REVIEW article

Front. Cell Dev. Biol., 14 December 2020

Sec. Molecular and Cellular Pathology

Volume 8 - 2020 | https://doi.org/10.3389/fcell.2020.580634

The Convergence of Alpha-Synuclein, Mitochondrial, and Lysosomal Pathways in Vulnerability of Midbrain Dopaminergic Neurons in Parkinson’s Disease

  • Department of Neurology, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, IL, United States

Abstract

Parkinson’s disease (PD) is the second most common neurodegenerative disease, characterized by progressive bradykinesia, rigidity, resting tremor, and gait impairment, as well as a spectrum of non-motor symptoms including autonomic and cognitive dysfunction. The cardinal motor symptoms of PD stem from the loss of substantia nigra (SN) dopaminergic (DAergic) neurons, and it remains unclear why SN DAergic neurons are preferentially lost in PD. However, recent identification of several genetic PD forms suggests that mitochondrial and lysosomal dysfunctions play important roles in the degeneration of midbrain dopamine (DA) neurons. In this review, we discuss the interplay of cell-autonomous mechanisms linked to DAergic neuron vulnerability and alpha-synuclein homeostasis. Emerging studies highlight a deleterious feedback cycle, with oxidative stress, altered DA metabolism, dysfunctional lysosomes, and pathological alpha-synuclein species representing key events in the pathogenesis of PD. We also discuss the interactions of alpha-synuclein with toxic DA metabolites, as well as the biochemical links between intracellular iron, calcium, and alpha-synuclein accumulation. We suggest that targeting multiple pathways, rather than individual processes, will be important for developing disease-modifying therapies. In this context, we focus on current translational efforts specifically targeting lysosomal function, as well as oxidative stress via calcium and iron modulation. These efforts could have therapeutic benefits for the broader population of sporadic PD and related synucleinopathies.

Genetic Links to Pathways of Parkinson’s Disease Vulnerability

Parkinson’s disease (PD) is the most common movement disorder, with a late onset for the majority of cases, affecting 1–2% of the population ≥65 years old (). The cardinal motor symptoms of PD are bradykinesia, rigidity, and resting tremor, leading to gait impairment and dynamic postural control dysfunction that compromise the quality of life for patients (). The onset of PD motor deficits is largely attributed to dopamine (DA) deficiency within the basal ganglia, due to the deterioration of substantia nigra pars compacta (SNpc) neurons (). The hallmark cellular pathology of most but not all PD cases consists of intraneuronal eosinophilic inclusions, namely, Lewy bodies and Lewy neurites, depending on their localization (; ). Despite being linked to PD, the timing and dynamics of the formation of Lewy bodies/neurites over the course of the disease remain enigmatic. Biochemical and ultrastructural evidence suggests that aggregated/fibrillar alpha-synuclein (aSyn), encoded by SNCA, is a defining feature of Lewy pathology in PD and Dementia with Lewy bodies, as well as intraglial inclusions in Multiple System Atrophy, diseases referred to as alpha-synucleinopathies (; ; ; ). Lipids and membranous organelles have also been documented in Lewy body structures (). A recent ultrastructural study using correlative and multi-imaging approaches demonstrated that aSyn-immunopositive Lewy inclusions also consist of lipid membranes and apparently damaged mitochondrial and lysosomal organelles with variable spatial organization (). This study is contemporary with the increasing genetic evidence for the contribution of mitochondrial and lysosomal processing pathways, converging with aSyn homeostasis in PD pathogenesis (; ; ). Thus, elucidating the interactions between aSyn and mitochondrial, lysosomal, and lipid homeostasis pathways in SNpc dopaminergic (DAergic) neurons will help understand PD progression and may be beneficial for the discovery of new therapeutic targets to develop novel therapeutic strategies.

PD is a predominantly sporadic disease with aging representing the greatest risk factor, whereas up to 10% of cases occur in a familial manner with both autosomal dominant and recessive transmission (). It is also likely that genetic as well as environmental causes contribute to both familial and sporadic PD, albeit to different extents (). SNCA was the first gene with mutations reported to cause autosomal dominant PD (A53T missense mutation), and to date, additional five missense SNCA mutations have been identified (A30P, A53E, E46K, G51D, and H50Q) (; ; ; ; ; ; ). Other genes have also been considered causal in autosomal dominant PD (including LRRK2, VPS35). Genes associated with autosomal recessive inheritance patterns are implicated in typical, early onset disease (PARKIN, PINK1, DJ-1, FBXO7) () and point toward functional implications for, but not limited to, the mitochondrial clearance pathway. Further atypical forms of parkinsonism, with juvenile onsets, include genes implicated in lysosomal function (ATP13A2) and synaptic vesicle endocytosis (SVE) pathway (DNAJC6 and SYNJ1). Among several other genes, LRRK2, SNCA, GBA1, CTSB, and SH3GL2 are associated with PD risk, as validated in the largest meta-analysis of genome-wide association studies (GWASs) to date (). Collectively, genetic evidence suggests that in both sporadic and familial PD, mitochondrial, endolysosomal, and synaptic vesicle homeostasis are compromised (; ; ; ).

Understanding the molecular mechanisms underlying the preferential susceptibility of SNpc DAergic neurons in PD remains a major focus of research. Because most currently available PD animal models do not manifest key pathogenic phenotypes of human pathology (), it has been difficult to study these mechanisms in vivo, representing a major caveat in modeling the disease. Furthermore, the increasing appreciation of multiple genetic “hits” contributing to PD raises the importance of addressing mechanistic interactions and potential pathway intersections using models representative of patient genetic heterogeneity. A significant development in this direction has been the establishment of human induced pluripotent stem cell (iPSC) technology allowing for long-term cultures of highly enriched patient-derived DAergic neurons (; ; ). Using this technology, neurons from patients with various PD genetic backgrounds have been studied addressing oxidative stress levels, mitochondrial function, and lysosomal and calcium homeostasis, whereas pathological aSyn remains a central aspect of investigation. aSyn plays a multifaceted pathological role in PD and related synucleinopathies, with aSyn-dependent toxicity impacting various cellular pathways (). Here, we focus on studies providing mechanistic insight into how interactions between aSyn, mitochondrial, endolysosomal, and synaptic pathways may be linked to DAergic vulnerability in PD. When feasible, emphasis is given to evidence derived from primary neurons and iPSC-derived DAergic neuronal models.

Alpha-Synuclein and Major Determinants of PD Dopaminergic Vulnerability

The neuromelanin-containing SNpc neurons, sending DAergic projections to the dorsal striatum, are preferentially vulnerable in PD (; ). A major concept is that degeneration is initiated at DAergic terminals, followed by the soma (; ). Quantification of DAergic phenotype deterioration using human post mortem tissue estimated that clinical PD manifestations are paralleled by ∼50% reduction of putaminal expression of tyrosine hydroxylase (TH), the rate limiting enzyme in DA production (). Interestingly, while the putaminal TH and DA transporter (DAT) expressions are lost within 4 years of diagnosis, a small number of residual TH and neuromelanin-containing SNpc neurons may persist even after 27 years ().

A major focus is placed on the distinct anatomical and functional features of SNpc DAergic neurons, linked to cell-autonomous pathways of vulnerability (; ). Firstly, single-cell tracing followed by digital reconstruction indicated that rat SNpc DAergic neurons possess widely spread and highly dense axonal arborization within the striatum (). Such an architecture can give rise to numerous synaptic connections and leads to high bioenergetic demands (; ). Assuming a similar nigrostriatal system architecture, human SNpc DAergic neurons were estimated to form even more synaptic connections, linked to even higher bioenergetic demands (). Based on computational modeling, larger size and axonal arbor complexity significantly increase the energetic cost for maintaining axon potential propagation and recovering the resting membrane potential (). Secondly, free cytosolic DA and DA metabolites are prone to oxidation, generating reactive quinones that can be neurotoxic and able to readily modify proteins causing protein aggregation (). Thirdly, midbrain DAergic neurons are autonomous pacemakers, involving spontaneous action potentials firing in a regular rhythmic manner (). The accompanying entry of calcium during repolarization, which supports pacemaking, DA synthesis, and ATP production, also increases mitochondrial oxidative stress (). Notably, while SNpc neurons are lost in PD, the neighboring ventral tegmental area (VTA) DAergic neurons are more resilient—a fact that has been partly attributed to the less extensive arborization and synaptic network, lower somatodendritic density of calcium channels (L-type), and higher endogenous expression of calcium buffering proteins (). In addition, DA metabolism may be different between SNpc and VTA neurons, possibly leading to higher levels of toxic intermediates of DA catabolism in PD (), as will be discussed in more detail.

Alpha-Synuclein and the Synaptic Compartment

Dysregulation of aSyn homeostasis has detrimental consequences for many pathways implicated in PD DAergic system vulnerability. aSyn is a 140 amino acid protein ubiquitously expressed in the central nervous system, predominately localized at the presynaptic compartment (; ). The primary amino acid sequence can be divided into three domains (Figure 1): the N-terminal domain (amino acid 1–60), the central domain also termed non-amyloid component of Aβ plaques (NAC; 61–95), and the C-terminal domain (96–140). The N-terminal domain mediates the association of aSyn with anionic phospholipids and shows preferential binding to smaller (∼45 μm diameter) vesicles (). Accordingly, biochemical and ultrastructural analyses indicated that aSyn associates with the membrane of synaptic vesicles (; ; ). aSyn oligomers are considered as primary pathogenic species in PD and related synucleinopathies. Interaction of aSyn oligomers with synaptic vesicle-like membranes demonstrated that N-terminus-mediated binding to membranes allows the rigid oligomeric core to be inserted into membranes and disrupt their integrity (). Interestingly, all familial PD SNCA mutations are localized in the N-terminal region of aSyn (A30P, A53E/T, E46K, G51D, and H50Q) (; ; ; ; ; ; ), and with the exception of G51D and A53E potentiate aSyn oligomerization and/or fibrillization in vitro, but exhibit differential propensity of forming inclusions within cells (; ; , ). In particular, a physiological role of aSyn in neurotransmission and synaptic vesicle trafficking has been demonstrated (). aSyn interacts with the vesicle-associated membrane protein (VAMP) 2 and promotes SNARE (Soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor Attachment Protein Receptor) complex assembly (), which enables neurotransmitter release via synaptic vesicle exocytosis. However, germline Snca-knockout mouse studies suggested that aSyn is not essential for basal neurotransmission in DAergic neurons, but rather plays a regulatory role in activity-dependent DA release (; ; ). Nevertheless, the specific physiological function of aSyn within the central nervous system requires further elucidation.

FIGURE 1

Aggregated pathological forms of aSyn at both presynaptic terminals () and along the axon () have been described in post mortem patient tissue, implicating aSyn pathology in synaptic deterioration. SNCA overexpression in transgenic mouse models has been linked to nigrostriatal terminal loss (), DA release deficits, and changes in synaptic vesicle clustering (). aSyn overexpression in ventral midbrain primary neuron cultures was linked to inhibition of the SVE pathway, attributed to a reduced recycling vesicle pool and defective reclustering after endocytosis (). Interestingly, SVE coordinates the replenishment of synaptic vesicles following neurotransmission and has emerged as a pathway of PD vulnerability, with SYNJ1 (synaptojanin 1) and DNAJC6 (auxilin) implicated as causal () or SH3GL2 (endophilin A1) as risk factor in PD (; ). Briefly, SVE begins with the invagination of a new clathrin-coated vesicle from the plasma membrane, with the participation of endophilin A1 and synaptojanin 1. Subsequently, auxilin-mediated removal of the clathrin lattice allows for the refilling with neurotransmitters, such as DA. LRRK2 mutations, leading to hyperactivation of LRRK2 kinase, are linked to SVE deficits since endophilin A1, synaptojanin 1, and auxilin are LRRK2 phosphorylation substrates (; ; ). Using LRRK2 PD iPSC-derived DAergic neurons, it was demonstrated that increased phosphorylation in the clathrin-binding domain of auxilin (S627) by LRRK2 impaired clathrin uncoating (). This mechanism was linked to the reduced density of synaptic vesicles at terminals, which concurred with oxidized DA accumulation and increased aSyn levels (). Based on this evidence, a synergistic effect of LRRK2 and aSyn on SVE could lead to decreased DA packaging into synaptic vesicles, thus contributing to PD vulnerability (Figure 2). In addition to synaptic deficits, axonopathy has also been reported in iPSC-derived neuronal cultures from A53T SNCA patients (). These cultures showed swollen varicosities immunopositive for aSyn, which were improved by small molecules targeting aSyn aggregation ().

FIGURE 2

Alpha-Synuclein and Mitochondria

Mitochondria are present in the synaptic compartment (; ) and crucial for maintaining synaptic activity and neuronal homeostasis by ATP production, calcium storage, and lipid metabolism (). Genetic evidence suggests that the pathways of mitochondrial quality control (PARKIN, PINK1, DJ-1, FBOX7) and mitochondrial fusion/fission dynamics (OPA1) are implicated in PD and parkinsonism (; ). Further biochemical studies showed mitochondrial respiratory chain complex I deficiency in PD SN tissue (). Hampering local energy support of DAergic synapses due to mitochondrial dysfunction could significantly contribute to progressive loss of nigrostriatal connections. Supporting this notion, post mortem immunofluorescence analysis showing putaminal loss of DAergic synapses in PD patients reported higher mitochondrial marker per axon volume (), which may reflect compensatory increased trafficking for energy support.

Aberrant aSyn–mitochondria interactions resulting in oxidative/nitrosative stress, as well as mitochondrial trafficking and respiration defects, can render DAergic synapses vulnerable. Application of recombinant oligomeric aSyn species to neuroblastoma cells and primary cortical neurons disrupted plasma membrane integrity, significantly increased intracellular reactive oxygen species (ROS), and reduced mitochondrial activity (). Formation of pathological oligomeric aSyn species within neurons, resulting from wild-type aSyn overexpression or expression of mutant aSyn, has been associated with reduced anterograde mitochondria trafficking () and mitochondrial fragmentation (; ; ; ; ). Mitochondrial transport defects were paralleled by reduced axonal fiber density and decreased synaptic robustness (). Microfluidic cultures of iPSC-derived neurons modeling DAergic-medium spiny neuron synapse showed that PD OPA1 mutant iPSC-derived DAergic neurons had impaired anterograde mitochondrial trafficking leading to progressive synaptic loss (). Mitochondria within OPA1 mutant neurons exhibited a fragmented phenotype, and it is not known whether fragmentation may per se reduce mitochondrial trafficking. If so, the role of aSyn in the regulation of mitochondrial dynamics could be crucial, and further investigation is required. Direct interaction of both wild-type and mutant (A53T, A30P) aSyn has been shown at mitochondria-associated membranes (MAMs) (), domains of endoplasmic reticulum (ER)–mitochondria contact, relevant for the exchange of ions and lipids. The aSyn–MAMs interaction has been suggested to enhance mitochondrial calcium uptake from the ER (), which could in turn affect ATP production and oxidative stress. Furthermore, aSyn accumulation in association with mitochondria can reduce complex I activity and elevate mitochondrial ROS production in DAergic neurons (; ). Proximity ligation assays in human post mortem PD and rat SN tissue indicated binding of aSyn to TOM20 (translocase of the outer membrane receptor 20), which can be a crucial interaction underlying aSyn-dependent complex I deficiency and oxidative stress (). Specifically, it was shown that via TOM20 binding, oligomeric, DA-modified, and phosphorylated (S129E phosphomimetic mutant) aSyn species could hamper the mitochondrial import of the complex I subunit Ndufs3, linked to lower basal respiration and oxidative damage (). The aSyn–TOM20 interaction has also been demonstrated in iPSC-derived DAergic neurons, possibly contributing to mitochondrial dysfunction in A53T and SNCA triplication PD neurons (). Compared with isogenic controls, A53T SNCA pluripotent stem cell-derived DAergic neurons showed exacerbated ROS/reactive nitrogen species (RNS) production and higher susceptibility upon exposure to mitochondrial toxins (). Furthermore, gene expression analysis in sporadic PD SNpc tissue, and comparison between A53T SNCA and isogenic pluripotent stem cell-derived DAergic neurons, has linked axodendritic pathology to an impaired antioxidative stress response ().

Alpha-Synuclein and Dopamine

DA signaling and metabolism are regulated by the coordinated actions of enzymes and transporters responsible for DA synthesis, packaging into vesicles and re-uptake following release, or for degradation of cytosolic DA. Sequestration or degradation is particularly important as the accumulation of DA in the cytosol generates ROS and oxidizes DA by-products (Figure 2). TH converts dietary tyrosine to L-dihydroxyphenylalanine (L-DOPA), which is ultimately converted to DA by aromatic amino acid decarboxylase (). Following synthesis, the vesicular monoamine transporter (VMAT)-2 uses ATP-driven vesicular electrochemical gradient to package cytosolic DA into vesicles along the axon and pre-synapses, but also into tubular structures at the somatodendritic compartment (; Figure 2). Neurotransmission is terminated by high-affinity DA reuptake through DAT at the pre-synapse, where DA can be recycled for exocytosis (Figure 2). At this stage, deficits in the SVE pathway, as reported in LRRK2 PD iPSC-derived DAergic neurons () among other cellular and in vivo models (), can lead to DA accumulation in the cytosol. Preventing the potentially neurotoxic effects of cytosolic build-up, the main degradation route begins with DA oxidative deamination to 3,4-dihydroxyphenylacetaldehyde (DOPAL), concurring with H2O2 (hydrogen peroxide) generation, by the outer mitochondrial membrane monoamine oxidase (MAO) (). Furthermore, the DOPAL metabolite is potentially toxic for DAergic cells and is by far more potent than DA in both oligomerizing and forming quinone protein adducts with aSyn (; ; ). Therefore, the route of conversion to the corresponding non-toxic 3,4-dihydroxyphenylacetic acid (DOPAC), catalyzed by aldehyde dehydrogenase ALDH1A1 (), is an important detoxification mechanism (Figure 2). Subsequently, DOPAC is degraded mainly to homovanillic acid by catechol−O−methyltransferase (). Dysregulated DA metabolism has been linked to SNpc vulnerability in PD since post mortem analyses showed decreased ALDH1A1 mRNA in PD SNpc but not VTA () and higher DOPAL:DOPAC and DOPAL:DA ratios in PD putamen (, ). In addition, theoretical indices derived from DA/metabolites relative ratios have suggested that both reduced vesicular DA uptake and ALDH1A1 activity accounted for DOPAL accumulation in PD putamen (). Quantitative proteomics and transcriptomics highlighted mitochondrial and lysosomal dysregulation and differential vulnerability of DAergic neurons derived from several isogenic PD gene knockout pluripotent stem cell lines ().

Mechanistically, dysregulated DA metabolism has emerged as a significant SNpc vulnerability pathway, converging with mitochondrial oxidative stress, with implications for both lysosomal dysfunction and aSyn pathology (Figure 3). In line with this, iPSC-derived DAergic neurons from an SNCA duplication patient showed higher aSyn aggregation/phosphorylation as well as higher ROS/RNS levels than cortical neurons derived from the identical iPSC line, although the underlying mechanisms require elucidation (). Cytosolic DA can be non-enzymatically converted to reactive DA-o-quinone (DA-Q), catalyzed by Fe3+ (ferric) iron (). Additional quinones and semiquinones are sequentially formed, thus aggravating oxidative stress (). Importantly, accumulation of oxidized DA/DA-Q represents a key phenotype developing over time in human iPSC-derived DAergic neurons from genetic PD forms related to mitochondrial (PARKIN, PINK1, DJ-1) and endolysosomal pathways (LRRK2, GBA1) or sporadic PD (, ; ; ). DA promotes the accumulation of pathological aSyn protofibril intermediates, involving oxidation to DA-Q (). Moreover, elevation of DA in mouse SN neurons by lentiviral overexpression of catalytically hyperactive TH promoted the formation of pathological aSyn oligomers and accelerated the DAergic deterioration of A53T aSyn overexpressing mice (). Another potential DAergic vulnerability mechanism linked to the aSyn–DA interaction is the impaired lysosomal degradation of proteins cleared via chaperone-mediated autophagy. DA-/autoxidized DA-modified aSyn was shown to bind to the lysosomal membrane, but was not efficiently taken up and degraded within the lumen (). In addition, elevation of cytosolic DA in mouse primary ventral midbrain neurons by L-DOPA administration inhibited protein degradation via chaperone-mediated autophagy in wild-type but not aSyn null neurons (). Based on molecular dynamic simulations, DA and oxidation derivatives non-specifically bind to the C-terminus of aSyn (aa 125–129), further stabilized by long-range electrostatic interactions with the NAC region (aa E83) (; Figure 1). An additional mechanism of DA-related toxicity is the modification of proteins by DA-Q, with adducts formed by the catechol moiety reacting with thiols of cysteines (). Two examples of DA-Q modified proteins are parkin and the lysosomal glucocerebrosidase (GCase). In neuronal cell lines, DA-Q-modified parkin showed lower E3 ubiquitin ligase activity and decreased solubility (). Moreover, catechol-modified parkin was detected in human control SNpc (). In addition, DA-Q modification of cysteines at the GCase catalytic site leads to decreased lysosomal GCase activity in iPSC-derived DAergic neurons, thus contributing to lysosomal dysfunction (). The primary DA metabolite DOPAL is highly neurotoxic in vitro and in vivo. Like DA, DOPAL is auto-oxidized to quinones (DOPAL-Q) with concomitant generation of ROS. In addition to the reported general increase in cellular oxidative stress linked to DOPAL and other DA oxidation derivatives, mitochondria can also be specifically impacted. Use of H2O2-sensitive genetically encoded thiol redox sensors indicated that short-term L-DOPA treatment of DAergic neurons induces MAO activity for catabolism of DA to DOPAL and concomitantly increases oxidative stress specifically within axonal mitochondria (). Although this mechanism was shown to be physiologically relevant for supporting ATP production (), it may also represent an additional source of mitochondrial stress in the PD milieu, accentuating DAergic neuron axonal/synaptic vulnerability. DOPAL is also linked to aSyn pathology, with injection into rat SN resulting in high molecular weight aSyn species and loss of TH+ neurons (). DOPAL/DOPAL-Q modify aSyn via the formation of adducts between DOPAL/DOPAL-Q aldehyde moiety and N-terminal aSyn lysines (domain of aa 1–60), thus increasing aSyn oligomerization (). aSyn modification by DOPAL could lead to loss of aSyn function at the presynapse, since it was shown that DOPAL-modified aSyn has reduced affinity for synaptic vesicle-like membranes (), and that DOPAL-aSyn oligomers have been shown to permeabilize lipid membranes leading to DA leak (). This leads to a vicious cycle of cytosolic DA/DOPAL accumulation, oxidative stress, toxic protein modifications promoting pathological aSyn, and lysosomal dysfunction via GCase. Addressing DOPAL build-up mechanisms in detail using iPSC-derived DAergic neurons will provide further insight into how DA release/metabolism equilibrium may be altered in PD. Importantly, such studies could open new venues for DA detoxification approaches, as an early intervention in PD.

FIGURE 3

Oxidized DA and derivatives also constitute the basis for the formation of neuromelanin, a dark polymeric pigment, which accumulates over a lifetime in human SN neurons and is considered as detoxifying under physiological conditions (). Neuromelanin has been observed in DJ-1 PD iPSC-derived DAergic neurons () and iPSC-derived midbrain-like organoids treated with DA or L-DOPA (). Electron microscopy of human SN revealed neuromelanin-containing organelles enveloping dark proteinaceous granular aggregates and lipid bodies (). Moreover, biochemical analyses indicated a high representation of endolysosomal pathway proteins, as well as higher molecular weight aSyn species, within neuromelanin organelles (). In addition to proteins and lipids, metals, such as Fe3+ (ferric) iron, which catalyzes DA oxidation, are bound to neuromelanin. Indeed, neuromelanin’s composition is indicative of the intersection between DA metabolism and aSyn-related pathways, with iron playing a significant modulatory role. Iron is enriched in the basal ganglia and SN (), whereas specifically in the putamen, iron levels increase with age reaching maximum concentration at 50–60 years (). Interestingly, another group of diseases shares the feature of high brain iron in the basal ganglia and progressive neurodegeneration with PD. This is the very rare and heterogeneous group of neurodegeneration with brain iron accumulation (NBIA) disorders, characterized by young onset and progressive extrapyramidal dysfunction (). Furthermore, certain NBIA cases show extensive Lewy pathology in the SN, and specifically SNpc, as well as the cerebral cortex (; ; ). Importantly, accumulation of iron in the SN of PD patients has been reported by several studies (; ; ). It is also possible that regulation of iron metabolism in the periphery is altered in PD as in the case of ceruloplasmin, a liver-synthesized enzyme that converts Fe2+ (ferrous iron) to Fe3+, thus facilitating peripheral iron transportation. Reduced ceruloplasmin activity has been reported in the SN and biofluids of some PD patients, and missense variations in the ceruloplasmin-encoding gene showed a possible link with SN iron deposition in few PD patients (). Iron can contribute to the pathways of oxidative stress and aSyn pathology (Figure 2). After reduction from the Fe3+ to the Fe2+ state, iron can participate in Fenton reactions that liberate radicals and can result in neurotoxic protein oxidation or lipid peroxidation (; ). Furthermore, iron binds to the C-terminus of aSyn (Figure 1; Fe2+: aa P120-A124 and P128-S129; Fe3+: aa P120-M127), increased by S129 phosphorylation (), a post-translational modification identified in Lewy bodies (). The aSyn–iron interaction is potentially toxic, since iron alone or in concert with DOPAL promotes aSyn oligomerization (; ; ). Conversely, aSyn can enhance iron toxicity via conversion of Fe3+ to Fe2+, leading to higher DOPAL susceptibility in neuronal cells (). Such activity has also been demonstrated in vivo following viral overexpression of human aSyn in the rat SN, leading to TH neuron loss (). Consequently, aSyn–iron interactions can aggravate oxidative stress and contribute to DAergic neuron vulnerability.

Mitochondrial antioxidants including N-acetylcysteine (precursor to glutathione synthesis) have also been shown to prevent the accumulation of oxidized DA and aSyn in iPSC-derived DAergic cultures (). Furthermore, antioxidant polyamines have recently been identified as substrates of the PD-linked lysosomal ATPase ATP13A2 (). Although the mechanisms are unclear, polyamine metabolism may be altered during aging but also in PD. Post mortem examinations have indicated a decrease of polyamines in basal ganglia (), and in PD, there appears to be a reduced expression of the catabolic enzyme spermidine/spermine N1-acetyltransferase 1 (SAT1) (). Further elucidation of functional interactions between modulators of oxidative stress and PD-linked genes will be important for novel, targeted PD antioxidant therapies.

Alpha-Synuclein and Calcium

aSyn and calcium homeostasis appear to be reciprocally regulated. Calcium binds to aSyn at a 32-aa C-terminal domain (Figure 1; ). This interaction promotes aSyn aggregation and can potentiate the interaction between aSyn and synaptic vesicles (; ). Calcium can also affect aSyn conformation via the calcium-activated protease calpain I. Using recombinant aSyn, one major cleavage site for monomeric (after aa 57) and two additional major sites for fibrillary aSyn (after aa 114 and 122) have been identified (). In vivo calpain inhibition via overexpression of the natural inhibitor calpastatin abolished aSyn truncation and could significantly reduce aSyn aggregation in A30P aSyn overexpressing mice (). Moreover, deficient extracellular vesicle release, a calcium-dependent process partly mediating aSyn secretion (; ), has been related to progressive aSyn accumulation in ATP13A2 iPSC-derived DAergic neurons (). Conversely, aSyn can affect intraneuronal calcium homeostasis, with overexpression leading to a sustained elevation of basal calcium levels (; ). Specifically, oligomeric aSyn can induce channel formation on artificial membranes leading to irregular calcium influx, which can result in calcium-dependent cellular toxicity (). Also, SNCA triplication iPSC-derived cortical neurons were shown to exhibit abnormal patterns of Ca2+ influx upon depolarization, attributed to the integration of oligomeric aSyn species into membranes ().

In addition, calcium dynamics can contribute to the vulnerability of SNpc neurons, acting in concert with aSyn and DA (Figure 2). Calcium enters DAergic neurons via voltage-gated calcium channels (Cav), residing at the axon terminals as well as at the soma and proximal dendrites (). The pacemaking activity of SNpc DAergic neurons is accompanied by calcium influx via L-type (Cav1.3 subtype) calcium channels, which are activated at relatively negative membrane potential (). Measurements using a mitochondrial matrix-targeted indicator showed that L-type channel-mediated calcium influx during pacemaking is linked to mitochondrial calcium influx via ER receptors and leads to increased basal levels of mitochondrial oxidative stress (). This calcium-dependent feed forward mechanism drives oxidative phosphorylation, but also constitutes sustained mitochondrial oxidative stress with a key role in SN DAergic vulnerability (). SN mouse primary neurons treated with the Cav1.2/Cav1.3 negative allosteric modulator nimodipine were significantly more resilient to L-DOPA, a treatment that raises cytosolic DA and leads to neurotoxicity (). Along this line, application of L-type calcium channel negative allosteric modulators (nimodipine and isradipine) could prevent the exacerbated elevation of cytosolic calcium and reduce susceptibility of SN neurons, as compared with VTA, in a Parkinsonian MPP + (1-methyl-4-phenylpyridinium) neurotoxin model (). aSyn knockout neurons did not show elevation of cytosolic calcium following MPP + treatment and were less sensitive to either L-DOPA or MPP+ (; ). Furthermore, GBA1-PD and ATP13A2-PD iPSC-derived DAergic neurons showed elevated basal calcium levels (; ), and importantly, inhibition of calcium influx and downstream signaling in long-term DJ-1 iPSC-derived DAergic neuron cultures could significantly reduce DA oxidation (). Collectively, Cav1.3-mediated calcium influx () and MAO-mediated DA metabolism () represent a dual source of sustained oxidative stress in DAergic neuron mitochondria and are reciprocally linked to aSyn and lysosomal homeostasis pathways (Figure 3). Additional calcium channels may play a role in calcium influx-related DAergic toxicity. For instance, single-cell mRNA and protein expression analyses indicated that the Cav2.3 channel subtype is most highly abundant in mature mouse SN DAergic neurons (). In this study, Cav2.3 channels were shown to contribute to activity-related calcium oscillations, and their knockout protected against MPTP (1-methyl-4-phenyl-1,2,3,6-tetrahydropyridin)-induced SNpc DAergic cell death in mice. Importantly, Cav2.3 expression was readily detected in GBA1-PD and healthy control iPSC-derived DAergic neurons (). These findings corroborate the importance of investigating further molecular players in calcium signaling dysregulation and suggest their contribution to the vulnerability of human DAergic neurons, for revealing new therapeutic targets.

Lysosomal Dysfunction and Alpha-Synuclein Linked by Glucocerebrosidase

Inefficient clearance via the autophagy–lysosome pathway has long been linked to PD (), and pathological aSyn can interfere with, and compromise, several stages of this pathway (). In more recent years, the increasing understanding of the key role of specifically lysosomal dysfunction in PD () has highlighted GBA1 as a crucial molecular player with direct implications for aSyn homeostasis. The gene GBA1 is the most common PD risk factor and encodes for the lysosomal enzyme GCase (). GCase is active in the acidic endolysosomal lumen, hydrolyzing glucose moieties from the glucolipids glucosylceramide (GluCer) and glucosylsphingosine (GluSph) (). Homozygous GBA1 loss-of-function mutations lead to the lysosomal storage disorder Gaucher’s disease, characterized by accumulation of GluCer and GluSph within the lysosomes of macrophages. In some Gaucher patients, manifestations of parkinsonism and dementia, as well as Lewy pathology, have been described (). Heterozygous GBA1 mutations are encountered in 7–12% of PD patients (GBA1-PD) () and shown to increase risk for motor symptom severity and dementia progression ().

GCase function is strongly and reciprocally connected to aSyn homeostasis (Figure 3), but GCase has also emerged as a molecular convergence target of pathways associated with multiple genetic or idiopathic PD forms. A Gaucher’s disease mouse model expressing mutant GCase showed hippocampal aSyn aggregation and memory deficits, and phenotypes significantly improved by adeno-viral wild-type GBA1 overexpression (). Generally, GCase deficiency is associated with higher intracellular aSyn levels, in neuronal models and iPSC-derived DAergic neurons from Gaucher’s disease and GBA1-PD patients (; ; ; ; ). In particular, the buildup of GluCer on endolysosomal membranes promotes the formation of pathological high molecular weight aSyn species, further converted to insoluble species (; ). Moreover, increased GluCer was also shown to de-stabilize aSyn tetramers (), which in contrast to oligomers are proposed to represent physiological multimeric forms less prone to aggregate (; ), although this is still controversial. GluCer-induced aSyn forms have also been directly associated with endogenous neurotoxicity, as well as decreased neuronal viability upon endocytosis from healthy DAergic neurons (). An equally important aspect of the aSyn–GCase interaction is that increased aSyn levels can per se impair lysosomal GCase activity via improper enzyme maturation and trafficking, an effect that also disrupts other lysosomal enzymes (; ). Specifically, aSyn disrupts the association between the SNARE protein ykt6, implicated in ER–Golgi trafficking, and membranes, validated in iPSC-derived DAergic neurons from SNCA triplication- or A53T aSyn PD patients (). Further mechanistic investigations in iPSC-derived DAergic neurons have revealed that some PD-associated proteins exert an inhibitory effect on GCase activity that can, at least partly, be attributed to DA oxidation. In long-term cultures of DJ-1-deficient iPSC-derived DAergic neurons, a time-dependent pathogenic cascade has been discovered that started with mitochondrial oxidative stress promoting the generation of DA-Qs (). These species of oxidized DA led to disruption of GCase activity through modification of cysteine residues at the GCase catalytic center (). A similar concurrent elevation of oxidized DA and reduced GCase activity was also observed in PINK1, PARKIN, LRRK2, and SNCA triplication iPSC-derived DAergic neurons (>90 days of neurons in culture), but also in sporadic PD iPSC-derived DAergic neurons at later time points (>180 days) (). Further studies will be important to identify additional pathways affecting GCase activity in different PD forms beyond DA metabolism ().

Disease-Modifying Therapies for PD

Thus far, there is strong evidence indicating that lysosomal dysfunction and mitochondrial oxidative stress are key factors for DAergic neuron vulnerability and tightly connected to aSyn homeostasis in PD etiopathology. Moreover, calcium and iron can have a significant contribution in pathways related to oxidative stress and pathological aSyn formation. Consequently, in this section, we discuss therapeutic approaches and clinical studies focusing on the molecular target GCase, as well as calcium and iron, as three important factors with high relevance for aSyn homeostasis. Notably, such therapeutic approaches are not directly targeting pathological aSyn, but could possibly restore the unbalanced equilibrium between aSyn, mitochondrial, and lysosomal pathways (for aSyn-targeted therapies, see ).

The function of GCase is crucial for both glucolipid metabolism and aSyn homeostasis. Increasing GCase activity is, at present, the overarching aim of translational efforts specifically targeting PD lysosomal dysfunction. To this end, one major emerging approach in GBA1-PD is promoting mutant lysosomal GCase translocation to the lysosome via small molecule modulators, validated in iPSC-derived DAergic culture studies. For instance, long-term cultured (>100 days) iPSC-derived DAergic neurons from Gaucher patients exhibited key disease-related phenotypes of GluCer/GluSph and aSyn accumulation (). Treatment with a GCase modulator (21 days, compound NCGC607) improved both phenotypes (). Importantly, small molecule enhancement of GCase activity (8 days, compound NCGC00188758) could also reduce aSyn in SNCA- and ATP13A2/PARK9-PD iPSC-derived DAergic long-term cultured neurons (>90 days), which also showed reduced GCase activity (). Alternatively, promoting wild-type GCase activity (10 days, compound S-181) successfully reduced glucolipids and DA/aSyn pathological phenotypes in LRRK2, DJ-1, and PARKIN as well as sporadic PD long-term iPSC-derived DAergic cultures (up to day 160) (). Furthermore, application of a farnesyltransferase inhibitor (LNK-754) could also promote GCase lysosomal translocation by promoting the ykt6–Golgi membrane interaction, reducing pathological aSyn in SNCA-PD DAergic neurons (). Indirect targeting of GCase activity includes pharmacological or genetic LRRK2 inhibition, assessed in GBA1- and LRRK2-PD iPSC-derived DAergic neurons (; ). This approach could significantly improve the pathological accumulation of oxidized DA and aSyn (including pS129-aSyn) (). Currently, the two main approaches to increase GCase activity in GBA1-PD patients that reached clinical trials are either compounds aiming to enhance the activity of mutant GCase function or targeted gene therapy. The small molecule chaperone ambroxol has been successfully used to enhance mutant GCase activity and reduce pathological aSyn in GBA1 and SNCA mouse models (). Results from a Phase 2 clinical trial using ambroxol in a small patient cohort with and without GBA1 mutations (NCT02941822) suggested that the compound penetrated the CSF and targeted GCase, leading to increased total aSyn levels in the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) (). However, the mechanisms underlying the effect of GCase targeting on total aSyn in CSF are not clear. Concerning gene therapy, a Phase 1/2a addresses the AAV (adeno-associated virus)9-mediated delivery of wild-type GBA1 into the central nervous system (NCT04127578). Biochemical assessments include GCase activity and GluCer/GluSph levels in the blood and CSF biofluids of GBA1-PD patients.

Voltage-gated calcium channels are targets for PD pharmacological interventions. The effects of isradipine, an L-type (Cav1) channel antagonist of the dihydropyridine class, have been more extensively studied with promising in vitro and in vivo results (). Moreover, epidemiological studies suggested that dihydropyridine use was associated with reduced PD risk (; ). However, results from the completion of a Phase 3 clinical study of 3-year duration, in previously untreated early PD patients (NCT02168842), indicated that isradipine did not slow the rate of clinical PD progression, as measured by UPDRS (Unified Parkinson’s Disease Rating Scale) scores (parts I–III, corresponding to mental function, daily living, and motor function) (). It thus remains to be examined whether a highly selective antagonist of Cav1.3 channels, linked to the pacemaking activity-induced oxidative stress in SNpc DAergic neurons (), may show disease-modifying potential. An additional challenge in objectively assessing efficacy of calcium-targeting approaches is the identification of specific target engagement markers.

Targeting iron in PD aims at alleviating DAergic neurons from an agent that can enhance oxidative stress and aSyn pathology. To this end, administration of the iron chelator deferiprone to mice prior to neurotoxic lesion was shown to protect them from nigrostriatal DAergic loss and mitigate oxidative stress (). A 2-year pilot, double-blind, placebo-controlled randomized clinical trial using deferiprone in early stage PD (NCT00943748), in addition to DAergic therapy, indicated reduction of SN iron deposition and some improvement of motor symptoms based on UPDRS score (). However, cessation of deferiprone treatment led to reappearance of SN iron deposition and waned clinical improvement (). Moreover, PD patients with lower ceruloplasmin activity in the CSF showed a greater reduction of SN iron levels within a 1-year deferiprone regimen (). Therefore, efficacy of iron chelation may vary between individuals, due to underlying differences in iron metabolism in the periphery. A follow-up Phase 2 clinical trial for 9 months (NCT02655315) and an additional 9-month Phase 2 study specifically in early stage PD (NCT02728843) further assess deferiprone for motor and non-motor symptoms (Movement Disorder Society-UPDRS scores).

The diverse genetic background of PD patients places a variable burden on the aSyn, mitochondrial, and lysosomal pathways of DAergic susceptibility, likely contributing to the heterogeneous clinical presentation. This realization intensifies the need for specific and sensitive biomarkers allowing for distinguishing disease stages, thus optimizing patient stratification. Such biomarkers could improve the evaluation or possibly predict patient responses to different therapies in the endeavor for personalized medicine. Under this scope, a thorough understanding of interactions between DAergic vulnerability pathways, aging, and environmental and genetic factors (Figure 3) can be instrumental to emerging strategies involving implantation of iPSC-derived DAergic progenitors from autologous sources into PD patients ().

Conclusion and Perspectives

Developments in the field of genetics have revealed a strong genetic component underlying familial and sporadic forms of PD. Mechanistic evidence has highlighted a deleterious feedback cycle whereby mitochondrial, lysosomal, and aSyn pathways converge and lead to DAergic susceptibility. In this feedback loop, calcium and iron can have a significant contribution as modulators exacerbating synaptic vulnerability. So far, the use of iPSC technology has helped to demonstrate that lysosomal dysfunction, accumulation of oxidized DA, and pathological aSyn represent shared iPSC-derived DAergic neuron phenotypes, despite the heterogeneity of PD genetic backgrounds. The concept of mechanistic convergence in DAergic vulnerability suggests that disease-modifying therapies require specific molecular targets able to restore equilibrium between individual pathways. Ideally, novel biomarkers reflecting the pathological status of PD-related pathways will optimize patient stratification for testing therapeutic responses and potentially increasing benefits for specific PD subpopulations. Furthermore, considering the wide use of DAergic medication for relieving PD motor symptoms, it will be crucial to investigate in detail DA metabolism and particularly DOPAL build-up mechanisms using iPSC-derived DAergic neurons. Such studies will provide novel insight into how DA release/metabolism equilibrium is altered in PD and open new venues for DA detoxification approaches, potentially as early interventions in PD.

iPSC-derived DAergic neurons used for in vitro modeling of PD represent a platform for investigating mechanisms of PD etiopathology and facilitate early phases of drug discovery. This technology, however, also presents limitations for studying PD biology, and several crucial questions remain to be elucidated. For example, interpretation and comparison of findings among different studies can be complicated by the fact that DAergic neuron cultures were obtained with variable purity and analyses were performed at different in vitro ages. Therefore, establishing conditions for culturing iPSC-derived DAergic neurons from different genetic backgrounds over longer periods would have to be standardized to accurately monitor the manifestation of different phenotypes including aSyn accumulation, lysosomal function, and oxidative stress. Moreover, iPSC-derived DAergic neuron cultures are especially suitable for studying cell-autonomous pathways of PD vulnerability. Yet, experimental disease modeling paradigms using additional cell types, including but not limited to glial cells, are required to better recapitulate the cell-to-cell interactions of the midbrain milieu. To this end, utilizing iPSC technology allowing for neuron–glia co-cultures as well as midbrain organoids may provide important answers. Patient-specific iPSC-derived models will serve as a resource for in vitro and in vivo disease modeling and drug screening, with the goal of testing neuroprotective compounds and developing therapeutic interventions.

Statements

Author contributions

GM, DK, and LFB wrote the manuscript. All authors contributed to the article and approved the submitted version.

Funding

This work was supported by the Associazione Italiana Sindromi Neurodegenerative da Accumulo di Ferro (AISNAF), the NBIA Disorders Association, the Hoffnungsbaum e.V. to LFB, and the National Institutes of Health grants R01 NS076054 and R37 NS096241 to DK.

Acknowledgments

We are thankful to Dr. Yvette C. Wong for helpful advice.

Conflict of interest

DK was the Founder and Scientific Advisory Board Chair of Lysosomal Therapeutics Inc., and Vanqua Bio. DK serves on the scientific advisory boards of The Silverstein Foundation, Intellia Therapeutics, and Prevail Therapeutics and is a Venture Partner at OrbiMed. The remaining authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.

References

Summary

Keywords

alpha-synuclein, calcium, dopamine, mitochondria, iron, Parkinson’s disease, synapse

Citation

Minakaki G, Krainc D and Burbulla LF (2020) The Convergence of Alpha-Synuclein, Mitochondrial, and Lysosomal Pathways in Vulnerability of Midbrain Dopaminergic Neurons in Parkinson’s Disease. Front. Cell Dev. Biol. 8:580634. doi: 10.3389/fcell.2020.580634

Received

06 July 2020

Accepted

10 November 2020

Published

14 December 2020

Volume

8 - 2020

Edited by

Friederike Zunke, University Hospital Erlangen, Germany

Reviewed by

Benjamin Dehay, UMR5293 Institut des Maladies Neurodégénératives (IMN), France; Ana Isabel Rodríguez Pérez, University of Santiago de Compostela, Spain

Updates

Copyright

*Correspondence: Lena F. Burbulla,

This article was submitted to Molecular Medicine, a section of the journal Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology

Disclaimer

All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.

Outline

Figures

Cite article

Copy to clipboard


Export citation file


Share article

Article metrics