Pediatric massage in conjunction with other traditional Chinese medicine therapies for tic disorder in children: systematic review and network meta-analysis

Background: Pediatric massage (PM) belongs to traditional Chinese medicine treatment (TCM) and is an alternative therapy for tic disorders (TD). This systematic review and network meta-analysis (NMA) was undertaken to evaluate the efficacy and safety of PM, the effectiveness of PM in conjunction with other TCM therapies for TD and to provide an evidence-based foundation for the clinical selection of the TD treatment regimens relating to traditional Chinese medicine.

Methods: Eight databases were systematically searched from their inception to June, 2024 for randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of PM and its combination with other TCM therapies for TD. Two researchers screened the studies and extracted the data according to our inclusion criteria, and the bias assessment tool from the Cochrane Handbook was used to evaluate the quality of the included studies. Stata 17.0 software was used to perform NMA, and the efficacy and safety of PM and its combination with other TCM therapies were compared and ranked.

Results: A total of 24 RCTs, covering 1,657 children with TD, were included in this NMA. There were 9 intervention measures, including PM, Western medicine (WM), PM + Chinese herbal medicine (CHM), PM + manual acupuncture (MA), PM + auricular acupuncture (AA), PM + Qigong therapy (QT), PM + cupping therapy (CT), PM + scraping therapy (ST), and PM + moxibustion (Mox). PM + CHM may be most effective at improving the total effective rate and decreasing YGTSS motor tics score and YGTSS vocal tics score; PM + MA may have the best performance in reducing the YGTSS total score; and simple PM may be the best at reducing the adverse reaction rate. The GRADE assessment showed that the overall response rate and the total YGTSS score were rated as low or very low quality due to the limitations of the original study, and other measures were rated as moderate quality. Therefore, these results need to be interpreted with caution and validated further.

Conclusion: PM and its combination with other TCM therapies are effective and safe interventions for TD in children. More specifically, PM + CHM may be the best choice for improving clinical effectiveness and reducing YGTSS motor tics score and YGTSS vocal tics score, while PM + MA may be the most effective for decreasing YGTSS total score. However, due to the limitations of this study, these conclusions still need to be validated using additional high-quality RCTs.

Systematic Review Registration: https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/PROSPERO/view/CRD42024553846, PROSPERO CRD42024553846.

1 Introduction

Tic disorder (TD) is a chronic neurological disorder that originates in childhood or adolescence, with an incidence rate as high as 0.9% in children (1). The core clinical symptoms of TD in children are repeated motor or vocal tics (2). Eighty-eight percent of TD patients have at least one other psychiatric symptom, such as attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, obsessive-compulsive disorder, or depression. These symptoms can seriously affect their quality of life and social function (3). The etiology of TD is unclear and may be related to the imbalance of neurotransmitters in the cortical-striatal-thalamo-cortical circuit (CSTC) (4). Commonly used conventional Western medicine (WM) therapy mainly includes dopamine receptor antagonists and noradrenergic agents (5). Although these drugs have been shown to be effective in the treatment of TD in children, there may be adverse effects such as drowsiness, fatigue, and extrapyramidal syndrome (EPS) that may reduce patient compliance and increase the risk of recurrence (6). Psychological therapies such as comprehensive behavioral intervention for tics (CBIT) are also effective approaches for managing TD. However, the availability of these treatments is often limited due to the insufficient number of trained practitioners (7). Therefore, safer, more effective, and more accessible therapies for TD in children are necessary.

Complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) for TD has received increasing attention (8). Pediatric massage (PM) is a recognized CAM therapy that is widely used in the treatment of TD in children and is guided by the traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) theory and modern medicine principles, using specific methods to stimulate acupoints and meridians to treat diseases (9). PM has the characteristics of being drug-free, simple to perform, highly safe, and easily accepted by children (10). PM has also been included in the diagnosis and treatment guidelines for TD (11). Furthermore in TCM, PM is considered to be the preferred external treatment for preschool children with TD (12).

In recent years, most randomized controlled trials (RCTs) evaluating PM for TD in children have involved the combination of PM and other TCM therapies, such as Chinese herbal medicine (CHM), manual acupuncture (MA), auricular acupuncture (AA), Qigong therapy (QT), cupping therapy (CT), scraping therapy (ST), and moxibustion (Mox). Previous studies have emphasized the efficacy of PM for TD in children but have only looked at the comparison between PM and WM or CHM (13). The optimal combination of TCM therapies to complement PM thus remains unknown. To some extent, this creates difficulties in selecting TD treatment regimens.

Network meta-analysis (NMA) can combine direct and indirect comparisons to evaluate and rank the efficacy and safety of multiple interventions, which has unique advantages over traditional pairwise meta-analysis (14). Therefore, NMA is particularly valuable when multiple PM combination therapies exist and direct comparative data are limited. By combining direct and indirect evidence through the NMA method, this study addresses the research gap that cannot be filled by traditional pairwise meta-analyses, in order to provide a more comprehensive evidence-based basis for selecting the best TD treatment strategy.

2 Methods

Our NMA adhered to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-analysis (PRISMA) statement (15). The protocol for our NMA was registered with the International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews (PROSPERO), number CRD42024553846 (https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/PROSPERO/view/CRD42024553846).

2.1 Eligibility criteria

2.1.1 Types of studies

Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) investigating PM or its combination with other TCM therapies for TD in children were considered.

2.1.2 Types of participants

Children (younger than 18 years) with TD diagnosed by any validated criteria (e.g., International Classification of Diseases, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, or Chinese Classification and Diagnostic Criteria of Mental Disorders) were included.

2.1.3 Types of interventions

The experimental group was administered PM, or PM combined with another TCM therapy such as Chinese herbal medicine (CHM), manual acupuncture (MA), auricular acupuncture (AA), Qigong therapy (QT), cupping therapy (CT), scraping therapy (ST), and moxibustion (Mox). The control group was treated with any of the described interventions compared to each other or to western medicine (WM).

2.1.4 Types of outcomes

The main outcome considered was the total effective rate. The secondary measure was the mean change in the Yale Global Tic Severity Scale (YGTSS) total score, YGTSS motor tics score, and YGTSS vocal tics score from the baseline. The safety outcome considered was the adverse reaction rate.

2.2 Exclusion criteria

The following criteria were applied to exclude studies from the analysis: studies with unclear descriptions of interventions, studies with incomplete data or without full text, studies without the outcomes specified in our NMA, and studies involving PM combined with more than one type of other TCM therapies.

2.2.1 Search strategy

The search strategy for our NMA was conducted according to the PRISMA 2020 statement. Two researchers (Jiayue Liu and Hanyu Zhang) systematically searched eight databases from their inception to June, 2024, including PubMed, Cochrane Library, Web of Science, Chinese National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI), Chinese Biomedical Literature Database (CBM), VIP Database, and Wanfang Database. There were no regional or language restrictions. The following terms were searched: Tourette syndrome, Tic disorder, Tourette disease, multiple tics-coprolalia syndrome, pediatric massage, pediatric tuina, tuina, massage, manual therapy, randomized controlled trials, chiropractic, and RCT. Table 1 shows the search strategy of PubMed specifically, and the retrieval modes of other databases were similar.

Table 1

Table 1. The search strategy of pubMed.

2.2.2 Search selection

Two researchers (Jiayue Liu and Hanyu Zhang) independently screened the studies according to the above eligibility and exclusion criteria. First, the retrieved studies were imported into NoteExpress software (16). After removing duplicate studies, preliminary screening was conducted using the titles and abstracts. Subsequently, full texts with titles and abstracts that met the criteria were carefully reviewed to determine their final inclusion. Any differences between the two researchers were resolved by discussion or consultation with a third researcher (Mengqian Lu).

2.3 Data extraction

Two researchers (Jiayue Liu and Hanyu Zhang) extracted the data independently using a standard information extraction table. Study characteristics were recorded, including the author, publication year, sample size, age, genders, and disease course. Intervention measures were also extracted, including those in the experimental and control groups and the treatment course. In addition, outcomes such as the total effective rate, YGTSS total score, YGTSS motor tics score, YGTSS vocal tics score, and adverse reaction rate were also extracted. Again any differences between the two researchers were resolved by discussion or consultation with a third researcher (Jinping Chen).

2.4 Risk of bias and quality assessment

Two researchers (Jiawei Sun and Yingqi Zhang) used the risk of bias assessment tool from the Cochrane Handbook to evaluate the quality of the included studies. The contents included random sequence generation, allocation concealment, blinding of subjects and researchers, blinding of outcome assessors, completeness of outcome data, and selective reporting of results, as well as other biases. The evaluation results included three levels: low risk, high risk, and unclear risk. Revman 5.4 software was used to make the risk of bias graph (17). The modified Jadad scale was used to assess the quality of the included studies, including the generation of randomized sequence, allocation concealment, blinding and withdrawal. With a total score of 7 on the modified Jadad scale, RCTs with a score between 1 and 3 were considered low quality, whereas studies with a score between 4 and 7 were considered high quality (18). In case of a disagreement, the two researchers negotiated or discussed with a third researcher to reach a resolution (Mengqian Lu).

2.5 Statistical analysis

Data synthesis was performed using Stata 17.0 software (19). A random effect model was used for all indicators. Count data were described by relative risk (RR) and 95% confidence interval (95% CI), and measurement data were described by weighted mean difference (MD) and 95% CI. The difference between the comparison groups was considered statistically significant if the 95% CI of the MD did not include 0, or the 95% CI of RR did not include 1. Additionally, the point division method was used to test the inconsistency between the direct and indirect comparison results (20). If P > 0.05, the consistency between them was deemed to be acceptable, and the consistency model was used for fitting. Otherwise, there was deemed to be an obvious inconsistency, and the inconsistency model was used for fitting. Subgroup analysis was used to explore the sources of inconsistency.

Probability ranking was performed using the surface under the cumulative ranking curve (SUCRA). SUCRA was expressed as a percentage, and the higher the percentage value, the better the efficacy or safety of the intervention. Sensitivity analysis was performed to evaluate the stability of the NMA results. If more than 10 studies were included, the risk of publication bias and the small sample effect were evaluated by funnel plot (21). If the image was roughly symmetric and most of the scatter points were distributed in the inverted funnel plot, it indicated that the results had less risk of publication bias and a small sample effect.

2.6 GRADE evaluation

The Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) guideline development tool was used to evaluate the quality of evidence (22). The factors that may reduce the quality of evidence include limitations in the included studies, imprecision, inconsistency, indirect evidence, and publication bias. The quality of evidence was evaluated as high, medium, low, and very low.

3 Results

3.1 Selection and identification of studies

We initially retrieved 759 studies in eight databases based on the above search strategy. A total of 358 duplicate studies were excluded, and after reviewing abstracts and titles, 37 studies were obtained. Finally, a total of 24 RCTs were included by carefully reading the full texts (Figure 1).

Figure 1

Figure 1. Studies search results and flow chart.

3.2 Included study characteristics

A total of 24 RCTs (23–46) were included in this NMA, including 1,657 children with TD. All RCTs were conducted in China and published between 2008 and 2023. There were 9 intervention measures: pediatric massage (PM), western medicine (WM), pediatric massage (PM) + Chinese herbal medicine (CHM), pediatric massage (PM) + manual acupuncture (MA), pediatric massage (PM) + auricular acupuncture (AA), pediatric massage (PM) + Qigong therapy (QT), pediatric massage (PM) + cupping therapy (CT), pediatric massage (PM) + scraping therapy (ST), and pediatric massage (PM) + moxibustion (Mox). The characteristics of the included studies are detailed in Table 2.

Table 2

Table 2. Characteristics of the included studies.

3.3 Methodological quality assessment

The results of the methodological quality assessment are shown in Figures 2, 3. Twelve studies (23–25, 28–31, 33, 37, 40, 44, 46) used the random number table method for randomization, and one study¹⁸ used the lottery method. Eight studies (27, 32, 36, 38, 39, 41, 43, 45) referred only to “randomization” without describing the method. Three studies (35, 42) used randomization methods that were considered high risk. One study (29) was rated as low risk for blinding of outcome assessment. One study (29) used the envelope method for allocation concealment, and the remaining studies did not mention specific allocation concealment methods. All the studies were considered low risk for data completeness and selective reporting. Five studies (23, 29, 30, 44, 46) were identified as high quality and the remaining (24–28, 31–43, 45) as low quality based on the modified Jadad score.

Figure 2

Figure 2. Bias risk assessment.

Figure 3

Figure 3. Risk of bias summary.

3.4 Network plots

The evidence relationships of the included studies are shown in Figure 4. In the network plots, the blue circles represent the number of studies involving the intervention, and the lines represent the number of studies that directly compare the two interventions. Regarding the total effective rate, 24 studies (23–46) were included in the NMA, involving 1,657 patients and 9 interventions. Regarding the YGTSS total score, 12 studies (23, 25, 26, 28–30, 32, 33, 35, 38, 42, 44) were amalgamated for the NMA, involving 843 patients and 7 interventions. Six studies (22, 25, 29, 32, 42, 44) reported YGTSS motor tic scores and vocal tic scores, including 416 patients and four interventions. With respect to the adverse reaction rate, 9 studies (24, 30, 32, 34, 39, 42–44, 46) were amalgamated for the NMA that covered 587 patients and 5 interventions.

Figure 4

Figure 4. Network plots. Network plots for the total effective rate (A), the YGTSS total score (B), the YGTSS motor tics score (C), the YGTSS vocal tics score (D), and adverse reaction rate (E) Blue circles represent the number of patients who received the therapy, and lines represent the presence of direct comparative evidence between the two therapies. WM, western medicine; PM, pediatric massage; CHM, Chinese herbal medicine; MA, manual acupuncture; AA, auricular acupuncture; QT, qigong therapy; CT, cupping therapy; ST, scraping therapy; Mox, moxibustion.

3.5 Inconsistency test

The results of our inconsistency test indicated that in terms of total clinical effective rate, there was inconsistency between the direct and indirect comparison results of the closed-loop “western medicine (WM)—pediatric massage (PM)- pediatric massage (PM) + manual acupuncture (MA)” (P = 0.038). Therefore, this index was fitted using the inconsistent model, and the indirect comparison results need to be interpreted carefully. The results of the direct and indirect comparison of the YGTSS total score were consistent (P > 0.05), and the consistency model was used to fit. Since the evidence relationship for the YGTSS motor tics score, YGTSS vocal tics score, and adverse reaction rate did not form a closed loop, there was no need for an inconsistency test.

3.6 NMA results

3.6.1 Total effective rate

Compared to western medicine (WM), pediatric massage (PM), pediatric massage (PM) + auricular acupuncture (AA), pediatric massage (PM) + Qigong therapy (QT), pediatric massage (PM) + moxibustion (Mox), and pediatric massage (PM) + scraping therapy (ST) each significantly increased the total effective rate. Moreover, compared to simple pediatric massage (PM), pediatric massage (PM) + Chinese herbal medicine (CHM) and pediatric massage (PM) + manual acupuncture (MA) significantly increased the total effective rate. In addition, compared to pediatric massage (PM) + scraping therapy (ST), pediatric massage (PM) + Chinese herbal medicine (CHM) had greater effects on the total effective rate. The 95%CI of the above RR values did not include 1, so the differences were considered to be statistically significant. There were no statistically significant differences between any other pairwise comparisons (Table 3; Figure 5A).

Table 3

Table 3. Results of the NMA for the total effective rate.

Figure 5

Figure 5. Forest plots for pairwise comparisons. Forest plots for pairwise comparisons of the total effective rate (A), the YGTSS total score (B), the YGTSS motor tics score (C), the YGTSS vocal tics score (D), and adverse reaction rate (E).

According to the SUCRA values (Figure 6A), the probability of interventions in descending order was as follows: pediatric massage (PM) + Chinese herbal medicine (CHM), pediatric massage (PM) + cupping therapy (CT), pediatric massage (PM) + manual acupuncture (MA), pediatric massage (PM) + Qigong therapy (QT), pediatric massage (PM) + auricular acupuncture (AA), pediatric massage (PM) + moxibustion (Mox), pediatric massage (PM) + scraping therapy (ST), simple pediatric massage (PM), western medicine (WM).

Figure 6

Figure 6. SUCRA values. SUCRA values for the total effective rate (A), the YGTSS total score (B), the YGTSS motor tics score (C), the YGTSS vocal tics score (D), and adverse reaction rate (E) The higher the SUCRA value, the better the efficacy or safety of the intervention.

3.6.2 YGTSS total score

Compared to western medicine (WM) and simple pediatric massage (PM), pediatric massage (PM) + Chinese herbal medicine (CHM) and pediatric massage (PM) + manual acupuncture (MA) significantly decreased the YGTSS total score. The 95% CI of MD values did not include 0, so the above differences were judged to be statistically significant. There were no statistically significant differences between any other pairwise comparisons (Table 4; Figure 5B).

Table 4

Table 4. Results of the NMA for the YGTSS total score.

According to the SUCRA values (Figure 6B), the probability of decreasing the YGTSS total score in descending order was as follows: pediatric massage (PM) + manual acupuncture (MA), pediatric massage (PM) + Chinese herbal medicine (CHM), pediatric massage (PM) + Qigong therapy (QT), pediatric massage (PM) + scraping therapy (ST), pediatric massage (PM) + cupping therapy (CT), simple pediatric massage (PM), western medicine (WM).

3.6.3 YGTSS motor tics score

Compared to western medicine (WM), simple pediatric massage (PM), and pediatric massage (PM) + Qigong therapy (QT), pediatric massage (PM) + Chinese herbal medicine (CHM) significantly reduced the YGTSS motor tics score. The 95% CI of MD values did not include 0, so the above differences were statistically significant. There were no statistically significant differences between any other pairwise comparisons (Table 5; Figure 5C).

Table 5

Table 5. Results of the NMA for the YGTSS motor tics score.

According to the SUCRA values (Figure 6C), the probability for decreasing the YGTSS score in descending order was as follows: pediatric massage (PM) + Chinese herbal medicine (CHM), simple pediatric massage (PM), pediatric massage (PM) + Qigong therapy (QT), western medicine (WM).

3.6.4 YGTSS vocal tics score

Compared to western medicine (WM) and simple pediatric massage (PM), pediatric massage (PM) + Chinese herbal medicine (CHM) significantly decreased the YGTSS vocal tics score. The 95%CI of MD values did not include zero, so the above differences were statistically significant. There were no statistically significant differences between any other pairwise comparisons (Table 6; Figure 5D).

Table 6

Table 6. Results of the NMA for the YGTSS vocal tics score.

According to the SUCRA values (Figure 6D), the probability for decreasing the YGTSS score in descending order was as follows: pediatric massage (PM) + Chinese herbal medicine (CHM), simple pediatric massage (PM), pediatric massage (PM) + Qigong therapy (QT), western medicine (WM).

3.6.5 Adverse reaction rate

Compared to western medicine (WM), simple pediatric massage (PM) and pediatric massage (PM) + Chinese herbal medicine (CHM) significantly reduced the adverse reaction rate. Here again the 95% CI of RR values did not include 1, so the above differences were deemed to be statistically significant. Again, there were no statistically significant differences between any other pairwise comparisons (Table 7; Figure 5E). According to the SUCRA values (Figure 6E), the probability of reducing the adverse reaction rate in descending order was as follows: simple pediatric massage (PM), pediatric massage (PM) + Chinese herbal medicine (CHM), pediatric massage (PM) + Qigong therapy (QT), pediatric massage (PM) + auricular acupuncture (AA), western medicine (WM).

Table 7

Table 7. Results of the NMA for the adverse reaction rate.

Pediatric massage (PM) + auricular acupuncture (AA) may cause fatigue and lethargy, and pediatric massage (PM) + Chinese herbal medicine (CHM) may cause gastrointestinal symptoms such as nausea (24, 34, 39, 43). These effects were considered to be relatively mild and acceptable. Western medicine (WM) may lead to adverse reactions such as dizziness, somnolence, diarrhea, rash, and tachycardia (24, 30, 34, 39, 42–44, 46). No obvious adverse reactions were reported with simple pediatric massage (PM) or pediatric massage (PM) + Qigong therapy (QT) (30, 32, 43, 44, 46).

3.6.6 Evaluation of stability of results

To assess the stability of the findings, we performed sensitivity analyses (Figure 7) and recalculated core outcome measures after excluding studies at high risk of bias (24–28, 31–43, 45). Reanalysis after excluding studies with high risk of bias showed that PM + CHM was most likely to have the best clinical response rate, which was consistent with the results before exclusion (Supplementary Material 1A–C). However, the therapies that ranked first in the total YGTSS score were different from those before exclusion (Supplementary Material 1D, E). This is presumably due to the fact that the original top-ranked therapy was not included in the remaining low-bias studies. This difference in results suggests that a higher proportion of the original studies at high risk of bias may have had an effect on the stability of some outcomes.

Figure 7

Figure 7. Sensitivity analysis diagrams. Sensitivity analysis for the total effective rate (A), the YGTSS total score (B), the YGTSS motor tics score (C), the YGTSS vocal tics score (D), and adverse reaction rate (E).

3.6.7 Publication bias and small sample effect

Comparison-correction funnel plots are shown in Figure 8. The comparison-corrected funnel plot has a roughly symmetrical distribution, though some scattered points were outside the funnel plot, suggesting the possibility of moderate publication bias or small sample effects. Fewer than 10 studies reported adverse reaction rates, so the comparison-corrected funnel plot for this index was not analyzed.

Figure 8

Figure 8. Comparison-correction funnel plots. Comparison-adjusted funnel plots for the total effective rate (A) and YGTSS score (B). If the image was roughly symmetric and most of the scatter points were distributed in the inverted funnel plot, the results had less risk of publication bias and a small sample effect.

3.7 Results of GRADE evaluation

Results of GRADE evaluation are shown in Table 8. The evidence quality for the total effective rate was rated as “very low”, while the evidence quality for the YGTSS total score was rated as “low”. The evidence quality for the YGTSS vocal tic score, YGTSS motor tic score, and the adverse reaction rate was rated as “moderate”.

Table 8

Table 8. Results of GRADE evaluation.

3.8 Subgroup analysis

Since there were inconsistency in the closed-loop “WM-PM-PM + MA” of total clinical effective rate, subgroup analysis was used to explore the potential causes. Considering that the differences in treatment courses may affect the research results, two subgroups were established: treatment courses ≥2 months and treatment courses <2 months. The results are detailed in Tables 9, 10; Figures 9, 10. In the subgroup with a treatment course <2 months, compared to western medicine (WM), pediatric massage (PM) + Chinese herbal medicine (CHM), pediatric massage (PM) + auricular acupuncture (AA), pediatric massage (PM) + manual acupuncture (MA), and pediatric massage (PM) + Qigong therapy (QT) each significantly increased the total effective rate (P < 0.05). Moreover, compared to simple pediatric massage (PM), pediatric massage (PM) + Chinese herbal medicine (CHM) significantly increased the total effective rate (P < 0.05). In the subgroup with a treatment course ≥2 months, compared to western medicine (WM), simple pediatric massage (PM) and pediatric massage (PM) + Chinese herbal medicine (CHM) significantly increased the total effective rate (P < 0.05). In both subgroups, the likely best outcome in terms of total response rate was pediatric massage (PM) + Chinese herbal medicine (CHM).What's more, the results showed that there was no closed loop of evidence relationship in the subgroup of treatment duration <2 months, and there was no significant inconsistency in the closed loop of “WM-PM-PM + MA” in the subgroup of treatment duration ≥2 months (P > 0.05). It can be seen that the duration of treatment may account for the inconsistency between the direct and indirect evidence for the overall response rate.

Table 9

Table 9. Results of the subgroup analysis (treatment course <2 months) for the total effective rate.

Table 10

Table 10. Results of the subgroup analysis (treatment course ≥ 2 months) for the total effective rate.

Figure 9

Figure 9. Results of the subgroup analysis for the total effective rate. Network plots for the total effective rate in the subgroups of treatment course <2months (A) and treatment course ≥2months (C) SUCRA values for the total effective rate in the subgroups of treatment course <2months (B) and treatment course ≥2months (D) WM, western medicine; PM, pediatric massage; CHM, Chinese herbal medicine; MA, manual acupuncture; AA, auricular acupuncture; QT, qigong therapy; CT, cupping therapy; ST, scraping therapy; Mox, moxibustion.

Figure 10

Figure 10. Graphical abstract. TD, tic disorders; PM, pediatric massage; TCM, traditional Chinese medicine treatment; WM, western medicine; YGTSS, Yale global tic severity scale; RCTs, randomized controlled trials; SUCRA, surface under the cumulative ranking curve; GRADE, the grading of recommendations, assessment, development and evaluation; CHM, Chinese herbal medicine; MA, manual acupuncture.

To clarify the impact of standardized protocols on outcomes, we evaluated the standardization degree of included RCTs based on whether PM operations adhered to expert consensus, guidelines, or textbooks, and conducted subgroup analyses according to the standardization degree of PM. The results showed that 3 RCTs (29, 30, 32) had good standardization because they performed PM operations by nationally planned textbooks (47–49). The remaining RCTs (23–28, 31, 33–46) did not mention the consensus, guidelines, or textbooks followed for PM operations (Supplementary Material 2). Subgroup analysis results indicated that in the subgroup with a higher degree of PM operation standardization, PM + QT had the highest probability of achieving the best efficacy in improving the total effective rate and reducing the total YGTSS score (Supplementary Material 3A–C, Supplementary Material 4A–C). In the subgroup with a lower degree of PM operation standardization, PM + CHM had the highest possibility of being the most effective in improving the total effective rate, while PM + MA had the highest probability of ranking first in reducing the total YGTSS score (Supplementary Material 3D–F, Supplementary Material 4D–F). This suggests that the impact of the standardization of PM operation techniques on outcomes deserves attention.

4 Discussion

4.1 The efficacy and safety of PM are positive for TD in children

PM has a significant curative effect on TD in children. The results of this NMA suggest the efficacy of PM in improving the total effective rate was significantly better than WM and that its efficacy in reducing YGTSS score was equivalent to WM. According to TCM theory, the pathogenesis of TD in children is related to spleen deficiency, liver hyperactivity, phlegm and fire disturbance, and wind formation from yin deficiency (50, 51). PM programs for TD include chiropractic, abdominal massage, and acupressure (12, 31). These PM techniques can relax the meridians, regulate the viscera, and relieve the somatic symptoms of TD (52). In addition, PM has the characteristics of being peaceful and gentle, and it can be combined with language communication to soothe the emotions of children during treatment (53). Modern medical studies have shown that PM can also improve the function of the hippocampus and other related brain regions by regulating the expression of brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF), insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1), 5-hydroxytryptamine 1A receptor (5-HT1AR), and synaptophysin-1 (Syn1), which enables it to treat neuropsychiatric symptoms caused by many diseases (54, 55). A previous systematic review and meta-analysis showed that PM improved clinical efficacy and reduced the YGTSS score and TCM syndrome score (56).

PM also shows potential in terms of safety for treating children with TD. The results of this NMA suggest that the probability safety in of simple PM was ranked first, and its incidence of adverse reactions was significantly lower than that of WM. Because the physiological systems of children are sensitive, the safety of therapies is particularly important for treating those with TD. PM is a non-invasive treatment with gentle and mild manipulation, which can minimize the stimulation of children's sensitive physiological system and reduce the risk of trauma (57). In addition, As a drug-free therapy, PM can avoid drug-related toxic and side effects, meeting the needs of children for treatment safety. The above intervention characteristics of non-invasive physical stimulation make PM have unique safety characteristics suitable for children. However, it should be noted that safety data in this analysis is limited, with only 9 RCTs reporting adverse reactions. Therefore, while this study provides preliminary NMA evidence supporting the safety of PM in treating children with TD, these findings should be interpreted with caution.

4.2 PM + CHM and PM + MA may have important advantages for TD in children

PM + CHM may be the best therapy for improving the clinically effective rate of TD. This NMA found that PM + CHM had the highest probability of enhancing the total effective rate and reducing the YGTSS motor tics score and vocal tics score. In addition, PM + CHM had the second highest probability of reducing YGTSS total score, and its efficacy was significantly better than that of simple PM. CHM plays an important role in complementary and alternative medicine for treating TD. According to TCM theory, CHM can improve the overall condition of TD patients by calming the liver, quenching the wind, resolving phlegm, and invigorating the spleen (58, 59). Modern medical research has also shown that CHM can alleviate behavioral symptoms of TD by inhibiting inflammatory responses, correcting neurotransmitter imbalances, and repairing nerve damage (60, 61). PM can relieve muscle spasms and calm the mind by stimulating local acupoints, and CHM can improve visceral functions by overall regulation. The combination of PM and CHM conforms to the principle of “internal and external treatment” in TCM. The synergistic effect of these two therapies may be the reason for their better efficacy compared to simple PM.

PM + MA also performed pretty well in relieving symptoms of TD in children. Our NMA results ranked PM + MA highest in probability of reducing the YGTSS total score and ranked in the top three in enhancing total effective rate. A previous NMA has demonstrated that acupuncture plus PM has a significant effect in improving clinical efficacy and reducing motor and vocal tics of children with TD, consistent with our findings (62). MA can regulate the circulation of qi and blood in meridians and relieve muscle spasticity so as to alleviate the convulsion symptoms of children with TD (63). Additionally, acupuncture at Baihui (GV20) and Yintang (GV29) can reduce the stereotypical behavior of Tourette's syndrome (TS) mice by reducing the expression of dopamine receptors in the striatum (STR) and substantia nigra pars compact (SNpc) (64). One study has also shown that PM + MA can maintain the balance of intestinal flora through “brain-gut axis” regulation and effectively relieve neuropsychiatric symptoms such as tic, irritability, and fatigue in children with TD (65). PM + MA may have a potential synergistic effect in relaxing muscles and regulating brain function and in doing so provide a curative effect on TD.

It can be seen that PM + CHM and PM + MA have their own mechanisms and advantages in the treatment of TD. CHM can regulate the neuroendocrine immune network, and PM can stimulate local muscles and nerves (32, 66). The combination of CHM and PM can improve the body state through internal and external interaction. This may be the reason for the outstanding efficacy of PM + CHM in the comprehensive efficacy indicators such as total effective rate. MA has a regulatory effect on the nervous system, and PM can relieve muscle spasticity (67). This may be the reason why PM + MA is more targeted to improve the total score of YGTSS, a neurological function related index. The above mechanistic differences between PM + CHM and PM + MA provide an explanation for the difference in ranking.

It is important to note that although these SUCRA rankings provide a reference for comparisons of intervention efficacy and safety, the wide confidence intervals in several comparisons reflect possible uncertainty. Therefore, the ranking conclusions need to be interpreted with caution. In addition, although this NMA suggests that PM combined with other TCM therapies may have better efficacy than simple PM, there is no evidence that more added therapies necessarily lead to better efficacy. This study only involved PM combined with one other TCM therapy, and the efficacy and safety of PM combined with multiple TCM therapies still need further study. The results of this study notwithstanding, blindly increasing the number of therapies is not recommended. In addition, what remains to be explored is the efficacy mechanism of PM combined with other TCM therapies and how to make the combination work best.

It is also worth noting that the GRADE assessment showed that outcomes such as overall response rate and total YGTSS score were rated as low or very low quality due to the limitations of the original study. Although our results, which are based on existing included studies, provide a degree of robustness, they need to be interpreted with caution. Our analysis suggested that PM + CHM may perform best in improving clinical efficacy, while PM + MA may perform best in reducing the total YGTSS score, but these conclusions still need further validation. Future RCTs should focus on methodological improvements, such as strengthening the blinding and randomization design, and improving the quality of reporting, so as to provide more solid and reliable evidence for the treatment of tic disorders in children.

4.3 Strengths and limitations

Several advantages of this study deserve to be emphasized. Most importantly, to the best of our knowledge, this is the first NMA to evaluate PM and its combination with other TCM therapies in the treatment of TD in children. Although previous systematic reviews have confirmed the safety and efficacy of PM in the treatment of TD, only a pairwise comparison between simple PM and WM or CHM has ever been performed (56, 62). In the clinical treatment of TD, PM is often not the only treatment means. This study assessed the efficacy and safety of PM and PM combined with other commonly used TCM therapies such as CHM, MA, AA, QT, CT, ST, and Mox, providing a more comprehensive, evidence-based foundation for selecting TCM treatment regimens for TD.

However, some limitations should be considered when interpreting our results. (1) First, despitestrict adherence to our inclusion and exclusion criteria and rigorous application of the Cochrane risk-of-bias tool, most eligible RCTs were single-center, small samples and demonstrated low methodological quality (e.g., unclear or high risk of bias in randomization, allocation concealment and blinding), which was attributed to inherent limitations in the available literature. The results of some outcomes changed after the exclusion of studies with high risk of bias, suggesting that the quality of the included studies may affect the robustness of the results. This should be considered when interpreting our findings. Therefore, future randomized controlled trials should pay attention to improving methodological rigor, such as implementing multicenter designs and standardizing randomization schedules and allocation concealment. (2) Second, there was heterogeneity in PM protocols among the included studies, including differences in core acupoints, manipulation, pressure, frequency, duration, and course of treatment. Subgroup analysis showed that the degree of standardization of PM operations may affect the results of the study. Additionally, there were differences in the diagnostic criteria used across the included studies. Although this situation reflects the characteristics of TCM syndrome differentiation and individualized treatment, the lack of standardized protocols may increase inconsistency. Future RCTs should adopt standardized consensus-based PM protocols and diagnostic criteria to improve the comparability and stability of the evidence. (3) Third, most of the included studies lacked long-term follow-up. Only two included studies (41, 45) included a half-year follow-up, and only one study (30) reported TD recurrence rates. Due to the lack of follow-up time, the persistence and recurrence risk of PM and related TCM therapy cannot be fully evaluated, which may affect the judgment of the long-term value of the therapy in clinical decision-making. Future studies need to extend the follow-up period and systematically collect recurrence data to comprehensively evaluate the long-term efficacy and safety. (4) In addition, it should be noted that all included RCTs were conducted in China, which may cause regional bias. Regional differences in patient demographics as well as attitudes toward PM therapy may limit the generalizability of our findings to other populations. (5) Finally, only one study (44) assessed patients' adherence by number of sessions, so our NMA was unable to quantify this key factor. Since adherence is particularly important in pediatric populations, future studies should infuse an assessment of adherence. Therefore, disease course, etiology, symptoms, and other factors should be fully considered in treating TD, and individual TCM therapies should be formulated on a case-by-case basis. In the future, high-quality, multi-center, large-sample RCTs should be conducted to provide more reliable evidence.

5 Conclusion

Our study indicates that PM and PM combined with other TCM therapies are effective and safe interventions for TD in children. PM + CHM may be the preferred intervention to improve the total effective rate and reduce YGTSS motor tics score and YGTSS vocal tics score for TD in children. PM + MA performs pretty well in reducing YGTSS total score. In addition, simple PM has significant advantages in reducing adverse reaction rates. However, there are still limitations to this study, such as the unclear or high risk of bias in the randomization and blinding of many included randomized controlled trials, which may affect the robustness of these findings. These conclusions thus need to be interpreted with caution and validated by high-quality, multi-center, large-sample RCTs.

Data availability statement

The original contributions presented in the study are included in the article/Supplementary Material, further inquiries can be directed to the corresponding authors.

Author contributions

JL: Investigation, Formal analysis, Methodology, Writing – original draft, Conceptualization. HZ: Investigation, Writing – review & editing, Formal analysis. TY: Writing – review & editing, Conceptualization, Supervision. JC: Investigation, Writing – review & editing. YZ: Investigation, Writing – review & editing. JS: Writing – review & editing, Investigation. YX: Investigation, Writing – review & editing. RN: Investigation, Writing – review & editing. JY: Writing – review & editing, Investigation. HZ: Investigation, Writing – review & editing. ML: Supervision, Writing – review & editing, Conceptualization.

Funding

The author(s) declare that financial support was received for the research and/or publication of this article. This work was financially supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 82374612, No. 82474673, and No. 81873392) and the Natural Science Foundation of Beijing (No. 7192113).

Acknowledgments

The authors thank AiMi Academic Services (https://www.aimieditor.com) for English language editing and review services.

Conflict of interest

The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.

The author(s) declared that they were an editorial board member of Frontiers, at the time of submission. This had no impact on the peer review process and the final decision.

Generative AI statement

The author(s) declare that no Generative AI was used in the creation of this manuscript.

Any alternative text (alt text) provided alongside figures in this article has been generated by Frontiers with the support of artificial intelligence and reasonable efforts have been made to ensure accuracy, including review by the authors wherever possible. If you identify any issues, please contact us.

Publisher's note

All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.

Supplementary material

The Supplementary Material for this article can be found online at: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fped.2025.1609934/full#supplementary-material

Abbreviations

5-HT1AR, 5-hydroxytryptamine 1A receptor; 95% CI, 95% confidence interval; AA, auricular acupuncture; BDNF, brain-derived neurotrophic factor; CHM, Chinese herbal medicine; CNKI, Chinese national knowledge infrastructure; CAM, complementary and alternative medicine; CBIT, comprehensive behavioral intervention for tics; CSTC, cortical-striatal-thalamo-cortical circuit; CT, cupping therapy; EPS, extrapyramidal syndrome; IGF-1, insulin-like growth factor-1; MA, manual acupuncture; MD, mean difference; Mox, moxibustion; NMA, network meta-analysis; PM, pediatric massage; PRISMA, preferred reporting items for systematic review and meta-analysis; QT, qigong therapy; RCTs, randomized controlled trials; RR, relative risk; ST, scraping therapy; SUCRA, surface under the cumulative ranking curve; Syn1, synaptophysin-1; GRADE, the grading of recommendations, assessment, development and evaluation; TD, tic disorder; TS, tourette's syndrome; TCM, traditional Chinese medicine; WM, western medicine; YGTSS, Yale global tic severity scale.

References

1. Liu H, Hua H, Kang T. White matter alterations predict outcomes of comprehensive behavioral intervention for tics in children with tourette syndrome: a diffusion MRI study. J Psychiatr Res. (2024) 175:418–24. doi: 10.1016/j.jpsychires.2024.05.003

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

2. Szejko N, Robinson S, Hartmann A, Ganos C, Debes NM, Skov L, et al. European clinical guidelines for Tourette syndrome and other tic disorders-version 2.0. Part I: assessment. Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry. (2022) 31(3):383–402. doi: 10.1007/s00787-021-01842-2

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

3. Wang S, Zhang Y, Wang M, Meng F, Liu Y, Zhang J. Deep brain stimulation for tourette’s syndrome. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. (2024) 8(8):Cd015924. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD015924

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

4. Naro A, Billeri L, Colucci VP, Le Cause M, De Domenico C, Ciatto L, et al. Brain functional connectivity in chronic tic disorders and Gilles De La Tourette syndrome. Prog Neurobiol. (2020) 194:101884. doi: 10.1016/j.pneurobio.2020.101884

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

5. He F, Luo J, Huang Y, Hao Y, Sun L, Ke X, et al. Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of aripiprazole oral solution in children and adolescents with tourette’s disorder. Child Adolesc Psychiatry Ment Health. (2024) 18(1):88. doi: 10.1186/s13034-024-00764-6

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

6. Roessner V, Eichele H, Stern JS, Skov L, Rizzo R, Debes NM, et al. European clinical guidelines for tourette syndrome and other tic disorders-version 2.0. Part III: pharmacological treatment. Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry. (2022) 31(3):425–41. doi: 10.1007/s00787-021-01899-z

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

7. Andrén P, Jakubovski E, Murphy TL, Woitecki K, Tarnok Z, Zimmerman-Brenner S, et al. European clinical guidelines for tourette syndrome and other tic disorders-version 2.0. Part II: psychological interventions. Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry. (2022) 31(3):403–23. doi: 10.1007/s00787-021-01845-z

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

8. Patel H, Nguyen K, Lehman E, Mainali G, Duda L, Byler D, et al. Use of complementary and alternative medicine in children with tourette syndrome. J Child Neurol. (2020) 35(8):512–6. doi: 10.1177/0883073820913670

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

9. Chen SC, Cheng HL, Han LF, Wu GT, Zhang RY, Suen LK, et al. Parent-administered pediatric tuina for the treatment of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder symptoms: process evaluation of a pilot randomized controlled trial. Complement Ther Med. (2022) 70:102854. doi: 10.1016/j.ctim.2022.102854

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

10. Yin LJ, Cecilia SL, Wu DR, Yang JH, Helle M Lsted A, Cai JX, et al. Effect of pediatric tuina on children’s recurrent acute respiratory tract infections: a retrospective cohort study in southern China. J Tradit Chin Med. (2024) 44(03):586–94. doi: 10.19852/j.cnki.jtcm.2024.03.003

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

11. Rong P, Ma R, Han XM, Wu HJ. Guideline for TCM pediatrics clinical diagnosis and treatment·tic disorder (amendment). J Pediatr Tradit Chin Med. (2019) 15(06):1–6. doi: 10.16840/j.issn1673-4297.2019.06.01

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

12. Wang XF, Han XM, Sun KX, Jiang YH, Rong P. Expert consensus on external treatment for tic disorder in children with traditional Chinese medicine (2024). Chin Pediatr Integr Tradit West Med. (2024) 16(01):1–7. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.16743865.2024.01.001

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

13. Wu JQ, Yang FS, Wang ZT, Wang L, Tian T, Xue Z, et al. Pediatric massage therapy for treatment of tic disorders in children: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Medicine (Baltimore). (2024) 103(12):e37568. doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000037568

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

14. Cui SF, Liu L, Zhang FL. The clinical effect and safety of non-pharmacological Chinese medicine therapy in treating chronic nonspecific low back pain: a systematic review and network meta-analysis protocol. Front Pharmacol. (2025) 16:1514231. doi: 10.3389/fphar.2025.1514231

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

15. Page MJ, McKenzie JE, Bossuyt PM, Boutron I, Hoffmann TC, Mulrow CD, et al. The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. Br Med J. (2021) 372:n71. doi: 10.1136/bmj.n71

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

16. Liao X, Tian Y, Zhang Y, Bian Z, Wang P, Li P, et al. Acupuncture for functional dyspepsia: Bayesian meta-analysis. Complement Ther Med. (2024) 82:103051. doi: 10.1016/j.ctim.2024.103051

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

17. Miao Y, Luo Y, Zhao Y, Liu M, Wang H, Wu Y, et al. Effectiveness of eHealth interventions in improving medication adherence among patients with cardiovascular disease: systematic review and meta-analysis. J Med Internet Res. (2024) 26:e58013. doi: 10.2196/58013

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

18. Zhu Y, Chen J, Zhang Y, Wang X, Wang J. Immunosuppressive agents for frequently relapsing/steroid-dependent nephrotic syndrome in children: a systematic review and network meta-analysis. Front Immunol. (2024) 15:1310032. doi: 10.3389/fimmu.2024.1310032

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

19. Wang C, Qiong WU, Ping LI, Wang C, Wu Qiong, Li P, Wang Z, Luo X, Li Y, et al. Effect of traditional Chinese medicine combined with western medicine on blood lipid levels and inflammatory factors in patients with angina pectoris in coronary heart disease identified as intermingled phlegm and blood stasis syndrome: a network meta-analysis. J Tradit Chin Med. (2023) 43(4):640–9. doi: 10.19852/j.cnki.jtcm.20230506.001

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

20. van Valkenhoef G, Dias S, Ades AE. Automated generation of node-splitting models for assessment of inconsistency in network meta-analysis. Res Synth Methods. (2016) 7:80–93. doi: 10.1002/jrsm.1167

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

21. Wang Z, Xu H, Wang Z, Zhou H, Zhang L, Wang Y, et al. efficacy and safety of multiple external therapies in patients with insomnia: a systematic review and network meta-analysis. Front Neurol. (2024) 15:1297767. doi: 10.3389/fneur.2024.1297767

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

22. Guyatt G, Oxman AD, Akl EA, Kunz R, Vist G, Brozek J, et al. GRADE guidelines:1. Introduction-GRADE evidence profiles and summary of findings tables. J Clin Epidemiol. (2011) 64(4):383–94. doi: 10.1016/j.jclinepi.2010.04.026

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

23. Li J, Sheng MJ, Pan H, Xiao H, Zhang JJ. Research of Baizhu Shaoyao san dispersion plus subtraction combined with pediatric push in treatment of multiple tic syndrome in children spleen deficiency and liver hyperactivity. Chin Community Doctors. (2019) 35(35):100–1. +103. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1007-614x.2019.35.056

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

24. Zhao WX. Clinical study of auricular acupuncture combined with massage in the treatment of children with tic disorders of spleen deficiency and phlegm accumulation. J Hebei Tradit Chin Med Pharmacol. (2022) 37(02):35–7. +52. doi: 10.166370/j.cnki.13-1214/r.2022.02.015

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

25. Liu J, Tian JB, Zhao JF, Li DT, Song WF, Bao TZ. Thirty cases of transient tic disorder in children combined with atlantoaxial instability treated with integral manipulation of spine in combination with pediatric massage and cervical traction. Henan Tradit Chin Med. (2021) 41(10):1587–90. doi: 10.16370/j.cnki.13-1214/r.2022.02.015

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

26. Xu Y. Observation on treating the Tanre Dongfeng type of pediatric tic disorder with the Jiawei Huanglian Wendan decoction. Clin J Chin Med. (2019) 11(35):58–9. +62. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1674-7860.2019.35.022

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

27. Lu RQ, Bao YJ, Peng XL, Zhang HM, Wang JY. Clinical study of Jianpi Pinggan pill and Chuanfu powder combined with chiropractic therapy in the treatment of children with tourette syndrome. Hebei J Tradit Chin Med. (2011) 33(01):41–2. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1002-2619.2011.01.022

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

28. He JY, Luo HS, Zhou X, Wu T. Observation on the curative effect of invigorating spleen and extinguishing wind tuina combined with needling four suture in the treatment of spleen deficiency and liver hyperactivity type children with tic disorder. Zhejiang Clin Med J. (2020) 22(11):1576–7. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1008-7664.2020.11.013

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

29. He T. Observation on Clinical Effect of Liao’s Tuina Manipulations in Treating Children’s Transient tic Disorder. Chengdu: Chengdu University of Traditional Chinese Medicine. (2019). doi: 10.26988/d.cnki.gcdzu.2019.000076

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

30. Zou LY, Lin JC, Deng SQ, Zhou M, Wu TC, Yu GH. 32 cases of transient tic disorder in children with hyperactive liver were treated by Pinggan Xifeng-tuina. Fujian J Tradit Chin Med. (2023) 54(04):55–6. +59. doi: 10.13260/j.cnki.jfjtcm.2023.04018

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

31. Shi XH, Ying HZ, Ying HF. Clinical study on acupuncture with qingxin pinggan method combined with spine pinching therapy for children multiple tics. New Chin Med. (2021) 53(16):135–8. doi: 10.13457/j.cnki.jncm.2021.16.035

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

32. Chen YX, Shen YJ, Chen ZW, Zhang XL, Zhao Y, Sun WQ. Efficacy and safety analysis of massage combined with simple Liuzijue exercises in the treatment of patients with tic disorder. Prog Modern Biomed. (2022) 22(17):3284–8. doi: 10.13241/j.cnki.pmb.2022.17.016

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

33. Cai YH, Qian S, Chen JL, Xu L. Clinical observation on 30 cases with tourette syndrome in children treated by massage combined with Yi cupping therapy. J Pediatr Tradit Chin Med. (2019) 15(01):71–4. doi: 10.16840/j.issn1673-4297.2019.01.23

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

34. Wei J. Clinical Observation of Combining Massage Therapy with Qiangzhisan to Treat Tourette’s Syndrome. Jinan: Shandong University of Traditional Chinese Medicine (2009).

Google Scholar

35. Geng YQ. Clinical Study on Massage Combined with Scraping Therapy for Children with Multipleetic Disorder (Qi Stagnation and Fire Type). Changchun: Chang chun University of Chinese Medicine (2018).

Google Scholar

36. Sun XH. Observation on the curative effect of tuina combined with Jingshenzhispasms decoction in treating children with polytic syndrome (heart-liver fire prosperous type). Chin Pediatr Integr Tradit West Med. (2010) 2(06):554–5. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1674-3865.2010.06.036

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

37. Zeng YY, Tan ZH, Song YY. Clinical analysis of adjustment of atlantoaxial joint dislocation by external treatment in children with tic disorder. J External Ther Tradit Chin Med. (2016) 25(05):42–3. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1006-978X.2016.05.025

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

38. He JY, Zhou X, Wu T. Clinical observation of 35 cases of tic disorder in children (spleen deficiency and dampness syndrome type) treated by Xifengzhijing chiropractic tuina combined with heat-sensitive moxibustion. Zhejiang J Tradit Chin Med. (2020) 55(11):811. doi: 10.13633/j.cnki.zjtcm.2020.11.018

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

39. Du YR, Wang B. Clinical observation of modified Xiaoyao powder combined with tuina in the treatment of children with tourette syndrome. China’s Naturopath. (2016) 24(05):60–1. doi: 10.19621/j.cnki.11-3555/r.2016.05.053

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

40. Wang T, Lou R. Clinical study on 30 cases of tourette syndrome treated by pediatric tuina combined with auricular acupuncture. J External Ther Tradit Chin Med. (2020) 29(04):44–5. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1006-978X.2020.04.024

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

41. He JY, Zhan Q, Zhou X. Clinical observation on the therapeutic effect of Xifengzhijing pediatric tuina on cervicogenic tic syndrome in children. Zhejiang Clin Med J. (2015) 17(01):55–6. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1008-7664.2015.01.028

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

42. Li JX. Clinical Observation on Tuina Therapy of Purging Heart and Clearing Liver in the Treatment of Children with Tourette Syndrome (Heart and Liver Fire Type). Jinan: Shandong University of Traditional Chinese Medicine. (2023). doi: 10.27282/d.cnki.gsdzu.2023.000064

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

43. Mo MH. Observation on the curative effect of soothing liver and relieving wind, eliminating phlegm and stopping spasm in combination with chiropractic therapy for children with multiple tic syndrome. Chin J Ethnomed Ethnopharm. (2011) 20(07):93–4. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1007-8517.2011.07.075

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

44. Du CY, Jin L, Liu X, Ma R. Clinical observation of visceral acupoint massage treatment of tourette’s syndrome with syndrome of spleen deficiency and phlegm accumulation. China J Tradit Chin Med Pharm. (2018) 33(06):2707–10.

Google Scholar

45. Jiang XY. Study on the combination of acupuncture and massage in the treatment of children with tourette’s syndrome. J Sichuan Tradit Chin Med. (2009) 27(8):115–6. Available online at: https://kns.cnki.net/kcms2/article/abstract?v=VgZR0u5wRbwmSx9i0FCft-sbez9qNxKJ0Q3lE9ETG6Z3ysjvk-avvul7Giwrjb3_l2_EC6KlU352F8IDcR0ZPABhnBGFAznIp7GrmgGNi_QiMuahG9Vb-XMGIhoyiuPplP9cNM4Q5EPVTmQhbQXcdGkKYWKf73U_aY_M1BlfWGHIDtaaI0fXBA==&uniplatform=NZKPT&language=CHS

Google Scholar

46. Chen YJ, Mi JQ. Clinical observation on the treatment of transient tic disorder in children with traditional Chinese tuina. J Pediatr Tradit Chin Med. (2008) 3(04):45–7. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1673-4297.2008.04.023

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

47. Liao PD. Pediatric Massage. Beijing: People’s Medical Publishing House (2016).

Google Scholar

48. Jin YC. Shanghai Style Pediatric Massage. Shanghai: Shanghai Science and Technology Press (2010).

Google Scholar

49. Jin YC. Shanghai Style Pediatric Massage (Revised Version). Shanghai: Shanghai Science and Technology Press (2014).

Google Scholar

50. Tian X, Ou GY, Hu SP, Wang C, Han F, Gao L. Integrated network pharmacology and experimental verification to explore the molecular mechanism of Jingxin Zhidong formula for treating tic disorder. J Ethnopharmacol. (2022) 305:116114. doi: 10.1016/j.jep.2022.116114

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

51. An YH, Tao J, Song QL. Discussion on the treatment of tourette disorder in children from the spleen perspective. MEDS Chin Med. (2023) 5(9):72–8. doi: 10.23977/MEDCM.2023.050909

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

52. Zhang XZ, Cao ML, Wang ZY. Experience of traditional Chinese medicine cluster therapy in intervention of refractory tic disorder in children. China J Tradit Chin Med Pharm. (2023) 38(08):3657–60. doi: 10.23977/medsc.2024.050218

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

53. Chen SC, Chen HL, Wang DD, Wang S, Yin YH, Suen LK, et al. Experience of parents in delivering pediatric tuina to children with symptoms of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder during the COVID-19 pandemic: qualitative findings from focus group interviews. BMC Complement Med Ther. (2023) 23(1):53. doi: 10.1186/s12906-023-03891-3

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

54. Wang W, Huang YM, Wang DJ, Yi XQ, Ai K. Effects of abdominal tuina on behavioral function and 5-hydroxytryptamine 1A receptor/synapsin-1 in hippocampal CA1 region of rats with hypoxic-ischemic brain injuries. J Acupunct Tuina Sci. (2023) 21(6):447–54. doi: 10.1007/s11726-023-1403-3

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

55. Wu R, Xiong Y, Gu Y, Cao LY, Zhang SY, Song ZX, et al. Traditional pediatric massage enhanced hippocampal GR, BDNF and IGF-1 expressions and exerted an anti-depressant effect in an adolescent rat model of CUMS-induced depression. Neuroscience. (2024) 542:47–58. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroscience.2024.01.025

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

56. Wang J, Lin W, Lin D. Meta-analysis on randomized controlled trials of massage therapy for tourette syndrome in children. J Baotou Med Coll. (2023) 39(01):74–83. +96. doi: 10.16833/j.cnki.jbmc.2023.01.015

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

57. Xia T, Fu JP, Tang HL, Chu AN, Pang J. Clinical observation on the effect of tuina in prevention and treatment of recurrent respiratory infection induced by pediatric lung qi deficiency. J Nanjing Univ Tradit Chin Med. (2018) 34(03):273–6. doi: 10.14148/ji.ssn.1672-0482.2018.0273

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

58. Yi Z, Zhang ZJ, Han XM, Ding Y, Chen YY, Wang XF, et al. A proprietary herbal medicine (5-ling granule) for tourette syndrome: a randomized controlled trial. J Child Psychol Psychiatry. (2015) 57(1):74–83. doi: 10.1111/jcpp.12432

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

59. Huang CH, Liao WL, Lee DY, Chou IC, Wang MY, Hsieh CL. Effects of Yi-Gan-San on the psychiatric behavior of children and adolescents with tourette’s syndrome: a randomized, double-blind, controlled preliminary study. J Ethnopharmacol. (2022) 290:115098. doi: 10.1016/j.jep.2022.115098

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

60. Chen JH, Leong KP, Leung YH, Chan WM, Li Z, Qiu J, et al. A Chinese herbal formulation, Xiao-Er-An-Shen decoction, attenuates tourette syndrome, possibly by reversing abnormal changes in neurotransmitter levels and enhancing antioxidant Status in mouse brain. Front Pharmacol. (2019) 10:812. doi: 10.3389/fphar.2019.00812

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

61. Xi LY, Ji XX, Ji WX, Yang Y, Zhang Y, Long H. Jing-an oral liquid alleviates tourette syndrome via the NMDAR/MAPK/CREB pathway in vivo and in vitro. Pharm Biol. (2022) 60(1):1790–800. doi: 10.1080/13880209.2022.2116056

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

62. Tong P, Yu L, Junxia W, Zhang J, Zhang J, Ran Z, et al. Acupuncture and other traditional Chinese medicine therapies in the treatment of children’s tic syndrome: a network meta-analysis. Front Neurosci. (2023) 17:1156308. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2023.1156308

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

63. You HZ, Zhou YF, Yu PB, Xie J, Chen J, Li JJ, et al. The efficacy of acupuncture on tic disorders in children: a retrospective and propensity score-matched study. Front Pediatr. (2021) 9:745212. doi: 10.3389/fped.2021.745212

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

64. Lin LX, Yu LL, Xiang HC, Hu X, Yuan X, Zhu H, et al. Effects of acupuncture on behavioral stereotypies and brain dopamine system in mice as a model of tourette syndrome. Front Behav Neurosci. (2019) 13:239. doi: 10.3389/fnbeh.2019.00239

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

65. Chang H, Tang YX, Wang ZX, Jia M, Shi SL, Re GN, et al. Effect of acupuncture combined with infantile tuina on intestinal flora in children with tic disorders. Chin Acupunct Moxibustion. (2023) 43(05):509–16. doi: 10.13703/j.0255-2930.20220724-0002

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

66. Wang YZ, Yang J, Han XM. Clinical efficacy of Shaomazhijing granules in the treatment of tourette’s syndrome: a randomized controlled trial. Hereditas. (2025) 162(1):90. doi: 10.1186/s41065-025-00462-z

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

67. Liu H, Wang C, Zhang H, Rezaei MJ. Exploring acupuncture as a therapeutic approach for tic disorders: a review of current understanding and potential benefits. Front Neurol. (2025) 16:1447818. doi: 10.3389/fneur.2025.1447818

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar