews
Editorial: COVID Ecology and Evolution: Systemic Biosocial Dynamics
Editorial03 September 2021
Editorial: COVID Ecology and Evolution: Systemic Biosocial Dynamics

In a vastly impacted world by COVID-19, it is widely observable how ecosystem heterogeneity – i.e. biological and environmental more importantly, where the latter include socio-economical aspects – plays a fundamental role in shaping COVID-19 space-time impact and response (Fig. 1). The lack to address ecosystem heterogeneity, that is partially reflected by administrative boundaries, within the decision making process can cause cascading extreme risks with multiple effects beyond morbidity and mortality in the human population. This is observed in many areas implementing disorganized control strategies or assuming non science-based ‘’one size fits all’’ approaches. An ecosystem approach is needed where the collective ecology of COVID-19 is taken into account, from the portfolio of its determinants to controls. During the COVID-19 pandemic, due to a reduced human activity (e.g. in industrial production and mobility), surprising positive environmental outcomes also occurred, such as the decrease of air and water pollution. Meanwhile, many other still open research questions arose, such as the spread of SARS-CoV-2 through the hydrologic cycle and pathways.

In light of the above considerations this Special Issue aimed to embrace a systemic analysis of COVID-19 considering the multifaceted reality of the problem, including basic research and practical implications. Thirteen papers were published accordingly, spanning biology (Cueno and Imai (2021), Cueno et al. (2021)), environmental epidemiology (Ran et al. (2020), Rahalkar and Bahulikar (2020), Pansini and Fornacca (2021), Salom et al. (2021)), public health and healthcare (Marei et al. (2020), Silva Campos et al. (2021), Zhu et al. (2021)), and health policy and social dynamics (Chaudhury and Banerjee (2020), Yang et al. (2020), Stöllberger and Winkler-Dworak (2020), Wagner et al. (2020)) of COVID-19. While certain papers aimed to investigate deeply the mechanisms underlying COVID-19 dynamics, others focused on determining socio-environmental associations useful for predictions and policy discussion. The differentiation between causality and predictability is a rather important point to emphasize due to the unfortunate generalized confusion between the two in ‘’big data’’ and model-driven investigations that has deep policy implications.

Considering COVID-19 biology, very interestingly, Cueno and Imai (2021) found preliminary evidence suggesting that the structural conformation of SARS-CoV-2 (SARS2) spike protein is distinct from other known human-infecting CoVs; this may have triggered the viral pathogenesis (for humans) that mainly relies on the spike glycoprotein (with a furin-like cleavage site (FLC) as a structural feature) located on the virus surface. As a follow up Cueno et al. (2021) analyzed the COVID-19 genomic epidemiology network over time and detected nine SARS2 FLC patterns that potentially correspond to nine country clusters associated to the rapid evolution of the SARS2 genome and its infectivity. This evidently shed light into the environmental determinacy of viral biology and infectivity as well as SARS-CoV-2 uniqueness that lead to the pandemic.

As for COVID-19 environmental vulnerability, Pansini and Fornacca (2021), based on multiscale data from China, found a positive correlation between infections and mortality and Carbon Monoxide (CO), Formaldehyde, PM 2.5, and Nitrogen Dioxide (NO2) (retrieved by Sentinel-5 data) but lack of correlation with population density. These results emphasized how air pollutants are likely population vulnerability factors as suggested by other mechanistic studies highlighting the facilitation of virus spread (including SARS-CoV-2) via pollutant particles. This was also suggested by Salom et al. (2021) via detected positive correlations between the inferred reproduction number and pollution levels, as well as with temperature and humidity beyond other health and biological factors (such as cholesterol and blood Rh as individual vulnerabilities).

Contrarily to these findings, Ran et al. (2020), found that associations (adjusted by temperature and relative humidity) between three gaseous air pollutants (NO2, SO2, and CO) and COVID-19 basic reproductive number (assumed to represent transmissibility) are not statistically correlated. The multivariable linear regression model was used on different pollution estimates from China kriged via meteorological data.

Overall the discrepancy of findings between these studies emphasizes the caveat of predictions that are always based on input data, their space-time scale, model type and methodology (i.e. how a model is run) as predominant elements. Additionally, a warning is about the lack of consideration of non-linearity in these models that adopt statistical linear correlation for inferring ‘’causality’’. It is rather important to stress that lack of correlation quite often is a signature of non-linear causation (as demonstrated by evidence on complex systems), and in general absence of correlation does not imply lack of causation between variables; this is easily provable by adopting a probabilistic rather than a categorical deterministic approach.

Yet, based on empirical evidence it is rather clear that persistent air pollution exposure is an ecological multi-scale public health issue where airborne pollutant particulates are likely acting as vector of COVID-19.

As for emphasizing the role of environmental disturbance into the ecology of emerging viruses, Rahalkar and Bahulikar (2020) found (based on previously published thesis) that a SARS-like CoV originating from Chinese horseshoe bats (Rhinolophus), was the predicted causative agent of Mojiang mineshaft miners' severe pneumonia-like illness in (2013). This provides very interestingly important clues into the potential ecosystem ontogeny of SARS-CoV-2.

As for public health more oriented toward population determinants, with Brazil data Silva Campos et al. (2021) tried to identify, via a MCDA model, the underpinning socio-economic and healthcare vulnerability of populations affected by COVID-19. Marei et al. (2020) emphasized the need of detailed identification of traveler's risk for minimizing COVID-19 spread. Zhu et al. (2021) highlighted how China prevention countermeasures for imported cases played an indispensable role in curbing COVID-19 spread, and suggested to prolong the 2-week quarantine period for monitoring asymptomatic patients.

In terms of health policy, Yang et al. (2020) discussed how COVID-19 represented a huge opportunity for clinical research. For this objective Stöllberger and Winkler-Dworak (2020) encouraged the sharing of clinical data for defining prognostic indicators and understanding the long-term pulmonary, cardiac, neurologic, and psychiatric consequences of COVID-19. Lastly, Chaudhury and Banerjee (2020) suggested ecotheraphy as a form of recovery from psychological effects of COVID-19.

In a broader perspective Wagner et al. (2020) reviewed economic and behavioral influencing factors of vaccine and antibiotics use and/or refusal globally. This has implications for the acceptance and coverage of COVID-19 vaccine: a topic that is extremely current due to the large vaccination hesitancy in many countries and subpopulations worldwide (also largely associated to misinformation generating risk aversion) that is impacting the curb of COVID-19 spread.

In conclusion, also in light of the diversity of this Special Issue papers, a firm belief should be that research and intervention for this pandemic and complex planetary issues alike, must overcome disciplinary boundaries as well as draw analogies and conclusions from previous events, including small unsuspicious local epidemics. This can raise early warning signals of disastrous systemic outbreaks whose pathogen biology may be largely unknown and extremely transmissible independently of many other factors, such the case of SARS-CoV-2 that ‘’globalized’’ the world.

We underline the huge role of the environment for the ecology (and biology) of infectious diseases, considering both their emergence and spillover in humans due to environmental transformations, and disease control mediated by inhibitory or enhancing socio-environmental factors such as hygiene and air pollution. Environmental change, due to aggressive local development and ingrained climate change, is dramatically the core of problems like SARS2 emergence where organized and stable ecosystem connections (environment-biota including humans) are compromised. Therefore, in order to study and prevent future pandemics, the hope is to see more nature-oriented protection and monitoring before any public health control when the problem already occurred. Additionally, the hope is for science-based solutions in the decision-making process where accurate and salient information is gathered considering objectives, space-time scales, environmental and non-linear dynamics, especially when disease mechanisms are relevant and policy decision are made rather than for mere prediction exercises.

Open transdisciplinary collaborations are certainly creating the optimal platform for this modus operandi, targeting ecosystem or planetary health at the global scale.

Fig. 1. Biocomplexity of COVID-19. The spread of COVID-19 worldwide manifested several ecological and evolutionary trajectories considering phylogenetic and socio-environmental determinants over space and time (including for instance climatological, air pollution, and healthcare factors underpinning vulnerability, exposure and control). Critical research and ecosystemic management of COVID-19 should consider the interdependencies of these factors underpinning novel and multidisciplinary areas such as eco-environmental phylogenetics and ecosystem health science. Phylogenetic tree was made in https://nextstrain.org/sars-cov-2/

3,574 views

1 citations

ORIGINAL RESEARCH
20 May 2021
Challenges Caused by Imported Cases Abroad for the Prevention and Control of COVID-19 in China
Jianfei Zhu, 13 more and Tao Jiang

4,015 views

8 citations

Structural Comparison of the SARS CoV 2 Spike Protein Relative to Other Human-Infecting Coronaviruses
Coronaviruses (CoV) are enveloped positive-stranded RNA viruses and, historically, there are 7 known human-infecting CoVs with varying degrees of virulence. CoV attachment to the host is the first step of viral pathogenesis and mainly relies on the spike glycoprotein located on the viral surface. Among the human-infecting CoVs, only the infection of SARS CoV 2 (SARS2) among humans resulted to a pandemic which would suggest that the protein structural conformation of SARS2 spike protein is distinct as compared to other human-infecting CoVs. Surprisingly, the possible differences and similarities in the protein structural conformation between the various human-infecting CoV spike proteins have not been fully elucidated. In this study, we utilized a computational approach to generate models and analyze the 7 human-infecting CoV spike proteins, namely: HCoV 229E (229E), HCoV OC43 (OC43), HCoV NL63 (NL63), HCoV HKU1 (HKU1), SARS CoV (SARS1), MERS CoV (MERS), and SARS CoV 2 (SARS2). Model quality assessment of all CoV models generated, structural superimposition of the whole protein model and selected S1 domains (S1-CTD and S1-NTD), and structural comparison based on RMSD values, Tm scores, and contact mapping were all performed. We found that the structural orientation of S1-CTD is a potential structural feature associated to both the CoV phylogenetic cluster and lineage. Moreover, we observed that spike models in the same phylogenetic cluster or lineage could potentially have similar protein structure. Additionally, we established that there are potentially 3 distinct S1-CTD orientation (Pattern I, Pattern II, Pattern III) among the human-infecting CoVs. Furthermore, we postulate that human-infecting CoVs in the same phylogenetic cluster may have similar S1-CTD and S1-NTD structural orientation. Taken together, we propose that the SARS2 spike S1-CTD follows a Pattern III orientation which has a higher degree of similarity with SARS1 and some degree of similarity with both OC43 and HKU1 which coincidentally are in the same phylogenetic cluster and lineage, whereas, the SARS2 spike S1-NTD has some degree of similarity among human-infecting CoVs that are either in the same phylogenetic cluster or lineage.

25,982 views

58 citations

ORIGINAL RESEARCH
23 December 2020
Demographic and Clinical Characteristics of Early Travel-Associated COVID-19 Cases
Reham M. Marei, 8 more and Hadi M. Yassine

4,625 views

4 citations

Despite vast improvements in global vaccination coverage during the last decade, there is a growing trend in vaccine hesitancy and/or refusal globally. This has implications for the acceptance and coverage of a potential vaccine against COVID-19. In the United States, the number of children exempt from vaccination for “philosophical belief-based” non-medical reasons increased in 12 of the 18 states that allowed this policy from 2009 to 2017 (1). Meanwhile, the overuse and misuse of antibiotics, especially in young children, have led to increasing rates of drug resistance that threaten our ability to treat infectious diseases. Vaccine hesitancy and antibiotic overuse exist side-by-side in the same population of young children, and it is unclear why one modality (antibiotics) is universally seen as safe and effective, while the other (vaccines) is seen as potentially hazardous by some. In this review, we consider the drivers shaping the use of vaccines and antibiotics in the context of three factors: individual incentives, risk perceptions, and social norms and group dynamics. We illustrate how these factors contribute to the societal and individual costs of vaccine underuse and antimicrobial overuse. Ultimately, we seek to understand these factors that are at the nexus of infectious disease epidemiology and social science to inform policy-making.

23,768 views

59 citations

Lethal Pneumonia Cases in Mojiang Miners (2012) and the Mineshaft Could Provide Important Clues to the Origin of SARS-CoV-2
With the COVID-19 pandemic reaching its worse heights, everyone is genuinely interested in the origin of SARS-CoV-2. In our quest, we started with two important questions: First, were there any similar atypical pneumonia outbreaks, even on a smaller level, reported in between SARS (2004) and COVID-19 (2019) from China? Secondly, where did the beta-coronavirus most closely related to date with SARS-CoV-2 at the genome sequence level, strain RaTG13 (CoV4991) sampled from a horseshoe bat in Yunnan province, exactly come from? It was found that RaTG13/CoV4991 was collected from Tongguan mineshaft in Mojiang, Yunnan, China, in 2013. Surprisingly, the same mineshaft was also associated with a severe pneumonia-like illness in miners in 2012 killing three of the six miners. A Master’s thesis (in the Chinese language) was found on the cnki.net website which described in detail the severe illness in miners. The thesis concluded that a SARS-like CoV originating from Chinese horseshoe bats (Rhinolophus) was the predicted causative agent. The cases were remotely monitored by a prominent pulmonologist in China. The retrospective analysis of the pneumonia cases shows striking similarities with COVID-19. Bilateral pneumonia, vascular complications like pulmonary thromboembolism, and secondary infections are the main similarities. The treatment regimes were similar to the currently given treatment for COVID-19. We propose that the Mojiang mineshaft and the miners' illness cases could provide important clues to the investigation of the origin of SARS-CoV-2. The cases should be studied by various academicians, researchers, and medical professionals. Many important questions are raised in this context.

128,967 views

43 citations

OPINION
11 September 2020
The Impact of COVID-19 Pandemic on Clinical Research in China: Challenges and Progress
Yuan Yang, 5 more and Yu-Tao Xiang

4,228 views

1 citations