Skip to main content

Opportunities and Challenges of Interprofessional Collaboration and Education

Cover image for Research Topic "Opportunities and Challenges of Interprofessional Collaboration and Education"
98kviews
Editorial21 March 2024
Editorial: Opportunities and challenges of interprofessional collaboration and education

interdependence; integration; shared responsibility; and team tasks. 3 These occur in various degrees from co-located teamwork with a few members to much wider networks with lesser levels of interdependence, integration and shared responsibility as the number of people involved increases.Preparing professionals for collaboration requires specific training, including learning from self and others. As the title of a World Health Organization publication from 1988 succinctly states this involves 'learning together to work together'. 4 The Centre for the Advancement of Interprofessional Education's (CAIPE) definition of interprofessional education (IPE) is 'occasions when two or more professions learn with, from and about each other, to improve collaboration, and the quality of care.' 5 The definition stresses the interactive nature of interprofessional learning (IPL) that may be formal, informal or serendipitous. IPL should involve more than simple observation of professionals at work, for example a medical student sitting in with a nurse practitioner, but rather participation, simulation and, if feasible, authentic real-life placements where learners become part of the team.There is a burgeoning literature on the contextual nature of IPC and factors leading to successful IPE.The field of interprofessional education and collaborative practice (IPECP) research and evaluation is expanding. The global network, InterprofessionalResearch. Global (IPR.Global), has proposed three areas for IPECP research that include building the science and scholarship of IPECP, addressing the complexity of interprofessional endeavours through innovative approaches, and developing evidence of impact along the continuum from IPE to service delivery. 6 These areas encompass health professional education, practice, and the connection between them.In this Frontiers in Medicine, Healthcare Professions Education, research topic on opportunities and challenges of interprofessional collaboration and education, the collection of 13 papers covers a range of topics related to IPECP but primarily focuses on IPE. Seven are of German authorship, reflecting in part the growth of IPE in Germany and indeed the other German-speaking countries of Austria and Switzerland. These three countries have formed a regional network, IP-Health (Society for Interprofessional Health and Social Care), which is a member of Interprofessional.Global (www.interprofessional.global).At the forefront of authentic practice-based IPE for health professional students are the interprofessional training wards (IPTW), which are functioning inpatient wards staffed by students working collaboratively under supervision. The first documented IPTW was opened in Sweden in 1996. 7 The first German IPTWs were implemented in 2017. 8 In addition, Albrecht et al discuss that health professionals such as physicians and nurses contribute significantly to the transformation process towards a healthy, sustainable and climate-sensitive society. The results of their survey suggest that the current state of climate-specific health literacy differs between different groups of health professionals. They conclude that there is a need to improve health professionals' levels of climate-specific health literacy and that IPCP and IPTWs play an important role in increasing awareness and knowledge regarding planetary health.Other IPL activities included in this research topic focus on learning through adaptation and simulation (de Wever et al) and during student placements on international electives (Nawagi et al). Given that healthcare communication is complex, interprofessional communication is perhaps even more complicated. There is a danger of poor health communication (between health professionals or between health professional and patient). Therefore there is a need for research on what is good interprofessional communication and the mechanisms explaining why some modes of communication are more efficient than others. This is addressed in two scoping reviews. First, in a scoping review on distributed team processes in healthcare services, Eid et al identify the need for improved communication and coordination, especially in geographically dispersed settings. Also, the study emphasises the need for more (longitudinal as well as intervention-control) research, particularly from low-and middle-income countries. In the study by Abu-Rish Blakeney et al it was found that poor communication in healthcare leads to inefficiencies, errors, and conflicts. In this study a model is proposed on how to involve multiple healthcare professions, patients, and families in collaborative care planning. Research and evaluation of IPE benefits from interdisciplinary as well as interprofessional input: exploring the utilisation of concepts and ways of working from disciplines not traditionally associated with health care. Ferreira et al advocate for the application of systems engineering (SE) to help manage and sustain the complexity of IPE and its aim of improving patient care through interprofessional collaboration.

The World Health Organization in 2010 concluded that one of the most promising solutions in view of the megatrends in healthcare can be found in interprofessional collaboration. 10 We extend our gratitude to all researchers across various disciplines who have contributed their work to our topic of interprofessional collaboration and education. We hope our readers find valuable insights and benefits for their research, teaching, and clinical practices, further enriching this important field.

9,407 views

10 citations

ORIGINAL RESEARCH
20 February 2024
Evaluating the impact of interprofessional training wards on patient satisfaction and clinical outcomes: a mixed-methods analysis
Sophie Schlosser-Hupf, 9 more and Martina Müller
Evaluating the impact of interprofessional training wards on patient satisfaction and clinical outcomes: a mixed-methods analysis
Introduction: Interprofessional teamwork is pivotal in modern healthcare, prompting the establishment of interprofessional training wards since 1996. While these wards serve as hubs for optimizing healthcare professional collaboration and communication, research into patient outcomes remains notably sparse and geographically limited, predominantly examining patient satisfaction and sparingly exploring other metrics like mortality or self-discharge rates. This study seeks to bridge this gap, comparing patient outcomes in interprofessional training wards and conventional wards under the hypothesis that the former offers no disadvantage to patient outcomes.Material and methods: We explored patient outcomes within an interprofessional student ward called A-STAR at a University Hospital from October 2019 to December 2022. Engaging with patients discharged between May 2021 and April 2022, we utilized digital and paper-based anonymous questionnaires, catering to patient preference, to gather pertinent data.Results: Analysis of outcomes for 1,482 A-STAR (interprofessional student ward) and 5,752 conventional ward patients revealed noteworthy findings. A-STAR patients tended to be younger (59 vs. 61 years, p < 0.01) and more frequently male (73.5% vs. 70.4%, p = 0.025). Vital clinical outcomes, such as discharges against medical advice, complication-driven readmissions, and ICU transfers, were statistically similar between groups, as were mortality rates (1.2% vs. 1.3%, p = 0.468). A-STAR demonstrated high patient satisfaction, underscored by positive reflections on team competence, ward atmosphere, and responsiveness to concerns, emphasizing the value placed on interprofessional collaboration. Patient narratives commended team kindness, lucid explanations, and proactive involvement.Discussion: This data collectively underscores the safety and reliability of patient care within training wards, affirming that patients can trust the care provided in these settings. Patients on the interprofessional ward demonstrated high satisfaction levels: 96.7% appreciated the atmosphere and conduct of ward rounds. In comparison, 98.3% were satisfied with the discussion and information about their treatment during their hospital stay.

9,112 views

15 citations

BRIEF RESEARCH REPORT
5 December 2023
Challenges and opportunities of evaluating work based interprofessional learning: insights from a pediatric interprofessional training ward
Christine Straub, 3 more and Sebastian Friedrich

2,818 views

10 citations

BRIEF RESEARCH REPORT
20 October 2023
Climate-specific health literacy in health professionals: an exploratory study
Lorenz Albrecht, 5 more and Carmen Jochem
Climate-specific health literacy in health professionals: an exploratory study
Health professionals such as physicians and nurses may play an important role in the transformation process towards a healthy, sustainable and climate-sensitive society. However, little is known about their climate-specific health literacy. This study aimed to assess knowledge regarding climate change and its impacts on health and climate-specific health literacy in health professionals.In July/August 2022, a cross-sectional, questionnaire-based study was carried out at the University Hospital Regensburg, Germany, to assess climate-specific health literacy in nurses and physicians from various clinical specialties. Descriptive and exploratory statistical analyses were performed.The study population consisted of 142 participants (57.7% women; response rate: 24,7%). Most participants (93%) considered climate change to be highly relevant. However, only 12% of respondents stated to be very well informed regarding the general consequences of climate change. Although 57% of all participants had never mentioned climate change in relation to health to their patients, participants with higher levels of knowledge regarding the effects of climate change were more likely to mention it compared to those with lower levels of knowledge. The most frequently stated obstacle to integrate the topic of climate change in clinical work was lack of time during work (79%), not enough information (42%) and lacking materials (39%). Differences between health professions were apparent.The results of our survey suggest that the current state of climate-specific health literacy differs between different groups of health professionals. There is a need to improve health professionals' levels of climate-specific health literacy and to increase the potential in interprofessional cooperation regarding planetary health.

9,005 views

35 citations

Using the modified Delphi technique to develop a framework for interprofessional education during international electives in health professions training institutions in Sub-Saharan Africa
International electives provide a learning platform where interprofessional education and collaborative practice (IPECP) skills can be cultivated. However, hardly any frameworks to guide the implementation of interprofessional education (IPE) during international electives, especially in the context of low-income settings have been published. To address this gap, this study used the modified Delphi approach to develop an IPE framework guide for international electives to be used by health professions training institutions in Sub-Saharan Africa.A rapid literature review and a study among students and faculty in four African health professional training institutions were done to inform the process. This was followed by the modified Delphi technique that used three Delphi rounds with a panel of eight experts to build consensus on the final framework for IPE during international electives. The level of consensus was set at ≥70% on each of the statements in all rounds.Out of the 52 statements in round 1, (n=37, 71%) reached consensus while (n=15, 29%) of the statements did not reach consensus and were discussed in round 2. Round 2 led to 42 statements to be utilized for round 3. In round 3, all statements (42) reached a consensus and an IPE framework to guide the implementation of international electives was developed. The framework consists of three sections. Section one highlights the various IPECP competencies to be gained by learners in the areas of teamwork, interprofessional communication, roles and responsibilities of interprofessional collaborative practice, values and ethics of interprofessional collaboration, and reflection and evaluation of oneself and the team. Section two gives guidance on the structuring of the IPE international electives in health professional training institutions. This includes subsections on operational/institutional needs, acculturation considerations, teaching strategies, assessment strategies, mode of delivery, and public health considerations. Section three consists of the various practical guides and approaches that health professional training institutions could use according to what works best in their setting.The modified Delphi technique was an adequate approach to aid the development of an IPE framework to guide implementation during international electives in various health professional training institutions.

7,830 views

15 citations

Poor communication within healthcare contributes to inefficiencies, medical errors, conflict, and other adverse outcomes. A promising model to improve outcomes resulting from poor communication in the inpatient hospital setting is Interprofessional Patient- and Family-Centered rounds (IPFCR). IPFCR brings two or more health professions together with hospitalized patients and families as part of a consistent, team-based routine to share information and collaboratively arrive at a daily plan of care. A growing body of literature focuses on implementation and outcomes of IPFCR to improve healthcare quality and team and patient outcomes. Most studies report positive changes following IPFCR implementation. However, conceptual frameworks and theoretical models are lacking in the IPFCR literature and represent a major gap that needs to be addressed to move this field forward. The purpose of this two-part review is to propose a conceptual framework of how IPFCR works. The goal is to articulate a framework that can be tested in subsequent research studies. Published IPFCR literature and relevant theories and frameworks were examined and synthesized to explore how IPFCR works, to situate IPFCR in relation to existing models and frameworks, and to postulate core components and underlying causal mechanisms. A preliminary, context-specific, conceptual framework is proposed illustrating interrelationships between four core components of IPFCR (interprofessional approach, intentional patient and family engagement, rounding structure, shared development of a daily care plan), improvements in communication, and better outcomes.

10,898 views

9 citations

ORIGINAL RESEARCH
27 September 2023
Development of individual competencies and team performance in interprofessional ward rounds: results of a study with multimodal observations at the Heidelberg Interprofessional Training Ward
Anika Mitzkat, 8 more and Jan Kiesewetter

6,508 views

6 citations

PERSPECTIVE
22 September 2023
Opportunities to apply systems engineering to healthcare interprofessional education
Susan Ferreira, 3 more and Philip Greilich

3,521 views

5 citations