East Asia includes some of the countries with the highest domestic fisheries catch in the world, notably China and Japan. The status of their fisheries matters to the world because these countries also deploy huge fishing fleets into the high seas and the Exclusive Economic Zones of other countries, tasked with compensating for stagnating or even declining local fisheries resources.
Rebuilding East Asian fishery resources is a challenge, however, because their status is often unknown. This situation is due, at least in part, to the fact that time series of data suitable for analysis requiring sophisticated, but data-demanding methods, being scarce or not available in the region.
This dissatisfying state of affairs is now gradually being overcome, notably through the development, by Froese et al. (, ), of stock assessment methods that require less data, but still produce results that are reliable results enough to inform fisheries management.
These approaches consist of:
(1) the āCMSY/BSMā method (Froese et al., ), which relies essentially on time-series of catchesāpreferably spanning two decades or moreāand ancillary data to estimate time series of abundance or ābiomassā for the assessed populations or āstocksā;
(2) the āLBB' method (Froese et al., ), which uses length-frequency samples, i.e., multiple measurements of fish lengths, to infer the status of a fish populations or stocks, and
(3) A reconceptualization of classical yield-per-recruit (Y/R) analysis (Beverton and Holt, ) such that can provide estimates of the ratio of current to unexploited biomass.
These methods were introduced to Chinese scientists via a highly successful training course held in Qingdao during June 16ā20, 2019. The course was taught by the authors and Dr. M.L. Deng Palomares, with Dr. Rainer Froese participating remotely.
During the course, multiple stock assessments were run which eventually evolved into the bulk of the articles presented here. A few articles that were written previously and/or independently of the course are also included.
Altogether, 161 East Asian marine stocks were assessed, of which 132 pertained to finfishes and 29 to invertebrates, especially squids. Of these, 83 stocks were exploited along the coast of the Chinese Mainland (Liang, Xian, Pauly et al.; Liang, Xian, Liu et al.; Wang, Wang, Liu et al.; Wang X. et al.; Zhai and Pauly(a); Zhai et al.; Zhang L. et al.), 22 from around Taiwan (Ju, Chen et al.; Ju, Tian et al.; Liang Xian, Liu et al.), 50 around Japan (Liang, Xian, Liu et al.; Ren and Liu; Wang, Wang, Liang et al.; Wang, Liang et al.; Zhang S. et al.) and 6 around South Korea (Liang, Xian, Liu et al.).
As is the case for all stock assessment methods, the CMSY/BSM and LBB methods rely on reliable input data, i.e., catch (and catch-per-unit-effort) time series for CMSY/BSM and length-frequency data for LBB. Problematic inputs, and unrealistic constraints (āpriorsā) will lead to biased parameter estimates, and a few of the 161 estimates presented here will be biased up- or downward. However, there is no reason to assume a systematic bias.
Overall, these assessments jointly represent the most comprehensive evaluation of the Status of Marine Fisheries in East Asia, and they paint a very sobering picture. Thus, if one gives each stock a similar weight, one can compute from these assessments, for each region, the average biomass (or fish resource abundance) currently remaining as a percentage of its inferred biomass or abundance in the absence of fishing.
These mean percentages are 25% for the Chinese Mainland, 16% for Taiwan, 30% for Japan and 26% for South Korea; all of these averages are well below 50%, the level the classical stock assessment model of Schaefer (, ) requires for Maximum Sustainable Yield to be generated (Pauly and Froese, ). The regional means were derived from several ratio estimates that were higher, i.e., there are stocks in East Asia that are not overfished. However, there were far more stocks that had extremely low values of current to unfished biomass, with the result that the mean ratio for East Asia was 25%.
That overfishing is prevalent in East Asia was previously known (Srinivasan et al., ; Li et al., ). However, most of these assessments include estimates of the parameters also required to compute the time needed for overfished stocks to recover, given a reduction of fishing pressure (see Demirel et al., ). Thus, this makes it possible for fisheries scientists in East Asia to straightforwardly compute fishing quotas allowing for increasing stock sizes by a factor of two in the average, but which would allow for the social cost of a reduction of fishing effort to be smaller than the benefits gained from abundant stocks embedded in functioning ecosystems.
Indeed, at least for the Chinese Mainland, Zhai and Pauly(b) found, based on the conversion of 19 food web models into particle-size distribution spectra, that the functioning of coastal marine ecosystem of East Asia are gradually eroded due to the fisheries-induced disappearance of large fish species and miniaturization of the remaining species.
Thus, rebuilding stocks in East Asia would not only benefit fisheries economically, in terms of their catches, but also re-establish the functioning, rich marine ecosystems that enable fisheries to flourish in the longer term.
äøäŗå°åŗęøäøē¶åµ
äøäŗå ę¬äøäŗäøēäøå½å ęøäøęęéęé«ēå½å®¶, ē¹å«ęÆäøå½åę„ę¬ć为弄蔄å½å åę»ēč³č”°éēęøäøčµęŗ, äøäŗå½å®¶ä¼åå ¬ęµ·åå ¶ä»å½å®¶ēäøå±ē»ęµåŗę“¾åŗåŗå¤§ēęęč¹é, å ę¤, å®ä»¬ēęøäøē¶åµå¤åäøēå ³ę³Øć
é建äøäŗęøäøčµęŗé¢å ·ęę, å äøŗå ¶čµęŗē¶ęå¾å¾ęÆęŖē„ēćé ęčæē§ę åµēéØååå åØäŗ, å¤ęēčµęŗčÆä¼°ę¹ę³éč¦å¤§éēę¶é“åŗåę°ę®, ččæē§ę°ę®åØäøäŗå°åŗéåøøå¾å°č§ęäøååØć
ē®å, éčæå¾·å½ęøäøå¦å®¶Rainer Froeseåå ¶åäŗå¼åēå ē§ę°ę®ē¼ŗä¹ę”ä»¶äøēęøäøē§ē¾¤čÆä¼°ę¹ę³, čæē§ē¶åµę£éęøč¢«ę¹åćčæäŗę¹ę³éč¦č¾å°ēęøäøę°ę®ä½äøŗč¾å „, ä½ä»č½äŗ§ēč¾äøŗåÆé ēē»ęę„äøŗęøäøē®”ēęä¾åčć
čæäŗę¹ę³å ę¬:
(1) āCMSY/BSMāę¹ę³ (Froese et al., ), å®äø»č¦ä¾čµäŗęøč·éēę¶é“åŗåļ¼ę¶é“č·Øåŗ¦ęå„½č¶ čæäŗå幓ļ¼ä»„åč¾ å©ę°ę®ę„估讔被čÆä¼°ē§ē¾¤ę群ä½ēäø°åŗ¦ęēē©éć
(2) āLBBāę¹ę³ (Froese et al., ), 评ę¹ę³ä½æēØęµéå¾å°ēä½éæé¢ēę°ę®, ę„ęØęęøäøē§ē¾¤ę群ä½ēē¶ęć
(3) 对ē»å øēåä½č”„å éęøč·éåę (Beverton and Holt, ) čæč”ę¦åæµé建, 仄估讔å½åēē©éäøęŖå¼åēē©éēęÆå¼ ć
čæäŗę¹ę³éčæ2019 幓 6 ę 18ā20 ę„åØéå²äø¾åēå¹č®čƾēØč¢«ä»ē»ē»ę„čŖå¤ęé«ę ”åē§ē é¢ęēäøå½ęøäøå¦č ć评课ēØäø»č¦ē±Maria Lourdes D. Palomareså士åDaniel Paulyå士ęę, Rainer Froese å士čæēØåäøćåØå¹č®čƾēØęé“, äøčæ°ę¹ę³č¢«ēØäŗäøäŗå°åŗä¼å¤ęøäøē§ē¾¤ę群ä½ēčµęŗčÆä¼°, å¹¶ęē»å½¢ęäŗę¬éåē大éØåęē« ćéåäøå¦ęéØåęē« ē¬ē«äŗę¬ę¬”å¹č®čƾēØ, ä¹åØåęčæč”äŗå¢č”„ć
ę¬éåå ±åÆ¹161äøŖäøäŗęµ·ę“ē§ē¾¤čæč”äŗčÆä¼°, å ę¬132ē§é±¼ē±»,29ē§ę čę¤åØē©ćåØčæäŗč¢«čÆä¼°ēē§ē¾¤äø, ę83äøŖē§ē¾¤äø»č¦åØäøå½å¤§é沿海被å¼å (Liang, Xian, Pauly et al.; Liang, Xian, Liu et al.; Wang, Wang, Liu et al.; Zhai and Pauly (a); Zhai et al.; Zhang L. et al.),22äøŖē§ē¾¤äø»č¦č¢«å°ę¹¾å°åŗå¼å (Ju, Chen et al.; Ju, Xian et al.; Liang, Liu et al.), ååøäŗę„ę¬ęµ·åēē§ē¾¤50äøŖ (Liang, Xian, Liu et al.; Ren and Liu; Wang, Wang, Liang et al.; Wang, Liang et al.; Zhang S. et al.), é©å½ęµ·å6äøŖ (Liang, Xian, Liu et al.)ć
äøęęē§ē¾¤čÆä¼°ę¹ę³ēę åµäø ę ·, CMSY/BSM å LBB ę¹ę³ä¾čµäŗåÆé ēč¾å „ę°ę®, å³ CMSY/BSMēęøč·éļ¼ååä½åŖåéęøč·éļ¼ę¶é“åŗåå LBB ēä½éæé¢ēę°ę®ćåēēč¾å „ę°ę®åēŗ¦ęę”ä»¶ļ¼āāå éŖå¼āļ¼å°åƼč“åę°ä¼°č®”åŗē°åå·®ćåØčæ161äøŖčÆä¼°ē§ē¾¤äø, ä¼ęéØåē§ē¾¤ēčÆä¼°ē»ęå č¾å „ę°ę®ē蓨éé®é¢č¢«é«ä¼°ęä½ä¼°, ä½ē®åēē ē©¶ęŖåē°ē³»ē»ę§čÆÆå·®ēååØć
ę»ä½ččØ, ę¬éåäøēęē« å ±åē»ęäŗē®å对äøäŗęµ·ę“ęøäøē¶åµęå Øé¢ēčÆä¼°ćå¦ęē»ęÆäøŖčÆä¼°ē§ē¾¤äøäøŖēøåēęé, åÆä»„ä»čæäŗčÆä¼°ē»ęäøč®”ē®åŗęÆäøŖåŗåå½åå©ä½ēē©éļ¼ęčµęŗäø°åŗ¦ļ¼äøęŖå¼åēē©éļ¼ęäø°åŗ¦ļ¼ęÆå¼ēå¹³åå¼ćäøå½å¤§éēå¹³åē¾åęÆäøŗ 25%, å°ę¹¾äøŗ 16%, ę„ę¬äøŗ 30%, é©å½äøŗ 26%ćęęčæäŗå¹³åå¼é½čæä½äŗ 50%, å³ Schaefer (, ) ēē»å øčµęŗčÆä¼°ęØ”åč¦ę±ēęę大åÆęē»äŗ§éēę°“å¹³ (Pauly and Froese, )ćč½ē¶čÆä¼°ē»ęę¾ē¤ŗäøäŗåŗåęå°ęŖčæåŗ¦ęęēē§ē¾¤, ä½ē±äŗååØå¤§éå©ä½ēē©éäøęŖå¼åēē©éęÆå¼ęä½ēē§ē¾¤, å ę¤äøäŗåŗå评ęÆå¼ę“ä½äøŗ25%å·¦å³ć
尽箔äøäŗå°åŗę®éååØčæåŗ¦ęęē°č±”ę©å·²č¢«ēē„ (Srinivasan et al., ; Li et al., ), ę¬éåäøēē»ęčæęä¾äŗę°ēäæ”ęÆ, ä¾å¦åØęęååéä½ę åµäø, ēØäŗč®”ē®čæåŗ¦ęęē§ē¾¤ę¢å¤ę¶é“ęéč¦ēåę°ēä¼°č®”å¼ (Demirel et al., ) ćčæä½æå¾äøäŗēęøäøå¦å®¶åÆä»„č®”ē®ē§å¦ēęęé é¢, ä»č使ē§ē¾¤ę°éå¹³åå¢å äø¤å, å¢å ēē§ē¾¤ę°éåø¦ę„ēę¶ēå°č¶ čæåå°ęęåå导č“ē社ä¼ęę¬ę失ć
äŗå®äø, åØå°19 äøŖé£ē©ē½ęØ”å转ę¢ęē²åŗ¦ååøč°±ä¹å, Zhai and Pauly(b) åē°, 仄äøå½å¤§éå°åŗäøŗä»£č”Øēäøäŗę²æęµ·ęµ·ę“ēęē³»ē»ēåč½ę£åØéęøč¢«ä¾µč, ęøäøę“»åØå¼čµ·ē大å鱼类ē©ē§ēę¶å¤±åå©ä½ē©ē§ēå°ååęÆé ęčæē§ē°č±”ēäø»č¦åå ćå ę¤, é建äøäŗē§ē¾¤äøä» ä¼åØęøč·éę¹é¢äøŗęøäøåø¦ę„ē»ęµå©ē, čäøčæå°é建åč½å„å Øćē©ē§äø°åÆēęµ·ę“ēęē³»ē», 使ęøäøč½å¤éæęē¹č£åå±ć
Publisher's Note
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.
Statements
Author contributions
All authors listed have made a substantial, direct, and intellectual contribution to the work and approved it for publication.
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
References
1
BevertonR. J. H.HoltS. J. (1957). On the dynamics of exploited fish populations. Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food. London: Fishery Investigations.
2
DemirelN.ZenginM.UlmanA. (2020). First large-scale Eastern Mediterranean and Black Sea stock assessment reveals a dramatic decline. Front. Mar. Sci.7:103. 10.3389/fmars.2020.00103
3
FroeseR.DemirelN.CoroG.KleisnerK. M.WinkerH. (2017). Estimating fisheries reference points from catch and resilience. Fish. Fish.18, 506ā526. 10.1111/faf.12190
4
FroeseR.WinkerH.CoroG.DemirelN.TsiklirasA. C.DimarchopoulouD.et al. (2018). A new approach for estimating stock status from length-frequency data. ICES J. Mar. Sci.75, 2004ā2015. 10.1093/icesjms/fsy078
5
LiJ.CaoK.DingF.YangW.ShenG.LiY. (2017). Changes in trophic-level structure of the main fish species caught by China and their relationship with fishing method. J. Fish. Sci. China24, 109ā119. 10.3724/SP.J.1118.2017.16164
6
PaulyD.FroeseR. (2020). MSY needs no epitaph- but it was abused. ICES J. Mar. Sci.78, 2204ā2210. 10.1093/icesjms/fsaa224
7
SchaeferM. B. (1954). Some aspects of the dynamics of populations important to the management of the commercial marine fisheries. Inter Am. Trop. Tuna Comm. Bull.1, 23ā56.
8
SchaeferM. B. (1957). A study of the dynamics of the fishery for yellowfin tuna in the eastern tropical Pacific Ocean. Inter Am. Trop. Tuna Comm. Bull.2, 243ā285.
9
SrinivasanU. T.WatsonR.SumailaU. R. (2012). Global fisheries losses at the exclusive economic zone level, 1950 to present. Mar. Policy36, 544ā549. 10.1016/j.marpol.2011.10.001
Summary
Keywords
stock assessments, catch time-series, length frequency data, China, Korea, Japan
Citation
Pauly D, Liang C and Xian W (2021) Editorial: The Status of Marine Fisheries in East Asia. Front. Mar. Sci. 8:787217. doi: 10.3389/fmars.2021.787217
Received
30 September 2021
Accepted
26 October 2021
Published
25 November 2021
Volume
8 - 2021
Edited and reviewed by
Yngvar Olsen, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Norway
Updates
Copyright
Ā© 2021 Pauly, Liang and Xian.
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
*Correspondence: Daniel Pauly d.pauly@oceans.ubc.ca
This article was submitted to Marine Fisheries, Aquaculture and Living Resources, a section of the journal Frontiers in Marine Science
Disclaimer
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.