The Response of Phagocytes to Indoor Air Toxicity
- Department of Biochemistry, University of Turku, Turku, Finland
This perspective presents a viewpoint on potential methods assessing toxicity of indoor air. Until recently, the major techniques to document moldy environment have been microbial isolation using conventional culture techniques for fungi and bacteria as well as in some instances polymerase chain reaction to detect microbial genetic components. However, it has become increasingly evident that bacterial and fungal toxins, their metabolic products, and volatile organic substances emitted from corrupted constructions are the major health risks. Here, we illustrate how phagocytes, especially neutrophils can be used as a toxicological probe. Neutrophils can be used either in vitro as probe cells, directly exposed to the toxic agent studied, or they can act as in vivo indicators of the whole biological system exposed to the agent. There are two convenient methods assessing the responses, one is to measure chemiluminescence emission from activated phagocytes and the other is to measure quantitatively by flow cytometry the expression of complement and immunoglobulin receptors on the phagocyte surface.
Indoor air problem is a tremendous health hazard, especially when a living building or working place is infested with toxic molds (1). Although microbial communities on surfaces do not directly correlate with the health trouble of the occupants, in many countries conventional techniques to document moldy environment due to dampness has been traditionally based on culture techniques using conventional isolation media and quantitation of colony forming units per, e.g., cubic meter (2). However, well-designed and well-conducted international so-called health effects of indoor pollutants: integrating microbial, toxicological, and epidemiological approaches studies proved that quantities of molds per se were not as good health correlates as the level of microbial markers (3–5). Indeed, the toxicity of molds and other toxic compounds emitted from damaged surfaces had a detrimental health effect as unambiguously shown in teaches in mold-infected schools (6). Therefore, it is imperative to adopt new thinking to search and exploit novel methods that will be robust enough, inexpensive, and reliable to be implemented into routine. Indoor air toxicity detection instead of colony detection is the future of environmental research.
Mycotoxins are usually analyzed with mass-spectrometry-based techniques that are coupled with pre-separation by a gas or liquid chromatography. These methods allow for the highly sensitive and accurate determination of tested samples. They are, however, expensive and time-consuming, taking from days up to weeks to obtain the results, and still providing only the detection of a single compound or a group of structurally related compounds at any given time (7). Moreover, the conventional methods do not take into account the possible synergistic effects of the mycotoxins and other microbial structure components as well as toxic compounds emitted from damaged surfaces which may enhance the toxicity. New technologies are becoming available that may enable the better assessing of the total toxicity. We have developed a test system which assesses rapidly and cost-efficiently the total indoor air toxicity using the Escherichia coli-lux method (8). While correlating well with the building-related symptoms of users, this assay can be criticized for using prokaryotic cells as probes. Below, we present ideas and directions of research based on mammalian neutrophils that could be exploited as probe cells for toxicity studies.
Principles of Phagocyte Activation
The process of phagocytosis is recently reviewed by Gordon (9). The generation and measurement of phagocyte chemiluminiscence (CL) are thoroughly described by Lilius and Marnila (10). Briefly, the activation of phagocytes produce electronically excited states, which on relaxation to the ground state emit photons, referred to as phagocyte CL. The commonly used activators include various opsonized or unopsonized particles and immune complexes. “In the opsonization process particles attach to complement compounds and immunoglobulins. Opsonized antigens are recognized partly by the complement receptor CR3, partly by the complement receptor CR1, and partly by FcγRII and FcγRIII receptors, which bind to the Fc portion of the IgG molecules attached to antigens.
Phagocytic cells are generally isolated from blood treated with anticoagulants. Leukocytes obtained after erythrocyte sedimentation are normally sufficient without further separation. Phagocytic cell activities can also be measured in the ex vivo state simply by diluting the whole blood enough to get rid of the inhibitory amounts of plasma and red cells. The ex vivo cells are, however, not necessarily in the same functional state as the cells after isolation steps where activation processes may take place. Luminol amplifies the CL emission by the factor of 103–104 and it has been shown to be oxidized in the myeloperoxidase reaction. When using luminol in the millimolar range, one needs less than a thousand phagocytic cells (as in the case in whole blood tests) to get reliable signals. The number of isolated cells used in routine tests varies, generally around 105. Hank’s balanced salt solution (HBSS) is the most frequently used buffer. Luminometers with strict temperature controls, multiple sample capabilities (up to 96 in microtiter plate readers) and computerized data processing are the instruments of choice” (10).
Measurement of In Vitro Toxicity
Routinely, in vitro toxicity testing was made as luminol-amplified CL assay by adding 25 µl of opsonized zymosan suspension (20 mg/ml) in HBSS buffer supplemented with gelatin (1 mg/ml) (gHBSS), 20 µl of luminol (10 mM in borate buffer, pH 9.0), and 100 µl of leukocyte suspension (varying number of neutrophils depending on the isolation method) to the wells of a white 96-well microtiter plate. Finally, toxic samples in various concentrations were added. The final reaction volume was 200 µl.
The CL signals of the microtiter plate wells were continuously recorded 0.5 s/well for 200 min in Hidex Sense multimode reader (Hidex Ltd., Turku, Finland) at 37 C. Three parallel wells were prepared from every reaction mixture. The background signal was measured from a well containing only the buffer and this reading was subtracted from the readings of the experimental wells. Figure 1 illustrates the principles of this technique.
Figure 1. Effect of T-2 toxin on neutrophil chemiluminescence was induced by opsonized zymosan. The reaction mixture contained 25 µl of opsonized zymosan suspension (20 mg/ml) in Hank’s balanced salt solution buffer supplemented with gelatin (1 mg/ml), 20 µl of luminol (10 mM in borate buffer, pH 9.0), and 100 µl of neutrophil suspension (50,000 cells). Finally, toxic samples in various concentrations were added. The final reaction volume was 200 µl. T-2 toxin: 0 µg/ml (□), 0.01 µg/ml (○), 0.1 µg/ml (▵), 1 µg/ml (▿), 10 µg/ml (◊), 100 µg/ml (◃), 1,000 µg/ml (▹). (A) The kinetic curves of the chemiluminiscence (CL) emission of neutrophils. (B) Inhibition of the peak CL emission of neutrophils by the T-2 toxin. (A) A strong luminol-amplified CL signal peaking at about 30 min was detected when opsonized zymosan was added to the reaction mixture containing 5 × 104 neutrophils. When, in addition to opsonized zymosan, also toxic samples were added the CL signal was dose-dependently reduced. EC50 value was determined from the dose curve where the CL signal was reduced 50%. T-2 toxin from Fusarium species appeared to have an EC50 value of 30 µg/ml calculated from peak CL values (B). EC50 is the concentration of a toxin that kills 50% of the bacterial cells. CPS is counts per second registered by the luminometer.
The other tested mycotoxins deoxyvalenol, moniliformin, antimycin A, and chloramphenicol had EC50 values ranging from 20 µg/ml to a few hundreds of micrograms per milliliter. The same mycotoxins gave similar or roughly 10-fold lower EC50 values in our E. coli-lux toxicity test (8). It should be noted that cytochalasin D was very weakly toxic in E. coli-lux toxicity test while chloramphenicol, being very toxic in E. coli-lux toxicity test, was weakly toxic in the neutrophil toxicity test. A dust sample (11) from a moisture-damaged object had EC50 values of 72 and 15 µg/ml in neutrophil toxicity test and E. coli-lux toxicity test, respectively.
By careful choosing the reaction conditions, one is able to differentiate between the binding and ingestion phases of phagocytosis in CL measurements. In these experiments, the ingestion of zymosan by neutrophils was measured flow-cytometrically as described by Nuutila and Lilius (12). Cytochalasin D inhibited the ingestion of opsonized (0.5% serum) and non-opsonized zymosan dose-dependently. The CL response induced by 25 µg zymosan consisted of two peaks with peak times of about 10 and 90 min, and 10 and 65 min in the absence and the presence of serum (0.5%), respectively. The second peak in the CL response is clearly the ingestion peak since cytochalasin D gradually inhibited it. The first peak is then the adhesion peak, which increases with increasing the concentration of cytochalasin D. The ingestion is dependent on the cytoskeleton and thus on ATP produced by mitochondria. We anticipate that well-known fungal and bacterial toxins affecting mitochondria such as antimycin A (13) reduce the ingestion phase but not the binding phase of phagocytes being expressed as a decrease of the second peak of the CL response.
Quantitation of Fungal Spore Antibodies
Fungal and bacterial spores are one of the main predisposal elements in contaminated indoor air (14–17). The virulence of many pathogens relates in part to their ability to evade phagocytosis by the virtue of certain surface antigens. The function of serum antibodies is to react with these antigens and make the microorganisms more susceptible to ingestion by neutrophils. When serum is incubated with spores, and if specific antibodies are present, the spores are rapidly and efficiently opsonized and phagocytosed by neutrophils. Thus, when this reaction is measured as a CL emission the exposure of an individual to spores is manifested as an elevated CL peak compared with the non-exposed controls. This CL emission correlates with the level of antibodies. The system is functional with both isolated cells and with the whole blood dilutions in both heterologous and autologous systems (18).
The spore assay was operated as described in the section “The measurement of in vitro toxicity” but instead of opsonized zymosan, test serum (1%) and intact spores (~1010) were added. Streptomyces albus spores were cultured and harvested from the mannitol salt agar and Aspergillus versicolor spores from malt agar by scraping and by diluting them into the distilled water. This suspension was then sonicated. Spores were isolated by filtration trough the cotton wool and re-suspended in 20% glycerol (19). When S. albus or/and A. versicolor spores and test serums were introduced to neutrophils the CL emission was significantly higher in individuals exposed to these microbes in damaged buildings (data not shown).
The autologous system utilizing neutrophils from the fingertip whole blood enables the development of in situ quick test systems to be operated with a portable luminometer.
By comparison, spore specific IgG and IgM antibody titers were assayed using enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay with intact spores as antigens (16, 20). Spores were fixed to the solid face of the microtiter wells, incubated with the test serum, and then with the anti-human immunoglobulin tagged with enzyme horseradish peroxidase. The enzyme activity from the solid phase was related to the bound antibody.
Serum samples of the exposed individuals from the microbe damaged buildings expressed elevated serum spore specific IgG and IgM antibody titers but IgM was in better correlation with the increased CL response from the same test serums.
It is noteworthy that according to literature (20) and our study the fungal and bacterial spore antigens may share common structures since there is substantial cross-reactivity in antibody responses regardless of the origin of the spore. If this is true, a single test antigen instead of panels containing multiple microbe antigens can be used.
Estimation of Toxicity In Vivo
We are aiming to collect human blood samples of the users of moisture-damaged buildings for establishing a biomonitoring assay for the toxic effects on exposed users. This assay is based on the measurement of the capability of phagocytes to emit photons when stimulated with opsonized zymosan. This has been shown to reflect remarkably well the pathophysiological state of the host. In many cases even the magnitude of the stress, the presence of pathogen in the body, or the activity of the disease can be estimated (10). Therefore, we believe that neutrophils can be utilized as a toxicological probe acting as an indicator of the whole biological system exposed to the agent. Here we show that the concept is indeed valid with test animals. How it will work with humans remains to be elucidated later.
Previous studies have shown that moniliformin is acutely toxic to rats with an LD50 cut-off value of 25 mg/kg bw (21). Here are the results of a subacute oral toxicity study. Rats were daily exposed to moniliformin of low doses from 0 to 15 mg/kg bw for 28 days. Two satellite groups were kept alive for an additional 14 days without treatment to detect possible delayed effects and to follow up recovery. The neutrophil CL measurements revealed the toxic effect of moniliformin on the rat innate immunity.
The phagocytic activity of the rat neutrophils was dramatically reduced in all dose groups and did not recover. “Even the lowest dose (3 mg/kg bw) caused a substantial decrease in the neutrophil activity reducing the final activity by 70% of the initial activity. Moreover, the decrease in neutrophil activity continued in the satellite groups subsequent to the cessation of moniliformin exposure, with a mean activity of 28 ± 18% in the final samples, compared with the negative control group. Also the neutrophil activity of the final samples of the negative control group was reduced by 29% from the initial samples. The reduction in the control group was most likely derived from stress caused by housing in metabolic cages, handling, blood collection, and daily i.g. administration of the vehicle by gavage. In spite of the reduced phagocytic activity of neutrophils, the number of neutrophils and total leukocyte counts in the blood samples of the dosed rats remained normal, suggesting that moniliformin has a functional effect on myeloid cells, rather than a lymphoid one. Additionally, the lymphoid organ weights (thymus, spleen) were unaffected, excluding dystrophic, and dysplastic effects.” (21).
Algorithms of Expression of Different Surface Receptors on Phagocytes
Do the infectious and other inflammatory diseases or exposure to indoor air pollutants induce alterations in the expression of the opsonin receptors of phagocytes?
Receptor expression measurements are described in Ref. (22). Briefly, erythrocytes were lysed and leukocytes were separated by centrifugation. Leukocytes (3 × 105) were incubated in 50 µl of gHBSS with receptor-specific monoclonal antibodies (0.4 µg) for 30 min at +4 C. A relative measure of receptor expression was obtained by determining the mean fluorescence intensity of 5,000 leukocytes. In the case of neutrophil FcγRI, the percentage of fluorescence positive cells (%) was also determined. Measurement of leukocyte receptor expression was performed using fluorescently (FITC or PE) labeled receptor-specific monoclonal antibodies.
We have performed a few studies where we have measured the receptor expression in various patient groups (23–26). The summary of the results of these studies is presented in Table 1. In monocytes, all the receptors were upregulated in bacterial and viral infections. In neutrophils, CR1, CR3, FcγRI, and FcγRII were upregulated, while FcγRIII was downregulated in bacterial infections. CR1 and FcγRII were downregulated, while CR3 and FcγRI were upregulated in viral infections. These results led us to conclude that the receptor expression could be used as a basis for the differential diagnosis of bacterial and viral infections (22). Whether the exposure to molds causes a specific pattern in opsonin receptor expression will be studied in a near future if resources are available.
This perspective highlights potential of neutrophils as a toxicological tool for studies of indoor air toxicity. Neutrophils are mammalian cells, therefore any toxicity imposed on them can be easily to extrapolated on the whole human body. They can be used either as probe cells, directly exposed to samples collected from damaged buildings or they can act as indicators of toxic effects on humans exposed to the toxic compounds of damaged buildings. The future shows whether the receptor expression measurements from leukocytes bring additional evidence for the indoor air toxicity assessments.
Part of this study is presented in the Indoor Air 2016 Conference in Ghent, Belgium, July 3–8, 2016 (27).
E-ML: project manager, planning the research/laboratory tests, analyzing the data. JA: execution and planning of the laboratory experiments, analyzing the data. LV: execution and planning of the laboratory experiments, analyzing the data.
Conflict of Interest Statement
The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
The Finnish Work Environment Fund (TSR 116050) funded the project.
2. Verdier T, Coutand M, Bertron A, Roques C. A review of indoor microbial growth across building materials and sampling and analysis methods. Build Environ (2014) 80:136–49. doi:10.1016/j.buildenv.2014.05.030
3. Huttunen K, Tirkkonen J, Täubel M, Krop E, Mikkonen S, Pekkanen J, et al. Inflammatory potential in relation to the microbial content of settled dust samples collected from moisture-damaged and reference schools: results of HITEA study. Indoor Air (2016) 26:380–90. doi:10.1111/ina.12223
4. Jacobs J, Borràs-Santos A, Krop E, Täubel M, Leppänen H, Haverinen-Shaughnessy U, et al. Dampness, bacterial and fungal components in dust in primary schools and respiratory health in schoolchildren across Europe. Occup Environ Med (2014) 71:704–12. doi:10.1136/oemed-2014-102246
5. Borràs-Santos A, Jacobs JH, Täubel M, Haverinen-Shaughnessy U, Krop EJ, Huttunen K, et al. Dampness and mould in schools and respiratory symptoms in children: the HITEA study. Occup Environ Med (2013) 70:681–7. doi:10.1136/oemed-2012-101286
6. Salin JT, Salkinoja-Salonen M, Salin PJ, Nelo K, Holma T, Ohtonen P, et al. Building-related symptoms are linked to the in vitro toxicity of indoor dust and airborne microbial propagules in schools: a cross-sectional study. Environ Res (2017) 154:234–9. doi:10.1016/j.envres.2017.01.015
12. Nuutila J, Lilius EM. Flow cytometric quantitative determination of ingestion by phagocytes needs the distinguishing of overlapping populations of binding and ingesting cells. Cytometry A (2005) 65:93–102.
14. Kildeso J, Wurtz H, Nielsen KF, Kruse P, Wilkins K, Thrane U, et al. Determination of fungal spore release from wet building materials. Indoor Air (2003) 13:148–55. doi:10.1034/j.1600-0668.2003.00172.x
15. Haverinen-Shaughnessy U, Hyvarinen A, Putus T, Nevalainen A. Monitoring success of remediation: seven case studies of moisture and mold damaged buildings. Sci Total Environ (2008) 1-3:19–27. doi:10.1016/j.scitotenv.2008.03.033
16. Schmechel D, Simpson JP, Beezhold D, Lewis DM. The development of species-specific immunodiagnostics for Stachybotrys chartarum: the role of cross-reactivity. J Immunol Methods (2006) 309:150–9. doi:10.1016/j.jim.2005.12.001
17. Andersen B, Nielsen KF, Thrane U, Szaro T, Taylor JW, Jarvis BB. Molecular and phenotypic descriptions of Stachybotrys chlorohalonata sp. nov. and two chemotypes of Stachybotrys chartarum found in water-damaged buildings. Mycologia (2003) 6:1227–38. doi:10.1080/15572536.2004.11833031
18. Lilius EM, Nuutila JT. Particle-induced myeloperoxidase release in serially diluted whole blood quantifies the number and the phagocytic activity of blood neutrophils and opsonization capacity of plasma. Luminescence (2006) 21:148–58. doi:10.1002/bio.899
20. Jaakkola MS, Laitinen S, Piipari R, Uitti J, Nordman H, Haapala AM, et al. Immunoglobulin G antibodies against indoor dampness-related microbes and adult-onset asthma: a population-based incident case-control study. Clin Exp Immunol (2002) 129:107–12. doi:10.1046/j.1365-2249.2002.01884.x
21. Jonsson M, Atosuo J, Jestoi M, Nathanail AV, Kokkonen UM, Anttila M, et al. Repeated dose 28-day oral toxicity study of moniliformin in rats. Toxicol Lett (2014) 233:38–44. doi:10.1016/j.toxlet.2014.11.006
22. Lilius EM, Nuutila J. Bacterial infections, DNA virus infections, and RNA virus infections manifest differently in neutrophil receptor expression. ScientificWorldJournal (2012) 2012:527347. doi:10.1100/2012/527347
23. Leino L, Sorvajärvi K, Katajisto J, Laine M, Lilius EM, Pelliniemi TT, et al. Febrile infection changes the expression of IgG Fc receptors and complement receptors in human neutrophils in vivo. Clin Exp Immunol (1997) 107:37–43. doi:10.1046/j.1365-2249.1997.d01-899.x
24. Isolauri E, Pelto L, Nuutila J, Majamaa H, Lilius EM, Salminen S. Altered expression of IgG and complement receptors indicates a significant role of phagocytes in atopic dermatitis. J Allergy Clin Immunol (1997) 99:707–13. doi:10.1016/S0091-6749(97)70034-4
25. Hohenthal U, Nuutila J, Lilius EM, Laitinen I, Nikoskelainen J, Kotilainen P. Measurement of complement receptor 1 on neutrophils in bacterial and viral pneumonia. BMC Infect Dis (2006) 6:11. doi:10.1186/1471-2334-6-11
26. Salminen E, Kankuri M, Nuutila J, Lilius EM, Pellimiemi TT. Modulation of IgG and complement receptor expression of phagocytes in kidney cancer patients during treatment with interferon-alpha. Anticancer Res (2001) 21:2049–55.
Keywords: neutrophils response, mold, indoor air pollution, toxicity tests, immuno response
Citation: Vilén LK, Atosuo J and Lilius E-M (2017) The Response of Phagocytes to Indoor Air Toxicity. Front. Immunol. 8:887. doi: 10.3389/fimmu.2017.00887
Received: 20 January 2017; Accepted: 11 July 2017;
Published: 28 July 2017
Edited by:Tamara Tuuminen, University of Helsinki, Finland
Reviewed by:Arup Sarkar, Trident Academy of Creative Technology, India
Mario M. D’Elios, University of Florence, Italy
Copyright: © 2017 Vilén, Atosuo and Lilius. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) or licensor are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
*Correspondence: Esa-Matti Lilius, firstname.lastname@example.org