Abstract
Hosts of avian brood parasites are under intense selective pressure to prevent or reduce the cost of parasitism. Many have evolved refined egg discrimination abilities, which can select for eggshell mimicry in their parasite. A classic assumption underlying these coevolutionary dynamics is that host egg recognition depends on the perceivable difference between their own eggs and those of their parasite. Over the past two decades, the receptor noise-limited (RNL) model has contributed to our understanding of these coevolutionary interactions by providing researchers a method to predict a host’s ability to discriminate a parasite’s egg from its own. Recent research has shown that some hosts are more likely to reject brown eggs than blue eggs, regardless of the perceived differences to their own. Such responses suggest that host egg recognition may be due to perceptual or cognitive processes not currently predictable by the RNL model. In this perspective, we discuss the potential value of using the RNL model as a null model to explore alternative perceptual processes and higher-order cognitive processes that could explain how and why some hosts make seemingly counter-intuitive decisions. Further, we outline experiments that should be fruitful for determining the perceptual and cognitive processing used by hosts for egg recognition tasks.
Introduction
Avian brood parasitism is an alternative reproductive strategy where one female lays her eggs in another bird’s nest, imposing the costs of rearing her young on a set of foster parents (). In response, hosts often evolve egg recognition abilities as a major line of defense against parasitism, which, in turn, can select for improved eggshell mimicry in their parasite and instigate a coevolutionary arms race (; ; ). Such interactions have provided researchers with a tractable system to examine parasitic relationships and coevolution (; ; ).
The perceptual and cognitive processes governing host egg recognition are central to understanding host decision-making and coevolutionary arms races (; ; ). Classic theory assumes that hosts can select for eggshell mimicry in the parasite by rejecting parasite eggs they perceive as dissimilar to their own (). Pioneering work by applied an avian receptor noise limited (RNL) model () to the common cuckoo, Cuculus canorus, and their respective hosts. They found that hosts with strong recognition abilities were parasitized by cuckoos that laid eggs with refined eggshell mimicry (as predicted by the RNL model). However, while useful for predicting discriminability between stimuli (; ), the RNL model’s original intent was to make predictions with which to compare behavioral responses and then infer color processing mechanisms (). Contrary to traditional expectations (; ), illustrated that some hosts reject brown model eggs more than blue model eggs, even when those eggs were equally dissimilar to the hosts’ own. In this experiment, model eggs were painted colors that specifically aligned with perceived variation in natural eggshell color (from blue-green to brown; ). This finding has been meta-replicated in five hosts from three continents, each of which face distinct forms of parasitism (; ; ); however, not all hosts will accept any egg models painted “blue” (; ; ; ). These counter-intuitive and, at times disparate, findings raise the question, “why have these hosts deviated from our null expectations”?
Here, we explore alternative visual-cognitive processes that may explain such deviations from the expected RNL model. Specifically, we describe color vision in birds by explaining how color is both received and perceived. We then outline the discrimination challenge facing hosts and describe a higher-level cognitive process (categorization) that hosts may use to process this color information during decision-making (; ; ). Our goal is to contextualize previous findings of strikingly similar color-biased rejection behaviors by describing egg recognition tasks from color reception through perception (Figure 1). Finally, we provide potential experimental frameworks to aid future investigations into the perceptual and cognitive processes used by hosts for egg discrimination tasks.
FIGURE 1
Color Reception
Birds are thought to have excellent color vision (; ; ; ). They possess four types of single-cone photoreceptors, sensitive to ultraviolet (or violet), short, medium, or long wavelength light (). Avian color reception is thought to be based on the stimulation of these single cones (; ), where estimates of quantum catches (i.e., the number of photons being absorbed by the cone from the stimulus) approximate the stimulation of each photoreceptor:
Where Qi represents the quantum catch for receptor i, R is the sensitivity of photoreceptor i after accounting for oil droplet transmittance, S is the reflectance of a stimulus, I is the irradiance in photon flux, and O is the ocular media that narrows the sensitivity of photoreceptors in birds (; ). By convention, we refer to the quantum catches of the ultraviolet/violet-, short-, medium-, and long-wavelength sensitive photoreceptors as Qu, Qs, Qm, and Ql, respectively.
Color Perception
Before a color can give rise to a perceptual experience in an organism, the color that is received by the eye must be transformed and transmitted to the brain (; ; ). This is done by forming opponent channels that contrast received quantum catches against each other (Figure 1), a process that underlies color discrimination in a range of organisms (; ; ; ; ). In theory, related opponent channels [e.g., (Qu+Ql) – (Qs+Qm) and (Qs+Qm) – (Qu+Ql)] can produce signals that vary in sign (positive or negative) and therefore may result in two different responses. Unfortunately, the actual neural mechanisms of each channel—and, indeed, the total number of channels used—are unknown in birds (; ; ; ). This makes it challenging to model the actual signals reaching the avian brain.
To circumvent this difficulty, developed the RNL model that predicts discriminability between stimuli. In this model, the actual opponent channels are unimportant and the sign of the signal makes no difference on model output (). This model assumes that visual signals and discrimination thresholds are determined by photoreceptor noise (), that there are one fewer opponent channels than photoreceptor types, and that altering light levels do not change perceived differences between stimuli (). The RNL model predicts differences between stimuli in just noticeable differences (JNDs), classifying stimuli as either discriminable (>1 JND) or not discriminable (<1 JND). Although in practice, it is generally recognized that the theoretical threshold of 1 JND is likely overly conservative in most natural contexts, and more realistic thresholds may be set ∼2 JNDs (, ; ). This model is appealing because it accurately estimates visible contrast, at least in some contexts (e.g., brightly lit conditions), provided reflectance spectra for two stimuli (e.g., those in a detection or discrimination task), spectral sensitivity estimates of each of the organism’s photoreceptor types (), and the irradiance of the environment () are available.
However, there are certain conditions that may impact the RNL model’s ability to accurately predict discriminability. For example, this model does not currently account for how visual contrast against the background impacts the thresholds beyond which two stimuli can be discriminated (i.e., for discrimination tasks). When viewing colorful stimuli, most animals will compensate for differences in light conditions through a process known as chromatic adaptation (; ). In this process, when the background predominantly reflects long-wavelength light (typical in birds’ nests), the viewer will upregulate short-wavelength receptor signals (e.g., blue) and downregulate long-wavelength receptor signals (e.g., brown; ). Consequently the predicted detection of blue-green eggs in brown nests is, rightly, improved (higher JND) by accounting for the nest background (). However, animals tend to perform better on discrimination tasks (e.g., comparing a parasite’s egg and a host’s egg) when stimuli are more similar to the background (e.g., two brown eggs on a brown nest) and poorer when stimuli are more different from the background (e.g., two blue eggs on a brown nest); thus, chromatic adaptation can effectively alter the threshold necessary to differentiate stimuli (; ; ). Currently, the RNL model does not account for these effects for discrimination tasks.
Higher-Order Processing
Most studies on color discrimination assume that animals use low-level cognitive mechanisms simply based on discrimination thresholds (); however, previous research has provided evidence of decision-rules based on higher-level cognitive mechanisms in invertebrates, fish, mammals, and even in birds (; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ). One such higher-level cognitive process is categorization, which occurs when responses to stimuli vary less within categories than between categories (; ; ). This is known as a boundary effect, which is a hallmark test of categorical perception and can only be assessed measuring responses across a phenotypic range that spans both sides of a decision boundary (; ; ; ). Categorization is thought to increase the speed, accuracy, and certainty of choices, while reducing the requirements for neural processing (; ), particularly useful for performing unfamiliar tasks or when information is uncertain (; ; ). Although the potential for hosts to use color categorization in egg recognition has been discussed previously (; ), and tests have illustrated a clear decision boundary (see figures S3 and S4 from, ), no study has yet confirmed that hosts use categorization for egg recognition ().
Discussion
By providing reasonable predictions about perceivable differences between host and parasite eggs, the RNL model has proven a crucial method for testing certain hypotheses surrounding co-evolutionary arms races between host perception and parasite egg phenotypes (; ). Comparisons between the predictions of the RNL model and actual host responses can demonstrate higher-order processes, such as categorization (; ), or help determine the discrimination thresholds necessary for specific egg recognition tasks (; ). Such experiments would refine our understanding of the perceptual and cognitive processes that underly egg recognition decisions (e.g., opponent channels, chromatic adaptation, and categorization) and advance our understanding of host-parasite coevolutionary dynamics. Here we outline tests necessary to explore hitherto untested perceptual and cognitive processes, which may explain why some hosts’ behaviors appear to deviate from the expectations of the RNL model (e.g., rejecting brown but accepting equally dissimilar blue eggs).
Host Selection for Proposed Tests
The experiments we outline below are ideally suited for hosts traditionally considered intermediate rejecters (; ; ), rather than hosts that unilaterally accept or reject eggs. Additionally, these tests are suited for hosts with intermediate, rather than extreme, eggshell colors so that experimental egg model stimuli can be realistically bluer or browner than the host’s. In such an experiment, a researcher would insert a single egg model, either experimental or control, into each host’s nest and record their response (reject/accept) within a predefined period (). We advocate that researchers estimate avian-perceived coloration of each host egg (rather than average host color as in ), experimental egg, and nest, in addition to measuring the irradiance at each nest, as these data are vital for interpreting host behavioral responses.
Perceptual Mechanisms
Egg rejection studies using egg models varying in coloration along a continuous range would be particularly useful for determining whether a host’s response is governed by a particular opponent channel (, ; ; ). Such experiments (Figure 2A) would allow a researcher to determine whether host response is better predicted by opponent channel(s) or discriminable differences predicted under the RNL model and also whether responses vary sharply anywhere along that color range (decision boundary, see below). This could be a fruitful line of research, since past studies have found that individual photoreceptor quantum catches provided better predictions of host response than discriminable differences predicted under the RNL model (; ). If hosts used a common opponent channel, that may explain why disproportionate rejections of brown eggs have been found in a range of hosts (; ; ; , ; ; ). If such a common channel exists, and is used for egg recognition, it most likely broadly distinguishes short- from long-wavelength dominated colors (e.g., blue and brown, respectively). Still, while uncovering a specific shared opponent channel used by diverse hosts would be exciting, other aspects of visual perception might also explain host behaviors that deviate from our null expectations.
FIGURE 2
Chromatic adaptation to the (typically) brown nest background provides one such intriguing possibility. demonstrated that the thresholds necessary for color discrimination can shift depending on the contrast between the color of the stimuli and the nest background. Thus, hosts with blue-green eggs would face a comparatively more challenging task when discriminating a blue egg (i.e., higher discrimination threshold) than discriminating a brown egg (i.e., lower discrimination threshold). Consistent with this observation, hosts found to disproportionately reject brown egg models laid (at least moderately) blue-green eggs (; ; ; , ; ; ). Although past experiments found that nest contrast did not influence host egg recognition (; ), a blue nest lining did increase performance on an egg discrimination task by 25% in the blue-green egg laying American robin Turdus migratorius (). We feel this is still a promising line of research, particularly if future studies employ an experimental manipulation of nest background () alongside sufficient variation in the color of egg stimuli to determine threshold values (sensu ). We suggest measuring the discrimination thresholds by recording behavioral responses to sets of blue-green and brown egg stimuli sufficiently diverse to surpass threshold levels (e.g., 66.7% rejection rates; see Figure 2B) on high and low contrast nest backgrounds.
Cognitive Mechanisms
If host responses show evidence of a sharp decision boundary (Figure 2A), subsequent experiments should test for color categorization. We suggest deploying discrete sets of egg models of carefully designed colors (; ; ; ), rather than eggs with continuously varying colors (sensu ). For example, egg sets could be bluer (set 1) and browner (set 2) than the hosts’ own (Figure 2C), but of identical brightness. Within each set, one stimulus (stimulus 1) should be relatively similar (e.g., 3 JND) to the host’s own egg (the control stimulus) and differ from the next stimulus (stimulus 2) in the set by an identical degree (e.g., 3 JND). Importantly, sets of stimuli should span the previously detected decision boundary, and there must be comparable perceivable differences within and between categories. While our focus is on colors ranging from blue-green to brown, other color ranges can be explored and more colors can be added as necessary. Color categorization would be detected if differences in host responses are significantly greater across the category boundary (see above) than within either category. Although this is a necessary follow-up test to confirm color categorization in hosts (), it may not reveal the basis for such categorical behavior. Typically, categorical behavioral responses in an experiment such as the one we propose (Figure 2) would imply hosts assign categorical labels to distinguishable egg stimuli (e.g., egg sets); however, identical responses may result from other processes (e.g., chromatic adaptation altering discrimination thresholds for certain discriminations tasks; Figures 2B,C). Regardless of the underlying mechanism of categorical behaviors (e.g., ), such rejection behavior would select for eggshell phenotypes in novel and unappreciated ways.
Expected Evolutionary Outcomes
Importantly, these perceptual and cognitive processes (i.e., chromatic adaptation, categorization) may all impact host egg recognition, and may not be mutually exclusive. Each can be tested by comparing host behavior to the predictions of the RNL model, and would impact host-parasite dynamics in interesting ways. For example, we would expect that heavily parasitized host populations that lay blue-green eggs would evolve even bluer eggs than unparasitized populations, under either categorization or chromatic adaptation, due to their preferential rejection of brown eggs (; ). In these cases, host discrimination might not only select for parasite eggshell mimicry, but also for shifts of the discrimination threshold itself (Figure 2B). We argue that these aspects of perception and cognition are as vital to coevolutionary arms races as the egg traits that are selected. Furthermore, we expect that the cognitive mechanisms underlying host egg recognition will be more plastic () than their egg and visual morphologies, which are, respectively, constrained and conserved traits (; ). Focusing research attention on these more labile cognitive processes will likely be fruitful for determining the role hosts play in shaping coevolutionary dynamics.
Conclusion
In this perspective, we propose that hosts’ discontinuous responses to continuous variation in eggshell color could be explained by more explicit perceptual (opponent channels, chromatic adaptation) and cognitive (categorization) models. By outlining fruitful directions for future research, we encourage researchers to use the RNL model as a null model with which to compare other higher-level processes. Avian brood parasitism provides an ideal system to not only learn about parasitism and coevolution (; ), but also the hitherto unidentified perceptual and cognitive mechanisms () used by wild birds. By developing experiments explicitly designed to discern the underpinnings of avian vision, we can learn more about how birds interpret the world around them, an understanding that is vital to grasping their past, present, and future evolutionary trajectories (; ; ), as well as to informing current conservation efforts (; ). It is our hope that this manuscript will catalyze future investigations into the cognitive processes that underly perception and decision-making in broad taxonomic groups and contexts.
Publisher’s Note
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.
Statements
Data availability statement
The original contributions presented in the perspective contain no data, further inquiries can be directed to the corresponding author/s.
Author contributions
DH provided the concept. DH, SR, and JV proposed experimental designs. All authors worked to develop and revise the writing.
Acknowledgments
We would like to thank Brian Peer for the invitation to this special issue of Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution and helpful feedback from Alex Di Giovanni and three reviewers.
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
References
1
AbernathyV. E.JohnsonL. E.LangmoreN. E. (2021). An experimental test of defenses against avian brood parasitism in a recent host.Front. Ecol. Evol.9:1–14.
2
Abolins-AbolsM.HanleyD.MoskátC.GrimT.HauberM. E. (2019). Anti-parasitic egg rejection by great reed warblers (Acrocephalus arundinaceus) tracks differences along an eggshell color gradient.Behav. Proc.166:103902. 10.1016/j.beproc.2019.103902
3
AidalaZ.CrostonR.SchwartzJ.TongL.HauberM. E. (2015). The role of egg-nest contrast in the rejection of brood parasitic eggs.J. Exp. Biol.2181126–1136. 10.1242/jeb.108449
4
Avarguès-WeberA.DeisigN.GiurfaM. (2011). Visual cognition in social insects.Ann. Rev. Entomol.56423–443. 10.1146/annurev-ento-120709-144855
5
BegumS.MoksnesA.RøskaftE.StokkeB. G. (2012). Responses of potential hosts of Asian cuckoos to experimental parasitism.Ibis154363–371. 10.1111/j.1474-919x.2012.01213.x
6
BenardJ.GiurfaM. (2008). The cognitive implications of asymmetric color generalization in honeybees.Animal Cogn.11283–293. 10.1007/s10071-007-0112-5
7
BenardJ.StachS.GiurfaM. (2006). Categorization of visual stimuli in the honeybee Apis mellifera.Animal Cogn.9257–270. 10.1007/s10071-006-0032-9
8
BlackwellB. F.DevaultT. L.SeamansT. W.LimaS. L.BaumhardtP.Fernández-JuricicE. (2012). Exploiting avian vision with aircraft lighting to reduce bird strikes.J. Appl. Ecol.49758–766. 10.1111/j.1365-2664.2012.02165.x
9
BowmakerJ. K.HeathL. A.WilkieS. E.HuntD. M. (1997). Visual pigments and oil droplets from six classes of photoreceptor in the retinas of birds.Vision Res.372183–2194. 10.1016/s0042-6989(97)00026-6
10
BrookeM.DaviesN. B. (1988). Egg mimicry by cuckoos Cuculus canorus in relation to discrimination by hosts.Nature335630–632. 10.1038/335630a0
11
BuchananK. L.GrindstaffJ. L.PravosudovV. V. (2008). Condition-dependence, developmental plasticity, and cognition: implications for ecology and evolution.Trends Ecol. Evol.231–7. 10.1016/j.tree.2013.02.004
12
CanniffL.DainsonM.LópezA. V.HauberM. E.GrimT.SamašP.et al (2018). Probing the limits of egg recognition using egg rejection experiments along phenotypic gradients.J. Visual. Exp.138:e57512. 10.3791/57512
13
CasseyP.HonzaM.GrimT.HauberM. E. (2008). The modelling of avian visual perception predicts behavioural rejection responses to foreign egg colours.Biol. Lett.4515–517. 10.1098/rsbl.2008.0279
14
CavesE. M.GreenP. A.ZippleM. N.PetersS.JohnsenS.NowickiS. (2018). Categorical perception of colour signals in a songbird.Nature560365–367. 10.1038/s41586-018-0377-7
15
CavesE. M.SchweikertL. E.GreenP. A.ZippleM. N.TaboadaC.PetersS.et al (2020). Variation in carotenoid-containing retinal oil droplets correlates with variation in perception of carotenoid coloration.Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol.74. 10.1007/s00265-020-02874-5
16
ChekeR. A.VennJ. F.JonesP. J. (2006). A spatio-temporal model for predicting when and where red-billed quelea will breed in southern Africa.J. Ornithol.1471–297.
17
DaviesN. B.BrookeL. (1989). An experimental study of co-evolution between the cuckoo, Cuculus canorus, and its hosts. II. host egg markings, chick discrimination and general discussion.J. Animal Ecol.58225–236. 10.2307/4996
18
DawkinsR.KrebsJ. R. (1979). Arms races between and within species.Proc. R. Soc. London B205489–511.
19
DominoniD. M.HalfwerkW.BairdE.BuxtonR. T.Fernández-JuricicE.FristrupK. M.et al (2020). Why conservation biology can benefit from sensory ecology.Nat. Ecol. Evol.4502–511. 10.1038/s41559-020-1135-4
20
DukasR.WaserN. M. (1994). Categorization of food types enhances foraging performance of bumblebees.Animal Behav.481001–1006. 10.1006/anbe.1994.1332
21
EndlerJ. A. (1993). The color of light in forests and its implications.Ecol. Monogr.631–27. 10.2307/2937121
22
EndlerJ. A.MielkeP. W. (2005). Comparing entire colour patterns as birds see them.Biol. J. Linn. Soc.86405–431. 10.1111/j.1095-8312.2005.00540.x
23
EndlerJ. A.WestcottD. A.MaddenJ. R.RobsonT. (2005). Animal visual systems and the evolution of color patterns: sensory processing illuminates signal evolution.Evolution591795–1818. 10.1111/j.0014-3820.2005.tb01827.x
24
GoldsmithT. H. (1990). Optimization, constraint, and history in the evolution of eyes.Quart. Rev. Biol.65281–322. 10.1086/416840
25
GoldstoneR. L.HendricksonA. T. (2009). Categorical perception.Wiley Interdiscipl. Rev. Cogn. Sci.169–78.
26
GreenP. A.BrandleyN. C.NowickiS. (2020). Categorical perception in animal communication and decision-making.Behav. Ecol.31859–867. 10.1093/beheco/araa004
27
HamA. D.OsorioD. C. (2007). Colour preferences and colour vision in poultry chicks.Proc. R. Soc. B2741941–1948. 10.1098/rspb.2007.0538
28
HanleyD.CasseyP.DoucetS. M. (2013). Parents, predators, parasites, and the evolution of eggshell colour in open nesting birds.Evol. Ecol.27593–617. 10.1007/s10682-012-9619-6
29
HanleyD.LópezA. V.FioriniV. D.ReboredaJ. C.GrimT.HauberM. E. (2019b). Variation in multicomponent recognition cues alters egg rejection decisions: a test of the optimal acceptance threshold hypothesis.Philos. Trans. R. Soc. London B374:20180195. 10.1098/rstb.2018.0195
30
HanleyD.GernK.HauberM. E.GrimT. (2019a). Host responses to foreign eggs across the avian visual color space.Am. Natur.19417–27. 10.1086/703534
31
HanleyD.GrimT.CasseyP.HauberM. E. (2015). Not so colourful after all: eggshell pigments constrain avian eggshell colour space.Biol. Lett.11:20150087. 10.1098/rsbl.2015.0087
32
HanleyD.GrimT.IgicB.SamašP.LópezA. V.ShawkeyM. D.et al (2017). Egg discrimination along a gradient of natural variation in eggshell coloration.Proc. R. Soc. B284:20162592. 10.1098/rspb.2016.2592
33
HarnadS. (1987). “Psychophysical and cognitive aspects of categorical perception: a critical overview,” in Categorical Perception: The Groundwork of Cognition, ed.HarnadS. (New York: Cambridge University Press), 1–25. 10.1016/j.cognition.2009.06.008
34
HartN. S. (2001). The visual ecology of avian photoreceptors.Progr. Retinal Eye Res.20675–703. 10.1016/s1350-9462(01)00009-x
35
HauberM. E.TongL.BánM.CrostonR.GrimT.WaterhouseG. I. N.et al (2015b). The value of artificial stimuli in behavioral research: making the case for egg rejection studies in avian brood parasitism.Ethology121521–528. 10.1111/eth.12359
36
HauberM. E.AidalaZ.IgicB.ShawkeyM. D.MoskátC. (2015a). Experimental shifts in egg–nest contrasts do not alter egg rejection responses in an avian host–brood parasite system.Animal Cogn.181133–1141. 10.1007/s10071-015-0886-9
37
HauberM. E.KimC. R.GoetheC.HanleyD. (2020). Self-referent phenotype matching is a poor predictor of egg rejection by American Robins.J. Field Ornithol.91254–262. 10.1111/jofo.12339
38
HonzaM.PolaèikováL.ProcházkaP. (2007). Ultraviolet and green parts of the colour spectrum affect egg rejection in the song thrush (Turdus philomelos).Biol. J. Linn. Soc.92269–276. 10.1111/j.1095-8312.2007.00848.x
39
JacobsG. H. (1981). Comparative Color Vision. Series in Cognition and Perception.New York: Academic Press.
40
KelberA. (2016). Colour in the eye of the beholder: receptor sensitivities and neural circuits underlying colour opponency and colour perception.Curr. Opin. Neurobiol.41106–112. 10.1016/j.conb.2016.09.007
41
KelberA.OsorioD. (2010). From spectral information to animal colour vision: experiments and concepts.Proc. R. Soc. B2771617–1625. 10.1098/rspb.2009.2118
42
KepecsA.UchidaN.ZariwalaH. A.MainenZ. F. (2008). Neural correlates, computation and behavioural impact of decision confidence.Nature455227–231. 10.1038/nature07200
43
KrauskopfJ.GegenfurtnerK. (1992). Color discrimination and adaptation.Vision Research322165–2175. 10.1016/0042-6989(92)90077-v
44
LachlanR. F.NowickiS. (2015). Context-dependent categorical perception in a songbird.Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A.1121892–1897. 10.1073/pnas.1410844112
45
LangmoreN. E.KilnerR. M.ButchartS. H. M.MaurerG.DaviesN. B.CockburnA.et al (2005). The evolution of egg rejection by cuckoo hosts in Australia and Europe.Behav. Ecol.16686–692. 10.1186/1742-9994-11-34
46
LindO. (2016). Colour vision and background adaptation in a passerine bird, the zebra finch (Taeniopygia guttata).R. Soc. Open Sci.3:160383. 10.1098/rsos.160383
47
MannaT. J.HanleyD.HonzaM.CapekM.RutilaJ.SamašP.et al (2020). Fitting different visual models to behavioral patterns of parasitic egg rejection along a natural egg color gradient in a cavity-nesting host species.Vision Res.16754–59. 10.1016/j.visres.2019.12.007
48
NelsonD. A.MarlerP. (1989). Categorical perception of a natural stimulus continuum: birdsong.Science244976–978. 10.1126/science.2727689
49
ÖdeenA.HåstadO. (2003). Complex distribution of avian color vision systems revealed by sequencing the SWS1 opsin from total DNA.Mol. Biol. Evol.20855–861. 10.1093/molbev/msg108
50
OlssonP.JohnssonR. D.FosterJ. J.KirwanJ. D.LindO.KelberA. (2020). Chicken colour discrimination depends on background colour.J. Exp. Biol.223:jeb209429.
51
OlssonP.LindO.KelberA. (2018). Chromatic and achromatic vision: parameter choice and limitations for reliable model predictions.Behav. Ecol.29273–282. 10.1093/beheco/arx133
52
OsorioD.VorobyevM. (2018). Principles and application of the receptor noise model of color discrimination: a comment on Olsson et al.Behav. Ecol.29283–284.
53
OsorioD.VorobyevM.JonesC. D. (1999). Colour vision of domestic chicks.J. Exp. Biol.2022951–2959. 10.1242/jeb.202.21.2951
54
PeerB. D.SealyS. G. (2004). Correlates of egg rejection in hosts of the Brown-headed Cowbird.Condor106580–599. 10.1007/s00114-017-1446-8
55
PorallaJ.NeumeyerC. (2006). Generalization and categorization of spectral colors in goldfish. II. experiments with two and six training wavelengths.J. Comparat. Physiol. A192469–479. 10.1007/s00359-005-0082-5
56
PriceT.FialkoK. (2018). Receptor noise models: time to consider alternatives?: A comment on Olsson et al.Behav. Ecol.29284–285. 10.1093/beheco/arx155
57
PriceT. D.StoddardM. C.ShevellS. K.BlochN. I. (2019). Understanding how neural responses contribute to the diversity of avian colour vision.Animal Behav.155297–305. 10.1016/j.anbehav.2019.05.009
58
ReeveH. K. (1989). The evolution of conspecific acceptance thresholds.Am. Natur.133:407. 10.1086/284926
59
RenoultJ. P.KelberA.SchaeferH. M. (2015). Colour spaces in ecology and evolutionary biology.Biol. Rev.92292–315. 10.1111/brv.12230
60
ReppB. H. (1984). “Categorical perception: issues, methods, findings,” in Speech and Language: Advances in Basic Research and Practice, Vol. 10ed.LassN. J. (New York: Academic Press), 244–335.
61
RochaF. A. F.SaitoC. A.SilveiraL. C. L.de SouzaJ. M.VenturaD. F. (2008). Twelve chromatically opponent ganglion cell types in turtle retina.Visual Neurosci.25307–315. 10.1017/S0952523808080516
62
RothsteinS. I. (1975). An experimental and teleonomic investigation of avian brood parasitism.Condor77250–271.
63
SandellJ. H.GrossC. G.BornsteinM. H. (1979). Color categories in macaques.J. Comparat. Physiol. Psychol.93626–635. 10.1037/h0077594
64
ShepardR. N. (1987). Toward a universal law of generalization for psychological science.Science2371317–1323. 10.1126/science.3629243
65
SolerJ. J.AvilésJ. M.MøllerA. P.MorenoJ. (2012). Attractive blue-green egg coloration and cuckoo-host coevolution.Biol. J. Linn. Soc.106154–168. 10.1111/j.1095-8312.2012.01857.x
66
SolerM.SolerJ. (2000). Brood-parasite interactions between great spotted cuckoos and magpies: a model system for studying coevolutionary relationships.Oecologia125309–320. 10.1007/s004420000487
67
SpottiswoodeC. N.StevensM. (2010). Visual modeling shows that avian host parents use multiple visual cues in rejecting parasitic eggs.Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A.1078672–8676. 10.1073/pnas.0910486107
68
SpottiswoodeC. N.StevensM. (2012). Host-parasite arms races and rapid changes in bird egg appearance.Am. Natur.179632–648. 10.1086/665031
69
StevensM. (2011). Avian vision and egg colouration: concepts and measurements.Avian Biol. Res.4168–184.
70
StevensM. (2013). Bird brood parasitism.Curr. Biol.23R909–R913.
71
StevensM.ParragaC. A.ICuthillC.PartridgeJ. C.TrosciankoT. S. (2007). Using digital photography to study animal coloration.Biol. J. Linn. Soc.90211–237. 10.1111/j.1095-8312.2007.00725.x
72
StevensM.TrosciankoJ.SpottiswoodeC. N. (2013). Repeated targeting of the same hosts by a brood parasite compromises host egg rejection.Nat. Commun.4:2475. 10.1038/ncomms3475
73
StoddardM. C.HauberM. E. (2017). Colour, vision and coevolution in avian brood parasitism.Philos. Trans. R. Soc. B372:20160339. 10.1098/rstb.2016.0339
74
StoddardM. C.StevensM. (2011). Avian vision and the evolution of egg color mimicry in the common cuckoo.Evolution652004–2013. 10.1111/j.1558-5646.2011.01262.x
75
StokkeB. G.HafstadI.RudolfsenG.BargainB.BeierJ.Bigas CampàsD.et al (2007). Host density predicts presence of cuckoo parasitism in reed warblers.Oikos116913–922. 10.1111/j.2007.0030-1299.15832.x
76
TapperD. N.HalpernB. P. (1968). Taste stimuli: a behavioral categorization.Science161708–709. 10.1126/science.161.3842.708
77
ten CateC.RoweC. (2007). Biases in signal evolution: learning makes a difference.Trends Ecol. Evol.22380–387.
78
TreismanM.FaulknerA.NaishP. L.RosnerB. S. (1995). Voice-onset time and tone-onset time: the role of criterion-setting mechanisms in categorical perception.Quart. J. Exp. Psychol. A48334–366. 10.1080/14640749508401394
79
VasasV.BrebneraJ. S.ChittkaL. (2018). Color discrimination is not just limited by photoreceptor noise: a comment on Olsson et al.Behav. Ecol.29284–285.
80
VenturaD. F.ZanaY.De SouzaJ. M.DevoeR. D. (2001). Ultraviolet colour opponency in the turtle retina.J. Exp. Biol.2042527–2534. 10.1242/jeb.204.14.2527
81
VorobyevM. (2003). Coloured oil droplets enhance colour discrimination.Proc. R. Soc. B2701255–1261. 10.1098/rspb.2003.2381
82
VorobyevM.OsorioD. (1998). Receptor noise as a determinant of colour thresholds.Proc. R. Soc. London B265351–358. 10.1098/rspb.1998.0302
83
YangC.LiZ.ZhangY.WangH.LiangW.MøllerA. P. (2016). Egg polymorphism and egg discrimination in the Daurian Redstarts Phoenicurus auroreus, a host of the common cuckoo Cuculus canorus.Ornithol. Sci.15127–132.
84
ZhangJ.MøllerA. P.YanD.LiJ.DengW. (2021a). Egg rejection changes with seasonal variation in risk of cuckoo parasitism in Daurian Redstarts, Phoenicurus auroreus.Animal Behav.175193–200. 10.1016/j.anbehav.2021.03.007
85
ZhangJ.SantemaP.LiJ.YangL.DengW.KempenaersB. (2021b). Host personality predicts cuckoo egg rejection in Daurian Redstarts Phoenicurus auroreus.Proc. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci.288:20210228. 10.1098/rspb.2021.0228
Summary
Keywords
brood parasitism, color categorization, egg rejection, opponent channels, receptor-noise limited model
Citation
Hanley D, Rutledge SL and Villa J (2021) The Perceptual and Cognitive Processes That Govern Egg Rejection in Hosts of Avian Brood Parasites. Front. Ecol. Evol. 9:702934. doi: 10.3389/fevo.2021.702934
Received
30 April 2021
Accepted
14 October 2021
Published
04 November 2021
Volume
9 - 2021
Edited by
Brian Peer, Western Illinois University, United States
Reviewed by
Virginia Abernathy, Clemson University, United States; Eleanor Caves, University of California, Santa Barbara, United States; Tanmay Dixit, University of Cambridge, United Kingdom, in collaboration with reviewer EC
Updates
Copyright
© 2021 Hanley, Rutledge and Villa.
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
*Correspondence: Daniel Hanley, dhanley2@gmu.edu
This article was submitted to Coevolution, a section of the journal Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution
Disclaimer
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.