Impact Factor 2.483 | CiteScore 2
More on impact ›

Policy Brief ARTICLE

Front. Public Health, 06 August 2019 |

Indonesia: Epidemiological Profiles of Early Childhood Caries

Rosa Amalia1*, Fania Chairunisa1, M. Fahmi Alfian1 and Al Supartinah2
  • 1Preventive and Community Dentistry Department, Faculty of Dentistry, Universitas Gadjah Mada Yogyakarta, Yogyakarta, Indonesia
  • 2Pediatrics Dentistry Department, Faculty of Dentistry, Universitas Gadjah Mada Yogyakarta, Yogyakarta, Indonesia

The Indonesia government has succeeded in achieving national health development targets and has invested heavily in public health. Many positive results have been achieved, which indicate an increasing number of school-aged children free of caries and a decrease in caries experience scores. However, result of previous studies on early childhood caries (ECC) in pre-school children showed high prevalence and severity. Understanding the link between the epidemiology of the ECC and components of health development is critical for formulating appropriate actions. The purpose of this study is to provide a comprehensive review of the epidemiology of ECC in Indonesia based on the results of the national basic health surveys. The complementary data describes access, utilization and profile of oral health personnel in Indonesia.


Dental caries affects people of all ages and remains the major problem of dental health among children worldwide (1). For preschool children, early childhood caries (ECC) defined as the presence of one or more decayed (non-cavitated or cavitated lesions), missing (due to caries) or filled tooth surfaces in any primary tooth in children <71 months of age (2). ECC is highly prevalent (3), associated with multiple risk factor (4), and reduces the quality of life (5). If ECC treatment is delayed, the condition of the child worsens and becomes harder to treat, increasing the treatment cost.

ECC is also highly prevalence in preschool children living in developing countries like Indonesia (6). Every 5 years, the Indonesian government conducts basic health surveillance. There are surveillance reports on oral health and caries in children for the years 2007, 2013 and 2018 (79). Unfortunately, direct comparison of data is difficult because the reporting format is not in a same manner for each year. This study will therefore be limited to a comprehensive review of the available data on ECC accessible from the basic health surveillance reports, and data from the scientific publications on ECC in Indonesia. Situational analysis of oral health services in Indonesia will also be explored. This description is intended to be a highlight of the factors associated with ECC in Indonesia that may facilitate the review of a national oral health policy for Indonesia.

Analysis On Policy Options and Implications

Epidemiological Data Analysis on ECC in Indonesia

Table 1 presents an overview of the prevalence of ECC and possible risk factors in Indonesia extracted from the basic health surveys conducted in 2007, 2013, and 2018 (79). This table is quite revealing in several ways. It is apparent from the table that more than half of children aged 5 years were experiencing oral health problem. Unfortunately, those who got treatment were only 9.5%. The data also looks unsatisfactory since only 2% of the children received treatment of fillings or extraction. The most disappointing results to emerge from the national survey is that a high prevalence of ECC and poor behavior on brushing teeth properly.


Table 1. Oral health data pertaining to preschoolers from 2007 to 2018.

However, a comparison of the data could not be conducted because of inconsistencies in the measures of the oral variables used for the surveillances. ECC severity using the dmft index, was only conducted in 2018. Also, the data on the dmft was not disaggregated. Data on the proportion of preschoolers who brush their teeth properly was only available in 2018. Despite this limitation, the table highlights a few important issues. First, it suggests that prevalence of ECC is increasing over the study period, and second, it suggests that children age 3–4 years contribute significantly to the high prevalence of ECC in the country. Caries severity also appears to increase by almost a third between the ages 3–4 and 5 years.

Publications on ECC in Indonesia has been limited in scope. Most of them were conducted in cities with few participants. In 1992, a study on preschool-aged children in the Jakarta area showed an ECC prevalence of 85.17% (10). Other research on ECC conducted in Jakarta in 2001 and 2008 reported prevalence of 81.2% (11) and 80.95% (12), respectively. The study in 200l was conducted in children 3–5 year old while that in 2008 was conducted in 3 year olds. The studies suggest that the prevalence of caries increased with age. Lower prevalence were reported in studies conducted in West and East Java; in West Java ECC prevalence was 70% (13) while it was 42.9% or children aged 3 years in East Java. The prevalence of severe ECC was 57.1% in East Java (14). Caries prevalence of 94.3% was reported in 4–6 year old children in Yogyakarta (15), and a prevalence of 100 and 88.5% reported in 5-year-olds resident in South Kalimantan and North Sulawesi, respectively (16, 17). Identified risk factors for ECC studies in Indonesia include low maternal education (12, 15), poor maternal knowledge of oral health (13, 16), and consumption of cariogenic foods, which had a significant relationship with the severity of ECC (12). Children who do not brush their teeth regularly from an early age also had high risk of ECC (15).

Socio-Demographic Context

Indonesia is an archipelago state which is located between two continents (Asia and Australia) and two oceans (Indian and Pacific). The width of land area in Indonesia is around 1,916,862.2 km2, while the width of its sea is about 3,257,483 km2. Indonesia is a country with the fourth largest population worldwide (18). Indonesian people are comprised of many ethnics and cultures. There are more than 700 local languages and dialects in the daily life of its people (19).

It is evident that variations in caries prevalence among children are associated with multiple factors, including ethnicity and culture. Results of national basic health surveys in Indonesia also show that prevalence and severity of oral disease varies across ethnic groups. Yearly, the highest average caries index is found on the island of Borneo, followed by Java and Sulawesi. Factors like socioeconomic status, natural fluoride content in the water, and the culture of sweet food consumption have been suggested as causes of the high caries prevalence. unfortunately the data is presented in general for all ages, while specific data about ECC in children is not available. Interestingly, since the causes of caries are the same at all ages, it can be hypothesized that the variation in the prevalence of ECC across ethnic groups will not be much different.

Health Policy Implications on ECC

Indonesia is classified as a country with lower-middle income population with increasing rate of national income per capita (20, 21). Despite this, 6.8% of Indonesians are living below the poverty line (22). To secure sufficient and sustainable health financing, The National Health Insurance (NHI) scheme was initiated to improve the access of all citizens to health. The scheme was started in January 2014 with the aim of covering about 250 million by 2019, thereby making it the world's largest social health insurance (23). In the Indonesia NHI scheme, oral health service is included as one of the benefit packages received by people. Benefit package for oral care in primary care including counseling, curative treatment (teeth restoration and minor surgery) and dental emergency care (24). This NHI package is valid for all ages, including children. The package also includes treatments for caries in children, including preventive restoration of fissure sealants. Unfortunately, to date, there is no detailed data available regarding utilization by groups of children under 5 years of age and what types of care are received by children related to ECC.

Recently, Ministry of Health developed the oral health provision grand design for 2015–2030 with the goal of having a healthy Indonesia free of caries by 2030. The Healthy Indonesia Free Caries campaign roadmap is revised every 5 years. The Road map started with the issuance of the National Act Plan of Oral Health Service which focused on strengthening policy, resources, and oral health service delivery. Targets were set for caries control in 12 years old children, oral health program at Community Health Centers (CHCs) were standardized, and the role of school-based dental programs and community-based health efforts were strengthened (25). The grand design of oral health provision accompanied the emergence of national policy on oral health laid out in the Ministry of Health Decree No. 89/2015 which identified oral health as an integral part of general health (26). Oral health services for infants focus on maintaining the health of the oral cavity before the teething stage, up to the age of 12 months. Information on oral health is provided to the parents and other family members by (a) counseling them about the growth phase of primary teeth, the conditions that accompany the process of teething and related abnormalities or diseases that often occur in infants as well as (b) educating them on how to maintain the health of their infant's oral cavity before teething until the incisors grow fully. It is stated that oral health services for children under the age of 5 years (between 12 and 72 months) is not very different from that for infants (26). The synergy of oral health policy for pre school and school children is expected to be a good foundation for reaching the target because, in the first 6 years, parents are expected to get good education about caries prevention for children, and the next 6 years of oral health education are applied directly to the children.

It is worthy to note that recently, the government of Indonesia has implemented the decentralization policy in the health sector, under Law No. 23/2014 on Local Government, stated that local government has a responsibility to focus on the delivery of defined essential services (which include health) while the central government has the responsibility to determine the expected standard for the provision of services. Decentralization plays a part, with each authority having an important role in setting policy in its region; every region has a unique approach depending on its individual needs. Unfortunately, reports about the success of ECC prevention program that take advantage of the opportunity for decentralization have not been published.

The number of community health centers and health workers in Indonesia has increased rapidly in the last few decades. Figure 1 shows the number of community health centers in Indonesia between 2013 and 2018. In 2013, this number stood at more than 9,600 units and then rose moderately to more than 9,700 units in 2014 and peaking at almost 10,000 units in 2018 (18, 2531). Figure 2 compares the number of health workers working at CHCs between 2013 and 2018. Nurses and midwives account for the largest share of health workers, followed by medical doctors and community health officers (at ~20,000, respectively). Dentists accounted for the smallest share of health workers, with <10,000. Unfortunately, data on the national health profiles of dental therapists is only available for the years 2013 (10,150 persons) and 2014 (10,219 persons). The low number of oral health personnel and the unequal geographical distributions of existing oral health resources are constraints for the provision of oral healthcare. In 2018, 46.97% of CHCs did not have a dentist (18, 31).


Figure 1. Number of community health centers in Indonesia (2013–2018). Source: Ministry of Health Republic Indonesia (18, 2731).


Figure 2. Number of health personnel in community health centers (2013–2018). Source: Ministry of Health Republic Indonesia (18, 2731).

Oral health personnel and CHCs have important role in the implementation of oral health policy regulations. Dental care has been offered to school children via the national school-based dental program (SBDP) for years. As part of the national school health strategy, SBDP are organized by community health centers located throughout Indonesia, and these aim to promote health by preventing oral disease and developing healthy behaviors. Community Health Centers also have responsibility to manage community-based dental programme where mothers and toddlers are the target of health programs including oral health. The issue of unsufficient number and unequal distribution of oral health personnel in Indonesia are quite worrying because the driving force for the dental public health program in CHC is expected to be the oral health personnel. It is evident that areas that have sufficient numbers of oral health personnel have been shown to have a school-based dental program that runs well and has a high rate of dental treatment to treat children's caries, and vice versa (32).


It is evident that the number of ECC studies carried out in Indonesia over the last 20 years is limited, yet in general the data generated consistently shows high prevalence. Methodological differences and confounding factors, especially socio-demographic influences, limit national comparisons of data on caries prevalence.

The increasing number of oral health personnel, along with the increase in the per-capita expenditure toward health services, does not seem to have had a significant impact. However, the decision maker (e.g., district health office) need to realize that the chosen strategic model to tackle ECC cannot be separated from the socio-economic context. For instance, since economic growth is a rapid process in Indonesia, consequently the consumption of sugar will be augmented. Therefore, dental caries in preschoolers can be expected to increase in coming years. In this case, successful cases of sugar restrictions policy in other countries could serve as examples of the importance of continuous oral health promotion (33).

Nevertheless, this approach is not without challenges. Sociodemographic variations can be a significant barrier, especially in low-income and low-education populations, and can have an impact on low awareness of the importance of oral health for children. This lack of awareness can be seen in the low rate of tooth brushing. This condition must be an alarm for policy makers because the current best practices for reducing the risk of ECC include twice-daily brushing with fluoridated tooth paste. Fortunately, due to policies in Indonesia, toothpaste is relatively affordable and must contain fluoride, so this should be an advantage in caries-prevention strategies. Following this, the role of parents is very important. This should be a concern because children's health development is very dependent on the health and well-being of their parents. The study concluded that some important health behaviors in parents, such as tooth brushing habits are important determinants of these behaviors in their young children. So promoting parent knowledge and attitude could affect their children oral health behavior and status (34).

Indonesia has had a series of policies regarding caries prevention strategies for children. The strength of this program is the direct involvement of parents for children under 6 years old, with parents at the center of counseling on how to maintain children's dental health. This program is community-based, with mothers as the targets. For children 6 years and older, the programs are directly applied and school-based. However, it is worth considering whether school-based dental programs that only focus on elementary education actually have a weakness, because children, at an early age (preschool, in kindergarten, or early childhood education), receive only limited information about good oral hygiene practices directly from oral health personnel. It is also important for oral health personnel to manage the ECC strategy for early childhood/kindergarten children conducted in schools, including conducting ECC risk assessments, teaching daily tooth brushing, and introducing the importance of regular dental visits.

Related to policy development at the regional level (decentralization), the role of the District Health Office is very important. Detailed directions or guidelines can be given to program implementers in the field regarding what should be conveyed to parents to prevent ECC, including the importance of avoiding sticky and sugary foods, not prolonging the use of bottles, and proper practice of oral hygiene. Decision-makers in each region will better understand the various approaches that can be attempted, depending on the specific conditions in each region. A policy of implementing a homogeneous strategy would not bring optimal results due to, for example, the presence of language and literacy barriers in remote and underdeveloped areas. Providing information using local languages or adapting modifiable procedures to cultures can help to overcome obstacles to understanding how to implement healthy behavior.

Despite limitations, there is a strength in the national policy implemented in Indonesia. NHI can be a guarantee of access to health services, reaching even families with low socio-economic status and children with special needs. It is important to note that dental health services at NHI also include preventive services, such as early detection, and preventive restoration, such as fissure sealants. However, parents often do not know that such services exist; they only know about services like restoration and tooth extraction (24). This understanding results in parents taking their children to the dentist only after the child has experienced pain (a toothache), which usually means the hole in the tooth is already deep.

It is important for oral health personnel to consistently and continuously conduct policy-maker advocacy regarding the consequences and preventive strategies for ECC. The national road map of the caries prevention strategy cannot only be targeted at school children, but must also be aimed at preschool children. The national target that considers only school children has even resulted in a lack of attention to ECC among oral health personnel themselves. This is such a concern because, nationally, there is no ECC program, and oral health personnel are not spread evenly. The high numbers of other health workers should be a resource that can be used to deal with dental diseases that occur in children.

Actionable Recommendations

Taken together, the results of analysis on epidemiological data and oral health policy suggest following recommendations:

• National preventive program toward ECC should be prioritized including activity of prevention program in kindergarten or early childhood education. However, oral health programs for young children cannot rely solely on school-based and the decision maker must consider a reasonable range of alternatives to expand the provision of the program.

• Expanding the program via maternal care should be considered as a potential alternative. Integrating immunization programs with dental check-ups also could be another option, since this program is widely spread and accepted among citizen.

• Oral health training can be provided for other health workers, like midwives, to help them identify, and refer high-risk patients for subsequent care management in a dental clinic. Such programs should be actively delivered via early childhood education programs by involving teachers and health cadres via integrated healthcare posts.

• Under the NHI system, there is a potential scheme in implementing early screening for ECC for pre-schoolers. Children referred upon screening will be treated free of charge in CHCs.

• National data on caries should illustrate the prevalence for each of the provinces to indicate regional differences. If the decision maker seeks to develop an efficient and sustainable oral health system, the successes, and failures of the existing service model must be identified. The decision maker needs to realize that the chosen strategic model to tackle ECC cannot be separated from the socio-economic context.


There is a necessity to review dental public health policies and develop effective strategies to prevent the epidemic of ECC in Indonesia. The key to success in the prevention and curative management of ECC lies not only in the availability of oral health personnel but also in a joint commitment with other parties. Further, advocacy to prevent healthcare problems among children is critical because this will have consequences for general health. In particular, policies that promote children's oral health as part of public health initiatives can help attract people's attention.

Author Contributions

RA initiated the idea for the manuscript, wrote the initial framework, and edited the manuscript. FC, MA, and AS added materials according to their expertise. Each author critically reviewed the manuscript for its intellectual content.

Conflict of Interest Statement

The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.


Authors thank to Dr. Iwan Dewanto, Vice Secretary General of Indonesia Dental Association for providing the latest data of Basic Health Survey on Oral Health.


1. World Health Organization (WHO). WHO Expert Consultation on Public Health Intervention Against Early Childhood Caries. Report of a meeting Bangkok, Thailand, 26–28 January 2016. Available online at:;jsessionid=C133A30C650ECF833755DBBF97228F25?sequence=1 (accessed September 28, 2018).

Google Scholar

2. American Dental Association. Statement on Early Childhood Caries. Available online at: (accessed December 15, 2018).

Google Scholar

3. GBD 2016 Disease and Injury Incidence and Prevalence Collaborators. Global, regional, and national incidence, prevalence, and years lived with disability for 328 diseases and injuries for 195 countries, 1990–2016: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study. Lancet. (2016) 390:1211–59. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(17)32154-2.

CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

4. Leong PM, Gussy MG, Barrow SY, de Silva-Sanigorski A, Waters E. A systematic review of risk factors during first year of life for early childhood caries. Int J Paediatr Dent. (2013) 23:235–50. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-263X.2012.01260.x

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

5. American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry. Policy on Early Childhood Caries (ECC): Classification, Consequences and Preventive Strategies. Available online at: (accessed December 9, 2018).

Google Scholar

6. Amalia R. Indonesia. In: Folayan MO (ed). A Compendium on Oral Health of Children Around the World: Early Childhood Caries. New York, NY: Nova Biomedical (2018). p. 155–65.

Google Scholar

7. Ministry of Health Republic Indonesia. Basic Health Survey. Jakarta: Ministry of Health Republic Indonesia (2008). Available online at: (accessed November 6, 2018).

Google Scholar

8. Ministry of Health Republic Indonesia. Basic Health Survey. Jakarta: Ministry of Health Republic Indonesia (2014). Available online at: (accessed November 6, 2018).

Google Scholar

9. Ministry of Health Republic Indonesia. Basic Health Survey. Jakarta: Ministry of Health Republic Indonesia (2019). Available online at: (accessed November 10, 2018).

Google Scholar

10. Suwelo IS. Karies Gigi pada Anak Dengan Pelbagai Faktor Etiologi. Kajian Pada Anak Usia Prasekolah. Edisi I. Jakarta: Penerbit Buku Kedokteran EGC (1992).

Google Scholar

11. Setiawati F. Faktor-faktor yang berhubungan dengan derajat keparahan karies pada anak usia 3-5 tahun dan program pencegahannya di DKI Jakarta. Jakarta: Penerbitan FKG UI (2001).

Google Scholar

12. Sugito FS, Djoharnas H, Darwita RR. Reastfeeding and early childhood caries (ECC) severity of children under three years old in Jakarta. Makara Kesehatan. (2008).12:8–9. doi: 10.7454/msk.v12i2.310

CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

13. Maharani DA, Rahardjo A. Mothers' dental health behaviours and mother-child's dental caries experiences: study of a suburb area in Indonesia. Makara Kesehatan. (2012) 16:72–6. doi: 10.7454/msk.v16i2.1632

CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

14. Sutjipto RW, Herawati, Kuntari S. The prevalence of early childhood caries and severe early childhood caries in preschool children at Gunung Anyar Surabaya. Dental J. (2014) 47:186–9. doi: 10.20473/j.djmkg.v47.i4.p186-189

CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

15. Utami S, Hendrartini Y, Pramono D. Faktor-Faktor yang Berhubungan dengan Tingkat Keparahan Early Childhood Caries (ECC) pada Anak Usia Prasekolah di Kabupaten Sleman. Thesis. Available online at: (accessed February 1, 2017).

Google Scholar

16. Adhani R, Sari NN, Aspriyanto D. Nursing mouth caries children 2-5 years old in Puskesmas Cempaka Banjarmasin. Jurnal PDGI. (2014) 63:1–7.

Google Scholar

17. Winda SU, Gunawan P, Wicaksono DA. Gambaran karies rampan pada siswa pendidikan anak usia dini di desa pineleng ii indah. J E-Gigi. (2015). 3:175–81. doi: 10.35790/eg.3.1.2015.6630

CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

18. Ministry of Health Republic Indonesia. Indonesia Health Profile Year 2017. Jakarta:Ministry of Health Republic of Indonesia (2018). Available online at: (accessed April 28, 2018).

Google Scholar

19. Ananta A, Arifin EN, Hasbullah MS, Handayani NB, Pramono A. Changing Ethnic Composition: Indonesia, 2000-2010. In: Paper for The XXVII IUSSP International Population Conference. Busan: Republic of Korea. Available online at: (accessed August 26–31, 2013).

Google Scholar

20. The World Bank. Data Indicators. Available online at: (accessed January 3, 2019).

Google Scholar

21. World Health Organization. Health Financing: Global Health Expenditure Database 2018 update. Available online at: (accessed March 24, 2019).

Google Scholar

22. Indonesian Central Board of Statistics. Proportion of Population Living Below the International Poverty Line 1990-2016. Available online at: (accessed March 18, 2019).

Google Scholar

23. Pisani E, Olivier Kok M, Nugroho K. Indonesia's road to universal health coverage: a political journey. Health Policy Plan. (2017) 32:267–76. doi: 10.1093/heapol/czw120

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

24. Dewanto I, Lestari NI. Panduan Pelaksanaan Pelayanan Kedokteran Gigi dalam Sistem Jaminan Kesehatan Nasional. Jakarta: Pengurus Besar Persatuan Dokter Gigi Indonesia. (2014). Available online at: (accessed September 11, 2018).

Google Scholar

25. Ministry of Health. National Act Plan of Dental and Oral Health Provision Year 2015−2019 (Rencana Aksi Nasional Pelayanan Kesehatan Gigi dan Mulut Tahun 2015 - 2019). (2016). p. 17–23. Available online at: (accessed October 10, 2018).

Google Scholar

26. Ministry of Health Decree. National Oral Health Initiatives. (2015). Available online at: (accessed November 14, 2018).

PubMed Abstract | Google Scholar

27. Ministry of Health Republic Indonesia. Indonesia Health Profile Year 2013. Jakarta:Ministry of Health Republic of Indonesia (2014). Available online at: (accessed April 20, 2018).

Google Scholar

28. Ministry of Health Republic Indonesia. Indonesia Health Profile Year 2014. Jakarta:Ministry of Health Republic of Indonesia (2015). Available online at: (accessed April 30, 2018).

Google Scholar

29. Ministry of Health Republic Indonesia. Indonesia Health Profile Year 2015. Jakarta: Ministry of Health Republic of Indonesia (2016). Available online at: (accessed May 2, 2018).

Google Scholar

30. Ministry of Health Republic Indonesia. Indonesia Health Profile Year 2016. Jakarta: Ministry of Health Republic of Indonesia (2017). Available online at: (accessed May 14, 2018).

Google Scholar

31. Ministry of Health Republic Indonesia. Indonesia Health Profile Year 2018. Jakarta:Ministry of Health Republic of Indonesia.2019. (In Bahasa) Available online at: (accessed May 3, 2018).

Google Scholar

32. Amalia R, Schaub RM, Stewart RE, Widyanti N, Groothoff JW. Impact of school-based dental program performance on the oral health-related quality of life in children. J Investig Clin Dent. (2017) 8:e12179. doi: 10.1111/jicd.12179

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

33. Thornley S, Marshall R, Reynolds G, Koopu P, Sundborn G, Schofield G. Low sugar nutrition policies and dental caries: a study of primary schools in South Auckland. J Paediatr Child Health. (2017) 53:494–9. doi: 10.1111/jpc.13449

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

34. Hoeft KS, Barker JC, Shiboski S, Pantoja-Guzman E, Hiatt RA. Effectiveness evaluation of Contra Caries Oral Health Education Program for improving Spanish-speaking parents' preventive oral health knowledge and behaviors for their young children. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol. (2016) 44:564–76. doi: 10.1111/cdoe.12250

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Keywords: early childhood caries, Indonesia, caries, policy, children

Citation: Amalia R, Chairunisa F, Alfian MF and Supartinah A (2019) Indonesia: Epidemiological Profiles of Early Childhood Caries. Front. Public Health 7:210. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2019.00210

Received: 30 April 2019; Accepted: 15 July 2019;
Published: 06 August 2019.

Edited by:

Morenike Oluwatoyin Folayan, Obafemi Awolowo University, Nigeria

Reviewed by:

Selda Rizalar, Istanbul Medipol University, Turkey
Katalin Dr. Papp, University of Debrecen, Hungary

Copyright © 2019 Amalia, Chairunisa, Alfian and Supartinah. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.

*Correspondence: Rosa Amalia,