Skip to main content
Editorial25 March 2024
Editorial: Models in population, community and ecosystem dynamics

When first published, the call for this special topic was left very broad, with the aim to "welcome models for all significant aspects of population, community and ecosystem dynamics". The purpose was to obtain -hopefully-an unbiased instantaneous picture of the current directions in the field of ecological modelling. As in most fields of science, the number of publications, methodologies, and models generated in theoretical ecology have inflated in the very recent decades (Rossberg et Only two articles out of the 10, more classically, tried to ascertain the state of the ecological system at equilibrium, whether it was microbial decomposition (Manzoni et al.

Coincidence or not, we live in times that are perceived by an increasing number of people as uncertain. Incoming challenges are numerous and their complexity hard to fully grasp: the advances of artificial intelligence (Weiser & von Krogh 2023), global security challenges (Booth & Wheeler 2023), pandemics (Batty 2020), the impending climate breakdown (Barnett 2023), the absence of clearcut political projects and effective policies (Turk 2022), the looming prospect of a biodiversity collapse (Maechler & Graz 2022), economic volatility (Ahir et al. 2022), etc.We will not enter into the otherwise fascinating debate of the influence of the social context on science (Latour 1987) or of the effect in return of ecological theory on society (Scoones 1999, Bosselman & Tarlock 1994). Nor will we resolve the question of whether ecological paradigms reflect the dominant philosophical ideas in the contemporaneous society (Simberloff 1980) or whether they are rather shaped by pragmatism reflecting the characteristics of the object they study (Travassos-Britto et al. 2021). What is certain is that all current research efforts aimed at understanding and including uncertainty into ecological theories are welcome and timely.In conclusion, what have we learnt from the rather limited set of papers published in this research topic on ecological modelling? Regarding uncertainty, we will take home the variety of practical methods described that aim at explicitly including e.g., noise and error propagation (Bian & Xia 2023), demographic and environmental stochasticity (Lindo et al. 2023), chaotic dynamics in eco-evolutionary processes (Wang & Wang 2022), and the upscaling of disturbance to a continental scale (Hély et al. 2023). The articles helped us realize as well that, rather than being a nuisance to be reduced, uncertainty and variability is a fundamental component of the functioning of ecological (Lindo et al. 2023) and evolutionary systems (Fussmann & Kopp 2023) to be understood and explained (Guo et al. 2022, Wang & Wang 2022, Hooker et al 2023, Dobson et al. 2023). Finally, the works of Manzoni et al. 2023 andZelnik et al. 2023 are here to remind us that a mechanistic understanding of ecological processes is as necessary as ever, if only because variability is a process in itself, with mechanisms that generate it. Variability is so intrinsic to complex ecological systems (Roy et al 2020), and multi-scale that a holistic approach to transcend rather focused studies, such as those included in this research topic, might be the next challenge to tackle in ecological modelling (Holyoak & Wetzel 2020). We hope that the readers of this special topic will find similar inspiration for their own research from one or several of the published articles in this research topic. As editors, we would be gratified if our research topic pave the way to future contributions that will help tackle uncertainty in our understanding of the functioning of ecological systems that are put under incomparable strain since the establishment of mankind as a major actor in the biosphere of or planet.

2,346 views

1 citations

PERSPECTIVE
30 October 2023
Plant communities and food webs
Andy Dobson, 1 more and Sarah Batterman
Plant communities and food webs
Recent theoretical work has provided major new insights into the ways that species interactions in food webs are organized in ways that permit the coexistence of significant numbers of species. But, we seem to have forgotten about trees, shrubs and grasses that are the basal species in all terrestrial ecosystems. Many of the food webs available for analysis over the last 30 years were based on freshwater or marine systems where algae were the main plants. Trees are very different from algae; they can live for centuries, while annually producing leaves, fruits and seeds that provide nutrients for a diversity of species on higher trophic levels. In sharp contrast to algae, they are only partly consumed by herbivores and usually compensate or recover from herbivory. Moreover, each individual tree supports its own food web of species that are only partially coupled to those of surrounding trees. If we are going to apply our theoretical understanding of food-web structure to species-rich terrestrial ecosystems in ways that are insightful for conservation, then we need a deeper examination of the role that higher plants play in food webs. In this article, we make a plea to more sharply consider higher plants in food webs and to do this by combining recent theoretical work on food webs, with recent empirical and theoretical work on plant communities. Ultimately, we argue for a deeper integration of plant community ecology into studies of food webs.

8,347 views

3 citations

Ecologists are increasingly recognising the importance of stochastic processes in generating spatial and temporal variation in biological communities. This variation is very high in soil, which hosts not less than ¼ of all biodiversity on Earth and is central to how the terrestrial ecosystem responds to perturbations. Measurement errors, demographic stochasticity (individual variability in traits such as birth and death rates), and environmental stochasticity (fluctuations in environmental properties) are the three main sources of stochasticity in ecology. Here we synthesise how these three sources of stochasticity are quantified and incorporated in the study of soil biodiversity, highlighting current limits, possible solutions and future research needs. We stress the relevance of all these factors to our future understanding of terrestrial ecosystems via plant-soil interactions and soil-climate feedbacks. In soil, the major sources of stochasticity are measurement errors and environmental stochasticity. Measurement errors are due to the small size, high abundance, and broad distributions of soil organisms, which limit sampling in space and especially over time. We argue that positive autocorrelation is a main characteristic of soil environmental properties, which may have important consequences on the response of soil biota to perturbations. At a local scale, large populations of soil organisms also imply a minor role of demographic stochasticity. Yet, we show that demographic stochasticity can be sizeable in some datasets but still much smaller than environmental stochasticity. Explicit consideration of stochastic processes in soil biodiversity research is essential to our future understanding of the processes that control soil biodiversity. In classical ecology, stochasticity implies probabilistic predictions in terms of population growth, extinction, species coexistence and community diversity. In soil, stochasticity implies very variable responses to climate change and the soil-climate feedback. Future studies will have to identify the major sources of environmental stochasticity with a particular focus on the interaction between multiple global change factors.

5,566 views

15 citations

ORIGINAL RESEARCH
18 July 2023
Trophic interactions between primary consumers appear to weaken during periods of synchrony
Katie R. Hooker, 8 more and Robert A. McCleery

2,893 views

2 citations

In rapidly changing environments populations and species face a challenge to remain adapted and avoid extinction or replacement by fitter types. If evolutionary adaptation cannot keep pace with the speed of environmental change populations will exhibit varying degrees of maladaptation with respect to the current environmental state. Reciprocal transplant experiments are an established method for comparatively assessing the relative fitness of multiple populations in their respective environments. Here we use a quantitative-genetics model to show that inference from reciprocal transplants can be misleading when applied to populations that are in the process of adapting to environmental change. Specifically, we analyze (a) the case of two populations adapting to two different fitness optima starting from a suboptimal initial state and (b) the case of two populations attempting to adapt to changing trait targets that move at different speeds. We find that, in both scenarios, populations can undergo transitional fitness states that, if reciprocal transplant experiments were performed, would lead to the conclusion of (local) non-adaptation or maladaptation. This signature of apparent maladaptation occurs although both populations strictly follow an evolutionary trajectory dictated by the principle of fitness increase over time. Our results have implications for potential patterns of latitudinal replacement of populations/species with ongoing global change and might help shed light on the surprising finding (based on reciprocal transplants) that many populations in the wild fail to show a strong signature of adaptation to their local environments.

4,086 views

6 citations

ORIGINAL RESEARCH
24 February 2023
Uncertainty propagation in a global biogeochemical model driven by leaf area data
Chenyu Bianand Jianyang Xia
Uncertainty propagation in a global biogeochemical model driven by leaf area data
Satellite-observed leaf area index (LAI) is often used to depict vegetation canopy structure and photosynthesis processes in terrestrial biogeochemical models. However, it remains unclear how the uncertainty of LAI among different satellite products propagates to the modeling of carbon (C), nitrogen (N), and phosphorus (P) cycles. Here, we separately drive a global biogeochemical model by three satellite-derived LAI products (i.e., GIMMS LAI3g, GLASS, and GLOBMAP) from 1982 to 2011. Using a traceability analysis, we then explored the propagation of LAI-driven uncertainty to modeled C, N, and P storage among different biomes. The results showed that the data uncertainty of LAI was more considerable in the tropics than in non-tropical regions, whereas the modeling uncertainty of C, N, and P stocks showed a contrasting biogeographic pattern. The spread of simulated C, N, and P storage derived by different LAI datasets resulted from assimilation rates of elements in shrubland and C3 grassland but from the element residence time (τ) in deciduous needle leaf forest and tundra regions. Moreover, the assimilation rates of elements are the main contributing factor, with 67.6%, 93.2%, and 93% of vegetated grids for the modeled uncertainty of C, N, and P storage among the three simulations. We further traced the variations in τ to baseline residence times of different elements and the environmental scalars. These findings indicate that the data uncertainty of plant leaf traits can propagate to ecosystem processes in global biogeochemical models, especially in non-tropical forests.

4,402 views

7 citations

Decomposition rate as an emergent property of optimal microbial foraging
Decomposition kinetics are fundamental for quantifying carbon and nutrient cycling in terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems. Several theories have been proposed to construct process-based kinetics laws, but most of these theories do not consider that microbial decomposers can adapt to environmental conditions, thereby modulating decomposition. Starting from the assumption that a homogeneous microbial community maximizes its growth rate over the period of decomposition, we formalize decomposition as an optimal control problem where the decomposition rate is a control variable. When maintenance respiration is negligible, we find that the optimal decomposition kinetics scale as the square root of the substrate concentration, resulting in growth kinetics following a Hill function with exponent 1/2 (rather than the Monod growth function). When maintenance respiration is important, optimal decomposition is a more complex function of substrate concentration, which does not decrease to zero as the substrate is depleted. With this optimality-based formulation, a trade-off emerges between microbial carbon-use efficiency (ratio of growth rate over substrate uptake rate) and decomposition rate at the beginning of decomposition. In environments where carbon substrates are easily lost due to abiotic or biotic factors, microbes with higher uptake capacity and lower efficiency are selected, compared to environments where substrates remain available. The proposed optimization framework provides an alternative to purely empirical or process-based formulations for decomposition, allowing exploration of the effects of microbial adaptation on element cycling.

4,062 views

20 citations