Abstract
In pregnancy, the semi-allogeneic fetus needs to be tolerated by the mother's immune system. Regulatory T cells (Tregs) play a prominent role in this process. Novel technologies allow for in-depth phenotyping of previously unidentified immune cell subsets, which has resulted in the appreciation of a vast heterogeneity of Treg subsets. Similar to other immunological events, there appears to be great diversity within the Treg population during pregnancy, both at the maternal-fetal interface as in the peripheral blood. Different Treg subsets have distinct phenotypes and various ways of functioning. Furthermore, the frequency of individual Treg subsets varies throughout gestation and is altered in aberrant pregnancies. This suggests that distinct Treg subsets play a role at different time points of gestation and that their role in maintaining healthy pregnancy is crucial, as reflected for instance by their reduced frequency in women with recurrent pregnancy loss. Since pregnancy is essential for the existence of mankind, multiple immune regulatory mechanisms and cell types are likely at play to assure successful pregnancy. Therefore, it is important to understand the complete microenvironment of the decidua, preferably in the context of the whole immune cell repertoire of the pregnant woman. So far, most studies have focused on a single mechanism or cell type, which often is the FoxP3 positive regulatory T cell when studying immune regulation. In this review, we instead focus on the contribution of FoxP3 negative Treg subsets to the decidual microenvironment and their possible role in pregnancy complications. Their phenotype, function, and effect in pregnancy are discussed.
Placental Development and Immune Evasion by Trophoblasts
The most striking feature of pregnancy is that a semi-allogeneic fetus is tolerated by the maternal immune system. This is in sharp contrast with solid organ transplantation, where an allograft will be rejected by the patient's immune system unless the patient takes immunosuppressive drugs. Since direct contact between maternal and fetal cells occurs at the maternal-fetal interface in the placenta, it is thought that maternal immune cells in the placenta do not attack the fetal cells (trophoblasts) because of the tolerogenic microenvironment created by regulatory T cells (Tregs) and other immune cells.
Trophoblast Development
The main function of the placenta is to provide oxygen and nutrients to the developing fetus. In the first-trimester, nutrients are mainly provided by uterine glands in a hypoxic environment as no active maternal blood flow has been established yet. Once active maternal blood flow in the placenta has commenced around weeks 11–12 of gestation, oxygen and nutrients are exchanged over a thin lining of fetal cells. Since the fetus is semi-allogeneic, as it inherits both maternal and paternal antigens, the fetal trophoblast cells may potentially be recognized as foreign by maternal immune cells. Three main types of trophoblasts can be distinguished: cytotrophoblasts (CTBs), syncytiotrophoblasts (SCTs), and extravillous trophoblasts (EVTs). At the beginning of the first trimester, the maternal-fetal interface consists of the maternal parenchymal cells in the decidua and the fetal SCTs (Figure 1A). Later in pregnancy, this interface is mainly represented by maternal decidual cells and the EVTs (Figure 1B), where a distinction is made between decidua basalis and decidua parietalis. Importantly, a second maternal-fetal interface is established when active maternal blood flow in the placenta has commenced. The maternal peripheral blood then comes into contact with the SCTs lining the fetal villi. From the moment these maternal-fetal interfaces have been established, it is of utmost importance for maternal immune cells to keep the balance between tolerizing the semi-allogeneic fetus, and at the same time maintaining the ability to form a robust immune response against pathogens upon infection.
Figure 1
Mechanisms by Trophoblasts for Avoiding and Modulating Immune Responses
The classical human leukocyte antigen (HLA) class I molecules HLA-A, -B, and -C are normally present on virtually all nucleated cells in the body and present intracellular antigens to surveilling T cells. Non-classical HLA molecules are selectively present, and have initially been described on trophoblasts in the placenta (1) and later also in other tissues (2–4). HLA class II is mainly expressed by antigen-presenting cells (APCs), including dendritic cells (DCs), macrophages, and B cells. Since the fetus inherits half of its genes from the father, it also inherits half of the paternal HLA alleles, which can potentially be recognized as foreign by the maternal immune system.
One way for the trophoblasts to evade recognition by the maternal immune system is lack of the polymorphic HLA-A, -B, and HLA class II molecules on their cell surface. Interestingly, EVTs do express polymorphic classical HLA-C molecules. The regular function of these molecules is to present a wide variety of pathogen-associated peptides to surveilling CD8+ T cells (5). Since HLA-C is polymorphic, its presence on trophoblasts can possibly also lead to allorecognition of the inherited paternal HLA-C by maternal T cells (6). EVTs may help to tip the local maternal immune balance toward tolerance by their expression of non-classical HLA-E and HLA-G (7), and possibly also HLA-F (8). The mechanisms responsible for the presence or absence of the specific HLA class I types on trophoblasts have not fully been elucidated yet (5). Expression of HLA molecules on trophoblasts allows them to escape natural killer (NK) cell recognition (9). HLA-G was first described on CTBs and has been shown to induce immune tolerance (10, 11) (described below). HLA-E also has tolerogenic properties as it can bind to the NK cell receptor CD94/NKG2A upon which NK cell activity is inhibited (12). SCTs, which are in direct contact with the maternal blood, do not express any HLA molecules (13), which would potentially render them sensitive to NK cell-mediated killing (13). However, for NK cells killing an activating ligand needs to be present on the target cell, which is likely missing on trophoblasts (14).
Trophoblasts express several molecules that are thought to dampen alloimmune reactivity, including PD-L1, PD-L2, CD200, and FasL (15–19), some of which are differentially expressed throughout gestation (17). Trophoblasts are also known to produce soluble factors with an immune-modulatory action, such as soluble HLA-G (sHLA-G), transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-β), and indoleamine 2,3-dioxygenase (IDO). TGF-β is known to have various functions and will be extensively discussed below. Since IDO causes local tryptophan deprivation (20), which is an essential amino acid required for T cell activation, elevated local IDO levels lead to inhibition of T cell activation. Recently, the role of galectins in pregnancy has become more apparent, as they were found to play an important role in suppressing the maternal immune system (21). Galectins on human trophoblasts modulate a number of regulatory mechanisms (22), such as induction of T cell apoptosis (23) and induction of Treg cell development (24).
Maternal Immune Cells in the Decidua
Not only the composition of fetal cells in the placenta but also the composition of maternal immune cells changes throughout gestation. Already before conception, as early as seminal plasma exposure, activation and proliferation of fetus-specific maternal T cells in uterine draining lymph nodes have been observed in murine models (25). In humans, maternal APCs and CD8+ T cells seem to get recruited to the ectocervix upon coitus, but their specificity remains unknown (26). In the first trimester of human pregnancy, maternal leukocytes account for 30–40% of all cells in the decidua (27). During this period, the most prominent immune cells are decidual NK (dNK) cells (~60%), macrophages (~20%), and T cells (~10%) (27–29). During gestation, dNK cell frequencies decrease, macrophage frequencies remain relatively stable, and T cell frequencies increase (29). Next to these main immune cell populations, innate lymphoid cell (ILCs) other than NK cells, DCs, B cells, NKT cells, granulocytes, and mast cells are found in the decidua (30–32).
Despite the many mechanisms that trophoblasts have to evade an alloimmune response, fetus specific immune recognition has been observed in mice (33). Furthermore, fetus-specific CD8+ T cells (34, 35) and inherited paternal antigen (IPA)-specific antibodies are found in maternal peripheral blood during pregnancy (36–38). Both HLA-C and HLA-E restricted CD8+ T cells, specific for viral and bacterial peptides, are present in humans (39). However, maternal CD8+ T cells could recognize the paternally inherited HLA-C from the fetus or fetal minor histocompatibility antigens, and if not suppressed are likely to attack the fetal trophoblasts (34, 35). Besides this, ~30% of pregnancies result in the formation of paternal HLA-specific IgG antibodies (38, 40). Allo-antibodies directed against HLA-C of the fetus do not necessarily appear to be detrimental to pregnancy outcome (41), but some studies do show that they are associated with spontaneous preterm deliveries and recurrent pregnancy loss (RPL) (42, 43). Therefore, to inhibit the effect of maternal immune components, it is thought that local immune regulation is required to prevent anti-fetal immunity.
Maternal TREG Cells During Gestation
To prevent a detrimental immune reaction against the fetus, maternal immune cells need to be regulated. The level of both FoxP3+ and Foxp3− Tregs is increased in the peripheral blood of pregnant women compared to non-pregnant control women (44, 45). While the proportion of total T cells in the decidua is low during the first trimester (~10%), of which 10-30% of the CD4+ T cells are Tregs (28, 29, 46, 47), later in pregnancy the proportion of Tregs significantly increases in the decidua [(46); van der Zwan et al. submitted]. In mice the importance of Tregs during implantation and for maintenance of a healthy pregnancy is evident. This was shown in murine studies by injecting abortion prone mice with CD25+ Tregs from wild-type pregnant mice, which led to a significantly increased litter size (48). Alternatively, depleting CD25+ Tregs during the implantation period of non-synergistically mated mice caused high fetal resorption (49). Depleting Tregs in the mid-gestation phase in non-sterile mice also resulted in high fetal resorption (50). In a systematic review of 17 studies on human pregnancy, it has been shown that the number and functionality of Tregs are diminished in women experiencing RPL, both in the peripheral blood and in the decidua, compared to control women (51). Similarly, in women with pre-eclampsia decreased Treg frequencies in both the periphery and the decidua and impairment in the signaling of peripheral blood Tregs have been found (45, 52, 53).
Using extensive mass cytometry panels containing more than 38 immune cell markers, we have previously shown that there is great heterogeneity in immune cell subsets among the different trimesters (van der Zwan et al. submitted). Interestingly, five Treg-like clusters were found to be differently distributed over the three trimesters. This could be attributed to the developmental changes in the placenta, causing a constant change in the possible cell-cell interactions between immune cells and different EVT subsets that seem to exist over different trimesters (54). Apart from that, a deficit in Treg presence and functionality has been observed in pregnancy complications such as PE, infertility, and RPL (55). Such complications arise at different periods of pregnancy, i.e., during implantation, <22–24 weeks of gestation or throughout gestation (56, 57). Taken together, as both Treg subsets and the initiation of complications can be prominent in a particular time frame of gestation, it might be that disbalances in different Treg subsets could play a role in the onset of different complications. Therefore, it is important to investigate the presence and functioning of the wide range of Treg subsets present during pregnancy.
Advances in TREG Identification
Regulatory T cells were originally named suppressor cells (58). Ideas and insights changed over time, and suppressor cells have endured much debate. In 1983 it was shown in mice that both CD8 (Lyt-2+) and CD4 (Lyt-2−) suppressor cells were present that expressed the I-J molecule (59). When the I-J molecule turned out not to exist and suppressor cells could not be identified in any other way, interest in these cells waned. The arrival of novel molecular technologies propelled new knowledge, which made immunological tolerance become more evident and revived interest in T suppressor cells, now referred to as Tregs (60). In 2001, the FoxP3 gene was identified in scurfy mice and later as a key transcription factor for Treg cell development and function in both humans and mice (61, 62). Subsequently, several FoxP3− Treg subsets were identified, as will be discussed below. Initially, it was hypothesized that Tregs could only be generated in the thymus (tTregs), but in the 2000s this concept was challenged by studies showing that Tregs could be induced from conventional T cells in the periphery (pTregs) (63, 64). It is thought that tTregs and pTregs function in distinct ways, recognize different types of antigens (autoantigens vs. foreign antigens), and are needed in different immunological events such as preventing T cell trafficking to an organ and preventing T cell priming by APC, respectively (65).
Because tTregs and pTregs can have different roles, there is a need for phenotypic markers to distinguish the two. While Helios and Nrp-1 have been proposed as markers for tTregs in mice (66, 67), it has been shown that Helios deficiency or Nrp-1 deficiency does not impede tTreg development (65, 68). Consequently, there is no consensus on which markers can distinguish tTregs from pTregs (65, 69, 70). Helios is associated with the promoter regions of apoptosis/cell survival genes, and Helios deficient FoxP3+ Tregs show increased inflammatory cytokine expression, which suggests the importance of Helios in suppressing the production of effector cytokines (71). Even though Nrp-1 is not essential for tTreg development, it seems to increase Treg immunoregulatory properties, such as an increased capacity for tumor infiltration (69, 72). When comparing Nrp-1 and Helios there is no consistent overlap in expression of these markers (65). In humans, Helios is found on Tregs, but Nrp-1 is not found on peripheral blood Tregs and can, therefore, be excluded as tTreg marker (66, 73). More recently CNS1 has been suggested to distinguish between tTregs and pTregs. However, since CNS1 is a FoxP3 enhancer, it is debatable whether this marker distinguishes FoxP3− tTreg and pTreg populations (74, 75).
Treg subsets are often identified by their co-signaling molecules. Many Treg subsets express co-signaling molecules, such as ICOS, PD-1, TIGIT, and TIM-3, which upon interaction with their ligand can alter their function to either activation or senescence (76–78). These co-signaling molecules, which can be present on both FoxP3+ and FoxP3− Tregs, have widely been discussed in several reviews (79–81). Similarly, the heterogeneity within FoxP3+ Tregs, generally described as CD4+CD25+CD127− in functional assays, has been extensively reviewed elsewhere (82–87). However, the heterogeneity within the FoxP3− compartment has not been elaborated on and will be discussed here in the context of pregnancy. Besides co-signaling molecules, several soluble factors affect the action of Tregs and are produced by these cells to mediate their immune regulatory effects. These will first be briefly reviewed.
Soluble Factors
IL-10
IL-10 is an immunomodulatory cytokine that is produced by many immune cells in the decidua, including most known Treg subsets. It has an effect on trophoblasts and innate- and adaptive immune cells within the decidua (88). Single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in the promoter region of IL-10 correlate with adverse pregnancy outcomes in humans (89). Next to that, the administration of recombinant IL-10 or IL-10 producing B cells to mice leads to reduced incidence of fetal resorption (90). Concomitantly, IL-10 null mice in sterile cages showed normal litter size, whereas administration of a danger signal in the form of a low dose of LPS to these mice resulted in increased fetal resorption (91, 92). These data suggest that IL-10 is an important mediator of immune regulation during pregnancy. In human pregnancy, decreased serum IL-10 levels or IL-10 production by PBMCs are associated with the occurrence of PE and RPL (93–98). This suggests that IL-10 producing immune cells are important for maintaining an uncomplicated pregnancy.
IL-10 induces expression of HLA-G on trophoblasts, which has direct and indirect immune suppressive effects (described below) (99). IL-10, together with HLA-G, can induce monocyte-derived DCs in vitro to differentiate into tolerogenic DCs (DC-10) that have immunosuppressive properties (100, 101). They exert their immunosuppressive properties by the production of IL-10, expression of HLA-G, and upregulation of inhibitory receptors for HLA-G (namely ILT2, ILT3, and ILT4). Furthermore, these tolerogenic DCs downregulate co-stimulatory molecules CD80 and CD86, as well as HLA-DR (102–104). DC-10s induce Tregs by their expression of ILT4 and by IL-10 production (105). Macrophages are also regulated by IL-10 (106). It has been shown that IL-10 acts on macrophages by controlling their metabolic pathways, causing activation, proliferation, and inflammatory responses to be inhibited (106, 107). Next to that, CD4+ T cell proliferation is suppressed by IL-10, antigen-experienced specific CD4+ T cells can be induced into an anergic state, and conventional T cells can be induced to convert to Tregs (103, 108–110).
TGF-β
TGF-β is produced by and has an immunomodulatory effect on multiple cell types present in the decidua (111–120). In the early implantation phase, TGF-β is important for trophoblast invasion in the endometrium (121, 122). In humans, TGF-β serum levels are elevated in pregnant women compared to non-pregnant women, and serum levels are higher in early pregnancy compared to late pregnancy (123). However, women experiencing RPL display a decrease in TGF-β serum levels compared to women undergoing elective termination for non-medical reasons (124). Interestingly, there are indications from mouse studies that TGF-β induced Tregs could prevent spontaneous abortion, but this effect needs to be elucidated further (111, 125).
TGF-β can inhibit NK cell and T cell activation and proliferation by repressing the mammalian target of rapamycin (mTOR) signaling pathway (126, 127), and similarly, suppress activation of dNK cells (120). Since dNK cells are important contributors to angiogenesis at the maternal-fetal interface, their cytotoxicity needs to be suppressed but they should still be able to execute their role in angiogenesis. A balanced TGF-β level may, therefore, be important to maintain correct functioning of dNK cells (120). Furthermore, TGF-β can affect T cells directly by inhibiting their proliferation and differentiation (128, 129), and indirectly by its inhibitory effect on APCs. HLA-class II on APCs is downregulated, activation of macrophages is downregulated, and maturation of DCs is prevented by TGF-β (116, 130–134). Next to that, the presence of TGF-β is needed for the induction of several FoxP3+ and FoxP3− Treg subsets by APCs (135–138).
HLA-G
As discussed above, HLA-G was first described on trophoblasts (1). Interestingly, also myeloid and lymphoid cells, such as the below described FoxP3−HLA-G+ Treg, can express HLA-G and secrete sHLA-G (139–141). HLA-G is oligomorphic and has seven isoforms, of which some are membrane-bound (HLA-G1 to -G4), and others are secreted as a soluble form (sHLA-G5 to -G7) (142). Several polymorphisms in the untranslated region (UTR) of the HLA-G gene have been associated with lower sHLA-G levels in both blood and seminal plasma (143, 144). In both PE and RPL, a reduction in serum sHLA-G levels has been observed compared to healthy control women (145–148). Together these observations highlight the possible importance of (s)HLA-G during pregnancy.
(s)HLA-G exerts its immunoregulatory effects on a wide variety of immune cells because of its interactions with several inhibitory receptors, of which ILT2 seems to be most prominent (149). Other receptors for (s)HLA-G are ILT4, KIR2DL4, and CD8. The ITL2 receptor is expressed on monocytes/macrophages, DCs, B cells, and some NK and T cells (150), while the ILT4 receptor is mainly present on macrophages, NK cells, and neutrophils (150, 151). Upon ILT2 or ILT4 binding to HLA-G, NK cells and T cells receive a signal that leads to inhibited killing capacity (152–154). In CD8+ T cells, this inhibited killing capacity is reflected by the down-regulation of granzyme B expression (155). KIR2DL4 has been identified on dNK cells and some T cell subsets. Engagement of this receptor with sHLA-G results in activation and secretion of different types of cytokines and chemokines, but does not result in direct cytotoxicity (156). Binding of sHLA-G with KIR2DL4 on NK cells results in the upregulation of a restricted set of chemokines and cytokines that can promote vascular remodeling (156). CD8 is not only expressed by cytotoxic T cells but also by some NK cell subsets (79, 157). When sHLA-G binds to CD8, this interaction inhibits cytotoxic activity and triggers FasL-mediated apoptosis in both the CD8+ T cells and CD8+ NK cells (158). Besides effector cells, APCs can also be affected by HLA-G. For example, in concert with IL-10, HLA-G induces DCs to differentiate into tolerogenic DC-10 cells (100, 101). Additionally, macrophages obtain a tolerogenic phenotype upon binding to HLA-G with their ILT2 or ILT4, and subsequently show reduced expression of HLA class II, CD80, and CD86. Such macrophages have been described to be similar to decidual macrophages as they also express IDO (159). Together this suggests that decidual macrophages are under the constant influence of HLA-G, produced by either trophoblasts or HLA-G+ Tregs.
Foxp3− Regulatory T Cells
FoxP3− HLA-G+ Tregs
In the lymphoid compartment, HLA-G expressing CD4+ and CD8+ cells show reduced proliferation in response to allogeneic and polyclonal stimuli (139). CD4+HLA-G+CD25−FoxP3− Tregs (Figures 2, 5, Table 1) suppress T cell proliferation through the expression of membrane-bound HLA-G1 and secretion of IL-10 and sHLA-G5 in a reversible, cell-contact independent and cell-contact dependent manner (139, 169). They have functionally been compared to other Treg populations such as FoxP3+ Tregs and Tr1 Tregs (discussed below), and represent a population that is distinct from tTregs (169–171). Interestingly, CD4+ and CD8+ T cells can also acquire a similar HLA-G1+ phenotype in vitro through trogocytosis (160), meaning the uptake of membrane fragments from another cell. Resting and activated CD25+ T cells that acquire HLA-G1 expression by trogocytosis differ functionally from the HLA-G+ tTregs, and they do not secrete sHLA-G5 and IL-10. They have been shown to exert their immune-suppressive capacity in a cell-contact dependent manner only (160), and will not be discussed further.
Figure 2
Table 1
| Subset | Induction/ activation | Suppressive mechanism | Function | Localization | Depletion in animal models | Master genes of differentiation | Cell volume changes in complications |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CD4+HLA-G+ Treg (139, 160) | Natural occurring (139) | Secretion of sHLA-G and IL-10 (139), and cell interaction with HLA-G (160) | Induction of HLA-G expression by trophoblasts, DC-10s and Tregs by IL-10 Inhibition of macrophages, NK cells and T cell killing | Found in peripheral blood (45) and decidua (141) | Has not been performed | Not known | Found to be increased in peripheral blood of pre-eclampsia patients (45) |
| Tr1-(like) Treg (109, 119) | Via trogocytosis (160) | Secretion of IL-10 and TGF-β, and cell interaction (136, 161) | Induction of HLA-G expression by trophoblasts, DC-10s and Tregs by IL-10 Lysis of APCs, disruption of metabolic state of T cells | Found in peripheral blood and decidua (119) | Has not been performed | Not known | Has not been described |
| Th3 Treg (162) | By APC in an IL-10 dominant microenvironment (110) | Secretion of TGF-β and IL-10 (162) | Induction of HLA-G expression by trophoblasts, DC-10s and Tregs by IL-10 Inhibition of NK cell and T cells and APC by TGF-β | Found in the decidua (163) | Has not been performed | Not known | Has not been described |
| CD8+ Treg (59) | By APC in presence of TGF-β and IL-4 (113, 135) | Suppress the secretion of immunoglobulins (164) | Prevent formation and suppressing production of IPA-specific antibodies. | Found in peripheral blood (CD8+HLA-G+ Treg) (45) and decidua (164) | Has not been performed | Not known | CD8+HLA-G+ Treg are increased in peripheral blood of pre-eclampsia patients (45) |
| NO-Treg (165) | CD101+CD103+ are induced by trophoblasts (164) | Secretion of IL-10 (165, 166) | Induction of HLA-G expression by trophoblasts, DC-10s and Tregs by IL-10. | Found in peripheral blood (165) | Has not been performed | Not known | Has not been described |
| TIGIT+ Treg (119) | Depends on nitric oxide, p53, IL-2, and OX-40 (165) | Secretion of IFNγ and IL-2 (119) | Induction of IL-10 production by APCs. Suppression of CD4+ effector T cells | Found in decidua (119) | Has not been performed | Not known | Has not been described |
| Vδ1+ γδ T cell (167) | Unknown | Secretion of IL-10 and TGF-β (115) | Induction of HLA-G expression by trophoblasts, DC-10s and Tregs by IL-10 Inhibition of NK cell and T cells and APC by TGF-β | Found in peripheral blood and decidua (168) | Has not been performed | Not known | Decreased amount in an abortion prone mice model (111) |
Overview of FoxP3− immune regulating T cells discussed in this review, how they are induced or activated, their main suppressive mechanism and how they function, their localization, animal models depletion assays, master genes for differentiation, and cell volume changes in complicated pregnancies.
HLA-G+ tTregs accumulate at sites of inflammation to regulate immune responses (172) and importantly, have also been found in the decidua (141, 173). CD4+HLA-G+ Treg frequencies are increased in peripheral blood throughout pregnancy compared to non-pregnant controls (45, 141). Interestingly, sHLA-G serum levels are also increased during pregnancy, while these levels are decreased in complicated pregnancies compared to healthy pregnancies (145–148). However, it is unlikely that a direct correlation between CD4+HLA-G+ Treg frequencies and serum sHLA-G levels exists, since other cells (in the placenta) produce sHLA-G as well. CD4+HLA-G+ Treg frequencies within the CD4+ T cell compartment are even higher in the decidua compared to those in peripheral blood (141, 173), suggesting a role in local immune regulation. In women with PE, decidual CD4+HLA-G+ Tregs are decreased, whereas in the peripheral blood their numbers remain unchanged compared to healthy control pregnancies (45, 173), indicating that in a healthy pregnancy these cells are induced locally, but to a lesser extent during PE.
Tr1 Treg
Tr1 Tregs (Figures 3, 5, Table 1) suppresses T cell proliferation mainly through IL-10 and TGF-β production. They also produce low amounts of IFN-γ, IL-5, and IL-2, and express granzyme B (109, 112, 174). Next to cytokine production, they can suppress other immune cells in a cell-contact dependent manner by using their KIR receptors or ectoenzymes (161). Tr1 Tregs are peripherally induced upon chronic antigen stimulation in the presence of IL-10 (175). Both HLA-G and IL-10 provided by APCs, like DC-10 cells, play a role in Tr1 Treg induction (103), indicated by their reduced induction by DC-10s when anti-HLA-G is added in vitro. Additionally, their induction is reverted when agonistic anti-ILT4 antibodies are added, but not when agonistic anti-ILT2 antibodies are added (103). Interestingly, EVTs are also able to induce Tr1-like cells via HLA-G directly (119).
Figure 3
Recently, co-expression of CD49b and LAG-3 has been described as phenotypic markers for Tr1 Tregs in mice and humans (176). This observation is under debate since a subsequent study only detected a small proportion of IL-10+ Tregs co-expressing CD49b and LAG3 (177). Due to their lack of a clear phenotype, Tr1 Tregs are often described as Tr1-like cells, as they have similar properties, such as IL-10 production. Tr1 Tregs can express the co-signaling molecules PD-1, CTLA-4, TIM-3, and ICOS (136, 177–179), and several other molecules related to their function, including GARP, LAP, ectoenzyme CD39, and CD73 (180), as well as KIRs and ILT receptors. FoxP3 is only transiently expressed by Tr1 Tregs. Since functional Tr1 Tregs are found in patients who have a mutation in the FoxP3 gene, FoxP3 appears not to be required for their development (110, 174).
Tr1-like Tregs have been identified in peripheral blood and various tissues (181), including the human decidua (119). These Tregs express high levels of PD-1, express granzymes, and lack FoxP3. They produce IL-10 and IFN-γ, and thereby may have a similar suppressive mechanism as bona fide Tr1 Tregs (119). Similar to Tr1 Treg, decidual Tr1-like Treg induction by EVTs can be partially reverted when agonistic anti-HLA-G antibodies are added, but not by anti-ILT2 (119). Tr1 Tregs are able to selectively lyse APCs in a cell-contact dependent manner, but not B and T cells (161). Lysis of APCs can cause amplification of the tolerogenic process since decreased numbers of activated APCs will generally lead to less activation of T cells. For this, the Tr1 Treg needs HLA-class I recognition of the APC through its KIR receptors, CD54/LFA-1 mediated adhesion, CD58/CD2 interaction, as well as CD155/CD226 ligation (161). Furthermore, the Tr1 has been described to directly affect T cells by their expression of ectoenzyme CD39 and CD73, which disrupts the metabolic state of effector T cells (180).
Th3 Tregs
The main suppressive effects of Th3 Tregs (Figures 4, 5, Table 1) are mediated by TGF-β production, in a cell-contact independent manner (135). Phenotypically these cells are CD25− and FoxP3−, they are thought to express Helios, and express LAP and GARP, which can be used as surrogate markers for TGF-β production (182, 183). Th3 cells also produce IL-10, but unlike Tr1 Tregs, they produce this in conjunction with IL-4 (113, 184). Similar to Tr1 Tregs, Th3 Tregs are peripherally induced upon antigen stimulation (135). The mechanism underlying the induction into either Th3- or Tr1 Treg remains poorly understood and is thought to depend on their microenvironment during priming (114, 185). Another question that remains to be answered is whether Tr1 and Th3 Tregs truly represent different subsets or differentiation states and whether they differ depending on the microenvironment in which they reside.
Figure 4
Figure 5
With the limited markers identified so far, it is difficult to phenotypically identify Th3 Tregs, which may explain the limited number of articles describing the presence of the Th3 cell during pregnancy. Dimova et al. observed in paired decidua and peripheral blood samples mRNA cytokine profiles similar to Th3, the first description of a possible presence of Th3 cells in the decidua (163). Importantly, no functional testing has been performed for Th3-like cells from the decidua, and their presence and role in pregnancy remains to be confirmed. Regardless, Th3 Treg was first described to have an important role in oral tolerance (182). Interestingly, exposure to semen through oral sex has been proposed to be beneficial for subsequent pregnancy outcomes in couples experiencing PE or RPL (186–188), providing a possible mechanistic explanation for this effect.
Other Treg Populations
Besides FoxP3− HLA-G+, Tr1, and Th3 Tregs, other immune regulatory T cell populations that have been described, albeit to a lesser extent, include CD8+ Tregs, nitric oxide (NO) induced FoxP3− Tregs, TIGIT+ Tregs, FoxP3dim Tregs, and γδ T cells (Figure 5, Table 1).
CD8+ Tregs are increasingly being recognized, even though they remain difficult to identify as there is no consensus on their phenotype. Both FoxP3+ and FoxP3− CD8+ Tregs have been described to have suppressive activities, indicating there also is heterogeneity in the CD8+ Treg population (189). Shao et al. showed that a CD8+ Treg subset can be activated by trophoblast cells. This activation appears not to be HLA restricted since their expansion is unaffected when cultured in the presence of pan-HLA class I blocking antibodies (164). When cultured with PBMCs, these CD8+ Tregs suppress the secretion of immunoglobulins in a cell-contact dependent manner, as shown using a trans-well system. While humoral immunity seemed to be dampened, these CD8+ Tregs did not have any suppressive effect on effector T cells. Phenotypically these cells can be identified as being CD101+ and CD103+ (164). Even though in a mixed lymphocyte reaction these CD8+ Tregs do not appear to suppress CD4+ and CD8+ T cells, they could potentially be important for preventing formation and suppressing production of IPA-specific antibodies.
Niedbala et al. described NO-induced Tregs (NO-Tregs) in mice (165). These cells are characterized as CD4+CD25+GITR+CD27+T-betlow, GATA3+, and FoxP3−, and they are induced from CD4+CD25− T cells via p53, IL-2, and OX-40 (165). Experimentally, the development of NO-Tregs was induced when using adoptive transfer of CD4+CD25− T cells into SCID mice, together with application of an NO synthase inhibitor. NO-Tregs produce IL-4 and IL-10, but no IL-2, TGF-β, or IFN-γ. Addition of antagonistic anti-IL4 antibodies led to reduced proliferation of NO-Tregs, whereas blocking IL-10 blocked their suppressive effect on CD4+CD25− cell differentiation (165, 166). These data suggest that NO-Tregs suppress through IL-10, in a cell-contact independent manner. While NO-Tregs has not yet been studied in the context of pregnancy, NO appears to be involved in pregnancy with NO levels fluctuating throughout the different gestational ages and being lower during PE (190–193). It would, therefore, be interesting to retrospectively study first-trimester blood samples of women who develop PE, to test if NO levels are already lower at this early time point of pregnancy, and to study NO-Treg formation in these patients in comparison to healthy controls.
Salvany-Celades et al. identified three types of functional Tregs in the decidua, of which two subsets were negative or low for FoxP3 (119). One of these is the PD-1high, Tr1-like cell, which has been described above. The second is the TIGIT+ Treg that is characterized by TIGIT positivity, low expression of CD25 and FoxP3, and intermediate expression of PD-1. TIGIT+ Tregs express high levels of IFN-γ and IL-2, and low levels of IL-10. TIGIT+ Tregs mainly suppress CD4+ effector T cells in proliferation assays, but not consistently CD8+ effector T cells. Interestingly, TIGIT+ Tregs seem to vary in their characteristics, depending on the trimester in which they are encountered (119): first-trimester TIGIT+ Tregs show an increased expression of IL-10 compared to term TIGIT+ Tregs. This difference in trimesters could be due to the microenvironment influencing their phenotype, or because they truly represent different subsets. TIGIT has been described to be expressed on multiple Treg subsets, and it can bind CD155 on APCs, which thereby increases their IL-10 production (194, 195). Binding of TIGIT induces Tregs to produce IL-10 and fibrinogen-like protein 2 (Fgl2). By usage of Fgl2 the Tregs obtain the capacity to suppress Th1 and Th17 cells in vitro, but not Th2 cells (77, 195). It would be interesting to determine the presence of TIGIT+ Tregs during pregnancy complications and to investigate their possible role in providing a tolerogenic microenvironment in successful pregnancies.
In the first-trimester decidua, γδ T cells produce high amounts of IL-10 and TGF-β (115, 196). As described above, these cytokines are important for establishing an immune suppressive microenvironment in the decidua. Transfer of uterine γδ T cell culture supernatant, containing a high concentration of TGF-β, into the uterus of mice before pregnancy prevents fetal resorption (111). Terzieva et al. identified the TCR repertoire from decidual γδ T cells and compared this to the repertoire of γδ T cells in peripheral blood. In 1st and 3rd trimester decidua they mostly found Vδ1+ TCR, whereas this particular δ chain was hardly present in the peripheral blood (168). Vδ1+ T cells are described to have a tolerogenic effect (167, 197). The possible role of γδ T cells in pregnancy is further suggested by another study showing higher numbers of γδ T cells in peripheral blood from women experiencing RPL compared to controls. The specific presence of the Vδ1 chain was not investigated (198). It would be interesting to determine the frequency and immune-suppressive effect of Vδ1+ T cells in the decidua of women experiencing RPL compared to women with elective termination of pregnancy.
Concluding Remarks
In this review we have discussed several types of Tregs that may contribute to a tolerogenic environment in the decidua (Figure 5, Table 1) besides FoxP3+ Tregs. Decidual Tregs seem to assist other cells in creating and maintaining a microenvironment where inflammatory signals are generally overruled by tolerogenic signals. Next to Tregs, this tolerogenic microenvironment is established and maintained by factors from paternal, maternal and fetal origin. Paternal contribution to this tolerogenic microenvironment comes early on from seminal fluid that contains tolerogenic factors such as TGF-β and paternal antigens for priming. Fetal trophoblasts contribute by their expression of tolerogenic HLA-G and HLA-E molecules, galectins, and PD-L1, and by their production of sHLA-G, IDO, and TGF-β. Next to this, the maternal contribution in maintaining a tolerogenic microenvironment in the decidua is provided by the decidual immune cells, which do not have an activated phenotype and produce IDO, TGF-β, IL-10, and sHLA-G.
It remains to be elucidated which mechanisms exactly attract Tregs to the decidua, if they are activated locally by APCs in the decidua or in the lymph nodes, where they proliferate, and if they are specific for fetal antigens. In mice, it has been shown that fetus-specific Tregs are already detectable in the uterine draining lymph nodes shortly after semen exposure and that their numbers increase upon pregnancy (199). While this could be similar in the human situation, in vitro fertilization with donor semen, where there is no paternal semen exposure, often results in a healthy uncomplicated pregnancy, albeit at a lower rate than in naturally conceived pregnancies (200). More information on the basic mechanisms of FoxP3− Tregs, as well as how they are initiated, is needed to provide insight in the deviations in frequencies or functionality of FoxP3− Treg subsets in pregnancy complications. Likewise, from a therapeutic point of view such basic mechanisms need to be clarified before possible novel therapeutic strategies can be developed. These therapies could be based on therapy designs similar to those proposed for FoxP3+ Tregs, such as infusion of Tregs or application of the cytokines needed for induction of specific Treg subsets (201).
While it is clear that FoxP3+ Tregs play a role in maintaining pregnancy, the relevance of the different types of FoxP3− Tregs herein needs to be established. FoxP3− Tregs with proven suppressive capacities are found in the decidua and are, therefore, likely to contribute to the tolerogenic microenvironment. However, studies such as depletion assays in mice need to be performed to confirm whether they play a non-redundant role in maintaining a healthy pregnancy. Since pregnancy is crucial for the existence of mankind, it is not surprising that there would be multiple mechanisms in play to establish a regulatory microenvironment to maintain a healthy pregnancy. Pregnancy complications for which no clear cause can be identified do occur, and it is plausible that many of these are related to a disbalance in maternal immune regulation. It would be helpful to get a better understanding of the function of all regulatory T cells present in the decidua, to be able to recognize their relevance in healthy and complicated pregnancies. As such, the use of multiple omics techniques to identify the decidual microenvironment by a holistic approach could give insights in the presence, frequency, and distribution of the different types of Tregs in pregnancy [(32, 202, 203); van der Zwan et al., submitted]. It is important to note that the time point of sampling is a crucial factor in such experiments, given the dynamic nature of the placental microenvironment.
Statements
Author contributions
JK contributed to the content design, writing the manuscript, and preparing the figures. FC, SH, and ME supervised the project and participated in critical discussions and evaluations of the text of the manuscript.
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
- Tregs
regulatory T cells
- tTreg
thymic derived regulatory T cell
- pTreg
periphery induced regulatory T cell
- EVTs
cytotrophoblasts (CTBs), syncytiotrophoblasts (SCTs) and extravillous trophoblasts
- HLA
human leukocyte antigen
- APCs
antigen presenting cells
- KIR
killer-cell immunoglobulin-like receptor
- TCR
T cell receptor
- IDO
indoleamine 2,3-dioxygenase
- dNK
decidual NK
- RPL
recurrent pregnancy loss
- PE
pre-eclampsia
- SNPs
single nucleotide polymorphisms
- NK
natural killer
- ILCs
innate lymphoid cell
- DCs
dendritic cells
- DC-10
tolerogenic DCs
- mTOR
mammalian target of rapamycin
- NO
nitric oxide
- TGF-β
transforming growth factor-beta
- IFN-γ
interferon gamma.
Abbreviations
References
1.
EllisSAPalmerMSMcMichaelAJ. Human trophoblast and the choriocarcinoma cell line BeWo express a truncated HLA Class I molecule. J Immunol. (1990) 144:731–5.
2.
MalletVBlaschitzACrisaLSchmittCFournelSKingAet al. HLA-G in the human thymus: a subpopulation of medullary epithelial but not CD83(+) dendritic cells expresses HLA-G as a membrane-bound and soluble protein. Int Immunol. (1999) 11:889–98. 10.1093/intimm/11.6.889
3.
Le DiscordeMMoreauPSabatierPLegeaisJMCarosellaED. Expression of HLA-G in human cornea, an immune-privileged tissue. Hum Immunol. (2003) 64:1039–44. 10.1016/j.humimm.2003.08.346
4.
CirulliVZalatanJMcMasterMPrinsenRSalomonDRRicordiCet al. The class I HLA repertoire of pancreatic islets comprises the nonclassical class Ib antigen HLA-G. Diabetes. (2006) 55:1214–22. 10.2337/db05-0731
5.
PapuchovaHMeissnerTBLiQStromingerJLTilburgsT. The Dual Role of HLA-C in Tolerance and Immunity at the Maternal-Fetal Interface. Front Immunol. (2019) 10:2730. 10.3389/fimmu.2019.02730
6.
TilburgsTScherjonSAvan der MastBJHaasnootGWVersteegVDV-MMRoelenDLet al. Fetal-maternal HLA-C mismatch is associated with decidual T cell activation and induction of functional T regulatory cells. J Reprod Immunol. (2009) 82:148–57. 10.1016/j.jri.2009.05.003
7.
AppsRMurphySPFernandoRGardnerLAhadTMoffettA. Human leucocyte antigen. (HLA) expression of primary trophoblast cells and placental cell lines, determined using single antigen beads to characterize allotype specificities of anti-HLA antibodies. Immunology. (2009) 127:26–39. 10.1111/j.1365-2567.2008.03019.x
8.
HackmonRPinnaduwageLZhangJLyeSJGeraghtyDEDunkCE. Definitive class I human leukocyte antigen expression in gestational placentation: HLA-F, HLA-E, HLA-C, and HLA-G in extravillous trophoblast invasion on placentation, pregnancy, and parturition. Am J Reprod Immunol. (2017) 77. 10.1111/aji.12643
9.
Rouas-FreissNGoncalvesRMMenierCDaussetJCarosellaED. Direct evidence to support the role of HLA-G in protecting the fetus from maternal uterine natural killer cytolysis. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. (1997) 94:11520–5. 10.1073/pnas.94.21.11520
10.
HuntJSPetroffMGMcIntireRHOberC. HLA-G and immune tolerance in pregnancy. FASEB J. (2005) 19:681–93. 10.1096/fj.04-2078rev
11.
TilburgsTCrespoACvan der ZwanARybalovBRajTStrangerBet al. Human HLA-G plus extravillous trophoblasts: immune-activating cells that interact with decidual leukocytes. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. (2015) 112:7219–24. 10.1073/pnas.1507977112
12.
BraudVMAllanDSO'CallaghanCASoderstromKD'AndreaAOggGSet al. HLA-E binds to natural killer cell receptors CD94/NKG2A, B and C. Nature. (1998) 391:795–9. 10.1038/35869
13.
BlaschitzAHutterHDohrG. HLA Class I protein expression in the human placenta. Early Pregnancy. (2001) 5:67–9.
14.
AppsRGardnerLTraherneJMaleVMoffettA. Natural-killer cell ligands at the maternal-fetal interface: UL-16 binding proteins, MHC class-I chain related molecules, HLA-F and CD48. Hum Reprod. (2008) 23:2535–48. 10.1093/humrep/den223
15.
ClarkDAKeilAChenZMarkertUManuelJGorczynskiRM. Placental trophoblast from successful human pregnancies expresses the tolerance signaling molecule, CD200 (OX-2). Am J Reprod Immunol. (2003) 50:187–95. 10.1034/j.1600-0897.2003.00086.x
16.
AbrahamsVMStraszewski-ChavezSLGullerSMorG. First trimester trophoblast cells secrete Fas ligand which induces immune cell apoptosis. Mol Hum Reprod. (2004) 10:55–63. 10.1093/molehr/gah006
17.
PetroffMGKharatyanETorryDSHoletsL. The immunomodulatory proteins B7-DC, B7-H2, and B7-H3 are differentially expressed across gestation in the human placenta. Am J Pathol. (2005) 167:465–73. 10.1016/S0002-9440(10)62990-2
18.
JonesRLStoikosCFindlayJKSalamonsenLA. TGF-beta superfamily expression and actions in the endometrium and placenta. Reproduction. (2006) 132:217–32. 10.1530/rep.1.01076
19.
LuBTengXFuGBaoLTangJShiHet al. Analysis of PD-L1 expression in trophoblastic tissues and tumors. Hum Pathol. (2019) 84:202–12. 10.1016/j.humpath.2018.10.001
20.
YeungAWTerentisACKingNJThomasSR. Role of indoleamine 2,3-dioxygenase in health and disease. Clin Sci. (2015) 129:601–72. 10.1042/CS20140392
21.
BaloghATothERomeroRParejKCsalaDSzenasiNLet al. Placental galectins are key players in regulating the maternal adaptive immune response. Front Immunol. (2019) 10:1240. 10.3389/fimmu.2019.01240
22.
RamhorstREGiribaldiLFraccaroliLToscanoMAStupirskiJCRomeroMDet al. Galectin-1 confers immune privilege to human trophoblast: implications in recurrent fetal loss. Glycobiology. (2012) 22:1374–86. 10.1093/glycob/cws104
23.
ThanNGRomeroRGoodmanMWeckleAXingJDongZet al. A primate subfamily of galectins expressed at the maternal-fetal interface that promote immune cell death. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. (2009) 106:9731–6. 10.1073/pnas.0903568106
24.
BloisSMIlarreguiJMTomettenMGarciaMOrsalASCordo-RussoRet al. A pivotal role for galectin-1 in fetomaternal tolerance. Nat Med. (2007) 13:1450–7. 10.1038/nm1680
25.
MoldenhauerLMDienerKRThringDMBrownMPHayballJDRobertsonSA. Cross-presentation of male seminal fluid antigens elicits T cell activation to initiate the female immune response to pregnancy. J Immunol. (2009) 182:8080–93. 10.4049/jimmunol.0804018
26.
SharkeyDJTremellenKPJasperMJGemzell-DanielssonKRobertsonSA. Seminal fluid induces leukocyte recruitment and cytokine and chemokine mRNA expression in the human cervix after coitus. J Immunol. (2012) 188:2445–54. 10.4049/jimmunol.1102736
27.
BulmerJNMorrisonLLongfellowMRitsonAPaceD. Granulated lymphocytes in human endometrium: histochemical and immunohistochemical studies. Hum Reprod. (1991) 6:791–8. 10.1093/oxfordjournals.humrep.a137430
28.
HeikkinenJMottonenMAlanenALassilaO. Phenotypic characterization of regulatory T cells in the human decidua. Clin Exp Immunol. (2004) 136:373–8. 10.1111/j.1365-2249.2004.02441.x
29.
WilliamsPJSearleRFRobsonSCInnesBABulmerJN. Decidual leucocyte populations in early to late gestation normal human pregnancy. J Reprod Immunol. (2009) 82:24–31. 10.1016/j.jri.2009.08.001
30.
BulmerJNWilliamsPJLashGE. Immune cells in the placental bed. Int J Dev Biol. (2010) 54:281–94. 10.1387/ijdb.082763jb
31.
Gomez-LopezNGuilbertLJOlsonDM. Invasion of the leukocytes into the fetal-maternal interface during pregnancy. J Leukoc Biol. (2010) 88:625–33. 10.1189/jlb.1209796
32.
Vento-TormoREfremovaMBottingRATurcoMYVento-TormoMMeyerKBet al. Single-cell reconstruction of the early maternal-fetal interface in humans. Nature. (2018) 563:347–53. 10.1038/s41586-018-0698-6
33.
MoldenhauerLMHayballJDRobertsonSA. Utilising T cell receptor transgenic mice to define mechanisms of maternal T cell tolerance in pregnancy. J Reprod Immunol. (2010) 87:1–13. 10.1016/j.jri.2010.05.007
34.
LissauerDPiperKGoodyearOKilbyMDMossPA. Fetal-specific CD8+ cytotoxic T cell responses develop during normal human pregnancy and exhibit broad functional capacity. J Immunol. (2012) 189:1072–80. 10.4049/jimmunol.1200544
35.
TilburgsTStromingerJL. CD8+ effector T cells at the fetal-maternal interface, balancing fetal tolerance and antiviral immunity. Am J Reprod Immunol. (2013) 69:395–407. 10.1111/aji.12094
36.
NakajimaHManoYTokunagaENozueG. Influence of previous pregnancy on maternal response to foetal antigens. Tissue Antigens. (1982) 19:92–4. 10.1111/j.1399-0039.1982.tb01421.x
37.
ReganLBraudePR. Is antipaternal cytotoxic antibody a valid marker in the management of recurrent abortion?Lancet. (1987) 2:1280. 10.1016/S0140-6736(87)91896-4
38.
ReganLBraudePRHillDP. A prospective study of the incidence, time of appearance and significance of anti-paternal lymphocytotoxic antibodies in human pregnancy. Hum Reprod. (1991) 6:294–8. 10.1093/oxfordjournals.humrep.a137325
39.
PietraGRomagnaniCManziniCMorettaLMingariMC. The emerging role of HLA-E-restricted CD8+ T lymphocytes in the adaptive immune response to pathogens and tumors. J Biomed Biotechnol. (2010) 2010:907092. 10.1155/2010/907092
40.
van KampenCAVersteeg-van der Voort MaarschalkMFJLangerak-LangerakJvan BeelenERoelenDLClaasFHJ. Pregnancy can induce long-persisting primed CTLs specific for inherited paternal HLA antigens. Human Immunol. (2001) 62:201–7. 10.1016/S0198-8859(01)00209-9
41.
AgrawalSPandeyMKMandalSMishraLAgarwalS. Humoral immune response to an allogenic foetus in normal fertile women and recurrent aborters. BMC Pregn Childbirth. (2002) 2:6. 10.1186/1471-2393-2-6
42.
LeeJRomeroRXuYMirandaJYooWChaemsaithongPet al. Detection of anti-HLA antibodies in maternal blood in the second trimester to identify patients at risk of antibody-mediated maternal anti-fetal rejection and spontaneous preterm delivery. Am J Reprod Immunol. (2013) 70:162–75. 10.1111/aji.12141
43.
MeulemanTvan BeelenEKaajaRJvan LithJMClaasFHBloemenkampKW. HLA-C antibodies in women with recurrent miscarriage suggests that antibody mediated rejection is one of the mechanisms leading to recurrent miscarriage. J Reprod Immunol. (2016) 116:28–34. 10.1016/j.jri.2016.03.003
44.
SomersetDAZhengYKilbyMDSansomDMDraysonMT. Normal human pregnancy is associated with an elevation in the immune suppressive CD25+ CD4+ regulatory T-cell subset. Immunology. (2004) 112:38–43. 10.1111/j.1365-2567.2004.01869.x
45.
ZareMNamavar JahromiBGharesi-FardB. Analysis of the frequencies and functions of CD4(+)CD25(+)CD127(low/neg), CD4(+)HLA-G(+), and CD8(+)HLA-G(+) regulatory T cells in pre-eclampsia. J Reprod Immunol. (2019) 133:43–51. 10.1016/j.jri.2019.06.002
46.
TilburgsTRoelenDLvan der MastBJvan SchipJJKleijburgCdeGroot-Swings GMet al. Differential distribution of CD4(+)CD25(bright) and CD8(+)CD28(-) T-cells in decidua and maternal blood during human pregnancy. Placenta. (2006) 27(Suppl. A):S47–53. 10.1016/j.placenta.2005.11.008
47.
MjosbergJBergGJenmalmMCErnerudhJ. FOXP3+ regulatory T cells and T helper 1, T helper 2, and T helper 17 cells in human early pregnancy decidua. Biol Reprod. (2010) 82:698–705. 10.1095/biolreprod.109.081208
48.
ZenclussenACGerlofKZenclussenMLSollwedelABertojaAZRitterTet al. Abnormal T-cell reactivity against paternal antigens in spontaneous abortion: adoptive transfer of pregnancy-induced CD4+CD25+ T regulatory cells prevents fetal rejection in a murine abortion model. Am J Pathol. (2005) 166:811–22. 10.1016/S0002-9440(10)62302-4
49.
ShimaTSasakiYItohMNakashimaAIshiiNSugamuraKet al. Regulatory T cells are necessary for implantation and maintenance of early pregnancy but not late pregnancy in allogeneic mice. J Reprod Immunol. (2010) 85:121–9. 10.1016/j.jri.2010.02.006
50.
RoweJHErteltJMAguileraMNFarrarMAWaySS. Foxp3(+) regulatory T cell expansion required for sustaining pregnancy compromises host defense against prenatal bacterial pathogens. Cell Host Microbe. (2011) 10:54–64. 10.1016/j.chom.2011.06.005
51.
KellerCCEikmansMvan der HoornM-LPLashleyLEELO. Recurrent miscarriages and the association with regulatory T cells; A systematic review. J Reprod Immunol. (2020) 139:103105. 10.1016/j.jri.2020.103105
52.
SasakiYDarmochwal-KolarzDSuzukiDSakaiMItoMShimaTet al. Proportion of peripheral blood and decidual CD4(+) CD25(bright) regulatory T cells in pre-eclampsia. Clin Exp Immunol. (2007) 149:139–45. 10.1111/j.1365-2249.2007.03397.x
53.
HanXGhaemiMSAndoKPetersonLSGanioEATsaiASet al. Differential Dynamics of the Maternal Immune System in Healthy Pregnancy and Preeclampsia. Front Immunol. (2019) 10:1305. 10.3389/fimmu.2019.01305
54.
LiuYFanXWangRLuXDangYLWangHet al. Single-cell RNA-seq reveals the diversity of trophoblast subtypes and patterns of differentiation in the human placenta. Cell Res. (2018) 28:819–32. 10.1038/s41422-018-0066-y
55.
GuerinLRPrinsJRRobertsonSA. Regulatory T-cells and immune tolerance in pregnancy: a new target for infertility treatment?Hum Reprod Update. (2009) 15:517–35. 10.1093/humupd/dmp004
56.
RaiRReganL. Recurrent miscarriage. Lancet. (2006) 368:601–11. 10.1016/S0140-6736(06)69204-0
57.
WhitleyGSCartwrightJE. Trophoblast-mediated spiral artery remodelling: a role for apoptosis. J Anat. (2009) 215:21–6. 10.1111/j.1469-7580.2008.01039.x
58.
GershonRKKondoK. Cell interactions in the induction of tolerance: the role of thymic lymphocytes. Immunology. (1970) 18:723–37.
59.
GreenDRFloodPMGershonRK. Immunoregulatory T-cell pathways. Annu Rev Immunol. (1983) 1:439–63. 10.1146/annurev.iy.01.040183.002255
60.
SakaguchiSWingKMiyaraM. Regulatory T cells - a brief history and perspective. Eur J Immunol. (2007) 37(Suppl. 1):S116–23. 10.1002/eji.200737593
61.
BrunkowMEJefferyEWHjerrildKAPaeperBClarkLBYasaykoSAet al. Disruption of a new forkhead/winged-helix protein, scurfin, results in the fatal lymphoproliferative disorder of the scurfy mouse. Nat Genet. (2001) 27:68–73. 10.1038/83784
62.
HoriSNomuraTSakaguchiS. Control of regulatory T cell development by the transcription factor Foxp3. Science. (2003) 299:1057–61. 10.1126/science.1079490
63.
ApostolouISarukhanAKleinLvon BoehmerH. Origin of regulatory T cells with known specificity for antigen. Nat Immunol. (2002) 3:756–63. 10.1038/ni816
64.
ChenWJinWHardegenNLeiKJLiLMarinosNet al. Conversion of peripheral CD4+CD25- naive T cells to CD4+CD25+ regulatory T cells by TGF-beta induction of transcription factor Foxp3. J Exp Med. (2003) 198:1875–86. 10.1084/jem.20030152
65.
ShevachEMThorntonAM. tTregs, pTregs, and iTregs: similarities and differences. Immunol Rev. (2014) 259:88–102. 10.1111/imr.12160
66.
ThorntonAMKortyPETranDQWohlfertEAMurrayPEBelkaidYet al. Expression of Helios, an Ikaros transcription factor family member, differentiates thymic-derived from peripherally induced Foxp3+ T regulatory cells. J Immunol. (2010) 184:3433–41. 10.4049/jimmunol.0904028
67.
YadavMLouvetCDaviniDGardnerJMMartinez-LlordellaMBailey-BucktroutSet al. Neuropilin-1 distinguishes natural and inducible regulatory T cells among regulatory T cell subsets in vivo. J Exp Med. (2012) 209:1713–22. 10.1084/jem.20120822
68.
CorbelCLemarchandelVThomas-VaslinVPelusASAgbotonCRomeoPH. Neuropilin 1 and CD25 co-regulation during early murine thymic differentiation. Dev Comp Immunol. (2007) 31:1082–94. 10.1016/j.dci.2007.01.009
69.
SzurekECebulaAWojciechLPietrzakMRempalaGKisielowPet al. Differences in expression level of helios and neuropilin-1 do not distinguish thymus-derived from extrathymically-induced CD4+Foxp3+ regulatory T cells. PLoS ONE. (2015) 10:e0141161. 10.1371/journal.pone.0141161
70.
ElkordE. Helios should not be cited as a marker of human thymus-derived tregs. commentary: Helios(+) and Helios(-) cells coexist within the natural FOXP3(+) T regulatory cell subset in humans. Front Immunol. (2016) 7:276. 10.3389/fimmu.2016.00276
71.
KimHJBarnitzRAKreslavskyTBrownFDMoffettHLemieuxMEet al. Stable inhibitory activity of regulatory T cells requires the transcription factor Helios. Science. (2015) 350:334–9. 10.1126/science.aad0616
72.
HansenWHutzlerMAbelSAlterCStockmannCKlicheSet al. Neuropilin 1 deficiency on CD4+Foxp3+ regulatory T cells impairs mouse melanoma growth. J Exp Med. (2012) 209:2001–16. 10.1084/jem.20111497
73.
MilpiedPRenandABruneauJMendes-da-CruzDAJacquelinSAsnafiVet al. Neuropilin-1 is not a marker of human Foxp3+ Treg. Eur J Immunol. (2009) 39:1466–71. 10.1002/eji.200839040
74.
ZhengYJosefowiczSChaudhryAPengXPForbushKRudenskyAY. Role of conserved non-coding DNA elements in the Foxp3 gene in regulatory T-cell fate. Nature. (2010) 463:808–12. 10.1038/nature08750
75.
RudenskyAY. Regulatory T cells and Foxp3. Immunol Rev. (2011) 241:260–8. 10.1111/j.1600-065X.2011.01018.x
76.
WagnerMIJostMSpratteJSchaierMMahnkeKMeuerSet al. Differentiation of ICOS+ and ICOS- recent thymic emigrant regulatory T cells. (RTE T regs) during normal pregnancy, pre-eclampsia and HELLP syndrome. Clin Exp Immunol. (2016) 183:129–42. 10.1111/cei.12693
77.
JollerNKuchrooVK. Tim-3, Lag-3, and TIGIT. Curr Top Microbiol Immunol. (2017) 410:127–56. 10.1007/82_2017_62
78.
JiangLTangCGongYLiuYRaoJChenSet al. PD-1/PD-L1 regulates Treg differentiation in pregnancy-induced hypertension. Braz J Med Biol Res. (2018) 51:e7334. 10.1590/1414-431x20187334
79.
XuYYWangSCLiDJDuMR. Co-signaling molecules in maternal-fetal immunity. Trends Mol Med. (2017) 23:46–58. 10.1016/j.molmed.2016.11.001
80.
MikoEMeggyesMDobaKBarakonyiASzeredayL. Immune checkpoint molecules in reproductive immunology. Front Immunol. (2019) 10:846. 10.3389/fimmu.2019.00846
81.
ZhangYHSunHX. Immune checkpoint molecules in pregnancy: focus on regulatory T cells. Eur J Immunol. (2020) 50:160–9. 10.1002/eji.201948382
82.
SakaguchiSSakaguchiNAsanoMItohMTodaM. Immunologic self-tolerance maintained by activated T cells expressing IL-2 receptor alpha-chains. (CD25). Breakdown of a single mechanism of self-tolerance causes various autoimmune diseases. J Immunol. (1995) 155:1151–64.
83.
LiuWPutnamALXu-YuZSzotGLLeeMRZhuSet al. CD127 expression inversely correlates with FoxP3 and suppressive function of human CD4+ T reg cells. J Exp Med. (2006) 203:1701–11. 10.1084/jem.20060772
84.
YuNLiXSongWLiDYuDZengXet al. CD4(+)CD25. (+)CD127. (low/-) T cells: a more specific Treg population in human peripheral blood. Inflammation. (2012) 35:1773–80. 10.1007/s10753-012-9496-8
85.
KostenIJRustemeyerT. Generation, subsets and functions of inducible regulatory T cells. Antiinflamm Antiallergy Agents Med Chem. (2015) 13:139–53. 10.2174/1871523013666141126100019
86.
JorgensenNPerssonGHviidTVF. The tolerogenic function of regulatory t cells in pregnancy and cancer. Front Immunol. (2019) 10:911. 10.3389/fimmu.2019.00911
87.
TsudaSNakashimaAShimaTSaitoS. New paradigm in the role of regulatory T cells during pregnancy. Front Immunol. (2019) 10:573. 10.3389/fimmu.2019.00573
88.
MosserDMZhangX. Interleukin-10: new perspectives on an old cytokine. Immunol Rev. (2008) 226:205–18. 10.1111/j.1600-065X.2008.00706.x
89.
ThaxtonJESharmaS. Interleukin-10: a multi-faceted agent of pregnancy. Am J Reprod Immunol. (2010) 63:482–91. 10.1111/j.1600-0897.2010.00810.x
90.
BusseMCampeKJNowakDSchumacherAPlenaglSLangwischSet al. IL-10 producing B cells rescue mouse fetuses from inflammation-driven fetal death and are able to modulate T cell immune responses. Sci Rep. (2019) 9:9335. 10.1038/s41598-019-45860-2
91.
SvenssonLArvolaMSallstromMAHolmdahlRMattssonR. The Th2 cytokines IL-4 and IL-10 are not crucial for the completion of allogeneic pregnancy in mice. J Reprod Immunol. (2001) 51:3–7. 10.1016/S0165-0378(01)00065-1
92.
MurphySPFastLDHannaNNSharmaS. Uterine NK cells mediate inflammation-induced fetal demise in IL-10-null mice. J Immunol. (2005) 175:4084–90. 10.4049/jimmunol.175.6.4084
93.
HennessyAPilmoreHLSimmonsLAPainterDM. A deficiency of placental IL-10 in preeclampsia. J Immunol. (1999) 163:3491–5.
94.
RaghupathyRMakhseedMAziziehFHassanNAl-AzemiMAl-ShamaliE. Maternal Th1- and Th2-type reactivity to placental antigens in normal human pregnancy and unexplained recurrent spontaneous abortions. Cell Immunol. (1999) 196:122–30. 10.1006/cimm.1999.1532
95.
PlevyakMHannaNMayerSMurphySPinarHFastLet al. Deficiency of decidual IL-10 in first trimester missed abortion: a lack of correlation with the decidual immune cell profile. Am J Reprod Immunol. (2002) 47:242–50. 10.1034/j.1600-0897.2002.01060.x
96.
BanerjeePGhoshSDuttaMSubramaniEKhalpadaJRoychoudhurySet al. Identification of key contributory factors responsible for vascular dysfunction in idiopathic recurrent spontaneous miscarriage. PLoS ONE. (2013) 8:e80940. 10.1371/journal.pone.0080940
97.
WangLQYanXTYanCFZhangXWHuiLYXueMet al. Women with recurrent miscarriage have decreased expression of 25-hydroxyvitamin D3-1alpha-hydroxylase by the fetal-maternal interface. PLoS ONE. (2016) 11:e0165589. 10.1371/journal.pone.0165589
98.
AziziehFYRaghupathyR. IL-10 and pregnancy complications. Clin Exp Obstet Gynecol. (2017) 44:252–8. 10.12891/ceog3456.2017
99.
MoreauPAdrian-CabestreFMenierCGuiardVGourandLDaussetJet al. IL-10 selectively induces HLA-G expression in human trophoblasts and monocytes. Int Immunol. (1999) 11:803–11. 10.1093/intimm/11.5.803
100.
SteinbrinkKWolflMJonuleitHKnopJEnkAH. Induction of tolerance by IL-10-treated dendritic cells. J Immunol. (1997) 159:4772–80.
101.
RistichVLiangSZhangWWuJHoruzskoA. Tolerization of dendritic cells by HLA-G. Eur J Immunol. (2005) 35:1133–42. 10.1002/eji.200425741
102.
ManavalanJSRossiPCVladGPiazzaFYarilinaACortesiniRet al. High expression of ILT3 and ILT4 is a general feature of tolerogenic dendritic cells. Transpl Immunol. (2003) 11:245–58. 10.1016/S0966-3274(03)00058-3
103.
GregoriSMagnaniCFRoncaroloMG. Role of human leukocyte antigen-G in the induction of adaptive type 1 regulatory T cells. Hum Immunol. (2009) 70:966–9. 10.1016/j.humimm.2009.07.022
104.
ComiMAmodioGGregoriS. Interleukin-10-producing DC-10 is a unique tool to promote tolerance via antigen-specific T regulatory type 1 cells. Front Immunol. (2018) 9:682. 10.3389/fimmu.2018.00682
105.
GregoriSTomasoniDPaccianiVScirpoliMBattagliaMMagnaniCFet al. Differentiation of type 1 T regulatory cells. (Tr1) by tolerogenic DC-10 requires the IL-10-dependent ILT4/HLA-G pathway. Blood. (2010) 116:935–44. 10.1182/blood-2009-07-234872
106.
IpWKEHoshiNShouvalDSSnapperSMedzhitovR. Anti-inflammatory effect of IL-10 mediated by metabolic reprogramming of macrophages. Science. (2017) 356:513–9. 10.1126/science.aal3535
107.
O'FarrellAMLiuYMooreKWMuiAL. IL-10 inhibits macrophage activation and proliferation by distinct signaling mechanisms: evidence for Stat3-dependent and -independent pathways. EMBO J. (1998) 17:1006–18. 10.1093/emboj/17.4.1006
108.
GrouxHBiglerMde VriesJERoncaroloMG. Interleukin-10 induces a long-term antigen-specific anergic state in human CD4+ T cells. J Exp Med. (1996) 184:19–29. 10.1084/jem.184.1.19
109.
LevingsMKSangregorioRGalbiatiFSquadroneSde Waal MalefytRRoncaroloMG. IFN-alpha and IL-10 induce the differentiation of human type 1 T regulatory cells. J Immunol. (2001) 166:5530–9. 10.4049/jimmunol.166.9.5530
110.
LevingsMKGregoriSTresoldiECazzanigaSBoniniCRoncaroloMG. Differentiation of Tr1 cells by immature dendritic cells requires IL-10 but not CD25+CD4+ Tr cells. Blood. (2005) 105:1162–9. 10.1182/blood-2004-03-1211
111.
SuzukiTHiromatsuKAndoYOkamotoTTomodaYYoshikaiY. Regulatory role of gamma delta T cells in uterine intraepithelial lymphocytes in maternal antifetal immune response. J Immunol. (1995) 154:4476–84.
112.
GrouxHO'GarraABiglerMRouleauMAntonenkoSde VriesJEet al. A CD4+ T-cell subset inhibits antigen-specific T-cell responses and prevents colitis. Nature. (1997) 389:737–42. 10.1038/39614
113.
InobeJSlavinAJKomagataYChenYLiuLWeinerHL. IL-4 is a differentiation factor for transforming growth factor-beta secreting Th3 cells and oral administration of IL-4 enhances oral tolerance in experimental allergic encephalomyelitis. Eur J Immunol. (1998) 28:2780–90.
114.
WeinerHL. The mucosal milieu creates tolerogenic dendritic cells and T(R)1 and T(H)3 regulatory cells. Nat Immunol. (2001) 2:671–2. 10.1038/90604
115.
NagaevaOJonssonLMincheva-NilssonL. Dominant IL-10 and TGF-beta mRNA expression in gammadeltaT cells of human early pregnancy decidua suggests immunoregulatory potential. Am J Reprod Immunol. (2002) 48:9–17. 10.1034/j.1600-0897.2002.01131.x
116.
CobboldSPAdamsENolanKFRegateiroFSWaldmannH. Connecting the mechanisms of T-cell regulation: dendritic cells as the missing link. Immunol Rev. (2010) 236:203–18. 10.1111/j.1600-065X.2010.00913.x
117.
SanjabiSOhSALiMO. Regulation of the immune response by TGF-beta: from conception to autoimmunity and infection. Cold Spring Harb Perspect Biol. (2017) 9:a022236. 10.1101/cshperspect.a022236
118.
PollheimerJVondraSBaltayevaJBeristainAGKnoflerM. Regulation of placental extravillous trophoblasts by the maternal uterine environment. Front Immunol. (2018) 9:2597. 10.3389/fimmu.2018.02597
119.
Salvany-CeladesMvan der ZwanABennerMSetrajcic-DragosVBougleux GomesHAIyerVet al. Three types of functional regulatory T cells control T cell responses at the human maternal-fetal interface. Cell Rep. (2019) 27:2537–47 e2535. 10.1016/j.celrep.2019.04.109
120.
ZhangJDunkCEShynlovaOCaniggiaILyeSJ. TGFb1 suppresses the activation of distinct dNK subpopulations in preeclampsia. EBioMedicine. (2019) 39:531–9. 10.1016/j.ebiom.2018.12.015
121.
LashGEOtunHAInnesBABulmerJNSearleRFRobsonSC. Inhibition of trophoblast cell invasion by TGFB1, 2, and 3 is associated with a decrease in active proteases. Biol Reprod. (2005) 73:374–81. 10.1095/biolreprod.105.040337
122.
LafontaineLChaudhryPLafleurMJVan ThemscheCSoaresMJAsselinE. Transforming growth factor Beta regulates proliferation and invasion of rat placental cell lines. Biol Reprod. (2011) 84:553–9. 10.1095/biolreprod.110.086348
123.
SinghMOrazulikeNCAshmoreJKonjeJC. Changes in maternal serum transforming growth factor beta-1 during pregnancy: a cross-sectional study. Biomed Res Int. (2013) 2013:318464. 10.1155/2013/318464
124.
XieJCaoY. Expression of TGF-beta1 and miR-99a in serum of patients with early spontaneous abortion and correlation with hormone levels during pregnancy. Exp Ther Med. (2019) 17:4593–7. 10.3892/etm.2019.7477
125.
QiuTTengYWangYXuL. Adoptive transfer of transforming growth factor-?1-induced CD4+CD25+ regulatory T cells prevents immune response-mediated spontaneous abortion. Reprod Fertil Dev. (2015) 28:1788–97. 10.1071/RD14503
126.
DelisleJSGirouxMBoucherGLandryJRHardyMPLemieuxSet al. The TGF-beta-Smad3 pathway inhibits CD28-dependent cell growth and proliferation of CD4 T cells. Genes Immun. (2013) 14:115–26. 10.1038/gene.2012.63
127.
VielSMarcaisAGuimaraesFSLoftusRRabilloudJGrauMet al. TGF-beta inhibits the activation and functions of NK cells by repressing the mTOR pathway. Sci Signal. (2016) 9:ra19. 10.1126/scisignal.aad1884
128.
GorelikLConstantSFlavellRA. Mechanism of transforming growth factor beta-induced inhibition of T helper type 1 differentiation. J Exp Med. (2002) 195:1499–505. 10.1084/jem.20012076
129.
GorelikLFlavellRA. Transforming growth factor-beta in T-cell biology. Nat Rev Immunol. (2002) 2:46–53. 10.1038/nri704
130.
BogdanCNathanC. Modulation of macrophage function by transforming growth factor beta, interleukin-4, and interleukin-10. Ann N Y Acad Sci. (1993) 685:713–39. 10.1111/j.1749-6632.1993.tb35934.x
131.
VodovotzYBogdanC. Control of nitric oxide synthase expression by transforming growth factor-beta: implications for homeostasis. Prog Growth Factor Res. (1994) 5:341–51. 10.1016/0955-2235(94)00004-5
132.
LeeYJHanYLuHTNguyenVQinHHowePHet al. TGF-beta suppresses IFN-gamma induction of class II MHC gene expression by inhibiting class II transactivator messenger RNA expression. J Immunol. (1997) 158:2065–75.
133.
NandanDReinerNE. TGF-beta attenuates the class II transactivator and reveals an accessory pathway of IFN-gamma action. J Immunol. (1997) 158:1095–101.
134.
YamaguchiYTsumuraHMiwaMInabaK. Contrasting effects of TGF-beta 1 and TNF-alpha on the development of dendritic cells from progenitors in mouse bone marrow. Stem Cells. (1997) 15:144–53. 10.1002/stem.150144
135.
WeinerHL. Induction and mechanism of action of transforming growth factor-beta-secreting Th3 regulatory cells. Immunol Rev. (2001) 182:207–14. 10.1034/j.1600-065X.2001.1820117.x
136.
LevingsMKBacchettaRSchulzURoncaroloMG. The role of IL-10 and TGF-beta in the differentiation and effector function of T regulatory cells. Int Arch Allergy Immunol. (2002) 129:263–76. 10.1159/000067596
137.
FuSZhangNYoppACChenDMaoMChenDet al. TGF-beta induces Foxp3 + T-regulatory cells from CD4 + CD25 - precursors. Am J Transplant. (2004) 4:1614–27. 10.1111/j.1600-6143.2004.00566.x
138.
CarrierYYuanJKuchrooVKWeinerHL. Th3 cells in peripheral tolerance. I. Induction of Foxp3-positive regulatory T cells by Th3 cells derived from TGF-beta T cell-transgenic mice. J Immunol. (2007) 178:179–85. 10.4049/jimmunol.178.1.179
139.
FegerUTolosaEHuangYHWaschbischABiedermannTMelmsAet al. HLA-G expression defines a novel regulatory T-cell subset present in human peripheral blood and sites of inflammation. Blood. (2007) 110:568–77. 10.1182/blood-2006-11-057125
140.
CarosellaEDGregoriSLeMaoultJ. The tolerogenic interplay(s) among HLA-G, myeloid APCs, and regulatory cells. Blood. (2011) 118:6499–505. 10.1182/blood-2011-07-370742
141.
AmodioGMugioneASanchezAMViganoPCandianiMSomiglianaEet al. HLA-G expressing DC-10 and CD4(+) T cells accumulate in human decidua during pregnancy. Hum Immunol. (2013) 74:406–11. 10.1016/j.humimm.2012.11.031
142.
HoWangYinKYLoustauMWuJAlegreEDaouyaMCaumartinJet al. Multimeric structures of HLA-G isoforms function through differential binding to LILRB receptors. Cell Mol Life Sci. (2012) 69:4041–9. 10.1007/s00018-012-1069-3
143.
ChenXYYanWHLinAXuHHZhangJGWangXX. The 14 bp deletion polymorphisms in HLA-G gene play an important role in the expression of soluble HLA-G in plasma. Tissue Antigens. (2008) 72:335–41. 10.1111/j.1399-0039.2008.01107.x
144.
CraenmehrMHCHaasnootGWDrabbelsJJMSpruyt-GerritseMJCaoMvan der KeurCet al. Soluble HLA-G levels in seminal plasma are associated with HLA-G 3'UTR genotypes and haplotypes. HLA. (2019) 94:339–46. 10.1111/tan.13628
145.
HuntJSJadhavLChuWGeraghtyDEOberC. Soluble HLA-G circulates in maternal blood during pregnancy. Am J Obstet Gynecol. (2000) 183:682–8. 10.1067/mob.2000.106762
146.
YieSMLiLHLiYMLibrachC. HLA-G protein concentrations in maternal serum and placental tissue are decreased in preeclampsia. Am J Obstet Gynecol. (2004) 191:525–9. 10.1016/j.ajog.2004.01.033
147.
JassemRMShaniWSLoiselDAShariefMBillstrandCOberC. HLA-G polymorphisms and soluble HLA-G protein levels in women with recurrent pregnancy loss from Basrah province in Iraq. Hum Immunol. (2012) 73:811–7. 10.1016/j.humimm.2012.05.009
148.
KeskinFKaratasAAlbayrakMBiyikIErkanMDemirinHet al. Maternal serum soluble HLA-G levels in missed abortions. Medicina. (2013) 49:435–8. 10.3390/medicina49100068
149.
GonzalezARebmannVLeMaoultJHornPACarosellaEDAlegreE. The immunosuppressive molecule HLA-G and its clinical implications. Crit Rev Clin Lab Sci. (2012) 49:63–84. 10.3109/10408363.2012.677947
150.
LiCHouserBLNicotraMLStromingerJL. HLA-G homodimer-induced cytokine secretion through HLA-G receptors on human decidual macrophages and natural killer cells. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. (2009) 106:5767–72. 10.1073/pnas.0901173106
151.
BaudhuinJMigraineJFaivreVLoumagneLLukaszewiczACPayenDet al. Exocytosis acts as a modulator of the ILT4-mediated inhibition of neutrophil functions. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. (2013) 110:17957–62. 10.1073/pnas.1221535110
152.
ColonnaMNavarroFBellonTLlanoMGarciaPSamaridisJet al. A common inhibitory receptor for major histocompatibility complex class I molecules on human lymphoid and myelomonocytic cells. J Exp Med. (1997) 186:1809–18. 10.1084/jem.186.11.1809
153.
Le GalFARiteauBSedlikCKhalil-DaherIMenierCDaussetJet al. HLA-G-mediated inhibition of antigen-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes. Int Immunol. (1999) 11:1351–6. 10.1093/intimm/11.8.1351
154.
FavierBLemaoultJLesportECarosellaED. ILT2/HLA-G interaction impairs NK-cell functions through the inhibition of the late but not the early events of the NK-cell activating synapse. FASEB J. (2010) 24:689–99. 10.1096/fj.09-135194
155.
AjithAPortik-DobosVNguyen-LefebvreATCallawayCHoruzskoDDKapoorRet al. HLA-G dimer targets Granzyme B pathway to prolong human renal allograft survival. FASEB J. (2019) 33:5220–36. 10.1096/fj.201802017R
156.
RajagopalanSLongEO. KIR2DL4. (CD158d): an activation receptor for HLA-G. Front Immunol. (2012) 3:258. 10.3389/fimmu.2012.00258
157.
JongesLEAlbertssonPvan VlierbergheRLEnsinkNGJohanssonBRvan de VeldeCJet al. The phenotypic heterogeneity of human natural killer cells: presence of at least 48 different subsets in the peripheral blood. Scand J Immunol. (2001) 53:103–10. 10.1046/j.1365-3083.2001.00838.x
158.
ContiniPGhioMPoggiAFilaciGIndiveriFFerroneSet al. Soluble HLA-A,-B,-C and -G molecules induce apoptosis in T and NK CD8+ cells and inhibit cytotoxic T cell activity through CD8 ligation. Eur J Immunol. (2003) 33:125–34. 10.1002/immu.200390015
159.
LeeCLGuoYSoKHVijayanMGuoYWongVHet al. Soluble human leukocyte antigen G5 polarizes differentiation of macrophages toward a decidual macrophage-like phenotype. Hum Reprod. (2015) 30:2263–74. 10.1093/humrep/dev196
160.
LeMaoultJCaumartinJDaouyaMFavierBLe RondSGonzalezAet al. Immune regulation by pretenders: cell-to-cell transfers of HLA-G make effector T cells act as regulatory cells. Blood. (2007) 109:2040–8. 10.1182/blood-2006-05-024547
161.
MagnaniCFAlberigoGBacchettaRSerafiniGAndreaniMRoncaroloMGet al. Killing of myeloid APCs via HLA class I, CD2 and CD226 defines a novel mechanism of suppression by human Tr1 cells. Eur J Immunol. (2011) 41:1652–62. 10.1002/eji.201041120
162.
WeinerHL. Oral tolerance: immune mechanisms and treatment of autoimmune diseases. Immunol Today. (1997) 18:335–43. 10.1016/S0167-5699(97)01053-0
163.
DimovaTNagaevaOStenqvistACHedlundMKjellbergLStrandMet al. Maternal Foxp3 expressing CD4+ CD25+ and CD4+ CD25- regulatory T-cell populations are enriched in human early normal pregnancy decidua: a phenotypic study of paired decidual and peripheral blood samples. Am J Reprod Immunol. (2011) 6(Suppl. 1):44–56. 10.1111/j.1600-0897.2011.01046.x
164.
ShaoLJacobsARJohnsonVVMayerL. Activation of CD8+ regulatory T cells by human placental trophoblasts. J Immunol. (2005) 174:7539–47. 10.4049/jimmunol.174.12.7539
165.
NiedbalaWCaiBLiuHPitmanNChangLLiewFY. Nitric oxide induces CD4+CD25+ Foxp3 regulatory T cells from CD4+CD25 T cells via p53, IL-2, and OX40. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. (2007) 104:15478–83. 10.1073/pnas.0703725104
166.
NiedbalaWBesnardAGJiangHRAlves-FilhoJCFukadaSYNascimentoDet al. Nitric oxide-induced regulatory T cells inhibit Th17 but not Th1 cell differentiation and function. J Immunol. (2013) 191:164–70. 10.4049/jimmunol.1202580
167.
HuaFKangNGaoYACuiLXBaDNHeW. Potential regulatory role of in vitro-expanded Vdelta1 T cells from human peripheral blood. Immunol Res. (2013) 56:172–80. 10.1007/s12026-013-8390-2
168.
TerzievaADimitrovaVDjerovLDimitrovaPZapryanovaSHristovaIet al. Early pregnancy human decidua is enriched with activated, fully differentiated and pro-inflammatory gamma/delta T cells with diverse TCR repertoires. Int J Mol Sci. (2019) 20:687. 10.3390/ijms20030687
169.
HuangYHZozulyaALWeidenfellerCSchwabNWiendlH. T cell suppression by naturally occurring HLA-G-expressing regulatory CD4+ T cells is IL-10-dependent and reversible. J Leukoc Biol. (2009) 86:273–81. 10.1189/jlb.1008649
170.
PankratzSBittnerSHerrmannAMSchuhmannMKRuckTMeuthSGet al. Human CD4+ HLA-G+ regulatory T cells are potent suppressors of graft-versus-host disease in vivo. FASEB J. (2014) 28:3435–45. 10.1096/fj.14-251074
171.
PankratzSRuckTMeuthSGWiendlH. CD4(+)HLA-G(+) regulatory T cells: molecular signature and pathophysiological relevance. Hum Immunol. (2016) 77:727–33. 10.1016/j.humimm.2016.01.016
172.
HuangYHZozulyaALWeidenfellerCMetzIBuckDToykaKVet al. Specific central nervous system recruitment of HLA-G(+) regulatory T cells in multiple sclerosis. Ann Neurol. (2009) 66:171–83. 10.1002/ana.21705
173.
HsuPSantner-NananBJoungSPeekMJNananR. Expansion of CD4(+) HLA-G(+) T Cell in human pregnancy is impaired in pre-eclampsia. Am J Reprod Immunol. (2014) 71:217–28. 10.1111/aji.12195
174.
PasseriniLDi NunzioSGregoriSGambineriECecconiMSeidelMGet al. Functional type 1 regulatory T cells develop regardless of FOXP3 mutations in patients with IPEX syndrome. Eur J Immunol. (2011) 41:1120–31. 10.1002/eji.201040909
175.
AkbariODeKruyffRHUmetsuDT. Pulmonary dendritic cells producing IL-10 mediate tolerance induced by respiratory exposure to antigen. Nat Immunol. (2001) 2:725–31. 10.1038/90667
176.
GaglianiNMagnaniCFHuberSGianoliniMEPalaMLicona-LimonPet al. Coexpression of CD49b and LAG-3 identifies human and mouse T regulatory type 1 cells. Nat Med. (2013) 19:739–46. 10.1038/nm.3179
177.
WhiteAMWraithDC. Tr1-like T cells - an enigmatic regulatory T cell lineage. Front Immunol. (2016) 7:355. 10.3389/fimmu.2016.00355
178.
AkdisMVerhagenJTaylorAKaramlooFKaragiannidisCCrameriRet al. Immune responses in healthy and allergic individuals are characterized by a fine balance between allergen-specific T regulatory 1 and T helper 2 cells. J Exp Med. (2004) 199:1567–75. 10.1084/jem.20032058
179.
HaringerBLozzaLSteckelBGeginatJ. Identification and characterization of IL-10/IFN-gamma-producing effector-like T cells with regulatory function in human blood. J Exp Med. (2009) 206:1009–17. 10.1084/jem.20082238
180.
SchulerPJSazeZHongCSMullerLGillespieDGChengDet al. Human CD4+ CD39+ regulatory T cells produce adenosine upon co-expression of surface CD73 or contact with CD73+ exosomes or CD73+ cells. Clin Exp Immunol. (2014) 177:531–43. 10.1111/cei.12354
181.
NiedzielskaMIsraelssonEAngermannBSiddersBSClausenMCatleyMet al. Differential gene expression in human tissue resident regulatory T cells from lung, colon, and blood. Oncotarget. (2018) 9:36166–84. 10.18632/oncotarget.26322
182.
WeinerHLda CunhaAPQuintanaFWuH. Oral tolerance. Immunol Rev. (2011) 241:241–59. 10.1111/j.1600-065X.2011.01017.x
183.
ElkordEAbd Al SamidMChaudharyB. Helios, and not FoxP3, is the marker of activated Tregs expressing GARP/LAP. Oncotarget. (2015) 6:20026–36. 10.18632/oncotarget.4771
184.
BacchettaRSartiranaCLevingsMKBordignonCNarulaSRoncaroloMG. Growth and expansion of human T regulatory type 1 cells are independent from TCR activation but require exogenous cytokines. Eur J Immunol. (2002) 32:2237–45. 10.1002/1521-4141(200208)32:8<2237::AID-IMMU2237>3.0.CO
185.
WahlSMSwisherJMcCartney-FrancisNChenWJ. TGF-beta: the perpetrator of immune suppression by regulatory T cells and suicidal T cells. J Leukoc Biol. (2004) 76:15–24. 10.1189/jlb.1103539
186.
KoelmanCACoumansABCNijmanHWDoxiadisIINDekkerGAClaasFHJ. Correlation between oral sex and a low incidence of preeclampsia: a role for soluble HLA in seminal fluid?J Reprod Immunol. (2000) 46:155–66. 10.1016/S0165-0378(99)00062-5
187.
ClarkDA. Oral tolerance and the materno-fetal relationship. J Reprod Immunol. (2019) 134–135, 36–39. 10.1016/j.jri.2019.07.003
188.
MeulemanTBadenNHaasnootGWWagnerMMDekkersOMle CessieSet al. Oral sex is associated with reduced incidence of recurrent miscarriage. J Reprod Immunol. (2019) 133:1–6. 10.1016/j.jri.2019.03.005
189.
LiuYLanQLuLChenMXiaZMaJet al. Phenotypic and functional characteristic of a newly identified CD8+ Foxp3- CD103+ regulatory T cells. J Mol Cell Biol. (2014) 6:81–92. 10.1093/jmcb/mjt026
190.
SeligmanSPBuyonJPClancyRMYoungBKAbramsonSB. The role of nitric oxide in the pathogenesis of preeclampsia. Am J Obstet Gynecol. (1994) 171:944–8. 10.1016/S0002-9378(94)70064-8
191.
NobunagaTTokugawaYHashimotoKKimuraTMatsuzakiNNittaYet al. Plasma nitric oxide levels in pregnant patients with preeclampsia and essential hypertension. Gynecol Obstet Invest. (1996) 41:189–93. 10.1159/000292266
192.
SilverRKKupfermincMJRussellTLAdlerLMullenTACaplanMS. Evaluation of nitric oxide as a mediator of severe preeclampsia. Am J Obstetr Gynecol. (1996) 175:1013–7. 10.1016/S0002-9378(96)80044-5
193.
ChoiJWImMWPaiSH. Nitric oxide production increases during normal pregnancy and decreases in preeclampsia. Ann Clin Lab Sci. (2002) 32:257–63.
194.
YuXHardenKGonzalezLCFrancescoMChiangEIrvingBet al. The surface protein TIGIT suppresses T cell activation by promoting the generation of mature immunoregulatory dendritic cells. Nat Immunol. (2009) 10:48–57. 10.1038/ni.1674
195.
JollerNLozanoEBurkettPRPatelBXiaoSZhuCet al. Treg cells expressing the coinhibitory molecule TIGIT selectively inhibit proinflammatory Th1 and Th17 cell responses. Immunity. (2014) 40:569–81. 10.1016/j.immuni.2014.02.012
196.
FanDXDuanJLiMQXuBLiDJJinLP. The decidual gamma-delta T cells up-regulate the biological functions of trophoblasts via IL-10 secretion in early human pregnancy. Clin Immunol. (2011) 141:284–92. 10.1016/j.clim.2011.07.008
197.
PengGWangHYPengWKiniwaYSeoKHWangRF. Tumor-infiltrating gammadelta T cells suppress T and dendritic cell function via mechanisms controlled by a unique toll-like receptor signaling pathway. Immunity. (2007) 27:334–48. 10.1016/j.immuni.2007.05.020
198.
PsarraKKapsimaliVTarassiKDendrinosSAthanasiadisTBotsisDet al. TCRgammadelta + T lymphocytes in unexplained recurrent spontaneous abortions. Am J Reprod Immunol. (2001) 45:6–11. 10.1111/j.8755-8920.2001.450102.x
199.
ShimaTInadaKNakashimaAUshijimaAItoMYoshinoOet al. Paternal antigen-specific proliferating regulatory T cells are increased in uterine-draining lymph nodes just before implantation and in pregnant uterus just after implantation by seminal plasma-priming in allogeneic mouse pregnancy. J Reprod Immunol. (2015) 108:72–82. 10.1016/j.jri.2015.02.005
200.
LansacJRoyereD. Follow-up studies of children born after frozen sperm donation. Human Reproduction Update. (2001) 7:33–7. 10.1093/humupd/7.1.33
201.
RobertsonSAGreenESCareASMoldenhauerLMPrinsJRHullMLet al. Therapeutic potential of regulatory T cells in preeclampsia—opportunities and challenges. Front Immunol. (2019) 10:478. 10.3389/fimmu.2019.00478
202.
HuhnOIvarssonMAGardnerLHollinsheadMStinchcombeJCChenPet al. Distinctive phenotypes and functions of innate lymphoid cells in human decidua during early pregnancy. Nat Commun. (2020) 11:381. 10.1038/s41467-019-14123-z
203.
PetersonLSStelzerIATsaiASGhaemiMSHanXAndoKet al. Multiomic immune clockworks of pregnancy. Semin Immunopathol. (2020). 10.1007/s00281-019-00772-1
Summary
Keywords
regulatory T (Treg) cells, pregnancy, preeclampsia, Tr1 regulatory cells, Th3 regulatory cells, HLA-G Treg, immune tolerance, recurrent pregnancy loss (RPL)
Citation
Krop J, Heidt S, Claas FHJ and Eikmans M (2020) Regulatory T Cells in Pregnancy: It Is Not All About FoxP3. Front. Immunol. 11:1182. doi: 10.3389/fimmu.2020.01182
Received
30 March 2020
Accepted
13 May 2020
Published
23 June 2020
Volume
11 - 2020
Edited by
Shigeru Saito, University of Toyama, Japan
Reviewed by
Sayaka Tsuda, University of Toyama, Japan; Lianjun Zhang, Suzhou Institute of Systems Medicine (ISM), China
Updates
Copyright
© 2020 Krop, Heidt, Claas and Eikmans.
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
*Correspondence: Michael Eikmans m.eikmans@lumc.nl
This article was submitted to Immunological Tolerance and Regulation, a section of the journal Frontiers in Immunology
Disclaimer
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.