ORIGINAL RESEARCH article

Front. Public Health, 10 June 2022

Sec. Environmental Health and Exposome

Volume 10 - 2022 | https://doi.org/10.3389/fpubh.2022.901485

Pesticide Residues in Commonly Consumed Vegetables in Henan Province of China in 2020

  • 1. Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, College of Public Health, Zhengzhou University, Zhengzhou, China

  • 2. Department of Occupational and Environmental Health Sciences, College of Public Health, Zhengzhou University, Zhengzhou, China

  • 3. Institute for Special Food Inspection, Henan Province Food Inspection Research Institute, Zhengzhou, China

  • 4. Department of Social Medicine, College of Public Health, Zhengzhou University, Zhengzhou, China

Article metrics

View details

23

Citations

5,5k

Views

1,4k

Downloads

Abstract

Background:

Pesticides are widely used in agricultural production to control insect pests and regulate plant growth in China, which may result in the presence of some pesticide residues in the vegetables. However, few studies of monitoring pesticides have been conducted in Henan Province. The aim of this study was to evaluate the level of pesticide residues in commonly consumed vegetables in the regions of Henan Province.

Methods:

In this study, we collected 5,576 samples of 15 different vegetables in 17 areas from Henan Province during 2020. Eight kinds of pesticides were analyzed by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS), including procymidone, lambda-cyhalothrin, cypermethrin, pendimethalin, isocarbophos, isazophos, fenthion and deltamethrin. The chi-square test was used to compare the detection rates of pesticide residues in different regions.

Results:

Of all the pesticides above, procymidone, lambda-cyhalothrin, cypermethrin, pendimethalin and isocarbophos were detected in vegetables, the detection rates were 27.0%, 16.2%, 11.4%, 3.5%, and 1.9%, respectively. However, isazophos, fenthion, and deltamethrin were not detected. In addition, procymidone, lambda-cyhalothrin, and cypermethrin were detected in urban areas, while pendimethalin was detected in rural areas. The detection rates of cypermethrin and pendimethalin in rural were 19.8% and 5.4%, respectively, which in urban were at relatively lower levels (13.7% and 1.9%, respectively) (P < 0.05). Compared the differences of pesticide detection rates among five areas of Henan province, we found that there were statistical differences in the detection rates of procymidone, cypermethrin and lambda-cyhalothrin in different regions (all P < 0.05).

Conclusion:

The results have revealed that the pesticide residues are present. Higher detection rates and more types of pesticides were found in rural areas than urban areas. In addition, there were higher detection rates in Eastern Henan. The findings provided valuable information on the current pesticide residues status, which can be a reference of pesticide supervision and management.

Introduction

Pesticides are widely used chemical agents which are used to control insect pests and regulate plant growth (1). Moreover, China is a large agricultural country, so pesticides play an important role in agricultural production. Although pesticides can improve the quality of agricultural products to a certain extent and bring some benefits to agricultural production, we also need to be aware of a series of problems caused by pesticides such as environmental pollution and health hazards (2). Pesticide residues are a serious problem due to their persistence, biological magnification and toxicity (3). Previous studies have shown that tea (4) and cooking oil (5) contain pesticide residues, which may pose potential hazards if eaten untreated. Studies have shown that the ingestion of food containing pesticide residues can cause cancer (6), heart disease (7) and other diseases to a certain extent. There is also a body of evidence that long-term pesticide exposure, even at low doses, can lead to negative effects such as birth defects, reduced birth weight, and fetal death (8). In addition, pesticide residues will also affect the export of agricultural products.

As the main source of our daily intake of vitamins and nutrients, vegetables are the important part of our daily life and are closely related to our health. In most Chinese people, each of us consumes at least 300 g of vegetables averagely per day (9). As people's living standards improve, the demand for vegetables is also increasing. In order to ensure the yield and quality of vegetables, farmers may spray pesticides in large doses during vegetable cultivation in order to prevent and control pests and diseases (10). And some farmers use pesticides incorrectly due to their lack of expertise in pesticide use and improper management of pesticides (11, 12), bringing about a series of pesticide residue problems. The problem of pesticide residues in vegetables is a global public health issue (13). With the growing population and accelerated urbanization, pesticide intake has generally increased in many countries around the world, and China is no exception. From 2015 to 2019, China ranked first in the world in terms of pesticide consumption, followed by the United States, which is a matter of concern (14).

The detection of pesticide residues in vegetables has always been a great challenge, because the composition of target substances is complex and we may can't achieve the expected detection effect due to the interference of multiple matrix substances (15). As an accurate qualitative and quantitative method, gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) is widely used in pesticide detection. Based on abundant advantages of GC-MS, such as fast, simple, sensitive, accurate, and good selectivity (16, 17), it can accurately identify target analytes and perform quantitative analysis, making it a highly sensitive and selective method.

The World Health Organization stressed that pesticide residues are a priority issue and it states that the effects of pesticides on human health are not immediate but long-term (18). At present, pesticide exposure in China is a problem that should be paid attention to. Pesticide has been detected in dust (19), river (20), drinking water (21), breast milk (22), dietary (23), and pediatric (24) and adult (25). In addition to the acute poisonings associated with pesticides including dizziness and headache, skin allergies, and burning of eyes (26), chronic hazards associated with long-term exposure are also a problem that cannot be ignored such as cancers, Alzheimer, Parkinson, asthma, diabetes, and obesity (27).

A few studies of pesticide monitoring have been carried out in China to assess the environmental load of pesticide residues and to assess the risk of short-term ingestion of pesticide residues in crops. Fungicides and other pesticide residues in local vegetables were detected in Zhejiang (28) and Shaanxi (29). Another study was conducted in 2018 to investigate the accumulation of pesticide residues in vegetables in 12 Chinese provinces (30), the results showed that 41.9% of the samples were positive. As a large agricultural province with a large population of more than 90 million people (31), Henan Province consumes a great quantity of vegetables, but few studies have detected pesticide residue concentration in vegetables in Henan. In order to ensure food safety and provide a basis for food supervision and regulation, we aimed to assess the pesticide residues of vegetables in Henan Province by using GC-MS method.

Materials and Methods

Sampling

The locations and the number of samples collected were shown in Figure 1. In this study, a wide variety of vegetables have been selected to detect the pesticide residue, including legumes (green bean and cowpea), root vegetables (ginger and yam), melon vegetables (cucumber), bulb vegetables (leek), eggplant vegetables (tomato, pepper, eggplant, and sweet pepper), leafy vegetables (spinach, common cabbage, celery, and lettuce), and fresh edible mushroom. Most of these vegetables were bought from supermarkets and farmers' markets, with a small proportion of samples coming from 15 locations such as vegetable markets, school canteens, shopping malls, and collective meal delivery units. These vegetables were randomly sampled from 17 prefecture-level administrative regions in Henan Province. A total of 3,234 of these vegetables were obtained from urban areas, while 2,342 samples were selected from rural areas.

Figure 1

Sample Treatment and Detection

The sample volume for vegetables was in accordance with GB/T 8855, while the edible mushroom samples were randomly sampled at 1 kg and the sampling area was based on GB 2763. For small samples, after sampling, unified treatment. For larger, basically homogeneous samples, they were divided or cut into smaller pieces on the symmetry axis or symmetry plane and then processed. For slender, flat samples or samples with different component contents, they were cut into small pieces or sections in different parts for post-processing. Before sending the samples pre-treated, we have crushed and sieved the samples. Chopped the samples, and then mixed them thoroughly, divided them by quartering or put them directly into a tissue masher to form a homogenate, and then placed them in a polyethylene bottle. According to the national standard GB 23200.113–2018, the sample was first extracted by using acetonitrile, then, the solid-phase extraction method was used to purify and concentrate the samples synchronously. Last, GC-MS was used to conduct qualitative and quantitative analyses. The types of the eight kinds of pesticides tested were procymidone, lambda-cyhalothrin, cypermethrin, pendimethalin, isocarbophos, isazophos, fenthion, and deltamethrin. The detailed steps were as follows.

The samples were firstly pre-treated, and 20 g was transferred into a 100 ml plastic centrifuge tube, adding 40 ml of acetonitrile, homogenizing for 2 min with a high-speed homogeniser at 15,000 revolutions per minute (r/min), and then 5–7 g of sodium chloride was added and shaken vigorously for several times and centrifuged for 5 min at 4200 r/min. The supernatant was sucked into a 100 ml flask, rotary evaporated to 1 ml in a water bath at 40°C, nitrogen blowing until nearly dry. The sample was then purified and washed several times with 3 ml of acetonitrile-toluene solution into a solid phase extraction column. The supernatant was collected, and concentrated in a water bath at 40°C. Then the sample was first re-dissolved with 2.5 ml of ethyl acetate and then added to the internal standard solution for determination. Retention time was determined qualitatively and peak height and peak area were quantified.

Statistical Analysis

The statistical analysis was performed using IBM SPSS Version 26.0, and P < 0.05 was considered statistical significance. Comparison of the detection situation of pesticide residues was performed in different regions by using the chi-square test.

Results

The Distributions of Eight Kinds of Pesticides in Different Vegetables

A total of 8 pesticide residues were detected in 5,576 samples in this study. The distributions of eight kinds of pesticides in different vegetables were shown in Table 1. The concentrations of pesticides in some vegetables with high detection rates was showed in Supplementary Figure 1. The 95th percentile (P95) of detection concentrations in vegetables as follows. Procymidone was detected in leek, cucumber, eggplant, and pepper. In addition, the concentrations of P95 for leek, cucumber, and eggplant were 3.853, 0.060, and 0.051 (mg/kg), respectively. Lambda-cyhalothrin was detected in 13 kinds of vegetables, and the concentrations of P95 in leek, celery, tomato, cowpea, lettuce, green bean, and pepper were 0.190, 0.111, 0.062, 0.043, 0.407, 0.034, and 0.048 (mg/kg), respectively. Cypermethrin was detected in 10 kinds of vegetables, and concentrations of P95 for leek, celery, tomato, common cabbage were 0.439, 0.027, 0.039, and 0.054 (mg/kg), respectively. Few vegetables had a value for the 75th percentile of detection concentrations, such as 0.084 mg/kg procymidone in leek and 0.126 mg/kg cypermethrin in Spinach. The detection rates of pesticide residues in all vegetables were 10.7% and 98.9% of the samples were qualified, samples fail to qualify was leek. Procymidone, lambda-cyhalothrin, cypermethrin, pendimethalin, and isocarbophos were detected in vegetables, the detection rate was 27.0%, 16.2%, 11.4%, 3.5%, and 1.9%, respectively. Isazophos, fenthion and deltamethrin were not detected.

Table 1

No. of samples (n)Detection rate (%)Concentration (mg/kg)
P5P10P25P50P75P90P95
Procymidone599
Leek45232.74< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.0841.7343.853
Cucumber6810.29< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.0140.060
Eggplant3917.95< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.0340.051
Pepper400< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Lambda-cyhalothrin1534
Leek42223.46< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.0710.190
Celery35216.48< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.0370.111
Tomato18417.93< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.0200.062
Cowpea1489.46< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.043
Lettuce12321.10< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.2440.407
Common cabbage147.14< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Green bean7613.16< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.0200.034
Cucumber682.94< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Pepper287.14< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.048
Ginger500< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Yam150< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Sweet Pepper100< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Fresh edible mushroom444.54< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Cypermethrin1368
Leek42122.8< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.1840.439
Celery3697.31< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.028
Tomato1519.93< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.039
Cowpea1483.38< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.005
Common cabbage847.14< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.054
Eggplant300< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Pepper685.88< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Ginger500< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Fresh edible mushroom422.38< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Spinach540< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.126NANA
Pendimethalin839
Leek4512.66< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Celery3884.38< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Isocarbophos216
Cowpea2161.85< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Isazophos481
Cowpea1850< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Lettuce1630< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Eggplant950< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Pepper280< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Sweet Pepper100< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Fenthion298
Cowpea1850< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Green bean1130< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Deltamethrin241
Tomato1510< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Common cabbage140< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Green bean760< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD

Description of the detection rate and concentration of various pesticides in each vegetable.

NA, Not applicable. Bold values indicates detection limit.

Description of the Detected Concentrations and Comparison of Detection Rates of Various Pesticides in Contrysides and Cities

As shown in Tables 2, 3, all vegetables were stratified by rural and urban areas to describe the concentrations of pesticides detected in vegetables. It found that procymidone, lambda-cyhalothrin, and cypermethrin were detected in urban areas, while pendimethalin was also detected in rural areas in the countryside. Procymidone was detected in leek, cucumber, and eggplant. Lambda-cyhalothrin was detected in leek, celery, tomato, common cabbage, and pepper. For some of the vegetables with higher detection rates in rural and urban areas, a description of their percentile was shown in Supplementary Figures 2, 3. Among these vegetables, the residue concentrations of the two pesticides in leek were still the highest, the concentrations of P95 were 2.307 and 0.699 (mg/kg), respectively. The highest concentrations of cypermethrin in these vegetables were detected in lettuce, and the concentration of P95 was 1.514 mg/kg. Only celery was detected for pendimethalin, and the concentration of P95 was 0.017 mg/kg. In the city, it was observed that the concentrations of P95 for leek were the highest in procymidone and cypermethrin, which were 4.596 and 0.134 (mg/kg), respectively. However, common cabbage, not leek, had the highest concentration of lambda-cyhalothrin, which the concentration of P95 was 1.103 mg/kg.

Table 2

No. of samples (n)Concentration (mg/kg)
P5P10P25P50P75P90P95
Procymidone203
Leek160< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.1802.307
Cucumber15< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.037NA
Eggplant14< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.0330.073NA
Pepper14< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Lambda-cyhalothrin580
Leek145< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.3880.699
Celery193< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.034
Tomato71< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.0210.047
Cowpea74< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Common cabbage43< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.054
Eggplant7< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Pepper20< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.017
Ginger17< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Fresh edible mushroom10< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Cypermethrin635
Leek145< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.0190.1420.257
Celery185< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.0720.178
Tomato83< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.0300.081
Cowpea74< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.0320.065
Lettuce58< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.0200.3831.514
Common cabbage3< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Green bean28< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.0340.044
Cucumber15< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Pepper6< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Ginger17< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Yam9< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Fresh edible mushroom11< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Pendimethalin367
Leek160< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Celery207< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.017
Isocarbophos107
Cowpea107< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Isazophos211
Cowpea98< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Lettuce73< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Eggplant33< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Pepper6< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Sweet Pepper1< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Fenthion137
Cowpea98< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Green bean39< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Deltamethrin102
Tomato71< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Common cabbage3< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Green bean28< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD

Description of the concentrations of various pesticides detected in each vegetable in the countryside.

NA, Not applicable. Bold values indicates detection limit.

Table 3

No. of samples (n)Concentration (mg/kg)
P5P10P25P50P75P90P95
Procymidone396
Leek292< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.1182.2554.596
Cucumber53< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.0090.064
Eggplant25< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.037
Pepper26< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Lambda-cyhalothrin788
Leek276< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.1020.372
Celery176< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.048
Tomato80< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.055
Cowpea74< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.018
Common cabbage41< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD1.103
Eggplant23< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Pepper48< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.024
Ginger33< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Fresh edible mushroom32< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.038
Spinach5< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.126NANA
Cypermethrin899
Leek277< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.0490.134
Celery167< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.0160.076
Tomato101< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.053
Cowpea74< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.018
Lettuce65< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.1050.350
Common cabbage11< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Green bean48< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.019
Cucumber53< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Pepper22< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.065
Ginger33< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Yam6< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Sweet Pepper9< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Fresh edible mushroom33< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD0.011
Pendimethalin472
Leek291< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Celery181< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Isocarbophos109< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Cowpea109< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Isazophos270< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Cowpea87< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Lettuce90< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Eggplant62< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Pepper22< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Sweet Pepper9< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Fenthion161< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Cowpea87< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Green bean74< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Deltamethrin139< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Tomato80< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Common cabbage11< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD
Green bean48< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD< LOD

Description of the concentrations of various pesticides detected in each vegetable in the city.

NA, Not applicable. Bold values indicates detection limit.

The detection rates of procymidone, lambda-cyhalothrin and isocarbophos in urban areas were 29.3%, 12.2%, and 2.8%, respectively, which were higher than rural areas (22.7%, 10.3%, and 0.9%). No significant difference in pesticide residues was observed between the two groups. In contrast, the detection rates of cypermethrin and pendimethalin in rural were 19.8% and 5.4%, respectively, which were higher than urban vegetables (13.7% and 1.9%) (P < 0.05). The detailed results were shown in Table 4.

Table 4

PesticideNo. of samples (n)Detection rate (%)P
countrysidecitycountrysidecity
Procymidone20339622.729.30.084
Cypermethrin63589919.813.70.001
Lambda-cyhalothrin58078810.312.20.291
Pendimethalin3674725.41.90.005
Isocarbophos1071090.92.80.322
Isazophos21127000NA
Fenthion13716100NA
Deltamethrin10213900NA

Comparison of detection rates of various pesticides between rural and city.

NA, Not applicable. Bold values indicates detection limit.

Pesticide Residues in Different Areas

Based on topography and rivers, the Henan province was divided into five parts: east, west, south, north, and central. The detection rates of procymidone, cypermethrin, and lambda-cyhalothrin resident in the eastern part of Henan Province were the highest, and the corresponding detection rates were 38.0%, 21.5%, and 18.8%, respectively. The lowest residue level of procymidone, cypermethrin and lambda-cyhalothrin in vegetables was measured in western, southern, northern Henan and the corresponding detection rates were 10.9%, 13.5%, and 8.2%, respectively, as shown in Table 5. And there were statistical differences in the detection rates of procymidone, cypermethrin and lambda-cyhalothrin in different regions (P < 0.05).

Table 5

PesticideNo. of samples (n) Detection rateP
Eastern HenanWestern HenanSouthern HenanNorthern HenanCentral subregion of Henan
Procymidone79(38%)119(10.9%)86(22.1%)77(14.3%)238(37.4%)0.000
Cypermethrin251(21.5%)200(20.5%)251(13.5%)190(14.7%)642(14.0%)0.019
Lambda-cyhalothrin213(18.8%)188(10.1%)220(8.2%)174(6.9%)573(11.7%)0.001
Pendimethalin142(3.5%)95(0%)138(2.2%)87(4.6%)377(4.5%)0.225
Isocarbophos34(0%)33(0%)44(2.3%)40(42.5%)65(3.1%)0.747
Isazophos87(0%)76(0%)94(0%)73(0%)151(0%)NA
Fenthion46(0%)40(0%)63(0%)47(0%)102(0%)NA
Deltamethrin38(0%)38(0%)33(0%)33(0%)99(0%)NA

Detection rate of various pesticides in different areas of Henan province.

NA, Not applicable. Bold values indicates detection limit.

Discussion

A total of 10.7% samples were detected pesticide residues. In another region of China and some developing countries (32–35), a high incidence of pesticide residues was found. Among all the samples tested, there was a higher detection rate of procymidone, lambda-cyhalothrin and cypermethrin. Similar results were obtained for samples tested in the Aegean region of Turkey (10). In our detection process, leek, celery, tomato, cowpea, and pepper were found to have higher detection rates as they may be more susceptible to insect pests. However, the types of pesticide residues were not exactly the same for each vegetable, indicating the irregular distribution of various pesticides in each vegetable as well as the different pesticide application habits of vegetable farmers (36).

After stratified analysis, we found that the detection rates of lambda-cyhalothrin and pendimethalin were higher in rural than urban areas, and this difference was statistically significant. In a survey conducted in a rural French community, it was concluded that pendimethalin was the most commonly measured pesticide when investigating local atmospheric pesticide levels during pesticide application (37), which is consistent with the results of our study, probably because pendimethalin is widely used in rural agriculture due to its wide range of applications and low toxicity (38), and some farmers cannot use it correctly. In future agricultural education, it is important to enhance the knowledge of the use of pesticides so that every farmer can follow Good Agricultural Practices (GAP) (39).

A comparison of the detection rates of pesticides in several regions in Henan revealed that the detection rates of procymidone, lambda-cyhalothrin, and cypermethrin were higher in eastern Henan than other regions, and this difference was statistically significant. This result may be due to the fact that the economic pillar of Eastern Henan has always been agriculture, being the most important grain-producing area in Henan. The level of economic development is an important contributor to pesticide residue (40). Compared to other areas in Henan, the industrial base is poor and the lack of certain research institutes leads to a weaker cultural knowledge of the local people, which also has an impact on the use of pesticides, and it is urgent to strengthen the education and management of farmers.

As we know, few studies were conducted to determine the levels of pesticide residues on various vegetables frequently consumed in Henan province. In China, pesticides are widely used in crops, and a total of 13.1 kg per hectare was used per unit of cropland averagely (41), especially in vegetables (9), so we detect several pesticide residues commonly found in vegetables. Although a large proportion of the samples were not detected for pesticides, we still need to put emphasis on food safety. In future research, we need to pay more attention to what factors influence pesticide residues in vegetables so that we can resolve the problem from source. And we can't ignore the serious health effects of other pollutants on human beings and environmental pollution (42, 43), such as PCB (44) and PAHs (45, 46). In addition, better supervision and regulation of pesticides as well as education of farmers is an important issue.

Conclusions

The results have revealed that the pesticide residues are present in commonly consumed vegetables in Henan Province of China. The study provides scientific evidences of detected residues of familiar pesticides in the commonly used vegetables in Henan Province. More attention should be paid to these vegetables and areas with high detection rates, to control pesticide residues at source and ensure food safety for residents.

Funding

This research was supported by the National Key Research and Development Program of China (Grant No: 2019YFC1710002), the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant Nos: 42177415 and 21806146), the Postdoctoral Science Foundation of China (Grant Nos: 2020T130604 and 2021M702934), the Science and Technique Foundation of Henan Province (Grant No: 212102310074), the Scientific and Technological Innovation of Colleges and Universities in Henan Province Talent Support Program (Grant No: 22HASTIT044), the Young Backbone Teachers Program of Colleges and Universities in Henan Province (Grant No: 2021GGJS015), and the Excellent Youth Development Foundation of Zhengzhou University (Grant No: 2021ZDGGJS057).

Publisher's Note

All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.

Statements

Data availability statement

The raw data supporting the conclusions of this article will be made available by the authors, without undue reservation.

Author contributions

Material preparation and data analysis were performed by CM and DW. The first draft of the manuscript was written by CM and all authors commented on previous versions of the manuscript. All authors contributed to the article and approved the submitted version.

Acknowledgments

The authors thank the participants, coordinators, and administrators for their supports, and laboratory for the facility support at the school of Public Health, Zhengzhou University, during the study.

Conflict of interest

The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.

Supplementary material

The Supplementary Material for this article can be found online at: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpubh.2022.901485/full#supplementary-material

Supplementary Figure 1

Concentrations of pesticides in some vegetables with high detection rates.

Supplementary Figure 2

Concentrations of pesticides in some vegetables with high detection rates in the countryside.

Supplementary Figure 3

Concentrations of pesticides in some vegetables with high detection rates in the city.

    Abbreviations

  • GC-MS

    gas chromatography-mass spectrometry

  • r/min

    revolutions per minute.

References

  • 1.

    ToptanciİKiralanMRamadanMF. Levels of pesticide residues in fruits and vegetables in the Turkish domestic markets. Environ Sci Pollut Res Int. (2021) 28:39451–7. 10.1007/s11356-021-13538-w

  • 2.

    AmbadeB. Chemical composition of runoff water in Raipur city, central India. Applied Water Science. (2014) 5:1–12. 10.1007/s13201-014-0163-0

  • 3.

    AyasZ. Review on DDT and its residues in Turkey's wetlands. J Environ Biol. (2007) 28:707–15.

  • 4.

    JaggiSSoodCKumarVRavindranathSDShankerA. Leaching of pesticides in tea brew. J Agric Food Chem. (2001) 49:5479–83. 10.1021/jf010436d

  • 5.

    CuiYKeRGaoWTianFWangYJiangG. Analysis of organochlorine pesticide residues in various vegetable oils collected in chinese markets. J Agric Food Chem. (2020) 68:14594–602. 10.1021/acs.jafc.0c05227

  • 6.

    Sandoval-InsaustiHChiuYHLeeDHWangSHartJEMínguez-AlarcónLet al. Intake of fruits and vegetables by pesticide residue status in relation to cancer risk. Environ Inte. (2021) 156:106744. 10.1016/j.envint.2021.106744

  • 7.

    ChiuYHSandoval-InsaustiHLeySHBhupathirajuSNHauserRRimmEBet al. Association between intake of fruits and vegetables by pesticide residue status and coronary heart disease risk. Environ Int. (2019) 132:105113. 10.1016/j.envint.2019.105113

  • 8.

    KimKHKabirEJahanSA. Exposure to pesticides and the associated human health effects. Sci Total Environ. (2017) 575:525–35. 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2016.09.009

  • 9.

    YuYHuSYangYZhaoXXueJZhangJet al. Successive monitoring surveys of selected banned and restricted pesticide residues in vegetables from the northwest region of China from 2011 to 2013. BMC Public Health. (2017) 18:91. 10.1186/s12889-017-4632-x

  • 10.

    BakirciGTYaman AcayDBBakirciFÖtleşS. Pesticide residues in fruits and vegetables from the Aegean region, Turkey. Food Chem. (2014) 160:379–92. 10.1016/j.foodchem.2014.02.051

  • 11.

    JallowMFAAwadhDGAlbahoMSDeviVYAhmadN. Monitoring of pesticide residues in commonly used fruits and vegetables in kuwait. Int J Environ Res Public Health. (2017) 14:833. 10.3390/ijerph14080833

  • 12.

    MeshramSGKahyaEMeshramCGhorbaniMAAmbadeBMirabbasiR. Long-term temperature trend analysis associated with agriculture crops. Theoretical Applied Climatology. (2020) 140:1139–59. 10.1007/s00704-020-03137-z

  • 13.

    GiacintiGRaynaudCCapblancqSSimonV. Matrix-Matching as an improvement strategy for the detection of pesticide residues. J Food Sci. (2016) 81:T1342–50. 10.1111/1750-3841.13296

  • 14.

    NarenderanSTMeyyanathanSNBabuB. Review of pesticide residue analysis in fruits and vegetables. pre-treatment, extraction and detection techniques. Food Res Int. (2020) 133:109141. 10.1016/j.foodres.2020.109141

  • 15.

    MaoXWanYLiZChenLLewHYangH. Analysis of organophosphorus and pyrethroid pesticides in organic and conventional vegetables using QuEChERS combined with dispersive liquid-liquid microextraction based on the solidification of floating organic droplet. Food Chem. (2020) 309:125755. 10.1016/j.foodchem.2019.125755

  • 16.

    OsmanKAAl-HumaidAMAl-RehiayaniSMAl-RedhaimanKN. Monitoring of pesticide residues in vegetables marketed in Al-Qassim region, Saudi Arabia. Ecotoxicol Environ Saf. (2010) 73:1433–9. 10.1016/j.ecoenv.2010.05.020

  • 17.

    AlgharibehGRAlFararjehMS. Pesticide residues in fruits and vegetables in Jordan using liquid chromatography/tandem mass spectrometry. Food Addit Contam Part B Surveill. (2019) 12:65–73. 10.1080/19393210.2018.1548505

  • 18.

    VergerPAl-YousfiAB. The dilemma of pesticide residues in fruits and vegetables in the Eastern Mediterranean Region. East Mediterr Health J. (2020) 26:760–1. 10.26719/2020.26.7.760

  • 19.

    WangAMahaiGWanYJiangYMengQXiaWet al. Neonicotinoids and carbendazim in indoor dust from three cities in China: Spatial and temporal variations. Sci Total Environ. (2019) 695:133790. 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2019.133790

  • 20.

    ChenYZangLShenGLiuMDuWFeiJet al. Resolution of the ongoing challenge of estimating nonpoint source neonicotinoid pollution in the Yangtze river basin using a modified mass balance approach. Environ Sci Technol. (2019) 53:2539–48. 10.1021/acs.est.8b06096

  • 21.

    MahaiGWanYXiaWWangAShiLQianXet al. A nationwide study of occurrence and exposure assessment of neonicotinoid insecticides and their metabolites in drinking water of China. Water Res. (2021) 189:116630. 10.1016/j.watres.2020.116630

  • 22.

    ChenDLiuZBarrettHHanJLvBLiYet al. Nationwide biomonitoring of neonicotinoid insecticides in breast milk and health risk assessment to nursing infants in the Chinese population. J Agric Food Chem. (2020) 68:13906–15. 10.1021/acs.jafc.0c05769

  • 23.

    ChenDZhangYLvBLiuZHanJLiJet al. Dietary exposure to neonicotinoid insecticides and health risks in the Chinese general population through two consecutive total diet studies. Environ Int. (2020) 135:105399. 10.1016/j.envint.2019.105399

  • 24.

    WangHYangDFangHHanMTangCWuJet al. Predictors, sources, and health risk of exposure to neonicotinoids in Chinese school children: a biomonitoring-based study. Environ Int. (2020) 143:105918. 10.1016/j.envint.2020.105918

  • 25.

    ZhangTSongSBaiXHeYZhangBGuiMet al. A nationwide survey of urinary concentrations of neonicotinoid insecticides in China. Environ Int. (2019) 132:105114. 10.1016/j.envint.2019.105114

  • 26.

    KafleSVaidyaAPradhanBJørsEOntaS. Factors associated with practice of chemical pesticide use and acute poisoning experienced by farmers in Chitwan district, Nepal. Int J Env Res Public Health. (2021) 18:4194. 10.3390/ijerph18084194

  • 27.

    MostafalouSAbdollahiM. Pesticides: an update of human exposure and toxicity. Arch Toxicol. (2017) 91:549–99. 10.1007/s00204-016-1849-x

  • 28.

    LinSTangTCangTYuSYingZGuSet al. The distributions of three fungicides in vegetables and their potential health risks in Zhejiang, China: a 3-year study (2015-2017). Environ Pollution. (2020) 267:115481. 10.1016/j.envpol.2020.115481

  • 29.

    WangSWangZZhangYWangJGuoR. Pesticide residues in market foods in Shaanxi Province of China in 2010. Food Chem. (2013) 138:2016–25. 10.1016/j.foodchem.2012.11.116

  • 30.

    XuXLiLHuangXLinHLiuGXuDet al. Survey of four groups of cumulative pesticide residues in 12 vegetables in 15 provinces in China. J Food Prot. (2018) 81:377–85. 10.4315/0362-028X.JFP-17-197

  • 31.

    Data of the seventh Census (2020). Available online at: http://www.stats.gov.cn/tjsj/pcsj/ (accessed March 08, 2022).

  • 32.

    LiWTaiLLiuJGaiZDingG. Monitoring of pesticide residues levels in fresh vegetable form Heibei Province, North China. Environ Monit Assess. (2014) 186:6341–9. 10.1007/s10661-014-3858-7

  • 33.

    TrudeACBKharmatsAYHurleyKMSteevesEATalegawkarSAGittelsohnJ. Household, psychosocial, and individual-level factors associated with fruit, vegetable, and fiber intake among low-income urban African American youth. BMC Public Health. (2016) 872:16. 10.1186/s12889-016-3499-6

  • 34.

    ChiuYHAfeicheMCGaskinsAJWilliamsPLPetrozzaJCTanrikutCet al. Fruit and vegetable intake and their pesticide residues in relation to semen quality among men from a fertility clinic. Hum Reprod. (2015) 30:1342–51. 10.1093/humrep/dev064

  • 35.

    ChowdhuryMAZBanikSUddinBMoniruzzamanMKarimNGanSH. Organophosphorus and carbamate pesticide residues detected in water samples collected from paddy and vegetable fields of the Savar and Dhamrai Upazilas in Bangladesh. Int J Env Res Public Health. (2012) 9:3318–29. 10.3390/ijerph9093318

  • 36.

    QinGChenYHeFYangBZouKShenNet al. Risk assessment of fungicide pesticide residues in vegetables and fruits in the mid-western region of China. J Food Composition Analysis. (2021) 95:103663. 10.1016/j.jfca.2020.103663

  • 37.

    CoscollaCLopezAYahyaouiAColinPRobinCPoinsignonQet al. Human exposure and risk assessment to airborne pesticides in a rural French community. Sci Total Environ. (2017) 584–5. 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2017.01.132

  • 38.

    DemirNAydinSBucurgatUU. Assessment of genotoxic effects of pendimethalin in Chinese hamster over cells by the single cell gel electrophoresis (Comet) assay. Turkish J Pharmaceutical Sci. (2017) 14:185–90. 10.4274/tjps.79663

  • 39.

    PessoaMCMendesLLGomesCSMartinsPAVelasquez-MelendezG. Food environment and fruit and vegetable intake in a urban population: a multilevel analysis. BMC Public Health. (2015) 15:1012. 10.1186/s12889-015-2277-1

  • 40.

    LiuHYBaiXMPangXP. Intercity variability and local factors influencing the level of pesticide residues in marketed fruits and vegetables of China. Sci Total Environ. (2020) 700:134481. 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2019.134481

  • 41.

    ZhuWWangRM. Impact of farm size on intensity of pesticide use: evidence from China. Sci Total Environ. (2021) 753:141696. 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.141696

  • 42.

    AmbadeB. (2012). Physico-Chemical Assessment of Rain, Fog and Runoffwater: Rain, Fog and Runoff Water Pollution is the Forerunner of Perdition.Germany: Omniscriptum Gmbh & Co. Kg.

  • 43.

    HasanMFNur-E-AlamMSalamMARahmanHPaulSCRakAEet al. Health risk and water quality assessment of surface water in an urban river of Bangladesh. Sustainability. (2021) 6832:13. 10.3390/su13126832

  • 44.

    AmbadeBShubhankarBKurwadkarSKumarAVermaSKMeshramSGet al. Polychlorinated biphenyl in sediments of Subarnarekha River. In: KurwadkarSMandalPKSoniS editors. Dioxin. London: CRC Press (2020). p. 35–55.

  • 45.

    AmbadeBSethiSSKumarASankarTK. Solvent extraction coupled with gas chromatography for the analysis of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in riverine sediment and surface water of subarnarekha river and its tributary, India. In: KailasaSKHussainCM editors. Miniaturized Analytical Devices.Germany: WILEY-VCH GmbH & Co. KGaA (2022). p. 71–89.

  • 46.

    AmbadeBSethiSSGiriBBiswasJKBauddhK. Characterization, Behavior, and Risk Assessment of Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs) in the Estuary Sediments. Bull Environ Contam Toxicol. (2022) 108:243–52. 10.1007/s00128-021-03393-3

Summary

Keywords

vegetables, pesticides, residues, Henan province, GC-MS

Citation

Ma C, Wei D, Liu P, Fan K, Nie L, Song Y, Wang M, Wang L, Xu Q, Wang J, Shi J, Geng J, Zhao M, Jia Z, Huan C, Huo W, Wang C, Mao Z, Huang S and Zeng X (2022) Pesticide Residues in Commonly Consumed Vegetables in Henan Province of China in 2020. Front. Public Health 10:901485. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2022.901485

Received

22 March 2022

Accepted

23 May 2022

Published

10 June 2022

Volume

10 - 2022

Edited by

Frederick Ato Armah, University of Cape Coast, Ghana

Reviewed by

Balram Ambade, National Institute of Technology, Jamshedpur, India; Concettina Fenga, University of Messina, Italy

Updates

Copyright

*Correspondence: Xin Zeng

†These authors have contributed equally to this work and share first authorship

This article was submitted to Environmental health and Exposome, a section of the journal Frontiers in Public Health

Disclaimer

All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.

Outline

Figures

Cite article

Copy to clipboard


Export citation file


Share article

Article metrics