REVIEW article

Front. Cell. Infect. Microbiol., 19 September 2025

Sec. Biofilms

Volume 15 - 2025 | https://doi.org/10.3389/fcimb.2025.1655335

The adaptability of Pseudomonas aeruginosa biofilm in oxygen-limited environments

  • 1. Department of Orthodontics, School and Hospital of Stomatology, China Medical University, Shenyang, Liaoning, China

  • 2. Shenyang Clinical Medical Research Center of Orthodontic Disease, Shenyang, China

Abstract

Under oxygen-limited conditions, the adaptability and underlying mechanisms of bacterial biofilms have become key areas of interest in microbiology and clinical infection research. Within biofilms—composed of bacterial communities and extracellular matrix—an oxygen gradient commonly forms, resulting in hypoxic or even anoxic microenvironments. Such conditions substantially increase biofilm antibiotic resistance and facilitate the persistence of chronic infections. This review systematically summarizes the adaptive strategies employed by biofilms in hypoxic environments, including anaerobic metabolism, phenazine-mediated electron shuttling, and virulence factor regulation. These adaptive responses are governed by genes involved in anaerobic metabolism, quorum sensing systems, and the secondary messenger 3,5-cyclic diguanylic acid (c-di-GMP), which collectively influence biofilm formation. Key transcriptional regulators such as Anr and Dnr, the two-component system NarXL, along with specific functional genes, form an intricate regulatory network. This article aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the adaptive mechanisms of Pseudomonas aeruginosa biofilms under oxygen-limited conditions, providing a theoretical foundation for the development of novel anti-infective therapies, targeting the biofilm infection microenvironment in cystic fibrosis and chronic wounds.

1 Introduction

Pseudomonas aeruginosa is a widely distributed Gram-negative bacterium known to cause nosocomial infections and potentially fatal infections in immunocompromised patients (; ). It is also a persistent colonizer of the lungs in cystic fibrosis (CF) patients, where it is notoriously difficult to eradicate (). During chronic infections, P. aeruginosa predominantly exists in biofilm form. Bacterial biofilms adhere to biological or abiotic surfaces and consist of bacterial communities embedded within an extracellular matrix (ECM), comprising proteins, polysaccharides, and extracellular DNA (eDNA), among other components (). These molecules provide structural integrity and facilitate intercellular adhesion (; ). Unlike planktonic bacteria, biofilms exhibit altered growth rates, metabolism, and gene expression profiles (). Bacteria in the inner layers of biofilms adapt to low metabolic activity and undergo anaerobic respiration. Due to the protective barrier of the ECM, biofilm-associated bacteria demonstrate increased antibiotic resistance by approximately 10- to 1000-fold (; ). Consequently, biofilms are inherently difficult to treat, leading to persistent and chronic infections that pose significant clinical challenges (Zhao et al., 2023a). It is estimated that 65% to 80% of human bacterial infections are associated with biofilms (Zhao et al., 2023a; ), underscoring the critical need to eradicate pathogenic biofilms for effective management of chronic infections.

Biofilm formation is a complex process influenced by various external factors, including nutrients, osmotic pressure, temperature, and oxygen availability (). The human body presents numerous low-oxygen or anaerobic niches. For example, P. aeruginosa grows as biofilms in the lungs of CF patients, where chronic infection leads to hypoxic or even anaerobic conditions (; ). Similarly, Salmonella colonizes anaerobic niches within the intestinal tract (), and oxygen concentrations in infected or necrotic tissues and wounds are notably low (). In vitro studies have confirmed that oxygen gradients are commonly present in bacterial biofilms, including those formed by P. aeruginosa (), Staphylococcus aureus (), and Enterococcus faecalis (), particularly in mature biofilms (). This oxygen limitation enhances pathogen virulence and survival (). Using oxygen microelectrode technology, localized hypoxia within P. aeruginosa biofilms has been confirmed, which restricts protein synthesis in mature biofilm interiors and contributes to antibiotic resistance (). Oxygen deficiency accounts for at least 70% of antibiotic resistance in mature P. aeruginosa biofilm cells, highlighting oxygen concentration as a critical factor in biofilm formation and multidrug resistance stability. Understanding how bacteria rapidly sense and respond to oxygen-limited environments is essential for improving infection treatments. This review summarizes the adaptations and mechanisms of P. aeruginosa biofilms under oxygen-limited conditions, aiming to provide a novel approach for eradicating biofilms through modulation of the infection microenvironment.

2 Formation of oxygen-limited microenvironment

The oxygen concentration gradient is an important characteristic of bacterial biofilms. The oxygen concentration in the environment is mostly around 19.95%. Generally, an oxygen concentration ranging from 11% to 1% is regarded as hypoxic (), while an environment with less than 1% oxygen or completely devoid of oxygen is an anoxic environment (). In CF lungs, P. aeruginosa forms biofilms where oxygen penetration is severely restricted. Microelectrode measurements reveal that oxygen levels decline progressively with depth and penetrate only 50 μm from the biofilm surface (), whereas the average biofilm thickness can reach 210 μm (). Consequently, cells deep within the biofilm experience hypoxic or anoxic conditions (; ). Active protein synthesis is confined to a zone roughly 30 μm above the base (). This oxygen limitation arises from both physical and biological factors: the dense biofilm matrix and viscous CF mucus impede diffusion, while host inflammatory responses recruit neutrophils whose respiratory burst consumes oxygen (). Additionally, oxygen is consumed directly by host and bacteria respiration at the biofilm periphery, maintaining a persistent hypoxic gradient (), as shown in Figure 1. Sputum from CF patients is predominantly micro-aerobic to anaerobic (; ; ). The extent of anoxic regions correlates with bacterial load and mucus thickness, potentially occupying large portions of mucus volume (). Notably, multidrug resistance protein (MexA) is more abundant in anoxic zones, suggesting enhanced drug tolerance under hypoxia in P. aeruginosa (; ; ). Despite being a facultative anaerobe, P. aeruginosa can maintain growth under oxygen-limited conditions (), which in turn promotes robust biofilm formation ().

Figure 1

3 The effect of oxygen-limited conditions on P. aeruginosa biofilms

3.1 Anaerobic metabolism

In human host environments, pathogens encounter fluctuating oxygen levels, with adaptive responses to such fluctuations primarily occurring at the metabolic level (). Metabolism reprogramming is central to initiating bacterial tolerance mechanisms and reactivating transitions from a non-replicating to an actively growing state. P. aeruginosa exhibits remarkable metabolic versatility, utilizing diverse catabolic and anabolic pathways encoded in its genome to thrive in harsh environments (; ). While aerobic metabolism dominates under oxygen-replete conditions, biofilm-embedded bacteria frequently reside in oxygen-limited niches. Under such constraints, P. aeruginosa shifts to aerobic metabolism—enabling sustained growth and metabolic activity without oxygen (). This adaptation encompasses anaerobic respiration and fermentation, as illustrated in Figure 2. Critically, this metabolic switch confers enhanced antibiotic tolerance and specific molecule resistance ().

Figure 2

For energy generation via respiratory, P. aeruginosa can utilize oxygen, nitrogen compounds, and potentially other electron acceptors such as thiosulfate (). Under oxygen-limited conditions, P. aeruginosa performs anaerobic respiration using nitrate, nitrite, or nitrous oxide as terminal electron acceptors, facilitating rapid growth and energy production. In the absence of nitrate and nitrite, P. aeruginosa employs two alternative fermentation pathways to support slow growth or survival. The first involves substrate-level phosphorylation through arginine utilization, resulting in very slow growth. The second fermentation pathway uses pyruvate as a substrate, converting it into acetate, lactate, and small amounts of succinate.

3.1.1 Anaerobic respiration

Nitrogen metabolism under anaerobic and biofilm conditions promotes the virulence and tolerance of pathogens under hypoxic stress. Denitrification, a continuous four-step, eight-electron reduction process converting nitrate to nitrogen, is a key pathway enabling P. aeruginosa to respire anaerobically under oxygen-limited conditions (; ). In this process, nitrate (NO3-) or nitrite (NO2-) serves as the terminal electron acceptor (TEA), replacing oxygen generate energy. Denitrification also serves as an important cellular redox balancing mechanism within biofilms, provided these electron acceptors are available in sufficient concentrations (; ). Using an alginate-encapsulated P. aeruginosa chronic infection model, it has been demonstrated that oxygen depletion limits bacterial growth. Supplementing nitrate as an alternative electron acceptor sustains the growth of P. aeruginosa microcolonies under oxygen-limited conditions, although the overall respiration rate decreases (). Consistent with these findings, lower nitrate and nitrite levels have been observed in infected wounds compared to non-infected controls, reflecting bacterial consumption via denitrification (). Clinically, the ability of P. aeruginosa to perform anaerobic respiration under hypoxic conditions contributes to enhanced biofilm formation (), aligning with model predictions ().

During hypoxic growth, nitric oxide (NO) can be produced endogenously as a denitrification intermediate or derived from exogenous NO donors. NO exhibits potent bactericidal properties (). Accumulation of NO under anaerobic conditions acts as a stress signal, ultimately promoting biofilm formation as a defense mechanism (; ). NO detoxification proteins, including NO reductase (NOR, encoded by norVW) and flavohemoglobin (Hmp), help mitigate NO toxicity during denitrification (). Interestingly, nitrite reductase (NIR) also has NO-independent functions; NO can indirectly induce NIR expression and regulate flagella biosynthesis and swimming motility by forming a ternary complex with the molecular chaperone DnaK and flagellin FliC in the periplasm, serving as a scaffold ().

Beyond anaerobic respiration, P. aeruginosa in the mucus layer of CF lungs can perform microaerobic respiration. This process rapidly consumes oxygen, creating an oxygen gradient (). In the CF lung microenvironment, microaerobic respiration can occur simultaneously with nitrate respiration when both oxygen and nitrate are present (). Three high-affinity terminal oxidases—the cbb3-1, cbb3-2, and cyanide-insensitive oxidases—enable growth at low oxygen concentrations and facilitate microaerobic growth. Notably, the genes encoding cbb3–2 oxidase and the cyanide-insensitive oxidase (cioAB) are highly expressed under oxygen-limited conditions (). The cyanide-insensitive oxidases not only increase under microaerobic conditions but may also protect cells against hydrogen cyanide toxicity during growth. The cbb3–1 oxidase is consistently expressed across various oxygen levels, suggesting P. aeruginosa maintains preparedness for sudden oxygen depletion without needing to trigger a transcriptionally regulated hypoxic response ().

3.1.2 Fermentation

Under oxygen-limited and nitrate-depleted conditions, P. aeruginosa biofilms sustain other energy supply through fermentation, primarily by activating the arginine fermentation pathway () and pyruvate fermentation (), which moderately support anaerobic growth and survival. L-arginine serves as a substrate for ATP production, enabling bacterial persistence under these conditions (). Specifically, P. aeruginosa utilizes the arginine deiminase (ADI) pathway to generate energy under oxygen-limited conditions, producing 1 mole of ATP per mole of L-arginine consumed. When arginine concentrations are sufficiently high, substrate-level phosphorylation can yield enough ATP to maintain bacterial growth. Thus, denitrification and arginine fermentation represent core metabolic processes in P. aeruginosa under oxygen-limited conditions.

Additionally, under anaerobic conditions, P. aeruginosa ferments pyruvate into lactate, acetate, and succinate. Although pyruvate fermentation does not support substantial anaerobic growth, it promotes long-term bacterial viability without contributing directly to proliferation (). Proteomic analyses of hypoxic biofilm regions further suggest that cells produce fermentation by-products such as acetate (). Notably, nitrate respiration inhibits pyruvate fermentation, whereas arginine fermentation proceeds independently of pyruvate metabolism ().

3.2 Phenazines as an electron shuttle

P. aeruginosa is well known for producing colored, redox-active metabolites called phenazines (). These phenazine compounds produced vary in structure and chemical properties (), functioning as electron-cycling molecules. The redox cycling of phenazine involves alternating reduction and oxidation reactions, which reoxidize accumulated NADH, thereby facilitating the transfer of electrons from reducing agents such as NAD(P)H to oxidizing agents like oxygen. This process promotes adenosine triphosphate (ATP) production and the generation of proton-motive force, allowing cells to survive in hypoxic regions and supporting colony growth (; ). The redox potential of phenazines enables their reduction by bacterial cells and subsequent reaction with higher-potential oxidizing agents outside the cells, such as ferric iron and oxygen (). Acting as electron shuttles between bacteria and external substrates (), phenazines alleviate limitations posed by scarce electron acceptors (). Effectively, within the deep layers of the biofilm community, electrons accumulated for ATP synthesis can be accepted by oxidized phenazines and transferred to extracellular oxidants like oxygen. The cbb3-type terminal oxidases Cco1 and Cco2 of P. aeruginosa, key components of the respiratory chain, participate in phenazine reduction ().

Phenazines and the cellular redox state directly influence biofilm morphogenesis via the regulatory protein RmcA, which modulates matrix components responsible for wrinkle formation (; ). Phenazine-producing colonies tend to grow smoothly, whereas phenazine-deficient strains exhibit rougher, highly wrinkled biofilms that maximize oxygen contact (). Wrinkling serves as an adaptive mechanism to optimize oxygen accessibility and maintain metabolic homeostasis. Beyond their redox roles, phenazines act as signaling molecules that promote biofilm formation. P. aeruginosa synthesizes phenazine pigments such as pyocyanin, which intercalate into DNA base-pair regions, enhancing electron transfer, causing structural perturbations, and increasing DNA viscosity. The interaction is crucial for biofilm development (). Disrupting the pyocyanin—DNA interaction—via antioxidants or other inhibitors—can impede biofilm formation and associated infections (). The redox cycling of pyocyanin also generates reactive oxygen species (ROS), which damage host cells and pathogen cells, releasing eDNA (; ). Phenazine compounds also mediate efficient extracellular electron transfer (EET) by interacting with eDNA in P. aeruginosa biofilms (). Together with the anaerobic stress responses, phenazines promote antibiotic tolerance and contribute to disease progression (; ). Notably, phenazines enhance biofilm tolerance to antibiotics such as ciprofloxacin ().

Phenazines also stimulate pyruvate fermentation under anoxic conditions by mediating expression of the ackA and pta genes required for this pathway (). Through their redox cycling, phenazines enable P. aeruginosa to oxidize pyruvate to acetate and couple acetate metabolism with ATP synthesis via acetate kinase, thereby enhancing survival. In pyruvate fermentation, ATP generation is tightly linked to redox balance, a contrast to the arginine fermentation pathway where this connection is absent ().

3.3 Virulence expression

Mathematical modeling studies have demonstrated that bacterial biofilms growing anaerobically in anoxic environments secrete elevated levels of toxins. These toxins diffuse through the environment and lyse neutrophils, helping the biofilm resist neutrophil-mediated attacks. Consequently, bacterial adaptability and biofilm formation are enhanced under these conditions (). P. aeruginosa biofilms express a highly regulated protein secretion apparatus known as the type III secretion system (T3SS), which planktonic cells cannot deploy (). The T3SS directly translocates a specific subset of exotoxin effector proteins–including ExoS, ExoU, ExoT, and ExoY–into host cells, driving P. aeruginosa pathogenicity (; ). Multiple studies indicate that bacteria mount adaptive responses to diverse environments by modulating gene expression and protein production, thereby regulating the expression of virulence factors (; ) and inducing virulence protein synthesis (). Oxygen limitation is a critical regulator of T3SS expression, a major virulence determinant in P. aeruginosa. Exposure to hypoxic conditions activates the T3SS (; ). This activation strongly depends on the glyoxylate shunt enzyme isocitrate lyase (ICL, encoded by aceA), which is highly expressed in cystic fibrosis isolates specifically under oxygen-limited conditions (). ICL-dependent regulation influences the expression of the T3 structural proteins, effectors, and regulatory proteins (ExsC, ExsD, and ExsE). Additionally, aceA modulates biofilm formation by affecting the expression of pslA, a gene involved in the biosynthesis of an extracellular polysaccharide (). Notably, aceA mutants display enhanced biofilm formation during anaerobic growth.

The RetS/LadS signaling pathway reciprocally regulates T3SS expression and biofilm formation through a complex mechanism involving the GacS/GacA two-component system, the small regulatory RNAs RsmZ and RsmY, and the translational repressor RsmA (; ; ; ; ). Activation of LadS—or downregulation of RetS—promotes GacS homodimer formation, resulting in GacA phosphorylation and activation, accompanied by increased production of rsmZ and rsmY. These small RNAs sequester RsmA, relieving its repression and thereby activating biofilm formation (; ). Conversely, RetS activation induces heterodimer formation with GacS, inhibiting the GacS/GacA pathway. Free RsmA then binds specific mRNA targets, modulating their stability and indirectly activating exsA-dependent T3SS expression (). The regulation of AceA may be mediated by the RetS/LadS signaling pathway ().

Moreover, the anaerobic regulator Anr senses oxygen limitation and induces expression of narL within the NarL/NarX two-component system. NarL represses the RsmA-antagonistic RNAs rsmZ and rsmY, resulting in increased levels of free RsmA, which stimulates T3SS expression. Free RsmA positively regulates T3SS and possibly other virulence determinants under its control, serving as a convergence point for P. aeruginosa’s response to various environmental cues ().

Finally, P. aeruginosa OprG, an outer membrane protein belonging to the OmpW family of eight β-barrel porins, is broadly distributed. In iron-rich anaerobic environments, ANR significantly upregulates oprG transcription. Purified OprG forms cation-selective channels and substantially enhances cytotoxicity ().

4 Regulatory mechanisms under oxygen-limited conditions

P. aeruginosa biofilms adapt to oxygen-limited conditions through coordinated regulatory mechanisms. Anaerobic metabolism, including denitrification, arginine fermentation, and pyruvate fermentation, is activated under oxygen-limited conditions. Additionally, quorum sensing systems and the secondary messenger cyclic di-GMP (c-di-GMP) play crucial roles in modulating biofilm formation in response. Transcriptional regulatory networks involving the transcription factors ANR and DNR, and the NarXL two-component system, orchestrate the biofilm’s adaptive responses under oxygen-limited environments. Moreover, recent studies have also identified specific genes that further support biofilms growth and development under such conditions.

4.1 Anaerobic metabolism-related genes

4.1.1 Denitrification regulatory genes

The expression of narI and nirS genes in P. aeruginosa is upregulated under anaerobic conditions, playing key roles in anaerobic respiration (). Notably, P. aeruginosa may induce denitrification genes in response to low oxygen levels regardless of nitrate availability. During anaerobic growth, two nitrate reductase gene clusters are expressed, one encoding a membrane-bound enzyme complex (narGHJI) associated with the cytoplasmic membrane, and another encoding a periplasmic enzyme complex (napAB) (). The membrane-bound nitrate reductase is essential for anaerobic growth, as P. aeruginosa depends on it for energy generation when nitrate is present (). Enzymes involved in nitrate respiration, including nitrate reductases NapA and NarG, accumulate in biofilms (). Furthermore, antibodies against NapA and NarG have been detected in the serum of CF patients, confirming in vivo production of these respiratory enzymes by (). The periplasmic nitrate reductase is not essential for anaerobic energy generation. However, it may balance intracellular redox states under low oxygen, a role reported in other microorganisms (). It is plausible that P. aeruginosa utilizes the periplasmic nitrate reductase similarly. The Nar complex, located in the cytoplasmic membrane, drives proton-motive force generation and ATP synthesis, whereas the periplasmic Nap complex mainly balances intracellular redox states without contributing directly to the transmembrane electrochemical gradient (; ; ). This view contrasts with earlier findings where the periplasmic nitrate reductase and nitrate transport genes (e.g., narK2) were downregulated during anaerobic nitrate growth, with no observed differential regulation of the membrane-bound reductase (; ). The discrepancy may stem from methodological differences, as the prior study lacked saturating mutagenesis and thus might have missed mutants in the nar operon. The narG gene is critical for anaerobic growth across varying nitrate concentrations. The narG operon also includes two homologs of the nitrate/nitrite antiporter gene narK, as well as PA3871 (nifM) and moaA1, which encode molybdopterin cofactor synthesis enzymes, and narHJI, encoding additional subunits of the membrane-bound nitrate reductase ().

4.1.2 Arginine fermentation regulatory genes

The arc operon encodes three key enzymes in the ADI pathway, arcA (arginine deiminase), arcB (catabolic ornithine carbamoyltransferase), and arcC (carbamate kinase), which is induced under oxygen-limited conditions (). Subsequent studies revealed that the arc operon also includes the arcD, encoding a hydrophobic membrane-associated protein involved in the ADI process (). Proteomic analyses of hypoxic P. aeruginosa biofilm regions reveal increased proteins linked to L-arginine and polyamine metabolism, with elevated ArcA and ArcB indicating active arginine-based energy production. Concurrently, the abundance of the cytosolic aminopeptidase PepA is approximately threefold higher in hypoxic compared to aerobic regions. PepA likely contributes to cellular protein degradation, recycling amino acids for stress responses such as pH homeostasis and energy generation (). Furthermore, the DNA-binding protein HupB is eight times more abundant in hypoxic zones relative to aerobic zones (). HupB, a small histone-like protein also known as heat-unstable (HU) protein, protects DNA from oxidative damage and facilitates adaptation to stress (). In mammalian hosts, chronic P. aeruginosa infections are modulated by L-arginine metabolism and its derivative NO, with enhanced arginine catabolism observed at chronic wound sites (). Microaerobic environments typical of chronic infection sites favor L-arginine fermentation, leading to NO deficiency, a hallmark of diminished host defense (). Interestingly, L-arginine also supports phenazine production, and arginine metabolism remains largely unexplored ().

4.1.3 Pyruvate fermentation regulatory genes

A genome-wide analysis of anaerobic metabolism in P. aeruginosa identified several key pyruvate-metabolizing genes, including NADH-dependent lactate dehydrogenase (ldhA), phosphotransacetylase (pta), and acetate kinase (ackA) (). The conversion of pyruvate to lactate and acetate relies on the intact ldhA and ackA-pta gene clusters, respectively (). The anaerobic induction of the ackA-pta promoter is modulated by oxygen tension through the transcriptional regulators Anr and the integration host factor (IHF) (). IHF, potentially encoded by the anr gene, is believed to contain a 4Fe-4S cluster that functions as an oxygen tension sensor (; ; ). The ihfA locus encodes a subunit of the DNA-bending IHF protein, which plays a role in transcriptional regulation (, ). Additionally, the gacS-ldhA operon (PA0926 and PA0927) was identified, encoding the sensor kinase GacS of the GacA/GacS two-component regulatory system and a putative fermentative lactate dehydrogenase (LdhA), respectively (). The ackA-pta locus (PA0835 and PA0836) likely encodes acetate kinase and Pta, respectively, while the adhA locus (PA5427) encodes a putative alcohol dehydrogenase (AdhA) (). Under oxygen-limited conditions, adhA is induced to facilitate ethanol catabolism, contributing to anaerobic energy metabolism ().

4.2 Quorum sensing

P. aeruginosa utilizes quorum sensing (QS), a cell-density-dependent intercellular communication system, which plays a pivotal role in regulating bacterial virulence and biofilm formation (). Two principal QS signaling molecules, N-butyryl-L-homoserine lactone (C4-HSL) and N-(3-oxododecanoyl)-L-homoserine lactone (3O-C12-HSL), mediate QS through the transcriptional activator pairs lasR/lasI and rhlR/rhlI, respectively. Notably, the expression of lasI and rhlI is significantly upregulated under low oxygen conditions (). The QS system modulates genes involved in denitrification, thereby influencing bacterial growth and survival by regulating NO levels within the biofilm. Additionally, QS activates the transcription of the pel gene, partially through the Rhl system. The pel gene product synthesizes the glucose-rich extracellular polysaccharide matrix essential for P. aeruginosa biofilm formation (; ).

In the CF airway environment, optimal expression of the rhl QS component benefits P. aeruginosa persistence. QS controls the expression of the snr-1 gene, which in turn regulates the denitrification rate (). Specifically, the rhl system acts as an anaerobic repressor of snr-1 transcription. Consequently, in the absence of RhlR, the reducing power provided by Snr-1 increases, thus enhancing NAR activity. However, dysregulation of denitrification genes in rhlR mutants leads to elevated transcription of nar and nir genes, causing accumulation of toxic NO and subsequent self-damage (). NO, a by-product of anaerobic respiration, accumulates in rhlR mutants despite a modest increase (2-fold) in NOR activity, which is insufficient to mitigate NO toxicity (). Thus, under anaerobic conditions, P. aeruginosa relies on the rhl QS system and NO reductase to regulate NO levels and sustain robust biofilm formation and survival ().

4.3 3,5-cyclic diguanylic acid (c-di-GMP)

Another crucial signaling molecule in P. aeruginosa is the second messenger 3,5-cyclic diguanylic acid (c-di-GMP), which facilitates bacterial adaptation to diverse environmental conditions (; ). The c-di-GMP plays a central role in regulating biofilm formation and dispersion (). Elevated intracellular c-di-GMP levels drive the transition from a planktonic to a biofilm lifestyle by repressing motility-related genes, including those regulated by FleQ, and activating genes involved in exopolysaccharide production and biofilm maturation (). Conversely, reduced c-di-GMP levels trigger biofilm dispersion by activating motility structures, including flagella and pili (). The synthesis and degradation of c-di-GMP are catalyzed by diguanylate cyclases (DGCs) and phosphodiesterases (PDEs), respectively (). Although the interplay between QS and c-di-GMP signaling in P. aeruginosa is not fully elucidated, both pathways regulate virulence and biofilm dynamics, suggesting potential crosstalk. Current evidence indicates that the QS system can modulate intracellular c-di-GMP concentrations (). Specifically, the Las-QS system may elevate c-di-GMP levels by stimulating DGC activity, whereas the Rhl-QS system might decrease c-di-GMP by inducing PDE activity. Furthermore, the tyrosine phosphatase TpbA inhibits the activity of the DGC TpbB via dephosphorylation, thereby reducing biofilm formation. Las-QS positively regulates TpbA expression, while Rhl-QS does not influence it (). Interestingly, TpbA also enhances rhl transcription, indicating that QS can negatively regulate c-di-GMP production in P. aeruginosa. However, the exact dynamics of c-di-GMP synthesis under varying QS states remain unclear. Moreover, NO has been reported to modulate DGC and PDE activities (; ). NO inhibits biofilm formation by enhancing PDE activity, leading to decreased intracellular c-di-GMP levels ().

4.4 Transcription factors

TFs play a crucial role in regulating gene expression in response to environmental changes. Bacteria sense oxygen-limited conditions in their environment through Anr or Dnr, and regulate the expression of a series of genes to enable the bacteria to colonize and grow in oxygen-limited environments.

4.4.1 Anr

Anr is a well-characterized global transcriptional regulator and a key activator of gene expression under hypoxic conditions. It governs a regulatory network of hypoxia-responsive genes and serves as a hallmark of anaerobic or microaerobic growth (). Under low oxygen tension, active Anr promotes P. aeruginosa biofilm formation and virulence, playing a crucial role in host colonization (; ). Deletion of the anr gene results in defective biofilm development and often abolishes anaerobic growth, whereas elevated Anr activity enhances biofilm formation (). Nevertheless, the precise underlying mechanisms remain incompletely understood. Notably, Anr regulon genes show no significant transcriptional increase under hypoxia, consistent with the findings of Alvarez-Orgeta et al (), suggesting Anr regulation involves mechanisms beyond its own regulon transcription.

Anr is indispensable for activating energy metabolism pathways during hypoxia. It strongly induces denitrification and regulates the expression of other transcriptional regulators, including dnr and the narXL two-component system (). The dnr is essential for activating denitrification during anaerobic growth, controlling a subset of genes involved in nitrate respiration (). The NarL response regulator modulates energy metabolism under hypoxic stress by promoting nitrate utilization and repressing less efficient energy-yielding pathways such as pyruvate and arginine fermentation (; ). Interestingly, while Anr enhances NarL production, it also independently promotes arginine fermentation by upregulating the arcDABC operon under anaerobic conditions (). Furthermore, Anr activates the ackA-pta operon responsible for pyruvate fermentation in response to low oxygen (; ).

Anr also upregulates genes encoding high-affinity cytochrome oxidases (hemF and hemN) and CupA fimbriae components (oprG and cupA1-5), facilitating respiratory adaptation during hypoxia and contributing to biofilm development and pathogenicity (). Additionally, Anr influences quorum sensing by regulating the small regulatory RNA PhrS (), thereby modulating biofilm adaptability under low oxygen.

A well-studied virulence factor of P. aeruginosa, the hemolytic phospholipase C (PlcH), is tightly regulated by Anr. The catabolism of choline released by PlcH enhances Anr activity (; , ). The plcH promoter contains a conserved Anr consensus binding sequence across all P. aeruginosa genomes (; ). Anr represses plcH expression, maintaining PlcH protein at levels that facilitate effective host-pathogen interactions without compromising biofilm integrity (). Under oxygen-limited conditions, PlcH production may become disadvantageous, as excessive PlcH protein can compromise the structural integrity of the P. aeruginosa biofilm. Anr likely binds directly to the plcH promoter, which contains a conserved Anr consensus sequence across all P. aeruginosa genomes. Mutations in this conserved sequence result in increased plcH expression under hypoxia. Although Anr shares its consensus binding sequence with the secondary regulator Dnr, their activation mechanisms differ; notably, Dnr does not participate in plcH repression (). Anr is active when its 4Fe-4S iron-sulfur cluster remains intact, whereas Dnr is activated by the oxidation of its heme cofactor by nitric oxide, which induces a conformational change enabling DNA binding (; ).

The small RNA ErsA also plays an important role in anaerobic adaptation. It regulates bacterial-host interactions, including biofilm maturation, motility, and antibiotic resistance (; Zhang et al., 2017; ). ErsA is transcriptionally induced under oxygen-limited conditions () and transmits low-oxygen signals to the Anr regulon. It positively regulates Anr expression at the post-transcriptional level (). Once ErsA surpasses a certain threshold, the RNA-binding protein Hfq acts synergistically with ErsA to activate Anr. This function of Hfq complements its own post-transcriptional regulation of Anr, indicating that ErsA-mediated activation of anr expression depends on Hfq (). Hfq’s chaperone activity likely promotes the interaction between ErsA and anr mRNA, enhancing anr mRNA translation, possibly by improving access to its initiation site. This positive regulation by ErsA contributes to the stabilization of anr mRNA, consistent with the observed reduction in anr mRNA levels when ErsA is absent. Additionally, Hfq has been reported to stimulate anr expression via an unknown mechanism (; ). Deletion of ErsA leads to reduced virulence of P. aeruginosa both in vitro and in vivo, markedly impaired biofilm formation and maturation (), and severely compromised anaerobic growth through denitrification and arginine fermentation. The role of ErsA in biofilm regulation may also involve downregulation of the AlgC enzyme () and the activation of the AmrZ regulon (). Furthermore, ErsA directly negatively regulates oprD mRNA, affecting the envelope composition of P. aeruginosa (Zhang et al., 2017; ). These findings suggest that P. aeruginosa’s adaptation to the CF lung environment may increase its reliance on ErsA for regulating anaerobic metabolism.

4.4.2 DNR

DNR is a critical transcriptional activator essential for initiating the denitrification process in P. aeruginosa. It was the first protein identified to restore anaerobic respiration and arginine substrate-level phosphorylation growth in anr mutants (). The expression and activity of Dnr are themselves regulated by Anr, positioning Dnr downstream in the oxygen-sensing regulatory cascade. Under hypoxic conditions, both Anr and Dnr coordinate to activate transcription of genes involved in denitrification and anaerobic respiration. Key operons under their control include narKGHJIm, encoding nitrate reductase; nirSM-CFLGHJEN, encoding nitrite reductase; and ccoN2O2Q2P2, encoding the cbb3–2 cytochrome oxidase complex.

In the presence of nitrate under anaerobic conditions, expression from the narK1 promoter is induced through the combined action of Anr, Dnr, and the nitrate-responsive two-component regulatory system NarXL (). The DNA-bending protein integration host factor (IHF) is also crucial for optimal promoter activity. Moreover, Anr and NarXL induce dnr expression, amplifying the regulatory cascade (). The cooperative function of NarXL and Dnr, regulated by ANR, is necessary for transcription of the nitrite reductase regulatory gene nirQ under anaerobic conditions (; ). Dnr belongs to the Crp-Fnr superfamily of transcriptional regulators and has been reported to activate expression of genes involved in the denitrification pathway, including nir, nor, and nos (; ). Transcriptional control of the nar locus occurs via the intergenic region between narXL and narK1. Both nitrate and nitrite induce narK expression, and a basal induction persists even during arginine fermentation (). The narK1 promoter activity is modulated by both Anr and Dnr, with Anr being indispensable for its baseline activation, while Dnr enhances promoter activity independently of Anr (). Anr indirectly facilitates transcriptional activation of nirS by inducing dnr expression in this regulatory hierarchy. The transcription of NorC also requires Anr and Dnr in the presence of nitrous oxide but is not directly regulated by NarL ().

Although the small RNA ErsA positively regulates Anr post-transcriptional (), no direct regulation of Dnr by ErsA has been observed. Nevertheless, dnr transcript levels decrease in the absence of ErsA, likely due to diminished Anr expression. Additionally, under anaerobic conditions, expression of the narXL genes is also upregulated by both Anr and Dnr ().

4.5 Two-component regulatory system

Two-component systems (TCSs) are widespread in prokaryotic genomes and constitute a fundamental regulatory network that enables bacteria to adapt, survive, and modulate pathogenicity in response to environmental changes. Functioning as molecular switches, these systems sense external stimuli and regulate gene expression accordingly, facilitating bacterial adaptation to diverse conditions. A canonical TCS consists of a membrane-bound sensor kinase (SK) and a cytoplasmic response regulator (RR), typically encoded adjacently in the genome (). Upon sensing environmental signals, the sensor domain of the SK undergoes conformational changes that are transmitted through the transmembrane region to its cytoplasmic histidine kinase domain. This triggers autophosphorylation of a conserved C-terminal histidine residue in trans (; ). The phosphoryl group is then transferred to a conserved aspartate residue on the RR, activating it. The activated RR modulates the transcription of downstream genes involved in diverse physiological processes, including bacterial virulence, pathogenesis, biofilm formation, cell division, and metabolite production (; ).

In P. aeruginosa, the NarXL system is a nitrate-responsive two-component regulatory system (). NarX is the sensor kinase and NarL its response regulator; in the presence of nitrate, NarXL activates and cooperates with Dnr to upregulate nar, nir, and nor genes encoding nitrate, nitrite, and nitric oxide reductases (). Simultaneously, NarL represses the arginine fermentation pathway by inhibiting the arginine-dependent activation of the arcDABC operon mediated by the transcriptional activator ArgR. Specifically, NarL suppresses the expression of arcA, arcB, and arcC genes without affecting the oxygen tension-dependent activation driven by Anr (). Under conditions where both nitrate and arginine are present, NarL binding likely interferes with ArgR’s interaction at overlapping DNA binding sites, thereby preventing ArgR-mediated induction of arcDABC transcription ().

4.6 Other factors

In addition to above factors, studies have identified other specialized genes that promote P. aeruginosa growth and biofilm formation. OmpW is an eight-helix β-barrel outer membrane porin that facilitates the uptake of small hydrophobic molecules (). It has been demonstrated that OmpW participates in bacterial adaptation to various environmental stresses (). In P. aeruginosa, OmpW expression is upregulated under hypoxic or anaerobic conditions (). However, OmpW expression may be downregulated when iron levels are low, as OmpW is implicated in iron uptake (). Concurrently, under hypoxia, the global regulator Lrp is upregulated (). The ompW promoter contains an Lrp-binding site, through which Lrp negatively regulates ompW expression ().

Another crucial outer membrane protein, OprF, functions as a cytokine and plays a vital role in regulating anaerobic metabolism in P. aeruginosa. It is essential for the optimal survival of anaerobic biofilms (). The absence of OprF results in severely impaired bacterial growth due to the loss of nitrite reductase activity and defects in anaerobic respiration. Notably, OprF is detectable exclusively in anaerobic biofilms (), and only CF patients with chronic infections possess antibodies against OprF. Bacteria lacking oprF exhibit diminished anaerobic biofilm formation, partly attributable to the lack of NIR activity. Two hypotheses have been proposed regarding OprF’s precise role in anaerobic growth. First, OprF may serve as a porin facilitating nitrate or nitrite transport into the cell and potentially interact directly with NIR to stabilize its enzymatic activity. Second, the absence of OprF may compromise peptidoglycan stability, as OprF has been shown to interact with this essential cell wall component (). Reduced peptidoglycan integrity renders cells more fragile and susceptible to environmental stress.

5 Clinical significance and future directions

Biofilm formation serves as a crucial protective strategy, enabling pathogenic bacteria to resist various environmental stresses (). The hypoxic microenvironment within biofilms facilitates bacterial adaptation through reduced metabolic activity and heightened antibiotic tolerance (; ), which contributes to persistent chronic infections. Traditional antibacterial treatments have largely targeted the eradication of pathogens but often overlook the modulation of the infected microenvironment, resulting in issues such as antibiotic resistance and incomplete bacterial clearance (; Zhao et al., 2023b). Recently, strategies aimed at reversing the hypoxic microenvironment have emerged as a promising research focus for combating biofilm-associated infections.

Reversal of hypoxia triggers a cascade of beneficial effects, including the reactivation of suppressed immune responses, promotion of osteogenesis and angiogenesis, induction of cuproptosis-like bacterial death, and stimulation of dendritic cells and macrophages to enhance antibacterial activity via chemotaxis and phagocytosis (). Photodynamic therapy (PDT) is a notable antibacterial approach capable of effectively killing bacteria and preventing multidrug resistance; however, its efficacy is markedly compromised under hypoxic conditions. Enhancing oxygen delivery to treatment sites and alleviating hypoxia significantly improves PDT efficacy, providing a promising avenue for biofilm eradication (; ; ).

Recent advancements include the development of porphyrinic metal-organic framework (MOF)-based metalloantibiotics that catalyze endogenous hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) decomposition to generate oxygen. The resulting oxygen enhances oxygen-dependent sonodynamic therapy (SDT), which disrupts bacterial homeostasis—affecting cell membrane integrity and quorum sensing systems—thereby promoting bacterial killing (). Concurrently, sustained oxygen production supports fibroblast survival and migration, stimulates angiogenic growth factors, promotes angiogenesis, and increases secretion of anti-inflammatory cytokines (). Nitric oxide (NO) exhibits dual effects depending on its concentration: high levels possess bactericidal activity, whereas low levels induce biofilm dispersion and sensitize bacteria to antibiotics (). In P. aeruginosa models, low-dose NO, which is non-lethal, acts as a signaling molecule triggering biofilm dispersal in ex vivo cystic fibrosis (CF) sputum, reducing bacterial tolerance to tobramycin alone or combined with ceftazidime. This highlights NO’s potential as an adjunct therapy for managing P. aeruginosa biofilm infections in CF patients (). Consequently, NO-based treatments represent a promising approach against antibiotic-resistant bacteria and biofilm-associated infections. Overall, alleviating biofilm hypoxia holds significant potential for enhancing treatment efficacy and overcoming chronic biofilm-related infections.

6 Conclusions

Biofilm cells exhibit an oxygen gradient that typically reduces their sensitivity to antibiotics, making complete eradication challenging. The adaptation of bacterial biofilms to hypoxic conditions is considered a crucial factor for their prolonged latent persistence in the human body. This hypoxic microenvironment triggers a series of complex bacterial responses. Current studies suggest that under oxygen-limited conditions, P. aeruginosa shifts to anaerobic metabolism, utilizing nitrate for denitrification to support growth. In the absence of nitrate or nitrite, survival is maintained through arginine or pyruvate fermentation pathways. Additionally, P. aeruginosa biofilms produce phenazine compounds to sustain redox balance within the biofilm matrix. Adaptation to oxygen limitation also involves the regulation of virulence gene expression and QS systems. These processes are coordinately controlled by transcriptional regulators such as Anr, Dnr, NarXL, and other specialized genes, collectively promoting bacterial survival and biofilm formation. A deeper understanding of the adaptive mechanisms employed by bacterial biofilms under oxygen-limited conditions can provide new directions for future treatments of biofilm-associated infections, including strategies targeting QS or c-di-GMP pathways, modulation of Anr or Dnr regulators, and nitric oxide-based therapies.

Statements

Author contributions

LR: Writing – review & editing, Writing – original draft. YY: Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing. KF: Writing – review & editing, Data curation, Investigation. XF: Investigation, Data curation, Writing – review & editing. JH: Writing – review & editing, Visualization. BZ: Conceptualization, Writing – review & editing. YL: Supervision, Writing – review & editing.

Funding

The author(s) declare financial support was received for the research and/or publication of this article. This work was supported by Basic Scientific Research Project of Education Department of Liaoning Province (LJKMZ20221190).

Conflict of interest

The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.

Generative AI statement

The author(s) declare that no Generative AI was used in the creation of this manuscript.

Any alternative text (alt text) provided alongside figures in this article has been generated by Frontiers with the support of artificial intelligence and reasonable efforts have been made to ensure accuracy, including review by the authors wherever possible. If you identify any issues, please contact us.

Publisher’s note

All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.

References

Summary

Keywords

biofilms, oxygen-limited, anaerobic metabolism, transcriptional factors, two-component systems, quorum sensing, Pseudomonas aeruginosa

Citation

Ren L, Yuan Y, Farea K, Feng X, He J, Liu Y and Zheng B (2025) The adaptability of Pseudomonas aeruginosa biofilm in oxygen-limited environments. Front. Cell. Infect. Microbiol. 15:1655335. doi: 10.3389/fcimb.2025.1655335

Received

27 June 2025

Accepted

03 September 2025

Published

19 September 2025

Volume

15 - 2025

Edited by

Ashwini Chauhan, University of Delhi, India

Reviewed by

Anju V. T., St. Joseph’s College, India

Rohit Ruhal, VIT University, India

Updates

Copyright

*Correspondence: Yi Liu, ; Bowen Zheng,

†These authors have contributed equally to this work and share first authorship

Disclaimer

All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.

Outline

Figures

Cite article

Copy to clipboard


Export citation file


Share article

Article metrics