CASE REPORT article

Front. Anesthesiol., 18 December 2023

Sec. General Pharmacology and Pharmacokinetics

Volume 2 - 2023 | https://doi.org/10.3389/fanes.2023.1298806

Delayed lethal central nervous system toxicity induced by a low-dose intrathecal administration of bupivacaine: case report

  • WS

    Weishang Song 1

  • HZ

    Hong Zhang 1

  • XL

    Xiaohui Li 1

  • CY

    Chengxiang Yu 1

  • YZ

    Yuhong Zhou 1

  • YL

    Yuesu Li 1*

  • BC

    Bing Chen 1,2*

  • 1. Department of Anesthesia, Wushan Country People’s Hospital of Chongqing, Chongqing, China

  • 2. Department of Anesthesia, The Second Affiliated Hospital of Chongqing Medical University, Chongqing, China

Abstract

Spinal anesthesia by intrathecal administration of local anesthetic (LA) is a routine practice. Local anesthetic system toxicity, occurring in the central nervous system (CNS) and cardiovascular system, is a common and life-threatening adverse event of LA through a variety of routes, but is rarely encountered in spinal anesthesia when a very low dose of LA is injected into the subarachnoid space. Here, we report a case with manifestations of delayed lethal CNS toxicity after spinal anesthesia. A 55-year-old man underwent elective repair surgery for a chronic ulcer after receiving 10 mg intrathecal administration of bupivacaine. He developed nausea, agitation, paresthesia and myoclonus on the arms, legs, and trunk, as well as a gradually reduced level of consciousness one hour after intrathecal administration. He was sedated, intubated, and transferred to the intensive care unit. Both CT and MRI scans of the brain and assessments of blood showed no abnormalities. The electroencephalogram showed spike waves occurring at electrodes C3, C4, P3, P4, and T5. The patient was sedated continuously and treated with valproate. These symptoms were completely resolved in the following days without residual neurological complications. No cardiovascular complications were observed during the entire process. The delayed lethal symptoms in this case were most likely to be CNS toxicity induced by intrathecal bupivacaine administration. CNS toxicity after spinal anesthesia may be underestimated and unpredictable and should be vigilantly cared for in clinical settings.

Introduction

Spinal anesthesia by intrathecal administration of local anesthetic (LA) is a routine practice for surgery of the lower abdomen, pelvis, or lower extremities. The most commonly adverse effects of spinal anesthesia are hypotension, respiratory paralysis, or underventilation due to the block of spinal nerves above T4, but the local anesthetic systemic toxicity (LAST) is rarely encountered in spinal anesthesia for a very low dose of LA is injected into the subarachnoid space. LAST is a common and life-threatening adverse event of LA through a variety of routes after inadvertent intravascular injection, overdose, or significant systemic absorption that plasma concentration of LA reaches a toxic level (). LAST can be further subdivided into central nervous system (CNS) toxicity and cardiovascular systemic toxicity. CNS toxicity occurs when LA crosses the blood-brain barrier, which leads to CNS excitation followed by CNS inhibition with potential respiratory depression and even death (). Cardiovascular system toxicity with the symptoms of dysrhythmias and low systemic vascular resistance occurs when systemic LA concentration reaches a higher level (). Here, we report a case with manifestations of delayed lethal CNS toxicity followed by intrathecal administration of 10 mg bupivacaine and reviewed cases with abnormal neurological symptoms after spinal anesthesia, which indicates CNS toxicity after spinal anesthesia may be underestimated and unpredictable and should be vigilantly cared for in clinical settings.

Case report

A 55-year-old man was presented for elective repair surgery for a chronic ulcer on the right foot induced by a 10-year history of type 2 diabetes mellitus. The chronic ulcer was debrided under general anesthesia uneventfully 142 days prior, and repaired with bone cement under local anesthesia uneventfully 132 days and 98 days prior, respectively. Moreover, he underwent an uneventful incision and drainage of the abscess of the ulcer under spinal anesthesia with ropivacaine three weeks prior. He had no history of drug abuse and seizures. Preoperative blood tests including liver function, renal function, and coagulation function of the patients were normal.

The puncture of spinal anesthesia was performed uneventfully in the L3–L4 interspace using a 25 G Quincke needle. 2 ml of 0.5% bupivacaine was injected into the subarachnoid space after obtaining cerebrospinal fluid. A good block was achieved about 5 min later. The surgery was uneventful and lasted about 50 min. No additional drugs were administered. The patient complained of nausea during transfer to the ward about 60 min after the intrathecal injection; thus, he was transferred to the post-anesthesia care unit. Finger prick blood was analyzed to detect hypoglycemia. Nausea was relieved after intravenous treatment of ondansetron 8 mg. However, about 10 min later, he became agitated and sweaty, complained of paresthesia on the skin below his neck, and developed involuntary, bilateral, asymmetrical, and arrhythmic myoclonic movements in both arms without loss of consciousness. Moreover, the heart rate, blood pressure, and arterial blood gas analysis were normal. Due to the symptoms of being sweaty and paresthesia on the skin, allergic reaction was doubted and hydrocortisone 100 mg was intravenously infused. Due to the symptoms of agitation, midazolam 5 mg was administered and dexmedetomidine was infused to sedate the patient. About 100 min after intrathecal injection, he was quickly intubated after the treatment of propofol and rocuronium for sudden blue jaundice of lips and loss of consciousness. The Glasgow coma scale was approximately 14 just before consciousness loss: eye opening was spontaneous, verbal response was responsible but a little confused, and the patient could obey commands to move his hands. The patient was transferred to the intensive care unit and a neurological doctor was consulted. Myoclonus still occurred and expanded to the legs when the muscle relaxation effect was eliminated (Supplementary Video S1). Both CT and MRI scans of the brain and assessments of blood showed no abnormalities. However, the electroencephalogram (EEG) showed spike waves occurring at electrodes C3, C4, P3, P4, and T5 (Figure 1), which showed myoclonus originated from the cortex of the parietal lobe and left temporal lobe. The patient was sedated continuously and treated with valproate. The frequency and amplitude of myoclonus decreased about 8 h after intrathecal injection. Although he still had sporadic myoclonus on postoperative day 1, he was peaceful and cooperative after stopping sedation. Therefore, he was extubated and transferred to the ward. He was discharged on postoperative day 4 without residual neurological complications. No cardiovascular complications were observed during the whole process.

Figure 1

Discussion

Other causes should be excluded before concluding that intrathecal bupivacaine is responsible for these delayed lethal side effects. Hypotension and underventilation are the most common adverse experiences following the administration of spinal anesthesia. However, this patient had no underventilation from intrathecal injection to the start of seizures. No hypotension occurred after intrathecal injection and even during the seizures. In addition, both the intrathecal puncture and repair surgery for chronic ulcer were performed by experienced doctors and were uneventful; no other drugs were used except for intrathecal bupivacaine; no abnormalities of CT and MRI scan of the brain and blood assessments were detected; these side effects were occurred about 1 h after intrathecal injection, relieved several hours, and completely recovered in the flowing days; the patient never underwent these symptoms before and after recovery. The total score of the Adverse Drug Reaction Probability Scale was 7 (Supplementary Table S1), which indicates that bupivacaine was the “probable” reason for these delayed lethal side effects.

The manifestations of CNS toxicity induced by LA include seizures, nausea, vomiting, perioral paresthesia, confusion, audio-visual disturbances, dysgeusia, agitation, or reduced level of consciousness (). Moreover, spinal myoclonus, which originates from the spinal cord and is characterized by a non-generalized neuromuscular dysfunction restricted to a few somatic regions, was reported to be a side effect after spinal anesthesia (). According to the manifestations of nausea, agitation, reduced level of consciousness, paresthesia and generalized myoclonus on arms, legs, and trunk, and spike waves in EEG, these side effects were compatible with CNS toxicity originating from the cerebral cortex induced by intrathecal bupivacaine administration.

Two pathways that lead to CNS toxicity after intrathecal administration of LA. One is that systemic absorbed LA crosses the blood-brain barrier, which usually occurs at high-dose LA administration (). The mean seizure dosage of bupivacaine in rhesus monkeys was found to be 4.4 ± 1.2 mg/kg with mean plasma concentration of 4.5 ± 1.7 μ/ml (). In this case, only 10 mg of bupivacaine was used, which is far lower than its toxic dose; thus, we believe this pathway is impossible. The other is that the drug in the cerebrospinal fluid cephalic diffused to the cerebral cortex then leads to neuron excitation (). In this case, even if the dose of LA is low, it can affect the activity of neurons. Therefore, we speculate cephalic diffusion is the reason for CNS toxicity induced by intrathecal LA administration.

Based on the theory of LA cephalic diffusion after intrathecal administration, CNS toxicity should be not rare. We reviewed the published literature and found that 30 publications (, , , ) involving 31 patients and two cats had generalized tonic-clonic seizures or myoclonus after spinal anesthesia (Table 1), which is a symptom of LA-induced CNS toxicity. Although these myoclonus or generalized tonic-clonic seizures were considered to originate from the spinal cord (), it could not be excluded that these side effects originated from the cerebral since the EEG assessment was absent in about 71% of the cases (Table 2) and abnormal EEGs were detected in two cases (, ). Moreover, these neurological symptoms presented in patients of different ages and genders, with or without neurological diseases, and different types of surgeries; they occurred quickly or slowly from several hours to one day after spinal anesthesia; and 64% of them were mild and resolved quickly and spontaneously (Table 2). Thus, CNS toxicity after spinal anesthesia is unpredictable and may be ignored in clinical settings, and underestimated. In addition, 46.7% of parturients underwent involuntary arm shaking or shivering soon after spinal anesthesia during cesarean delivery while they didn't feel cold (), which has some similarity with myoclonus indicates that involuntary arm shaking may be a CNS toxicity induced by LA. Taken together, the rare complication of CNS toxicity induced by intrathecal LA administration may not be rare.

Table 1

StudyAgeGenderMedical historyType of surgeryType of anesthesiaSide effectsAb-normal EEGTreatmentPrognosis
Cenani ()UCUC (cat)UCUCB, MMyoclonusUCUCUC
McFadzean and Holopherne-Doran ()UCUC (cat)UCUCB, MMyoclonus, hypersensitivity of the tailUCUCUC
Vanmarcke et al. ()76 yearsFemaleHysterectomy, supraventricular tachycardiaTotal hip arthroplastyHyperbaric B 15 mg, S 2.5 μgMyoclonus of the lower extremities followed by generalized tonic-clonic seizures 1 h after intrathecal injectionYesSedation, intubation, valproateResolved completely 6 days after stopping sedation
Pradhan and Robson ()44 yearsFemaleTwo previous caesarean sectionElective caesarean sectionHyperbaric B 13 mg, F 15 μg, M 100 μgMild myoclonus of the right upper limb 1 h after intrathecal injection, followed by increased frequency and amplitude of myoclonus spreading to both upper limbs and trunkNoUCResolved completely by 48 h
Patel and Verma ()35 yearsFemaleUCCesarean sectionBMyoclonus followed by generalized tonic-clonic seizuresUCUCUC
Sieffien et al. ()64 yearsFemaleDiabetes mellitus, restless legs syndromeTotal hip arthroplastyIsobaric B 10 mgBilateral myoclonus of the upper limbs and torso about 210 min after intrathecal injection, which persisted 90 minUCSedation, muscle relaxantResolved completely
Shaikh et al. ()68 yearsFemaleHepatitis C positiveRemoval of infected a femur implantHyperbaric B 15 mgModerate to severe pain in non-operated leg about 140 min after intrathecal injection, myoclonus about 20 min after pain onsetUCMagnesium sulphate, lidocaineResolved completely after drug infusion
Jacob et al. ()80 yearsFemaleUCSurgical treatment of leg bones fractureLevobupivacaineA tonic-clonic seizure with sphincter incontinence soon after intrathecal injectionNoNoResolved completely
Silva et al. ()67 yearsFemaleNoHip replacement surgeryB 10 mgUnbearable pain in legs and perineum and bilateral myoclonus in the lower limbs 7 min after intrathecal injectionNoSedation, muscle relaxant, intubationResolved completely at POD1
Tajima et al. ()33 yearsFemaleUCEmergency caesarean sectionHyperbaric BMyoclonus of the upper limbs 76 min after intrathecal injectionUCNoCeased 4 h after intrathecal injection
Shiratori et al. ()33 yearsFemaleNoElective cesarean sectionHyperbaric B 13 mgMyoclonus about 130 min after intrathecal injection, which gradually increased in frequency and magnitudeUCNoDisappeared 5 h after intrathecal injection
Kösem and Kılınç ()36 yearsFemaleNoSurgery for left leg varicesHyperbaric B 15 mgMyoclonus of right leg about 1 h after intrathecal injection, which persisted 5 hUCNoResolved completely
Nakamoto et al. ()35 yearsFemaleNoElective cesarean sectionHyperbaric B 12.5 mg, F 15 μgMyoclonus in both upper extremities about 1 h after intrathecal injectionUCSedationStopped after midazolam treatment
Lev et al. ()28 yearsFemaleNoElective cesarean sectionHyperbaric B 8 mg, M 0.15 mgMyoclonus of the arms, legs, and trunk 2 h after intrathecal injectionNoClonazepam, muscle relaxantResolved after 72 h with a very mild proximal right leg weakness
Kim et al. ()27 yearsFemaleHepatitis B carrierEmergency cesarean sectionB 8 mgGeneralized tonic-clonic seizures 3 min after delivery, which followed by loss of consciousness and apneaNoIntubationResolved after several hours
Abrão et al. ()63 yearsMaleNoTransurethral resection of the prostateB 15 mgMyoclonus of the lower limbs and significant agitation soon after intrathecal injectionUCSedation, intubationResolved completely on POD3
Zamidei et al. ()77 yearsFemaleNoHip replacementIsobaric B 12 mgSudden myoclonus of the arms, legs, and trunk on POD1NoValproate, clonazepamDisappeared completely on POD4
Lee et al. ()35 yearsFemaleNoSurgical treatment of peroneal tendonitisHyperbaric B 9 mgMyoclonus of both legs and arm about 100 min after intrathecal injectionUCSedationDisappeared completely 4 h after its onset
Bamgbade et al. ()90 yearsMaleCardiac failure, ischemic heart diseaseProstatectomyHyperbaric B 10 mgRight leg myoclonus during the attempt at lithotomy positioning soon after intrathecal injectionUCAn epidural dose of 10 ml of 0.25% bupivacaineResolved 10 min after epidural treatment
Bamgbade et al. ()64 yearsFemaleCoronary artery disease, diabetes mellitusUreterotomyHyperbaric B 10 mgLower-limb myoclonus 1 h after intrathecal injection, which lasted less than 3 minUCNoResolved completely
Bamgbade et al. ()53 yearsFemaleHypertension, rheumatoid arthritisPelvic surgeryHyperbaric B 12.5 mg, M 300 mgLower-limb myoclonus about 90 min after intrathecal injection, which lasted 1 hUCSedationResolved completely
Bamgbade et al. ()67 yearsMaleDiabetes, peripheral neuropathy, obesity, asthmaRefashioning of a left below-knee amputation stumpHyperbaric B 12.5 mg, M 300 mgMyoclonus in the absent amputated limb about 1 h after intrathecal injectionUCSedationResolved completely
Galante ()73 yearsMaleA serious urinary tract infection with multiresistant Escherichia Coli.Transurethral resection of the prostateHyperbaric B 13 mg, F 20 μgGeneralized tonic-clonic seizure with transient loss of consciousness 20 min before the end of the procedure, which persisted 65 minUCSedationDisappeared completely
Alfa and Bamgbade ()53 yearsFemaleHypertension, hyperlipidemia, rheumatoid arthritisSurgical repair of cystocoele and uterine prolapseHyperbaric B 12.5 mg, M 300 mgMyoclonus of both lower limbs 3 h after intrathecal injection, followed by increased amplitude and frequency of the myoclonus, which persisted about 2 hUCSedationResolved completely
Lin et al. ()UCUCUCExcision of a Baker's cystHypobaric B 12.5 mgMyoclonus in the lower legs 1 h after intrathecal injection, followed by gradually increased amplitude and frequency of the myoclonus, which persisted about 50 minUCSedationResolved completely
Kim et al. ()18 yearsMaleUCVaricocelectomyHyperbaric B 14 mgMyoclonus on upper extremities 90 min after intrathecal injection, which sustained about 1 monthUCAnti-convulsants, muscle relaxantResolved completely
Lee et al. ()45 yearsFemaleUCUCHyperbaric B 12 mgMyoclonus on lower extremities 2 h after intrathecal injectionUCSedationResolved completely
Batra et al. ()45 daysMaleNoBilateral inguinal hernia repairB 2 mg, F 2.5 µgMyoclonus on left thigh and arm soon after intrathecal injection, which persisted 4 minNoNoResolved spontaneously
Celik et al. ()56 yearsFemaleUCUCHyperbaric B 15 mgBilateral myoclonus on the lower extremities 2 h after intrathecal injection, which persisted about 1 hUCNoStopped completely
Chen et al. ()36 yearsMaleUCUreteroscopic lithotomyTetracaine 18 mgEpisodic seizure soon after intrathecal injectionUCUCUC
Watanabe et al. ()81 yearsMaleNoBilateral ureterostomyIsobaric dibucaine 3.6 mgPeriodic left plantar flexion after intrathecal injection, which persisted 70 minYesNoResolved spontaneously
Nadkarni and Tondare ()45 yearsFemaleNoAbdominal hysterectomy5% lidocaine 1.5 mlBilateral myoclonus of the abdomen, low back, thighs, and legs about 2 h after intrathecal injectionUCSedationResolved completely
Fox et al. ()57 yearsFemaleNephrectomyUreterostomyTetracaine 14 mgSlight twitching around the right knee 5 h after surgery, followed by strong myoclonus on the thigh and knee, which persisted several hoursUCSedationResolved completely

The characteristics of the published cases with myoclonus after spinal anesthesia.

UC, unclear; B, bupivacaine; S, sufentanil; F, fentanyl; M, morphine; EEG, electroencephalogram; POD, postoperative day.

Table 2

HeadingSubgroupNumber (%)HeadingSubgroupNumber (%)
Age≥65 years9 (29)GenderFemale22 (71)
≥18 years and <65 years20 (65)Male8 (23)
<18 years1 (3)Unclear1 (3)
Unclear1 (3)Preoperative neurological diseasesYes2 (6)
Type of surgeryCesarean7 (23)No21 (68)
Urinary7 (23)Unclear8 (26)
Abdominal5 (16)Abnormal EEGYes2 (6)
Orthopedic7 (23)No7 (23)
Others3 (10)Unclear22 (71)
Unclear2 (6)Time of neurological symptomQuick8 (23)
Local anestheticBupivacaine26 (84)Delayed22 (71)
Levobupivacaine1 (3)Unclear1 (3)
Ropivacaine0 (0)Degree of myoclonusMild20 (64)
Lidocaine1 (3)Moderate4 (13)
Tetracaine2 (6)Severe4 (13)
Dibucaine1 (3)Unclear3 (10)

Summary of the published cases with myoclonus after spinal anesthesia.

EEG, electroencephalogram. Quick myoclonus was categorized as those occurred within 10 min or described as soon after intrathecal injection. Delayed myoclonus was categorized as those occurred more than 30 min after intrathecal injection.

Although CNS toxicity after spinal anesthesia is unpredictable, our literature review found that (Table 2) it mainly occurred in female patients (75%), patients with ages between 18 and 65 years (65%), and bupivacaine administration (84%). The potential for CNS toxicity correlates with the potency of LA. Potent lipid-soluble agents such as bupivacaine can cause CNS toxicity at lower doses than less potent agents, such as levobupivacaine and ropivacaine (). Shiratori et al. () found that 70% of patients had neurological symptoms after spinal and epidural anesthesia with bupivacaine. Moreover, our case underwent an uneventful incision and drainage of the abscess under spinal anesthesia with ropivacaine three weeks ago. These data indicate that intrathecal administration of bupivacaine has a high risk of CNS toxicity even if a very low dose was used.

Although 64% of the CNS toxicity induced by intrathecal LA administration was mild and resolved quickly and spontaneously, 13% of cases (, , , ) were severe and needed medical interventions to avoid hypoxia as presented in our case (Table 2). Importantly, the time of the CNS toxicity development after spinal anesthesia was delayed (occurred more than 30 min after intrathecal injection) in 71% of cases (Table 2). Therefore, CNS toxicity following spinal anesthesia can be fatal and delayed, which should be sustained care even if the patient leaves the operation room.

Conclusion

Intrathecal administration of a low-dose LA, especially bupivacaine, can result in delayed, lethal, and unpredictable CNS toxicity, which may be underestimated and should be vigilantly cared for in clinical settings.

Statements

Data availability statement

The original contributions presented in the study are included in the article/Supplementary Material, further inquiries can be directed to the corresponding authors.

Ethics statement

Ethical approval was not required for the study involving humans in accordance with the local legislation and institutional requirements. Written informed consent to participate in this study was not required from the participants or the participants’ legal guardians/next of kin in accordance with the national legislation and the institutional requirements. Written informed consent was obtained from the individual(s) for the publication of any potentially identifiable images or data included in this article.

Author contributions

WS: Conceptualization, Writing – original draft. HZ: Conceptualization, Writing – original draft. XL: Writing – original draft, Data curation. CY: Data curation, Writing – original draft. YZ: Writing – original draft, Formal Analysis. YL: Conceptualization, Writing – review & editing. BC: Conceptualization, Writing – review & editing, Funding acquisition.

Funding

The author(s) declare financial support was received for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.

This work is supported by the Grant [2021]24 from the Kuanren Talents Program of the Second Affiliated Hospital of Chongqing Medical University, and the Young and Middle-aged Outstanding Medical Team of Chongqing.

Conflict of interest

The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.

Publisher’s note

All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.

Supplementary material

The Supplementary Material for this article can be found online at: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fanes.2023.1298806/full#supplementary-material

Supplementary Video S1

Representative symptom of myoclonus in this case.

References

Summary

Keywords

spinal anesthesia, bupivacaine, toxicity, central nervous system, myoclonus

Citation

Song W, Zhang H, Li X, Yu C, Zhou Y, Li Y and Chen B (2023) Delayed lethal central nervous system toxicity induced by a low-dose intrathecal administration of bupivacaine: case report. Front. Anesthesiol. 2:1298806. doi: 10.3389/fanes.2023.1298806

Received

22 September 2023

Accepted

04 December 2023

Published

18 December 2023

Volume

2 - 2023

Edited by

Andrea Meli, Fondazione IRCCS Ca’ Granda Ospedale Maggiore Policlinico, Italy

Reviewed by

Rudrashish Haldar, Sanjay Gandhi Post Graduate Institute of Medical Sciences (SGPGI), India

William R. Wolowich, Nova Southeastern University, United States

Updates

Copyright

*Correspondence: Yuesu Li Bing Chen

† These authors have contributed equally to this work and share first authorship

Disclaimer

All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.

Outline

Figures

Cite article

Copy to clipboard


Export citation file


Share article

Article metrics