MINI REVIEW article

Front. Astron. Space Sci., 30 May 2023

Sec. Planetary Science

Volume 10 - 2023 | https://doi.org/10.3389/fspas.2023.1176740

Radiative transfer and inversion codes for characterizing planetary atmospheres: an overview

  • 1. Max-Planck-Institut für Sonnensystemforschung, Göttingen, Germany

  • 2. Georg-August-Universität Göttingen, Göttingen, Germany

Abstract

The study of planetary atmospheres is crucial for understanding the origin, evolution, and processes that shape celestial bodies like planets, moons and comets. The interpretation of planetary spectra requires a detailed understanding of radiative transfer (RT) and its application through computational codes. With the advancement of observations, atmospheric modelling, and inference techniques, diverse RT and retrieval codes in planetary science have been proliferated. However, the selection of the most suitable code for a given problem can be challenging. To address this issue, we present a comprehensive mini-overview of the different RT and retrieval codes currently developed or available in the field of planetary atmospheres. This study serves as a valuable resource for the planetary science community by providing a clear and accessible list of codes, and offers a useful reference for researchers and practitioners in their selection and application of RT and retrieval codes for planetary atmospheric studies.

1 Introduction

Planetary science, including the study of exoplanets, is currently a very active and fascinating multi-disciplinary field covering astronomy, astrophysics, geophysics, astrobiology, among other fields. By studying planets, we can answer fundamental questions about their origin, formation, evolution, potential for life, and physico-chemical processes. The spectrum of a planet contains valuable information about its atmospheric chemical composition and physical processes. Deriving atmospheric properties like the vertical thermal structure, chemical composition and dynamics is essential to understand the origin, evolution, and how the atmospheres are influenced by physical and chemical mechanisms.

Numerous physico-chemical problems in planetary atmospheres require a detailed understanding of radiative transfer (RT) of photons in different environments. Detailed solutions of the RT equation demand high computational capabilities. The technical implementation of these solutions in codes is a rapidly developing area, and numerous RT approaches have been attempted in recent years. Several groups then attacked the problem from a variety of perspectives by using completely different, independent and dedicated numerical algorithms. Some atmospheric RT codes have been developed with a particular aim or for the interpretation of a particular planet. Later on, in some cases, their functionalities have been extended beyond their original purposes but still limited to the study of a specific type of planets. In recent years, breakthroughs in atmospheric retrieval have been made possible through a combination of advancements in instrumentation, computational resources, sophisticated atmospheric modelling, and powerful statistical inference techniques.

There are varying levels of complexity in atmospheric models and the physico-chemical processes considered in RT and inversion codes, motivated by atmospheric observations. As a result, a significant number of RT and inversion codes have been developed and widely used in different atmospheric contexts, depending on whether the planet being studied is Earth, another planet or body in the Solar System, or an exoplanet. Spectra of Solar System planets can be spatially distributed and have a high signal-to-noise ratio, and can be supplemented with in situ measurements or a priori knowledge. However, exoplanetary spectroscopy currently lacks this observational capability, and retrievals must navigate a much larger parameter space for exoplanetary atmospheres than that for Solar System planets.

The selection of a particular code may depend on various factors, such as the physical problem to face, the estimation technique, computation time, flexibility, user-friendliness, among others. The selection of the most appropriate code suited for a specific problem may result in more accurate and reliable results, highlighting the importance of having a comprehensive list of available codes. This mini-review provides a comprehensive overview of the current RT and inversion codes used in the planetary and exoplanetary communities, as seen from the perspective of a user. These codes are crucial in predicting and interpreting spectra of planetary atmospheres, both in hydrostatic equilibrium and in expanding comas. The quality and extent of these codes are critical for the effective use of space and ground-based telescopes facilities. Madhusudhan (2018) has already provided a review of exoplanetary atmospheric retrieval, some existing retrieval codes, and a description of their differences, Barstow and Heng (2020) provides a discussion of open problems in retrieval analysis, and more recently, MacDonald and Batalha (2023) provides a catalogue of the atmospheric retrieval codes for exoplanets published to date. In this mini-review, we expand and update the codes list, including a large new generation of RT and atmospheric retrieval codes for Solar System and exoplanets.

2 RT and inversion codes

One commonly used way to interpret the measured spectra is calculating a synthetic spectrum for comparison with that measured by solving the radiative transfer (forward model) -i.e., computation of the outgoing radiation from the planetary surface for a given set of free parameters-, and inferring parameters like temperature and chemical abundance profiles. This last step is called inversion or retrieval and consists in comparing the measured and best modelled/synthetic spectra adjusting the atmospheric parameters in such a way as to minimise any discrepancy. A number of radiative transfer codes or forward models and inversion algorithms are already constructed, and generally available and used by the planetary and exoplanetary characterisation communities. A comprehensive list of RT and retrieval codes in the literature is shown in Table 1, indicating where to find them (if available) and the estimation technique employed (Section 3).

TABLE 1

Code nameLinkReferences
Alfnoor‡—Changeat et al. (2020)
APOLLO▴https://github.com/alexrhowe/APOLLOHowe et al. (2017) and Howe et al. (2022)
ARCiS ‡http://www.exoclouds.comMin et al. (2020)
ARTS †https://radiativetransfer.org/Buehler et al. (2018)
ASIMUT †—Vandaele et al. (2006b) and Vandaele et al. (2006a)
ATMO ▴‡•https://www.erc-atmo.eu/?page_id=322Tremblin et al. (2015), Wakeford et al. (2017), and Evans et al. (2017)
AURA ‡—e.g., Pinhas et al. (2018)
Aura-3D ‡—Nixon and Madhusudhan (2022)
Aurora ‡—Welbanks and Madhusudhan (2021)
BART ▴https://github.com/exosports/BARTBlecic (2016)
Benneke & Seager ‡—Benneke and Seager (2013)
Brewster‡▴—Burningham et al. (2017)
Carrión-González et al.▴—Carrión-González et al. (2020)
Cerberus▴—Swain et al. (2014)
CCF-sequence ⧫—Fisher et al. (2020)
CHIMERA †▴‡https://github.com/mrline/CHIMERALine et al. (2013)
DISORThttp://www.rtatmocn.com/Stamnes et al. (2000)
Dynesty ‡https://dynesty.readthedocs.io/en/stable/Speagle (2020)
Ehrenreich et al.—Ehrenreich et al. (2006)
exoCNN⧫https://gitlab.astro.rug.nl/ardevol/exocnnMartínez et al. (2022)
ExoGAN ⧫https://osf.io/6dxps/Zingales and Waldmann (2018)
ExoJAX▴https://github.com/HajimeKawahara/exojaxKawahara et al. (2022)
—Damiano and Hu (2020)
exoretrievals‡—Espinoza et al. (2018)
Exo-REMhttps://gitlab.obspm.fr/Exoplanet-Atmospheres-LESIA/exoremBaudino et al. (2015) and Baudino et al. (2017)
Fortney et al. •—Fortney et al. (2005) and Fortney et al. (2010)
gCMCRThttps://github.com/ELeeAstro/gCMCRTLee et al. (2022)
Gibson et al.▴—Gibson et al. (2020)
HARPhttps://github.com/luminoctum/athena-harpLi et al. (2018)
HELA ⧫https://github.com/exoclime/HELAMarquez-Neila et al. (2018)
HELIOS-R ‡https://github.com/exoclime/HELIOSLavie et al. (2017) and Oreshenko et al. (2017)
Helios-r2 ‡https://github.com/exoclime/Helios-r2Kitzmann et al. (2020)
Home made (MPS) †—Jarchow (1998)
HRCCS ‡https://www.dropbox.com/sh/0cxfolfmrs8ip37/AABZYoHr8nuRlHJG84dArX4ea?dl=0Brogi and Line (2019)
HyDRA ‡—Gandhi and Madhusudhan (2017)
HyDRo ‡—Piette et al. (2021)
INARA ⧫https://gitlab.com/frontierdevelopmentlab/astrobiology/inaraSoboczenski et al. (2018)
Johnson & Marley⧫https://github.com/WreckItTim/MLP-Estimating-Exoplanet-ParametersJohnsen et al. (2020)
KOPRAhttps://www.imk-asf.kit.edu/english/312.phpHoepfner et al. (1998), Stiller et al. (1998, 2000, 2002)
Lellouch et al. †—Lellouch et al. (2017)
Lupu et al.▴‡—Lupu et al. (2016)
Madhusudhan & Seager •▴—Madhusudhan and Seager (2009)
Madhusudhan et al. ▴—Madhusudhan and Seager (2010) and Madhusudhan et al. (2011)
MARGE ⧫github.com/exosports/margeHimes et al. (2022)
Marley & McKay—Marley and McKay (1999)
MassSpec ▴—de Wit and Seager (2013)
MERC ‡—Seidel et al. (2020)
METIS ▴—Lacy and Burrows (2020)
MOLIERE †—Urban et al. (2004)
Moreno et al.—Moreno (1998) and Moreno et al. (2001)
NEMESIS †‡https://users.ox.ac.uk/∼atmp0035/nemesis.htmlIrwin et al. (2008)
Nixon & Madhusudhan⧫—Nixon and Madhusudhan (2020)
PETRA •▴—Lothringer and Barman (2020)
petitRADTRANS ‡▴https://petitradtrans.readthedocs.io/en/latest/Mollière et al. (2019)
PICASOhttps://github.com/natashabatalha/picasoRobbins-Blanch et al. (2022); Batalha et al. (2019)
plan-net ⧫https://github.com/exoml/plan-netCobb et al. (2019)
PLATON ‡https://github.com/ideasrule/platonZhang et al. (2020)
PLATON II ‡https://github.com/ideasrule/platonZhang (2020)
PolyChord ‡https://github.com/PolyChord/PolyChordLiteHandley et al. (2015a) and Handley et al. (2015b)
POSEIDON ‡https://github.com/MartianColonist/POSEIDONMacDonald and Madhusudhan (2017)
PSG †‡https://github.com/nasapsgVillanueva et al. (2018)
Pyrat-Bay ▴https://pyratbay.readthedocs.io/en/latest/Cubillos and Blecic (2021)
Pytmosph3Rhttps://pypi.org/project/pytmosph3r/Caldas et al. (2019) and Falco et al. (2022)
p-winds▴https://github.com/ladsantos/p-windsDos Santos et al. (2022)
REDFOX—Scheucher et al. (2020)
rfast▴https://github.com/hablabx/rfastRobinson and Salvador (2023)
SCARLET ‡▴—Benneke (2015)
smarter‡—Lustig-Yaeger et al. (2022)
species‡•▴https://github.com/tomasstolker/speciesStolker et al. (2020)
Tauhttps://cpc.cs.qub.ac.uk/summaries/AEPN_v1_0.htmlHollis et al. (2013)
TauREx 2.6 ‡▴https://github.com/ucl-exoplanets/TauREx_publicWaldmann et al. (2015b) and Waldmann et al. (2015a)
TauREx 3.1 ‡https://taurex3-public.readthedocs.io/en/latest/Al-Refaie et al. (2021)
ThERESA▴—Challener and Rauscher (2022)
tierra ▴https://github.com/disruptiveplanets/tierraNiraula et al. (2022)
TRIDENT—MacDonald and Lewis (2022)
Vasist et al.⧫—Vasist et al. (2023)
VI-retrieval⧫—Yip et al. (2022)

Some radiative transfer and inversion codes used in the (exo) planetary community. Symbols: OE algorithm (†), nested sampling (‡), MCMC method (▴), Grid search (•), and ML approaches (⧫).

Retrieval codes can use either parametric models or self-consistent equilibrium models to estimate the composition and pressure-temperature (P-T) profiles from spectral data. Parametric models do not make any assumptions about thermochemical and radiative-convective equilibrium, using instead parametric forms for the P-T profile and composition. Self-consistent models compute profiles based on assumptions of the atmosphere’s physical and chemical properties and processes, with varying levels of complexity from 1-D atmospheres to full 3-D general circulation models. We do not cover 3-D general circulation codes specifically in this paper, they are complex and couple many processes together in a three-dimensional time-marching calculation. For a discussion of the principles of atmospheric retrievals of exoplanets see Gandhi and Madhusudhan (2017). When calculating a synthetic atmospheric spectrum, lines are read from atomic and molecular databases -databases differ in completeness and accuracies-, and opacities are calculated via diverse approaches (Rengel, 2022).

Some RT models used for Solar System planets and exoplanets have their roots in Earth codes. There are several RT codes used in the Earth atmospheric community but they are just listed here: 4A/OP [Scott (1974); Scott and Chedin (1981)], 6S [Lee et al. (2020)], AccuRT1[Stamnes et al. (2018)]; ARMS Weng et al. (2020), BIRRA2 [Gimeno García et al. (2011)], BTRAM3 [Chapman et al. (2004)], DISORT [Stamnes et al. (1988)], Eradiate4 [Govaerts et al. (2022)], FASCODE [Smith et al. (1978); Clough et al. (1981)], FUTBOLIN [Martin-Torres and Mlynczak (2005)], GARLIC [Schreier et al. (2014)], GENLN2 [Edwards (1992)], IMAP-DOAS [Frankenberg et al. (2005)], IMLM Gloudemans et al. (2005), KCARTA56 [DeSouza-Machado et al. (2020)], LBLRTM78 [Clough et al. (2005)], LEEDR [Fiorino et al. (2014)], LinePak9 [Gordley et al. (1994)], libRadtran10 [Mayer and Kylling (2005)], MODTRAN11 [Berk et al. (1998)], MPI12 [Gropp et al. (1998)], PUMAS13 [Villanueva et al. (2015); Villanueva et al. (2022)], RFM14 [Dudhia (2017)], RTMOM [Govaerts (2006)], RTTOV15 [Saunders et al. (1999); Matricardi (2007)], SARTA1617 [Strow et al. (2003)], SARTre [Mendrok (2006)], SASKTRAN18 [Bourassa et al. (2008); Zawada et al. (2015)], SBDART19 [Ricchiazzi et al. (2002)], SCIATRAN20 [Rozanov et al. (2005); Rozanov et al. (2014)], SICOR21 [Borsdorff et al. (2017); Borsdorff et al. (2018)], SKIRT22 [Baes et al. (2003)], SMART-G23 [Ramon et al. (2019)], TOMRAD [Dave (1964)], VDISORT [Lin et al. (2022)], VLIDORT/LIDORT24 [Spurr and Christi (2019)], WFM-DOAS [Buchwitz et al. (2004); Buchwitz et al. (2005)] as well as models by Hartogh (1989), Tinetti et al. (2006a), Tinetti et al. (2006b) and Robinson et al. (2011).

3 Retrieval or parameter fitting or estimation techniques

The objective of an optimization algorithm is to extensively and efficiently sample a high-dimensional parameter space to find the best solution space given the data. The retrieval or parameter fitting or estimation techniques commonly used are Optimal Estimation (OE) algorithm (†), nested sampling (‡), Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) method (▴), Grid search (•), and more recently, data-driven Machine Learning (ML) approaches (⧫). OE is popular in the Solar System community and assumes Gaussian statistics. It is fast and efficient and applicable to exoplanets under some specific conditions (e.g., Rengel et al., 2008; Hartogh et al., 2010; Lee et al., 2011; Line et al., 2012; Shulyak et al., 2019; Rengel et al., 2022; Villanueva et al., 2022). Grid search is simple and computationally cheap, but it can be inefficient (e.g., Madhusudhan & Seager, 2009). MCMC provides a better parameter exploration of the parameter space but with limitations in calculating the model evidence for model comparison and can be computationally expensive (e.g., Benneke and Seager, 2012; Madhusudhan et al., 2014; Waldmann et al., 2015b; Blecic, 2016; Cubillos, 2016; Evans et al., 2017; Wakeford et al., 2017; Lacy and Burrows, 2020). Nested sampling algorithm facilitates efficient parameter space exploration and calculation of model evidence (e.g., Benneke and Seager, 2013; Waldmann et al., 2015a; Gandhi and Madhusudhan, 2017; Pinhas et al., 2018; Brogi and Line, 2019; Fisher and Heng, 2019; Mollière et al., 2019; Min et al., 2020; Seidel et al., 2020; Shulyak et al., 2020). ML algorithms can be computationally efficient, but they require large amounts of training data and can be sensitive to biases in the training set (e.g., Waldmann, 2016; Marquez-Neila et al., 2018; Soboczenski et al., 2018; Zingales and Waldmann, 2018; Cobb et al., 2019; Fisher et al., 2020; Hayes et al., 2020; Nixon and Madhusudhan, 2020). An example of an application of the forward model and retrieval technique is provided in Figure 1.

FIGURE 1

4 Verification and validation of RT and retrieval codes

The retrieval problem is a challenging one due to its ill-posed and ill-conditioned nature. This means that even a small change in measurements can result in a significant deviation in the estimated model, making the inverse solution computation extremely unstable (e.g., Ih and Kempton, 2021). Currently, each retrieval code has its unique method for computing opacities and input models, lacking community standards. Furthermore, models continue to become more complex and data quality improves, retrieval codes face increasingly complex and degenerate problems (e.g., Welbanks and Madhusudhan, 2019).

Verification and validation of planetary retrieval codes is an important aspect. Verification can be readily accomplished using synthetic measurements and code inter-comparison. Inter-model comparisons of forward and retrieval suites have already been underway, with notable studies by Clarmann et al., 2003; Baudino et al., 2017; Schreier et al., 2018; Barstow et al., 2020; Barstow et al., 2022). Validation is challenging due to the lack of reference “truth” data (e.g., in situ measurements). Thus, for an assessment of exoplanet atmospheric remote sensing, data dedicated to Solar System planets like Earth, Mars and Venus is an ideal test case. To our knowledge, this kind of data have been rarely used to demonstrate the capabilities of exoplanet atmospheric studies. Observing planetary transits in our own Solar System, for example, can serve as an invaluable benchmark and can provide crucial information for future exoplanet characterizations (e.g., Ehrenreich et al., 2011; Ehrenreich et al., 2012; Montañés-Rodríguez et al., 2015; López-Puertas et al., 2018; Schreier et al., 2018).

Results from inter-comparison show that small differences in the forward model setup can lead to noticeable differences in the retrieval outcome (Barstow et al., 2020). These efforts are crucial for improving the field and providing a clearer understanding of the sources of variability and their impact on the results. Such comparisons provide a roadmap for future advancements and refinements in modelling, enabling us to compare theoretical predictions with observations. They also offer an opportunity to identify any remaining problems, leading to the improvement of existing codes and the development of more reliable and consistent codes. The continued pursuit of inter-model comparisons will drive the field forward towards a better understanding of the retrieval problem. Furthermore, the inherent similarities in methods was investigated (Line et al., 2013), and there is now considerable work to understand and quantify the role of different modelling choices affecting accuracy and precision on constraints (Barstow et al., 2020).

5 Final remarks

Our current understanding of planetary atmospheres is limited by model completeness and robustness. Forward modelling and spectral retrieval is the leading technique for interpretation of spectra and is employed by various teams using a variety of forward models and parameter estimation algorithms. Numerous codes are available and continue been developed. The code employed which contain the complexity of models should be chosen with care depending on the specific questions whose answer is sought and on the nature of the data at hand (considering spectral coverage and region, resolution, precision, signal-to-noise ratio, etc.). The efficiency of these codes is a critical issue, but beyond the scope of this paper.

The study of RT in planetary atmospheres is a rapidly developing field, with numerous advances being made in both the understanding of the RT process and in the development of RT codes. With continued research and development including the improving of observational capabilities, it is likely that even more sophisticated RT codes and inversion algorithms will be developed in the future, enabling us to better understand the diversity of planetary systems beyond our own and the mechanisms shaping their atmospheres.

Statements

Author contributions

MR wrote the first draft of the manuscript. All authors contributed to the article and approved the submitted version.

Funding

Authors acknowledge the support by the DFG priority program SPP 1992 “Exploring the Diversity of Extrasolar Planets” (DFG PR 36 24602/41).

Acknowledgments

This research has made use of NASA’s Astrophysics Data System Bibliographic Services.

Conflict of interest

The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.

Publisher’s note

All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.

References

  • 1

    Al-RefaieA. F.ChangeatQ.WaldmannI. P.TinettiG. (2021). TauREx 3: A fast, dynamic, and extendable framework for retrievals. Astrophys. J.917, 37. 10.3847/1538-4357/ac0252

  • 2

    BaesM.DaviesJ. I.DejongheH.SabatiniS.RobertsS.EvansR.et al (2003). Radiative transfer in disc galaxies – III. the observed kinematics of dusty disc galaxies. Mon. Notices R. Astronomical Soc.343, 1081–1094. 10.1046/j.1365-8711.2003.06770.x

  • 3

    BarstowJ. K.ChangeatQ.ChubbK. L.CubillosP. E.EdwardsB.MacDonaldR. J.et al (2022). A retrieval challenge exercise for the ariel mission. Exp. Astron.53, 447–471. 10.1007/s10686-021-09821-w

  • 4

    BarstowJ. K.ChangeatQ.GarlandR.LineM. R.RocchettoM.WaldmannI. P. (2020). A comparison of exoplanet spectroscopic retrieval tools. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc.493, 4884–4909. 10.1093/mnras/staa548

  • 5

    BarstowJ. K.HengK. (2020). Outstanding challenges of exoplanet atmospheric retrievals. Outst. Challenges Exopl. Atmos. Retrievals216, 82. 10.1007/s11214-020-00666-x

  • 6

    BatalhaN. E.MarleyM. S.LewisN. K.FortneyJ. J. (2019). Exoplanet reflected-light spectroscopy with picaso. Astrophysical J.878, 70. 10.3847/1538-4357/ab1b51

  • 7

    BaudinoJ.-L.MollièreP.VenotO.TremblinP.BézardB.LagageP.-O. (2017). Toward the analysis ofJWSTExoplanet spectra: Identifying troublesome model parameters. Identifying Troubl. Model. Param.850, 150. 10.3847/1538-4357/aa95be

  • 8

    BaudinoJ. L.BézardB.BoccalettiA.BonnefoyM.LagrangeA. M.GalicherR. (2015). Interpreting the photometry and spectroscopy of directly imaged planets: a new atmospheric model applied to β Pictoris b and SPHERE observations, 582, A83. 10.1051/0004-6361/201526332

  • 9

    BennekeB.SeagerS. (2012). Atmospheric retrieval for super-earths: Uniquely constraining the atmospheric composition with transmission spectroscopy. Astrophys. J.753, 100. 10.1088/0004-637X/753/2/100

  • 10

    BennekeB.SeagerS. (2013). How to distinguish between cloudy mini-neptunes and water/volatile-dominated super-earths. Astrophys. J.778, 153. 10.1088/0004-637X/778/2/153

  • 11

    BennekeB. (2015). Strict upper limits on the carbon-to-oxygen ratios of eight hot jupiters from self-consistent atmospheric retrieval. arXiv e-prints , arXiv:1504.07655.

  • 12

    BerkA.BernsteinL.AndersonG.AcharyaP.RobertsonD.ChetwyndJ.et al (1998). Modtran cloud and multiple scattering upgrades with application to aviris. Remote Sens. Environ.65, 367–375. 10.1016/S0034-4257(98)00045-5

  • 13

    BlecicJ. (2016). Observations, thermochemical calculations, and modeling of exoplanetary atmospheres. arXiv e-prints , arXiv:1604.02692.

  • 14

    BorsdorffT.Aan de BrughJ.HuH.AbenI.HasekampO.LandgrafJ. (2018). Measuring carbon monoxide with tropomi: First results and a comparison with ecmwf-ifs analysis data. Geophys. Res. Lett.45, 2826–2832. 10.1002/2018GL077045

  • 15

    BorsdorffT.aan de BrughJ.HuH.NédélecP.AbenI.LandgrafJ. (2017). Carbon monoxide column retrieval for clear-sky and cloudy atmospheres: A full-mission data set from sciamachy 2.3µm reflectance measurements. Atmos. Meas. Tech.10, 1769–1782. 10.5194/amt-10-1769-2017

  • 16

    BourassaA.DegensteinD.LlewellynE. (2008). Sasktran: A spherical geometry radiative transfer code for efficient estimation of limb scattered sunlight. J. Quantitative Spectrosc. Radiat. Transf.109, 52–73. 10.1016/j.jqsrt.2007.07.007

  • 17

    BrogiM.LineM. R. (2019). Retrieving temperatures and abundances of exoplanet atmospheres with high-resolution cross-correlation spectroscopy. Astronomical J.157, 114. 10.3847/1538-3881/aaffd3

  • 18

    BuchwitzM.de BeekR.BramstedtK.NoëlS.BovensmannH.BurrowsJ. P. (2004). Global carbon monoxide as retrieved from SCIAMACHY by WFM-DOAS. Atmos. Chem. Phys.4, 1945–1960. 10.5194/acp-4-1945-2004

  • 19

    BuchwitzM.de BeekR.NoëlS.BurrowsJ. P.BovensmannH.BremerH.et al (2005). Carbon monoxide, methane and carbon dioxide columns retrieved from sciamachy by wfm-doas: Year 2003 initial data set. Atmos. Chem. Phys.5, 3313–3329. 10.5194/acp-5-3313-2005

  • 20

    BuehlerS. A.MendrokJ.ErikssonP.PerrinA.LarssonR.LemkeO. (2018). ARTS, the Atmospheric Radiative Transfer Simulator - version 2.2, the planetary toolbox edition. Geosci. Model. Dev.11, 1537–1556. 10.5194/gmd-11-1537-2018

  • 21

    BurninghamB.MarleyM. S.LineM. R.LupuR.VisscherC.MorleyC. V.et al (2017). Retrieval of atmospheric properties of cloudy L dwarfs. Mon. Notices R. Astronomical Soc.470, 1177–1197. 10.1093/mnras/stx1246

  • 22

    CaldasA.LeconteJ.SelsisF.WaldmannI. P.BordéP.RocchettoM.et al (2019). Effects of a fully 3d atmospheric structure on exoplanet transmission spectra: Retrieval biases due to day–night temperature gradients. Astronomy Astrophysics623, A161. 10.1051/0004-6361/201834384

  • 23

    Carrión-GonzálezO.García MuñozA.CabreraJ.CsizmadiaSz.SantosN. C.RauerH. (2020). Directly imaged exoplanets in reflected starlight: The importance of knowing the planet radius. A&A640, A136. 10.1051/0004-6361/202038101

  • 24

    ChallenerR. C.RauscherE. (2022). Theresa: Three-dimensional eclipse mapping with application to synthetic jwst data. Astronomical J.163, 117. 10.3847/1538-3881/ac4885

  • 25

    ChangeatQ.Al-RefaieA.MugnaiL. V.EdwardsB.WaldmannI. P.PascaleE.et al (2020). Alfnoor: A retrieval simulation of the ariel target list. Astronomical J.160, 80. 10.3847/1538-3881/ab9a53

  • 26

    ChapmanI. M.NaylorD. A.PhillipsR. R. (2004). Correlation of atmospheric opacity measurements by SCUBA and an infrared radiometer. Mon. Notices R. Astronomical Soc.354, 621–628. 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2004.08223.x

  • 27

    ClarmannT.HöpfnerM.FunkeB.López-PuertasM.DudhiaA.JayV.et al (2003). Modelling of atmospheric mid-infrared radiative transfer: The amil2da algorithm intercomparison experiment. J. Quantitative Spectrosc. Radiat. Transf.78, 381–407. 10.1016/S0022-4073(02)00262-5

  • 28

    CloughS. A.KneizysF. X.RothmanL. S.GalleryW. O. (1981). “Atmospheric spectral transmittance and radiance: FASCOD1 B,”. Atmospheric transmission. Editor FanR. W. (Washington, DC: International Society for Optics and Photonics), 0277, 152–167. 10.1117/12.931914

  • 29

    CloughS.ShephardM.MlawerE.DelamereJ.IaconoM.Cady-PereiraK.et al (2005). Atmospheric radiative transfer modeling: A summary of the aer codes. J. Quantitative Spectrosc. Radiat. Transf.91, 233–244. 10.1016/j.jqsrt.2004.05.058

  • 30

    CobbA. D.HimesM. D.SoboczenskiF.ZorzanS.O’BeirneM. D.BaydinA. G.et al (2019). An ensemble of bayesian neural networks for exoplanetary atmospheric retrieval. Astronomical J.158, 33. 10.3847/1538-3881/ab2390

  • 31

    CubillosP. E.BlecicJ. (2021). The PYRAT BAY framework for exoplanet atmospheric modelling: A population study of hubble/WFC3 transmission spectra. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc.505, 2675–2702. 10.1093/mnras/stab1405

  • 32

    CubillosP. E. (2016). Characterizing exoplanet atmospheres: From light-curve observations to radiative-transfer modeling. arXiv e-prints, arXiv:1604.01320. 10.48550/arXiv.1604.01320

  • 33

    DamianoM.HuR. (2020). ExoReL: A bayesian inverse retrieval framework for exoplanetary reflected light spectra. Astronomical J.159, 175. 10.3847/1538-3881/ab79a5

  • 34

    DaveJ. V. (1964). Meaning of successive iteration of the auxiliary equation in the theory of radiative transfer. Astrophysical J.140, 1292. 10.1086/148024

  • 35

    de WitJ.SeagerS. (2013). Constraining exoplanet mass from transmission spectroscopy. Science342, 1473–1477. 10.1126/science.1245450

  • 36

    DeSouza-MachadoS.StrowL. L.MottelerH.HannonS. (2020). kcarta: a fast pseudo line-by-line radiative transfer algorithm with analytic jacobians, fluxes, nonlocal thermodynamic equilibrium, and scattering for the infrared. Atmos. Meas. Tech.13, 323–339. 10.5194/amt-13-323-2020

  • 37

    Dos SantosL. A.VidottoA. A.VissapragadaS.AlamM. K.AllartR.BourrierV.et al (2022). p-winds: An open-source python code to model planetary outflows and upper atmospheres. A&A659, A62. 10.1051/0004-6361/202142038

  • 38

    DudhiaA. (2017). The reference forward model (rfm). J. Quantitative Spectrosc. Radiat. Transf.186, 243–253. 10.1016/j.jqsrt.2016.06.018

  • 39

    EdwardsD. P. (1992). GENLN2: A general line-by-line atmospheric transmittance and radiance model. Version 3.0: Description and users guide.

  • 40

    EhrenreichD.TinettiG.des EtangsA. L.Vidal-MadjarA.SelsisF. (2006). The transmission spectrum of earth-size transiting planets. Astronomy Astrophysics448, 379–393. 10.1051/0004-6361:20053861

  • 41

    EhrenreichD.Vidal-MadjarA.WidemannT.GronoG.TangaP.BarthelemyM.et al (2011). VizieR online data catalog: Transmission spectrum of Venus (Ehrenreich+, 2012). VizieR Online Data Catalog , J/A+A/537/L2.

  • 42

    EhrenreichD.Vidal-MadjarA.WidemannT.GronoffG.TangaP.BarthélemyM.et al (2012). Transmission spectrum of Venus as a transiting exoplanet, 537, L2. 10.1051/0004-6361/201118400

  • 43

    EspinozaN.RackhamB. V.JordánA.ApaiD.López-MoralesM.OsipD. J.et al (2018). Access: A featureless optical transmission spectrum for WASP-19b from magellan/IMACS. Mon. Notices R. Astronomical Soc.482, 2065–2087. 10.1093/mnras/sty2691

  • 44

    EvansT. M.SingD. K.KatariaT.GoyalJ.NikolovN.WakefordH. R.et al (2017). An ultrahot gas-giant exoplanet with a stratosphere548, 58–61. 10.1038/nature23266

  • 45

    FalcoA.ZingalesT.PlurielW.LeconteJ. (2022). Toward a multidimensional analysis of transmission spectroscopy. Astronomy Astrophysics658, A41. 10.1051/0004-6361/202141940

  • 46

    FiorinoS. T.RandallR. M.ViaM. F.BurleyJ. L. (2014). Validation of a uv-to-rf high-spectral-resolution atmospheric boundary layer characterization tool. J. Appl. Meteorology Climatol.53, 136–156. 10.1175/JAMC-D-13-036.1

  • 47

    FisherC.HengK. (2019). How much information does the sodium doublet encode? Retrieval analysis of non-lte sodium lines at low and high spectral resolutions. Astrophysical J.881, 25. 10.3847/1538-4357/ab29e8

  • 48

    FisherC.HoeijmakersH. J.KitzmannD.Márquez-NeilaP.GrimmS. L.SznitmanR.et al (2020). Interpreting high-resolution spectroscopy of exoplanets using cross-correlations and supervised machine learning. Astronomical J.159, 192. 10.3847/1538-3881/ab7a92

  • 49

    FortneyJ. J.MarleyM. S.LoddersK.SaumonD.FreedmanR. (2005). Comparative planetary atmospheres: Models of TrES-1 and HD 209458b. Astrophysical J.627, L69–L72. 10.1086/431952

  • 50

    FortneyJ. J.ShabramM.ShowmanA. P.LianY.FreedmanR. S.MarleyM. S.et al (2010). Transmission spectra of three-dimensional hot jupiter model atmospheres. Astrophysical J.709, 1396–1406. 10.1088/0004-637x/709/2/1396

  • 51

    FrankenbergC.PlattU.WagnerT. (2005). Retrieval of co from sciamachy onboard envisat: Detection of strongly polluted areas and seasonal patterns in global co abundances. Atmos. Chem. Phys.5, 1639–1644. 10.5194/acp-5-1639-2005

  • 52

    GandhiS.MadhusudhanN. (2017). Retrieval of exoplanet emission spectra with HyDRA. Mon. Notices R. Astronomical Soc.474, 271–288. 10.1093/mnras/stx2748

  • 53

    GibsonN. P.MerrittS.NugrohoS. K.CubillosP. E.de MooijE. J. W.Mikal-EvansT.et al (2020). Detection of Fei in the atmosphere of the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-121b, and a new likelihood-based approach for Doppler-resolved spectroscopy. Mon. Notices R. Astronomical Soc.493, 2215–2228. 10.1093/mnras/staa228

  • 54

    Gimeno GarcíaS.SchreierF.LichtenbergG.SlijkhuisS. (2011). Near infrared nadir retrieval of vertical column densities: Methodology and application to sciamachy. Atmos. Meas. Tech.4, 2633–2657. 10.5194/amt-4-2633-2011

  • 55

    GloudemansA. M. S.SchrijverH.KleipoolQ.van den BroekM. M. P.StraumeA. G.LichtenbergG.et al (2005). The impact of sciamachy near-infrared instrument calibration on ch4 and co total columns. Atmos. Chem. Phys.5, 2369–2383. 10.5194/acp-5-2369-2005

  • 56

    GordleyL. L.MarshallB. T.Allen ChuD. (1994). Linepak: Algorithms for modeling spectral transmittance and radiance. J. Quantitative Spectrosc. Radiat. Transf.52, 563–580. 10.1016/0022-4073(94)90025-6

  • 57

    GovaertsY. M. (2006). Rtmom v0b.10 user’s manual.

  • 58

    GovaertsY.NolletY.LeroyV. (2022). Radiative transfer model comparison with satellite observations over ceos calibration site Libya-4. Atmosphere13, 1759. 10.3390/atmos13111759

  • 59

    GroppW.Huss-LedermanS.LumsdaineA.LuskE.NitzbergB.SaphirW.et al (1998). MPI - The Complete Reference, 2. The MIT Press.

  • 60

    HandleyW. J.HobsonM. P.LasenbyA. N. (2015a). polychord: nested sampling for cosmology. Mon. Notices R. Astronomical Soc. Lett.450, L61–L65. 10.1093/mnrasl/slv047

  • 61

    HandleyW. J.HobsonM. P.LasenbyA. N. (2015b). polychord: next-generation nested sampling. Mon. Notices R. Astronomical Soc.453, 4385–4399. 10.1093/mnras/stv1911

  • 62

    HartoghP.BłeckaM. I.JarchowC.SagawaH.LellouchE.de Val-BorroM.et al (2010). First results on Martian carbon monoxide fromHerschel/HIFI observations. Herschel/HIFI Obs.521, L48. 10.1051/0004-6361/201015159

  • 63

    HartoghP. (1989). Chirptransformations-Spektrometer Fur die passive Millimeterwellenradiometrie: Messung der 142 GHz Emissionslinie des atmospharischen Ozons. Ph.D. thesis. Göttingen, Germany: Georg-August-Universität Göttingen.

  • 64

    HayesJ. J. C.KerinsE.AwiphanS.McDonaldI.MorganJ. S.ChuanraksasatP.et al (2020). Optimizing exoplanet atmosphere retrieval using unsupervised machine-learning classification. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc.494, 4492–4508. 10.1093/mnras/staa978

  • 65

    HimesM. D.HarringtonJ.CobbA. D.BaydinA. G.SoboczenskiF.O’BeirneM. D.et al (2022). Accurate machine-learning atmospheric retrieval via a neural-network surrogate model for radiative transfer. Planet. Sci. J.3, 91. 10.3847/PSJ/abe3fd

  • 66

    HoepfnerM.StillerG. P.KuntzM.von ClarmannT.EchleG.FunkeB.et al (1998). Karlsruhe optimized and precise radiative transfer algorithm: II. Interface to retrieval applications. Interface Retr. Appl.3501, 186–195. 10.1117/12.317753

  • 67

    HollisM.TessenyiM.TinettiG. (2013). tau: A 1d radiative transfer code for transmission spectroscopy of extrasolar planet atmospheres. Comput. Phys. Commun.184, 2351–2361. 10.1016/j.cpc.2013.05.011

  • 68

    HoweA. R.BurrowsA.DemingD. (2017). An information-theoretic approach to optimize jwst observations and retrievals of transiting exoplanet atmospheres. Astrophysical J.835, 96. 10.3847/1538-4357/835/1/96

  • 69

    HoweA. R.McElwainM. W.MandellA. M. (2022). Gj 229b: Solving the puzzle of the first known t dwarf with the apollo retrieval code. Astrophysical J.935, 107. 10.3847/1538-4357/ac5590

  • 70

    IhJ.KemptonE. M.-R. (2021). Understanding the effects of systematics in exoplanetary atmospheric retrievals. Astronomical J.162, 237. 10.3847/1538-3881/ac173b

  • 71

    IrwinP. G. J.TeanbyN. A.de KokR.FletcherL. N.HowettC. J. A.TsangC. C. C.et al (2008). The NEMESIS planetary atmosphere radiative transfer and retrieval tool. J. Quant. Spectrosc. Radiat. Transf.109, 1136–1150. 10.1016/j.jqsrt.2007.11.006

  • 72

    JarchowC. (1998). Bestimmung atmosphärischer wasserdampf-und ozone profile mittels bodengebundener millimeterwellen-fernerkundung.

  • 73

    JohnsenT. K.MarleyM. S.GulickV. C. (2020). A multilayer perceptron for obtaining quick parameter estimations of cool exoplanets from geometric albedo spectra. Publ. Astronomical Soc. Pac.132, 044502. 10.1088/1538-3873/ab740d

  • 74

    KawaharaH.KawashimaY.MasudaK.CrossfieldI. J. M.PannierE.van den BekeromD. (2022). Autodifferentiable spectrum model for high-dispersion characterization of exoplanets and Brown dwarfs. Astrophysical J. Suppl. Ser.258, 31. 10.3847/1538-4365/ac3b4d

  • 75

    KitzmannD.HengK.OreshenkoM.GrimmS. L.ApaiD.BowlerB. P.et al (2020). Helios-r2: A new bayesian, open-source retrieval model for Brown dwarfs and exoplanet atmospheres. Astrophysical J.890, 174. 10.3847/1538-4357/ab6d71

  • 76

    LacyB. I.BurrowsA. (2020). JWST transit spectra. i. exploring potential biases and opportunities in retrievals of tidally locked hot jupiters with clouds and hazes. Astrophysical J.905, 131. 10.3847/1538-4357/abc01c

  • 77

    LavieB.MendonçaJ. M.MordasiniC.MalikM.BonnefoyM.DemoryB.-O.et al (2017). HELIOS–RETRIEVAL:An open-source, nested sampling atmospheric retrieval code; application to the HR 8799 exoplanets and inferred constraints for planet formation. Astronomical J.154, 91. 10.3847/1538-3881/aa7ed8

  • 78

    LeeE. K. H.WardenierJ. P.PrinothB.ParmentierV.GrimmS. L.BaeyensR.et al (2022). 3D radiative transfer for exoplanet atmospheres. gCMCRT: A GPU-accelerated mcrt code. gCMCRT A GPU-accelerated MCRT Code929, 180. 10.3847/1538-4357/ac61d6

  • 79

    LeeJ.-M.FletcherL. N.IrwinP. G. J. (2011). Optimal estimation retrievals of the atmospheric structure and composition of HD 189733b from secondary eclipse spectroscopy. Mon. Notices R. Astronomical Soc.420, 170–182. 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2011.20013.x

  • 80

    LeeK.-S.LeeC. S.SeoM.ChoiS.SeongN.-H.JinD.et al (2020). Improvements of 6s look-up-table based surface reflectance employing minimum curvature surface method. Asia-Pacific J. Atmos. Sci.56, 235–248. 10.1007/s13143-019-00164-3

  • 81

    LellouchE.GurwellM.ButlerB.FouchetT.LavvasP.StrobelD.et al (2017). Detection of CO and HCN in pluto’s atmosphere with ALMA. Icarus286, 289–307. 10.1016/j.icarus.2016.10.013

  • 82

    LiC.LeT.ZhangX.YungY. L. (2018). A high-performance atmospheric radiation package: With applications to the radiative energy budgets of giant planets. J. Quantitative Spectrosc. Radiat. Transf.217, 353–362. 10.1016/j.jqsrt.2018.06.002

  • 83

    LinZ.StamnesS.LiW.HuY.LaszloI.TsayS.-C.et al (2022). Polarized radiative transfer simulations: A tutorial review and upgrades of the vector discrete ordinate radiative transfer computational tool. Front. Remote Sens.3. 10.3389/frsen.2022.880768

  • 84

    LineM. R.WolfA. S.ZhangX.KnutsonH.KammerJ. A.EllisonE.et al (2013). A systematic retrieval analysis of secondary eclipse spectra. I. A Comp. Atmos. Retr. Tech.775, 137. 10.1088/0004-637X/775/2/137

  • 85

    LineM. R.ZhangX.VasishtG.NatrajV.ChenP.YungY. L. (2012). Information content of exoplanetary transit spectra: AN initial look. Astrophysical J.749, 93. 10.1088/0004-637x/749/1/93

  • 86

    López-PuertasM.Montañés-RodríguezP.PalléE.HöpfnerM.Sánchez-LópezA.García-ComasM.et al (2018). Aerosols and water ice in jupiter’s stratosphere from UV-nir ground-based observations. Astron. J.156, 169. 10.3847/1538-3881/aadcef

  • 87

    LothringerJ. D.BarmanT. S. (2020). The PHOENIX exoplanet retrieval algorithm and using H− opacity as a probe in ultrahot jupiters. Astronomical J.159, 289. 10.3847/1538-3881/ab8d33

  • 88

    LupuR. E.MarleyM. S.LewisN.LineM.TraubW. A.ZahnleK. (2016). Developing atmospheric retrieval methods for direct imaging spectroscopy of gas giants in reflected light. i. methane abundances and basic cloud properties. Astronomical J.152, 217. 10.3847/0004-6256/152/6/217

  • 89

    Lustig-YaegerJ.SotzenK. S.StevensonK. B.LugerR.MayE. M.MayorgaL. C.et al (2022). Hierarchical bayesian atmospheric retrieval modeling for population studies of exoplanet atmospheres: A case study on the habitable zone. Astronomical J.163, 140. 10.3847/1538-3881/ac5034

  • 90

    MacDonaldR. J.BatalhaN. E. (2023). A catalog of exoplanet atmospheric retrieval codes. Res. Notes AAS7, 54. 10.3847/2515-5172/acc46a

  • 91

    MacDonaldR. J.LewisN. K. (2022). Trident: A rapid 3d radiative-transfer model for exoplanet transmission spectra. Astrophysical J.929, 20. 10.3847/1538-4357/ac47fe

  • 92

    MacDonaldR. J.MadhusudhanN. (2017). HD 209458b in new light: Evidence of nitrogen chemistry, patchy clouds and sub-solar water. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc.469, 1979–1996. 10.1093/mnras/stx804

  • 93

    MadhusudhanN. (2018). Atmospheric retrieval of exoplanets. Cham: Springer International Publishing, 1–30. 10.1007/978-3-319-30648-3_104-1

  • 94

    MadhusudhanN.CrouzetN.McCulloughP. R.DemingD.HedgesC. (2014). H2O abundances in the atmospheres of three hot jupiters, 791–L9. 10.1088/2041-8205/791/1/L9

  • 95

    MadhusudhanN.HarringtonJ.StevensonK. B.NymeyerS.CampoC. J.WheatleyP. J.et al (2011). A high C/O ratio and weak thermal inversion in the atmosphere of exoplanet WASP-12b. 469, 64–67. 10.1038/nature09602

  • 96

    MadhusudhanN.SeagerS. (2009). A temperature and abundance retrieval method for exoplanet atmospheres, 707, 24–39. 10.1088/0004-637X/707/1/24

  • 97

    MadhusudhanN.SeagerS. (2010). On the inference of thermal inversions in hot jupiter atmospheres. Astrophys. J.725, 261–274. 10.1088/0004-637X/725/1/261

  • 98

    MarleyM. S.McKayC. P. (1999). Thermal structure of uranus’ atmosphere. Icarus138, 268–286. 10.1006/icar.1998.6071

  • 99

    Marquez-NeilaP.FisherC.SznitmanR.HengK. (2018). Supervised machine learning for analysing spectra of exoplanetary atmospheres. 10.48550/ARXIV.1806.03944

  • 100

    Martin-TorresF. J.MlynczakM. G. (2005). FUTBOLIN (full transfer by ordinary LINe-by-line methods): A new radiative transfer code for atmospheric calculations in the visible and infrared 2005, A21A–A05.

  • 101

    MartínezF. A.MinM.KampI.PalmerP. I. (2022). Convolutional neural networks as an alternative to bayesian retrievals for interpreting exoplanet transmission spectra. Astron. &amp Astrophys.662, A108. 10.1051/0004-6361/202142976

  • 102

    MatricardiM. (2007). An inter-comparison of line-by-line radiative transfer models. 10.21957/b3amji4k

  • 103

    MayerB.KyllingA. (2005). Technical note: The libradtran software package for radiative transfer calculations - description and examples of use. Atmos. Chem. Phys.5, 1855–1877. 10.5194/acp-5-1855-2005

  • 104

    MendrokJ. (2006). The SARTre model for radiative transfer in spherical atmospheres and its application to the derivation of cirrus cloud properties. Berlin: Ph.D. thesis, Freie Univ.

  • 105

    MinM.OrmelC. W.ChubbK.HellingC.KawashimaY. (2020). The ARCiS framework for exoplanet atmospheres. Model. philosophy Retr.642, A28. 10.1051/0004-6361/201937377

  • 106

    MollièreP.WardenierJ. P.van BoekelR.HenningTh.MolaverdikhaniK.SnellenI. A. G. (2019). Petitradtrans - a python radiative transfer package for exoplanet characterization and retrieval. A&A627, A67. 10.1051/0004-6361/201935470

  • 107

    Montañés-RodríguezP.González-MerinoB.PalléE.López-PuertasM.García-MelendoE. (2015). Jupiter as an Exoplanet: UV to NIR Transmission Spectrum Reveals Hazes, a Na Layer, and Possibly Stratospheric H2O-ice Clouds, 801, L8. 10.1088/2041-8205/801/1/L8

  • 108

    MorenoR.MartenA.BiraudY.BézardB.LellouchE.PaubertG.et al (2001). Jovian stratospheric temperature during the two months following the impacts of comet Shoemaker–Levy 9Shoemaker-Levy 949, 473–486. 10.1016/S0032-0633(00)00139-2

  • 109

    MorenoR. (1998). Observations millimetriques et submillimetriques des planetes geantes. Etude de jupiter apres la chute de la comete sl9. Ph.D. thesis. Thèse de doctorat dirigée par Marten, André Terre, océan, espace Paris 6 1998.

  • 110

    NiraulaP.de WitJ.GordonI. E.HargreavesR. J.Sousa-SilvaC.KochanovR. V. (2022). The impending opacity challenge in exoplanet atmospheric characterization. Nat. Astron.6, 1287–1295. 10.1038/s41550-022-01773-1

  • 111

    NixonM. C.MadhusudhanN. (2020). Assessment of supervised machine learning for atmospheric retrieval of exoplanets. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc.496, 269–281. 10.1093/mnras/staa1150

  • 112

    NixonM. C.MadhusudhanN. (2022). Aura-3D: A three-dimensional atmospheric retrieval framework for exoplanet transmission spectra. Astrophys. J.935, 73. 10.3847/1538-4357/ac7c09

  • 113

    OreshenkoM.LavieB.GrimmS. L.TsaiS.-M.MalikM.DemoryB.-O.et al (2017). Retrieval Analysis of the Emission Spectrum of WASP-12b: Sensitivity of Outcomes to Prior Assumptions and Implications for Formation History, 847, L3. 10.3847/2041-8213/aa8acf

  • 114

    PietteA. A. A.MadhusudhanN.MandellA. M. (2021). HyDRo: Atmospheric retrieval of rocky exoplanets in thermal emission. Mon. Notices R. Astronomical Soc.511, 2565–2584. 10.1093/mnras/stab3612

  • 115

    PinhasA.RackhamB. V.MadhusudhanN.ApaiD. (2018). Retrieval of planetary and stellar properties in transmission spectroscopy with Aura. Mon. Notices R. Astronomical Soc.480, 5314–5331. 10.1093/mnras/sty2209

  • 116

    RamonD.SteinmetzF.JolivetD.CompiègneM.FrouinR. (2019). Modeling polarized radiative transfer in the ocean-atmosphere system with the gpu-accelerated smart-g Monte Carlo code. J. Quantitative Spectrosc. Radiat. Transf.222-223, 89–107. 10.1016/j.jqsrt.2018.10.017

  • 117

    RengelM. (2022). About the atomic and molecular databases in the planetary community. 10.5281/zenodo.7040446

  • 118

    RengelM.HartoghP.JarchowC. (2008). Mesospheric vertical thermal structure and winds on Venus from HHSMT CO spectral-line observations. HHSMT Co. spectral-line Obs.56, 1368–1384. 10.1016/j.pss.2008.07.004

  • 119

    RengelM.ShulyakD.HartoghP.SagawaH.MorenoR.JarchowC.et al (2022). Ground-based HCN submillimetre measurements in titan’s atmosphere: An intercomparison with herschel observations, 658, A88. 10.1051/0004-6361/202141422

  • 120

    RicchiazziP.YangS.GautierC. (2002). Sbdart: A practical tool for plane-parallel radiative transfer in the earth’s atmosphere.

  • 121

    Robbins-BlanchN.KatariaT.BatalhaN. E.AdamsD. J. (2022). Cloudy and cloud-free thermal phase curves with picaso: Applications to wasp-43b. Astrophysical J.930, 93. 10.3847/1538-4357/ac658c

  • 122

    RobinsonT. D.MeadowsV. S.CrispD.DemingD.A’HearnM. F.CharbonneauD.et al (2011). Earth as an extrasolar planet: Earth model validation using epoxi Earth observations. Astrobiology11, 393–408. 10.1089/ast.2011.0642

  • 123

    RobinsonT. D.SalvadorA. (2023). Exploring and validating exoplanet atmospheric retrievals with solar system analog observations. Planet. Sci. J.4, 10. 10.3847/PSJ/acac9a

  • 124

    RozanovA.RozanovV.BuchwitzM.KokhanovskyA.BurrowsJ. (2005). Sciatran 2.0 – A new radiative transfer model for geophysical applications in the 175–2400nm spectral region. Adv. Space Res.36, 1015–1019. 10.1016/j.asr.2005.03.012

  • 125

    RozanovV.RozanovA.KokhanovskyA.BurrowsJ. (2014). Radiative transfer through terrestrial atmosphere and ocean: Software package sciatran. J. Quantitative Spectrosc. Radiat. Transf.133, 13–71. 10.1016/j.jqsrt.2013.07.004

  • 126

    SaundersR.MatricardiM.BrunelP. (1999). An improved fast radiative transfer model for assimilation of satellite radiance observations. Q. J. R. Meteorological Soc.125, 1407–1425. 10.1002/qj.1999.49712555615

  • 127

    ScheucherM.WunderlichF.GrenfellJ. L.GodoltM.SchreierF.KappelD.et al (2020). Consistently simulating a wide range of atmospheric scenarios for K2-18b with a flexible radiative transfer module. Astrophys. J.898, 44. 10.3847/1538-4357/ab9084

  • 128

    SchreierF.Gimeno GarcíaS.HedeltP.HessM.MendrokJ.VasquezM.et al (2014). Garlic — A general purpose atmospheric radiative transfer line-by-line infrared-microwave code: Implementation and evaluation. J. Quantitative Spectrosc. Radiat. Transf.137, 29–50. 10.1016/j.jqsrt.2013.11.018

  • 129

    SchreierF.MilzM.BuehlerS. A.von ClarmannT. (2018). Intercomparison of three microwave/infrared high resolution line-by-line radiative transfer codes. J. Quantitative Spectrosc. Radiat. Transf.211, 64–77. 10.1016/j.jqsrt.2018.02.032

  • 130

    ScottN. A. (1974). A direct method of computation of the transmission function of an inhomogeneous gaseous medium - I: Description of the method. J. Quant. Spectrosc. Radiat. Transf.14, 691–704. 10.1016/0022-4073(74)90116-2

  • 131

    ScottN. A.ChedinA. (1981). A fast line-by line method for atmospheric absorption computations: The automatized atmospheric absorption atlas. J. Appl. Meteorology20, 802–812. 10.1175/1520-0450(1981)020⟨0802:AFLBLM⟩2.0.CO;2

  • 132

    SeidelJ. V.EhrenreichD.PinoL.BourrierV.LavieB.AllartR.et al (2020). Wind of change: Retrieving exoplanet atmospheric winds from high-resolution spectroscopy. A&A633, A86. 10.1051/0004-6361/201936892

  • 133

    ShulyakD.LaraL. M.RengelM.NèmecN. E. (2020). Stellar impact on disequilibrium chemistry and observed spectra of hot Jupiter atmospheres, 639, A48. 10.1051/0004-6361/201937210

  • 134

    ShulyakD.RengelM.ReinersA.SeemannU.YanF. (2019). Remote sensing of exoplanetary atmospheres with ground-based high-resolution near-infrared spectroscopy, 629, A109. 10.1051/0004-6361/201935691

  • 135

    SmithH. J. P.DubeD. J.GardnerM. E.CloughS. A.KneizysF. X. (1978). Fascode: Fast Atmospheric Signature CODE (spectral transmittance and radiance).

  • 136

    SoboczenskiF.HimesM. D.O’BeirneM. D.ZorzanS.Gunes BaydinA.CobbA. D.et al (2018). Bayesian deep learning for exoplanet atmospheric retrieval. arXiv e-prints , arXiv:1811.03390.

  • 137

    SpeagleJ. S. (2020). dynesty: a dynamic nested sampling package for estimating Bayesian posteriors and evidences. Mon. Notices R. Astronomical Soc.493, 3132–3158. 10.1093/mnras/staa278

  • 138

    SpurrR.ChristiM. (2019). The LIDORT and VLIDORT linearized scalar and vector discrete ordinate radiative transfer models: Updates in the last 10 years. Cham: Springer International Publishing, 1–62. 10.1007/978-3-030-03445-0_1

  • 139

    StamnesK.HamreB.StamnesS.ChenN.FanY.LiW.et al (2018). Progress in forward-inverse modeling based on radiative transfer tools for coupled atmosphere-snow/ice-ocean systems: A review and description of the accurt model. Appl. Sci.8, 2682. 10.3390/app8122682

  • 140

    StamnesK.TsayS. C.WiscombeW. J.LaszloI. (2000). Disort: A general-purpose fortran program for discrete ordinate-method radiative transfer in scattering and emitting layered media: Documentation of methodology. Greenbelt, United States: Nasa report, NASA.

  • 141

    StamnesK.TsayS.WiscombeW.JayaweeraK. (1988). Numerically stable algorithm for discrete-ordinate-method radiative transfer in multiple scattering and emitting layered media. Appl. Opt.27, 2502–2509. 10.1364/ao.27.002502

  • 142

    StillerG. P.HoepfnerM.KuntzM.von ClarmannT.EchleG.FischerH.et al (1998). Karlsruhe optimized and precise radiative transfer algorithm. Part I: Requirements, justification, and model error estimation. Justif. Model. error Estim.3501, 257–268. 10.1117/12.317754

  • 143

    StillerG. P. (2000). The Karlsruhe optimized and precise radiative transfer algorithm. Karlsruhe, Germany: Tech. rep. LK 01; Wissenschaftliche Berichte, FZKA-6487 (Dezember 2000). 10.5445/IR/270048971.22.02.11

  • 144

    StillerG. P.von ClarmannT.FunkeB.GlatthorN.HaseF.HöpfnerM.et al (2002). Sensitivity of trace gas abundances retrievals from infrared limb emission spectra to simplifying approximations in radiative transfer modelling. J. Quantitative Spectrosc. Radiat. Transf.72, 249–280. 10.1016/S0022-4073(01)00123-6

  • 145

    StolkerT.QuanzS. P.TodorovK. O.KühnJ.MollièreP.MeyerM. R.et al (2020). Miracles: Atmospheric characterization of directly imaged planets and substellar companions at 4–5 μm: I. Photometric analysis of β pic b, HIP 65426 b, PZ tel B, and HD 206893 B. A&A635, A182. 10.1051/0004-6361/201937159

  • 146

    StrowL.HannonS.De Souza-MachadoS.MottelerH.TobinD. (2003). An overview of the airs radiative transfer model. IEEE Trans. Geoscience Remote Sens.41, 303–313. 10.1109/TGRS.2002.808244

  • 147

    SwainM. R.LineM. R.DerooP. (2014). On the detection of molecules in the atmosphere of hd 189733b using hst nicmos transmission spectroscopy. Astrophysical J.784, 133. 10.1088/0004-637X/784/2/133

  • 148

    TinettiG.MeadowsV. S.CrispD.FongW.FishbeinE.TurnbullM.et al (2006a). Detectability of planetary characteristics in disk-averaged spectra. I: The earth model. Astrobiology6, 34–47. 10.1089/ast.2006.6.34

  • 149

    TinettiG.MeadowsV. S.CrispD.KiangN.KahnB. H.VelusamyT.et al (2006b). Detectability of planetary characteristics in disk-averaged spectra II: Synthetic spectra and light-curves of earth. Astrobiology6, 881–900. 10.1089/ast.2006.6.881

  • 150

    TremblinP.AmundsenD. S.MourierP.BaraffeI.ChabrierG.DrummondB.et al (2015). Fingering convection and cloudless models for cool Brown dwarf atmospheres, 804, L17. 10.1088/2041-8205/804/1/L17

  • 151

    UrbanJ.BaronP.LautiéN.SchneiderN.DassasK.RicaudP.et al (2004). Moliere (v5): A versatile forward- and inversion model for the millimeter and sub-millimeter wavelength range. J. Quantitative Spectrosc. Radiat. Transf.83, 529–554. 10.1016/S0022-4073(03)00104-3

  • 152

    VandaeleA.KruglanskiM.MaziereD. (2006b). Modeling and retrieval of atmospheric spectra using asimut. Atmos. Sci. Conf.628, 71.

  • 153

    VandaeleA.KruglanskiM.De MazièreM. (2006a). Modeling and retrieval of atmospheric spectra using asimut. European Space Agency. (Special Publication) ESA SP.

  • 154

    VasistM.RozetF.AbsilO.MollièreP.NasedkinE.LouppeG. (2023). Neural posterior estimation for exoplanetary atmospheric retrieval.

  • 155

    VillanuevaG. L.LiuzziG.FaggiS.ProtopapaS.KofmanV.FauchezT.et al (2022). Fundamentals of the planetary spectrum generator.

  • 156

    VillanuevaG. L.MummaM. J.NovakR. E.KäuflH. U.HartoghP.EncrenazT.et al (2015). Strong water isotopic anomalies in the martian atmosphere: Probing current and ancient reservoirs. Science348, 218–221. 10.1126/science.aaa3630

  • 157

    VillanuevaG. L.SmithM. D.ProtopapaS.FaggiS.MandellA. M. (2018). Planetary Spectrum Generator: An accurate online radiative transfer suite for atmospheres, comets, small bodies and exoplanets. small bodies Exopl.217, 86–104. 10.1016/j.jqsrt.2018.05.023

  • 158

    WakefordH. R.SingD. K.KatariaT.DemingD.NikolovN.LopezE. D.et al (2017). HAT-P-26b: A neptune-mass exoplanet with a well-constrained heavy element abundance. Science356, 628–631. 10.1126/science.aah4668

  • 159

    WaldmannI. P. (2016). Dreaming Atmos.820, 107. 10.3847/0004-637X/820/2/107

  • 160

    WaldmannI. P.RocchettoM.TinettiG.BartonE. J.YurchenkoS. N.TennysonJ. (2015a). Tau-REx II: Retrieval of emission spectra. Astrophys. J.813, 13. 10.1088/0004-637X/813/1/13

  • 161

    WaldmannI. P.TinettiG.RocchettoM.BartonE. J.YurchenkoS. N.TennysonJ. (2015b). Tau-REx I: A next generation retrieval code for exoplanetary atmospheres. Astrophys. J.802, 107. 10.1088/0004-637X/802/2/107

  • 162

    WelbanksL.MadhusudhanN. (2021). Aurora: A generalized retrieval framework for exoplanetary transmission spectra. Astrophysical J.913, 114. 10.3847/1538-4357/abee94

  • 163

    WelbanksL.MadhusudhanN. (2019). On degeneracies in retrievals of exoplanetary transmission spectra. Astronomical J.157, 206. 10.3847/1538-3881/ab14de

  • 164

    WengF.YuX.DuanY.YangJ.WangJ. (2020). Advanced radiative transfer modeling system (ARMS): A new-generation satellite observation operator developed for numerical weather prediction and remote sensing applications. Adv. Atmos. Sci.37, 131–136. 10.1007/s00376-019-9170-2

  • 165

    YipK. H.ChangeatQ.Al-RefaieA.WaldmannI. (2022). To sample or not to sample: Retrieving exoplanetary spectra with variational inference and normalising flows.

  • 166

    ZawadaD. J.DueckS. R.RiegerL. A.BourassaA. E.LloydN. D.DegensteinD. A. (2015). High-resolution and Monte Carlo additions to the sasktran radiative transfer model. Atmos. Meas. Tech.8, 2609–2623. 10.5194/amt-8-2609-2015

  • 167

    ZhangM.ChachanY.KemptonE. M. R.KnutsonH. A.ChangW. H. (2020). Platon II: New capabilities and a comprehensive retrieval on HD 189733b transit and eclipse data. Transit Eclipse Data899, 27. 10.3847/1538-4357/aba1e6

  • 168

    ZhangX. (2020). Atmospheric regimes and trends on exoplanets and Brown dwarfs. Res. Astronomy Astrophysics20, 099. 10.1088/1674-4527/20/7/99

  • 169

    ZingalesT.WaldmannI. P. (2018). ExoGAN: Retrieving exoplanetary atmospheres using deep convolutional generative adversarial networks. Astronomical J.156, 268. 10.3847/1538-3881/aae77c

Summary

Keywords

atmospheres, radiative transfer, planets and satellites, retrieval, exoplanets

Citation

Rengel M and Adamczewski J (2023) Radiative transfer and inversion codes for characterizing planetary atmospheres: an overview. Front. Astron. Space Sci. 10:1176740. doi: 10.3389/fspas.2023.1176740

Received

28 February 2023

Accepted

15 May 2023

Published

30 May 2023

Volume

10 - 2023

Edited by

Josep M. Trigo-Rodríguez, Spanish National Research Council (CSIC), Spain

Reviewed by

Knut Stamnes, Stevens Institute of Technology, United States

Updates

Copyright

*Correspondence: M. Rengel,

Disclaimer

All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.

Outline

Figures

Cite article

Copy to clipboard


Export citation file


Share article

Article metrics