EDITORIAL article

Front. Mar. Sci., 25 November 2021

Sec. Marine Fisheries, Aquaculture and Living Resources

Volume 8 - 2021 | https://doi.org/10.3389/fmars.2021.787217

Editorial: The Status of Marine Fisheries in East Asia

  • 1. Sea Around Us, Institute for the Ocean and Fisheries, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada

  • 2. CAS Key Laboratory of Marine Ecology and Environmental Sciences, Institute of Oceanology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Qingdao, China

  • 3. Laboratory for Marine Ecology and Environmental Science, Qingdao National Laboratory for Marine Science and Technology, Qingdao, China

  • 4. Center for Ocean Mega-Science, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Qingdao, China

East Asia includes some of the countries with the highest domestic fisheries catch in the world, notably China and Japan. The status of their fisheries matters to the world because these countries also deploy huge fishing fleets into the high seas and the Exclusive Economic Zones of other countries, tasked with compensating for stagnating or even declining local fisheries resources.

Rebuilding East Asian fishery resources is a challenge, however, because their status is often unknown. This situation is due, at least in part, to the fact that time series of data suitable for analysis requiring sophisticated, but data-demanding methods, being scarce or not available in the region.

This dissatisfying state of affairs is now gradually being overcome, notably through the development, by Froese et al. (2017, 2018), of stock assessment methods that require less data, but still produce results that are reliable results enough to inform fisheries management.

These approaches consist of:

  • (1) the ā€œCMSY/BSMā€ method (Froese et al., 2017), which relies essentially on time-series of catches—preferably spanning two decades or more—and ancillary data to estimate time series of abundance or ā€œbiomassā€ for the assessed populations or ā€œstocksā€;

  • (2) the ā€œLBB' method (Froese et al., 2018), which uses length-frequency samples, i.e., multiple measurements of fish lengths, to infer the status of a fish populations or stocks, and

  • (3) A reconceptualization of classical yield-per-recruit (Y/R) analysis (Beverton and Holt, 1957) such that can provide estimates of the ratio of current to unexploited biomass.

These methods were introduced to Chinese scientists via a highly successful training course held in Qingdao during June 16–20, 2019. The course was taught by the authors and Dr. M.L. Deng Palomares, with Dr. Rainer Froese participating remotely.

During the course, multiple stock assessments were run which eventually evolved into the bulk of the articles presented here. A few articles that were written previously and/or independently of the course are also included.

Altogether, 161 East Asian marine stocks were assessed, of which 132 pertained to finfishes and 29 to invertebrates, especially squids. Of these, 83 stocks were exploited along the coast of the Chinese Mainland (Liang, Xian, Pauly et al.; Liang, Xian, Liu et al.; Wang, Wang, Liu et al.; Wang X. et al.; Zhai and Pauly(a); Zhai et al.; Zhang L. et al.), 22 from around Taiwan (Ju, Chen et al.; Ju, Tian et al.; Liang Xian, Liu et al.), 50 around Japan (Liang, Xian, Liu et al.; Ren and Liu; Wang, Wang, Liang et al.; Wang, Liang et al.; Zhang S. et al.) and 6 around South Korea (Liang, Xian, Liu et al.).

As is the case for all stock assessment methods, the CMSY/BSM and LBB methods rely on reliable input data, i.e., catch (and catch-per-unit-effort) time series for CMSY/BSM and length-frequency data for LBB. Problematic inputs, and unrealistic constraints (ā€œpriorsā€) will lead to biased parameter estimates, and a few of the 161 estimates presented here will be biased up- or downward. However, there is no reason to assume a systematic bias.

Overall, these assessments jointly represent the most comprehensive evaluation of the Status of Marine Fisheries in East Asia, and they paint a very sobering picture. Thus, if one gives each stock a similar weight, one can compute from these assessments, for each region, the average biomass (or fish resource abundance) currently remaining as a percentage of its inferred biomass or abundance in the absence of fishing.

These mean percentages are 25% for the Chinese Mainland, 16% for Taiwan, 30% for Japan and 26% for South Korea; all of these averages are well below 50%, the level the classical stock assessment model of Schaefer (1954, 1957) requires for Maximum Sustainable Yield to be generated (Pauly and Froese, 2020). The regional means were derived from several ratio estimates that were higher, i.e., there are stocks in East Asia that are not overfished. However, there were far more stocks that had extremely low values of current to unfished biomass, with the result that the mean ratio for East Asia was 25%.

That overfishing is prevalent in East Asia was previously known (Srinivasan et al., 2012; Li et al., 2017). However, most of these assessments include estimates of the parameters also required to compute the time needed for overfished stocks to recover, given a reduction of fishing pressure (see Demirel et al., 2020). Thus, this makes it possible for fisheries scientists in East Asia to straightforwardly compute fishing quotas allowing for increasing stock sizes by a factor of two in the average, but which would allow for the social cost of a reduction of fishing effort to be smaller than the benefits gained from abundant stocks embedded in functioning ecosystems.

Indeed, at least for the Chinese Mainland, Zhai and Pauly(b) found, based on the conversion of 19 food web models into particle-size distribution spectra, that the functioning of coastal marine ecosystem of East Asia are gradually eroded due to the fisheries-induced disappearance of large fish species and miniaturization of the remaining species.

Thus, rebuilding stocks in East Asia would not only benefit fisheries economically, in terms of their catches, but also re-establish the functioning, rich marine ecosystems that enable fisheries to flourish in the longer term.

äøœäŗšåœ°åŒŗęø”äøšēŠ¶å†µ

äøœäŗšåŒ…ę‹¬äø€äŗ›äø–ē•ŒäøŠå›½å†…ęø”äøšę•ęžé‡ęœ€é«˜ēš„å›½å®¶, ē‰¹åˆ«ę˜Æäø­å›½å’Œę—„ęœ¬ć€‚äøŗå¼„č”„å›½å†…åœę»žē”šč‡³č”°é€€ēš„ęø”äøščµ„ęŗ, äøœäŗšå›½å®¶ä¼šå‘å…¬ęµ·å’Œå…¶ä»–å›½å®¶ēš„äø“å±žē»ęµŽåŒŗę“¾å‡ŗåŗžå¤§ēš„ę•ęžčˆ¹é˜Ÿ, å› ę­¤, å®ƒä»¬ēš„ęø”äøšēŠ¶å†µå¤‡å—äø–ē•Œå…³ę³Øć€‚

é‡å»ŗäøœäŗšęø”äøščµ„ęŗé¢‡å…·ęŒ‘ęˆ˜, å› äøŗå…¶čµ„ęŗēŠ¶ę€å¾€å¾€ę˜ÆęœŖēŸ„ēš„ć€‚é€ ęˆčæ™ē§ęƒ…å†µēš„éƒØåˆ†åŽŸå› åœØäŗŽ, å¤ę‚ēš„čµ„ęŗčÆ„ä¼°ę–¹ę³•éœ€č¦å¤§é‡ēš„ę—¶é—“åŗåˆ—ę•°ę®, č€Œčæ™ē§ę•°ę®åœØäøœäŗšåœ°åŒŗé€šåøøå¾ˆå°‘č§ęˆ–äøå­˜åœØć€‚

ē›®å‰, é€ščæ‡å¾·å›½ęø”äøšå­¦å®¶Rainer FroeseåŠå…¶åŒäŗ‹å¼€å‘ēš„å‡ ē§ę•°ę®ē¼ŗä¹ę”ä»¶äø‹ēš„ęø”äøšē§ē¾¤čÆ„ä¼°ę–¹ę³•, čæ™ē§ēŠ¶å†µę­£é€ęøč¢«ę”¹å–„ć€‚čæ™äŗ›ę–¹ę³•éœ€č¦č¾ƒå°‘ēš„ęø”äøšę•°ę®ä½œäøŗč¾“å…„, ä½†ä»čƒ½äŗ§ē”Ÿč¾ƒäøŗåÆé ēš„ē»“ęžœę„äøŗęø”äøšē®”ē†ęä¾›å‚č€ƒć€‚

čæ™äŗ›ę–¹ę³•åŒ…ę‹¬:

  • (1) ā€œCMSY/BSMā€ę–¹ę³• (Froese et al., 2017), å®ƒäø»č¦ä¾čµ–äŗŽęø”čŽ·é‡ēš„ę—¶é—“åŗåˆ—ļ¼ˆę—¶é—“č·Øåŗ¦ęœ€å„½č¶…čæ‡äŗŒåå¹“ļ¼‰ä»„åŠč¾…åŠ©ę•°ę®ę„ä¼°č®”č¢«čÆ„ä¼°ē§ē¾¤ęˆ–ē¾¤ä½“ēš„äø°åŗ¦ęˆ–ē”Ÿē‰©é‡ć€‚

  • (2) ā€œLBBā€ę–¹ę³• (Froese et al., 2018), čÆ„ę–¹ę³•ä½æē”Øęµ‹é‡å¾—åˆ°ēš„ä½“é•æé¢‘ēŽ‡ę•°ę®, ę„ęŽØę–­ęø”äøšē§ē¾¤ęˆ–ē¾¤ä½“ēš„ēŠ¶ę€ć€‚

  • (3) åÆ¹ē»å…øēš„å•ä½č”„å……é‡ęø”čŽ·é‡åˆ†ęž (Beverton and Holt, 1957) čæ›č”Œę¦‚åæµé‡å»ŗ, ä»„ä¼°č®”å½“å‰ē”Ÿē‰©é‡äøŽęœŖå¼€å‘ē”Ÿē‰©é‡ēš„ęÆ”å€¼ 怂

čæ™äŗ›ę–¹ę³•é€ščæ‡2019 幓 6 月 18–20 ę—„åœØé’å²›äø¾åŠžēš„åŸ¹č®­čÆ¾ēØ‹č¢«ä»‹ē»ē»™ę„č‡Ŗå¤šę‰€é«˜ę ”å’Œē§‘ē ”é™¢ę‰€ēš„äø­å›½ęø”äøšå­¦č€…ć€‚čÆ„čÆ¾ēØ‹äø»č¦ē”±Maria Lourdes D. Palomares博士和Daniel Paulyåšå£«ę•™ęŽˆ, Rainer Froese åšå£«čæœēØ‹å‚äøŽć€‚åœØåŸ¹č®­čÆ¾ēØ‹ęœŸé—“, äøŠčæ°ę–¹ę³•č¢«ē”ØäŗŽäøœäŗšåœ°åŒŗä¼—å¤šęø”äøšē§ē¾¤ęˆ–ē¾¤ä½“ēš„čµ„ęŗčÆ„ä¼°, å¹¶ęœ€ē»ˆå½¢ęˆäŗ†ęœ¬é›†åˆŠēš„å¤§éƒØåˆ†ę–‡ē« ć€‚é›†åˆŠäø­å¦ęœ‰éƒØåˆ†ę–‡ē« ē‹¬ē«‹äŗŽęœ¬ę¬”åŸ¹č®­čÆ¾ēØ‹, ä¹ŸåœØåŽęœŸčæ›č”Œäŗ†å¢žč”„ć€‚

ęœ¬é›†åˆŠå…±åÆ¹161äøŖäøœäŗšęµ·ę“‹ē§ē¾¤čæ›č”Œäŗ†čÆ„ä¼°, åŒ…ę‹¬132ē§é±¼ē±»,29ē§ę— č„Šę¤ŽåŠØē‰©ć€‚åœØčæ™äŗ›č¢«čÆ„ä¼°ēš„ē§ē¾¤äø­, ꜉83äøŖē§ē¾¤äø»č¦åœØäø­å›½å¤§é™†ę²æęµ·č¢«å¼€å‘ (Liang, Xian, Pauly et al.; Liang, Xian, Liu et al.; Wang, Wang, Liu et al.; Zhai and Pauly (a); Zhai et al.; Zhang L. et al.),22äøŖē§ē¾¤äø»č¦č¢«å°ę¹¾åœ°åŒŗå¼€å‘ (Ju, Chen et al.; Ju, Xian et al.; Liang, Liu et al.), åˆ†åøƒäŗŽę—„ęœ¬ęµ·åŸŸēš„ē§ē¾¤50äøŖ (Liang, Xian, Liu et al.; Ren and Liu; Wang, Wang, Liang et al.; Wang, Liang et al.; Zhang S. et al.), éŸ©å›½ęµ·åŸŸ6äøŖ (Liang, Xian, Liu et al.)怂

äøŽę‰€ęœ‰ē§ē¾¤čÆ„ä¼°ę–¹ę³•ēš„ęƒ…å†µäø€ ę ·, CMSY/BSM 和 LBB ę–¹ę³•ä¾čµ–äŗŽåÆé ēš„č¾“å…„ę•°ę®, 即 CMSY/BSMēš„ęø”čŽ·é‡ļ¼ˆå’Œå•ä½åŠŖåŠ›é‡ęø”čŽ·é‡ļ¼‰ę—¶é—“åŗåˆ—å’Œ LBB ēš„ä½“é•æé¢‘ēŽ‡ę•°ę®ć€‚å­˜ē–‘ēš„č¾“å…„ę•°ę®å’Œēŗ¦ęŸę”ä»¶ļ¼ˆā€˜ā€˜å…ˆéŖŒå€¼ā€ļ¼‰å°†åÆ¼č‡“å‚ę•°ä¼°č®”å‡ŗēŽ°åå·®ć€‚åœØčæ™161äøŖčÆ„ä¼°ē§ē¾¤äø­, ä¼šęœ‰éƒØåˆ†ē§ē¾¤ēš„čÆ„ä¼°ē»“ęžœå› č¾“å…„ę•°ę®ēš„č“Øé‡é—®é¢˜č¢«é«˜ä¼°ęˆ–ä½Žä¼°, ä½†ē›®å‰ēš„ē ”ē©¶ęœŖå‘ēŽ°ē³»ē»Ÿę€§čÆÆå·®ēš„å­˜åœØć€‚

ę€»ä½“č€ŒčØ€, ęœ¬é›†åˆŠäø­ēš„ę–‡ē« å…±åŒē»„ęˆäŗ†ē›®å‰åÆ¹äøœäŗšęµ·ę“‹ęø”äøšēŠ¶å†µęœ€å…Øé¢ēš„čÆ„ä¼°ć€‚å¦‚ęžœē»™ęÆäøŖčÆ„ä¼°ē§ē¾¤äø€äøŖē›øåŒēš„ęƒé‡, åÆä»„ä»Žčæ™äŗ›čÆ„ä¼°ē»“ęžœäø­č®”ē®—å‡ŗęÆäøŖåŒŗåŸŸå½“å‰å‰©ä½™ē”Ÿē‰©é‡ļ¼ˆęˆ–čµ„ęŗäø°åŗ¦ļ¼‰äøŽęœŖå¼€å‘ē”Ÿē‰©é‡ļ¼ˆęˆ–äø°åŗ¦ļ¼‰ęÆ”å€¼ēš„å¹³å‡å€¼ć€‚äø­å›½å¤§é™†ēš„å¹³å‡ē™¾åˆ†ęÆ”äøŗ 25%, å°ę¹¾äøŗ 16%, ę—„ęœ¬äøŗ 30%, éŸ©å›½äøŗ 26%ć€‚ę‰€ęœ‰čæ™äŗ›å¹³å‡å€¼éƒ½čæœä½ŽäŗŽ 50%, 即 Schaefer (1954, 1957) ēš„ē»å…øčµ„ęŗčÆ„ä¼°ęØ”åž‹č¦ę±‚ē”Ÿęˆęœ€å¤§åÆęŒē»­äŗ§é‡ēš„ę°“å¹³ (Pauly and Froese, 2020)ć€‚č™½ē„¶čÆ„ä¼°ē»“ęžœę˜¾ē¤ŗäøœäŗšåŒŗåŸŸęœ‰å°šęœŖčæ‡åŗ¦ę•ęžēš„ē§ē¾¤, ä½†ē”±äŗŽå­˜åœØå¤§é‡å‰©ä½™ē”Ÿē‰©é‡äøŽęœŖå¼€å‘ē”Ÿē‰©é‡ęÆ”å€¼ęžä½Žēš„ē§ē¾¤, å› ę­¤äøœäŗšåŒŗåŸŸčÆ„ęÆ”å€¼ę•“ä½“äøŗ25%å·¦å³ć€‚

å°½ē®”äøœäŗšåœ°åŒŗę™®éå­˜åœØčæ‡åŗ¦ę•ęžēŽ°č±”ę—©å·²č¢«ē†ŸēŸ„ (Srinivasan et al., 2012; Li et al., 2017), ęœ¬é›†åˆŠäø­ēš„ē»“ęžœčæ˜ęä¾›äŗ†ę–°ēš„äæ”ęÆ, ä¾‹å¦‚åœØę•ęžåŽ‹åŠ›é™ä½Žęƒ…å†µäø‹, ē”ØäŗŽč®”ē®—čæ‡åŗ¦ę•ęžē§ē¾¤ę¢å¤ę—¶é—“ę‰€éœ€č¦ēš„å‚ę•°ēš„ä¼°č®”å€¼ (Demirel et al., 2020) ć€‚čæ™ä½æå¾—äøœäŗšēš„ęø”äøšå­¦å®¶åÆä»„č®”ē®—ē§‘å­¦ēš„ę•ęžé…é¢, ä»Žč€Œä½æē§ē¾¤ę•°é‡å¹³å‡å¢žåŠ äø¤å€, å¢žåŠ ēš„ē§ē¾¤ę•°é‡åø¦ę„ēš„ę”¶ē›Šå°†č¶…čæ‡å‡å°‘ę•ęžåŽ‹åŠ›åÆ¼č‡“ēš„ē¤¾ä¼šęˆęœ¬ęŸå¤±ć€‚

äŗ‹å®žäøŠ, åœØå°†19 äøŖé£Ÿē‰©ē½‘ęØ”åž‹č½¬ę¢ęˆē²’åŗ¦åˆ†åøƒč°±ä¹‹åŽ, Zhai and Pauly(b) å‘ēŽ°, ä»„äø­å›½å¤§é™†åœ°åŒŗäøŗä»£č”Øēš„äøœäŗšę²æęµ·ęµ·ę“‹ē”Ÿę€ē³»ē»Ÿēš„åŠŸčƒ½ę­£åœØé€ęøč¢«ä¾µčš€, ęø”äøšę“»åŠØå¼•čµ·ēš„å¤§åž‹é±¼ē±»ē‰©ē§ēš„ę¶ˆå¤±å’Œå‰©ä½™ē‰©ē§ēš„å°åž‹åŒ–ę˜Æé€ ęˆčæ™ē§ēŽ°č±”ēš„äø»č¦åŽŸå› ć€‚å› ę­¤, é‡å»ŗäøœäŗšē§ē¾¤äøä»…ä¼šåœØęø”čŽ·é‡ę–¹é¢äøŗęø”äøšåø¦ę„ē»ęµŽåˆ©ē›Š, č€Œäø”čæ˜å°†é‡å»ŗåŠŸčƒ½å„å…Øć€ē‰©ē§äø°åÆŒēš„ęµ·ę“‹ē”Ÿę€ē³»ē»Ÿ, ä½æęø”äøščƒ½å¤Ÿé•æęœŸē¹č£å‘å±•ć€‚

Publisher's Note

All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.

Statements

Author contributions

All authors listed have made a substantial, direct, and intellectual contribution to the work and approved it for publication.

Conflict of interest

The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.

References

  • 1

    BevertonR. J. H.HoltS. J. (1957). On the dynamics of exploited fish populations. Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food. London: Fishery Investigations.

  • 2

    DemirelN.ZenginM.UlmanA. (2020). First large-scale Eastern Mediterranean and Black Sea stock assessment reveals a dramatic decline. Front. Mar. Sci.7:103. 10.3389/fmars.2020.00103

  • 3

    FroeseR.DemirelN.CoroG.KleisnerK. M.WinkerH. (2017). Estimating fisheries reference points from catch and resilience. Fish. Fish.18, 506–526. 10.1111/faf.12190

  • 4

    FroeseR.WinkerH.CoroG.DemirelN.TsiklirasA. C.DimarchopoulouD.et al. (2018). A new approach for estimating stock status from length-frequency data. ICES J. Mar. Sci.75, 2004–2015. 10.1093/icesjms/fsy078

  • 5

    LiJ.CaoK.DingF.YangW.ShenG.LiY. (2017). Changes in trophic-level structure of the main fish species caught by China and their relationship with fishing method. J. Fish. Sci. China24, 109–119. 10.3724/SP.J.1118.2017.16164

  • 6

    PaulyD.FroeseR. (2020). MSY needs no epitaph- but it was abused. ICES J. Mar. Sci.78, 2204–2210. 10.1093/icesjms/fsaa224

  • 7

    SchaeferM. B. (1954). Some aspects of the dynamics of populations important to the management of the commercial marine fisheries. Inter Am. Trop. Tuna Comm. Bull.1, 23–56.

  • 8

    SchaeferM. B. (1957). A study of the dynamics of the fishery for yellowfin tuna in the eastern tropical Pacific Ocean. Inter Am. Trop. Tuna Comm. Bull.2, 243–285.

  • 9

    SrinivasanU. T.WatsonR.SumailaU. R. (2012). Global fisheries losses at the exclusive economic zone level, 1950 to present. Mar. Policy36, 544–549. 10.1016/j.marpol.2011.10.001

Summary

Keywords

stock assessments, catch time-series, length frequency data, China, Korea, Japan

Citation

Pauly D, Liang C and Xian W (2021) Editorial: The Status of Marine Fisheries in East Asia. Front. Mar. Sci. 8:787217. doi: 10.3389/fmars.2021.787217

Received

30 September 2021

Accepted

26 October 2021

Published

25 November 2021

Volume

8 - 2021

Edited and reviewed by

Yngvar Olsen, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Norway

Updates

Copyright

*Correspondence: Daniel Pauly

This article was submitted to Marine Fisheries, Aquaculture and Living Resources, a section of the journal Frontiers in Marine Science

Disclaimer

All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.

Outline

Cite article

Copy to clipboard


Export citation file


Share article

Article metrics