REVIEW article

Front. Immunol., 08 January 2021

Sec. Alloimmunity and Transplantation

Volume 11 - 2020 | https://doi.org/10.3389/fimmu.2020.618427

Allogeneic CAR Cell Therapy—More Than a Pipe Dream

  • Department of Bone Marrow Transplantation and Cellular Therapy, St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital, Memphis, TN, United States

Abstract

Adoptive cellular immunotherapy using immune cells expressing chimeric antigen receptors (CARs) has shown promise, particularly for the treatment of hematological malignancies. To date, the majority of clinically evaluated CAR cell products have been derived from autologous immune cells. While this strategy can be effective it also imposes several constraints regarding logistics. This includes i) availability of center to perform leukapheresis, ii) necessity for shipment to and from processing centers, and iii) time requirements for product manufacture and clinical release testing. In addition, previous cytotoxic therapies can negatively impact the effector function of autologous immune cells, which may then affect efficacy and/or durability of resultant CAR products. The use of allogeneic CAR cell products generated using cells from healthy donors has the potential to overcome many of these limitations, including through generation of “off the shelf” products. However, allogeneic CAR cell products come with their own challenges, including potential to induce graft-versus-host-disease, as well as risk of immune-mediated rejection by the host. Here we will review promises and challenges of allogeneic CAR immunotherapies, including those being investigated in preclinical models and/or early phase clinical studies.

Introduction

Adoptive cellular therapy refers to the isolation of immune cells, followed by ex vivo manipulation and subsequent delivery into patients as a therapeutic intervention. An area of interest is the exploration of cellular or immunotherapeutic approaches for the treatment of oncologic diseases, including using chimeric antigen receptors (CARs) (1–3). CARs combine the specificity of an antibody with signaling domains of effector cells and costimulatory molecules (1–3). When constitutively expressed on the surface of an immune cell through non-viral or viral transduction, CARs enable an effector cell to recognize targets in an antigen-specific manner. CARs designed to target a specific tumor-associated-antigen (TAA) can then be used for anticancer therapy (1–3).

Cell therapy with T cells expressing CARs (CAR T cells) represent a significant advance in the field of cancer immunotherapy and is fueling the development of CAR-based immunotherapies using other immune cells. The most successful CAR cell therapy approach thus far has been the treatment of patients with highly relapsed/refractory CD19-positive hematological malignancies using CD19-CAR T cells derived from autologous T cells. Across numerous institutions, using a variety of CAR constructs and manufacturing strategies, CD19-CAR T cell therapy has been extremely efficacious (4, 5). This success led to the FDA approval of three such products: tisagenlecleucel (Kymriah, Novartis), axicabtagene ciloleucel (Yescarta, Kite Pharmaceuticals), and brexucabtagene autoleucel (Tecartus, Kite Pharmaceuticals) (6–9). Additionally, autologous CAR T cells have shown robust anti-tumor activity for hematological malignancies targeting BCMA, CD20, CD22, and CD30 (10–13).

The autologous (patient-derived) CAR T cell paradigm has also highlighted the limitations of such therapies, including the challenges of leukapheresis, manufacturing and efficacy in an often heavily pre-treated patient population (14). Seeking to overcome these barriers, allogeneic CAR strategies are actively being developed. Significant challenges of using allogeneic cells exist and center upon the inherent immunologic mismatch between donor and recipient. However, despite these challenges, allogeneic CAR strategies hold the potential to offer quicker, more efficacious and more accessible CAR therapies.

In this review, we will discuss a variety of allogeneic CAR cell therapy platforms that are being developed, including the use of different immune cells and/or subtypes, as well as gene-editing techniques (Figure 1). Additionally, we will highlight clinical experiences with allogeneic CAR cell therapies and on-going clinical trials to treat malignancies.

Figure 1

The Need for Allogeneic CAR Therapies

Most CAR cell therapies to date, including the FDA approved products, are generated using autologous T cells. This has several important advantages, including infusion of CAR-engineered cell products without immunologic mismatch between donor and recipient. However, the use of autologous immune cells also has clinical and economical disadvantages. Autologous CAR cell production can be long and complicated. The process includes navigating the logistics of performing successful leukapheresis for a patient with relapsed/refractory malignant disease, accessing a manufacturing/treatment facility, and shipping and manufacturing times that commonly take several weeks. This time delay can be significant, particularly in a group of patients with aggressive relapsed/resistant cancers, who are at risk of clinical deterioration which could preclude proceeding with CAR cell therapy. Furthermore, generation of a cell product is not guaranteed and for those whom a product can be successfully generated, a proportion have limited short- or long-term efficacy. This is likely in part due to poor autologous immune cell fitness in cancer patients, particularly following aggressive cancer-directed therapies (15). Earlier collection of T cells may ameliorate some issues related to autologous T cell fitness. However, this strategy would only benefit the subset of patients determined to be at high-risk of needing CAR therapy early on in their disease process. Lastly, autologous cell therapy is performed for individual patients and is associated with significant costs, limiting broader applications of this therapy (16, 17).

The use of immune cells from donors, or allogeneic cell therapies, offers many advantages over autologous cells including the potential to be cost effective, readily available, and provide a higher quality product (Figure 2). Healthy donor cells confer a more uniform starting material, allowing for more predictable manufacturing and performance of generated cell product. Following the single donor to single recipient model, use of a family member would provide an easily accessible and highly motivated allogeneic donor. Furthermore, allogeneic therapies have the potential to provide a ready to use “off the shelf” immunotherapeutic, such that a single manufacturing run would allow dosing for several patients and/or multiple dosing for individual patients. Likewise, by increasing the scale of production and creating an inventory or bank of manufactured CAR immune cells from healthy donors, the cost per patient would decrease while access to product would increase.

Figure 2

Challenges with Allogeneic Therapies

Despite the recognized potential benefits of allogeneic CAR therapies, they are not without risk and significant challenges must be overcome in order to successfully implement this approach. These challenges stem from the immunologic mismatch between donor and recipient, and the resultant bidirectional risk to the cellular product and to the recipient in vivo. If the administered allogeneic cells recognize and attack healthy recipient tissues, the cellular therapy may cause unwanted graft-versus-host-disease (GVHD). Conversely, if the recipient’s immune system recognizes and reacts against the allogeneic product the cell therapy may be rejected, limiting the therapeutic effect.

Graft-Versus-Host-Disease

Allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplant (HCT) highlights the significant risk of GVHD by adoptive transfer of allogeneic T cells (18). Human leukocyte antigen (HLA) mismatch between donor and recipient leads to donor immune recognition of, and subsequent alloreactivity against, recipient tissues (19–21). Clinically, this is manifested as GVHD. T cells are primarily responsible for causing acute GVHD, triggering tissue cell death via FAS ligand, perforin, granzyme and other signaling pathways (22, 23). The risk of GVHD correlates with increasing donor/recipient HLA-disparity. Most commonly affecting the skin, gastrointestinal tract and liver, GVHD carries a significant risk of post-HCT morbidity and mortality (24, 25). In HCT, the risk of GVHD may be mitigated through donor selection, T cell depletion/selection and/or use of immunosuppressive pharmacologic therapies (26–30). However, some of these strategies are in direct opposition with the goals of allogeneic CAR therapies which depend on highly immunocompetent cells. Therefore, decreasing the risk of GVHD from allogeneic CAR immune cells must balance with the need to retain high levels of immune activity of the effector cell. Such strategies may include T cell-subset selection or gene editing approaches, as well as continued exploration of cell products such as γδ T cells, invariant (i)NKT cells, or allogeneic NK cells that do not induce GVHD.

Immunogenicity

Expansion and persistence of CAR immune cells are important to achieve both short- and long-term efficacy. While desired duration of persistence may vary based on the malignancy being treated, it has been shown that prolonged remission of acute leukemia correlates with duration of persistence of autologous CAR T cells (31). In the autologous setting, CAR cell longevity can be compromised through immunological rejection of the CARs “foreign” proteins. The use of allogeneic immune cells carries further increased risk of immunogenicity as both the CAR and effector cells are “foreign.” Acutely, this would result in impaired short-term responses as cells are rejected before exerting the intended therapeutic effect. The use of lymphodepleting chemotherapy prior to infusion of allogeneic CAR cellular products should mitigate the risk of acute rejection, augmenting CAR cell persistence (32). However, subsequent recipient immune reconstitution may result in delayed rejection of the adoptively transferred cells, providing an opportunity for malignant relapse. Furthermore, the use of allogeneic cells confers risk of alloimmunization, where the recipient develops donor-specific anti-HLA antibodies (DSAs). Alloimmunization is a well-recognized cause of graft failure and rejection in HCT (33). While desensitization strategies exist, the development of DSAs may preclude a patient from proceeding with HCT in the future or limit re-dosing of the allogeneic CAR product. Genetic modification to remove donor major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules or expansion of donor pools to allow for increased HLA-matching may mitigate these risks.

Allogeneic CAR Strategies by Effector Cell Type

The most widely used CAR platform currently in clinical practice are CAR T cells. These products are largely manufactured using a batched pool of autologous donor T cells collected via peripheral blood leukapheresis and the CAR-T product administered without selection of specific cell types. While this strategy may work in the autologous setting, to mitigate potential risk of using allogeneic immune cells strategies using various T cell subgroups or different immune cell types are being tested in both preclinical and clinical settings. Here we review strategies being explored to make allogeneic CAR immune therapy possible, as well as on-going clinical trials evaluating these strategies (Table 1).

Table 1

TargetDiagnosisStrategy to reduce GVHD and/or rejectionOther genetic modificationNCT #
T cells
BCMAMMTRAC KOCAR (LV), CD52KONCT04093596
MMTRAC and B2M KOCAR (knock in)NCT04244656
CD7T-cell leuk or lymphTRAC KOCAR (*), CD7 KONCT04264078
CD19NHLTRAC KOCAR (LV), CD52KONCT03939026
NHLTRAC KOCAR (LV), CD52KONCT04416984
B-ALLTRAC KOCAR (LV), CD52KONCT02808442
ALL*CAR (*)NCT04173988
B-cell leuk or lymphTRAC and B2M KOCAR (LV)NCT03166878
B-cell leuk or lymphTRAC and B2M KOCAR (knock in)NCT04035434
B-cell leuk or lymph*CAR (*)NCT04384393
B-cell leuk or lymph*CAR (*)NCT04264039
Leuk or lymph*CAR (*)NCT04227015
B-ALL or lymphTRAC KOCAR (knock in)NCT03666000
B-cell leuk or lymph*CAR (*)NCT03229876
B-ALL*CAR (*)NCT04166838
CD19/20/22Leuk or lymphTRAC KOCAR (*)NCT03398967
CD20Lymph*CAR (*)NCT04176913
B-cell lymph or CLL*CAR (knock in)NCT04030195
CD22B-ALLTRAC KOCAR (LV), CD52KONCT04150497
CD70Leuk or lymphTRAC and B2M KOCAR (knock in)NCT04502446
RCCTRAC and B2M KOCAR (knock in)NCT04438083
CD123AMLTRAC KOCAR (LV)NCT03190278
CS1MMTRAC KOCAR (LV)NCT04142619**
NKG2DLCRC*CAR (RV)NCT03692429
MesothelinMesothelin+ STTRAC KOCAR, PD1 KONCT03545815
EBV-specific T cells
CD19Leuk or lymphCell productCAR (RV)NCT01430390
CD30LymphCell productCAR (RV)NCT04288726**
γδ T cells
NKG2DLSTCell productCAR (RV)NCT04107142**
iNKT cells
CD19B-cell leuk or lymphCell productCAR (RV), IL15NCT03774654
NK cells
CD19B-cell leuk or lymphCell product (cord blood)CAR (RV), IL15NCT03056339
CD19B-cell lymph or CLLCell product (iPSC)CAR, IL15, CD16NCT04245722

Selected clinical studies with allogeneic CAR immune cells.

ALL, acute lymphoblastic leukemia; CLL, chronic lymphatic leukemia; CRC, colorectal cancer; NHL, non-Hodgkin lymphoma; MM, multiple myeloma; Leuk, Leukemia; Lymph, lymphoma; RCC, renal cell carcinoma; ST, solid tumor.

LV, lentivirus; RV, retrovirus; *not disclosed; **not yet recruiting or currently closed for recruitment (as of 10’2020).

T Cells

T cells are a powerful component of the human immune system, providing surveillance for, and protection against, foreign antigen. Antigen recognition occurs via the T cell receptor (TCR), a heterodimer complex composed of two subunits and located on the surface of T cells. In a healthy donor, the majority (> 90%) of circulating T cells have a TCR consisting of an alpha (α) and beta (β) chain, referred to as an αβ T cell (34). The remaining T cells contain a TCR composed of a gamma (γ) and delta (δ) subunit, γδ T cells (35). The interaction between the TCR and antigen triggers a signaling cascade through the TCR which activates the T cell. αβ T cells recognize foreign or non-self-antigen presented through the MHC on antigen presenting cells, while γδ T cells are MHC-independent (36). Furthermore, αβ T cells can be subdivided based on function (i.e., CD4-positive and CD8-positive T cells) and/or degree of differentiation (i.e., naïve and memory T cells) (37, 38). When a T cell is transduced with a CAR, the CAR adds an additional receptor to the T cell without interruption to the native TCR. CAR T cells can expand and contract in response to antigen stimuli via the CAR, allowing for robust responses in the setting of active target recognition, but also potential for memory-surveillance state when an intended target is not currently present. Below, we review different types of T cells used to generate allogeneic CAR T cells.

T Cells From Prior Allogeneic Transplant Donor

The use of donor lymphocyte infusion (DLI) after allogeneic HCT is a standard clinical practice. The therapeutic intent of unmodified DLI centers on the properties of donor T cells, such that they can correct mixed donor/recipient chimerism and combat viral infections (39). However, DLIs are not specific for TAAs and therefore have minimal anti-cancer benefit, especially outside the setting of minimal residual disease (39–41). As CAR T cells began to be explored clinically for the treatment of active disease, an initial venture into allogeneic CAR T cell products focused on the post-HCT population using T cells from the HCT donor. Brudno et al. evaluated the use of allogeneic CD19-directed CAR T cells derived from an individual patient’s HCT donor to treat patients with progressive disease after transplant, who had a median donor chimerism of 100%, demonstrating anti-tumor benefits and safety of this approach, including no reports of new-onset GVHD (42). This study exemplified the possibility of increasing the potential for graft-versus-tumor effect of donor-derived T cells, without significantly increasing risk of GVHD.

The use of HCT-donor-derived CAR T cells is limited to post-HCT patients with an available and willing donor, whom are largely treated at facilities with the capability to manufacture clinical grade CAR T cell products. Therefore, this method is innately lacking some of the benefits of an “off the shelf product” and is not widely accessible. However, several benefits of using an allogeneic product are retained, including the use of healthy donor cells, ease of leukapheresis timing and minimal risk of diminished persistence in vivo due to lack of HLA-mismatch. Additionally, this approach allows for exploration into the use of CAR T cells in different disease settings such as prophylaxis post-HCT to reduce relapse in high-risk populations. Data suggest that this strategy is feasible without added toxicity and, in addition to providing leukemic control, may help with control of viral-reactivations post-HCT via native TCR recognition (43, 44).

Virus-Specific T Cells

The adoptive transfer of allogeneic virus-specific T cells (VSTs) has emerged as a safe and effective means of providing antiviral benefit in multiple patient populations (45–48). This has led to the generation of partially HLA-matched banks comprised of libraries of “off the shelf,” purified allogeneic VSTs. Importantly, across numerous clinical studies including in allogeneic HCT populations, the incidence of GVHD has been very minimal. Although the complete mechanism is not fully understood, decreased TCR diversity in VSTs (i.e., memory T cells) is felt to decrease the risk of alloreactivity (i.e., GVHD).

The safety profile seen using allogeneic VSTs created interest in the development of an allogeneic platform using CAR-transduced VSTs. Demonstrating feasibility of VSTs as effector cells, autologous CAR transduced VSTs targeting TAAs (CD30 [Hodgkin lymphoma], HER2 [glioblastoma] and GD2 [neuroblastoma, osteosarcoma]) have successfully been manufactured and infused into patients, with encouraging safety and efficacy profiles (49–51). This strategy has also been explored in the post-HCT patient population using primarily donor-derived VSTs and thus far results are promising. In one study, CD19-redirected VSTs were generated using peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) collected from the HCT donor and then infused into patients with B-cell malignancy at escalating doses (52). Manufacturing time for this product was significant, requiring culture for 5 – 6 weeks. Treatment was well tolerated with no GVHD and there was evidence of anti-leukemia activity, as well as retained recognition of viral stimuli. Similar preliminary results have been reported in an on-going trial evaluating allogeneic EBV-specific T cells transduced with a CD19-CAR (NCT 01430390) (53). Notably, donor sources in this trial include the HCT donor or 3rd party donors when the HCT donor is not available, with recipients of the CAR-transduced 3rd party cells also showing encouraging response rates.

Clinical experience to date with allogeneic CAR-transduced VSTs has shown intended anti-tumor effects with minimal GVHD risk. Additional benefit includes the finding that viral-specificity is retained and can trigger CAR T cell expansion in vivo, thereby potentially providing on-going, intermittent stimulus and promoting persistence. A limitation of studies thus far centers on the fact that data are largely confined to CAR-transduced VSTs derived from a patients’ HCT donor, thereby drastically minimizing the challenges of rejection and alloimmunization. Drawing from clinical experiences with unmodified VSTs from 3rd party banks, persistence of VSTs is typically limited to a few months (48); therefore, we would hypothesize that the issue of rejection and limited persistence of CAR-transduced VSTs remains.

Memory T Cells

When devising strategies for allogeneic cellular therapies the use of memory T cell subsets as effector cells may confer a decreased risk of GVHD. T cell maturation and differentiation inversely correlates with alloreactivity, such that memory T cell subsets are less alloreactive than naïve T cells. Therefore, memory T cells are less likely to cause GVHD in the HLA-mismatched setting (54). Functionally it has also been noted that the effectiveness and persistence of CAR T cells is influenced by the degree of differentiation of the T cell subsets in autologous CAR T cell platforms (55–58). While the use of memory T cells to generate autologous CAR T cells is actively being studied using a variety of CAR constructs (NCT03389230, NCT02146924, NCT02051257, NCT03288493), their use in the allogeneic setting has not yet been evaluated.

T cell subsets can be distinguished through identification of extracellular surface markers, including CD45RO, CD45RA, CD62L, CCR7 and CD27 (37, 38). Several studies have highlighted that generating CAR T cells from central memory (CD45RO+/CD62L+ or CCR7+) T cells or memory stem cells (Tscm) T cell populations is associated with improved CAR T-cell effector function (59–61). Other groups have just focused on utilizing CD45RA-negative T cells, which includes the central memory and effector memory T cell subsets, since these subsets have decreased alloreactive potential (62). After showing promise in animal models, CD45RA-depletion began to be studied in human allogeneic HCT. Clinical studies demonstrated that this approach is feasible and carried a decreased risk of GVHD, both when utilized in primary graft manipulation and post-transplant DLI (63–67). Building upon this clinical experience, the role of memory T cell subsets as effector cells in CAR therapy has been studied pre-clinically. Investigators have shown that CD45RA-negative T cells expressing either a NKG2DL-specific or CD19-CAR have anti-cancer effects and decreased in vivo and in vitro alloreactivity (68–70). Using a similar approach, CD19-CAR-engineered CD27-negative T cells (effector and terminal effector memory subsets) have also shown promise in preclinical models (71). These data suggest that the approach of using allogeneic memory T cells as effector cells in CAR therapy may have merit in the clinical arena; however, additional studies are needed to define the optimal memory T cell subset, which should be used as a source to generate memory CAR T cells with reduced alloreactivity.

Genetically Modified αβ T Cells

Several strategies are being explored to improve allogeneic αβ T cells, which are summarized in Figure 3. Gene editing of T cells to reduce the risk of GVHD and rejection is perhaps the most promising and widespread approach, particularly for the development of an “off the shelf” product. Given that GVHD is driven in large part by TCR recognition of host tissue, gene-editing approaches focused on the native αβ TCR of the effector cell are under investigation. Many groups have explored disrupting the T cell receptor constant alpha chain (TRAC) or beta chain (TRBC). Torikai et al. showed that knocking out the αβ TCR from CD19-CAR T cells did not significantly alter the cells ability to kill CD19-positive targets (72). This initial report in 2012 used zinc finger nuclease mediated knockout of TRAC or TRBC. In recent years, with advancement in gene editing techniques, numerous groups have demonstrated knockout of TRAC using transcription activator like effector nucleases (TALENs) as well as CRISPR/Cas9 (73, 74). Another technique, targeting the CAR to the TRAC locus, was associated with improved anti-tumor activity in one preclinical study (74). In addition to gene-editing approaches, protein-based strategies are being developed to retain the TCR within the Golgi apparatus using an anti-TCR linked to the KDEL motive (75). While these techniques have become increasingly efficient, any remaining T cells that continue to express αβ TCR can be removed magnetically ex vivo using anti- αβTCR antibodies. Stenger et al. showed that TCR knockout of CD19-CAR T cells had high anti-leukemic functionality in the absence of alloreactivity. However, the gene-edited CAR T cells did not persist as long in vivo compared to CAR T cells with endogenous TCR, demonstrating a possible concern with this technique (76). Furthermore, modification to the endogenous TCR does not address the issue of immunogenicity.

Figure 3

To decrease immunogenicity, investigators have targeted β-2 microglobulin (B2M), a component of HLA class I molecules that is present on all T cells (77). As recipient T cell recognition of allogeneic CAR T cells can occur via interaction of HLA/MHC, knockout of the B2M gene in CAR T cells may prevent alloantigen presentation by infused the T cells. This thereby offers another strategy to limit host recognition and clearance of infused allogeneic CAR T cells. Ren et al. showed that CAR T cells including knockout of B2M had reduced alloreactivity in vivo (78). Kagoya et al. showed that B2M knockout to eliminate HLA class I as well as knockout of class II major histocompatibility complex transactivator (CIITA) to eliminate HLA class II improved CAR T cells persistence in vitro (79). Other strategies to mitigate immunogenicity rely on depleting resident immune cells. Lymphodepleting chemotherapy prior to cellular infusion by itself should reduce immune-mediated clearance of CAR T cells, however immune responses to components of the CAR have been reported (80–82). To increase immunosuppression post-CAR T cell infusion, investigators have explored the use of the monoclonal antibody, alemtuzumab, which targets the pan-lymphocyte antigen CD52 (83). Since the mean half-life of alemtuzumab is 6.1 days (84), this approach would require the knockout of CD52 on allogeneic CAR T cells to prevent their depletion post infusion (85). Since the use of alemtuzumab is associated with an increased risk of viral reactivation/infection (e.g. cytomegalovirus, adenovirus) after allogeneic HCT (86, 87), close monitoring of recipients of alemtuzumab and CAR T cells is warranted for now since the risk of viral reactivation/infection in the setting of CAR T cell therapy is currently unknown. Lastly, active depletion of alloreactive host T cells is being explored including the expression of so called alloimmune defense receptors (ADRs) on infused allogeneic T cells that selectively recognizes 4-1BB, a cell surface receptor that is temporarily upregulated by activated host T cells (88).

Several clinical trials using gene-edited allogeneic CAR T cells are actively enrolling with some early results presented in abstract format. Many of these products include knockout of both CD52 and TRAC, to address both risk of GVHD and rejection. Pooled data from the CALM (NCT 02746952) and PALL (NCT02808442) studies (cellular product: UCART19) were presented by Allogene Therapeutics and Servier. UCART19 features an anti-CD19 scFv, as well as TRAC and CD52 knockout and was first shown to have clinical activity in two infants with B-ALL who achieved molecular remission after treatment (89). Data presented included 17 patients with relapsed/refractory B-ALL treated with a lymphodepleting regimen including alemtuzamab, 14 of whom had a CR or CRi. Additionally, UCART19 showed overall an acceptable safety profile (90). Neelapu et al. presented early results from the ALLO-501 trial (NCT03939026), which evaluates an allogeneic CAR T cell product targeting CD19 with knock out of TRAC and CD52, and includes a novel CD52 antibody for lymphodepletion prior to CAR T cell infusion. Twenty-two patients had been enrolled, with response seen in 12 of 19 evaluable patients (7 complete responses) (91). Wang et al. presented the first 5 patients treated with TruUCART GC027, an allogeneic anti-CD7 CAR T cell product with knock out of TRAC and CD7 by CRISP/Cas9 gene editing technology to avoid both GVHD and fratricide. Four of the initial 5 treated patients showed a complete response with an acceptable safety profile (92).

Gene editing has emerged as the leading strategy being tested in the clinic as investigators seek to develop an “off the shelf” allogeneic CAR therapy platform. As gene editing techniques advance, this method offers great potential to mitigate potential risks and downsides associated with the use of allogeneic cells. By increasing the number of genetic edits made to a single cell the possibilities increase; however, it will take time to thoroughly investigate the short- and long-term safety of these gene edited products in patients.

γδ T Cells

Animal models show that γδ T cells play an important role in tissue homeostasis and cancer immunosurveillance (93). Allogeneic γδ T cells have been given to patients with cancer after lymphodepleting chemotherapy and were shown to expand in vivo without causing GVHD (94). γδ T cells recognize cancer through a broad spectrum of receptors, rather than in a single clonally expanded fashion, which may mitigate tumor escape via single antigen loss (95). These T cells are also typically abundant in tissues, which may provide an advantage over αβ T cells when developing therapeutics to treat solid tumors (93). Their ability to recognize targets in an MHC independent manner confers a low risk of alloreactivity and GVHD, thereby increasing the potential of using allogeneic γδ T cells in CAR T cell therapies.

Polyclonal γδT cells transduced with a CD19-CAR have been shown to expand and demonstrated anti-tumor effects in vitro and in in vivo murine models (96). Capsomidis et al. demonstrated CAR dependent antigen specific killing in vitro using GD2-CAR γδ T cells (97). Several companies are now moving forward with clinical trial development using allogeneic CAR-transduced γδ T cells including, Adicet Bio, Cytomed Therapeutics, GammaDelta Therapeutics and TC BioPharm (98). Furthermore, a clinical trial evaluating allogeneic CAR γδ T cells targeting NKG2DL for the treatment of solid tumors has been registered on clinicaltrials.gov, but is not yet recruiting (NCT04107142).

iNKT Cells

Invariant natural killer T (iNKT) cells are a rare subclass of immune cells that are restricted by CD1d, a glycolipid presenting HLA I like molecule expressed on B cells, antigen presenting cells and some epithelial tissues (99–101). Thus, since iNKT express an invariant TCR, they do not cause GVHD. iNKT cells have been shown to be decreased in number and defective in cancer patients (102–104). iNKT cells also protect from GVHD after allogeneic HCT (105–107). Preclinical studies of iNKT engineered with CARs targeting CD19 and GD2 have been effective in murine models against lymphoma and neuroblastoma, respectively (108–110). CAR-engineered iNKT cells also appear to be safe in humans and are promising for “off the shelf” use given the lack of GVHD. Preliminary results from an ongoing trial (NCT03294954) using autologous GD2-CAR iNKT cells with co-expression of IL15 for the treatment of pediatric patients with neuroblastoma have shown this approach to be feasible and safe (111). Clinical experience of allogeneic CAR iNKT cells is yet to be published so possible adverse events cannot be predicted, however an ongoing clinical trial evaluating allogeneic CAR19-iNKT cells for the treatment of hematological malignancy (NCT03774654) aims to test safety and efficacy.

NK Cells

NK cells, are of great interest in the treatment of cancer as they contribute to graft-versus-tumor effect and do not cause GVHD (112, 113). Endogenous NK cells are part of the innate immune system and can target cancer cells that downregulate HLA class I molecules (112). Tumor cells often downregulate their HLA molecules as an escape mechanism against T cells, making them susceptible to NK cells (114–116). Clinically, adoptively transferred non-CAR engineered allogeneic NK cells have shown to be safe in patients with cancer (117–120). NK cells are a promising alternative to T cells for CAR engineering given the low risk of GVHD and their innate anti-cancer properties. Numerous preclinical studies have shown CAR engineered NK cells to be effective against hematologic malignancy targets (CD19 and CD20), as well as solid tumor targets (WT1 and GD2) (121–126). Notably, Liu et al. published results on 11 patients with lymphoid tumors, treated on an early phase clinical trial using allogeneic (cord blood derived) NK cells transduced with a gene containing a CD19-CAR, IL-15, and an inducible caspase 9 safety switch. In this study, 73% of patients demonstrated anti-tumor response. Inclusion of IL-15 in the CAR construct may have contributed to the persistence of the NK cells, which were shown to expand and persist for at least 12 months. There were no major toxic effects of the therapy (127).

Allogeneic NK cells can be prepared form numerous sources, including peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs), cord blood, and pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) (128). In addition, a NK-cell line, NK-92, genetically modified to express a CAR, is actively being explored in early phase clinical testing (NCT03383978) (129). Current strategies to generate clinical grade NK cells from PBMCs or cord blood rely on the use of irradiated feeder cells, most commonly K562 cells genetically modified to express i) 4-1BBL and membrane-bound (mb) IL15 or ii) mbIL21 and exogenous IL2 (130–132). More recently, exosomes or plasma membrane particles derived from mbIL21 expressing K562 cells have also been successfully used for the ex vivo expansion of NK cells (133). iPSCs present an attractive source for generating NK cells without feeder cells (134, 135), and an early phase clinical study with unmodified iPSC-derived NK cells is in progress (NCT03841110). In addition, iPSC cells can be genetically modified and/or gene edited prior to NK cell differentiation, enabling the provision of an unlimited supply of modified NK cells (136–138).

Discussion

Autologous CAR T cell therapy has revolutionized the treatment of hematological malignancies, highlighting the therapeutic potential of cellular therapies, as well as opportunities for continued improvement. Subsequently, the number of CAR therapy trials has increased dramatically in recent years, exploring new targets, manufacturing strategies, CAR constructs, patient populations and effector cells. While many of these trials continue to use autologous immune cells, the number using allogeneic CAR products are rapidly increasing. The apparent benefits of allogeneic therapies have spurred a robust interest in developing techniques that counter the predicted limitations, including exploration of various effector cell types and gene editing techniques. One hurdle that will definitively need to be addressed is immunogenicity, which already has emerged as a potential roadblock of autologous CAR T cell therapies, especially when no lymphodepleting chemotherapy is given prior to T cell infusion (139). Thus, recipients of “off the shelf” cell products might require immune-modulation post cell infusion to enable their long-term persistence. However, given the extensive experience with allogeneic HCT and solid organ transplantation, we believe that immunogenicity will not present an unsurmountable barrier. While production of “off the shelf” therapeutic products require increased resources during the development and manufacturing process, the ultimate goal is to develop cell products that have a favorable safety and efficacy profile and are widely accessible and affordable. However, at present it is too early to estimate the cost of an allogeneic cell product; this will depend on the required genetic modifications, which might include not only viral transduction but also gene-editing. Another driving factor of cost will be how many cell doses can be prepared from one lot of “off the shelf” cell products since release testing of genetically-modified cell products is cost intense. Nevertheless, we believe that continued investment in the optimization of these allogeneic strategies is warranted based on the current data and that allogeneic cell products will usher in a new era of cell therapy.

Funding

The work of the authors is in part supported by the National Cancer Institute/National Institutes of Health grant P30CA021765. The content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the NIH.

Statements

Author’s note

Figures created with BioRender.com.

Author contributions

KC, SG, and AT wrote, reviewed, and edited the manuscript. All authors contributed to the article and approved the submitted version.

Conflict of interest

SG has patent applications in the field of immunotherapy, is a DSMB member of Immatics, and on the scientific advisory board of Tidal.

The remaining authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.

References

  • 1

    EshharZWaksTGrossGSchindlerDG. Specific activation and targeting of cytotoxic lymphocytes through chimeric single chains consisting of antibody-binding domains and the gamma or zeta subunits of the immunoglobulin and T-cell receptors. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA (1993) 90(2):720–4. doi: 10.1073/pnas.90.2.720

  • 2

    GrossGGorochovGWaksTEshharZ. Generation of effector T cells expressing chimeric T cell receptor with antibody type-specificity. Transplant Proc (1989) 21(1 Pt 1):127–30.

  • 3

    GrossGWaksTEshharZ. Expression of immunoglobulin-T-cell receptor chimeric molecules as functional receptors with antibody-type specificity. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA (1989) 86(24):10024–8. doi: 10.1073/pnas.86.24.10024

  • 4

    GruppSAKalosMBarrettDAplencRPorterDLRheingoldSRet al. Chimeric antigen receptor-modified T cells for acute lymphoid leukemia. N Engl J Med (2013) 368(16):1509–18. doi: 10.1056/NEJMoa1215134

  • 5

    PorterDLLevineBLKalosMBaggAJuneCH. Chimeric antigen receptor-modified T cells in chronic lymphoid leukemia. N Engl J Med (2011) 365(8):725–33. doi: 10.1056/NEJMoa1103849

  • 6

    MaudeSLLaetschTWBuechnerJRivesSBoyerMBittencourtHet al. Tisagenlecleucel in Children and Young Adults with B-Cell Lymphoblastic Leukemia. N Engl J Med (2018) 378(5):439–48. doi: 10.1056/NEJMoa1709866

  • 7

    NeelapuSSLockeFLBartlettNLLekakisLJMiklosDBJacobsonCAet al. Axicabtagene Ciloleucel CAR T-Cell Therapy in Refractory Large B-Cell Lymphoma. N Engl J Med (2017) 377(26):2531–44. doi: 10.1056/NEJMoa1707447

  • 8

    SchusterSJBishopMRTamCSWallerEKBorchmannPMcGuirkJPet al. Tisagenlecleucel in Adult Relapsed or Refractory Diffuse Large B-Cell Lymphoma. N Engl J Med (2019) 380(1):45–56. doi: 10.1056/NEJMoa1804980

  • 9

    WangMMunozJGoyALockeFLJacobsonCAHillBTet al. KTE-X19 CAR T-Cell Therapy in Relapsed or Refractory Mantle-Cell Lymphoma. N Engl J Med (2020) 382(14):1331–42. doi: 10.1056/NEJMoa1914347

  • 10

    RamosCAGroverNSBeavenAWLullaPDWuM-FIvanovaAet al. Anti-CD30 CAR-T Cell Therapy in Relapsed and Refractory Hodgkin Lymphoma. J Clin Oncol (2020) 38(32):3794–804. doi: 10.1200/JCO.20.01342

  • 11

    RajeNBerdejaJLinYSiegelDJagannathSMadduriDet al. Anti-BCMA CAR T-Cell Therapy bb2121 in Relapsed or Refractory Multiple Myeloma. N Engl J Med (2019) 380(18):1726–37. doi: 10.1056/NEJMoa1817226

  • 12

    ShahNNHighfillSLShalabiHYatesBJinJWoltersPLet al. CD4/CD8 T-Cell Selection Affects Chimeric Antigen Receptor (CAR) T-Cell Potency and Toxicity: Updated Results From a Phase I Anti-CD22 CAR T-Cell Trial. J Clin Oncol (2020) 38(17):1938–50. doi: 10.1200/JCO.19.03279

  • 13

    TillBGJensenMCWangJQianXGopalAKMaloneyDGet al. CD20-specific adoptive immunotherapy for lymphoma using a chimeric antigen receptor with both CD28 and 4-1BB domains: pilot clinical trial results. Blood (2012) 119(17):3940–50. doi: 10.1182/blood-2011-10-387969

  • 14

    RoddieCO’ReillyMDias Alves PintoJVisputeKLowdellM. Manufacturing chimeric antigen receptor T cells: issues and challenges. Cytotherapy (2019) 21(3):327–40. doi: 10.1016/j.jcyt.2018.11.009

  • 15

    ThommenDSSchumacherTN. T Cell Dysfunction in Cancer. Cancer Cell (2018) 33(4):547–62. doi: 10.1016/j.ccell.2018.03.012

  • 16

    LinJKLermanBJBarnesJIBoursiquotBCTanYJRobinsonAQLet al. Cost Effectiveness of Chimeric Antigen Receptor T-Cell Therapy in Relapsed or Refractory Pediatric B-Cell Acute Lymphoblastic Leukemia. J Clin Oncol (2018) 36(32):3192–202. doi: 10.1200/JCO.2018.79.0642

  • 17

    LinJKMufflyLSSpinnerMABarnesJIOwensDKGoldhaber-FiebertJD. Cost Effectiveness of Chimeric Antigen Receptor T-Cell Therapy in Multiply Relapsed or Refractory Adult Large B-Cell Lymphoma. J Clin Oncol (2019) 37(24):2105–19. doi: 10.1200/JCO.18.02079

  • 18

    ZeiserRBlazarBR. Acute Graft-versus-Host Disease - Biologic Process, Prevention, and Therapy. N Engl J Med (2017) 377(22):2167–79. doi: 10.1056/NEJMra1609337

  • 19

    CarapitoRJungNKwemouMUntrauMMichelSPichotAet al. Matching for the nonconventional MHC-I MICA gene significantly reduces the incidence of acute and chronic GVHD. Blood (2016) 128(15):1979–86. doi: 10.1182/blood-2016-05-719070

  • 20

    MartinPJLevineDMStorerBEWarrenEHZhengXNelsonSCet al. Genome-wide minor histocompatibility matching as related to the risk of graft-versus-host disease. Blood (2017) 129(6):791–8. doi: 10.1182/blood-2016-09-737700

  • 21

    SantosNRodríguez-RomanosRNietoJBBuñoIVallejoCJiménez-VelascoAet al. UGT2B17 minor histocompatibility mismatch and clinical outcome after HLA-identical sibling donor stem cell transplantation. Bone Marrow Transplant (2016) 51(1):79–82. doi: 10.1038/bmt.2015.207

  • 22

    BakerMBAltmanNHPodackERLevyRB. The role of cell-mediated cytotoxicity in acute GVHD after MHC-matched allogeneic bone marrow transplantation in mice. J Exp Med (1996) 183(6):2645–56. doi: 10.1084/jem.183.6.2645

  • 23

    GraubertTADiPersioJFRussellJHLeyTJ. Perforin/granzyme-dependent and independent mechanisms are both important for the development of graft-versus-host disease after murine bone marrow transplantation. J Clin Invest (1997) 100(4):904–11. doi: 10.1172/JCI119606

  • 24

    GlucksbergHStorbRFeferABucknerCDNeimanPECliftRAet al. Clinical manifestations of graft-versus-host disease in human recipients of marrow from HL-A-matched sibling donors. Transplantation (1974) 18(4):295–304. doi: 10.1097/00007890-197410000-00001

  • 25

    HarrisACYoungRDevineSHoganWJAyukFBunworasateUet al. International, Multicenter Standardization of Acute Graft-versus-Host Disease Clinical Data Collection: A Report from the Mount Sinai Acute GVHD International Consortium. Biol Blood Marrow Transplant (2016) 22(1):4–10. doi: 10.1016/j.bbmt.2015.09.001

  • 26

    BleakleyMHeimfeldSLoebKRJonesLAChaneyCSeropianSet al. Outcomes of acute leukemia patients transplanted with naive T cell-depleted stem cell grafts. J Clin Invest (2015) 125(7):2677–89. doi: 10.1172/JCI81229

  • 27

    KrögerNSolanoCWolschkeCBandiniGPatriarcaFPiniMet al. Antilymphocyte Globulin for Prevention of Chronic Graft-versus-Host Disease. N Engl J Med (2016) 374(1):43–53. doi: 10.1056/NEJMoa1506002

  • 28

    LangPFeuchtingerTTeltschikHMSchwingerWSchlegelPPfeifferMet al. Improved immune recovery after transplantation of TCRαβ/CD19-depleted allografts from haploidentical donors in pediatric patients. Bone Marrow Transplant (2015) 50(Suppl 2):S6–10. doi: 10.1038/bmt.2015.87

  • 29

    Urbano-IspizuaARozmanCMartínezCMarínPBrionesJRoviraMet al. Rapid engraftment without significant graft-versus-host disease after allogeneic transplantation of CD34+ selected cells from peripheral blood. Blood (1997) 89(11):3967–73. doi: 10.1182/blood.V89.11.3967

  • 30

    ZeiserRLeveson-GowerDBZambrickiEAKambhamNBeilhackALohJet al. Differential impact of mammalian target of rapamycin inhibition on CD4+CD25+Foxp3+ regulatory T cells compared with conventional CD4+ T cells. Blood (2008) 111(1):453–62. doi: 10.1182/blood-2007-06-094482

  • 31

    FinneyOCBrakkeHMRawlings-RheaSHicksRDoolittleDLopezMet al. CD19 CAR T cell product and disease attributes predict leukemia remission durability. J Clin Invest (2019) 129(5):2123–32. doi: 10.1172/JCI125423

  • 32

    KlebanoffCAKhongHTAntonyPAPalmerDCRestifoNP. Sinks, suppressors and antigen presenters: how lymphodepletion enhances T cell-mediated tumor immunotherapy. Trends Immunol (2005) 26(2):111–7. doi: 10.1016/j.it.2004.12.003

  • 33

    CiureaSOCaoKFernandez-VinaMKongtimPMalkiMAFuchsEet al. The European Society for Blood and Marrow Transplantation (EBMT) Consensus Guidelines for the Detection and Treatment of Donor-specific Anti-HLA Antibodies (DSA) in Haploidentical Hematopoietic Cell Transplantation. Bone Marrow Transplant (2018) 53(5):521–34. doi: 10.1038/s41409-017-0062-8

  • 34

    KreslavskyTGleimerMGarbeAIvon BoehmerH. αβ versus γδ fate choice: counting the T-cell lineages at the branch point. Immunol Rev (2010) 238(1):169–81. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-065X.2010.00947.x

  • 35

    PauzaCDLiouMLLahusenTXiaoLLapidusRGCairoCet al. Gamma Delta T Cell Therapy for Cancer: It Is Good to be Local. Front Immunol (2018) 9:1305. doi: 10.3389/fimmu.2018.01305

  • 36

    LegutMColeDKSewellAK. The promise of γδ T cells and the γδ T cell receptor for cancer immunotherapy. Cell Mol Immunol (2015) 12(6):656–68. doi: 10.1038/cmi.2015.28

  • 37

    KochSLarbiADerhovanessianEOzcelikDNaumovaEPawelecG. Multiparameter flow cytometric analysis of CD4 and CD8 T cell subsets in young and old people. Immun Ageing (2008) 5:6. doi: 10.1186/1742-4933-5-6

  • 38

    van den BroekTBorghansJAMvan WijkF. The full spectrum of human naive T cells. Nat Rev Immunol (2018) 18(6):363–73. doi: 10.1038/s41577-018-0001-y

  • 39

    DeolALumLG. Role of donor lymphocyte infusions in relapsed hematological malignancies after stem cell transplantation revisited. Cancer Treat Rev (2010) 36(7):528–38. doi: 10.1016/j.ctrv.2010.03.004

  • 40

    KolbHJMittermüllerJClemmCHollerELedderoseGBrehmGet al. Donor leukocyte transfusions for treatment of recurrent chronic myelogenous leukemia in marrow transplant patients. Blood (1990) 76(12):2462–5. doi: 10.1182/blood.V76.12.2462.2462

  • 41

    PatiARGodderKLambLGeeAHenslee-DowneyPJ. Immunotherapy with donor leukocyte infusions for patients with relapsed acute myeloid leukemia following partially mismatched related donor bone marrow transplantation. Bone Marrow Transpl (1995) 15(6):979–81.

  • 42

    BrudnoJNSomervilleRPShiVRoseJJHalversonDCFowlerDHet al. Allogeneic T Cells That Express an Anti-CD19 Chimeric Antigen Receptor Induce Remissions of B-Cell Malignancies That Progress After Allogeneic Hematopoietic Stem-Cell Transplantation Without Causing Graft-Versus-Host Disease. J Clin Oncol (2016) 34(10):1112–21. doi: 10.1200/JCO.2015.64.5929

  • 43

    KebriaeiPSinghHHulsMHFigliolaMJBassettROlivaresSet al. Phase I trials using Sleeping Beauty to generate CD19-specific CAR T cells. J Clin Invest (2016) 126(9):3363–76. doi: 10.1172/JCI86721

  • 44

    KebriaeiPCiureaSOHulsMHSinghHOlivaresSSuSet al. Pre-Emptive Donor Lymphocyte Infusion with CD19-Directed, CAR-Modified T Cells Infused after Allogeneic Hematopoietic Cell Transplantation for Patients with Advanced CD19+ Malignancies. Blood (2015) 126(23):862–. doi: 10.1182/blood.V126.23.862.862

  • 45

    TzannouIPapadopoulouANaikSLeungKMartinezCARamosCAet al. Off-the-Shelf Virus-Specific T Cells to Treat BK Virus, Human Herpesvirus 6, Cytomegalovirus, Epstein-Barr Virus, and Adenovirus Infections After Allogeneic Hematopoietic Stem-Cell Transplantation. J Clin Oncol (2017) 35(31):3547–57. doi: 10.1200/JCO.2017.73.0655

  • 46

    LeenAMBollardCMMendizabalAMShpallEJSzabolcsPAntinJHet al. Multicenter study of banked third-party virus-specific T cells to treat severe viral infections after hematopoietic stem cell transplantation. Blood (2013) 121(26):5113–23. doi: 10.1182/blood-2013-02-486324

  • 47

    MelenhorstJJLeenAMBollardCMQuigleyMFPriceDARooneyCMet al. Allogeneic virus-specific T cells with HLA alloreactivity do not produce GVHD in human subjects. Blood (2010) 116(22):4700–2. doi: 10.1182/blood-2010-06-289991

  • 48

    O’ReillyRJProckopSHasanANKoehneGDoubrovinaE. Virus-specific T-cell banks for ‘off the shelf’ adoptive therapy of refractory infections. Bone Marrow Transpl (2016) 51(9):1163–72. doi: 10.1038/bmt.2016.17

  • 49

    PuleMASavoldoBMyersGDRossigCRussellHVDottiGet al. Virus-specific T cells engineered to coexpress tumor-specific receptors: persistence and antitumor activity in individuals with neuroblastoma. Nat Med (2008) 14(11):1264–70. doi: 10.1038/nm.1882

  • 50

    SavoldoBRooneyCMDi StasiAAbkenHHombachAFosterAEet al. Epstein Barr virus–specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes expressing the anti-CD30ζ artificial chimeric T-cell receptor for immunotherapy of Hodgkin disease. Blood (2007) 110(7):2620–30. doi: 10.1182/blood-2006-11-059139

  • 51

    AhmedNBrawleyVHegdeMBielamowiczKKalraMLandiDet al. Specific Chimeric Antigen Receptor-Modified Virus-Specific T Cells for Progressive Glioblastoma: A Phase 1 Dose-Escalation Trial. HER2-JAMA Oncol (2017) 3(8):1094–101. doi: 10.1001/jamaoncol.2017.0184

  • 52

    CruzCRMicklethwaiteKPSavoldoBRamosCALamSKuSet al. Infusion of donor-derived CD19-redirected virus-specific T cells for B-cell malignancies relapsed after allogeneic stem cell transplant: a phase 1 study. Blood (2013) 122(17):2965–73. doi: 10.1182/blood-2013-06-506741

  • 53

    CurranKJSauterCSKernanNAProckopSEBouladFPeralesMet al. Durable Remission Following “Off-the-Shelf” Chimeric Antigen Receptor (CAR) T-Cells in Patients with Relapse/Refractory (R/R) B-Cell Malignancies. Biol Blood Marrow Transplant (2020) 26(3, Supplement):S89. doi: 10.1016/j.bbmt.2019.12.590

  • 54

    AndersonBEMcNiffJYanJDoyleHMamulaMShlomchikMJet al. Memory CD4+ T cells do not induce graft-versus-host disease. J Clin Invest (2003) 112(1):101–8. doi: 10.1172/JCI17601

  • 55

    GolubovskayaVWuL. Different Subsets of T Cells, Memory, Effector Functions, and CAR-T Immunotherapy. Cancers (Basel) (2016) 8(3):36. doi: 10.3390/cancers8030036

  • 56

    RiddellSRSommermeyerDBergerCLiuLSBalakrishnanASalterAet al. Adoptive therapy with chimeric antigen receptor-modified T cells of defined subset composition. Cancer J (2014) 20(2):141–4. doi: 10.1097/PPO.0000000000000036

  • 57

    SinghNPerazzelliJGruppSABarrettDM. Early memory phenotypes drive T cell proliferation in patients with pediatric malignancies. Sci Transl Med (2016) 8(320):320ra3. doi: 10.1126/scitranslmed.aad5222

  • 58

    XuYZhangMRamosCADurettALiuEDakhovaOet al. Closely related T-memory stem cells correlate with in vivo expansion of CAR.CD19-T cells and are preserved by IL-7 and IL-15. Blood (2014) 123(24):3750–9. doi: 10.1182/blood-2014-01-552174

  • 59

    PriesnerCAleksandrovaKEsserRMockel-TenbrinckNLeiseJDrechselKet al. Automated Enrichment, Transduction, and Expansion of Clinical-Scale CD62L+ T Cells for Manufacturing of Gene Therapy Medicinal Products. Hum Gene Ther (2016) 27(10):860–9. doi: 10.1089/hum.2016.091

  • 60

    SabatinoMHuJSommarivaMGautamSFellowesVHockerJDet al. Generation of clinical-grade CD19-specific CAR-modified CD8+ memory stem cells for the treatment of human B-cell malignancies. Blood (2016) 128(4):519–28. doi: 10.1182/blood-2015-11-683847

  • 61

    SommermeyerDHudecekMKosasihPLGogishviliTMaloneyDGTurtleCJet al. Chimeric antigen receptor-modified T cells derived from defined CD8+ and CD4+ subsets confer superior antitumor reactivity in vivo. Leukemia (2016) 30(2):492–500. doi: 10.1038/leu.2015.247

  • 62

    SallustoFGeginatJLanzavecchiaA. Central memory and effector memory T cell subsets: function, generation, and maintenance. Annu Rev Immunol (2004) 22:745–63. doi: 10.1146/annurev.immunol.22.012703.104702

  • 63

    MaschanMBlagovSShelikhovaLShekhovtsovaZBalashovDStarichkovaJet al. Low-dose donor memory T-cell infusion after TCR alpha/beta depleted unrelated and haploidentical transplantation: results of a pilot trial. Bone Marrow Transplant (2018) 53(3):264–73. doi: 10.1038/s41409-017-0035-y

  • 64

    MufflyLSheehanKArmstrongRJensenKTateKRezvaniARet al. Infusion of donor-derived CD8(+) memory T cells for relapse following allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation. Blood Adv (2018) 2(6):681–90. doi: 10.1182/bloodadvances.2017012104

  • 65

    ShookDRTriplettBMEldridgePWKangGSrinivasanALeungW. Haploidentical stem cell transplantation augmented by CD45RA negative lymphocytes provides rapid engraftment and excellent tolerability. Pediatr Blood Cancer (2015) 62(4):666–73. doi: 10.1002/pbc.25352

  • 66

    TriplettBMShookDREldridgePLiYKangGDallasMet al. Rapid memory T-cell reconstitution recapitulating CD45RA-depleted haploidentical transplant graft content in patients with hematologic malignancies. Bone Marrow Transplant (2015) 50(7):1012. doi: 10.1038/bmt.2015.139

  • 67

    TalleurACLiYAkelSSharmaAQudeimatASrinivasanAet al. Haploidentical CD45RA-Negative Donor Lymphocyte Infusions Are Feasible, Safe and Associated with Clinical Benefit. Biol Blood Marrow Transplant (2020) 26(3, Supplement):S268. doi: 10.1016/j.bbmt.2019.12.435

  • 68

    ChanWKSuwannasaenDThromRELiYEldridgePWHoustonJet al. Chimeric antigen receptor-redirected CD45RA-negative T cells have potent antileukemia and pathogen memory response without graft-versus-host activity. Leukemia (2015) 29(2):387–95. doi: 10.1038/leu.2014.174

  • 69

    FernándezLFernándezAMironesIEscuderoACardosoLVelaMet al. GMP-Compliant Manufacturing of NKG2D CAR Memory T Cells Using CliniMACS Prodigy. Front Immunol (2019) 10:2361. doi: 10.3389/fimmu.2019.02361

  • 70

    TerakuraSYamamotoTNGardnerRATurtleCJJensenMCRiddellSR. Generation of CD19-chimeric antigen receptor modified CD8+ T cells derived from virus-specific central memory T cells. Blood (2012) 119(1):72–82. doi: 10.1182/blood-2011-07-366419

  • 71

    TalleurACMétaisJ-YLiYThromRETillmanHRooneyBet al. Allogeneic CD27-depleted cells in adoptive cell therapy. Adv Cell Gene Ther (2019) 2(2):e45. doi: 10.1002/acg2.45

  • 72

    TorikaiHReikALiuPQZhouYZhangLMaitiSet al. A foundation for universal T-cell based immunotherapy: T cells engineered to express a CD19-specific chimeric-antigen-receptor and eliminate expression of endogenous TCR. Blood (2012) 119(24):5697–705. doi: 10.1182/blood-2012-01-405365

  • 73

    OsbornMJWebberBRKnippingFLonetreeCLTennisNDeFeoAPet al. Evaluation of TCR Gene Editing Achieved by TALENs, CRISPR/Cas9, and megaTAL Nucleases. Mol Ther (2016) 24(3):570–81. doi: 10.1038/mt.2015.197

  • 74

    EyquemJMansilla-SotoJGiavridisTvan der StegenSJHamiehMCunananKMet al. Targeting a CAR to the TRAC locus with CRISPR/Cas9 enhances tumour rejection. Nature (2017) 543(7643):113–7. doi: 10.1038/nature21405

  • 75

    MaciociaPWawrzynieckaPKassimatisLPuleM. A Protein-Based Method to Develop Allogeneic Chimeric Antigen Receptor T-Cells. Blood (2018) 132(Supplement 1):700–. doi: 10.1182/blood-2018-99-112544

  • 76

    StengerDStiefTAKaeuferleTWillierSRatajFSchoberKet al. Endogenous TCR promotes in vivo persistence of CD19-CAR-T cells compared to a CRISPR/Cas9-mediated TCR knockout CAR. Blood (2020) 136(12):1407–18. doi: 10.1182/blood.2020005185

  • 77

    WangDQuanYYanQMoralesJEWetselRA. Targeted Disruption of the β2-Microglobulin Gene Minimizes the Immunogenicity of Human Embryonic Stem Cells. Stem Cells Transl Med (2015) 4(10):1234–45. doi: 10.5966/sctm.2015-0049

  • 78

    RenJLiuXFangCJiangSJuneCHZhaoY. Multiplex Genome Editing to Generate Universal CAR T Cells Resistant to PD1 Inhibition. Clin Cancer Res (2017) 23(9):2255–66. doi: 10.1158/1078-0432.CCR-16-1300

  • 79

    KagoyaYGuoTYeungBSasoKAnczurowskiMWangCHet al. Genetic Ablation of HLA Class I, Class II, and the T-cell Receptor Enables Allogeneic T Cells to Be Used for Adoptive T-cell Therapy. Cancer Immunol Res (2020) 8(7):926–36. doi: 10.1158/2326-6066.CIR-18-0508

  • 80

    BrentjensRJRivièreIParkJHDavilaMLWangXStefanskiJet al. Safety and persistence of adoptively transferred autologous CD19-targeted T cells in patients with relapsed or chemotherapy refractory B-cell leukemias. Blood (2011) 118(18):4817–28. doi: 10.1182/blood-2011-04-348540

  • 81

    HayKATurtleCJ. Chimeric Antigen Receptor (CAR) T Cells: Lessons Learned from Targeting of CD19 in B-Cell Malignancies. Drugs (2017) 77(3):237–45. doi: 10.1007/s40265-017-0690-8

  • 82

    JensenMCPopplewellLCooperLJDiGiustoDKalosMOstbergJRet al. Antitransgene rejection responses contribute to attenuated persistence of adoptively transferred CD20/CD19-specific chimeric antigen receptor redirected T cells in humans. Biol Blood Marrow Transplant (2010) 16(9):1245–56. doi: 10.1016/j.bbmt.2010.03.014

  • 83

    LevitskyJLeventhalJRMillerJHuangXChenLChandrasekaranDet al. Favorable effects of alemtuzumab on allospecific regulatory T-cell generation. Hum Immunol (2012) 73(2):141–9. doi: 10.1016/j.humimm.2011.11.008

  • 84

    FernandezO. Alemtuzumab in the treatment of multiple sclerosis. J Inflammation Res (2014) 7:19–27. doi: 10.2147/JIR.S38079

  • 85

    PoirotLPhilipBSchiffer-ManniouiCLe ClerreDChion-SotinelIDerniameSet al. Multiplex Genome-Edited T-cell Manufacturing Platform for “Off-the-Shelf” Adoptive T-cell Immunotherapies. Cancer Res (2015) 75(18):3853–64. doi: 10.1158/0008-5472.CAN-14-3321

  • 86

    ChakrabartiSMackinnonSChopraRKottaridisPDPeggsKO’GormanPet al. High incidence of cytomegalovirus infection after nonmyeloablative stem cell transplantation: potential role of Campath-1H in delaying immune reconstitution. Blood (2002) 99(12):4357–63. doi: 10.1182/blood.V99.12.4357

  • 87

    ChakrabartiSMautnerVOsmanHCollinghamKEFeganCDKlapperPEet al. Adenovirus infections following allogeneic stem cell transplantation: incidence and outcome in relation to graft manipulation, immunosuppression, and immune recovery. Blood (2002) 100(5):1619–27. doi: 10.1182/blood-2002-02-0377

  • 88

    MoFWatanabeNMcKennaMKHicksMJSrinivasanMGomes-SilvaDet al. Engineered off-the-shelf therapeutic T cells resist host immune rejection. Nat Biotechnol (2020). doi: 10.1038/s41587-020-0601-5

  • 89

    QasimWZhanHSamarasingheSAdamsSAmroliaPStaffordSet al. Molecular remission of infant B-ALL after infusion of universal TALEN gene-edited CAR T cells. Sci Transl Med (2017) 9(374). doi: 10.1126/scitranslmed.aaj2013

  • 90

    BenjaminRGrahamCYallopDJozwikACiocarlieOJainNet al. Preliminary Data on Safety, Cellular Kinetics and Anti-Leukemic Activity of UCART19, an Allogeneic Anti-CD19 CAR T-Cell Product, in a Pool of Adult and Pediatric Patients with High-Risk CD19+ Relapsed/Refractory B-Cell Acute Lymphoblastic Leukemia. Blood (2018) 132(Supplement 1):896–. doi: 10.1182/blood-2018-99-111356

  • 91

    NeelapuSSMunozJLockeFLMiklosDBBrownRMcDevittJTet al. First-in-human data of ALLO-501 and ALLO-647 in relapsed/refractory large B-cell or follicular lymphoma (R/R LBCL/FL): ALPHA study. J Clin Oncol (2020) 38(15_suppl):8002–. doi: 10.1200/JCO.2020.38.15_suppl.8002

  • 92

    WangXLiSGaoLYuanZWuKLiuLet al. Abstract CT052: Clinical safety and efficacy study of TruUCAR™ GC027: The first-in-human, universal CAR-T therapy for adult relapsed/refractory T-cell acute lymphoblastic leukemia (r/r T-ALL). Cancer Res (2020) 80(16 Supplement):CT052–CT. doi: 10.1158/1538-7445.AM2020-CT052

  • 93

    KhairallahCChuTHSheridanBS. Tissue Adaptations of Memory and Tissue-Resident Gamma Delta T Cells. Front Immunol (2018) 9:2636. doi: 10.3389/fimmu.2018.02636

  • 94

    WilhelmMSmetakMSchaefer-EckartKKimmelBBirkmannJEinseleHet al. Successful adoptive transfer and in vivo expansion of haploidentical γδ T cells. J Transl Med (2014) 12:45. doi: 10.1186/1479-5876-12-45

  • 95

    ScheperWSebestyenZKuballJ. Cancer Immunotherapy Using γδT Cells: Dealing with Diversity. Front Immunol (2014) 5:601. doi: 10.3389/fimmu.2014.00601

  • 96

    DenigerDCSwitzerKMiTMaitiSHurtonLSinghHet al. Bispecific T-cells expressing polyclonal repertoire of endogenous γδ T-cell receptors and introduced CD19-specific chimeric antigen receptor. Mol Ther (2013) 21(3):638–47. doi: 10.1038/mt.2012.267

  • 97

    CapsomidisABenthallGVan AckerHHFisherJKramerAMAbelnZet al. Chimeric Antigen Receptor-Engineered Human Gamma Delta T Cells: Enhanced Cytotoxicity with Retention of Cross Presentation. Mol Ther (2018) 26(2):354–65. doi: 10.1016/j.ymthe.2017.12.001

  • 98

    KabelitzDSerranoRKouakanouLPetersCKalyanS. Cancer immunotherapy with γδ T cells: many paths ahead of us. Cell Mol Immunol (2020) 17(9):925–39. doi: 10.1038/s41423-020-0504-x

  • 99

    BendelacASavagePBTeytonL. The biology of NKT cells. Annu Rev Immunol (2007) 25:297–336. doi: 10.1146/annurev.immunol.25.022106.141711

  • 100

    ExleyMGarciaJWilsonSBSpadaFGerdesDTahirSMet al. CD1d structure and regulation on human thymocytes, peripheral blood T cells, B cells and monocytes. Immunology (2000) 100(1):37–47. doi: 10.1046/j.1365-2567.2000.00001.x

  • 101

    SalioMSilkJDJonesEYCerundoloV. Biology of CD1- and MR1-restricted T cells. Annu Rev Immunol (2014) 32:323–66. doi: 10.1146/annurev-immunol-032713-120243

  • 102

    FujiiSShimizuKKlimekVGellerMDNimerSDDhodapkarMV. Severe and selective deficiency of interferon-gamma-producing invariant natural killer T cells in patients with myelodysplastic syndromes. Br J Haematol (2003) 122(4):617–22. doi: 10.1046/j.1365-2141.2003.04465.x

  • 103

    MollingJWKölgenWvan der VlietHJBoomsmaMFKruizengaHSmorenburgCHet al. Peripheral blood IFN-gamma-secreting Valpha24+Vbeta11+ NKT cell numbers are decreased in cancer patients independent of tumor type or tumor load. Int J Cancer (2005) 116(1):87–93. doi: 10.1002/ijc.20998

  • 104

    MollingJWLangiusJALangendijkJALeemansCRBontkesHJvan der VlietHJet al. Low levels of circulating invariant natural killer T cells predict poor clinical outcome in patients with head and neck squamous cell carcinoma. J Clin Oncol (2007) 25(7):862–8. doi: 10.1200/JCO.2006.08.5787

  • 105

    ChaidosAPattersonSSzydloRChaudhryMSDazziFKanferEet al. Graft invariant natural killer T-cell dose predicts risk of acute graft-versus-host disease in allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation. Blood (2012) 119(21):5030–6. doi: 10.1182/blood-2011-11-389304

  • 106

    Leveson-GowerDBOlsonJASegaEILuongRHBakerJZeiserRet al. Low doses of natural killer T cells provide protection from acute graft-versus-host disease via an IL-4-dependent mechanism. Blood (2011) 117(11):3220–9. doi: 10.1182/blood-2010-08-303008

  • 107

    RubioMTBouilliéMBouazzaNComanTTrebeden-NègreHGomezAet al. Pre-transplant donor CD4(-) invariant NKT cell expansion capacity predicts the occurrence of acute graft-versus-host disease. Leukemia (2017) 31(4):903–12. doi: 10.1038/leu.2016.281

  • 108

    HeczeyALiuDTianGCourtneyANWeiJMarinovaEet al. Invariant NKT cells with chimeric antigen receptor provide a novel platform for safe and effective cancer immunotherapy. Blood (2014) 124(18):2824–33. doi: 10.1182/blood-2013-11-541235

  • 109

    TianGCourtneyANJenaBHeczeyALiuDMarinovaEet al. CD62L+ NKT cells have prolonged persistence and antitumor activity in vivo. J Clin Invest (2016) 126(6):2341–55. doi: 10.1172/JCI83476

  • 110

    RotoloACaputoVSHolubovaMBaxanNDuboisOChaudhryMSet al. Enhanced Anti-lymphoma Activity of CAR19-iNKT Cells Underpinned by Dual CD19 and CD1d Targeting. Cancer Cell (2018) 34(4):596–610.e11. doi: 10.1016/j.ccell.2018.08.017

  • 111

    HeczeyACourtneyANMontalbanoARobinsonSLiuKLiMet al. Anti-GD2 CAR-NKT cells in patients with relapsed or refractory neuroblastoma: an interim analysis. Nat Med (2020) 26(11):1686–90. doi: 10.1038/s41591-020-1074-2

  • 112

    WuJLanierLL. Natural killer cells and cancer. Adv Cancer Res (2003) 90:127–56. doi: 10.1016/S0065-230X(03)90004-2

  • 113

    OlsonJALeveson-GowerDBGillSBakerJBeilhackANegrinRS. NK cells mediate reduction of GVHD by inhibiting activated, alloreactive T cells while retaining GVT effects. Blood (2010) 115(21):4293–301. doi: 10.1182/blood-2009-05-222190

  • 114

    AlgarraIGarcía-LoraACabreraTRuiz-CabelloFGarridoF. The selection of tumor variants with altered expression of classical and nonclassical MHC class I molecules: implications for tumor immune escape. Cancer Immunol Immunother (2004) 53(10):904–10. doi: 10.1007/s00262-004-0517-9

  • 115

    CostelloRTGastautJAOliveD. Tumor escape from immune surveillance. Arch Immunol Ther Exp (Warsz) (1999) 47(2):83–8.

  • 116

    MehtaRSRezvaniK. Chimeric Antigen Receptor Expressing Natural Killer Cells for the Immunotherapy of Cancer. Front Immunol (2018) 9:283. doi: 10.3389/fimmu.2018.00283

  • 117

    NguyenRWuHPoundsSInabaHRibeiroRCCullinsDet al. A phase II clinical trial of adoptive transfer of haploidentical natural killer cells for consolidation therapy of pediatric acute myeloid leukemia. J Immunother Cancer (2019) 7(1):81. doi: 10.1186/s40425-019-0564-6

  • 118

    RubnitzJEInabaHKangGGanKHartfordCTriplettBMet al. Natural killer cell therapy in children with relapsed leukemia. Pediatr Blood Cancer (2015) 62(8):1468–72. doi: 10.1002/pbc.25555

  • 119

    RubnitzJEInabaHRibeiroRCPoundsSRooneyBBellTet al. NKAML: a pilot study to determine the safety and feasibility of haploidentical natural killer cell transplantation in childhood acute myeloid leukemia. J Clin Oncol (2010) 28(6):955–9. doi: 10.1200/JCO.2009.24.4590

  • 120

    GellerMACooleySJudsonPLGhebreRCarsonLFArgentaPAet al. A phase II study of allogeneic natural killer cell therapy to treat patients with recurrent ovarian and breast cancer. Cytotherapy (2011) 13(1):98–107. doi: 10.3109/14653249.2010.515582

  • 121

    ZhaoQAhmedMTassevDVHasanAKuoTYGuoHFet al. Affinity maturation of T-cell receptor-like antibodies for Wilms tumor 1 peptide greatly enhances therapeutic potential. Leukemia (2015) 29(11):2238–47. doi: 10.1038/leu.2015.125

  • 122

    EsserRMüllerTStefesDKloessSSeidelDGilliesSDet al. NK cells engineered to express a GD2 -specific antigen receptor display built-in ADCC-like activity against tumour cells of neuroectodermal origin. J Cell Mol Med (2012) 16(3):569–81. doi: 10.1111/j.1582-4934.2011.01343.x

  • 123

    ImaiCIwamotoSCampanaD. Genetic modification of primary natural killer cells overcomes inhibitory signals and induces specific killing of leukemic cells. Blood (2005) 106(1):376–83. doi: 10.1182/blood-2004-12-4797

  • 124

    ShimasakiNFujisakiHChoDMasselliMLockeyTEldridgePet al. A clinically adaptable method to enhance the cytotoxicity of natural killer cells against B-cell malignancies. Cytotherapy (2012) 14(7):830–40. doi: 10.3109/14653249.2012.671519

  • 125

    ChuYHochbergJYahrAAyelloJvan de VenCBarthMet al. Targeting CD20+ Aggressive B-cell Non-Hodgkin Lymphoma by Anti-CD20 CAR mRNA-Modified Expanded Natural Killer Cells In Vitro and in NSG Mice. Cancer Immunol Res (2015) 3(4):333–44. doi: 10.1158/2326-6066.CIR-14-0114

  • 126

    MüllerTUherekCMakiGChowKUSchimpfAKlingemannHGet al. Expression of a CD20-specific chimeric antigen receptor enhances cytotoxic activity of NK cells and overcomes NK-resistance of lymphoma and leukemia cells. Cancer Immunol Immunother (2008) 57(3):411–23. doi: 10.1007/s00262-007-0383-3

  • 127

    LiuEMarinDBanerjeePMacapinlacHAThompsonPBasarRet al. Use of CAR-Transduced Natural Killer Cells in CD19-Positive Lymphoid Tumors. N Engl J Med (2020) 382(6):545–53. doi: 10.1056/NEJMoa1910607

  • 128

    VeluchamyJPKokNvan der VlietHJVerheulHMWde GruijlTDSpanholtzJ. The Rise of Allogeneic Natural Killer Cells As a Platform for Cancer Immunotherapy: Recent Innovations and Future Developments. Front Immunol (2017) 8(631). doi: 10.3389/fimmu.2017.00631

  • 129

    TangXYangLLiZNalinAPDaiHXuTet al. First-in-man clinical trial of CAR NK-92 cells: safety test of CD33-CAR NK-92 cells in patients with relapsed and refractory acute myeloid leukemia. Am J Cancer Res (2018) 8(6):1083–9.

  • 130

    FujisakiHKakudaHShimasakiNImaiCMaJLockeyTet al. Expansion of Highly Cytotoxic Human Natural Killer Cells for Cancer Cell Therapy. Cancer Res (2009) 69(9):4010–7. doi: 10.1158/0008-5472.CAN-08-3712

  • 131

    LeeDA. Cellular therapy: Adoptive immunotherapy with expanded natural killer cells. Immunol Rev (2019) 290(1):85–99. doi: 10.1111/imr.12793

  • 132

    ShimasakiNCoustan-SmithEKamiyaTCampanaD. Expanded and armed natural killer cells for cancer treatment. Cytotherapy (2016) 18(11):1422–34. doi: 10.1016/j.jcyt.2016.06.013

  • 133

    OyerJGittoSBKhederzadehSShaverKLeeDAAltomareDet al. Assessment of antitumor function of NK cells expanded with exosomes from K562.mb21 cells. J Clin Oncol (2017) 35(7_suppl):132–. doi: 10.1200/JCO.2017.35.7_suppl.132

  • 134

    UedaTKumagaiAIriguchiSYasuiYMiyasakaTNakagoshiKet al. Non-clinical efficacy, safety and stable clinical cell processing of induced pluripotent stem cell-derived anti-glypican-3 chimeric antigen receptor-expressing natural killer/innate lymphoid cells. Cancer Sci (2020) 111(5):1478–90. doi: 10.1111/cas.14374

  • 135

    CichockiFBjordahlRGaidarovaSMahmoodSAbujarourRWangHet al. iPSC-derived NK cells maintain high cytotoxicity and enhance in vivo tumor control in concert with T cells and anti–PD-1 therapy. Sci Trans Med (2020) 12(568):eaaz5618. doi: 10.1126/scitranslmed.aaz5618

  • 136

    ZhuHBlumRHBernareggiDAskEHWuZHoelHJet al. Metabolic Reprograming via Deletion of CISH in Human iPSC-Derived NK Cells Promotes In Vivo Persistence and Enhances Anti-tumor Activity. Cell Stem Cell (2020) 27(2):224–37.e6. doi: 10.1016/j.stem.2020.05.008

  • 137

    LiYHermansonDLMoriarityBSKaufmanDS. Human iPSC-Derived Natural Killer Cells Engineered with Chimeric Antigen Receptors Enhance Anti-tumor Activity. Cell Stem Cell (2018) 23(2):181–92.e5. doi: 10.1016/j.stem.2018.06.002

  • 138

    ShankarKCapitiniCMSahaK. Genome engineering of induced pluripotent stem cells to manufacture natural killer cell therapies. Stem Cell Res Ther (2020) 11(1):234–. doi: 10.1186/s13287-020-01741-4

  • 139

    MajznerRGMackallCL. Clinical lessons learned from the first leg of the CAR T cell journey. Nat Med (2019) 25(9):1341–55. doi: 10.1038/s41591-019-0564-6

Summary

Keywords

allogeneic, CAR, cell therapy, immunotherapy, cancer

Citation

Caldwell KJ, Gottschalk S and Talleur AC (2021) Allogeneic CAR Cell Therapy—More Than a Pipe Dream. Front. Immunol. 11:618427. doi: 10.3389/fimmu.2020.618427

Received

16 October 2020

Accepted

30 November 2020

Published

08 January 2021

Volume

11 - 2020

Edited by

Alice Bertaina, Stanford University, United States

Reviewed by

Kara Davis, Stanford University, United States; Sergio Querol, Banc de Sang i Teixits, Spain

Updates

Copyright

*Correspondence: Aimee C. Talleur,

This article was submitted to Alloimmunity and Transplantation, a section of the journal Frontiers in Immunology

Disclaimer

All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.

Outline

Figures

Cite article

Copy to clipboard


Export citation file


Share article

Article metrics