Original Research ARTICLE
Loss-of-Function NUBPL Mutation May Link Parkinson's Disease to Recessive Complex I Deficiency
- 1Population Bio, Inc., New York, NY, United States
- 2Valley Parkinson Clinic, Los Gatos, CA, United States
- 3Department of Pathology, Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, CA, United States
- 4Population Bio, UK, Begbroke, Oxfordshire, United Kingdom
In an unbiased genome-wide screen for copy number variants (CNVs) on a cohort of Parkinson's disease (PD) patients, we identified in one patient a complex chromosomal rearrangement involving the nucleotide binding protein-like (NUBPL) gene on chromosome 14q12. We noted that mutations in the NUBPL gene had been reported as causing autosomal recessive (AR) mitochondrial Complex I (CI) deficiency in children. The precise breakpoints of the rearrangement in our PD case were found to be identical to those described in a patient with AR CI deficiency who also harbored a second pathogenic mutation in NUBPL. Mitochondrial dysfunction has long been considered a strong contributor to PD, and there is substantial evidence that decreased CI activity plays a central role in PD pathogenesis. We hypothesize that pathogenic NUBPL variants may increase the risk for PD analogous to variants in the glucosylceramidase beta (GBA) gene that increase the risk of developing PD in heterozygous carriers.
Mitochondrial dysfunction is a hallmark pathology of Parkinson's disease (PD), particularly reduced complex I (CI) activity (1, 2). Despite the biochemical evidence for impaired CI activity, and accumulation of mitochondrial DNA mutations in sporadic PD (3, 4), no pathogenic variants impacting nuclear CI genes have been reported in PD. In contrast, CI deficiency, a rare early-onset disorder, is known to occur via a recessive or X-linked mechanism for 33 nuclear-encoded CI genes. Thus, there is considerable genetic evidence that mutations impacting both alleles for CI genes result in severe phenotypes, but it is not known if heterozygous carriers of CI gene mutations may have an increased risk for late-onset neurodegenerative disorders such as PD.
We report here, for the first time, a PD patient who carries a loss-of-function variant impacting the CI gene nucleotide binding protein-like (NUBPL; gene aliases IND1, huInd1, C14orf127), which codes for an iron-sulfur (Fe/S) assembly protein. Since the identification of NUBPL as a CI deficiency gene in 2008 (5) and a clinical report in 2010 of a pediatric patient with CI deficiency due to compound heterozygous mutations in NUBPL (MIM 613621, 618242) (6), 17 additional patients (in 13 families) have been reported with recessive NUBPL disease (7–13). Our PD patient's variant, which was found in a genome-wide screen for copy number variants (CNVs), is identical to the chromosomal rearrangement found in the first reported case of NUBPL CI deficiency (6). We therefore propose that carriers of NUBPL mutations may have an increased risk for developing PD.
The PD case described herein is from a genetic research cohort of 466 unrelated PD patients undergoing clinical care at the Parkinson's Institute and Clinical Center (Sunnyvale, CA). Written informed consent was obtained from all participants and the study was approved by El Camino Hospital's institutional review board (protocol ECH-99-22). The demographics of the cohort are: European ancestry, familial (27%) and sporadic (73%) cases, males (65%), and early onset (<50 years of age, 10%) and late onset cases (>50 years of age; 90%). A subset of the patients, including the patient reported herein, were screened for pathogenic mutations in PD genes GBA, LRRK2, PARK7 (DJ-1), PINK1, PRKN (PARK2), and SNCA (PARK1/4) using the targeted 188-gene sequencing panel described by Lee et al. (14). All subjects were clinically assessed by movement disorder specialists, which included a medical history and neurological examination.
Genome-wide CNV detection on genomic DNA samples was performed using aCGH on 1 million probe microarrays (catalog design #021529) acquired from Agilent Technologies (Santa Clara, CA); detailed methods are described elsewhere (15). Briefly, raw data were generated in an ISO-certified service laboratory (Oxford Gene Technology, Oxford, UK) and analysis was performed by Population Bio. CNV data was interpreted using Population Bio's control CNV database generated on apparently healthy males and females of European ancestry. First pass assessment of potentially PD-relevant CNVs focused on large, exonic chromosomal gains or losses that were found in one or more PD cases but not in 1,000 Population Bio controls.
After filtering our patient's aCGH data to include only CNVs that were exonic and not found in our 1,000 controls, the only remaining CNV was the NUBPL-disrupting chromosomal rearrangement. In addition to absence in our controls, this CNV is not found in the Database of Genomic Variants. However, ClinVar reports three pediatric patients with deletion genome coordinates similar to our patient's, one is the first reported patient with recessive NUBPL CI deficiency (ClinVar Accession VCV000000008) (6) and the other two (ClinVar Accessions VCV000152033 and VCV000153681) were reported based on review of chromosomal microarray data for 21,698 patients that had developmental delay, intellectual disability, autism spectrum disorders, or multiple congenital anomalies (16).
We used the PCR primers previously described (Supplementary Data) (17) to validate the complex CNV: 5′-inversion PCR (5′-inv), forward = GTTCACCACCATACCCCAAC and reverse = GTTAACCCGCCCTTTCTCTC; 3′-inversion PCR (3′-inv), forward = AGGGGATCTGACAGTAAAAGAGG and reverse = AGAAGATACCAGGACTTTCACAG. For comparison, results for both the previously reported CI deficiency patient and our PD patient are reported (Figure 1B). The previously reported 1855bp PCR product (17) is potentially a misreported size since the breakpoint sequences and deletion and duplication sizes of this patient match those found in our PD patient. Breakpoint sequencing data (Figure 1C) in our PD patient are the same as those reported in the CI deficiency patient, based on comparison of the sequence traces [we noted an error in Tucker et al. (17) Figure 2B, which omitted a C nucleotide in the sequence listed above the upper trace data]. We verified the size of the deletion and duplication found in our PD patient by performing a BLAT analysis of each PCR product and calculating the genomic distance as follows: deletion = distance between position of breakpoint upstream of exon 1 and position of breakpoint just downstream of exon 4 (deletion removes exons 1-4); duplication = distance between position of breakpoints on either side of exon 7 (duplication/inversion of exon 7). Sanger sequencing of NUBPL exons and flanking sequence was performed to determine if our PD patient had any additional deleterious variants, but none were found.
Figure 1. PD case with a chromosomal rearrangement disrupting CI assembly factor gene NUBPL. (A) Genome-wide CNV (aCGH) analysis revealed a complex chromosomal rearrangement in a female patient diagnosed with sporadic PD that consists of a 254Kb deletion (hg19, chr14:31867829-32121888) and 132Kb duplication (hg19, chr14:32143699-32275649). Gene annotation for the rearrangement was mapped in the UCSC genome browser (hg19) and shows HEATR5A and NUBPL are disrupted and there is a complete loss of LOC101927124, DTD2, and GPR33. Only gene dosage is shown and not the orientation of the inverted duplicated region (see B). Based on the microarray data, this CNV appeared to be the same as the one reported in a CI deficiency patient (6). A template switching model for the rearrangement was proposed and depicted in Tucker et al. (17) (B) PCR confirmation that the rearrangement detected in the sporadic PD case (PD-1256) is identical to the one previously found in a CI deficiency patient (6, 17). PCR experiments on PD-1256 were performed using previously reported PCR primers (see Methods). (C). Sequence chromatograms of upstream and downstream PCR products that were generated using previously described PCR primers (17). Chromosomal positions (hg19) and orientation of the regions (black arrows) are indicated. Identical sequences were found at both breakpoints (upstream and downstream) in the PD patient as were found in the CI deficiency patient (see Methods), including the LINE and MER2 repeat elements and a 15bp insertion at the downstream breakpoint (sequence is the reverse complement of the Tucker et al. sequence).
We performed a genome-wide array comparative genomic hybridization (aCGH) screen of 466 PD cases and 1,000 controls to detect CNVs that could contribute to PD risk. The data were filtered for large-sized, exonic CNVs that occur in one or more PD patients but not in controls. We identified a PD patient with a complex chromosomal rearrangement, encompassing a 254 Kb deletion and a 132 Kb duplication at chromosome 14q12, that disrupts the NUBPL gene (Figure 1A); no other large, exonic CNVs were present in this patient. In addition to NUBPL, the rearrangement disrupts HEAT repeat containing 5A (HEATR5A) and results in complete loss of a long non-coding RNA (LOC101927124), D-aminoacyl-tRNA deacylase 2 (DTD2), and G protein-coupled receptor 33 (gene/pseudogene) (GPR33). We confirmed by PCR analysis (Figure 1B) and breakpoint sequencing (Figure 1C) that this complex CNV is identical to a previously described mutation in a child with CI deficiency (6, 17).
Our patient is of European ancestry with no family history of PD or parkinsonism. She resided in the United States and died at the age of 67, so we could not determine if she was related to the previously reported child with CI deficiency (6), who was reported to be from Australia (9).
Her symptoms started at age 62 with tremor of left upper and lower extremities and bradykinesia. She received clear benefit from dopamine replacement therapy; however, she quickly experienced wearing-off within a year of taking L-dopa and her symptoms progressed quickly. Cardinal symptoms of PD present upon neurological examination included asymmetric onset, bradykinesia, postural instability, rigidity, and tremor. Her speech was mildly dysarthric (dysarthria is often found in NUBPL CI deficiency patients) (9), she showed slight loss of facial expression, and her handwriting was severely impaired. She did not report changes in cognition or hallucinations. Autonomic symptoms included orthostatic symptoms like lightheadedness and urinary incontinence. Both her and her sister were reported to have restless legs symptoms. No dyskinesia was observed. Overall, the clinical presentation was compatible with Parkinson's disease, but differential diagnosis of multiple system atrophy was also considered because of the prominent autonomic symptoms and rather short period of symptomatic benefit from L-dopa and fast disease progression.
We report on the first genetic evidence of a PD case harboring a complex rearrangement in the NUBPL gene leading to loss of protein function. Pathogenic mutations in NUBPL are a cause of autosomal recessive CI deficiency in pediatric patients (MIM 613621, 618242). Our patient's mutation (Figure 1) is identical to one of the mutations reported in the first case of NUBPL CI deficiency (6, 17). This complex CNV (Figure 1A) results in partial loss of HEATR5A and NUBPL and full loss of LOC101927124, DTD2, and GPR33. Limited information is available for HEATR5A and LOC101927124. The DTD2 gene is known to be involved in chiral proofreading during translation (18), and GPR33 is linked to innate immunity and has undergone pseudogenization in humans (19). While these other genes cannot be ruled out as potential factors in PD, we consider NUBPL as a promising candidate PD risk gene because of strong evidence of mitochondrial CI dysfunction in PD (2).
We could not determine if our PD patient was related to the Calvo et al. patient (6), who resided in different countries (USA and Australia). While it is possible this is a recurrent rearrangement, there is no evidence of this as no differences were found (breakpoint sequences were identical, see Methods) between our PD case and the CI deficiency case (17). The ClinVar database reports two pediatric patients with similar sized deletions (see Methods), but the precise breakpoints are not known so we cannot conclude if these deletions are the same as found in our PD patient and the CI deficiency patient. If the mechanism was the same in both ClinVar cases, one would expect them to also carry a duplication but this was not reported for either patient.
Limitations of the genetic investigation methods we performed on our patient's DNA are: the aCGH microarray detects CNVs that are ~5 Kb or greater, so smaller sized CNVs (e.g., indels) or other types of structural variants (e.g., copy number neutral inversions) will not be identified; whole exome sequencing and/or whole genome sequencing was not performed on the patient's DNA. Therefore, we cannot rule out that other PD-relevant rare deleterious variants may eventually be found in our patient's genome with higher resolution methods. However, we did rule out pathogenic variants in well-established PD genes (GBA, LRRK2, PARK7, PINK1, PRKN, and SNCA) based on screening our patient's DNA with a 188-gene sequencing panel (14).
Precedents exist for genes causing early onset and severe clinical presentation when both alleles contain pathogenic mutations, and milder symptoms and later onset when only one allele is impacted by a pathogenic mutation. Notably, the association between PD and Lewy body disorders with mutations in the GBA gene, which causes autosomal recessive Gaucher disease (MIM 606463), has resulted in new clinical insights and drug discovery programs for PD (20, 21). Furthermore, there is growing evidence that other recessive lysosomal storage disease genes are associated with increased risk of PD in carriers of pathogenic variants (22). Analogous to the link between GBA heterozygous mutations and PD, we hypothesize that individuals heterozygous for NUBPL mutations could have an increased risk for developing PD. Given the extensive evidence for mitochondrial dysfunction — particularly reduced CI activity — in late-onset neurological disorders (2), we believe this novel finding provides a basis for the nomination of NUBPL as a gene that may cause or contribute to PD pathology. However, broader screening of larger cohorts of cases and controls via sequencing and copy number microarrays is warranted to support a potential association between NUBPL mutations and PD. Functional validation of PD-associated variants, if found, may further confirm if heterozygous carriers of NUBPL variants that reduce CI activity are at increased risk for PD. Finally, in order to determine if heterozygous carriers are at increased risk of PD, we suggest that it would be fruitful to examine parents and grandparents of individuals diagnosed with NUBPL CI deficiency.
In closing, we note that mitochondrial function is complex and involves numerous genes and environmental factors, several of which are already linked to PD (23). Large consortium driven studies have the resources to efficiently genetically validate candidate PD genes that may be causing or contributing to PD due to rare and/or common variants (24). Interestingly, a recent large study suggests that NUBPL and other complex I genes known to cause monogenic mitochondrial disorders are associated with PD risk and age of onset (25).
Data Availability Statement
Publicly available data can be found here: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/clinvar/variation/929501/ The raw data supporting the conclusions of this article will be made available by the authors, without undue reservation, to any qualified researcher. Requests to access the datasets should be directed to Eli Hatchwell (email@example.com).
The studies involving human participants were reviewed and approved by El Camino Hospital's institutional review board (protocol ECH-99-22). The patients/participants provided their written informed consent to participate in this study. Written informed consent was obtained from the individual for the publication of any potentially identifiable images or data included in this article.
PE, EH, and BS: conception and design of the study, data acquisition, analysis, and interpretation, and wrote the manuscript. NH, JL, and BS: patient recruitment, provision of study materials, and patient clinical assessments. All authors revised/approved the manuscript.
A portion of this study was funded by the Parkinson Alliance (BS and JL).
Conflict of Interest
PE and EH are employees of Population Bio, Inc.
The remaining authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
We are indebted to the PD patients participating in this study for their commitment to help move the research toward a cure.
1. Giachin G, Bouverot R, Acajjaoui S, Pantalone S, Soler-Lopez M. Dynamics of human mitochondrial complex I assembly: implications for neurodegenerative diseases. Front Mol Biosci. (2016) 3:43. doi: 10.3389/fmolb.2016.00043
3. Dolle C, Flones I, Nido GS, Miletic H, Osuagwu N, Kristoffersen S, et al. Defective mitochondrial DNA homeostasis in the substantia nigra in Parkinson disease. Nat Commun. (2016) 7:13548. doi: 10.1038/ncomms13548
4. Lin MT, Cantuti-Castelvetri I, Zheng K, Jackson KE, Tan YB, Arzberger T, et al. Somatic mitochondrial DNA mutations in early Parkinson and incidental Lewy body disease. Ann Neurol. (2012) 71:850–4. doi: 10.1002/ana.23568
5. Bych K, Kerscher S, Netz DJ, Pierik AJ, Zwicker K, Huynen MA, et al. The iron-sulphur protein Ind1 is required for effective complex I assembly. EMBO J. (2008) 27:1736–46. doi: 10.1038/emboj.2008.98
6. Calvo SE, Tucker EJ, Compton AG, Kirby DM, Crawford G, Burtt NP, et al. High-throughput, pooled sequencing identifies mutations in NUBPL and FOXRED1 in human complex I deficiency. Nat Genet. (2010) 42:851–8. doi: 10.1038/ng.659
7. Balint B, Charlesworth G, Stamelou M, Carr L, Mencacci NE, Wood NW, et al. Mitochondrial complex I NUBPL mutations cause combined dystonia with bilateral striatal necrosis and cerebellar atrophy. Eur J Neurol. (2019) 26:1240–3. doi: 10.1111/ene.13956
8. Friederich MW, Perez FA, Knight KM, Van Hove RA, Yang SP, Saneto RP, et al. Pathogenic variants in NUBPL result in failure to assemble the matrix arm of complex I and cause a complex leukoencephalopathy with thalamic involvement. Mol Genet Metab. (2020) 129:236–42. doi: 10.1016/j.ymgme.2019.12.013
9. Kevelam SH, Rodenburg RJ, Wolf NI, Ferreira P, Lunsing RJ, Nijtmans LG, et al. NUBPL mutations in patients with complex I deficiency and a distinct MRI pattern. Neurology. (2013) 80:1577–83. doi: 10.1212/WNL.0b013e31828f1914
10. Kimonis V, al-Dubaisi R, Maclean AE, Hall K, Weiss L, Stover AE, et al. NUBPL mitochondrial disease: new patients and review of the genetic and clinical spectrum. J Med Genet. (2020) doi: 10.1136/jmedgenet-2020-106846
11. Maclean AE, Kimonis VE, Balk J. Pathogenic mutations in NUBPL affect complex I activity and cold tolerance in the yeast model Yarrowia lipolytica. Hum Mol Genet. (2018) 27:3697–709. doi: 10.1093/hmg/ddy247
12. Protasoni M, Bruno C, Donati MA, Mohamoud K, Severino M, Allegri A, et al. Novel compound heterozygous pathogenic variants in nucleotide-binding protein like protein (NUBPL) cause leukoencephalopathy with multi-systemic involvement. Mol Genet Metab. (2020) 129:26–34. doi: 10.1016/j.ymgme.2019.11.003
13. Tenisch EV, Lebre AS, Grevent D, de Lonlay P, Rio M, Zilbovicius M, et al. Massive and exclusive pontocerebellar damage in mitochondrial disease and NUBPL mutations. Neurology. (2012) 79:391. doi: 10.1212/WNL.0b013e3182611232
14. Lee K, Nguyen KD, Sun C, Liu M, Zafar F, Saetern J, et al. LRRK2 p.Ile1371Val Mutation in a Case with Neuropathologically Confirmed Multi-System Atrophy. J Parkinsons Dis. (2018) 8:93–100. doi: 10.3233/JPD-171237
15. Prasad A, Merico D, Thiruvahindrapuram B, Wei J, Lionel AC, Sato D, et al. A discovery resource of rare copy number variations in individuals with autism spectrum disorder. G3. (2012) 2:1665–85. doi: 10.1534/g3.112.004689
16. Miller DT, Adam MP, Aradhya S, Biesecker LG, Brothman AR, Carter NP, et al. Consensus statement: chromosomal microarray is a first-tier clinical diagnostic test for individuals with developmental disabilities or congenital anomalies. Am J Hum Genet. (2010) 86:749–64. doi: 10.1016/j.ajhg.2010.04.006
17. Tucker EJ, Mimaki M, Compton AG, McKenzie M, Ryan MT, Thorburn DR. Next-generation sequencing in molecular diagnosis: NUBPL mutations highlight the challenges of variant detection and interpretation. Hum Mutat. (2012) 33:411–8. doi: 10.1002/humu.21654
19. Bohnekamp J, Boselt I, Saalbach A, Tonjes A, Kovacs P, Biebermann H, et al. Involvement of the chemokine-like receptor GPR33 in innate immunity. Biochem Biophys Res Commun. (2010) 396:272–7. doi: 10.1016/j.bbrc.2010.04.077
24. International Parkinson Disease Genomics Consortium (IPDGC). Ten years of the international Parkinson disease consortium: progress and next steps. J Parkinsons Dis. (2020) 10:19–30. doi: 10.3233/JPD-191854
25. Billingsley KJ, Barbosa IA, Bandres-Ciga S, Quinn JP, Bubb VJ, Deshpande C, et al. Mitochondria function associated genes contribute to Parkinson's Disease risk and later age at onset. NPJ Parkinsons Dis. (2019) 5:8. doi: 10.1038/s41531-019-0080-x
Keywords: complex I deficiency, copy number variant, genetic risk, Ind1, mitochondrial dysfunction, NUBPL, nucleotide binding protein-like, Parkinson's disease
Citation: Eis PS, Huang N, Langston JW, Hatchwell E and Schüle B (2020) Loss-of-Function NUBPL Mutation May Link Parkinson's Disease to Recessive Complex I Deficiency. Front. Neurol. 11:555961. doi: 10.3389/fneur.2020.555961
Received: 26 April 2020; Accepted: 28 September 2020;
Published: 29 October 2020.
Edited by:Tim Anderson, University of Otago, Christchurch, New Zealand
Reviewed by:Manabu Funayama, Juntendo University, Japan
Graziella Madeo, Fondazione Novella Fronda Onlus, Italy
Copyright © 2020 Eis, Huang, Langston, Hatchwell and Schüle. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.