The peer review process

In this section, you'll find guides and advice to help you navigate the peer review process in your role as an editor. Although some of the information here focuses specifically on Frontiers' peer review, the skills you'll learn are universal and apply widely in your editorial career, across journals.

About Frontiers' peer review

Understanding article types

A clear comparison of the article types used at Frontiers, including their purpose and submission requirements.

How to select reviewers

Use these guidelines to build a balanced set of reviewers and send the right invitations.

The Handling Editor role

A practical overview of what’s involved in being a Handling Editor for Frontiers’ journals.

Editorial processes and skills

What to look for in a manuscript

A practical framework to help you assess scientific merit using straightforward checks before and during peer review.

How to give constructive feedback

Constructive feedback is one of the most valuable outcomes of peer review. See our tips on how to provide it well.

Handling appeals

Guidance on how to assess appeals consistently, treat all parties respectfully, and protect the integrity of the journal.