Six decades later the US active space experiment program has changed dramatically. The number of space-based experiments has seen a steep decline, supplanted by ground-based experiments that study the heating and modification of the ionosphere induced by powerful transmitters, such as the facilities of the High-Frequency Active Auroral Research Program (HAARP) and at Arecibo. This decline can be attributed to several reasons, summarized by the fact that the 'low-hanging fruits' had already been collected and much more is known today about the space environment, that space flight became more bureaucratic and more risk-adverse, and budgetary pressures [Delzanno and Borovsky, 2018].Yet, there are many reasons to be optimistic about the future of active experiments in space. There are new scientific and national-security drivers that demand new active space experiments. One example involves magnetosphere-ionosphere coupling, where a high-power electron beam could be used for magnetic field line mapping and connect phenomena occurring in the distant magnetosphere with their image in the ionosphere [National Research Council, 2012]. Another example concerns radiation belt remediation, where the fluxes of an artificial radiation belt created by a high-altitude nuclear explosion could be substantially reduced by space-based injection of electromagnetic plasma waves with the objective of protecting critical space assets. Furthermore, there are new maturing technologies (metamaterials, compact relativistic accelerators, antennas constructed of superparamagnetic nanoparticles, cube-satellites, …), ever better diagnostics and data-gathering capabilities, and new computational tools that can support the design and interpretation of active experiments like never before. Indeed, This optimism was conveyed by the 65 participants of the Workshop 'Active Experiments in Space: Past, Present and Future' who gathered in Santa Fe, New Mexico, in September 2017 (see the link http://www.cvent.com/events/active-experiments-in-spacepast-present-and-future/event-summary-73675ac6ba5745d48d181933c4783454.aspx?dvce=1 for a list of talks presented at the workshop) and is echoed in this Frontiers special issue with the same name.This special issue was designed to connect the past, the present and the future of active experiments in space and serve as a reference for the community. It involves several review articles of past active experiments discussing chemical releases (Haerendel, 2019) and diamagnetic cavities (Winske et al., 2019), artificial aurora experiments (Mishin, 2019), the APEX electron-beam experiments (Prech et al., 2018), and an overview of active experiments involving the Los Alamos National Laboratory (Pongratz, 2018). A review of more recent active experiments focusing on electromagnetic wave injection and wave-particle interaction physics is given by Golkowski et al. (2019). A review on the potential use of electron beams to solve outstanding problems in space physics is presented by Sanchez et al. (2019), while a review on the future of active experiments is presented by Borovsky and Delzanno (2019). The special issue also contains several 'Original Research' articles. A major focus is on the research associated with the use of high-power electron beams for space applications. These articles include a discussion of the development of new, compact, relativistic electron accelerators (Lewellen et al., 2019), a tether-based spacecraft charging mitigation scheme (Marchand and Delzanno, 2018), the evolution of a relativistic electron beam for magnetic-field line mapping in near-Earth space (Powis et al., 2019) and how magnetic-field-line curvature affects the ionospheric accessibility of the electron beam (Willard et al., 2019a), a method for measuring the local magneticfield-line curvature in the inner magnetosphere with a variable-energy electron beam (Willard et al., 2019b), and the atmospheric signatures created by relativistic electron beams (Marshall et al., 2019). New ionospheric experiments involving very-long-distance propagation of high-frequency waves are discussed by Yampolski et al. (2019). A simulation study of the effect of plasma releases on the equatorial spread F is presented by Zawdie et al. (2019), while the use of plasma releases to enhance energetic neutral atom imaging is discussed by Scime and Keesee (2019). Active experiments for planetary missions are discussed by Gilet et al. (2018) for active probes and by Voshchepynets et al. (2019) for sounding radar operations.In the words of Nobel laureate Hannes Alfvén [Alfvén, 1970]: 'The center of gravity of the physical sciences is always moving. Every new discovery displaces the interest and the emphasis. Equally important is that new technological developments open new fields for scientific investigation. To a considerable extent the way science takes depends on the construction of new instruments as is evident from the history of science.' This is certainly true for active experiments and an exciting new season of active experiments in space awaits. Ad maiora!
Editorial06 March 2020
Editorial: Active Experiments in Space: Past, Present, and FutureThe 1970s and 1980s were heydays for using active electron beam experiments to probe some of the fundamental physical processes that occur throughout the heliosphere and in astrophysical contexts. Electron beam experiments were used to study spacecraft charging and spacecraft-plasma coupling; beam-plasma interaction physics; magnetic bounce and drift physics; auroral physics; wave generation; and military applications. While these experiments were enormously successful, they were also limited by the technologies that were available at that time. New advances in space instrumentation, data collection, and accelerator technologies enable a revolutionary new generation of active experiments using electron beams in space. In this paper we discuss such an experiment, the Beam Plasma Interactions Experiment (Beam PIE), a sounding rocket experiment designed to (a) advance HEMT-based RF linear accelerator electron accelerator technology for space applications and (b) study the production of whistler and X-mode waves by modulated electron beams.
REVIEW
27 November 2019
Ennio R. Sanchez, 8 more and Michael Nicolls
10 Authors
- ER
Ennio R. Sanchez
SRI International, United States
- AT
Andrew T. Powis
Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory, United States
- ID
Igor D. Kaganovich
Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory, United States
- RM
Robert Marshall
Ann and H. J. Smead Department of Aerospace Engineering Sciences, University of Colorado, United States
- PP
Peter Porazik
Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory, United States
- JJ
Jay Johnson
Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory, United States
- MG
Michael Greklek-Mckeon
Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory, United States
- KS
Kailas S. Amin
Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory, United States
- DS
David Shaw
Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory, United States
- MN
Michael Nicolls
SRI International, United States
The Sun’s connection with the Earth’s magnetic field and atmosphere is carried out through the exchange of electromagnetic and mass flux and is regulated by a complex interconnection of processes. During space weather events, solar flares or fast streams of solar atmosphere strongly disturb the Earth’s environment. Often the electric currents that connect the different parts of the Sun-Earth system become unstable and explosively release the stored electromagnetic energy in one of the more dramatic expressions of space weather – the auroral storm and substorm. Some aspects of the magnetosphere-ionosphere connection that generates auroral arcs during space weather events are well-known. However, several fundamental problems remain unsolved because of the lack of unambiguous identification of the magnetic field connection between the magnetosphere and the ionosphere. The correct mapping between different regions of the magnetosphere and their foot-points in the ionosphere, coupled with appropriate distributed measurements of plasma and fields in focused regions of the magnetosphere, is necessary to establish unambiguously that a given magnetospheric process is the generator of an observed arc. The three most important problems for which the correct magnetic field mapping would provide closure to are the substorm growth phase arcs, the expansion phase onset arcs and the system of arcs that emerge from the magnetosphere-ionosphere connection during the development of the early substorm expansion phase phenomenon known as substorm current wedge (SCW). Energetic electron beams, used as magnetic field tracers, can enable the closure needed. However, the application of beams as tracers require demonstration that the beams can be injected into the loss cone, that the spacecraft potentials induced by the beam emission are manageable, and that sufficient electron flux reaches the atmosphere to be detectable by optical or radio means after the beam has propagated thousands of kilometers under competing effects of beam spread and constriction as well as effects of beam-induced instabilities. In this communication we provide a review of the latest results of synergistic research carried out under the NSF INSPIRE program to address these challenges and discuss the next steps toward the realization of active experiments in space using relativistic electron beams.
REVIEW
9 May 2019
Active Experiments in Space: The Future
Joseph E. Borovskyand Gian Luca Delzanno
Planned active space experiments and ideas for future active space experiments are reviewed. Three active experiments being readied are DSX (Demonstration and Space eXperiments), SMART (Space Measurement of Rocket-released Turbulence), and BeamPIE (Beam Plasma Interaction Experiment). Ideas for future experiments include relativistic-electron-beam experiments for magnetic-field-line tracing, relativistic-electron-beam experiments to probe the middle atmosphere, plasma-wave launching using superparamagnetic-nanoparticle amplification of magnetic fields, the heavy-ion mass loading of collisionless magnetic-field-line reconnection, the use of electrostatically charged tethers to pitch-angle scatter radiation-belt particles, cold plasma releases to modify magnetospheric plasma physics, and neutral-gas releases to enhance neutral-particle imaging of the magnetosphere. Technologies that are being developed to enable future space active experiments are reviewed: this includes the development of compact relativistic accelerators, superparamagnetic particle amplified antennae, CubeSats, and a new understanding of how to control dynamic spacecraft charging. New capabilities to use laboratory facilities to design space active experiments as well as new computer-simulation capabilities to design and understand space active experiments are reviewed.
REVIEW
30 April 2019
Experiments With Plasmas Artificially Injected Into Near-Earth Space
Gerhard Haerendel
Plasma injection experiments in space are being ordered according to five aspects: (1) Diagnostics of electric fields, (2) Coupling to the ionosphere, (3) Interactions with the solar wind, (4) Modification experiments, and (5) Special physical processes. Historically first were releases of neutral gases with the aim to measure atmospheric parameters. They were soon followed by plasma injections applied to the measurement of plasma flows and parallel electric fields. Long-range coupling to the environment was a most important aspect of the plasma releases. It concerned, on the one hand, the need for corrections of the derived diagnostic parameters and, on the other hand, the understanding of the formation of the ubiquitous striations and deformations of the plasma clouds. A special application was the investigation of cometary interactions by releases in the solar wind. Modification experiments in the ionosphere were done intentionally or occurred as byproducts of rocket launches or other activities. A particular goal was to trigger natural large-scale ionospheric instabilities like equatorial spread F in order to improve the understanding of the natural phenomena. Large-scale plasma injections in the magnetosphere have been performed in order to change the conditions of wave-particle interactions and potentially trigger observable effects. Special goals were so-called skidding experiments and testing Alfvén’s critical ionization velocity effect. In this review we will emphasize the principle objectives and illustrate the results from selected experiments.
A review is given of the effects observed during injections of powerful electron beams from sounding
rockets into the upper atmosphere. Data come from in situ particle and wave measurements near a beam
emitting rocket and ground-based optical, wideband radiowave, and radar observations. The overall data
cannot be explained solely by collisional degradation of energetic electrons but require collisionless beam
plasma interactions (BPI) be taken into account. The beam-plasma discharge theory describes the features
of the region near a beam-emitting rocket, where the beam-excited plasma waves energize plasma electrons,
which then ignite the discharge. The observations far beneath the rocket reveal a double-peak structure of
artificial auroral rays, which can be understood in terms of the beam-excited strong Langmuir turbulence
being affected by collisions of ionospheric electrons. This leads to the enhanced energization of ionospheric
electrons in a narrow layer termed the plasma turbulence layer (PTL), which explains the upper peak. Similar
double-peak structures or a sharp upper boundary in rayed auroral arcs have been observed in the auroral
ionosphere by optical, radar, and rocket observations, and called Enhanced Aurora. A striking resemblance
between Enhanced and Artificial Aurora altitude profiles indicates that they are created by the above BPI
process which results in the PTL.
We present numerical simulations and analysis of atmospheric effects of a beam of 1~MeV electrons precipitating in the upper atmosphere from above. Beam parameters of 100~J or 1~kJ injected in 100~ms or 1~second were chosen to reflect the current design requirements for a realistic mission. We calculate ionization signatures and optical emissions in the atmosphere, and estimate the detectability of optical signatures using photometers and cameras on the ground. Results show that both instruments should be able to detect the beam spot. Chemical simulations show that the production of odd nitrogen and odd hydrogen are minimal. We use electrostatic field simulations to show that the beam-induced electron density column can enhance thunderstorm electric fields at high altitudes enough to facilitate sprite triggering. Finally, we calculate signatures that would be observed by incoherent scatter radar (ISR) and subionospheric VLF remote sensing techniques, although the latter is hindered by the limitations of 2D simulations.
Controlled experiments involving injection of 0.5 Hz – 8 kHz electromagnetic waves into the Earth’s magnetosphere have played an important role in discovering and elucidating wave-particle interactions in near-Earth space. Due to the significant engineering challenges of efficiently radiating in the ELF/VLF: 300 Hz – 30 kHz band, few experiments have been able to provide sustained transmissions of sufficient power to excite observable effects for scientific studies. Two noteworthy facilities that were successful in generating a large database of pioneering and repeatable observations were the Siple Station Transmitter in Antarctica and the High Frequency Active Auroral Research Program (HAARP) facility in Alaska. Both facilities were able to excite Doppler shifted cyclotron resonance interactions leading to linear and nonlinear wave amplification, triggering of free running emissions, and pitch angle scattering of energetic electrons. Amplified and triggered waves were primarily observed on the ground in the geomagnetic conjugate region after traversal of the magnetosphere along geomagnetic field aligned propagation paths or in the vicinity of the transmitter following two traversals of the magnetosphere. In several cases, spacecraft observations of the amplified and triggered signals were also made. The observations show the amplifying wave particle interaction to be dynamically sensitive to specific frequency and also specific frequency-time format of the transmitted wave. Transmission of multiple coherent waves closely spaced in frequency showed that the wave particle interaction requires a minimum level of coherency to enter the nonlinear regime. Theory and numerical simulations point to cyclotron resonance with counter streaming particles in the 10-100 keV range as the dominant process. A key feature of the nonlinear interaction is the phase-trapping of resonant particles by the wave that is believed to drive non-linear wave amplification and the triggering of free-running emissions. Observations and modeling of controlled wave injections have important implications for naturally occurring whistler mode emissions of hiss and chorus and the broader phenomena of radiation belt dynamics. A review of observational, theoretical, and numerical results is presented and suggestions for future studies are made.
The APEX mother-daughter project (Active Plasma EXperiments) was launched into an elliptical polar orbit (440 –-- 3080 km) in December 1991. It consisted of the main Russian Interkosmos--25 (IK--25) satellite and the Czech MAGION--3 subsatellite, both with international scientific payloads. The mission used intensive modulated electron beam emissions and xenon plasma or neutral releases from the main satellite for studies of dynamic processes in the magnetosphere and upper ionosphere. Its main scientific objectives were to simulate an artificial aurora and to study optical and radio emissions from the aurora region, and to investigate the dynamics and relaxation of modulated electron and plasma jets, artificially injected into the ionospheric plasma. The experiments studied the Critical Ionization Velocity phenomenon and a diamagnetic cavity formation during the xenon releases, local and distant effects of the electron beam injection, spacecraft charging and potential balance, and plasma-wave interactions during the artificial emissions. Attempts were performed to utilize the modulated electron beam as an active transmitting antenna in the space. The theory of ballistic wave propagation across plasma barrier was tested in a joint active experiment with the Dushanbe ionospheric heater facility.
In the paper, we give a short overview of the IK--25/MAGION--3 scientific instrumentation and methodology of experiments with artificial beam injections and we provide a review of the main APEX active experiments results, many of which have been published only in the Russian language so far. From a historical 25-years-long perspective, we try to put the results of the APEX experiments into the context of other active experiments in the space plasma.








