Skip to main content

Re-Purposing Universities for Sustainable Human Progress

Cover image for Research Topic "Re-Purposing Universities for Sustainable Human Progress"
266kviews
Editorial15 March 2022
Editorial: Re-Purposing Universities for Sustainable Human Progress

very institutions have been criticized for their slow response and inadequate action, for simultaneously promulgating high carbon and consumptive lifestyles and economies, and for entrenched intellectual practices and pedagogies that underpin these miscarriages. Invoking the notion of system failure, Sterling (this volume) argues that universities are largely maladapative, echoing a sentiment across the collection that our academic institutions are no longer fit for purpose. For many, a fundamental barrier to change is that academic institutions are beholden to the same economic forces that have brought society to the brink of crisis (e.g. Green, this volume, Bauer et al. this volume, Lopez--Lopez et al this volume, Hurth & Stewart this volume). The late 20th century's 'great acceleration' in global economic growth and material consumption has been reflected in the re--direction of academia towards the marketisation and commodification of university operations, alongside the adoption of a global accountancy culture of rankings and metrics. Hurth & Stewart (this volume) reappraise this conventional economic framing in the light of the rise of the "Wellbeing Economy" and the recent emergence in the business sector of "purpose--led" companies, which operationalise this new, sustainability--aligned, economic imperative. They argue that concept of 'purpose' offers universities a roadmap to a rapid journey towards being fully wisdom--driven and sustainability--driving organisations. To deliver on this call for change, "universities will need to renew their commitments to serving the public good, be dedicated to an unwavering challenge--orientation, create post--disciplinary structures, and be the change one seeks to see in the world" (Fazey et al. this volume p.1). These authors see three levels of threat to this happening: (1) the risks to operations and business models (manifest emergencies); (2) risks that arise because assumptions, ideologies, systems, and structures cannot match the scale of the manifest challenges (conceptual emergencies); and (3) risks posed as a result of current identities and sense of purpose being incapable of supporting the changes needed to overcome the conceptual challenges (existential emergencies). Despite its potential for collective action, Gardner et al. (this volume) argue that the academic sector's response to these threats has been limited to three partial adjustments: (1) promoting solutions--focused research; (2) institutionalising "education for sustainable development"; and (3) reducing their own institutional footprints. But to be proportionate to the scale and seriousness of the planetary challenge, reform will have to go beyond universities merely getting their respective houses in order by greening their research, curricula and campuses and signing up to reputation--enhancing public commitments without commensurate action (Latter & Capstick; Green, this volume). A vital first step in that transformation process is for universities to recognise that there is a problem. Multiple contributors emphasise the deep reluctance within the closed world of universities to confront the culpability of the academic enterprise in our current unsustainability crisis. Historically, universities have proved to be remarkably resilient institutions, keeping external social change at arms--length by traditional practices of inquiry, tight--knit communities of scholars and students, and autonomous governance structures. O'Neil (this volume) refers to the defensive posture institutions adopt when their autonomy is challenged as institutional fragility; to counter this intrinsic intransigence, universities will have to deliberately develop transformational intent -interventions to actively disrupt the status quo to open up the possibilities of seeing the world from fresh frames of reference and create capacities for deep transformational change (Fazey et al. this volume). Transformational intent necessitates a whole--institution cultural shift in mindsets, across research, teaching, knowledge transfer, and campus operations (Sterling, this volume). From the top, it needs to be supported by a facilitative rather than directive executive leadership, allowing everyone --staff, students, and stakeholders --to co--produce the mission and shape the transformation (Bauer et al. this volume). This challenge, according to O'Neil (this volume), demands that universities flatten their hierarchical structures, think systemically, collaborate, be authentic, be just, be equitable, be inclusive, build relationships, and enact a collective vision that requires collective decision making. Within the heart of the organisation, it will necessitate systemic change in and across diverse sectors, and compel academics to reappraise their role as change agents (Konig et al. this volume). For Lopez--Lopez (this volume), the transformation must go further by promoting a "pedagogy of care" that extends the academic worldview to a 'Community of Life', blending learning with compassion in a practical application of Maxwell's wisdom inquiry to the problems of humanity. It is a premise that has deep parallels with the environmental theology of Thomas Berry, which Mickey (this volume) argues underpins the need for sustainability transitions at universities to embrace the intrinsic, not merely instrumental, value of nature in a whole--Earth perspective. As well as more enlightened worldviews, new governance paradigms and fresh metrics of accountability and responsibility will be required for university renewal. For Robinson & Laycock Pedersen (this volume) that means destabilizing prevailing governance structures and processes to create a new stable academic system, and the authors use resilience principles to show how this might be operationalised. Recurrent throughout the Research Topic is the view that the current competition for contemporary views of 'scientific excellence' prevents participating universities from fully engaging in a wider set of alternative activities and scientific excellence. The widespread use of league tables and accounting to capture and assess teaching and research performance tell us little about how well academic institutions are faring in terms of their core mission (Green, this volume). Mono--disciplinary research is still accorded greater value than innovative citizen science, but authentic dialogues will be required with a wide range of stakeholders, including grassroots groups and informal but dynamic social movements (Bell et al, this volume). As Bauer et al. (this volume) outline, effective engagement with community organisations opens up new ways of learning -individually and as an institution --around urgent social and environmental issues but this also requires radical new structures and processes for participation, facilitation and cooperation between stakeholders from different fields and sectors. Conventional university norms would suggest that 'it is not the proper job of the Professor to go out into the community and stir up political activism!' (Maxwell this volume) but this is rejected head--on by Gardner et al. (this volume), who argue convincingly for advocacy and activism to be placed at the heart of the new academic purpose. There are signs that more organised levels of change, driven from the top, are underway in some institutions and institutional contexts. Fioramonti et al. (this volume) give a first--hand view of the political innovations occurring in Italy to systematically and inter--disciplinarily align education to a sustainable future. Similarly, Davidson (this volume) outlines how the 2015 Welsh Well--being of Future Generations Act is starting to influence the way universities are approaching research and curriculum. Specifically, Davidson argues that delivering "well--being of future generations" or "sustainability" is becoming shorthand for a commitment to designing in future--proofing, systems thinking, creative problem solving, self--awareness, open--mindedness toward difference, understanding of global issues/power relationships, and optimism and action for a better world. Tyndale et al. (this volume) outline University College London's decade--long journey to live out their founding commitment to: 'innovation, accessibility, and relevance for the benefit of humanity'. They remind us that there are many foundations in place in universities that can be harnessed and they provide an optimistic view that universities do not need to re--purpose but rather more fully build on the foundation already in place. Despite such aspirational enlightenment, the reality for many universities, especially in low and middle income countries, is that sustainability remains an accessory to catching up on economic and social development. A telling example comes from Jordan, from where El Hassan et al (this volume) describe an unsustainable university sector firmly shackled to the state--building process, which is hindering its academic community re--imagining higher education for wider public good. But clearly changes are afoot. It is significant that the backdrop to the growing disaffection with the academic endeavour has been the twinning of a Climate and Ecological Emergency (CEE) (Green, this volume; Gardner et al., this volume) with a global pandemic. It is a powerful pairing that has provided both the impetus for systemic change and major asperities to hinder it (e.g. Bell et al this volume). The way that UK universities addressed Climate Emergency Declarations highlights this duality, with many declarations being used as individual promotional statements within a collective sector response, despite being instigated, not from internal academic concerns, but from a substantial increase in public concern and pressure from civil society (Latter & Capstick, this volume). For Green (this volume), the lacklustre response of universities globally to the CEE is an indication that climate change and sustainability remain "add--ons" or peripheral to core academic core business, highlighting the challenge of building long--term thinking on the back of short--term concerns -even those as impactful as a global pandemic. Perhaps more optimistically, Bell & Payne (this volume) highlight how Fernando Reimers's edited book on 'Education and Climate Change: the role of universities' provides examples of how the inherently contextual nature of climate impacts are revitalising global concerns at the local level. Writing here, Reimers (this volume) explores how the pandemic has motivated universities to develop more socially--embedded learning systems, although these reactive initiatives generally lack clear strategic intent or theories of action. What seems clear is that the skills, graduate attributes and modes of learning demanded by a re-energised socially--embedded populous who are emerging from a pandemic and gaining deep awareness of the structural unsustainability faced, will be very different to those currently offered. For a start, the fast pace of technological change will mean that technical skills are likely to quickly become obsolete. This, in turn, necessitates a more fluid curriculum and intellectual experience that provides the tools for students to think critically, systemically and creatively about multiple problems that cross traditional disciplinary divides. This may require a complete rethinking about how universities are conceived and located (Costanza et al., this volume). The COVID19 pandemic has given renewed impetus to this, particularly given the rapid transition to online learning. For Costanza and co--authors this reconfiguration potentially recasts the traditional role of universities as storehouses of knowledge and academics as conveyors of that content. The massive and growing availability of information on the internet provides an opportunity to open up access to top--quality university education in developing countries with relatively modest educational infrastructure. The authors set out a vision for global collaboration --a coordinated 'meta--university' that could provide students anywhere access to world--class online pedagogic tools and analysis--based courses, thereby allowing local faculty to focus on interactive, transdisciplinary, in--person, solutions--focused courses that address real--world problems. Despite the collection's overarching message that universities are not moving far enough or fast enough, this Research Topic demonstrates a consensus on the nature of the ultimate goal and the immediate need for radical change, as well as, vitally, an emerging roadmap of how to get there. The 23 contributions offer differing visions on how that radical change might be operationalised, but some common calls emerge:1. TRANSFORMATIVE CHANGE IS NOT AN OPTION: Across the world, academia is set for profound reform, whether it likes it or not. The growing global urgency for purposeful change, not least from student bodies, will present universities with threat multipliers too overwhelming to resist or forestall. Discussions within higher education institutions, therefore, need to switch from 'should we change?' to 'how should we change?';2. PURPOSE IS KEY: At the highest level, universities need to rethink their ethos and purposetheir raison d'etre --that centres on a bold and ambitious strategic contribution to long--term sustainable wellbeing for all, engaging all stakeholders in this shared journey. Two standards focused on achieving a purpose--driven organisation in practice are available to support leadership, and those who can help hold them accountable: ISO 37000 -Governance of Organizations: Guidance and PAS 808: Purpose--driven Organisations: Worldviews, Principles and Behaviours (forthcoming); 3. DEEP CHANGE CAN UNLOCK WIN--WINS: This essential deep--level, root--and--branch rethinking of the academic mission has the potential to re--energise teaching, research and external engagement, blending the bespoke strengths of individual universities to create genuinely distinctive meaningful and legitimate institutional identities; 4. REMEMBER, WE ARE ALL IN THIS TOGETHER: The operational route to transformative change will be unique to each university, but the broad path will involve a shift to interdisciplinary, participatory, reflexive academic mindsets and endeavours, in which researchers and students are more closely coupled with the communities they serve and the environmental systems within which their ultimate survival is deeply embedded; 5. THE WRITING IS ON THE WALL: This challenge presents an exciting but closing window of opportunity and renewal for a university. Those universities unwilling or unable to rise to the call are likely to find themselves increasingly marginal to the emerging needs of society and economy in a state of transition struggling towards a safer and secure future. Ultimately, perhaps what emerges most strongly from this collection of perspectives is the realisation that at the heart of the current academic identity crisis there lies a leadership void. It is our sincere hope that this Research Topic inspires the universities' leadership (governing bodies and senior executives) as well as the entire academic body, to dig into their deepest levels of assumptions about the point of universities, and through this unleash their desire and direct their ability to drive the urgent re--purposing of universities. Although we primarily make a plea to university leadership to drive this change, the question of re--imagining and re--purposing higher education for sustainable human progress is a challenge that all stakeholders -including academics, students, policymakers and media -need to embrace fully, if collectively we are to increase the chances of an assured future beyond the apocalyptic one in prospect

3,884 views

16 citations

CURRICULUM, INSTRUCTION, AND PEDAGOGY
20 September 2021
Taking the Complex Dynamics of Human–Environment–Technology Systems Seriously: A Case Study in Doctoral Education at the University of Luxembourg
Ariane König, 5 more and Karl Pickar

3,226 views

3 citations

In leadership positions at UCL, we have spent more than a decade seeking to fulfil our university’s founding commitment – inspired almost two centuries ago by the utilitarian philosopher Jeremy Bentham – to innovation, accessibility and relevance for the benefit of humanity. Our guiding principle has been to make our institution and its activities greater than the sum of its parts. To enable us to have most impact in “sustainable human progress”, we have focused our approach on cross-disciplinarity – by which we mean collaboration between experts in different disciplines that transcends subject boundaries – because the problems faced by society cannot be solved by research from one discipline alone. In recent years we have come to understand the boundaries between disciplines to be a subset of the many types of barriers – such as those between communities (disciplinary, academic and otherwise) and between different kinds of activity – that can inhibit the fulfilment of our vision to maximise our public benefit. In order to address crucial challenges – from the local to the global – we need to form collaborations across society that increase our mutual knowledge and engagement. We need to understand how the translation and application of knowledge will change in different settings and according to different practicalities. And we need to better reflect and enhance our role as convenors of different stakeholders to promote greater shared dialogue, co-creation and action.

2,770 views

2 citations

Wales is the first country in the world to have put into law the protection of future generations; the first country to have a legal mechanism through the Act to deliver on the Sustainable Development Goals and the first country to have put the Brundtland definition of sustainable development into law. What does this mean for the values taught in Welsh universities and how can the university role be re-purposed in the interests of future generations? Building on her research for the book #futuregen: Lessons from a Small Country which was published this year, Jane Davidson, who, in her previous role as Minister in Welsh Government, proposed what is now the Well-being of Future Generations (Wales) Act 2015, will explore the opportunities from this new values framework to transform the university sector, in particular the student experience in Wales, and whether there are further lessons that would be valuable elsewhere.

2,637 views

1 citations

Higher education in Jordan has been tied closely to the state-building process in the century since the modern Hashemite state’s foundation in 1921, with its explicit purpose being to educate and train high volumes of students who are competent and capable to serve as contributors to the state’s development. Though this purpose has largely been successful to date, it is becoming increasingly clear that more is needed than simply issuing degrees. In an increasingly globalized world, it is necessary to educate those who can contribute to future research arenas and labor markets over which a single state has limited control. Within this perspective, we detail the evolved societal position that higher education institutions in Jordan occupy and how that position has made such institutions a liability in the nation’s continued sustainable development. Specifically, we outline the unsustainability of impersonal, inefficient and ineffective infrastructure, centralization of policies and academic practices, lack of autonomy and/or self-governance, considerable financial dependence on the state, and a general hesitation for higher education institutions to seek boldly societal and economic impact beyond the simple production of graduates. To counter this unsustainability, we propose a three-pronged approach that can help catalyze the re-imagining of Jordan’s higher education institutions so that they become maximally effective contributors to the state’s future sustainable development. Our proposed approach is based on (i) internally decentralizing higher education institutions to enable greater autonomy and academic freedom, (ii) re-purposing these institutions to become more student-centric, and (iii) embracing diversity and academic community recognition.

4,576 views

12 citations

New ways of doing research are needed to tackle the deep interconnected nature of 21st Century challenges, like climate change, obesity and entrenched social and economic inequalities. While the impact agenda has been shaping research culture, this has largely been driven by economic imperatives, leading to a range of negative unintended consequences. Alternative approaches are needed to engage researchers in the pursuit of global challenges, but little is known about the role of impact in research cultures, how more or less healthy “impact cultures” might be characterised, or the factors that shape these cultures. We therefore develop a definition, conceptual framework and typology to explain how different types of impact culture develop and how these cultures may be transformed to empower researchers to co-produce research and action that can tackle societal challenges with relevant stakeholders and publics. A new way of thinking about impact culture is needed to support more societally relevant research. We propose that healthy impact cultures are based on: i) rigorous, ethical and action-oriented research; ii) underpinned by the individual and shared purpose, identities and values of researchers who create meaning together as they generate impact from their work; iii) enabling multiple impact sub-cultures to develop among complementary communities of researchers and stakeholders, which are porous and dynamic, enabling these communities to work together where their needs and interests intersect, as they build trust and connection and attend to the role of social norms and power; and iv) enabled with sufficient capacity, including skills, resources, leadership, strategic and learning capacity. Based on this framework we identify four types of culture: corporate impact culture; research “and impact” culture; individualistic impact culture; and co-productive impact culture. We conclude by arguing for a bottom-up transformation of research culture, moving away from the top-down strategies and plans of corporate impact cultures, towards change driven by researchers and stakeholders themselves in more co-productive and participatory impact cultures that can address 21st Century challenges.

28,782 views

40 citations

Universities are one potentially important place – albeit not the only one – to initiate the next generation into becoming the adult humans needed to navigate the difficult future of the Anthropocene. The university of the future will fail this mission, if it only prepared young people in the technical expertise required to manage accelerating climate crises and the breakdown of Earth’s life support and interlocking human systems. The depth and extent of transformation that awaits society requires people skilled in coping emotionally and in effectively engaging the plethora of challenges ahead with agility, creativity, resolve, vision and integrity. It requires universities themselves to transform into institutions of human development that cease to participate, pardon and propagate patterns of exploitation and, instead, become singularly dedicated to restoring and regenerating the conditions for life. This paper articulates a vision of a radically different future “university”. Building on others’ calls for transformation-supporting education, we frame universities’ role in the larger arc of inner and outer human and societal development. We spell out some of the implications and needs such a shift would entail. The paper is written in the spirit of the future university that we envision: not just from our analytical thinking brain, but drawing also on our imaginative/intuitive, emotional, and sensing/embodied ways of knowing. As such, it breaks with conventional academic writing and opens up wider possibilities for and commitment to life-affirming and restorative action.

6,634 views

20 citations