GENERAL COMMENTARY article
Sec. Animal Nutrition and Metabolism
Volume 10 - 2023 | https://doi.org/10.3389/fvets.2023.1227500
Commentary: Invited review: glucosinolates might result in low methane emissions from ruminants fed brassica forages
- School of Biosciences and Veterinary Medicine, University of Camerino, Matelica, Italy
by Sun, X. (2020) Front. Vet. Sci. 7:588051. doi: 10.3389/fvets.2020.588051
The present commentary aims to clarify some main physiological concepts and literature findings that may be subject to confusion arising from the invited review (1) (referred to as “TIR” hereafter), published in 2020 in this journal Frontiers in Veterinary Science.
The purpose of TIR was “to summarize literature reports on the use of brassica forage to mitigate CH4 emissions … and highlight the possible role of glucosinolates”. The articles quoted in TIR indicate that “ruminants fed forage brassica emit low methane”, and that “a shorter mean retention time of particulate and liquid digesta is associated with less CH4 yield”.
Then, the “Effects of Secondary Metabolites in Brassica Forages on Triiodothyronine” and “The effects of Free Triiodothyronine on Digesta Retention Time and on Methane Emissions” are reviewed.
Several concerns arise when TIR faces “Effects of Secondary Metabolites in Brassica Forages on Triiodothyronine”. The topic of Brassicas, glucosinolates (GLS), and thyroid function is challenging, and the related literature is really extensive. The present Commentary considers articles cited by TIR, and we believe that certain results from these articles have not been adequately considered, leading to an unsupported hypothesis.
First, TIR states that “S-methyl-L-cysteine sulfoxide can increase ghrelin and thyroid hormones in the plasma (12)”. However, in that cited review (2), it is stated that “kale feeding is associated with increased blood plasma concentrations of growth hormone and thyroxine” (not ghrelin and thyroid hormones). This sentence refers to previous experiments by the same author [(3, 4); the latter is not cited by TIR], comparing diets (kale vs. ryegrass-clover pasture) and iodine supplementation (with vs. without). In the presence of supplementary iodine (“to counteract the goitrogenic properties of the inorganic thiocyanate ion released on hydrolysis of GLS”), kale feeding was associated with an elevation in the plasma concentration of T4. When iodine supplementation compensated for the anti-thyroidal actions of GLS, S-methyl-L-cysteine sulfoxide (SMCO) was hypothesized to have a stimulatory effect on T4 increase. However, to the best of our knowledge, this hypothesis was not further investigated. It should be noted that T3 (triiodothyronine) remained unaffected by the diet. As stated in TIR, “it is unlikely that SMCO has an effect on blood FT3 concentration”. When growing lambs were fed kale without iodine supplementation, concentrations of both thyroid hormones (TH) dropped (less markedly for T3), as expected and reported (4).
Comparably, serum T4 concentrations decreased in lambs grazing Brassicas, which were restored by iodine supplementation (5). Again, serum T3 levels remained unaffected by the diets (5). Unfortunately, the citation of this latter article in TIR appears to be non-compliant, as it states that “For example, feeding turnip (Brassica rapa L.) and kale (B. oleracea L. var. acephala DC) to fattening lambs can increase the concentrations of T3 and T4 in serum (76)”.
Similar findings were observed in calves fed rapeseed–mustard cakes with high or low GLS contents (6): “T3 remained within the normal range”, while T4 decreased in a dose-dependent manner. Unfortunately, these results, reported in the original article as “thyroxine changed quadratically with increasing glucosinolate levels”, were reported in TIR as “quadratically increased serum T4 concentration”.
Goitrogenic effects of GSL, and therefore their ability to decrease T4 secretion by the gland and TH blood concentrations, are widely confirmed by the literature cited in TIR, involving pigs (7), mares (8), turkeys (9), and sheep (10, 11).
Among the references mentioned in TIR, only the abstract is available for (12), stating that “The sheep receiving GLS and nitrates without iodine and selenium supplementation developed enlargement of the thyroid gland, … low T4 level…, high T3 level and a narrow T3/T4 ratio”. The full text of (13), dealing with rats, is not available.
The thyroid gland primarily secretes T4, making blood T4 concentrations indicative of the synthesizing and secretory rates of the gland. On the other hand, T3 secretion by the thyroid gland is minimal, and the majority of circulating T3 is derived from the activation of T4 to T3 by deiodinase enzymes at the peripheral level. Therefore, circulating T3 concentrations reflect the rate of deiodinase activity, representing the balance between peripheral enzymes involved in activating and inactivating T4.
The data from articles cited by TIR are consistent with basic physiological knowledge regarding the effects of GLS and iodine on thyroid gland activity and TH blood concentrations. It has been well-established for decades that GLS derivatives inhibit TH synthesis and secretion, interfering with various steps of the process in a dose-dependent manner. The main effects involve the inhibition of the thyroperoxidase (TPO) enzyme, leading to the impairment of iodide uptake, oxidation, binding to thyroglobulin, and hormone secretion. Moreover, such goitrogenic compounds interfere with the deiodination of T4 in peripheral tissues. Many literature articles on various species have reported that iodine supplementation can at least partially restore physiological functions and parameters, including circulating TH, impaired by GLS intake.
Among mammals, ruminants are less sensitive to these effects than monogastric species due to greater degradation of the active compounds in the forestomach environment. Regarding the effects on blood TH concentrations and T3/T4 ratio, it is important to consider the quality and amounts of Brassica forages included in the diets (and iodine intake, as well). Recently, in dairy cows, no effect was found on T3 replacing 25% of DM with Brassicas (14), nor on T3 and T4 with 30 and 45% forage rape (15).
In conclusion, literature data are often contradictory and do not seem to support the hypotheses proposed in TIR (“GSLs and/or their breakdown products in brassica forage crops … increase blood FT3 concentration in ruminants”). Furthermore, the “Concluding remarks” (“GSL and its metabolites can elevate the concentration of FT3 in ruminants”) and the “Abstract” (“It is reported that feeding brassica forages to sheep can increase the concentration of free triiodothyronine (FT3) in serum. We hypothesize that GSLs or their breakdown products may stimulate the secretion of thyroid hormone FT3 in ruminants”) is not substantiated by the cited references. Finally, in Figure 4, the first step of the diagram appears to lack support from the references cited.
All authors listed have made a substantial, direct, and intellectual contribution to the work and approved it for publication.
Publication fees are granted by unspecified funds of LT (FAR/LT/BVI000023unicam).
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.
3. Barry TN, Duncan S, Sadler WA, Miller KR, Sheppard AD. Iodine metabolism and thyroid hormone relationships in growing sheep fed on Kale and ryegrass-clover fresh forage diets. Br J Nutr. (1983) 49:241–53. doi: 10.1079/BJN19830031
5. Cox-Ganser JM, Jung GA, Pushkin RT, Reid RL. Evaluation of Brassicas in grazing systems for sheep: II. Blood composition and nutrient status. J Anim Sci. (1994) 72:1832–41. doi: 10.2527/1994.7271832x
6. Ravichandiran S, Sharma K, Dutta N, Pattanaik AK, Chauhan JS, Agnihotri A. Comparative assessment of soybean meal with high and low glucosinolate rapeseed-mustard cake as protein supplement on performance of growing crossbred calves. J Sci Food Agric. (2008) 88:832–8. doi: 10.1002/jsfa.3159
7. Lee JW, Wang S, Huang Y, Seefeldt T, Donkor A, Logue BA, et al. Toxicity of canola-derived glucosinolates in pigs fed resistant starch-based diets. J Anim Sci. (2020) 98:skaa111. doi: 10.1093/jas/skaa111
8. Lopez-Rodriguez MF, Cymbaluk N, Epp T, Laarveld B, Serrano Recalde EC, Simko E, et al. Effects of the glucosinolate sinigrin in combination with a noniodine supplemented diet on serum iodine and thyroid hormone concentrations in nonpregnant mares. J Equine Vet Sci. (2020) 91:103110. doi: 10.1016/j.jevs.2020.103110
9. Mikulski D, Jankowski J, Zdunczyk Z, Juskiewicz J, Slominski BA. The effect of different dietary levels of rapeseed meal on growth performance, carcass traits, and meat quality in turkeys. Poult Sci. (2012) 91:215–23. doi: 10.3382/ps.2011-01587
13. Okulicz M, Bialik I, Chichłowska J. The influence of sinigrin on thyroid hormones level and lipid metabolism in rat. Med Vet. (2002) 1:113–9. Available online at: http://www.acta.media.pl/pl/full/5/2002/000050200200001000010011300119.pdf
14. Castillo-Uman M, Balocchi O, Pulido R, Sepúlveda-Varas P, Pacheco D, Muetzel S, et al. Milk production responses and rumen fermentation of dairy cows supplemented with summer brassicas. Animal. (2020) 14:1684–92. doi: 10.1017/S175173112000021X
15. Keim JP, Daza J, Beltrán I, Balocchi O, Pulido RG, Sepúlveda-Varas P, et al. Milk production responses, rumen fermentation, and blood metabolites of dairy cows fed increasing concentrations of forage rape (Brassica napus ssp. biennis). J Dairy Sci. (2020) 103:9054–66. doi: 10.3168/jds.2020-18785
Keywords: Digesta Retention Time, free triiodothyronine, greenhouse gas, physiological parameters, plant secondary compounds, rumen
Citation: Todini L and Fantuz F (2023) Commentary: Invited review: glucosinolates might result in low methane emissions from ruminants fed brassica forages. Front. Vet. Sci. 10:1227500. doi: 10.3389/fvets.2023.1227500
Received: 23 May 2023; Accepted: 18 September 2023;
Published: 06 October 2023.
Edited by:Nazir Ahmad Khan, University of Agriculture, Pakistan
Reviewed by:Juan Keim, Universidad Austral de Chile, Chile
Copyright © 2023 Todini and Fantuz. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
*Correspondence: Luca Todini, email@example.com
†These authors have contributed equally to this work and share first authorship