When evolution is free to proceed in a fashion most closely analogous to the way it operated in creating organic life on Earth, complexity arises at different levels (Ray, 1997). The complexity of a genetic architecture can be quantified by studying the exponent of the scale-free degree distribution of the network resulting from a functional genomic array. In silico, the exponent of the distribution depended on the mutation rate: low mutation rates gave rise to distributions with high exponents and hence complex genetic architectures (Gerlee and Lundh, 2008). Complexity was highly linked to epistasis. The genes of complex digital organisms had a higher degree of interdependence than their simple counterparts (Lenski et al., 1999). Indeed, the evolution of complex traits was possible as long as the building blocks of the complex function were favored by selection (Lenski et al., 1999). This is so because novel traits appeared by reusing existing information (Ofria et al., 2008) leading to a "complexity ratchet" that can be stronger than selection (Liard et al., 2020). The amount of information that a genome encodes about the world in which it evolves always increased when the fitness of the organism depended only on their own sequence information (Adami et al., 2000).
The ability of organisms to persist in the face of changing conditions requies a balance between robustness and evolvability, that is, between resisting and allowing phenotypic change (Lenski et al., 2006). This robustness is the most likely cause for the connected genotype networks and asymmetric phenotypic transitions found in digital organisms (Fortuna et al., 2017). It increased with mutation rate and decreased with population size (Elena et al., 2007). Nevertheless, robustness was achieved at expenses of losing epistatic interactions (Edlund and Adami, 2004). The ability to produce adaptive evolutionary change was related to robustness. In silico, robustness promoted evolvability only at the last stages of the adaptive process (Elena and Sanjuán, 2008). Moreover, mutations became more frequent in changing environments (Crombach and Hogeweg, 2008) and were more likely to encode novel phenotypes in digital organisms with complex phenotypes (Fortuna et al., 2017).
Using digital evolution to understand the mechanisms responsible for phenotypic plasticity has shed light on the selective pressures that could favor one type of plasticity (genetic-based) over another (nongenetic-based). The simplest strategy for selection is to evolve plasticity with no genetic basis, which is analogous to the effect of the temperature on the phenotype (e.g., nearly all enzyme activity is temperaturedependent). This kind of plasticity comes at no fitness cost to the organisms. In contrast, changing gene expression in response to the environment required much more complex selective pressures for plasticity to prevail (Clune et al., 2007). In changing environments, phenotypic plasticity provided a mechanism for organisms to regulate trait expression, which can stabilize populations. In this research
The role of chance variation and history on the adaptation process has been explored using populations of digital organisms. For example, long-term evolutionary change was highly contingent (Yedid and Bell, 2001;2002) and depended on the mutation rate: at low mutation rates, dominant genotypes descended from previous dominant genotypes, but at high mutation rates new dominant genotypes descended from one of the many rare genotypes (Yedid and Bell, 2001). In addition, evolutionary history influenced the adaptation to a new environment, which suggested that past adaptation may hinder or promote some evolutionary outcomes over others (Wagenaar and Adami, 2004). Phylogenetic reconstruction methods and hypothesis on the diversification process that takes place after mass extinctions were also tested in silico. On the one hand, phylogenetic reconstruction methods often failed when selection between branch points was absent (Hagstrom et al., 2004). On the other hand, diversification took place faster after random mass extinctions than after selective extinctions (Yedid, Ofria, and Lenski, 2009). Moreover, phenotypic traits that arose earlier in a lineage's history also tended to be expressed earlier in the development of individuals (Clune et al., 2012), which supports the hypothesis that ontology recapitulates phylogeny.
One of the main results from digital evolution experiments on genome architecture is that mutation rate limits genome size, supporting the Drake's empirical rule observed in vivo (Drake, 1991). When mutation rate per site was high, evolution promoted small-size genomes at expenses of reducing fitness since evolving more complex functions involved more genes (Knibbe et al., 2007). This is so because smaller genomes will undergo less mutations per replication and hence move a population away from an error threshold (Wilke et al., 2001). In contrast, under low mutation rates, insertions are more beneficial than deletions (Gupta et al., 2016) and the gain of robustness allows for the accumulation of non-coding sequences (Knibbe et al., 2007), driving genome expansion and the exploration of the mutational neighborhood.Selection plays also an important role in shaping genome size. Indeed, the genome reduction observed in some bacteria can be reproduced in silico by lowering the selection pressure (Batut et al., 2013).
Small genomes with few genes only have a very basic regulation activity while large ones develop complex regulatory networks with the number of transcription factors scaling quadratically with the number of metabolic genes (Molina and van Nimwegen, 2009). The same trend evolved in silico as response to the mutational pressure (Beslon et al., 2010). It has also been shown that breaking up interactions among genes (i.e., reducing the epistatic effects of mutations) diminished the deleterious effect of mutations in environments with high mutation rates (Edlund and Adami, 2004). Yet, deleterious mutations facilitated the evolution of complex, beneficial functions (Covert et al., 2013). Indeed, interactions among genes were required to evolve complex traits (Lenski et al., 2003). These epistatic interactions among genes to increase fitness may even take place between plasmids and the chromosome (Misevic et al., 2013).
THE EVOLUTION OF SEX.Digital evolution has been used to test the hypothesis that sexual reproduction is advantageous in changing environments (Misevic et al., 2010). When the environment changed rapidly and substantially, it was easier to maintain sexual reproduction than for sexual organisms to invade a formerly asexual population. It has also been used to test hypothesis on the evolution of sexual displays and mating preferences (Chandler et al., 2012). Mate preferences spread easily once they appeared and were only limited when they were very costly, which suggests that sexual displays and viability might be regulated by common genetic mechanisms (i.e., pleiotropy). Indeed, sexual reproduction shapes the genetic architecture (e.g., the genomes of sexual organisms being more modular than those of asexual ones). By evolving genomes of digital organisms, Misevic et al. (2006) found that genes encoding different functional traits had less overlap and genes encoding a particular trait were more tightly clustered on the genome of sexual organisms than on the genome of the asexual ones. Moreover, epistasis was weaker in sexual than in asexual organisms (Misevic et al., 2006).THE EVOLUTION OF COOPERATION.
Dividing tasks among specialized group members is an important aspect of the major transitions in evolution. For example, when task-switching costs increased, groups of digital organisms increasingly evolved division of labor strategies (Goldsby et al., 2012). In addition, digital evolution has provided experimental evidence supporting the hypothesis that the cells that contribute to the body's functionality but cannot produce an offspring themselves arise as an adaptation to confine metabolic work that damages a cell's DNA, which allows germ cells to keep their DNA pristine for future multicellular offspring (Goldsby et al., 2014). This transition to multicellularity was observed even allowing each organism to manage its own spatial distribution and reproductive process, which led to the emergence of several distinct life histories as shown by Moreno and Ofria (2022) in this research topic (https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fevo.2022.750837/full).
All authors listed have made a substantial, direct, and intellectual contribution to the work and approved it for publication.
