Sarah Wigham
Patricia Watts2
Ania Zubala- 1Faculty of Medical Sciences, Population Health Sciences Institute, Newcastle University, Newcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom
- 2Teapot Trust, Edinburgh, United Kingdom
- 3Institute of Health Research and Innovation, University of the Highlands and Islands, Inverness, United Kingdom
- 4Newcastle upon Tyne Hospital NHS Foundation Trust, Newcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom
- 5Cumbria, Northumberland Tyne and Wear NHS Foundation Trust, Newcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom
Background: Children with physical health long-term conditions (LTCs) have increased risk of mental health difficulties relative to healthy peers. However, availability of psychological support integrated into pediatric physical health settings is limited, and there are long waiting times for access to child mental health services. Arts-based therapies involve using creative media to develop a therapeutic relationship, and offer a potential alternative to talking-based therapies. The aim of this systematic review is to establish the effectiveness of arts-based therapies for improving the mental health of children with physical health LTCs.
Methods: The review protocol was published on PROSPERO. Four electronic databases were searched (Medline, Embase, Cinahl, and PsycINFO), plus hand searches of two key journals and relevant reviews, and forward/back citations searches of selected articles were conducted. The Effective Public Health Practice Project (EPHPP) Quality Assessment Tool was used to assess bias in selected articles. Second reviewers completed 10% of article screening and 20% of bias assessments. The findings were synthesized narratively.
Results: Sixteen studies met inclusion criteria and demonstrated some improvements on indicators of mental health and well-being including quality of life, coping behaviors, anxiety, self-concept, and mood. However, replication across interventions and outcomes was absent. Overall, the quality of evidence of effectiveness in the studies reviewed was moderate/weak. This was due to bias in study design; other limitations included a lack of detail on intervention components, e.g., use of a manual, and single recruitment sites.
Conclusions: The heterogeneity of existing research evaluating arts-based therapies for children with physical health LTCs limits conclusions about effectiveness. Suggestions are made to inform the design of future research studies to help build a robust evidence base.
Introduction
Pediatric physical health long-term conditions (LTCs) have a childhood onset, require ongoing management over a long period of time, are often multi-system, and typically require complex treatments with both medications and non-pharmacological interventions and services (Mokkink et al., 2008; DoH, 2012). Pediatric physical health LTCs require significant psychological adjustments to symptoms, medical regimes, and pain and may detrimentally affect the well-being of children relative to healthy peers (Denny et al., 2014; Kazak et al., 2015). Children may be isolated from peers during hospital stays and miss participating in activities that contribute to quality of life, and research suggests that children with physical health LTCs are susceptible to poor mental health (Knight et al., 2015; Butler et al., 2018). The prevalence of anxiety and depression is high, and mental health and well-being difficulties are up to four times higher in children with physical health LTCs than in healthy peers (Hysing et al., 2007; Pinquart and Shen, 2011a,b; Ferro, 2016; Brady et al., 2017). Mental health is a key predictor of a successful clinical course; for example, baseline depression in children with rheumatic diseases was associated with higher levels of pain and disability 4 years later (Colver et al., 2018; Gray et al., 2018; Hanns et al., 2018). Good childhood mental health optimizes engagement in daily activities for children and families; facilitates psychosocial development, educational attainment, and increased life-course opportunity; and protects against adult mental health problems (DoH, 2011; Colver et al., 2018; Tollisen et al., 2018). Additionally, parents of children with physical health LTCs are prone to high levels of stress/distress, and poor mental health of their child may be an additional burden on them and on child mental health services, which are under-resourced (Crouch et al., 2019; Rosenberg et al., 2019).
Given the potential burden of poor mental health, UK statutory guidance identifies integration of psychological support into pediatric physical health settings as an indicator of service quality (DoH, 2011; Foster et al., 2017; Parsons et al., 2017; NHSE, 2018). However, evidence suggests that services for pediatric physical health LTCs are not routinely set up in this way, staff time and resources are limited, access to psychological support is patchy, and there are long wait lists for child and adolescent mental health services (Wiener et al., 2015; Cruikshank et al., 2016; Davis et al., 2017). Further, there are currently significant gaps in the evidence base for the best type of psychological support for children with physical health LTCs (Kazak et al., 2015; Knight et al., 2019).
A review evaluating psychological interventions for anxiety and depression in children with physical health LTCs found cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) effective under certain circumstances—in the short-term for mild/moderate symptoms of depression (Thabrew et al., 2018). A recent evidence synthesis evaluated a range of mental health interventions for children with physical health LTCs, for example, parenting interventions, play therapy, relaxation, and emotional intelligence training (Moore et al., 2019). The review utilized meta-ethnography and identified benefits from the perspectives of patients, families, and practitioners experiencing the interventions (Moore et al., 2019; Shaw et al., 2019). The authors developed a conceptual model of constructs (e.g., empowerment) important for enabling benefit from mental health interventions for children with physical health LTCs (Moore et al., 2019; Shaw et al., 2019). Although some evidence of effectiveness was found for CBT, the review also highlighted an overall lack of quantitative evidence of the effectiveness of mental health interventions for children with physical health LTCs and the absence of trials conducted in the UK (Moore et al., 2019).
The aim of the current review is to inform preparation for a feasibility trial of arts-based therapies in the UK National Health Service (NHS). NICE defines arts-based therapies as psychotherapeutic techniques combined with creative activities to facilitate self-expression and recommends their provision in the management of children with psychosis (NICE, 2016). Arts-based therapies involve using creative media to develop a therapeutic relationship and can be an alternative to talking-therapies through facilitating the expression of inner states that are difficult to articulate verbally (American Art Therapy Association, 2018; Fancourt and Finn, 2019). Although the benefits of arts-based therapies in mental health settings suggest the potential for transferability to physical health services, arts-based therapies are not routinely available as a psychological support in UK NHS physical health settings.
Research has demonstrated some positive effects of arts-based therapies for children with physical health LTCs; however, the evidence base is small (Cohen-Yatziv and Regev, 2019). Previous reviews relevant to this clinical group include two reviews of visual art therapy—one for children with a range of physical health conditions (Clapp et al., 2018) and one focusing on children with cancer (Aguilar, 2017). A systematic review of music interventions for patients with cancer was not specific to children (also included adult samples) and included studies evaluating physical health outcomes (without measurement of mental health outcomes) and studies evaluating music as a distraction (Bradt et al., 2016). These reviews identified some small evidence of effectiveness and some bias in the design of previous studies, and our review builds on the findings of these reviews. Our specific focus is evaluating the potential of arts-based therapies as a psychological support for pediatric physical health settings and the identification of methodological characteristics important to consider in designing future robust research studies to contribute to building an evidence base (Cohen-Yatziv and Regev, 2019). In preparation for a feasibility trial of arts-based therapies in the UK NHS, we reviewed existing arts-based therapy studies in order to help design the trial.
Aims of the Study
The aims of this systematic review are to (i) identify studies evaluating the effectiveness of arts-based therapies for improving the mental health of children with physical health LTCs and (ii) examine the quality of the identified studies using a formal assessment tool.
Methods
A systematic review was reported in accordance with PRISMA guidelines (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses) (Moher et al., 2009). The protocol was published on PROSPERO (CRD registration number: 42019134461).
Inclusion Criteria
Inclusion criteria for the review and PICO components (population, intervention, comparator, and outcome) are shown in Table 1A. Inclusion criteria comprised the following: studies recruiting participants ≤18 years of age with pediatric physical health LTCs, defined as requiring ongoing management with medication and/or other treatment interventions over a long period of time (Mokkink et al., 2008; DoH, 2012); studies evaluating arts-based therapies, defined as systematic interventions implemented by a therapist with the aim of improving health through creative expression (for example, drawing, play, photography, movement, music) and a therapeutic relationship promoting communication, connection, and self-awareness (NICE, 2016; Hackett et al., 2017; American Art Therapy Association, 2018); additionally, only articles published after the year 2000 given rapid developments in medical settings and treatment interventions; and finally, those using a published outcome measure or structured assessment (e.g., time sampling) of mental health or well-being.
Table 1A. Inclusion criteria.
We conducted the searches in May 2020, and Table 1B shows the information sources. We searched four electronic databases, conducted hand searches of two key journals, searched reference lists of relevant reviews, and conducted forward/back citations searches of articles meeting inclusion criteria. The search strategy for Medline is shown in Table A1.
Table 1B. Information sources.
Study Selection
One researcher (SW) screened titles and abstracts of articles identified in the searches, with 10% independently screened by a second reviewer (AZ), and the level of agreement was 96%. Ambiguous articles were included. 98 articles were selected for full-text screening. SW carried out full-text screening, with 10% screened independently by a second reviewer (AZ). Agreement was 100%. Figure 1 shows the selection process to determine the eligibility of articles for inclusion in the review.
Figure 1. The PRISMA flowchart showing study selection process.
Synthesis
Due to high heterogeneity in study design, quantitative synthesis of information was not possible, and we used a narrative synthesis of intervention effectiveness incorporating four elements—intervention conceptualization and theoretical model, tabulation of information, exploring patterns within and across studies, and assessment of methodological quality (Popay et al., 2006).
Intervention Conceptualization and Theoretical Model
Various conceptualizations of arts-based therapies occur in the literature. In this review, we focus on arts-based therapies (visual, drama, music, and play) that include interaction, development of a therapeutic relationship, and facilitating communication and expression (NICE, 2016; Hackett et al., 2017; American Art Therapy Association, 2018). We excluded articles evaluating use of art media for distraction, (e.g., while having an injection), for leisure (e.g., listening to music), or for education. The purpose of the review was to inform the design of a randomized feasibility study of arts-based therapies in the UK NHS. We built a logic model (Figure 3) showing areas we felt may be important in a trial evaluating the effectiveness of arts-based therapies in pediatric physical health settings in order to guide information extraction and interpretation of the review findings, and we developed the model informed by the synthesis (Popay et al., 2006).
Assessment of Methodological Quality
Studies were assessed for risk of bias by SW using the Effective Public Health Practice Project (EPHPP) Quality Assessment Tool (Thomas et al., 2004). JB and AZ independently rated 20%, and agreement was 80%.
Results
Key Characteristics of Studies
Three thousand three hundred and fifty articles were identified from the electronic database searches after removal of duplicates. After title/abstract screening, 98 articles were screened in full, and 16 articles were selected for inclusion in the review. Information was extracted and tabulated, with Tables 2, 3 showing study characteristics and Table 4 showing significant findings from the selected articles.
Table 2. Participant, study, and intervention characteristics.
Table 3. Intervention characteristics.
Table 4. Outcome measures and results.
Eight studies were conducted in the USA (Robb, 2000; Colwell et al., 2005, 2013; Robb et al., 2008, 2014; Beebe et al., 2010; Madden et al., 2010; Stafstrom et al., 2012), two studies were carried out in Canada (Barrera et al., 2002; MacDonald et al., 2019), one in Iraq (Abdulah and Abdulla, 2018), one in Hong Kong (Li et al., 2011), two in Iran (Khodabakhshi Koolaee et al., 2016; Tomaj et al., 2016), one in Italy (Giordano et al., 2020), and one study in Sweden (Uggla et al., 2018).
Quality of Studies Included in This Review
The quality of studies was appraised using structured criteria relevant for intervention effectiveness evaluations, and Figure 2 shows a summary of the quality assessments (Thomas et al., 2004). None of the studies had global ratings of high quality, 13 studies had a moderate global rating, and 3 studies had weak ratings of quality. All studies had some strong components (e.g., describing participant randomization, use of a published outcome measure); however, the global quality rating of all articles was reduced by specific design limitations. These included confounding variables, a narrow recruitment pool (e.g., one inpatient unit), or a lack of blinding. The purpose of the quality appraisal was to identify areas to address when designing a future trial, and potential bias in the studies reviewed is integrated into the narrative synthesis below and informs the model in Figure 3.
Figure 2. Quality assessment of studies included in the review.
Figure 3. Conceptual model of characteristics important for future research trials evaluating effectiveness of arts-based therapies for mental health and well-being in pediatric physical health settings.
Narrative Synthesis
Given that evidence of the effectiveness of psychological interventions for individual pediatric physical health conditions is limited (Moore et al., 2019), we present the results according to health condition.
Arts-Based Therapies for Children With Cancer
Nine studies evaluated arts-based therapies for children with cancer. Six studies had controlled designs, three of those describing a randomization process and the remainder having cohort designs.
Children With Cancer: Arts-Based Therapies Using Visual Media
Two studies evaluated visual/craft media (Khodabakhshi Koolaee et al., 2016; Abdulah and Abdulla, 2018). In the first study, parent-reported health-related quality of life measured using a short (10-item) questionnaire improved after a group intervention, though a limitation of the study was no measurement of child-reported outcomes (Abdulah and Abdulla, 2018). The authors stated that the intervention was not provided during chemotherapy, and this level of detail is important information for replication in future research and practice. The second study using visual media demonstrated significantly more reductions in anger and anxiety for the intervention group; a strength of the study was the specific inclusion criteria (scoring above the mean on standardized measures of anxiety and anger) and provision of an intervention schedule (Khodabakhshi Koolaee et al., 2016). The study demonstrated statistically significant post-intervention improvements but did not report whether changes were clinically significant. Both studies recruited narrow age groups relative to other studies reviewed, and this is a strength given developmental differences, though scant detail on intervention components or where to find detailed intervention schedules was a limitation.
Children With Cancer: Arts-Based Therapies Using Music
Five studies evaluated the effectiveness of music-based therapies for children with cancer (Robb, 2000; Barrera et al., 2002; Colwell et al., 2005; Robb et al., 2008; Giordano et al., 2020). The first study provided a detailed protocol and demonstrated that music elicited significantly more engaging behavior but no improvements on an outcome measure of affect (Robb, 2000). Music-based therapy was associated with improvements in feelings (e.g., “It made my nausea go away”) for actively involved Canadian pediatric hematology inpatients (Barrera et al., 2002). A limitation was the single-group single-site design, while a strength was the use of child- and parent-reported outcome measures and qualitative assessment of acceptability (Barrera et al., 2002). A third study evaluating music-based therapy for children with cancer recruited from an inpatient service demonstrated significant improvements in self-concept, though the control group had art activities, which may have been a confounder (Colwell et al., 2005). Strengths of the study were the use of a board-certified therapist and a computer music program, suggesting potential for replication. Giordano et al. (2020) evaluated pre-operative music therapy for children with leukemia and parents and found less anxiety relative to a control group, and acceptability to medical staff was high. Finally Robb et al. (2008) demonstrated significantly more positive coping behaviors including smiling and active engagement in music group participants compared to two control groups. Although published outcome measures were not used, the study was included in the review because outcomes were assessed using a formalized behavioral rating system with integrated reliability checks. A strength of the study was the multi-site randomized controlled trial (RCT) design and the use of intervention delivery guides.
Children With Cancer: Composite Arts-Based Therapies (Music, Movement, and Art) and Virtual Reality Play Therapy
One study evaluating a composite arts-based intervention (music, movement, and art) described very specific participant inclusion criteria—those with a brain tumor, receiving treatment for at least 3 months, no less than weekly (Madden et al., 2010). The development of psychological interventions for children with specific physical health conditions has been recommended (Moore et al., 2019). This is therefore a strength of the study, compared to other studies reviewed recruiting children with a heterogeneity of conditions. A limitation was the wide age range of participants, while another study strength was a mixed methods design, including qualitative perspectives of service providers. Service provider perspectives were positive, while child-reported mood and parent-reported pain improved significantly (Madden et al., 2010).
One study evaluated virtual reality play therapy using published measures of anxiety and depression (Li et al., 2011). This is a study strength in relation to other included studies, as limited availability of reliable psychological interventions specifically for anxiety and depression in children with physical health LTCs has been described (Thabrew et al., 2018). There were significantly more reductions in depression symptoms in the intervention group (Li et al., 2011).
In summary, nine studies examined the effectiveness of arts-based therapies on the mental well-being of children undergoing treatment for cancer. Overall, the studies indicated some positive impact; however, the heterogeneity of intervention content and implementation, the outcomes measured, and limitations regarding study quality (e.g., presence of confounding variables, lack of randomization, and single-site evaluations) make it difficult to draw firm conclusions and generalizations or to replicate studies.
Arts-Based Therapies for Children With Blood Disorders and Other Health Conditions
Children With Blood Disorders and Other Health Conditions: Arts-Based Therapies Using Visual Media
Three studies evaluated interventions for children with asthma, epilepsy, and insulin-dependent diabetes (Beebe et al., 2010; Stafstrom et al., 2012; MacDonald et al., 2019).
The first study using visual craft media demonstrated improved mood and quality of life in children with asthma, recruited from a school outpatient clinic (Beebe et al., 2010). Study strengths were measuring child- and parent-report perspectives, providing an intervention schedule, use of health condition–specific outcome measures, controlled design, and data collection 6 months post-intervention.
In the second study, 16 children with epilepsy reported positively on art therapy received; however, outcome measures showed no improvements (Stafstrom et al., 2012). Lastly, 80% of participants with diabetes rated arts-based therapies positively in a satisfaction survey; however, participants were required to attend weekly from remote/rural locations, and attrition was high (MacDonald et al., 2019).
Children With Blood Disorders and Other Health Conditions: Music Media and Play Therapy
Children with a range of health conditions receiving one-to-one music-based therapy demonstrated significant reductions in anxiety or pain but no more so than control groups (music listening/composition) (Colwell et al., 2013). A multi-site music therapy evaluation (n = 113) for children with hematopoietic stem cell transplants demonstrated social, family, and spiritual improvements 3 months post-intervention (Robb et al., 2014). A strength of the study was a process for assessing intervention fidelity across sites/therapists.
An RCT of music-based therapy for children receiving hematopoietic stem cell transplants showed improved physical function post-intervention. A study strength was describing parent involvement and the wait-list control design, so all participants had access to the intervention (Uggla et al., 2018).
Finally self-concept was improved 1 month post-intervention (eight play therapy sessions) for 60 children with thalassemia major across two hospital sites (Tomaj et al., 2016).
In summary, seven studies examined the effectiveness of arts-based therapies on the mental well-being of children undergoing treatment for blood disorders and other health conditions. Once again, the studies indicated some positive impact, but significant heterogeneity of intervention characteristics (e.g., whether individual or group format), variety of outcomes measured, and design limitations mean that firm conclusions about effectiveness across studies are not possible.
Discussion
The review identified and appraised 16 articles evaluating the effectiveness of arts-based therapies for improving the mental health of children with physical health LTCs. Some improvements were demonstrated in articles selected, including, for example, improved quality of life, coping behaviors, self-concept, improved mood, and reduced anxiety. Participants included children with a range of physical health LTCs, and interventions comprised arts-based therapies utilizing music, play, and visual media in the context of a therapeutic relationship. However, the heterogeneity in intervention characteristics and design limitations identified mean that it is not possible to make conclusions about effectiveness across studies. Further, the review highlights that the existing evidence base for the effectiveness of arts-based therapies as a psychological intervention for pediatric physical health settings is sparse and requires development (Cohen-Yatziv and Regev, 2019).
A lack of post-intervention positive changes on published outcome measures, in some studies, contrasted with measures of satisfaction (where used), which did indicate benefits. This is in accordance with the findings of a recent evidence synthesis of mental health interventions for children with physical health LTCs, which found meta-ethnographic evidence of benefit but a lack of effectiveness evidence (Moore et al., 2019). This underlines the importance of measuring outcomes using quantitative and qualitative methods across a range of indicators (e.g., school attendance) and from a range of perspectives when designing future evaluations of arts-based therapies for children with physical health LTCs. The strengths and limitations of the studies reviewed informed a logic model (Figure 3), and we use this to make suggestions to guide the design of future research evaluations of the effectiveness of arts-based therapies for children with physical health LTCs in order to help develop the field (Cohen-Yatziv and Regev, 2019). For example, none of the studies reviewed assessed if changes reached minimum thresholds for clinically significant or meaningful change (de Vet et al., 2006); further, most of the effectiveness evaluations in the studies reviewed are cross-sectional. In future studies, quantitative prospective assessments would facilitate evaluating sustained effects after the intervention, and the use of outcome measures with published norm/cut-scores would facilitate more accurate interpretation of any changes in scores resulting from interventions. Most studies recruited participants from a single site. Future research recruiting from multiple sites should incorporate processes for ensuring intervention consistency between sites, evaluation of intervention effectiveness across sites, and feasibility of sustainable integration of arts-based therapies into pediatric physical health LTC service structures, including identification of barriers and facilitators. Most of the studies were conducted in the USA and generalizability to the UK NHS or health services in other countries cannot be assumed, given different health service structures and funding.
Review Strengths and Limitations
Limitations of the review include small numbers of studies identified and heterogeneity in their design, so quantitative pooling of results across studies or health conditions was not possible. Arts-based therapies may require tailoring for children with different physical health LTCs; however, an in-depth synthesis of findings on the effectiveness of arts-based therapies for specific health conditions was not possible.
We have taken a reductionist perspective of effectiveness; our inclusion criterion was studies using published mental health outcome measures, and we excluded qualitative studies. We acknowledge that this definition of effectiveness will not capture all effects, mechanisms, and dynamic processes of change occurring during arts-based therapies (Gerber et al., 2018). We did not screen gray literature or include end-user consultation, and we did not have resources to complete full independent screening and quality appraisals or translate and include articles not published in English. These are potential sources of bias in our review.
The aim of the review was to explore the effectiveness of arts-based therapies to improve mental health for children with physical health LTCs. Only one RCT of an arts-based therapy (music) was identified in a recent review of psychological interventions for children with physical health LTCs (Moore et al., 2019). Given this, we looked broadly and included cohort and within-subject designs, which are, however, not strong indicators of effectiveness. Elevated mental health symptoms were not an inclusion criterion for our review, and only one study (Khodabakhshi Koolaee et al., 2016) recruited participants scoring above the mean on standardized measures (of anxiety and anger); this is a limitation of our review with regard to assessing improved mental health. However, given the long wait times for access to child mental health services, it is important to explore the effectiveness of reducing sub-threshold mental health symptoms and any preventative potential of arts-based therapies, and this is a strength of the review (NHS Digital, 2019).
Study Implications and Future Research
The review identified a number of design limitations important to address in future research, and we have summarized these in a model. Future trials would benefit from including end-user consultation in intervention design and service integration and could evaluate the involvement of parents and online formats of delivery to support transferring acquired/internalized coping skills outside/after intervention and for children in remote locations.
The choice of evidence-based psychological interventions available for children with physical health LTCs is currently small (Moore et al., 2019). Arts-based therapies present a potential option; however, the findings from the review confirm that research is required prior to any sustainable integration into physical heath settings. The review has highlighted some areas to clarify in future research. None of the studies reviewed distinguished between using arts-based therapies as preventative or treatment interventions. Given health service resource constraints, it is unlikely that arts-based therapies can be available to all children in physical health LTC settings, so this distinction requires consideration in future studies. Future research should evaluate how arts-based therapies might be integrated into assessment processes to support clinical teams in identifying mental health difficulties and facilitate children accessing the support they require early. In future research, economic analysis could facilitate examining any savings made by avoiding treatment complications through providing arts-based therapies (Seid et al., 2004; Shaw, 2016). In the absence of any extra health service funding, economic evaluations including an invest-to-save analysis will be important to demonstrate any reduced costs from integrating arts-based therapies in the NHS, e.g., fewer referrals to child and adolescent mental health services (Shaw, 2016). Participant inclusion criteria were not always clear in the studies reviewed. Again, limited health service resources will influence decisions about access to psychological interventions, and identifying the characteristics of children who may benefit most from arts-based therapies is important to clarify in future research and could be explored using mixed methods approaches.
Conclusions
Integration of psychological support into pediatric physical health settings is an indicator of service quality (DoH, 2011; Foster et al., 2017; Parsons et al., 2017; NHSE, 2018). However, there is limited evidence-based psychological support available for children with physical health LTCs, and this is a barrier to the provision of integrated services (Thabrew et al., 2018; Moore et al., 2019). The findings from this systematic review of effectiveness demonstrated that replication of interventions and outcomes across studies was absent, so conclusions about the effectiveness of arts-based therapies for improving the mental well-being of children with physical health LTCs cannot be made. The findings also highlight design characteristics important to incorporate when developing future trials evaluating the effectiveness of arts-based therapies. If future robustly designed research studies can demonstrate the effectiveness of arts-based therapies for children with physical health LTCs, commissioning is more likely, and this could potentially create increased choice of psychological interventions for children and families, be an alternative to talking-based therapies for children who might find it hard to speak about their difficulties, and increase the resources available for service providers.
Data Availability Statement
All datasets presented in this study are included in the article/supplementary material.
Author Contributions
SH, SW, PW, AZ, and SJ conceptualized the review. SW, AZ, and JB analyzed results. SW wrote the first draft of the manuscript. All authors contributed to editing, commenting, and revising manuscript versions, read and approved the submitted version.
Funding
We are grateful to Newcastle upon Tyne Hospitals NHS Charity (reg. 1057213) for funding this study.
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
References
Abdulah, D. M., and Abdulla, B. M. O. (2018). Effectiveness of group art therapy on quality of life in paediatric patients with cancer: a randomized controlled trial. Complement. Ther. Med. 41, 180–185. doi: 10.1016/j.ctim.2018.09.020
Aguilar, B. A. (2017). The efficacy of art therapy in pediatric oncology patients: an integrative literature review. J. Pediatr. Nurs. 36, 173–178. doi: 10.1016/j.pedn.2017.06.015
American Art Therapy Association (2018). About Art Therapy. Available online at: https://arttherapy.org/about-art-therapy/ (accessed January 31, 2020).
Austin, J. K., and Huberty, T. J. (1993). Development of the child attitude toward illness scale. J. Pediatr. Psychol. 18, 467–480. doi: 10.1093/jpepsy/18.4.467
Barrera, M. E., Rykov, M. H., and Doyle, S. L. (2002). The effects of interactive music therapy on hospitalized children with cancer: a pilot study. Psychooncology 11, 379–388. doi: 10.1002/pon.589
Beck, J. S., Beck, A. T., and Jolly, J. B. (2005). Beck Youth Inventories-(BYI-II). San Antonio, Tx: PsychCorp. Pearson Clinical.
Beebe, A., Gelfand, E. W., and Bender, B. (2010). A randomized trial to test the effectiveness of art therapy for children with asthma. J. Allergy Clin. Immunol. 126, 263–266. doi: 10.1016/j.jaci.2010.03.019
Bieri, D., Reeve, R. A., Champion, G. D., Addicoat, L., and Ziegler, J. B. (1990). The Faces Pain Scale for the self-assessment of the severity of pain experienced by children: development, initial validation, and preliminary investigation for ratio scale properties. Pain 41, 139–150. doi: 10.1016/0304-3959(90)90018-9
Bradt, J., Dileo, C., Magill, L., and Teague, A. (2016). Music interventions for improving psychological and physical outcomes in cancer patients. Cochrane Database Syst. Rev. 8. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD006911.pub3
Brady, A. M., Deighton, J., and Stansfeld, S. (2017). Psychiatric outcomes associated with chronic illness in adolescence: a systematic review. J. Adolesc. 59, 112–123. doi: 10.1016/j.adolescence.2017.05.014
Butler, A., Van Lieshout, R. J., Lipman, E. L., MacMillan, H. L., Gonzalez, A., Gorter, J. W., et al. (2018). Mental disorder in children with physical conditions: a pilot study. BMJ Open 8:e019011. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2017-019011
Clapp, L. A., Taylor, E. P., Di Folco, S., and Mackinnon, V. L. (2018). Effectiveness of art therapy with pediatric populations affected by medical health conditions: a systematic review. Arts Health 11, 183–201. doi: 10.1080/17533015.2018.1443952
Cohen-Yatziv, L., and Regev, D. (2019). The effectiveness and contribution of art therapy work with children in 2018-what progress has been made so far? A systematic review. Int. J. Art Ther. 24, 100–112. doi: 10.1080/17454832.2019.1574845
Colver, A., McConachie, H., Le Couteur, A., Dovey-Pearce, G., Mann, K. D., McDonagh, J. E., et al. (2018). A longitudinal, observational study of the features of transitional healthcare associated with better outcomes for young people with long-term conditions. BMC Med. 16:111. doi: 10.1186/s12916-018-1102-y
Colwell, C. M., Davis, K., and Schroeder, L. K. (2005). The effect of composition (art or music) on the self-concept of hospitalized children. J. Music Ther. 42, 49–63. doi: 10.1093/jmt/42.1.49
Colwell, C. M., Edwards, R., Hernandez, E., and Brees, K. (2013). Impact of music therapy interventions (listening, composition, orff-based) on the physiological and psychosocial behaviors of hospitalized children: a feasibility study. J. Pediatr. Nurs. 28, 249–257. doi: 10.1016/j.pedn.2012.08.008
Crouch, L., Reardon, T., Farrington, A., Glover, F., and Creswell, C. (2019). “Just keep pushing”: parents' experiences of accessing child and adolescent mental health services for child anxiety problems. Child Care Health Dev. 45, 491–499. doi: 10.1111/cch.12672
Cruikshank, M., Foster, H. E., Stewart, J., Davidson, J. E., and Rapley, T. (2016). Transitional care in clinical networks for young people with juvenile idiopathic arthritis: current situation and challenges. Clin. Rheumatol. 35, 893–899. doi: 10.1007/s10067-015-2950-x
Davis, A. M., Rubinstein, T. B., Rodriguez, M., and Knight, A. M. (2017). Mental health care for youth with rheumatologic diseases–bridging the gap. Pediatr. Rheumatol. 15:85. doi: 10.1186/s12969-017-0214-9
de Vet, H. C., Terwee, C. B., Ostelo, R. W., Beckerman, H., Knol, D. L., and Bouter, L. M. (2006). Minimal changes in health status questionnaires: distinction between minimally detectable change and minimally important change. Health Qual. Life Outcomes 4:54. doi: 10.1186/1477-7525-4-54
Denny, S., de Silva, M., Fleming, T., Clark, T., Merry, S., Ameratunga, S., et al. (2014). The prevalence of chronic health conditions impacting on daily functioning and the association with emotional well-being among a national sample of high school students. J. Adolesc. Health 54, 410–415. doi: 10.1016/j.jadohealth.2013.09.010
DoH (2011). No Health Without Mental Health: A Cross-Government Mental Health Outcomes Strategy for People of All Ages. Supporting Document–The Economic Case for Improving Efficiency and Quality in Mental Health. Leeds: Department of Health.
DoH (2012). Long Term Conditions Compendium of Information: Third Edition, 3rd Edn. Leeds: Department of Health.
Fancourt, D., and Finn, S. (2019). What is the Evidence on the Role of the Arts in Improving Health and Well-Being. A Scoping Review. Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe.
Ferro, M. (2016). Major depressive disorder, suicidal behaviour, bipolar disorder, and generalised anxiety disorder among emerging adults with and without chronic health conditions. Epidemiol. Psychiatr. Sci. 25, 462–474. doi: 10.1017/S2045796015000700
Foster, H. E., Minden, K., Clemente, D., Leon, L., McDonagh, J. E., Kamphuis, S., et al. (2017). EULAR/PReS standards and recommendations for the transitional care of young people with juvenile-onset rheumatic diseases. Ann. Rheum. Dis. 76, 639–646. doi: 10.1136/annrheumdis-2016-210112
Gantt, L., and Tabone, C. (2003). “The formal elements art therapy scale and “draw a person picking an apple from a tree,” in Handbook of Art Therapy, ed C. Malchiodi (New York, NY: Guilford), 420–427.
Gerber, N., Bryl, K., Potvin, N., and Blank, C. A. (2018). Arts-based research approaches to studying mechanisms of change in the creative Arts therapies. Front. Psychol. 9:2076. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2018.02076
Giordano, F., Zanchi, B., De Leonardis, F., Rutigliano, C., Esposito, F., Brienza, N., et al. (2020). The influence of music therapy on preoperative anxiety in pediatric oncology patients undergoing invasive procedures. Arts Psychother. 68:101649. doi: 10.1016/j.aip.2020.101649
Gray, S., Cheetham, T., McConachie, H., Mann, K. D., Parr, J. R., Pearce, M. S, et al. (2018). A longitudinal, observational study examining the relationships of patient satisfaction with services and mental well-being to their clinical course in young people with Type 1 diabetes mellitus during transition from child to adult health services. Diabet. Med. 35, 1216–1222. doi: 10.1111/dme.13698
Hackett, S. S., Ashby, L., Parker, K., Goody, S., and Power, N. (2017). UK art therapy practice-based guidelines for children and adults with learning disabilities. Int. J. Art Ther. 22, 84–94. doi: 10.1080/17454832.2017.1319870
Hanns, L., Cordingley, L., Galloway, J., Norton, S., Carvalho, L. A., Christie, D., et al. (2018). Depressive symptoms, pain and disability for adolescent patients with juvenile idiopathic arthritis: results from the Childhood Arthritis Prospective Study. Rheumatology 57, 1381–1389. doi: 10.1093/rheumatology/key088
Hysing, M., Elgen, I., Gillberg, C., Lie, S. A., and Lundervold, A. J. (2007). Chronic physical illness and mental health in children. Results from a large-scale population study. J. Child Psychol. Psychiatry. 48, 785–792. doi: 10.1111/j.1469-7610.2007.01755.x
Jenkins, B. N., Fortier, M. A., Kaplan, S. H., Mayes, L. C., and Kain, Z. N. (2014). Development of a short version of the modified yale preoperative anxiety scale. Anesth. Analg. 119, 643–650. doi: 10.1213/ANE.0000000000000350
Kazak, A. E., Abrams, A. N., Banks, J., Christofferson, J., DiDonato, S., Grootenhuis, M. A., et al. (2015). Psychosocial assessment as a standard of care in pediatric cancer. Pediatr. Blood Cancer 62, 426–459. doi: 10.1002/pbc.25730
Khodabakhshi Koolaee, A., Vazifehdar, R., and Bahari, F. (2016). Impact of painting therapy on aggression and anxiety of children with cancer. Caspian J. Pediatr. 2, 135–141.
Knight, A., Vickery, M., Faust, L., Muscal, E., Davis, A., Harris, J., et al. (2019). Gaps in mental health care for youth with rheumatologic conditions: a mixed methods study of perspectives from behavioral health providers. Arthritis Care Res. 71, 591–601. doi: 10.1002/acr.23683
Knight, A., Weiss, P., Morales, K., Gerdes, M., Rearson, M., Vickery, M., et al. (2015). Identifying differences in risk factors for depression and anxiety in pediatric chronic disease: a matched cross-sectional study of youth with lupus/mixed connective tissue disease and their peers with diabetes. J. Pediatr. 167, 1397–1403. doi: 10.1016/j.jpeds.2015.07.048
Lamers, S. M., Westerhof, G. J., Bohlmeijer, E. T., ten Klooster, P. M., and Keyes, C. L. (2011). Evaluating the psychometric properties of the mental health continuum-short form (MHC-SF). J. Clin. Psychol. 67, 99–110. doi: 10.1002/jclp.20741
Lansky, S. B., List, M. A., Lansky, L. L., Ritter-Sterr, C., and Miller, D. R. (1987). The measurement of performance in childhood cancer patients. Cancer 60, 1651–1656. doi: 10.1002/1097-0142(19871001)60:7<1651::AID-CNCR2820600738>3.0.CO;2-J
Li, H. C. W., and Lopez, V. (2007). Development and validation of a short form of the Chinese version of the State Anxiety Scale for Children. Int. J. Nurs. Stud. 44, 566–573. doi: 10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2005.12.004
Li, W., Chung, J. O., and Ho, E. (2011). The effectiveness of therapeutic play, using virtual reality computer games, in promoting the psychological well-being of children hospitalised with cancer. J. Clin. Nurs. 20, 2135–2143. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2702.2011.03733.x
Lundqvist, P., Kleberg, A., Edberg, A. K., Larsson, B. A., Hellström-Westas, L., and Norman, E. (2014). Development and psychometric properties of the Swedish ALPS-Neo pain and stress assessment scale for newborn infants. Acta Paediatr. 103, 833–839. doi: 10.1111/apa.12672
MacDonald, C., Friedman, S., and Marks, S. (2019). Creative arts diabetes initiative: group art therapy and peer support for youth and young adults transitioning from pediatric to adult diabetes care in Manitoba. Can. J. Diabetes 34, 377–383. doi: 10.1016/j.jcjd.2019.04.016
Madden, J. R., Mowry, P., Gao, D., McGuire Cullen, P., and Foreman, N. K. (2010). Creative arts therapy improves quality of life for pediatric brain tumor patients receiving outpatient chemotherapy. J. Pediatr. Oncol. Nurs. 27, 133–145. doi: 10.1177/1043454209355452
McGrath, P. A. (1985). “Multidimensional pain assessment in children,” in Advances in Pain Research and Therapy, ed H. L. Fields (New York, NY: Raven Press), 387–393.
McGrath, P. A., Seifert, C. E., Speechley, K. N., Booth, J. C., Stitt, L., and Gibson, M. C. (1996). A new analogue scale for assessing children's pain: an initial validation study. Pain 64, 435–443. doi: 10.1016/0304-3959(95)00171-9
Moher, D., Liberati, A., Tetzlaff, J., Altman, D. G., and Prisma Group (2009). Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. PLoS Med. 6:e1000097. doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1000097
Mokkink, L. B., Van Der Lee, J. H., Grootenhuis, M. A., Offringa, M., and Heymans, H. S. (2008). Defining chronic diseases and health conditions in childhood (0–18 years of age): national consensus in the Netherlands. Eur. J. Pediatr. 167, 1441–1447. doi: 10.1007/s00431-008-0697-y
Moore, D. A., Nunns, M., Shaw, L., Rogers, M., Walker, E., Ford, T., et al. (2019). Interventions to improve the mental health of children and young people with long-term physical conditions: linked evidence syntheses. Health Technol. Assess. 23, 1–164. doi: 10.3310/hta23220
Nelson, W. M., and Finch, A. J. (2000). Children's Inventory of Anger: ChIA Manual. Melton South: Western Psychological Services.
NHS Digital (2019). Waiting Times for Children and Young People's Mental Health Services, 2018 - 2019 Additional Statistics. Leeds: National Health Service.
NHSE (2018). NHS England Funding and Resource 2018/19: Supporting ‘Next Steps for the NHS Five Year Forward View'. Wakefield: National Health Service England.
NICE (2016). Psychosis and Schizophrenia in Children and Young People: Recognition and Management. (NICE Clinical Guideline CG115). London: National Institute for Health and Care Excellence.
Parsons, S., Thomson, W., Cresswell, K., Starling, B., McDonagh, J. E., and Barbara Ansell National Network for Adolescent, R. (2017). What do young people with rheumatic disease believe to be important to research about their condition? A UK-wide study. Pediatr. Rheumatol. 15, 53–53. doi: 10.1186/s12969-017-0181-1
Piers, E. V., and Herzberg, D. S. (2002). Piers-Harris Children's Self-Concept Scale: Manual. Melton South: Western Psychological Services.
Pinquart, M., and Shen, Y. (2011a). Anxiety in children and adolescents with chronic physical illnesses: a meta-analysis. Acta Paediatr. 100, 1069–1076. doi: 10.1111/j.1651-2227.2011.02223.x
Pinquart, M., and Shen, Y. (2011b). Depressive symptoms in children and adolescents with chronic physical illness: an updated meta-analysis. J. Pediatr. Psychol. 36, 375–384. doi: 10.1093/jpepsy/jsq104
Polonsky, W. H., Anderson, B. J., Lohrer, P. A., Welch, G., Jacobson, A. M., Aponte, J. E., et al. (1995). Assessment of diabetes-related distress. Diabetes Care 18, 754–760. doi: 10.2337/diacare.18.6.754
Popay, J., Roberts, H., Sowden, A., Petticrew, M., Arai, L., Rodgers, M., et al. (2006). Guidance on the Conduct of Narrative Synthesis in Systematic Reviews. A Product From the ESRC Methods Programme Version, 1. Lancaster: Lancaster University.
Ravens-Sieberer, U., Erhart, M., Rajmil, L., Herdman, M., Auquier, P., Bruil, J., et al. (2010). Reliability, construct and criterion validity of the KIDSCREEN-10 score: a short measure for children and adolescents' well-being and health-related quality of life. Qual. Life Res. 19, 1487–1500. doi: 10.1007/s11136-010-9706-5
Reid, G. J., Gilbert, C. A., and McGrath, P. J. (1998). The pain coping questionnaire: preliminary validation. Pain 76, 83–96. doi: 10.1016/S0304-3959(98)00029-3
Robb, S. L. (2000). The effect of therapeutic music interventions on the behavior of hospitalized children in isolation: developing a contextual support model of music therapy. J. Music Ther. 37, 118–146. doi: 10.1093/jmt/37.2.118
Robb, S. L., Burns, D. S., Stegenga, K. A., Haut, P. R., Monahan, P. O., Meza, J., et al. (2014). Randomized clinical trial of therapeutic music video intervention for resilience outcomes in adolescents/young adults undergoing hematopoietic stem cell transplant: a report from the Children's Oncology Group. Cancer 120, 909–917. doi: 10.1002/cncr.28355
Robb, S. L., Clair, A. A., Watanabe, M., Monahan, P. O., Azzouz, F., Stouffer, J. W., et al. (2008). Randomized controlled trial of the active music engagement (AME) intervention on children with cancer. Psychooncolgy 17, 699–708. doi: 10.1002/pon.1301
Rosenberg, A. R., Bradford, M. C., Junkins, C. C., Taylor, M., Zhou, C., Sherr, N., et al. (2019). Effect of the promoting resilience in stress management intervention for parents of children with cancer (PRISM-P): a randomized clinical trial. JAMA Netw. Open 2:e1911578. doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2019.11578
Seid, M., Varni, J. W., Segall, D., and Kurtin, P. S. (2004). Health-related quality of life as a predictor of pediatric healthcare costs: a two-year prospective cohort analysis. Health Qual. Life Outcomes 2:48. doi: 10.1186/1477-7525-2-48
Shaw, L., Moore, D., Nunns, M., Thompson, C. J., Ford, T., Berry, V., et al. (2019). Experiences of interventions aiming to improve the mental health and well-being of children and young people with a long-term physical condition: a systematic review and meta-ethnography. Child Care Health Dev. 45, 832–849. doi: 10.1111/cch.12708
Sherbourne, C. D., and Stewart, A. L. (1991). The MOS social support survey. Soc. Sci. Med. 32, 705–714. doi: 10.1016/0277-9536(91)90150-B
Spence, S. H., Barrett, P. M., and Turner, C. M. (2003). Psychometric properties of the Spence Children's Anxiety Scale with young adolescents. J. Anxiety Disord. 17, 605–25. doi: 10.1016/S0887-6185(02)00236-0
Spielberger, C. D. (1973). State-Trait Anxiety Inventory for Children. Palo Alto: Consulting Psychologists Press. doi: 10.1037/t06497-000
Stafstrom, C. E., Havlena, J., and Krezinski, A. J. (2012). Art therapy focus groups for children and adolescents with epilepsy. Epilepsy Behav. 24, 227–233. doi: 10.1016/j.yebeh.2012.03.030
Thabrew, H., Stasiak, K., Hetrick, S. E., Donkin, L., Huss, J. H., Highlander, A., et al. (2018). Psychological therapies for anxiety and depression in children and adolescents with long-term physical conditions. Cochrane Database Syst. Rev. 2017:CD012488. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012488.pub2
Thomas, B., Ciliska, D., Dobbins, M., and Micucci, S. (2004). A process for systematically reviewing the literature: providing the research evidence for public health nursing interventions. Worldviews Evid. Based Nurs. 1, 176–184. doi: 10.1111/j.1524-475X.2004.04006.x
Tollisen, A., Selvaag, A. M., Aulie, H. A., Lilleby, V., Aasland, A., Lerdal, A., et al. (2018). Physical functioning, pain, and health-related quality of life in adults with juvenile idiopathic arthritis: a longitudinal 30-year followup study. Arthritis Care Res. 70, 741–749. doi: 10.1002/acr.23327
Tomaj, O. K., Estebsari, F., Taghavi, T., Nejad, L. B., Dastoorpoor, M., and Ghasemi, A. (2016). The effects of group play therapy on self-concept among 7 to 11 year-old children suffering from thalassemia major. Iran. Red Crescent Med. J. 18:e35412. doi: 10.5812/ircmj.35412
Uggla, L., Bonde, L. O., Hammar, U., Wrangsjö, B., and Gustafsson, B. (2018). Music therapy supported the health-related quality of life for children undergoing haematopoietic stem cell transplants. Acta Paediatr. 107, 1986–1994. doi: 10.1111/apa.14515
Varni, J. W., Burwinkle, T. M., Katz, E. R., Meeske, K., and Dickinson, P. (2002). The PedsQL™ in pediatric cancer: reliability and validity of the pediatric quality of life inventory™ generic core scales, multidimensional fatigue scale, and cancer module. Cancer 94, 2090–2106. doi: 10.1002/cncr.10428
Varni, J. W., Burwinkle, T. M., Rapoff, M. A., Kamps, J. L., and Olson, N. (2004). The PedsQL™ in pediatric asthma: reliability and validity of the Pediatric Quality of Life Inventory™ generic core scales and asthma module. J. Behav. Med. 27, 297–318. doi: 10.1023/B:JOBM.0000028500.53608.2c
Varni, J. W., Katz, E. R., Seid, M., Quiggins, D. J., Friedman-Bender, A., and Castro, C. M. (1998). The Pediatric Cancer Quality of Life Inventory (PCQL). I. Instrument development, descriptive statistics, and cross-informant variance. J. Behav. Med. 21, 179–204. doi: 10.1037/t65932-000
Weissman, M. M., Orvaschel, H., and Padian, N. (1980). Children's symptom and social functioning: self-report scales. J. Nerv. Ment. Disord. 168, 736–740. doi: 10.1097/00005053-198012000-00005
Wiener, L., Viola, A., Koretski, J., Perper, E. D., and Patenaude, A. F. (2015). Pediatric psycho-oncology care: standards, guidelines, and consensus reports. Psychooncology 24, 204–211. doi: 10.1002/pon.3589
Wong, D. L., and Baker, C. M. (2001). Smiling face as anchor for pain intensity scales. Pain 89, 295–297. doi: 10.1016/S0304-3959(00)00375-4
Appendix
Table A1. Search strategy used for the EBSCO interface and Medline database.
Keywords: pediatric, arts-based therapies, physical health long-term conditions, mental health, children
Citation: Wigham S, Watts P, Zubala A, Jandial S, Bourne J and Hackett S (2020) Using Arts-Based Therapies to Improve Mental Health for Children and Young People With Physical Health Long-Term Conditions: A Systematic Review of Effectiveness. Front. Psychol. 11:1771. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2020.01771
Received: 24 March 2020; Accepted: 26 June 2020;
Published: 25 September 2020.
Edited by:
Andrew Kemp, Swansea University, United KingdomReviewed by:
Liz Shaw, University of Exeter, United KingdomDiogo Lamela, Universidade Lusófona do Porto, Portugal
Copyright © 2020 Wigham, Watts, Zubala, Jandial, Bourne and Hackett. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
*Correspondence: Simon Hackett, simon.hackett@cntw.nhs.uk