ORIGINAL RESEARCH article
Sec. Marine Ecosystem Ecology
Volume 5 - 2018 | https://doi.org/10.3389/fmars.2018.00387
Symbiont Chloroplasts Remain Active During Bleaching-Like Response Induced by Thermal Stress in Collozoum pelagicum (Collodaria, Retaria)
- 1Sorbonne Université, CNRS – UMR7144 – Ecology of Marine Plankton Group – Station Biologique de Roscoff, Roscoff, France
- 2Université Côte d’Azur, Institut de Biologie Valrose UMR7277, Nice, France
- 3Sorbonne Université, CNRS – UMR 7093, Laboratoire d’Océanographie de Villefranche (LOV), Observatoire Océanologique, Villefranche-sur-Mer, France
Collodaria (Retaria) are important contributors to planktonic communities and biogeochemical processes (e.g., the biologic pump) in oligotrophic oceans. Similarly to corals, Collodaria live in symbiosis with dinoflagellate algae, a relationship that is thought to explain partly their ecological success. In the context of global change, the robustness of the symbiotic interaction, and potential subsequent bleaching events are of primary interest for oceanic ecosystems functioning. In the present study, we compared the ultrastructure, morphology, symbiont density, photosynthetic capacities and respiration rates of colonial Collodaria exposed to a range of temperatures corresponding to natural conditions (21∘C), moderate (25∘C), and high (28∘C) thermal stress. We showed that symbiont density immediately decreased when temperature rose to 25∘C, while the overall Collodaria holobiont metabolic activity increased. When temperature reached 28∘C, the holobiont respiration nearly stopped and the host morphological structure was largely damaged, as if the host tolerance threshold has been crossed. Over the course of the experiment, the photosynthetic capacities of remaining algal symbionts were stable, chloroplasts being the last degraded organelles in the microalgae. These results contribute to a better characterization and understanding of temperature-induced bleaching processes in planktonic photosymbioses.
Retaria encompass Foraminifera and Radiolaria sensu stricto or Radiozoa. Within Radiozoa, Collodaria have been recently unraveled as key players in oceanic ecosystems (Biard et al., 2016; Guidi et al., 2016). Previously overlooked because of their fragility, the use of non-destructive, in situ, imaging tools showed that Collodaria represents nearly 30% of zooplankton biomass at subsurface in oligotrophic oceans (Biard et al., 2016). Collodaria were also reported as central actors in plankton community networks related to carbon export to the deep ocean via both primary production and vertical flux (Guidi et al., 2016). Initially described by E. Haeckel toward the end of the 19th century (Haeckel, 1887), Collodaria have been little studied so far, with only a few landmark studies conducted on radiolarian morphology and physiology (Anderson, 1983).
Collodaria are unicellular organisms that live either solitary (cell size ∼1 mm) or form colonies up to a few centimeters long. Each colony is composed of hundreds to thousands of cells agglomerated in a gelatinous matrix. All cells, individually represented by a spherical structure called the central capsule, are connected together through cytoplasmic extensions and some particular species can bear a siliceous skeleton (Anderson, 1976a,b). Collodaria feed on prey from the surrounding environment but can be considered as mixotrophic organisms, since they also rely on symbiotic interactions with photosynthetic dinoflagellates. Swanberg (1983) suggested that photosymbiosis provides Retaria with the minimum energy to subsist, while their energy and nutrients for growth would come from their heterotrophic regime. Collodaria can consume 4% of their symbionts everyday (Anderson, 1983) and a part of the photosynthates are transferred to the host, mostly as lipid storage pool (Anderson et al., 1983). Microalgae symbionts isolated from the collodarian species Collozoum spp. have been recently identified as Brandtodinium nutricula, a dinoflagellate species belonging to the Peridiniales order (Probert et al., 2014). As B. nutricula can be cultivated in host-free media and has been found in association with different radiolarian hosts and even with the jellyfish Velella velella, this microalga is thought to be a generalistic symbiont having free-living stages (Decelle et al., 2015).
The breakdown of the symbiotic associations in corals, so-called coral bleaching, has been originally described by Glynn (1984), who depicted coral bleaching as a reaction to environmental constraints, due to the massive loss of symbiotic algae, or alternatively as a decline of their photosynthetic pigment content. Recent projections suggest that more than half of the coral reefs worldwide will experience several bleaching events by the year 2100, as a consequence of ocean temperature rise of 1–1.8°C (Logan et al., 2014). Coral bleaching has significant deleterious consequences on coral reef ecosystem functioning and as a result, on several countries economy and food supply (Hoegh-Guldberg et al., 2007). Numerous studies have tried to decipher the relationships between corals -or other cnidarians such as sea anemones- and their symbionts upon environmental perturbations. Although bleaching events involve the whole holobiont and all possible interactions between its biotic components (Baird et al., 2009), in cnidarians most studies considered bleaching as being induced by the microalgal partner release (reviewed in Lesser, 2011). One of the proposed mechanisms suggests the production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) when symbiont photosynthesis is impaired by heat stress (Lesser, 2006). These ROS lead to the death of the host cells by triggering apoptosis, notably through the induction of protease enzymes (Cikala et al., 1999). During the stress and death of the host cells, microalgal symbiotic cells can be either healthy (Baghdasarian and Muscatine, 2000) or damaged (Fujise et al., 2014). In the later case, it is unclear whether the symbiont damages are due to the host cell apoptosis or to other symbiont related processes, such as programmed cell death (PCD) or host autophagic digestion (Dunn et al., 2007; Paxton et al., 2013).
Considering the potential impact of bleaching in Collodaria on the marine ecosystem functioning and the lack of recent studies on their biology, this study aims at a better characterization of their functional behavior. We performed a controlled thermal stress experiment on Collodaria to investigate potential plankton bleaching and the photosymbiosis response to elevated temperatures using both morphological and physiological analyses.
Materials and Methods
Collodarian colonies were collected in the bay of Villefranche-sur-Mer (France, 43°41′10″ N, 7°18′50″ E) using a Regent plankton net (680 μm mesh size) handheld from a boat, immediately handpicked and transferred into clean beakers filled with seawater filtered over 0.2 μm filters. Colonies were incubated at ambient seawater temperature (21°C) for 3–4 h to allow self-cleaning of particles embedded in their gelatinous matrix. A total of 300 colonies with similar morphotypes were transferred individually into two 17L-Kreisel tank aquaria (JHT-17G, Exotic Aquaculture, Hong-Kong) filled with 0.2 μm filtered seawater and placed in two distinct thermostatic incubators set at 21°C (TC135S, Lovibond Water testing, United Kingdom). As treatments were performed in single experimental units (called pseudoreplication by Hurlbert, 1984), colonies were randomly placed in the two aquaria. Two liters of 0.2 μm filtered seawater from the Kreisel tanks were changed on a daily basis. Electroluminescent diode ramps (Easyled 6800 K°, Aquatlantis, Portugal) provided constant white light at 100 μmol photon m-2 s-1. Colonies were further exposed to two thermal treatments during 3 days (T0, T1, and T2). In one aquarium, the control treatment (CT) remained at 21°C over the course of the experiment. In the other aquarium, the temperature of the stressed treatment (ST) was raised from 21°C (T0), to 25°C (T1) on the first day and then from 25°C to 28°C (T2) on the second day. The water temperature increased by 1°C per hour sufficiently in advance to enable a 12 h-acclimation before sampling. In the following text, a “condition” refers to the unique combination of a treatment and a sampling time point (e.g., CT-T0).
18S ribosomal DNA gene sequences from the Collodarian host and the dinoflagellate symbionts of 30 holobiont specimens collected during the experiment were retrieved from the transcriptome data (see details in Supplementary Text 1). Briefly, for each sample, host and symbiont sequences were aligned separately with reference sequences using MAFFT (Katoh et al., 2002). Phylogenetic trees were obtained using maximum likelihood reconstruction method in RAxML (Stamatakis, 2014), allowing the genetic identification of the host and the symbiont species.
Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM)
For each condition, Collodarian specimens were collected in triplicates and independently fixed for 2 h at room temperature with 2.5% glutaraldehyde in a mix of cacodylate buffer (0.1 M, pH 7.4)/artificial seawater, then washed with 0.1 M cacodylate buffer (pH 7.4) and postfixed with 1% osmium tetroxide in cacodylate buffer containing 1% potassium ferrocyanide. Each samples were embedded in Epon resin after 10 min dehydration in 90% acetone and 2 baths of 10 min in acetone 100%. Ultrathin sections (70–80 nm) of colony parts were obtained using a diamond knife mounted on an ultramicrotome (Ultracut S, Leica) and placed on copper TEM grids coated with formvar film. To increase the contrast, the grids were treated with conventional uranyl acetate stain followed by lead citrate. Samples were observed under a JEOL JEM 1400 transmission electron microscope equipped with a CCD camera (Morada, Olympus SIS).
Oxygen consumption was measured using oxygen optodes, as described in Lilley et al. (2014). Each sample was made of two colonies incubated together in 5 mL tubes filled with filtered seawater and equipped with light-sensitive oxygen spots (PreSens Precision Sensing GmbH, Germany). For each condition, 6 measurements were made: 5 replicates and an additional control tube filled with 0.2 μm filtered seawater only that was used for blank corrections. This control tube therefore records the background respiration of the few organisms still present since neither 0.2 μm filtered seawater nor containers were sterile. After 30 min of dark-acclimation, oxygen was measured using a Fibox 3 optical oxygen meter (PreSens) every 20 min during 2 h. Light (100 μmol photon m-2 s-1) was then switched on for 2 h and oxygen was measured again every 20 min for 2 h under light exposure.
After calibration, the phase delay measured by the sensor was converted into O2 concentration (in μmol L-1). Linear regressions between oxygen concentration against time were fitted through all data points for each replicate and for dark and light measurements separately. Values showing standardized residues <-1.5 and >1.5 were considered as outliers and removed from the dataset to ensure linearity (54 out of 384 measures). Slopes of the fitted regression gave individual consumption rates (μmol O2 L-1h-1) and blank slopes were removed from experimental slopes to remove the water background respiration associated with the use of non–sterile water/containers [see Lilley et al. (2014)]. In all cases, this background O2 change was negligible (average slope: 0.08) compared to the respiration/photosynthesis signal recorded (average slope: 0.21). Respiration rates were estimated as the slope during the dark experiment and gross photosynthesis rates were computed as differences of slopes between light (net photosynthesis) and dark. The respiration/photosynthesis signal recorded corresponds then to the net respiration and photosynthesis of the holobiont (including host, symbionts, and the associated microbiota). For normalization, rates were divided by the colony biomass estimated from binocular inspection (see the following morphological measurement methods). The Q10 temperature coefficient is the factor by which the reaction rate increases when the temperature is raised by ten degrees. It has been calculated using the following equation: where R1 and R2 are the reaction rates at the corresponding temperatures T1 and T2.
Chlorophyll Fluorescence Measurements Coupled With Microscopy
For each condition, 5 collodarian colonies were transferred to cavity slides and maintained with a coverslip to prevent them from moving. For every 5 replicated colonies, photosynthetic parameters of individual symbiotic microalgae were measured on three different fields of observation using a Pulse Amplitude Modulated fluorometer coupled to a microscope (MICROSCOPY-PAM; Walz, Effeltrich, Germany), equipped with a 10 × objective lens. After the colonies were incubated in the dark for at least 5 min, the basal level of fluorescence (F0) was measured under modulated light (9 μmol photons m-2 s-1, frequency: 8 Hz at 625 nm), and a saturating light pulse (1707 μmol photons m-2 s-1, during 8 × 60 ms at 625 nm) allowed determining the maximum fluorescence level (FM). The Dark-adapted maximal quantum Yield (FV/FM) of photosystem II (PSII) was computed as follows:
The colonies were then exposed to actinic light (463 μmol photons m-2 s-1 at 625 nm) during 2 min followed by another saturating light pulse to measure the light-adapted PSII fluorescence yield (FV’/FM’; Genty et al., 1989). Pilot experiments and light curves were previously performed to determine the optimal duration of the dark incubation and actinic light intensity. The saturating pulse settings were adjusted according to preliminary experiments performed on cultures of B. nutricula (Supplementary Text 2).
For every colony, a number of 6 to 15 areas of interest, corresponding to single symbiotic cells, were selected on each picture (see Supplementary Figure S1). Outliers were removed when measured values were inconsistent (e.g., FV/FM = 0 or 1), being mostly due to field depth impairments. Overall, we obtained between 13 and 45 measurements for each of the 5 replicate colonies per experimental condition. To avoid bias due to these sampling size differences between conditions to compare, the FV/FM medians were computed for each microscopic field (3 microscopic fields per colony; 5 replicated colonies per condition).
Images of all colonies used for oxygen and PAM fluorescence analyses were acquired under a binocular microscope (Zeiss Stemi SV11 mounted with an Olympus DP21 camera system) and analyzed using the ImageJ software (Rasband, 1997)1. Stressed colonies at sampling time 2 (ST-T2) were too degraded to be manipulated and observed under binocular microscope. For this specific condition, morphological measurements were performed for one colony and data are provided as indicative trends, while 13 to 17 replicates were accounted for other conditions. Correction factors were applied to normalize measurements in function of the different magnifications used to take each picture. On large field of view, we used image thresholding of ImageJ to measure full colonies area, width and we derived biovolume estimates from the prolate ellipsoid equation described in Biard et al. (2016). We also enumerated the total number of central capsules present on the observable part of the colonies using the automated cell count functionality of ImageJ. On zoomed in fields of view, we measured each central capsule area along with central capsule area covered by microalgal symbionts. As previously, we counted the total number of central capsules on the observable part of the colonies. We also enumerated the symbionts observed between central capsules (i.e., in the matrix) and measured their areas. At this magnification the symbiont cell area was homogeneous, we derived the number of symbionts per central capsule by dividing their total area by the average area of a symbiont (3x10-4mm2). Symbiont density was thus expressed as the number of symbionts per area. Carbon content was derived from the central capsule counts using a conversion factor of 131 ng C per capsule (Michaels et al., 1995).
All the statistical analysis and associated figures were performed using R version 3.5.1 (R Core Team, 2013). For fluorescence and oxygen analyses, pairwise permutation tests from the rcompanion library have been used to test for significance of the interaction treatment-sampling time effect.
For symbiont density analysis, a t-test was applied to compare the regression slopes at each sampling time between the two treatments.
Colonies were identified as Collozoum pelagicum by phylogenetic analysis of the 18S rDNA gene sequences (NCBI accession MG907123, Supplementary Figure S2) onto a reference tree published in Biard et al. (2015). We were also able to retrieve 18S rDNA sequences of a dinoflagellate identified as B. nutricula by phylogenetic placement (NCBI accession MG905637, Supplementary Figure S3), confirming that C. pelagicum hosts B. nutricula as symbiotic algae.
C. pelagicum Morphological Changes Upon Heat Stress
Depending on colony size, an average of 800 (SD = 300) C. pelagicum cells were agglomerated in the gelatinous matrix, corresponding to an average density of 10 cells per mm2 of colony surface. (Table 1 and Supplementary Table S1). Cells were distributed in the matrix forming defined compartments (Figure 1a). Central capsules, appearing bright under the microscope (Figure 1a), exhibited a size ranging from 100 to 150 μm. Each central capsule contained a large electron dense droplet, an endoplasm and an ectoplasm (Figure 1b). Sudan Black staining suggested that this droplet, surrounded by a vacuolar membrane was constituted of fibrous elements and lipids. The endoplasm contained multiple nuclei displaying fibrillar nucleoplasm chord-like structures of chromatin attached to the inner surface of the nuclear membrane (Figures 1c,d). The endoplasm was delimited from the ectoplasm by a multiple layer membrane (Figure 1e).
TABLE 1. Summary of the statistics of the morphological and physiological measurements in control (CT) and heat-stressed (ST) colonies of Collozoum pelagicum at 3 sampling times (T0, T1, and T2).
FIGURE 1. Description of Collozoum pelagicum morphology and ultrastructure. Collozoum pelagicum colony morphological aspect by binocular observation (a). Observation of the general organization of a central capsule observed by Transmission Electron Microscopy (b,c). Focus on nuclei in the endoplasm of the central capsule (d), membranes at the periphery of the central capsule (e) and in hospite Brandtodinium nutricula cells (f), observed by electron microscopy. Bcw, B. nutricula cell wall; C, Chloroplast; Ccl, cord-like Chromatin; Ccm, Central capsule membrane; EdD, Electron-dense Droplet; EdDM, Electron-dense Droplet Membrane; Nu, Nuclei; Py, Pyrenoid; St, Starch granule; V, Vacuole; Vm, Vacuolar membrane.
Brandtodinium nutricula cells were always within cytoplasmic structures, either spread in the gelatinous matrix or closely associated to the central capsules (Figures 1a,b) and exhibited a thick cell wall and no flagella. B. nutricula were enclosed in a vacuole and separated from the C. pelagicum ectoplasm by a vacuolar membrane (Figure 1f). B. nutricula cells contained pyrenoid-bearing lobed chloroplasts, located essentially at the cell periphery, and associated with starch granules. Comparisons of phenotypes from control colonies (CT at 21°C) to heat stressed colonies (ST) at 3 sampling times (T0:21°C, T1:25°C, and T2:28°C) demonstrated that the general morphology of control colonies was preserved during the entire experiment. The polysaccharide matrix surrounded the evenly distributed central capsules and the compartments forming the colony remained visible (Figures 2a,b). In heat-stressed conditions, the central capsules from the colonies were still observable but irregularly distributed (Figures 2c,d). The gelatinous matrix was altered at 25°C and completely disorganized at 28°C, while colony compartments disappeared, being replaced by large bubbles inside the colonies (Figure 2d). With respect to ultrastructural features, ectoplasms were degraded, revealing large spaces around vacuoles, at T2 for CT colonies (Figures 2e,f) and earlier (from T1) in ST colonies (Figure 2g). Ectoplasm of ST-T2 colonies completely shrunk (Figure 2h). Compared to freshly collected specimens, both control and thermal stress experiments showed highly condensed chromatin in their nuclei, with an increase in electron-dense filaments (Figures 1c,d, 2i–l).
FIGURE 2. Morphological and ultrastructural changes in control and heat-stressed Collozoum pelagicum. Observation of colonies overall morphological aspect at control T1 (a) and control T2 (b) at 21°C, thermal stress T1 at 25°C (c) and thermal stress T2 at 28°C (d). Focus on the ultrastructure of ectoplasm at control T1 (e), control T2 (f), thermal stress T1 (g), and thermal stress T2 (h). Focus on the nuclei ultrastructure at control T1 (i) and control T2 (j), thermal stress T1 (k), and thermal stress T2 (l) arrows.
Physiological Impact of Heat Stress on C. pelagicum
At seawater temperature, the respiration rate was of 3.94 (SD = 0.99) μLO2 mgC-1 h-1 (Table 1, Figure 3, and Supplementary Tables S1, S2). The incubation conditions did not affect significantly the respiration rates in control colonies, with values of 4.58 (SD = 0.83) μLO2 mgC-1 h-1 at T1 and 4.84 (SD = 1.25) μLO2 ind-1 h-1 at T2. For heat-stressed colonies, the respiration rates slightly increased at 25°C, reaching 5.82 (SD = 1.62) μLO2 mgC-1 h-1, and decreased markedly to 2.94 (SD = 1.56) μLO2 mgC-1 h-1 at 28°C.
FIGURE 3. Normalized respiration rates in control (blue) and heat-stressed (red) colonies of Collozoum pelagicum. The rates are normalized to the surface area of the colony. Control colonies were maintained at 21°C, while stressed colonies were sampled at 25°C (T1) and 28°C (T2). Pairwise comparison from permutation test between each condition was represented by letters. Statistical supports are described in Supplementary Tables 1, 4A.
The experimental conditions induced a decrease of the average B. nutricula cell density, from nearly 80 symbionts mm-2 at T0 and T1, down to 59 symbionts mm-2 at T2, for control colonies (Table 1 and Figure 4). The symbiont density decrease occurred significantly faster in heat-stress conditions with as few as 60 symbionts mm-2 at T1 (25°C) already. The regression line slopes between T0 and T1 were significantly different with a stronger drop in symbiont densities in stressed colonies compared to controls (p-value = 0.05). At T2 (28°C), symbiont density kept decreasing down to 50 symbionts mm-2, but the reaction norm slopes were not significantly different from the control conditions between T1 and T2 (Table 1 and Figure 4). The B. nutricula cells were mainly located in the vicinity of the central capsules, with nearly 8% of the symbionts found in the cytoplasmic extension throughout the gelatinous matrix. During our experiment, the symbiont density varied nearby the central capsule but remained stable for those in the matrix (Figure 4).
FIGURE 4. Variations of the symbiont density in control (blue) and heat-stressed colonies (red) of Collozoum pelagicum. Control colonies were maintained at 21°C, while stressed colonies were sampled at 21°C (T0), 25°C (T1) and 28°C (T2). The upper and bottom parts represent the density of symbionts attached to central capsules and in the gelatinous matrix, respectively. As indicated by a star, slopes of reaction norms for symbionts from central capsule (represented as dotted lines) were significantly different between T0 and T1 (p-value < 0.025), but not between T1 and T2. Statistical supports are described in Supplementary Tables 1, 4B,C.
With respect to photosynthetic parameters, we first measured the oxygen production of entire colonies to globally estimate their overall photosynthesis, then we carried out fluorometric measurements coupled to microscopy to evaluate the photosynthetic efficiency of photosystem II for individual symbiotic cells. Both methods demonstrated that the photosynthetic apparatus was not impacted by neither the stalling nor the thermal stress conditions. Photosynthetic rates remained stable at about 4 μLO2 mgC-1 h-1 with no significant changes across all conditions (Table 1, Figure 5a, and Supplementary Tables S1, S2) and the maximal photosystem II quantum yield (FV/FM) average was 0.58 (SD = 0.04), a nearly optimal value for phytoplanktonic cells (Table 1, Figure 5b, and Supplementary Tables S1, S3). No photoprotective processes of energy dissipation were observed (Supplementary Tables S1, S3). Coupling fluorometry analysis to microscopy enabled to measure individual cells photosynthetic capacities. The PAM microscopy analysis thus revealed that at CT-T2 and during the entire heat-stress experiment, the number of observed B. nutricula cells per microscopic field decreased, as also suggested by the symbiont density counts. During the experiment, we also observed that the variability of the FV/FM increased both within colonies and between colonies, particularly in the stressed treatment where the coefficient of variation significantly increased from T0 to T1 and T2 (Figure 5b, Supplementary Figure S4, and Supplementary Tables S1, S4).
FIGURE 5. Photosynthetic rates of the symbionts in control (blue) and heat-stressed (red) colonies of Collozoum pelagicum. (a) Box-plots of photosynthesis rates measured by oxygen production, when normalized by the symbiont surface of the colony. (b) Box-plots of PAM-microscopy measurements. Pairwise comparison from permutation test between each condition was represented by letters. Statistical supports are described in Supplementary Tables 1, 4D,E.
Symbionts Morphological Changes
TEM micrographs were used to monitor ultrastructural changes of the symbiotic B. nutricula cells. In control colonies, vacuolar structures containing filamentous particles were observed in cells at T1 (Figure 6a and Supplementary Figure S5). At T2, these filamentous particles were still present and electron-dense bodies containing membrane-packaged cellular debris appeared within the symbiotic cells (Figure 6b) but nuclei as well as chloroplast ultrastructure remained preserved (Supplementary Figure S6).
FIGURE 6. Morphological structures corresponding to the main cellular responses induced in in hospite B. nutricula cells in control and heat-stressed colonies of Collozoum pelagicum. Transmission electron microscopy of C. pelagicum cross section in control T1 (a), control T2 (b) at 21°C, and thermal stress T1 at 25°C (c) and thermal stress T2 at 28°C (d). Asterisks: filamentous particles, black triangles: apoptotic bodies, white triangles: vacuolar matrix.
In thermally stressed colonies, filamentous particles were also observed but to a lesser extent. Instead, an important vacuolization around the B. nutricula cells, thylakoid disorganization, nucleus dissolution and destabilized organelles structures were observed at 25°C (Figure 6c), suggesting autophagic processes. At 28°C, the B. nutricula cells from heat-stressed colonies showed marked necrosis patterns with numerous apoptotic bodies and their cellular content appeared completely shrunk, with abundant electron-dense bodies (Figure 6d). Inside decaying symbiotic cells, chloroplasts were the only healthy looking organelles, consistent with the maintenance of the photosynthetic capacities observed in the physiological study (Figure 6 and Supplementary Figure S6).
Bleaching is commonly described in the phylum Cnidaria as a loss of color originating in the exclusion of the symbiotic dinoflagellates (i.e., genus Symbiodinium) from the animal, and/or the degradation of photosynthetic pigments in the chloroplasts of the symbionts (Douglas, 2003). Bleaching has also been shown to occur in the benthic protists Foraminifera (Rhizaria) hosting symbiotic diatoms (Schmidt et al., 2011; Edgar et al., 2013). Here, as symbionts were lightly arranged around the central capsule, the color loss was not detectable to the naked eye, but we observed a decrease of the dinoflagellate symbiont (B. nutricula) density in the planktonic species C. pelagicum (Collodaria, Retaria) during a heat stress experiment. This study shows that bleaching processes, as initially defined by Kleppel et al. (1989), are not restricted to benthic fauna, but likely constitute a broader stress response in marine organisms harboring photosymbionts. C. pelagicum belongs to the most diverse and abundant collodarian clade C7 from the Sphaerozoidae family, which is particularly dominant in coastal biomes and in the western part of the Mediterranean Sea (Biard et al., 2017), stressing out the potential ecological impact of such symbiont loss events in the environment.
Although we cannot exclude that cellular processes involved in the symbiont loss can be radically distinct among different taxa, one might consider that, as described for cnidarians (Weis, 2008), the decrease of symbiont density in C. pelagicum could originate in the digestion and/or expulsion of B. nutricula cells. Indeed, it has been shown that, under standard conditions, cnidarians continuously expel degraded forms of Symbiodinium cells to maintain a healthy population in symbiosis, whereas in stress conditions healthy algal cells are also released in the environment (Ralph et al., 2001; Fujise et al., 2014). In our study, the number of B. nutricula cells located at the vicinity of the central capsules decreased, but symbiont density in the gelatinous matrix remained constant. Assuming that expulsion of B. nutricula cells requires to go through the gelatinous matrix, an increased density would have been expected.
In our study, the respiration rate increase between 21 and 25°C could be related to symbiont digestion. The estimated temperature coefficient Q10 for C. pelagicum reached the value of 2.66, falling into the Q10 range of 2 to 3 estimated for zooplankton (Hernández-León and Ikeda, 2005; Ikeda, 2014). Respiration rate increase as a function of temperature has already been reported in a large panel of zooplankton groups such as Rhizaria, Copepods, Tintinnids (Vidal, 1980; Verity, 1985; Lombard et al., 2005) and could be due to several processes. The global rates of chemical reactions generally increase with temperature (Arrhenius, 1889) and, until enzymatic structure is altered, most biological enzymatic processes require oxygen, so that oxygen demand usually increases with temperature. Also, higher temperatures likely enhance the growth of prokaryotes associated to the host and in turn could contribute to a not negligible part of the holobiont respiration (del Giorgio et al., 1997). Finally, it has also been shown that digestion increases the respiration rate of organisms (Conover, 1978).
Looking at the ultrastructure to characterize the observed bleaching process, all B. nutricula cells inside the hosts showed signs of programmed cell death (PCD) mechanisms, such as autophagy (vacuolization) or apoptosis (cell shrinkage, chromatin condensation), suggesting overall cell decay. Apoptosis is triggered by a series of controlled cellular processes involving caspases, which cleave key proteins, cytoskeletal elements and cell adhesion molecules (Dunn et al., 2007). In the autophagic pathway, the target is enveloped in a membrane structure before lysosomal fusion, which initiates digestion by hydrolytic enzymes (Cuervo, 2004). Both apoptosis and autophagy have been observed during cnidarian bleaching and can occur simultaneously (Dunn et al., 2007) or alternatively in response to hyperthermal stress (Richier et al., 2006; Dani et al., 2016). In addition, another process related to symbiotic dinoflagellate autophagy has been reported in cnidarians and is referred to as “symbiophagy,” which results in the digestion of the resident dinoflagellates (Downs et al., 2009). TEM observations in C. pelagicum suggested that a similar diversity of PCD-like mechanisms would be involved in planktonic symbiosis breakdown. Originally reported in metazoans, PCD-like mechanisms have also been described in phytoplankton in the case of nutrient stress and could occur during viral infections (see review by Bidle, 2015).
Our observations also evidenced the presence of filamentous structures, probably virus-like particles (VLPs), potentially involved in the collapsing of B. nutricula cells, whose features appeared similar to the single stranded RNA viruses previously described in Symbiodinium cells (Weynberg et al., 2017; Buerger and van Oppen, 2018). These authors indeed proposed that the cnidarian endosymbiont Symbiodinium harbors a lysogenic virus within its genome that would induce a lytic infection cycle under stressed conditions. Such lysis of symbiotic dinoflagellates by viruses supports the microbial bleaching hypothesis, which suggests that bleaching could be initiated by the microbial community shift induced by heat-stress (Correa et al., 2016; Thurber et al., 2017). Levin et al. (2017) also described that only thermosensitive Symbiodinium showed a marked transcriptional response to viral infection when heat stressed. To our knowledge, only one study has described large icosahedral virus-like particles associated with vacuolar structures in phaeodarians, a taxonomic group close to radiolarians, within the Rhizaria lineage (Gowing, 1993). This study suggests that VLPs could have been acquired by the host through feeding on sinking particles, while in our case, it seems that the viral attack was restricted to the B. nutricula cells.
Viral infections in marine algae have been shown to promote ROS activity, triggering subsequent caspase activity and further PCD processes in host cells (Bidle and Vardi, 2011; Bidle, 2015). Nevertheless, as ROS could also be generated by the over-reduction of photosystem I reaction centers (Roberty et al., 2015) during the thermal stress, it was not possible to attribute the cause of the observed PCD directly to the abiotic stress or as a consequence of the pathogen pressure. Weynberg et al. (2017) observed that if nuclear structures were rapidly degraded by virus infection, other organelles like chloroplasts and mitochondria remained almost intact until infectious particles filled the entire cell structure. This is consistent with our observation showing that chloroplasts remained morphologically intact and active, even though other B. nutricula organelles were severely damaged. Both oxygen production and fluorometry measurements demonstrated that photosynthesis rates were not altered by heat stress as B. nutricula photosynthetic efficiencies remained globally stable. The increased variability of individual photosynthetic efficiencies during heat-stress treatments suggests that healthy B. nutricula could compensate for damaged symbionts so as to buffer the holobiont photosynthetic activity.
Based on our observations (e.g., respiration virtually stopped, morphological structure altered), a temperature of 28°C (i.e., T2) likely exceeded the C. pelagicum colonies tolerance threshold. The pronounced thermal stress we applied in our experiment aimed at observing and characterizing a marked response of the symbiotic system, likely preventing the potentially existing acclimation period required for the host plastic response. The free-living stage of the microalgal symbionts B. nutricula tolerates temperatures up to 29°C when grown in batch culture, displaying relatively high growth rates and photosynthetic efficiency (Supplementary Figure S7). Symbiodinium physiology was also more affected by heat stress when in symbiosis with corals than when maintained free-living in culture (Buxton et al., 2009). Photosymbiosis induces critical symbiont morphological and physiological changes (i.e., loss of motility) likely leading to a greater sensitivity when host protection is altered and prevent buffering external stressors.
In this study, we show that C. pelagicum can exhibit heat-induced bleaching. We unveiled several features of the processes, such as host cells degradation, partial digestion and potential viral infection of the B. nutricula cells, while the chloroplast was clearly the last structure to remain active. These results raise questions regarding the underlying cellular processes involved in symbiont loss in C. pelagicum and preservation mechanisms of chloroplast activity during B. nutricula cell collapsing. Further analysis using complementary approaches like transcriptomics or metabolomics would certainly be helpful to decipher more precisely the C. pelagicum holobiont response to elevated temperatures.
EV, MM-S, CB, EB, TL, and FN performed the experiments. EV performed the PAM fluorometry measurements, image analyses, the statistical treatments and wrote the manuscript. VD contributed to the TEM analyses and manuscript writing. MM-S performed the oxygen measurements. CB performed the sequence analyses. CB, FL, CSi, CSa, and FN commented and contributed to the final version of the manuscript. FN planned and designed the research.
This work benefited from the support of the projects IMPEKAB ANR-15-CE02-0011 and inSIDE ANR-12-JSV7-0009-01 of the French National Research Agency (ANR). This research was supported by the research infrastructure EMBRC-Fr (www.embrc-france.fr). CB received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation program under the Marie Skłodowska-Curie grant agreement no. 706430 (DYNAMO).
Conflict of Interest Statement
The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
The authors greatly acknowledge the Centre Commun de Microscopie Appliquée (Université Côte d’Azur), especially Sophie Pagnotta who performed the TEM image acquisitions. The authors acknowledge the members of Villefranche-sur-mer oceanological observatory for their help during the experimental work, especially Simon Ramondenc, Guillaume de Liege, David Luquet, Sophie Marro, and Régis Lasbleiz. The manuscript was deposited before peer-review on the pre-print server biorXiv (Villar et al., 2018).
The Supplementary Material for this article can be found online at: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fmars.2018.00387/full#supplementary-material
Anderson, O. R. (1976a). Fine structure of a collodarian radiolarian (Sphaerozoum punctatum Müller 1858) and cytoplasmic changes during reproduction. Mar. Micropaleontol. 1, 287–297. doi: 10.1016/0377-8398(76)90012-8
Anderson, O. R. (1976b). Ultrastructure of a colonial radiolarian Collozoum inerme and a cytochemical determination of the role of its zooxanthellae. Tissue Cell 8, 195–208. doi: 10.1016/0040-8166(76)90046-X
Biard, T., Bigeard, E., Audic, S., Poulain, J., Gutierrez-Rodriguez, A., Pesant, S., et al. (2017). Biogeography and diversity of Collodaria (Radiolaria) in the global ocean. ISME J. 11, 1331–1344. doi: 10.1038/ismej.2017.12
Biard, T., Pillet, L., Decelle, J., Poirier, C., Suzuki, N., and Not, F. (2015). Towards an integrative morpho-molecular classification of the Collodaria (Polycystinea, Radiolaria). Protist 166, 374–388. doi: 10.1016/j.protis.2015.05.002
Biard, T., Stemmann, L., Picheral, M., Mayot, N., Vandromme, P., Hauss, H., et al. (2016). In situ imaging reveals the biomass of giant protists in the global ocean. Nature 532, 504–507. doi: 10.1038/nature17652
Buxton, L., Badger, M., and Ralph, P. (2009). Effects of moderate heat stress and dissolved inorganic carbon concentration on photosynthesis and respiration of Symbiodinium Sp. (dinophyceae) in culture and in symbiosis. J. Phycol. 45, 357–365. doi: 10.1111/j.1529-8817.2009.00659.x
Cikala, M., Wilm, B., Hobmayer, E., Böttger, A., and David, C. N. (1999). Identification of caspases and apoptosis in the simple metazoan Hydra. Curr. Biol. 9, 959–962. doi: 10.1016/S0960-9822(99)80423-0
Correa, A. M. S., Ainsworth, T. D., Rosales, S. M., Thurber, A. R., Butler, C. R., and Vega Thurber, R. L. (2016). Viral outbreak in corals associated with an in situ bleaching event: atypical herpes-like viruses and a new Megavirus infecting Symbiodinium. Front. Microbiol. 7:127. doi: 10.3389/fmicb.2016.00127
Dani, V., Priouzeau, F., Pagnotta, S., Carette, D., Laugier, J.-P., and Sabourault, C. (2016). Thermal and menthol stress induce different cellular events during sea anemone bleaching. Symbiosis 69, 175–192. doi: 10.1007/s13199-016-0406-y
Decelle, J., Colin, S., and Foster, R. A. (2015). “Photosymbiosis in marine planktonic protists,” in Marine Protists, eds S. Ohtsuka, T. Suzaki, T. Horiguchi, N. Suzuki, and F. Not (Tokyo: Springer), 465–500. doi: 10.1007/978-4-431-55130-0_19
Downs, C. A., Kramarsky-Winter, E., Martinez, J., Kushmaro, A., Woodley, C. M., Loya, Y., et al. (2009). Symbiophagy as a cellular mechanism for coral bleaching. Autophagy 5, 211–216. doi: 10.4161/auto.5.2.7405
Dunn, S. R., Schnitzler, C. E., and Weis, V. M. (2007). Apoptosis and autophagy as mechanisms of dinoflagellate symbiont release during cnidarian bleaching: every which way you lose. Proc. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci. 274, 3079–3085. doi: 10.1098/rspb.2007.0711
Edgar, K. M., Bohaty, S., Gibbs, S., Sexton, P., Norris, R., and Wilson, P. (2013). Symbiont ‘bleaching’in planktic foraminifera during the Middle Eocene Climatic Optimum. Geology 41, 15–18. doi: 10.1130/G33388.1
Fujise, L., Yamashita, H., Suzuki, G., Sasaki, K., Liao, L. M., and Koike, K. (2014). Moderate thermal stress causes active and immediate expulsion of photosynthetically damaged zooxanthellae (Symbiodinium) from corals. PLoS One 9:e114321. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0114321
Genty, B., Briantais, J.-M., and Baker, N. R. (1989). The relationship between the quantum yield of photosynthetic electron transport and quenching of chlorophyll fluorescence. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 990, 87–92. doi: 10.1016/S0304-4165(89)80016-9
Guidi, L., Chaffron, S., Bittner, L., Eveillard, D., Larhlimi, A., Roux, S., et al. (2016). Plankton networks driving carbon export in the oligotrophic ocean. Nature 532, 465–470. doi: 10.1038/nature16942
Haeckel, E. (1887). “Report on Radiolaria collected by HMS Challenger during the years 1873-1876. Volume XVIII (Part 1) p. xcix-c,” in The Voyage of HMS Challenger, eds C. W. Thompson and J. Murray (London: Her Majesty’s Stationary Office).
Hoegh-Guldberg, O., Mumby, P. J., Hooten, A. J., Steneck, R. S., Greenfield, P., Gomez, E., et al. (2007). Coral reefs under rapid climate change and ocean acidification. Science 318, 1737–1742. doi: 10.1126/science.1152509
Katoh, K., Misawa, K., Kuma, K., and Miyata, T. (2002). MAFFT: a novel method for rapid multiple sequence alignment based on fast Fourier transform. Nucleic Acids Res. 30, 3059–3066. doi: 10.1093/nar/gkf436
Lesser, M. P. (2011). “Coral Bleaching: Causes and Mechanisms,” in Coral Reefs: An Ecosystem in Transition, eds Z. Dubinsky and N. Stambler (Dordrecht: Springer), 405–419. doi: 10.1007/978-94-007-0114-4_23
Levin, R. A., Voolstra, C. R., Weynberg, K. D., and van Oppen, M. J. H. (2017). Evidence for a role of viruses in the thermal sensitivity of coral photosymbionts. ISME J. 11, 808–812. doi: 10.1038/ismej.2016.154
Lilley, M. K. S., Thibault-Botha, D., and Lombard, F. (2014). Respiration demands increase significantly with both temperature and mass in the invasive ctenophore Mnemiopsis leidyi. J. Plankton Res. 36, 831–837. doi: 10.1093/plankt/fbu008
Lombard, F., Sciandra, A., and Gorsky, G. (2005). Influence of body mass, food concentration, temperature and filtering activity on the oxygen uptake of the appendicularian Oikopleura dioica. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser. 301, 149–158. doi: 10.3354/meps301149
Michaels, A. F., Caron, D. A., Swanberg, N. R., Howse, F. A., and Michaels, C. M. (1995). Planktonic sarcodines (Acantharia, Radiolaria, Foraminifera) in surface waters near Bermuda: abundance, biomass and vertical flux. J. Plankton Res. 17, 131–163. doi: 10.1093/plankt/17.1.131
Probert, I., Siano, R., Poirier, C., Decelle, J., Biard, T., Tuji, A., et al. (2014). Brandtodinium gen. nov. and B. nutricula comb. Nov. (Dinophyceae), a dinoflagellate commonly found in symbiosis with polycystine radiolarians. J. Phycol. 50, 388–399. doi: 10.1111/jpy.12174
Richier, S., Sabourault, C., Courtiade, J., Zucchini, N., Allemand, D., and Furla, P. (2006). Oxidative stress and apoptotic events during thermal stress in the symbiotic sea anemone, Anemonia viridis. FEBS J. 273, 4186–4198. doi: 10.1111/j.1742-4658.2006.05414.x
Roberty, S., Fransolet, D., Cardol, P., Plumier, J.-C., and Franck, F. (2015). Imbalance between oxygen photoreduction and antioxidant capacities in Symbiodinium cells exposed to combined heat and high light stress. Coral Reefs 34, 1063–1073. doi: 10.1007/s00338-015-1328-5
Schmidt, C., Heinz, P., Kucera, M., and Uthicke, S. (2011). Temperature-induced stress leads to bleaching in larger benthic foraminifera hosting endosymbiotic diatoms. Limnol. Oceanogr. 56, 1587–1602. doi: 10.4319/lo.2011.56.5.1587
Thurber, R. V., Payet, J. P., Thurber, A. R., and Correa, A. M. S. (2017). Virus–host interactions and their roles in coral reef health and disease. Nat. Rev. Microbiol. 15, 205–216. doi: 10.1038/nrmicro.2016.176
Vidal, J. (1980). Physioecology of zooplankton. IV. Effects of phytoplankton concentration, temperature, and body size on the net production efficiency of Calanus pacificus. Mar. Biol. 56, 203–211. doi: 10.1007/BF00645344
Villar, E., Dani, V., Bigeard, E., Linhart, T., Mendez-Sandin, M., Bachy, C., et al. (2018). Chloroplasts of symbiotic microalgae remain active during bleaching induced by thermal stress in Collodaria (Radiolaria). bioRxiv [Preprint]. doi: 10.1101/263053
Keywords: heat stress, photosymbiosis, bleaching, dinoflagellate, Collodaria, Radiolaria, Retaria, plankton
Citation: Villar E, Dani V, Bigeard E, Linhart T, Mendez-Sandin M, Bachy C, Six C, Lombard F, Sabourault C and Not F (2018) Symbiont Chloroplasts Remain Active During Bleaching-Like Response Induced by Thermal Stress in Collozoum pelagicum (Collodaria, Retaria). Front. Mar. Sci. 5:387. doi: 10.3389/fmars.2018.00387
Received: 08 June 2018; Accepted: 03 October 2018;
Published: 29 October 2018.
Edited by:Matthew D. Johnson, Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, United States
Reviewed by:Anthony William Larkum, University of Technology Sydney, Australia
Manuel F. G. Weinkauf, Université de Genève, Switzerland
Copyright © 2018 Villar, Dani, Bigeard, Linhart, Mendez-Sandin, Bachy, Six, Lombard, Sabourault and Not. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.